ELSEVIER
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
journal homepage: www.olsevier.com/locate/dsx
Diabetes & Metabolic Syndrome: Clinical Research & Reviews Ai
Review
The role of collagen homeostasis in the pathogenesis of vascular
disease associated to insulin resistance
2
Maria M, Adeva-Andany’, Elvira Castro-Quintela, Carlos Fernandez-Fernandez,
Natalia Carneiro-Frei
, Matilde Vila-Altesor
mveral Meicine Depremen, Hosp General ua Cardona, Fado bazin sn, 1546, Fer pain
ARTICLE INFO
‘Aeceped 1 Api 2019,
1. Introduction
Insulin resistance is associated with devastating vascular dam-
age that is not fully explained by traditional carciovascular tsk
factors ar hypergiycemia, as the risk of cardiovascular disease re-
mains elevated despite adequate glycemic control []. Patients with
Insulin resistance experience a systemic disorder of collagen ho-
‘meostasis that may contribute to eause vascular injury among ather
complications. Collagen abundance, structural properties and
fibrillar arrangement are abnormal on the extracellular matrix of
every tissue examined, including skin, tendons, bone, skeletal
"muscle, eye, peripheral nerves, kidney, lung, liver. and blood vessels
of any size [2]. Excessive collagen deposition occurs in the inter-
stitial space of tissues and contributes to cause clinical manifesta-
tions of diabetes such as fibrotic skin, predisposition to bone
fractures, impaired lung function, diastolic dysfunction, and liver
disease. Heavy deposits of collagen are present in the capillary
basement membrane and the vascular wall of arteries af any size. In
capillaries, the ensuing thickening of the capillary basement
‘membrane typifies microangiopathy associated to insulin resis-
‘ance. In the arterial wall, the striking accumulation of collagen on
the tunica media causes intima-media thickening, Histological ex-
aminations reveal similar findings (accumulation of disordered
collagen) in blood vessel of any size from capillaries to large ar-
teries, suggesting a common pathogenic mechanism to microvas-
cular and macrovascular disease [3.i]. Histological
‘microangiopathy (thickening ofthe capillary basement membrane)
Js present in normogiycemic subjects with high risk of developing,
* Corresponding autor
neds sso
ns ML Ado Anda
1871-4021je 2019 Published by Elsevier Lid on behalf of Diabetes India
diabetes but is very rare in hyperglycemic patients with diabetes
secondary to pancreatitis. Glucagon deficiency in patients with
global pancreas damage prevents insulin resistance from devel-
ping and patients with pancreatitis tend to experience exquisite
insulin sensitivity. These findings indicate that insulin resistance
rather than hyperglycemia is the major factor responsible for
vascular injury [5], Vascular smooth muscle cells synthesize
extracellular matrix in the tunica media of the arterial wall, The
interaction between smooth muscle cells and the surrounding
extracellular matrix is essential ta normal structure and function of
the blood vessel, Any modification in the composition of the
extracellular matrix is sensed by smooth musele cells via plasma
'membrane receptors and elicits appropriate cellular adjustment, so
‘hat the extracellular matrix regulates cellular function. Collagen is
4 major component of the extracellular matsix throughout the
human body. Alteration of collagen homeostasis in the arterial wall
‘may play a crucial role in the pathogenesis of vascular disease
associated to insulin resistance, The cause of the profound
disruption of collagen metabolism associated with insulin resis-
tance is unknown [5]
2. Insulin resistance is associated with a systemic alteration
of collagen homeostasis,
Collagen is a crucial component of the extracellular matrix in
human tissues. Three polypeptide chains (named a chains) twisted
around each other into a triple helix compose one collagen mole-
cle. numberof distinet2-chains have been identified in humans,
Collagen molecules may assemble as homotrimers or heterotrimers
of a chains. Mutations in the different genes coding each a-chain
Jead to a variety of human disorders, including the syndrome of
Ehlers-Danlos, characterized by fragility of the blood vessel wallwre ene Ate-dany ea Babes Mtoe Syarome: Cn Reser & Redes 15 (2019) 1877-186
‘Amino acids in = chains are arranged ina specific repeating pattern,
Gly-X-¥, Every third amino acid in any collagen chain is glycine.
The presence of glycine at this positon is essential to bring the
{three 2 chains together and form the triple helix. Proline and 4-
hydroxyproline occupy frequently the X and ¥ positions, respec-
tively, and contribute to the stability ofthe triple helix. Hydroxyl-
ation of profine is @ key step to collagen formation, as a critical
‘number of prolyl residues must be hydroxylated to form a stable
triple helix [7]. Hydroxyproline concentration in a tissue has been
used as an index of the amount of collagen present in that tissue.
Human collagen contains about 12-14% 4-hydroxyproline while
clastin contains about 1.5% [8]. A number of collagen types achieve
specific functions in every tissue, but structural and functional
ifferences berween them are not well defined. Some types of
collagen assemble into fibcis by formation of covalent cross-links
between neighboring collagen molecules. Cross-linking of
‘collagen into fibrils occurs in several enzymatic steps. Collagen f=
brils may represent the base for hyciroxyapatite crystals to deposit
physiologically in bone tissue and pathologically in sot tissues such
as the arterial wall [7].
Properties of human collagen undergo a marked deterioration
with age that may be related with insulin resistance, as decline of
insulin sensitivity is a physiological feature of aging. Consistently,
‘age-related collagen modifications mimic those observed in
Younger patients with insulin resistance. Skin collagen undergoes
‘age-related changes characterized by increased stiffness and! frag-
‘mentation of collagen fibrils (9. In human bone, there is an age-
related change in collagen content and cross-links from 3 to 89
years of age [10], Excessive collagen deposition resulting in thick-
‘ening of the basement membrane of capillaries associated with age
has been documented in the retina the skeletal muscle, and the
liver [1113]. A prominent feature of the aging process in the
arterial wall is the progressive accumulation of collagen in the
tunica media, In human aortas obtained at autopsy, mechanical
‘measurements suggest that collagen accumulation reduces the
clastic response ofthe arterial wall [81,15],
thas been long known that insulin resistance is associated with
‘marked alterations in the abundance, structure, and layout of
collagen throughout the fnuman body. Collagen is less soluble by
‘acid and pepsin and less digestible by collagenases and cyanogen,
bromide in patients with diabetes compared to controls. Defective
collagen metabolism in the interstitial space contributes ta cause
diabetic complications, such as skin changes, restricted joint
mobility, tendon diseases, predisposition to bone fractures, and
‘layed wound healing [3,16], Alteration of collagen homeostasis,
precedes the clinical onset of diabetes, having been detected in
patients with insulin resistance. In 1975, Hamlin etal. stated: “The
possibility must be considered that a connective ussue defect may
precede the diabetes and play a sole in its pathogenesis" [17]
Ia review of the literature, patients with diabetes have more
than three times the odds of tendinopathy compared fo controls.
Diabetes predisposes to a wide range of tendon diseases, including
‘contracture, rupture, impaired tendon healing, and asymptomatic
‘Achilles tendinopathy [18]. Abnormal collagen structure in tendons
may contribute to cause tendinopathy in patients with diabetes.
Properties of collagen (evaluated by enzymatic digestion) from the
central tendon ofthe diaphragma obtained at autopsy ae altered in
patients with diabetes. The collagen fibrils become stiff and insol-
tuble compared to control subjects [17]. The ultrastructure of
collagen in extensor tendons (evaluated by X-ray diffraction) shows
‘major changes in patients with diabetes compared to normal ten-
dons [19]. In a cross-sectional study, Achilles tendon stiffness was
higher and tendon fibril density was greater in patients wit di
betes compared to control subjects [20]
Limited joint mobility occurs commonly among, patients with
diabetes and may affect any joint, including wrist, elbow, ankle, and
spine, Joint stifiness is associated with sclerotic and microvascular
‘complications. Knee osteoarthritis is mae frequent inpatients with
diabetes and the complication rate of total knee arthroplasty is
higher compared to controls. Aseptic loosening and need for revi-
sion surgery alter total knee arthroplasty occur more frequently in
patients with diabetes, reducing functional outcome [21]
Patients with diabetes have an increased incidence of interver-
tebral disc herniation compared to nondiabetic individuals.
Collagen isan important component ofthe intervertebral disc. Type
1 collagen accounts for 1~2% of all disc collagen, but its binding to
type ll fbrils enhances the resistance of the disc, The evelof type IX
collagen in the intervertebral disc is reduced in patients with dia-
betes compared to control subjects. This reduction may facilitate
the development of disc herniation [22]
‘A meta-analysis of the literature concluded that the risk of bone
fracture is more elevated in patients with diabetes compared to
‘control subjects. Glycated hemoglobin (HDAIC) was not linked to
bone mineral density [23]. Bone extracellular matrix is composed of
collagen fibrils and mineral. Type I collagen is the most abundant
collagen in bone, although types ll and V are also present. The
elevated risk of bone fracture associated with diabetes is not
‘explained by 2 reduction in bone mineral density, suggesting that
the poor bone quality is related to defective bone collagen [10]
Dura mater is a dense collagen structure, The properties of dura
‘mater collagen obtained at autopsy are markedly altered in patients
‘with diabetes. Compared to normal specimens, dura mater collagen
from diabeti patients is much more resistant co solubilization [24].
Ina biracial study with Chinese and Caucasian participants,
collagen content in adipose tissue (assessed by the level of hy-
droxyproline) increased with the degree of insulin resistance,
evaluated by the homeostasis model assessment of insulin resis-
tance (HOMAAIR) index, in both population groups. The level of
hydroxyproline (ancl the extent of fibrosis) in adipose tissue was
higher among more insulin-resistant patients [25]. Analogous re-
sults were obtained among obese subjects that underwent hyper-
insulinemic euglycemic clamp to evaluate insulin sensitivity. The
‘extent of fibrosis in adipose tissue was higher in more insulin
resistant subjects compared to those more insulin sensitive.
Fibrosis of adipose tissue in obese subjects is associated with in-
sulin resistance [26] ina study that reeruited healthy males, the
synthesis of type I and type Ill collagens in the adipose tissue
increased in response to insulin resistance. Insulin resistance was
induced by overfeeding-related weight gain and assessed by
‘euglycemic hyperinsulinemic clamps, Collagen content was
‘measured in biopsy samples, Insulin resistance was followed by
elevated content of type! and type Il collagens in the adipose tissue
ba
3. Collagen homeosta
‘with insulin resistance
and microangiopathy associated
‘Numerous investigations have long documented the presence of
systemic capillary Involvement in patients with insulin resistance,
‘characterized by collagen accumulation and subsequent thickening,
‘of the capillary basement membrane, the histopathological ball-
mark of diabetic microangiopathy [3.5,28- 20]. This alteration
precedes the clinical diagnosis of type 2 diabetes, so that capillary
basement membrane thickening can be demonstrated in predia-
betie subjects prior to detectable hyperglycemia. In contrast, the
‘width ofthe capillary basement membrane in patients with type 1
diabetes is normal at the time of diagnosis and thickens with
increasing duration of the disease. These findings suggest that in-
sulin resistance is a major factor causing microvascular damage
[29-31], Histological examinations reveal that thickening of theLAL Ade nny Dees & Metab: yatome inc Research Reviews 12 (2013) 177-1883 oo
basement membrane occurs in the capillaries of every tissue
examined, including retina, kidney, skeletal muscle, skin, liver,
Jung, and peripheral nerves. Microangiopathy may contribute ta
cause complications of diabetes such as retinopathy, nephropathy
and peripietal neuropathy [3],
31. Gingival tissue
In patients with diabetes, basement membrane thickening is
‘dentified in terminal arterioles and capillaries from gingival tissue,
compared to control subjects. In prediabetic patients, approxl-
‘mately 503 of the terminal arteriales and capillaries show base-
‘ment membrane thickening, In obese subjects, this alteration Is
cccasionally present while no change is observed in control sub-
jects [1
32. Kidney
Diabetic nephropathy is characterized by thickening of the
basement membrane ofthe glomerular capillaries and expansion of
‘mesangial matrix (Kimmelstiel and Wilson intercapillary sclerosis).
‘Thickening of the basement membrane of kidney tubules and
capsular epithelivm is alsa present [1225]. Mesangial content of
type VI collagen has been found 2.8-fold higher in patients with
diabetes compared to control subjects [15]
33. Be
Microangiopathy affecting retinal capillaries has been long
documented in patients with diabetes. Diabetic retinopathy is
characterized by capillary aneurysms and a cluster of exudates and
hemorrhages in the retina surrounding the aneurysms. Thickening,
ff the retinal capillary basement membrane is observed [22]
Electron microscopy and histochemical studies performed on hu-
‘man eyes confirm that the retinal capillary wall is thickened in
patients with diabetes campared to normal samples [11]. Micro-
vascular abnormalities in the choroid have also been identified in
patients with diabetes [36]. The prevalence of brain micro-
angiopathy (evaluated as cerebral microbleces on magnetic reso-
rnance imaging) is higher in diabetic patients with proliferative
retinopathy, compared to nondiabetic subjects and diabetic pa-
tients without retinopathy, suggesting that retinal changes may
indicate a generalized microangiopathy [37]
3.4, Nervous system
Brain small vessel disease expressed on magnetic resonance
Simaging as lacunar Infarctons, white matter lesions and micro-
bieedss common inpatients with diabetes compared with healthy
Individuals. Cerebral microangiopathy is associated with abnormal
sin capillary perfusion (assessed by capillary microscopy), Su-
gesting that cerebral microangiopathy is 4 manifestation of gener-
alized microvascular dysfunction [38,39}.
‘The capillary basement membrane of sural nervesis thicker (by
52.9%) in patients with diabetes compared to control nerves.
Endoneuri microangiopathy is closely associated with clinical
diabetic polyneuropathy {40}. Similarly to the capillary basement
‘membrane, the thickness ofthe perineural cll basement mem-
brane (asessed by electron microscopy) is greater in sural nerves
from patients with diabetes compared to nondiabetic subjects
Thickening of perineural cel basement membrane may precede
the recognition of hyperglycemia, n sciatic nerve samples from
patients with diabetes, aggregation of type VI collagen fibrils i
‘dentified adjacent to te basement membranes of perineuril cells
bs}
435, skin
‘Microangiopathy targets the skin of patients with diabetes.
Histological examinations show thickening of the basement
‘membrane of dermal capillaries and deposition of hyaline periodic
Aacid-Schiff (PAS)-positive material an the normpally fibrillar area
external to the endothelial cell, compared to normal control bi-
opsies [28,42]. Dermal collagen is also abnormal in the intetstitial
space. Atomic force microscopy images of normal human skin
reveal tightly packed and well-organized dermal collagen fibrils,
In contrast, dermal collagen fibrils are fragmented and disorga-
nized in patients with diabetes [9]. Patients with diabetes show
increased cross-linking of the skin collagen fibrils, Skin collagen is
stiffer and more insoluble than that of nondiabetic indivicuals
20} On skin biopsy samples, thickening of the epidermis and
dermis with collagen accumulation is observed in patients with
diabetes compared to controls. Type Ill collagen is the predomi-
rant type deposited in diabetic skin, Fragmented and cross-linked
collagen contributes to cause clinical abnormalities such as thick
tight skin typical of diabetes [21]. Fibrocytes from diabetic pa-
tients do not increase the expression of type | collagen on stim-
ulation, unlike normal fibrocytes. This abnormality may
Contribute to explain impaired wound healing [13], Diabetes is 2
frequent finding among patients with cutaneous collagenous
vasculopathy, an idiopathic skin microangiopathy characterized
by dilated dermal capillaries with walls thickened by hyaline
‘material containing collagen IV by immunohistochemisry. Simi-
larly, collagenous colitis has been reported in patients with type 1
diabetes, Endoscopic biopsies showed marked thickening of the
subepithelial collagen plate (Masson's trichrome positive, Congo
red negative) in samples from stomach, duodenum, terminal
ileum, and colon [44
36, Sketetat muscle
‘Thickening of the capillary basement membrane in the skeletal
muscle is avery constant finding among patients with diabetes. The
‘width (measured by electron microscopy) ofthe capillay basement
membrane is over twice compated to normal subjects. Hypersly=
cemic patients with diabetes due to pancreatitis rarely experience
this alteration while thickening of the capillary basement mem-
brane is found in approximately 50% of normoglycemic subjects
‘with family history of diabetes, suggesting that insulin resistance
rather than hyperglycemia is the major factor responsible for
microvascular disease [5,23]. Follow-up skeletal muscle biopsy
examinations on the subjects with family history of diabetes
revealed that patients who developed diabetes (47%) during the
{ollow-up period showed progressive thickening of their capillary
basement membrane compared to the initial measurement [45].
Collagen synthesis increases inthe skeletal muscle of healthy males
Jn response to insulin resistance. Participants underwent over-
autttion to 10% weight gain, Skeletal muscle biopsies were ob-
tained to measure collagen content and_hyperinsulinemic
euglycemic clamps were performed to assess insulin sensitivity
Overfeeding and weight gain worsened! insulin sensitivity. In
response to insulin resistance, an increase in the mRNA level of type
1. 1, V, and VI collagens was observed in the skeletal muscle.
Type Ill and type Vi collagen protein levels were unchanged [27]
Comparable results were documented in healthy subjects who
‘underwent lipid infusion to induce insulin resistance, compared to
saline infusion. Following insulin resistance, an overexpression of
{ype I and type ll collagen genes with an increase of mRNA levels
‘was observed on biopsy samples of skeletal muscle [46], Consis-
tently, the amount of fype | and type Il collagens in skeletal muscle
(measured in biopsy samples) is increased in patients with insulinvss ene Ate-dany ea Babes Mtoe Syarome: Cn Reser & Redes 15 (2019) 1877-186
resistance (assessed by_hyperinsulinemic euglycemic clamp)
compared to insulin-sensitive subject [47}
37. Heart
“Myocardial microangiopathy is a complication of diabetes. His-
tological examination of autopsy samples document intense PAS-
positive deposits on the smallest branches of coronary arteries in
patients with diabetes compared to control subjects. The presence
(of PAS-positive material in the small vessels ofthe myocardium was
closely related tothe presence of nodular glomeruloscleross in the
kidney [8]. In addition to myocardial microangiopathy, interstitial
fibrosis with accumulation of type Il collagen is typically present in
the myocardium of patients with diabetes compared to controls
[29,50]. Type I collagen mRNA level is elevated by twofold in car-
diac fibroblasts (cells that synthesize extracellular matrix} derived
from patients with type 2 diabetes compared t controls [51]. The
association between insulin resistance and serum mazkers of
collagen synthesis has been investigated in obese subjects. Serum
procollagen type ll aminopeptide was measured and insulin
sensitivity was evaluated by the HOMA-IR index. Regression ana-
Iyses showed that serum procollagen type Ill aminopeptide level
was independently correlated with HOMA.IR and HDL-c, suggest-
Ing that markers of cardiac fibrosis are related to insulin resistance
[50]. Myocardial interstitial fibrosis impairs diastolic function hin-
‘ering ventricular relaxation and contributes to increase the risk of
heart failure in patients with insulin resistance. in addition, inter-
stitial fibrosis may predispose (0 cardiac arthythmias, Impaired
diastolic function has been reported in patients with insulin resis-
tance and obesity [50]
38. Lung
Diabetic microangiopathy occurs in the lung. Electron micro-
scopy examination on human lung samples shows thickening of the
alveolar capillary basement membrane. In addition, the thickness
of the basement membrane of bronchial epithelial cells is greater in
patients with diabetes compared to control subjects and interstitial
fibrosis with collagen accumulation is observed. There is n0 close
correlation between fasting blood glucose or HbAIc level and
basement membrane thickness in lung tissue [35,52]. Patients with
insulin resistance suffer from subclinical lung dysfunction long
before the clinical onset of type 2 diabetes. Cross-sectional studies
in different population groups reveal an independent association
between insulin resistance and impaited ventilatory function,
including reduced forced vital capacity (FVC) and forced expiratory
volume in 1's (FEV1). I has been suggested that measurement of
Jung function by spirometry may be useful to estimate the pro-
_sression of systemic microvascular disease in patients with insulin
resistance [53] In nondiabetic subjects the decline of FYC and FEV1
‘was prospectively investigated during 5 years. After adjustment for
confounders, subjects who developed diabetes during the follow-
up period had greater deciine of ventilatory function compared to
those who did not develop diabetes [=4]. The prospective associ
tion between pulmonary function and incidence of diabetes was
investigated by the National Health and Nutrition Examination
Survey Epidemiologic Follow-Up Study, a cohort study of US adults.
Individuals with restrictive lung disease are at risk for developing
diabetes, but obstructive lung disease is not associated with di
betes incidence [55]
39, Liver
In the normal liver, the perisinusoidal space of Disse contains
‘occasional small deposits of collagen fibrils including types II, 1V,
‘and XIX, Patients with insulin resistance typically develop a non-
Cirrhotic form of hepatic sinusoidal fibrosis (diabetic hepato-
sclerosis) that is not associated with nonalcoholic steatohepatitis.
‘On histological examination, the most striking feature isthe pres
cence of dense perisinusoldal fibrosis. On electron microscopy, ant
increase in the amount of collagen fibrils within the space of Disse
‘with abundant collagen bundles and segments of perisinusoidal
basement membrane-like deposition are observed among patients
‘with diabetes while collagen deposits are absent in control sub-
jects, Perisinusoidal collagen accumulation is associated with hya-
Tine thickening of small hepatic artery branches and perivascular
fibrosis composed mainly of fibrillar collagen, Patients with dia-
betes who develop hepatic sinusoidal fibrosis (collagenization of
the space of Disse) usually have evidence of microvascular disease,
‘such a5 retinopathy, nephropathy, and peripheral and autonomic
‘neuropathy. By immunocytochemistry, an increase in type { and
type Ill collagens is identified that corresponds to the collagen
bundles seen under electron microscopy. Type IV collagen shows
linear segments of perisinusoidal staining, imparting a basement
‘membrane-like appearance. Stellate cell activation is observed in
patients with diabetic hepatosclerosis [90.57], Hepatic peri-
sinusoidal fibrosis has been observed in obese patients as wel.
Electron microscopy examination of liver biopsy samples from
‘obese patients shows deposition of abundant collagen fibrils and
tlectron-dense material resembling basement membrane within
the space of Disse [57]
4 Collagen homeostasis and macroanglopathy associated
‘with insulin resistance
Patients with insulin resistance develop vascular damage char-
acterized by atherosclerasis and medial calcification (Monckebere's
‘slerosis) that may be explained by defective extracellular matrix
homeostasis on the arteriat wall Fatty streaks or intimal xanthomas
are focal accumulations of fa-laden macrophages (foam cells) in
the arterial intima, Micrascopically, the media is preserved and
‘extracellular matrix accumulation has not been found an these
lesions. Intimal xanthomas are at lesions that usually egress, The
‘extent of fatty streaks in young petsons docs not predict the extent
‘of raised lesions (fibrous plaques) in later life. Potentially progres-
‘sive atherosclerotic lesions include intima-media thickening of the
arterial wall and fibrous plaques. Vascular calcification is associated,
With either of them. intima-media thickening is a difuse widening
fof the intima-media of the arterial wall, Or histological examina-
tion, the lesion is characterized by collagen accumulation, Micro
‘calcification foci are a very common finding. There are no foam
cells, Fibrous plaques are focaly distributed in the same area that
the intima-media thickening lesion. Fibrous plaques are raised le-
sions that protrude into the lumen of the artery. Dense bundles of
collagen are found in every fibrous plaque. The densely fibrotic
‘areas are fee from large accumulations of fat. Small lacunar spaces
‘re commonly seen in this fibrous structure. Calcification can be
seen in the plaque and in the adjacent artery wall. In advanced
fibrous plaques, the collagenous extracellular matrix forms a
fibrous cap that encloses a necrotic core containing debris including
lipids. The fibroatheroma plaque contains varying degrees of infil-
tration by maeraphages and lymphocytes that represent a protec-
tive response. Advanced fibrous plaques with a necrotic core
(fibrous cap atheroma) may undergo complications such as rupture
‘or thrombosis that cause lie-threatening occlusive episodes
[58-66], Inuima-media thickening and fibrous plaques are
‘commonly complicated by arterial wall calcification. Vascular
‘calcification is driven by smooth muscle cells in response to altered
‘extracellular matrix and involves deposition of carbonated hhy-
droxyapatite (calcium phosphate) on the extracellular matrix.LAL Ade nny Dees & Metab: yatome inc Research Reviews 12 (2013) 177-1883 oo
Arterial calcification is observed microscopically in the intima-
‘media thickening. lesion, indicating that microcacification foci
develop at the beginning ofthe atherosclerosis process (56-69). In
analyses of human coronary arteries conducted to quantify the
calcium-to-phosphate ratio on the tssue, microcalifications
composed of amorphous calcium phosphate can be demonstrated
at a preatheroma stage, suggesting that the formation of calcium
phosphate granules isan early event inthe atherosclerotic process
[70}. Electron microscopy examination on human aorta samples
dbtained at autopsy detects zones of microcaleiication on intima-
‘media thickening lesions, confirming that calcified deposits are
formed at an early stage of atherosclerosis development [57]
Autopsy studies reveal that atherosclerotic lesions begin to
appear in young population groups indicating that preventive ac-
tuons need to be implemented early in life. Among them, compel-
ling evidence derived from prospective studies has demonstrated
‘hat animal protein ineveases the risk of both type 2 diabetes and
cardiovascular disease by causing insulin resistance. Restriction or
discontinuation of animal protein consumption is crucial to reduce
vascular disease associated with insulin resistance [51/55]
In a comprehensive histopathologic study of medium-to-large
caliber blood vessels in 100 autopsy subjects, vascular tissue was
analyzed to determine the percent fibrosis of over 700 vaseular
segments, The percent fibrosis (% collagen) ofthe tunica media was
strongly correlated within subjects across all blood vessels sug-
gesting that fibrosis isa global process independent of the vessel
im
Investigation on human atherogenesis has been accelerated by
the development of models of human atherosclerotic lesions and
induced pluripotent stem cell technology that makes available
human vascular cells generated from induced pluripotent stem
cells [6,72
4.1. Role of collagen homeostasis in the pathogenesis of
‘macrovascular disease associated to insulia resistance
In 1883, Thoma and Kaefer suggested that medial damage
played a primary rolein the development of atherosclerosis. Medial
lesions resulted in focal arcas of injury which became filled up by a
fibrotic repair process leading to atherosclerotic plaques. Medial
‘Shinning was later confirmed to be an initial typical finding in
fibrous plaques [4,58], Smooth muscle cells in the medial layer
synthesize extracellular matrix. Abundant components of human
arterial extracellular matrix are elastin, proteogiycans and collagen.
‘Additional constituents include enzymes that degrade extracellular
‘matrix (such as matrix metalloproteinases) and their inhibitors,
and molecules that regulate the assembly of collagen into fib
such as small leucine-rich repeat proteoglycans including decorin
‘The extracellular matrix interacts with smooth muscle cells via cell,
membrane receptors such as integrins. Changes in extracellular
‘matrix composition are detected by smooth muscle cells and elicit
pathophysiological_ responses. Molecular interactions between
components of the extracellular matrix (such as collagen) and
smooth muscle cells contribute to the normal function and adaptive
responses to damaged arterial wall, Dysfunctional overproduction
‘of collagen in response toan unknown injury leads tothe structural
changes that characterize vascular damage associated to insulin
resistance [73,74], Mattix degrading proteins and theit inhibitors or
other molecules that regulate collagen assembly into fbrilar
structures may play a role modulating arterial damage, but their
Impact has not been defined {75}. There is a pathological “diabetes
phenotype" in vascular smooth muscle cells. Smooth muscle cells
isolated from patients with diabetes exhibit abnormal morphology
and greater adhesion and migration in cell cultures compared to
those from nondiabetic subjects [76].
Collagen composition, distribution, and mechanisms of fibrillar
assembly on the normal wall of human arteries are not well novi,
Type [and type Ill collagens are the most abundant types in the
medial layer. Type IV and type V collagens have been fouind around
individual smooth muscle cell in the medial layer and surrounding
endothelial cells in the intima forming a basement membrane.
Unlike type IY, type V collagen is also distributed throughout the
extracellular matrix in the aortic media [15]. Type It collagen has
been detected in small amounts in the media of human aorta sec-
tions. The average content of type Il collagen is approximately 1% of
{otal arterial collagen while collagens types Il, and IV amount 10
{99% [77], Type XIX collagen has been identified on the endothelial
basement membrane of human blood vessels [3]
Patients with insulin resistance show abaormal collagen ho-
‘meostasis in the arterial wall including elevated collagen content,
disordered collagen arrangement, and altered collagen composi-
‘ion, which contributes to cause vascular injury. Intima-media
thickening and fibrous plaques are characterized by accumulation
of collagen. The measurement of hydroxyproline reveals an in-
crease ofthe collagen content in fibrous plaques, comprising 40% of
the total protein versus 25% in normal human aorta. Collagen
constitutes as much as 60% of the total protein in advanced lesions
[811578] Fibrous plaques show disordered and shapeless collagen
structures, in contrast to the organized assembly of fibrillar
collagen in the normal arterial wall, Collagen fibrils degenerate in
the dead tissue zones of atheromatous plaques [15]. Collagen dls-
tribution is nor uniform within the flarous plaques. These lesions
consist of regions with abundance of type Ian type II collagens
and areas deficient in these collagen types [15,72,79]. The amount
of type IV collagen increases with the advance of atherosclerosis.
Heavily thickened type IV collagen structures surrounding incl-
Vidual smooth muscle cells are found in fibrous plaques [15]. The
abundance of type I collagen increases markedly in atherosclerotic
lesions, particularly in samples with calcification. The amount of
‘ype Il collagen is higher in the tissue around the calcium deposit
[77]. The relationship between collagen and arterial calification
has been investigated én vitro in human carotid atherosclerotic
plaques and three-dimensional collagen hydrogels (that mimic
structural features of the atherosclerotic fibrous cap). There is ar
Inverse relationship between collagen content and the size of
microcaleifications in human fibrous plaques. The micro
cakifications aggregate within fibrous plaques in gaps between
collagen fibers. Similarly, increasing collagen content in the
hydrogels reduces microcaleifcation size by 90% compared to the
samples without collagen. Further, collagen degradation promotes
_mierocakification. Localized collagen decay within the plaque al-
lows extracellular vesicles to accumulate and initiate the caleifca-
tdon process. Then, microcalcfications serve as bullding blocks for
larger calcifications when normal collagen is deficient [20]
5, Summary
Insulin resistance is associated with systemic impairment of
collagen homeostasis that affects the extracellular matrix of human
tissues including blood vessels of any size. Excessive deposition of
abnormal collagen on the interstitial space contributes to cause
‘kin abnormalities, bone fractures, tendon disorders, lung
‘dysfunction, diastolic dysfunction, and liver disease. Accumulation
of defective collagen on the capillary wall causes microvascular
disease including retinopathy, peripheral neuropathy, and ne-
phropathy. Collagen accumulation on the medial layer of large ar-
{eties produces intima-media thickening, Fibrous plaques develop
in regions of intima-media thickening with further collagen
deposition. Both lesions are associated with calcification of the
arterial wall,2 ene Ate-dany ea Babes Mtoe Syarome: Cn Reser & Redes 15 (2019) 1877-186
Funding
‘There was no financial support for this work
Conflicts of interest
‘The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Acknowledgement
We are pleased to acknowledge the continuous support from Ms.
Gema Souto-Adeva,
References
(1 ng Fae Selective wn esse a te deepen
Diaberes 2016 jum 65,6:1400- 71, bed PMID: 27222300, Pubmed Central
Picib:Pucas73431.EpuD 2016105/26.ene
[2] Wiliams AS Kang L Wassemnan DH The extaclblar mass and inslin
feskance. Tents Endocrine Netabol TEM 2015 267) 137-ah. Pub
Pb: 25059707. Pabed Cental PRICID: PMCHASOD3B. Eps 2015001.
[a] Sor, vid Men Shaul¥, Rede Caf} Diab bilons A report of
fives cases Am J Med 1970 jula{tio4—@. MbMied PMID 5431478 Epub
is7oo7f0. eng.
yb Hed. Dabtic macrangipathy Quancaiv hitapathoagiea
‘de ofthe extramural coronary ste rm typ 2 (nen dn depen
‘lent abe patents: Disbeolg 1987 Nov341 88D, Pub PID
‘345555, Epub 1987/1101. ng
Spain MD, Unger RA, Madcon UL Sts of muscle caplary basement
‘eek peal, ets, delet a aoc cao Cla
Utes 1968 Sep 7(3).1973-88, PubMed PMID. 9575423 Pubmed Cea
PRctD"Pca97361. Epub 196803). en.
Livedova A VorobyevaD, Vasa Matava O, Fler E, lager Weal
Ex wo culture of tumon ateresete plagues: a model to sty Wane
fais in atherogenesi. Atherosdersis 2017 Dec207:90~8. PubMed MD
Sototaco, pubis cenral PMCID: PMESEI1 192. Epub 2017/1110. eng
Prockop DI, Kinikke Kt, Tuderman (, Guzman NA. The besyhess of
fell and is sores ns of two pars. En! | Med 1979] 5:30
1325. PubMed PMID: 4990 Epu 197507105. en.
Suh ER The nfutice of age and ahereseleass on te comity of sie
Inuima2 aan and mucopoysceharides. | Atboveser tes 1965 Mak
‘ApeSidi:241-8. PubMed PMID: 14273075, Ep 19650901. ag
Ireyropulos A). obihaid Balinese), ammenkerg C
San Vet au Ateraone of dermal connscve tesa colagen tn pbs
oleae bass of aged-apocarng Ski Mtns One 2018:1(4)eD1S3806,
Pubted FMD 204752. Ped ental PMD: PMCARALSCS Ep 2016)
4/23. eng.
Wo Saito Mt Kida V. Kats, Marumo K Diabetes, colagen and bone quality. Core
(steopocs Rep 2014 Jus 42.28181-X PubMed PUD: 24623587. Epu 2014)
5/14 eng.
Inn] Feber Taurone 5, spletil M, so 2, Varsanyi 8 Seager. ea Uta.
Srucife of aurovascuor changes mat dete espa tt
Umunopathel Pharmacol 2018 Juy-Doe81. 304682017744. PubMed
in: 29250013, Pubmed Cen PID: PACSEA92Y7, Epub 2007/12,
ng
112] Rib Vogler, Witamson Je Ate capary basement membrane
‘hangs rite 9 oping and to caetes rel Dnbetes 1972 Aa 21,8)
S381 805. Pues PD: 4538085. Epub 1972/0801 eng.
113) Berrau 9, GuilorR Durand ANC Kaus, CabreauT. Passa Pct a Uta-
Sucual aspects ofthe liver peisausodal poce in dabes pats wit
fd shout micoungopaty” Diabetes 162 Dee 3(12)1051-7. Pubod
‘uo: 7173488, Cub 1882/1201 ene
114] Spina M, Garin 5 Minne J Monte IC, Serf Facaind A. Age rene
‘apes in compostin and methanol progertes of he tune med of he
‘Upper thoracic human arta Astesosclerosis (alas, Tes) 1963 an Fb:
(276. Ped PRMD: 6524497. Ep 1883)0)01- or
113] Shethonin BY, Demogsty SP, Maykantow VR aon Gl. Rokewee VS
Disoiduln af Spe kl Vad coagen in ner! and atheresderoe
furan arterial wal: mimunamorpologea characterises. Collagen Relat
es im Sp} 255~68 Pubhiee Pubs 3902343 Epu TORSKN, ene.
115] Masvel PR Tnnns PMC Chandan 5 Cordon D expel ble lve te
‘lon of Ta, M3 and ROMP npn wlth ype dabetes- Diabet
Med |e Diabet Ase 2001 Oe 15 00)777 80. Fused PAID 11578905,
Epub 2001/1027 eng
i] Mami Goan U6 Laschin Yt, Apparent accelerated aging of muman
Callan in diabetes melus, Puabetes 1098 O24 30024, Dubad
Pub: 170154 Epa 1975/1001 ene.
1a] Ranger TA, Wong AM Cook. Coida J. here an asecation betwen
ra
5
‘6
m1
fo
co
{eoinopay and diabetes melitus? A systematic revi with meta-analysis
[Be] Sports Med 2016 Aug's; 982 4. Med PRMD 26800718. pub
2015/1125.
{19} James V7. Ociige 1. Metennan 5, Yue DK. Use of acon in sadly
Sf human dabete and aging collagen. Diabetes 1991. Nara03)391—4
‘obted PMID: 1008280, pb 1991/0510. en,
{20} Coupe C Svensson RB Kongsgaal N. Kevan V, Goss J Seorgaed 0,
Stat Human Achils tendo gheation an funtion a dabetes ApH PS
{tesa = 1985) 2016 an 15: 12001307 Tbe Pe 25251,
pu 2015/10 en
{2h Rosenbloom At Lite joint moby in insulin depend cildhood dia
bets fur | Pela 1950 Mar:1496):380- PubMed PMID: 2185025. Epub
‘so0i001. eng.
12 Ksplan Aes states Sins ME, Herp! Oe SA comparison of
the ype cole eels ofthe intervertebral senate lene a
‘polaber atone eared wh mr msroiceomyESine)
(Gr Publ fur Spire Sec Eur Spal Defornty Soc Eu Section Cec Span es
Scc2018 jan s(t :24-21- rue Pte: 2907141, Ep 2017/1027. en
Vester P Discrepancies intone mineral density race is
patients witn ype ane type 2 cabete.a mets analyse Oneopor® In)
EEzabisbed Rest Coop between Eur Fou Oxeapors Natl Osteoporos
Found USA 2007 ApE-1¢4)-27--4, Cubed PMID: 17068657 Epub 2006/10,
26 ng
Koi A ies of age ad dabetes mis on eysnogen biome digestion
fofthunan da tar alge Connect ise Res 198:11(2"3)165-73
Fubied PAD: 6224690. Fp 1983/00. ers.
{25 Albo DL, fotoog J in WN Schafer Al Shepherd J. Kolad SK Sue
‘nous far Abas inks obey tins esance In Chinese Aaerans
F'Chn aiocrne afta, 2018 Sep 1:1049):3104_ 206. Pabsled PAD
2245511 Pamed Central RUCID: PACE 2591, Epub 20180531. eg
Gaglen ,cardc M,cinsF.Corosnho Farin Adare Meal
‘Gmestalaipese sue Abrosis and insulin fesstance i severe best. Aut
Diabetes 2015 Aug 0:5 e175. Puthted UD: 25258766, Pubmed! Coat
PID: PNICASSH596. Eps 2015/0811 ene
‘am C5. covington 9, Bape! 8. Tehoukon ¥, rk D, Johannsen DL ta
‘Weight an eeals dramatic increases in seletl msl extracel ra
femoreing. | Cin Endocrinol Netad 2074 May919)1740~57. PubMed
tb: 228169, med Cent PMID: PMEADICGRD. Epub 201403708,
123)
124
126)
ra
ene,
‘tan DF, Betupr DL, Rosen WK ee J, Fosham PH, Fre sin
Caples of alate, potest ade apd nenditete suger Changes
Sco iy lig microscope, Diabetes 180 Ap4:251-7. RN PD
‘tz. Fpub 156108). ene
‘Sperstin MD capillary bacemenc membranes an dlabatc necoangipaty.
‘Ag ncn Ned 157218 325" 44 usted Pui #197108, Epub 197230/01
(23)
(29)
{10} Wiiamson lo Curent stats ofan basement membrane dsase
Indabeaes melits Diabecs 1577 Jan26,165- 75 Publed PAID: 313626,
Epub 1877/0701 eng,
{| Ln Dally Ropnsy MS. Micreustion in diabetes alt a sty of
singialiosies, Hu Pathol 1875 ns(}.77~96, PubMed PRI: 1089085,
Eo 1973)01701- ene,
152] Fedengald 8. Anew approach eo some problems of tinal vascular disease
‘Am Opbihatas) 1989 Ape s24)487~95. bed TID: 18114393 Epo
tscgjouot. eng
Ha Notun 5, tte spo £6 curse ype lee i ee
J39(1):31-7 Paes Fb: 2310938 pu 180/001 eng
(34) ers J 1, Sager A, Acaham V, Dion AS. Areata PS Sioherial and
‘nmunohlsocherlalchaaeerain of human type XO defines 3 el
‘us f basement membrane zone coger Ar | Ptkal 1097 Dec 1518)
172930. Pobhee PAID. 8403725, Pubmed Ceniral PMEID: PMC 1838978,
Epub 1857/1224 ene.
135] Weynan 8. Jonckhuore A, Fans A, Rahier |. Diabetes metus induces 2
thickening f the pulmonary bas lamina. REspr int Rev Thorac Ds
1888651 14-8, PubMed PMID: 8573685, Fou 1898)02)12. ene
{196 Hoa Rs 0 Wang Iv, Ning H Wang. Choos! mcrvanuie protieaton
‘Seconaty to habets melts, Oncaret 2017 ln 0 S2) 20240, PabMec
‘hd: 280840, Pubmed Contra PMCID: PMCSASG770. Ep 2016/1223,
ong.
[7] Wocedeman j van Duinketon ¢, Wats MP, Bake F Saaeke , Mll AC,
{tal Prolfrivesetinopathy tn type teases 8 asaiated sh eer
‘crobleeds. wich i part of generalized microangiopathy. Diabetes Cre
Soe apret(ay1 165-8 Phd iD: 24379122. Epub 2013) 10. ng.
Uemura Kawamura, Hota M Pathogenesis and neuroimaging o ie
‘bral ag an snl veal scasen type 2 dabetex «pose nk beeen,
‘eid wel fetal pecs abner, | Dice vet 2017
Manta a8 Pifed PMID: 27238779. Pubmed Cental PMCID!
Pyes324202. Epub 2016/05/31 eng.
Emanuel A, an Duinkesken€ Wales MP, Klein M. Rarhot Fock etal
‘The presence of ceeel wie muller lesions ad lower skin mre
peranion predicts lower eognitve performance n pe tects pales
‘sith recnopaty but not x heathy eontras-A onaltainl study. Mleracr-
uation (New York NY" 1908) 2010 fan 10. 12530, PubMed. PMD:
$3650710. Epub 2015/01/20. en
138)
139)‘ae Adee Ansan et Lj Daews MecaoteSyarame: Cn Reece Revews 52019 1877-1865
10) Kan Hsieh chien HE Ln YH, Yen TY, Chao Cet al cD40-mediated
HIF-taipia expres underiing tncoanglopathy ip labene ave fo
thology. Ds Medes Mac 2018. Ape 25:1(2)PubNed PMID. 29548140,
Pulsed Cenzal PMID: PLC5909861, Epa 2018/03/20. eng,
Jat) Johnson PC Brendel K Meza E. Hunan daetc perineal el basement
‘membrane thckeang Lal nests | Tec Neos Pathol 1081 Mort)
355-70. Pubhed PID: 7464050 Ep 1981/03/01 eng
[a2] Foalso F. Cn G, Magan 5, Caml M, sgh C, Novell, e
Prospective sy on teatstenahy Th ype ? eben fot ler. Di
Sebgi 2090 Jak} 1542-8, PubMed PMD: 2712418. Ep 200510)
2a.one.
143] Walker A Nissen Geiger A Migratory, metabolic and functional alterations
Of frocjis in typo 2 dabetes WHR ie 2018 Novi7QN1}:1122-22,
Push Pub: 40184318 td 2015108). ene
onder L Tariew M,Leveque Challe | Piel N, Lecia ME Cutaneous
tellagenousvasculopathy report of two cases presonting 25 senate
(lingiccasas and review of the Ineratue, Ain] Deamatopathel 2017
Sepiaet?-& ued ub: 28005942. Ep 2017]0614 ene
145] Feingoid KR Browner WS. Siesicin MD. Pspetve stuces of muscle
{plan Basement membrane width ny prea} Cla Fresno Metab
1889 Oece.4; 704 Pubbied PMID: 2778038, Epub 1869/1007. e08.
1} Richardson DK oshyap 8. aM, Cos K, Marana 8). Faas et
tipi infsion decreases the expresicn of nucleat encoded mitochondrial
ees a increases the expression of extaclat rae genes inhuman
Seltlmsl ol Chem 2005 War 191280 11142807, Puen PMID
{S886 Fou 2004/12/76 eng
17] era Wang Rehardson DK, Finlayson for Pratpanawatr ta
Inereeee collagen content in nelnteetat ster muse fm | Poss
Encino ketal 2008 Mor:200/3)e560 5, PubMed PAD 162058,
Epub 2005/1077, eng,
1) Lee Hilo ant histochemical changes inte coronary ares of ld
Gdabeas patents. Dubetologa 1968 NovilS).208-72. PABMeS PMID:
$2233 Epub 18/1101 eng.
[Ha] SiizsoUrwe SusreM,Yooio Ho Tbe Collagen
Temodeling in myocarais of patents wth betes. | Ch Pte. 1893
Janatiy22-6 "Pubhied PDs 7E7OSIR Pobmed Cena" PMDS
PACSOT107, ep 1003/01)0% ery,
[50] uli , Ala, Bohm». Brunt, Hammad, pouser t a Nealal
fellagen turnover in roxmeteasive obese patents exon to ns Tess
Sag Gos) obs tos ora stt-& red Mab Tone
151] Seg Riches KBageghni SA, ORogan Porter KE, Turner NA nes
fasting laerentfuncieral diferences beeen human crdae AbODLS
fur fom nondlabete and Type? dabete dona caslovasc Pho the
mr soc caaiovase Pal 2014 jurAug:25¢4}204" 10. Pubs PMID:
24740387, Ep 20140422 en
‘Watanabe K'Senu 5 Teyoshis H.Yosids M, Thickness of he basement
‘membrane of bronchial epithelial ces In lung dase as determined by
trancronchat hops. Resor Med HE? Auge 7}408— 10, ADA PID
S527041. Ep 1887/6801 ng.
158] Klein OL Krsinan JA cick Sl. Sysematicvevew ofthe assocation
Desteen ung finion and Type 2 dabetes metas, Dabe Wed Je Diabet
‘ssoe 2010 ep:2718):977-87 PubNled PID: 20722670. Epub 2010/0821
ne
154] Lange Groth, Mortensen. Apleyat M.Ayboe Snot Pea Diabetes
‘liu sel venation pac five yea leap a Er Resp |
{hoo ava) 88-02 uted Pan: 24a0Kae Fol SOHDIONON cre
155] Fords, vanino DM Prospective aoc been ung faction ad the
Incidence of dabees: Andings om the nauonal Health and nuiacn exe
tamination. Saveyepidemiagle folowap study, Diatetes Care 2008,
‘bona t2}. 2966-70 Putte MID 15862215 Epes 200413725, eng
196] Lavy F. Bouse sage P. Echinad E, Gin, Bouse L.Grimaud ae
Perino ess sl basement membrane ne marl hers oF
abet patent. Hun Patho! 1057 AugM(@):775 80. PubMed PMID:
Sp1oiza. pub 1087/0501. ng.
1501 Jase Reeoio Sedna Z ibogenesiin fat ver aso with
thesia dabewes metus ype 2 Dig Dis Si 2008 Mars3.785-8,
PubMed PHUD. 17845888, Epub 200778712. ens
1a] Scart Mitel J, the morphology, terminology and pathogenesis of
tera plagues. Potnd Med 1902 ja s8:25~4. PubMed FMD: 15409683,
abd Central Mtb: PUC24E94@8, Eps 19601/0, eng
159] Mech KG, Duance VC, Bishop KA. the astibuion Or elage tyes
fd V (AB) normal and atheroserticuman aorta. | Patho 1580
Jansnaa aso Pubntce Pubs 691657 pun TORGIN|OL. ene
[60] Jonasson i oi Sal ndjersG Hansson GK Regional acunulatons
fells macrophages and smooth inste cll the human thevoslec
Plague. Ateriwleros (Das. Tex) 1986 M-Apo2) 131-8, Publ
PMID: 2937595 Epub 1985)0310. en
Jot] Newnan are WP, Watuey W, Berenson CS, Autopsy studs in United
States chiléren and adolescents, Relationship a sk torso atherosclete
lesons Ann 9 Aca! St IDOI S2216-25, PubMed PMD: 2042828. fd
Wa
182
(2
(os
(sa)
(6s
(69)
(6a)
(68)
(69
(70)
vm
va
731
va)
1
v5
im
ps)
9
(80)
1991/01/01, ena.
Stary HC, Chair AB, Clagow Cayton J sl Je W, Resend ME et
‘Adesnton a tal tty sesh spa inlempedlt leona theo
A repo fom te Comentee on Vascular Lesions ofthe Coon on Ate.
Sclerosis, American Hear Assocation. Cieulaton 1984 May8S).2462-75,
Pubhies Pub: 8131178. epub 1003/05/01. eng.
Stary HC. Chandler AB, Digsmore RE, Raster Vy, Glgov 5, sll Jk Wet
‘dstnwion of advanced types of atbereslerete lesions and 3 histalageal
fasten of atereeerosh. A tet rm the Commitee on Vase
tesons of the Counel on Arterosclerons, American Heat Aasocaton Arte
Hoscie ram Vase Ba! 1995 Sep: 13(9 12-31 Pubhed PMID: T7907.
Epub 199509), eng
\Vismant & Keldge 1D, burke AP, ab A Schwait St, Lesins fiom sudden
‘oronary deth: a compreensive morpbelogel canieaton scheme for
iheroeotc lesions Arteroscer Tom Vase tol 2000 Mayi203)
1962.75 PubMed PM 10807742 pun D0DN/!1G eng
MeGilj He MeManan CA Herderick E, Zeke AW, Maom GT, Tracy RE
‘al Obes accelerates the progression of caranay atheresclrus tn young
pen. Greltion 2002 Jun 11105231-2712-8, PubMed PMID: 1205793,
Epub 2002105/12. eng
overs RB, Debecnadl 8 Cletlens J. Schurgess UL Mutsaers 8. yan der
Vasse Gl. bcrocaications ies ial esans of three human
foronary steve AN J Fal 200 fu! 7(6)2879-87. PubMed PMID
21331376. Pubned Catal PMCID: PMCS 129016, Ep 2011105103. erg.
louryshev Lard, Vlarten BA Caleies depos oration nial
thickens of the human ara. Atevoseorosts 1005. Nov:T18:9-21
Pabhee Pb: 8579636 tau 1955/11/01 ene
ProvtooeD.Skepper JN, Hes, toner Mk, Shanahan CM. Welssorg PL
‘Apoptosis regulates haan vascular aeteatin ia vive: evidee fo in
thon of velar caliiation by. apoptotic bodies Cie Res 2000 Nov
‘gan 1):1085- 6, Pubed PMI: 11090332 fh 2000/1795 ene
Batsan Ml A utceson JO Alaa crac vesicles s mediators
ff canhovaclarcacficaton: ron Catdovese Med 2007498, Pabhied
hab: 20329045, Pond Cental PMID: FMICS790 140. Ep 20161001,
ns
Fors RB Dutta RK, Cleans JP, Musas PH. de Goch. van der Vase
Eel eaetieabons ia humva corona arteries a detetined with 3 proton
‘mktorobe, Anal chem 2008 Jan 1801)55-61 Pued PMID: 180zrs0s,
Epub 2007/11/22 eng
Selvin & Naja 38 Comish TC, Matsa MK. A comprehensive hcoptho
ice eshte of celina seven: Geass a phon
‘ogy of stra sifering.Athroserose 2010 an-208{169-P4 Pub
Pb Tecsa07y.rubined Cenest PMCID: FMC2811392. Epub 200907728,
ns
{er Song, i i, py, shin Gi, Kim, ta. Functional ecatation
‘fsmooth masie cells sa ced plsypotent tery cel ftom aman sori
Socth msl calls Cire Res 2010 Jon 8:1081)4120-3. PubMed PMID:
1905997 Epub 2000/1205. eng.
‘Meculagh KA, Blan C. Cllage eharaetoisation and cell ansormation in
human atherosclerosis Nate 1973 Now 6258 35308 75-5. Pabed PMID
186882. ub 1975/13/00 ens.
Chstakoy DA, myasoedove VA Menichenko AA, Greek AV, Orekov AN
Caen’ mati vests and ‘atherelernBiobed Res Int 2017 20"7
{aGa300. bhted PHD. 26238720, Pubmed Cental PMCID: PMCS 2,
Epub 2017/2115. eng
Benson F ula K, Dance P, AsutoG,Almgren Oro Alacer
SEAL ADAMS"? tr ncocatd with» high-rie plaque phenotype inhuman
Shorts Se Rep 2017 jun 10:71)3753. Pubes PND: 28623250
Pubmed Central PCID: PMCSA7877. Ep 2017/06/15 eng
Rees K:Alshanwan AR, Warburton f, Reza 0 Ball SG, Wood IC ct
Elevated expression ves of ml-43}5 im saphenoun vein sean mice
tells rm paints with Type 2 dobetes dive persistent changes in pheno
lupe and inet. Mol Cell Crd 2014 Sep: 73:240~ 30. PubAed PMID:
276. Pubmed Central PMCID: PMCHT2ISS4. Epub 20140615 ne
Kuan A. Choowska A Pezowice C, Witkewiez “W, Gann A
Nalcmowice Ke al The content of collagen typeI uma ates
fomebted withthe sage of atherosdero and cation foc Canoxate
Patol OM Sc Cardiovasc Patel 2017 May = h:28-21~7. PubMed PMID:
25284062 Epub 20170312. ong.
Hector Ee, Hobs So. Mercer DK, tritengen j Walrghe cL. uakatve
easurcment of mature collagen cas in thurs afd ary pags
Iipeosletoss 2010 Augs2tI(2}471-a. PubMed PD. 20417515, pub
aoiowstrr ene.
‘Voce kauterberg | Lcazaion of elagn ype iW aa V, Abronectin
lain in burtan ates bythe inde ammneuorscence rete.
anoles Pract 18 Oce181(5)'358-75. PubMed PMD 3837302. Epub
6/070. ers.
Hurcheson JD. Goetsch eraero 8, Maldonado N Ruiz J Goh W. et 2
Genesis and growth of extraceulat-vese-derved mieocalatcaton In
ibevoscerotie pues No Mater 2016 Mar-153) 935-48, se PND
ipa26n4.Pulnned Central PMCID: PMCATGTG?S. Epub 20160112 ne