N° 66, 2011

pp. 89-106

) !"#+$%+& '($#*,-%-+-#$+./0%- +1+$%/+

& 20"%0%&, 2#/+%-',2,/0"%0,3%/
4! 50+ 06#+ & '($#7,01+ 8+ 06#+ /0%0#+ %2-+ %-',2,/0"%0,3#+
& 20"%&0/
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA*

%&234&5+.$+0#'%+-#+$ /+& 20"%0 /+95#+&#$#!"%+#$+./0%- +6%+/,:2,8,&%- +52+0#'%+

-#+,20#";/+& 2/0%20#+(%"%+#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+-#!,- +%+$%/+(%"0,&5$%",-%>
-#/+95#+%- (0%2+$%/+8,:5"%/+& 20"%&05%$#/+%($,&%-%/+( "+#$+/#&0 "+(?!$,& +#2+#$+
"-#2+&,#20@8,& A+4-,&, 2%$'#20#=+#/#+,20#";/+/#+6%+,2&"#'#20%- +& 2+$%+%'>
($,%&,B2+-#$+#'($# +-#+$ /+& 20"%0 /+C& 2+ &%/,B2+-#+$ /+&%'!, /+ (#"%- /+( "+
$%+:$ !%$,D%&,B2CA+.$+#28 95#+95#+/#+ 8"#&#+%+& 20,25%&,B2+%(520%+%+$%+& 2/,>
-#"%&,B2+-#+$%+& '($#*,-%-+("#/#20#+#2+$%+%&&,B2+(?!$,&%=+(%"%+%/@+& '("#2-#"+
'#* "+#$+#20 "2 +-#+$ /+& 20"%0 /+(?!$,& /+1+/5+%$&%2&#=+1+ !0#2#"+52%+&$%"%+
(#"/(#&0,3%+/ !"#+$ +95#+%( "0%+#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +:$ !%$A
!"#"$%"&'(#")*++E 20"%0 +F+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+F+' 3,$,-%-+F+/,/0#'%+& '($#* +F+
:$ !%$,D%&,B2+F+<#"#&6

!627-*,7+E 20"%&0/+& 2&$5-#-+!1+06#+/0%0#+%"#+%+5/5%$+%/+2#&#//%"1+0#&62,95#+

,2+06#+(5!$,&+'%2%:#'#20+%88%,"#+"#'%,2,2:+& 2/0%20$1+,'( "0%20+8 "+06#+(5!$,&+
%-',2,/0"%0, 2+%2-+06#+%-',2,/0"%0,3#+$%G=+%/+%+/&,#20,8,&+,0#'A+4--,0, 2%$$1=+06,/+
,20#"#/0+6%/+,2&"#%/#-+G,06+06#+#2$%":#'#20+ 8+06#+5/#+ 8+06#+& 20"%&0/=+-5",2:+
06#+&6%2:#/+&%5/#-+!1+:$ !%$,D%0, 2A+H6#+ 88#"#-+%((" %&6+( ,20/+0 +06#+& 2>
/,-#"%0, 2+ 8+06#+& '($#7,01+("#/#20+,2+(5!$,&+%&0, 2=+8 "+%+!#00#"+52-#"/0%2-,2:+
8+06#+#23," 2'#20+ 8+(5!$,&+(" &5"#'#20/+%2-+06#,"+"#%&6=+& 2/,-#",2:+06#+
(#"/(#&0,3#+!" 5:60+!1+06#+:$ !%$+%-',2,/0"%0,3#+$%GA
,*-'./%0&++E 20"%&0+F+4-',2,/0"%0, 2+F+I !,$,01+F+E '($#7+/1/0#'+F+J$ >
!%$,D%0, 2+F+K%G

CONTENIDO: PRELIMINAR.– I. EL ESTADO Y SUS COMPLEJIDADES.–

II. EL CONTRATO ADMINISTRATIVO COMO INSTRUMENTO NECESARIO.–
III. SUJETO, FORMAS Y CONTROL EN UN CONTEXTO COMPLEJO.

PRELIMINAR
K%/+&5#/0, 2#/+"#$%0,3%/+%+$%+& 20"%0%&,B2+-#$+./0%- +C +%$+./0%- C+/#+
2 /+("#/#20%2+& ' +52+%/520 +&%":%- +-#+& 0,-,%2,-%-=+( "+$ +5/5%$+-#+
("#/#2&,%+#2+$%+"50,2%+("L&0,&%+-#+$%+!5" &"%&,%+(?!$,&%=+$ +95#+(#"',0#+
-#*%"+ -#+ $%- + C/,2+ 95#+ #$$ + (5#-%+ 0 '%"/#+ & ' + 52%+ ( /,&,B2+ -#+

! "%!/#$*0%$#!(0!&'!)+,-0#%,('(!.0+1#'&!(0!20+0340&'!5!6,067#$!*4+('($#!(0&!8$#$!970#$'60#,:'+$!(0!
;0#0:<$!=(6,+,%1#'1,-$>
 MN -#/,20#";/+ + -#/("#&, + ( "+ $%+ "#8$#7,B2+ &,#20@8,&%C+ $%/+ 1%+ %O#*%/+ (#" +
& 2/0%20#/+1+/ /0#2,-%/+"#8$#7, 2#/+0#B",&%/+%&#"&%+-#+$%+#7,/0#2&,%+-#+
$ /+& 20"%0 /+%-',2,/0"%0,3 /=+$ /+& 20"%0 /+(?!$,& /=+ +$ /+& 20"%0 /+-#$+
./0%- +& ' +52%+&%0#: "@%+& 2+2%05"%$#D%+*5"@-,&%+(" (,%+ +%50B2 '%P+
& ' + & 20"%0 /+ 95#+ 6%2+ & 2/0,05,- + 1+ & 2/0,051#2+ %&05%$'#20#+ C
%-#'L/+-#+/5+-#&,-,-%+3 &%&,B2+-#+(" 1#&0%"/#+#2+#$+8505" C+52+0#'%+
95#+Q0,#2#+/5/0%2&,%+( $;',&%RSA+K +&,#"0 +#+,2#$5-,!$#+#/+95#+#$+./0%- +
& 20"%0%P+#/+-#&,"=+#$+./0%- =+#2+0%20 +/5*#0 +-#+<#"#&6 +95#+#/=+#'($#%+
$%+ 0;&2,&%+ *5"@-,&%+ & 20"%&05%$+ & ' + 52%+ 6#""%',#20%+ 5/5%$+ #2+ /5+
-#/#'(#O +(%"%+#$+&%!%$+$ :" +-#+/5/+8,2#/=+1+$ +6%&#=+&$%" +#/0L=+%+0"%3;/+
-#+ $%+ Q852&,B2+ %-',2,/0"%0,3%R=+ 95#+ & 2/0,051#+ $%+ 8B"'5$%+ (#"%0,3%+
'#-,%20#+$%+&5%$+#$+./0%- +/#+3,2&5$%=+*5"@-,&%'#20#+6%!$%2- =+& 2+ 0" /+
/5*#0 /+-#+<#"#&6 +C1%+/#%2+#/0 /+$ /+&,5-%-%2 /+ +%-',2,/0"%- /C+ +
0%'!,;2+#2+$ +"#8#",- +%+2#: &, /+*5"@-,& /+#20"#+/5*#0 /+ +#20#/+(?!$,& /=+
$ /+&5%$#/+#/0%!$#&#2+2#7 /+& 20"%&05%$#/+-,3#"/ /=+%+8,2+-#+&5'($,"+& 2+
$ /+& '#0,- /+-#+:#/0,B2+95#+0,#2#2+%/,:2%- /A
46 "%+!,#2=+-#20" +-#+$ /+'?$0,($#/+#28 95#/+0#'L0,& /+95#+/#+(5#-#2+
#7($ "%"+#2+$%+%'($,%+& 2/0#$%&,B2+/5/0%20,3%+95#+& '("#2-#+#$+%&L(,0#+
-#+$%+& 20"%0%&,B2+(?!$,&%+ +& 2+#$+./0%- =+#2+#/0%+ ( "052,-%-+6%"#' /+
"#8#"#2&,%+%+%$:52 /+-#+$ /+%$&%2&#/+1+(" !$#'%/+95#+-#",3%2+-#+$%/+& '>
($#*,-%-#/+8 "'%$#/+95#+,'("#:2%2+C#2+8 "'%+,20#:"%$C+%+$%+%-',2,/>
0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%=+1=+(%"0,&5$%"'#20#=+%+/5/+'%2,8#/0%&, 2#/+& 20"%&05%$#/=+
0%20 +#2+#$+(" &#/ +-#+8 "'%&,B2+-#$+& 20"%0 =+& ' +#2+$ +"#8#"#20#+%+
$%+#*#&5&,B2+1+$ /+'#&%2,/' /+-#+& 20" $+-,/(5#/0 /+(%"%+:%"%20,D%"+$ /+
-#"#&6 /+(5#/0 /+#2+*5#: A+./0 +/#+("#0#2-#+ !/#"3%"+-#/-#+$%+(#"/(#&>
0,3%+95#+!",2-%=+("#&,/%'#20#=+$%+& '($#*,-%-+',/'%+-#$+./0%- +& ' +
%(%"%0 =+& ' + ":%2,D%&,B2=+1+& ' +%&0,3,-%-+ +852&,B2+95#+#/0L+52,- +
%$+<#"#&6 +1+%+/5/+'%2,8#/0%&, 2#/+3%$ "%0,3%/+#+,2/0"5'#20%$#/=+$%/+&5%>
$#/+6%2+ (#"%- +6,/0B",&%'#20#+& ' +52+8%&0 "+,20#:"%- "=+(#" +95#=+
#2+#$+' '#20 +%&05%$=+#2+$%+"#%$,-%-+& 20#'( "L2#%+95#+2 /+& '(#0#=+
%-95,#"#2+ &%"%&0#"@/0,&%/+ (%"0,&5$%"'#20#+ -#/0%&%-%/=+ #2+ %0#2&,B2+ %$+
'%"&%- +#+,2#$5-,!$#+(" &#/ +-#+:$ !%$,D%&,B2=+/ !"#+0 - +& 2+#$+%3%2&#+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

-#+$%/+25#3%/+0#&2 $ :@%/+C#2+(%"0,&5$%"+$%/+"#$%0,3%/+%+$%+,28 "'%&,B2+

1+$%/+& '52,&%&, 2#/C+,'(%&0%+'%/,3%'#20#=+1+#2+8 "'%+-#&,/,3%=+$%/+
"#$%&, 2#/+&5$05"%$#/=+#& 2B',&%/+1+*5"@-,&%/+95#+/5":#2+'L/+3#$ D'#20#+
#20"#+/5*#0 /+-#+-,3#"/ +( "0#+1+#20,-%-=+1+95#+%6 "%+%(%"#&#2+"#:,-%/+
( "+#$+<#"#&6 +(?!$,& +1+#$+<#"#&6 +(",3%- +-#+'%2#"%+("L&0,&%'#20#+
,20#:"%-%=+,20#"%&0,3%=+& '($#'#20%",%+ =+,2&$5/ =+,2-,/0,20%A
.2+#8#&0 =+%+(%"0,"+-#+$%+/,'($#+(#"&#(&,B2+-#+25#/0"%+-,2L',&%+& 0,>
-,%2%=+#/+8 "D / +"#& 2 &#"+1+& 2&$5,"+95#+$%+"#3 $5&,B2+0#&2 $B:,&%+-#+
$%/+?$0,'%/+-;&%-%/+6%+0"%2/8 "'%- +$%+& 2&#(&,B2+1+#$+8 "'%0 +-#+$%/+

?! @'&!0%!0&!1A#6,+$!/$#!,B4'&!,&4%1#'1,-$!5!/#0:,%$!C40!06/&0'!0&!6'0%1#$!"(4'#($!D'#:E'!(0!"+10##E'!0+!
%4!0+%'5$!FG'!*,B4#'!(0&!:$+1#'1$!'(6,+,%1#'1,-$H>!+ !"#$%(& ()&'"*"#$,%-".*(/012"-%(J+)/3I!JK!L?I!
?MNOI!/>!?PPI!Q'(#,(>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 TT

%&0,3,-%-#/+65'%2%/+& 2+#8#&0 +'52-,%$=+1+6%+,'(5$/%- =+#2+'51+!"#3#+

($%D =+#$+/5":,',#20 +1+$%+,2/0%$%&,B2+-#8,2,0,3%+-#+25#3%/+8 "'%/+-#+ ">
:%2,D%&,B2=+0"%!%* =+"#$%&,B2=+& '52,&%&,B2+1+2#: &, /+#20"#+,2-,3,-5 /+
1+ ":%2,D%&, 2#/=+8#2B'#2 +-#$+&5%$+2 +(5#-#+#/&%(%"+#$+./0%- A
MS
SOBRE LA
.$+#28 95#+/#$#&&, 2%- +(#"',0#+& '("#2-#"+95#+0%$#/+&,"&52/0%2&,%/+ COMPLEJIDAD
6%2+0#2,- =+#2+'%0#",%+-#+& 20"%0%&,B2+& 2+#$+./0%- =+#$+&%"L&0#"+1+$%+ DEL ESTADO Y LAS
&5%$,-%-+-#+Q& 2/0%20#/R=+#/0 +#/=+-#+8%&0 "#/+/,#'("#+("#/#20#/+C& 2+ CONTRATACIONES
'%1 "+ +'#2 "+,20#2/,-%-+ +#70#2/,B2C=+1+& 2+#8#&0 +,2#$5-,!$#'#2> ADMINISTRATIVAS
0#+,28$51#20#+#2+$%+& 28#&&,B2+0#B",&%=+%$+,:5%$+95#+#2+$%+"#%$,D%&,B2+1+ ABOUT THE
%-%(0%&,B2+ ("L&0,&%+ -#+ $%+ &5#/0,B2+ & 20"%&05%$+ -#+ $%+ %-',2,/0"%&,B2+ COMPLEXITY OF
(?!$,&%A THE STATE AND
ADMINISTRATIVE
U%"%+& '#2D%"=+#/+& 23#2,#20#+0#2#"+#2+& 2/,-#"%&,B2+95#+0%$+#*#"&,&, + CONTRACTS
'#0 - $B:,& +,23,0%+%+0 '%"+& ' +(520 +-#+(%"0,-%+$%+"#3,/,B2+-#+%$:5>
2 /+-%0 /+"#$%0,3 /+%$+./0%- +1+%+/5+&%0#: ",D%&,B2+*5"@-,&%+& ' +Q("#>
/5(5#/0 +/5!*#0,3 R+,2#7&5/%!$#+#2+&5%$95,#"+%(" 7,'%&,B2+%+$%+0;&2,&%+
& 20"%&05%$=+1%+95#+/#+(%"0#+-#+95#+/5+&%"L&0#"+-#+%&0 +,20#:"%- "+-#+
3 $520%-#/+/5( 2#+Q/5*#0 /R+95#+& 2&5""%2+#2+0%$+,20#:"%&,B2A
H%$+&,"&52/0%2&,%+,'($,&%=+%+/5+3#D=+& 2/,-#"%"+$%+(%"0,&5$%"+& '($#*,-%-+
":%2,D%0,3%+ 95#+ %& '(%O%+ %$+ ./0%- + & ' + 8,:5"%+ *5"@-,&%A+ U#" =+ %-,>
&, 2%$'#20#=+#2+#$+&%/ +-#$+./0%- +1+0 -%/+$%/+( /,!$#/+ ":%2,D%&, 2#/+
+#20,-%-#/+(?!$,&%/+#2+:#2#"%$=+%(%"#&#+& ' +-%0 +,2#7&5/%!$#+$%+#/>
(#&@8,&%+/5*#&,B2+%$+<#"#&6 +95#+-#$,',0%+/5/+%&05%&, 2#/+-#+&5%$95,#"+
2%05"%$#D%=+#2+%0#2&,B2+%$+(",2&,(, +-#+$#:%$,-%-+95#+-#0#"',2%=+#2+/5/+
$@2#%/+!L/,&%/+ +#/#2&,%$#/=+#$+(#"8,$+-#+& 28,:5"%&,B2+& 2&#(05%$+-#$+./>
0%- +-#+<#"#&6 +!%* +$%+& 2&#(&,B2+'L/+%3%2D%-%+-#+$%+&,3,$,D%&,B2=+
#2+&5%20 +%+$%+#/0"5&05"%+ ":%2,D%0,3%+1+$%/+8 "'%/+3L$,-%/+(%"%+#$+#*#">
&,&, +-#$+( -#"A+H - +#/0 + (#"%+!%* +#$+'%1 "+:"%- +-#+3,2&5$%&,B2+%+$%+
2 "'%+*5"@-,&%=+$ +&5%$+/#+0"%-5&#+#2+& '($#*,-%-+852&, 2%$=+#2+%!,#"0 +
& 20"%/0#+& 2+#$+(",2&,(, +-#+$,!#"0%-+-#+%&&,B2+6%/0%+$ +(" 6,!,- +( "+
$%+2 "'%=+95#+/,"3#+-#+'%"& +%+$%+%&05%&,B2+-#+$ /+/5*#0 /=+#2+#$+&%'( +
-#$+<#"#&6 +(",3%- A
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

4+/5+3#D=+#$$ +6%&#+-,",:,"+$%+',"%-%+6%&,%+$ /+Q%/(#&0 /+852&, 2%$#/R+95#+

(#"%2+*5"@-,&%'#20#+(%"%+$%+& 2/0"5&&,B2=+#7("#/,B2+1+#*#&5&,B2+-#+$%+
3 $520%-+-#+$ /+/5*#0 /V+$ +95#+#2+#/(%&, +-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +
/#+(%0#20,D%+#2+$%+2 &,B2+-#$+Q(" &#-,',#20 RA+.$+(" &#-,',#20 +& ' +
&%0#: "@%+,'("#:2%+$%+0 0%$,-%-+-#$+%&05%"+%-',2,/0"%0,3 + =+(%"%+/#"+'L/+
("#&,/ +#2+$%+%8,"'%&,B2=+,'("#:2%+$%+0 0%$,-%-+-#+$%/+%&05%&, 2#/+-#$+
./0%- =+ (#" + & 2+ $%+ & 22 0%&,B2+ -#+ :%"%20@%+ #2+ 8%3 "+ -#$+ &,5-%-%2 +
%$+&5%$+/,"3#A+U "+#$$ =+$%+#7,/0#2&,%+-#+$%/+#7,:#2&,%/+(" &#-,'#20%$#/=+
& ' +"#95,/,0 +#/#2&,%$+-#+3%$,-#D+-#+$%/+-#&,/, 2#/+(?!$,&%/=+#/+52+-%0 +
95#+0%'!,;2+%(%"#&#+#2+#$+#/&#2%", +-#+$%+& '($#*,-%-=+52,- +%+52%+-#+
/5/+(",2&,(%$#/+& 2/#&5#2&,%/+("L&0,&%/+1+*5"@-,&%/=+#$+&5%$+#/+#$+Q& 20" $R+
/ !"#+$%/+& 20"%0%&, 2#/+C0%20 +#2+$ +95#+& 2&,#"2#+%+/5/+8 "'%$,-%-#/=+
Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420
 MW & ' +#2+$ +95#+%0%O#+%+$%+#*#&5&,B2=+%(520%2- +%+$ /+'#&%2,/' /+-#+
"#/( 2/%!,$,-%-CA
4+0"%3;/+-#+$%+"#3,/,B2+-#+$ /+%/(#&0 /+'L/+-#/0%&%- /+/ !"#+0%$#/+-%0 /=+
/#+(" ( 2#+#$+#*#"&,&, +-#+"#8$#7,B2+95#+/#+& 2/,:2%+#2+$ /+0;"',2 /+95#+
/,:5#2A

I . E L E S TA D O Y S U S C O M P L E J I D A D E S
X +#/+-#/("#&,%!$#+2,+/5(#"8$5 +,2-%:%"+/ !"#+#$+/#20,- +6,/0B",& +-#+$%/+
(%$%!"%/=+1%+95#=+#2+'5&6%/+ &%/, 2#/=+#/0#+/#+#2&5#20"%+#/0"#&6%'#20#+
%0%- +%$+/#20,- +',/' +-#+$%/+,-#%/+ +,2/0,05&, 2#/+&51 +/,:2,8,&%- +#7>
("#/%2+ +-#/,:2%2=+0%$+& ' +/5&#-#+#2+#$+&%/ +-#$+Q./0%- RA+4/@=+(5#/=+
"#/5$0%+,20#"#/%20#+1+?0,$+(%"%+#$+%2L$,/,/+"#%$,D%"+52%+!"#3#+"#8#"#2&,%+%+
#/0#+(520 =+& ' +(",'#"+' 3,',#20 +6%&,%+#$+ !*#0,3 +95#+2 /+6#' /+
0"%D%- A
.$+5/ +-#+$%+(%$%!"%+Q./0%- R=+& 2+$%+& 22 0%&,B2+95#+52,3#"/%$'#20#+
/#+$#+%0",!51#+#2+$%+%&05%$,-%-=+/#+5!,&%+-5"%20#+$ /+,2,&, /+-#$+/,:$ +YZ[=+
1+ $%+ ,2,&,%0,3%+ -#+ /5+ #'($# + /#+ %0",!51#+ %+ X,& $L/+ I%95,%3#$ + \#2+ 6!$
)(B&1%)"=+-#+S]S^_A+.$+%50 "+$%+#'($#%+(%"%+,-#20,8,&%"+Q$ /+- ',2, /+95#+
6%2+0#2,- +1+& 20,2?%2+0#2,#2- +,'(#", +/ !"#+$ /+6 '!"#/R8$<#+#/0#+
' - =+/#+%&5O%+52+2# $ :,/' +(%"%+,-#20,8,&%"+%+52+8#2B'#2 +25#3 +1+
2 3#- / A+E ' +#7($,&%+I $#/V
K%+%(%",&,B2+-#$+./0%- +& 2/0,051#=+$%+:"%2+2 3#-%-+-#+$%+;( &%+' >
-#"2%=+95#+("#&,/%'#20#+/#+&%"%&0#",D%+( "+(" -5&,"/#+#2+#$$%+$%+:"%2+
& 2/0#$%&,B2+-#+$ /+./0%- /+#5" (# /+`ab+.3,-#20#'#20#+#$+2 '!"#+-#+
./0%- +6%!"@%+-#+/#"3,"+(%"%+-#/,:2%"+52%+8 "'%&,B2+( $@0,&%+ ",:,2%$=+/,2+
,-#20,-%-+& 2+ 0"%/+%20#", "#/+\c#,2 /=+U",2&,(%- /=+['(#", /_A+<#+#/0%+
'%2#"%+"#:,/0"%!%+52%+52,-%-+( $@0,&%+&51%+#7,/0#2&,%+1+(#"/,/0#2&,%+#"%+
,2-#(#2-,#20#+-#+$%+8,:5"%+-#$+U"@2&,(#+1+-#$+c#1=+#+,2&$5/ +-#+$%/+& $#&>
0,3,-%-#/+/ &,%$#/+0%$#/+& ' +$%+[:$#/,%=+$%+4",/0 &"%&,%+ +$%/+d$,:%"95@%/=+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

%+(#/%"+-#+$ +-#/0%&%- +-#+/5+& '#0,- A+.$+./0%- +/5!/,/0#+%/@+/#(%"%>

-%'#20#=+& 2+,'(5/ +(" (, =+-#+$%/+,2-,3,-5%$,-%-#/=+85#"%2+;/0%/+/5/+
: !,#"2 /+ +/5/+!#2#8,&,%", /+`ab+.$+./0%- =+#/%+"#%$,-%-+#'#":#20#+-#+
$%+;( &%=+/#+& 23,#"0#+#2+52+& 2&#(0 +52,3#"/%$=+95#+#/+#$+95#+/#+#7("#/%+
& 2+#$+3 &%!$ +Q./0%- R=+#$+',/' +#2+0 - /+$ /+,-, '%/+,2- >#5" (# /V+
Q)0%0 R=+#2+,0%$,%2 P+Qe0%0R+`ab=+#2+8"%2&;/P+Q)0%%0R=+#2+%$#'L2P+Q)0%0#R=+
#2+,2:$;/A+H%20 +#$+& 2&#(0 +./0%- =+& ' +#$+2 '!"#=+95#-%" 2+52,>
3#"/%$,D%- /A+),2+#'!%": =+$%+(%$%!"%+2 +/,"3#+-#+"B05$ +%+52+(" -5&0 +
,2%$0#"%!$#P+%$+& 20"%", =+-#/-#+#20 2&#/+\/,:$ +YZ[_+#$$%+3%+%-%(0L2- /#+
%$+(" &#/ +#3 $50,3 +-#+%95#$$ +95#+#7("#/%+`abRWA

R! 2A'%0!,"&'2(5)07'/6(=+1$+,$>!F"%1'($!5!;0#0:<$!S:$+*,B4#':,T+!U4#E(,:'!(0&!"%1'($VH>!"+!4#$5&"6#(
& (7 , -86(9012"-6>!.'#':'%W!)+,-0#%,('(!.0+1#'&!(0!20+0340&'I!9+%1,141$!(0!;0#0:<$!XY7&,:$I!?MMZI!
/>!ZM>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 TT

.20 2&#/=+-#/-#+/5+%(%",&,B2+6,/0B",&%+8 "'%$+C95#+#2+#$+- ',2, +&,#2>

0@8,& +(" (, +-#+$%/+&,#2&,%/+/ &,%$#/+\(%"0,&5$%"'#20#+#2+#$+<#"#&6 =+$%+
/ &, $ :@%+1+$%+&,#2&,%+( $@0,&%_+/#+5!,&%+#2+#$+(#"@ - +,2-,&%- C+/#+"#>
& 2 &#+$%+#7,/0#2&,%+-#$+./0%- +& ' +52+8#2B'#2 +:#2#"%$,D%- =+( "+/5+
M^
52,3#"/%$,D%&,B2P+(#" =+%-#'L/=+0%'!,;2+/#+'%2,8,#/0%+/5+:#2#"%$,D%&,B2+ SOBRE LA
COMPLEJIDAD
& ' +& 2/#&5#2&,%+-#+/5+#/0"#&6%+"#$%&,B2+-#+&%5/%>#8#&0 +& 2+#$+"#8 ">
DEL ESTADO Y LAS
D%',#20 + +$%+"#3,0%$,D%&,B2+-#$+<#"#&6 =+#2+0%20 +95#+#/+52+#$#'#20 +
CONTRATACIONES
-#+,20#:"%&,B2+,2/0,05&, 2%$+&%(%D+-#+%( "0%"+$%/+!%/#/+2#&#/%",%/+(%"%+$%+
ADMINISTRATIVAS
& 2/0"5&&,B2+0#B",&%+1+$%+"#%$,D%&,B2+("L&0,&%+-#+$%+,-#%+-#$+( -#"+( $@0,>
& +,20#:"%- +#+,20#:"%- "=+$ +95#+!L/,&%'#20#+/#+"#/5#$3#+%+0"%3;/+-#+$%+ ABOUT THE
"#&#(&,B2+-#$+<#"#&6 +" '%2 +& ' +'#-, +#8,&,#20#+(%"%+& 20"%""#/0%"+ COMPLEXITY OF
THE STATE AND
%+$%+-,/:"#:%&,B2+1+-#/,20#:"%&,B2+-#+$ /+0#"",0 ", /+:#"'%2 /A+.2+#/0#+
ADMINISTRATIVE
/#20,- =+#/+& 2052-#20#+$%+( /,&,B2+-#+f#$$#"+#2+/5+%2L$,/,/+/ !"#+$ /+
CONTRACTS
/5(5#/0 /+6,/0B",& /+-#$+./0%- +%&05%$V
.$+./0%- +/B$ +( -@%+,2-#(#2-,D%"/#+& ' +52,-%-+-#+%&&,B2+',$,0%"=+#& >
2B',&%+1+( $@0,&%+!%* +$%+8 "'%+-#+52%+,2-#(#2-,D%&,B2+& ' +52,-%-+-#+
-#&,/,B2+*5"@-,&%+52,3#"/%$A+K%+-,/:"#:%&,B2+( $@0,&%+-#$+['(#" +1+-#+$ /+
H#"",0 ", /+6%!@%+%&%""#%- +52%+,20 $#"%!$#+,2/#:5",-%-+#2+#$+-#"#&6 +
`ab+g"#20#+%+$%+-,/:"#:%&,B2+*5"@-,&%+:#"'%2%+%(%"#&@%+#$+<#"#&6 +c >
'%2 =+/,/0#'%0,D%- +( "+$%+!5" &"%&,%+h5/0,2,%2 =+& ' +52+=-+$1"('-:aA
.$+-#"#&6 +&5$0 +6,D +("#&,/%+#2& '#2-%"+$%+h5/0,&,%+%+852&, 2%", /+#/>
(#&,%$,D%- /=+8 "'%- /+#2+#$+<#"#&6 +c '%2 +#2+$%/+52,3#"/,-%-#/+-#$+
2 "0#+-#+[0%$,%+`ab^A

<#+ #/0%+ '%2#"%+ /#+ (" -5&#+ $%+ ,2/0%$%&,B2+ -#8,2,0,3%+ -#$+ ./0%- + & ' +
#/0"5&05"%+ ( $@0,&%+ -,/(5#/0%+ (%"%+ $%+ ,20#:"%&,B2+ -#$+ ( -#"=+ $ + 95#+ 3%+
%& '(%O%- =+-#/-#+$5#: =+-#+$%+& 28,:5"%&,B2+-#+#/%+#/0"5&05"%+ ":L2,>
&%+*5",-,8,&%-%+#2+(%"0,&5$%"=+( "+$ +95#+& ""#/( 2-#+%+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+
C& ' +$%+#7("#/,B2+'L/+%3%2D%-%+-#+$%+ ":%2,D%&,B2+/ &,%$=+%95#$$ +
95#+ #2+ 0;"',2 /+ %&05%$#/+ ( -"@%+ #20#2-#"/#+ & ' + 52%+ '%2,8#/0%&,B2+
/5(#", "+-#+$%+Q/ &,#-%-+&,3,$+ ":%2,D%-%R+(%"%+#$+'%2#* +-#+$ +(?!$,& =+
-#+$ /+%/520 /+& $#&0,3 /=+-#+%95#$$ /+%/520 /+95#+( "+/5+(" (,%+2%05"%>
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

$#D%+2 +(5#-#2+#2& 20"%"+%0#2&,B2+/%0,/8%&0 ",%+%+0"%3;/+-#+$%+%&05%&,B2+

/,2:5$%"+-#+$ /+,2-,3,-5 /+95#+,20#:"%2+$%/+& '52,-%-#/C+$%+0%"#%+-#$+
#'($# +-#+0 - +52+,2/0"5'#20%$+*5"@-,& =+-#20" +-#$+&5%$+2 +/#+(5#-#+
-#/&%"0%"+$%+8,:5"%+-#$+& 20"%0 +C#2+%0#2&,B2+%+/5+&5%$,-%-C=+(%"%+-%"+
#/0%!,$,-%-=+&#"0#D%+1+& 28,%!,$,-%-+& 2+"#/(#&0 +%+$%/+"#$%&, 2#/+,20#">
/5!*#0,3%/+& 2+#8#&0 +*5"@-,& A
<#20" +-#+#/#+(" &#/ +6,/0B",& >( $@0,& =+/#+'%"&%+& 2+0,20%+,2-#$#!$#+
$%+0"%2/8 "'%&,B2+-#$+<#"#&6 +& 2+#$+/5":,',#20 +-#$+<#"#&6 +(?!$,>
& +1=+#2+(%"0,&5$%"=+-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+95#+%(%"#&#+& ' +52%+
"%'%+%50B2 '%+-#+$%+-,/&,($,2%+*5"@-,&%+(%"%+%0#2-#"=+("#&,/%'#20#=+$%/+

O! ;'&&'+6([0#6'++>!: 6,;%(& 2(4#$%&6>!\0]1'!#0,6/#0%,T+>!QA],:$!;>8>W!8$+($!(0!.4&14#'!":$+T6,:'I!

?MZ?I!/>!?Z?>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 Mi "#$%&, 2#/+*5"@-,&%/+#20"#+#$+&,5-%-%2 +1+$ /+&#20" /+-#+( -#"+-#$+./0%- +
95#=+%+(%"0,"+-#+#20 2&#/+C2 +$ +(#"-%' /+-#+3,/0%C+/ 2+$ /+&#20" /+
-#+( -#"+-#+$%+/ &,#-%-=+&#20" /+95#+#/0L2+%$+/#"3,&, +-#$+&,5-%-%2 A+<#+
%$$@=+$%/+&%"%&0#"@/0,&%/+/,2:5$%"#/+-#+#/#+Q25#3 R+<#"#&6 =+95#=+-#/-#+
$5#: =+%!"#3%+2#&#/%",%'#20#+#2+$%/+85#20#/+-#+52%+&,#2&,%+1%+-#/%"" >
$$%-%+1+'%-5"%+#2+/5/+&%0#: "@%/+#+,2/0,05&, 2#/=+%5295#=+&$%" +#/0L=+!%* +
$%+ B(0,&%+ -#+ 52%/+ "#$%&, 2#/+ ,20#"/5!*#0,3%/+ -,8#"#20#/V+ $%/+ (" (,%/+ -#$+
<#"#&6 +&,3,$=+& '?2+ +(",3%- A+
.2+#$+8 2- =+/#+0"%0%+-#+52%+"#%$,-%-+95#+ !#-#&#=+& ' +/#+6%+-,&6 +
%20#/=+%+&,"&52/0%2&,%/+6,/0B",&%/+95#+2 +(5#-#2+-#*%"/#+-#+$%- +(%"%+
( -#"+#20#2-#"+%-#&5%-%'#20#+#$+8#2B'#2 A+H%$+#/+#$+%! "-%*#+95#+
( 2#+ -#+ '%2,8,#/0 + )#!%/0,L2+ I%"0@2>c#0 "0,$$ =+ & 2+ /,2:5$%"+ '%#/>
0"@%=+ %$+ ,-#20,8,&%"+ #$+ %/520 + & ' + Q52+ 3#"-%-#" + (";/0%' + -#+ ,2/0,>
05&, 2#/+-#$+<#"#&6 +&,3,$+%$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 P+,2/0,05&, 2#/+1+
8,:5"%/+ 95#=+ %$+ "#/5$0%"+ & '52#/=+ 6%2+ #7,:,- + #+ ,'(5#/0 + #2+ (",'#"+
$5:%"+/5+-,8#"#2&,%&,B2=+1+#2+52%+8%/#+5$0#", "=+$%+8,*%&,B2+-#+/5+(" (,%+
/5/0%20,3,-%-RiA
.20 2&#/=+#2+0;"',2 /+:#2#"%$#/=+( -#' /+#20#2-#"+/,2+'%1 "+-,8,&5$>
0%-+95#+#$+-#/%"" $$ +-#+$%+/ &,#-%-+6%+/,- =+#2+!5#2%+'#-,-%=+#$+-#/%>
"" $$ +1+$%+0"%2/8 "'%&,B2+C +95,DL+/#%+'#* "+-#&,"+$%+Q%-%(0%&,B2RW+
& 2/0%20#+ -#$+ ./0%- + 1+ /5/+ ,2/0,05&, 2#/=+ (%"%+ %&05%$,D%"=+ #2+ 8 "'%+
(#"'%2#20#+1+#/0"%0;:,&%=+/5/+&%(%&,-%-#/+ ":%2,D%0,3%/+1+ (#"%0,3%/+
-#+"#/(5#/0%+%+$%/+#7,:#2&,%/+-#+$%/+& '52,-%-#/+1+$ /+,2-,3,-5 /=+$ /+
&5%$#/+!5/&%2+%$&%2D%"+1+'%20#2#"+& 2-,&, 2#/+-#+3,-%+%-#&5%-%/+1+
/%0,/8%&0 ",%/A+./0 +0%'!,;2+/#+#7("#/%+#2+2,3#$#/+& 28 "'%- /+& ' +
(%"L'#0" /+"#8#"#2&,%$#/+95#+"#/5$0%2+,:5%$'#20#+:$ !%$#/+1+(" (#2>
-#2+%+/5+8 "'%$,D%&,B2+& ' +Q-#"#&6 /R=+%+8,2+-#+/,/0#'%0,D%"+ +("#&,>
/%"+-#+'#* "+'%2#"%+$%/+"#$%&, 2#/+-#+$ /+,2-,3,-5 /+& 2+$ /+&#20" /+-#+
( -#"+(?!$,& =+0%$+& ' +/5&#-#+-#+'%2#"%+(" :"#/,3%+1+/ /0#2,-%+& 2+$ /+
Q-#"#&6 /+65'%2 /RA
U5#/+!,#2=+-#/-#+#/0%+B(0,&%+#/+8 "D / +#20#2-#"+95#+#/#+(" &#/ +& 2>
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

0,25 + 1+ / /0#2,- + -#+ 0"%2/8 "'%&,B2+ :#2#"%$+ -#+ $%+ / &,#-%-=+ 95#+ #/0L+
%& '(%O%- +( "+$ /+&%'!, /+1+%-%(0%&, 2#/+-#$+%(%"%0 +#/0%0%$=+%(52>
0%+-,"#&0%+1+-#&,-,-%'#20#+6%&,%+$%+& 28 "'%&,B2+-#$+./0%- +:*&*7"(=+
&51%+("#/#2&,%+(%"%+$%+,20#"3#2&,B2+#2+$ /+%/520 /+-#+,20#";/+& $#&0,3 +/#+
& 2&,!#+-#/-#+$%+B(0,&%+:#"#2&,%$+1+$%+%&&,B2+#/0"%0;:,&%+-#+$%/+( $@0,&%/+
(?!$,&%/=+$%/+&5%$#/+& 2-5&#2+%+52%+/,:2,8,&%0,3%+%'($,%&,B2+-#+/5/+#/>
(%&, /+-#+("#/#2&,%=+%+$%+(%"+95#+%+$%+'5$0,($,&%&,B2+1+-,3#"/,8,&%&,B2+-#+
$ /+'#-, /+,2/0"5'#20%$#/=+& 2+#$+ !*#0,3 +-#+,2/0%$%"+52+(" 0%: 2,/' +
#/0%0%$+-,8#"#20#+95#=+%+/5+3#D=+,'( 2:%+52+25#3 +#/95#'%+-#+"#$%&,B2+

L! 42(7 , -86(-"!"2( *(2%(<=* #"#(& 2(7 , -86(%&'"*"#$,%$"!6>!\0-,&&'W!9+%1,141$!D'#:E'!^-,0($I!)+,-0#%,('(!

(0!\0-,&&'I!?MNPI!/>Z>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 TT

& 2+$ /+&,5-%-%2 /+1+%&#20?#+$%+& '($#*,-%-+/,/0;',&%+-#$+./0%- +& 2>

0#'( "L2# ]A
<,&6 + #2+ 0" /+ 0;"',2 /=+ #$+ ./0%- + 2 + (5#-#+ #/&%(%"+ %+ $%+ -,2L',&%+
M]
& 2/0%20#+95#+,'($,&%+#$+-#/%"" $$ +:#2#"%$+-#+$%+/ &,#-%-+/#2&,$$%'#20#+ SOBRE LA
( "95#+#/+52+& '( 2#20#+,2/0"5'#20%$+-#+$%+',/'%+95#+0,#2#+%/,:2%- =+ COMPLEJIDAD
%-#'L/=+ 52+ " $+ (" 0%:B2,& + #+ ,2/5/0,05,!$#=+ 6%/0%+ - 2-#+ (#"',0#+ %0,/> DEL ESTADO Y LAS
!%"+$%+(" /(#&0,3%A+.2+0%$+/#20,- =+$%+-,2L',&%+%$5-,-%+C52,-%+%$+&"#&,> CONTRATACIONES
',#20 +#2+3%",#-%-=+$%+%'($,05-+:# :"L8,&%+1+-#' :"L8,&%=+%/@+& ' +%+$%+ ADMINISTRATIVAS
3#$ &,-%-+-#+$%/+"#$%&, 2#/C=+(" (,%+-#+$%+#"%+,28 "'L0,&%+1+0#$#'L0,&%+ ABOUT THE
95#+3,3,' /=+& '( "0%+$%+,2& "( "%&,B2+-#+$ /+#$#'#20 /+%3%2D%- /+-#+ COMPLEXITY OF
/ ( "0#+%$+& '($#* +,2%: 0%!$#+-#+3@2&5$ /=+95#+"#95,#"#2+$%+%($,&%&,B2+ THE STATE AND
-#+,2/0"5'#20%$+*5"@-,& +%& "-#=+-#+- 2-#+-#",3%+#$+-,/#O +-#+25#3%/+ ADMINISTRATIVE
8B"'5$%/+ +$%+%-%(0%&,B2+-#+$%/+("#3,%'#20#+#7,/0#20#/=+%+8,2+-#+ 8"#&#"+ CONTRACTS
"#/(5#/0%/+#8,&,#20#/+#2+#$+25#3 +#20 "2 A
K5#: + -#+ #/0#+ !"#3@/,' + "#&5#20 + ,20" -5&0 ", =+ 2 + "#/5$0%"L+ -,8@&,$+
& '("#2-#"+95#+$%+8,:5"%+-#$+& 20"%0 +&#$#!"%- +( "+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+
(?!$,&%+/#+#2&5#20"#+C-%- +95#+/#+6%+#2& 20"%- +1+/#+#2& 20"%"LC+#2+
#$+&#20" +',/' +-#+$%+"#%$,-%-+*5"@-,& >("L&0,&%+-#+$%+%&0,3,-%-+%-',2,/>
0"%0,3%+-#$+./0%- =+( "+$ +95#+/5+0"%0%',#20 +1+'%2#* =+0%20 +- &0",2%", +
& ' +0#B",& +C%/@+& ' +0%'!,;2+#2+$ +"#8#",- +%$+&%'( +-#+$%+"#%$,D%>
&,B2+8 "#2/#+ +-#+$%+("L&0,&%+%($,&%&,B2+-#+-#"#&6 C=+-#!#+& 2/,-#"%"+
$%/+& '($#*,-%-#/+#2+$%/+95#+/#+,2/#"0%+1+%+$%/+95#+-#!#+%-%(0%"/#+(%"%+
&5'($,"+/5+8,2%$,-%-+#/#2&,%$'#20#+,2/0"5'#20%$=+%+$ +95#+-#!#2+& 20",>
!5,"=+& 2+,:5%$+2,3#$+-#+& '(" ',/ =+$%+& 2/0"5&&,B2+0#B",&%+- &0",2%",%=+
$%+$#:,/$%&,B2+1+$%+*5",/("5-#2&,%A
.2+,:5%$+/#20,- +-#+ !/#"3%&,B2=+-#!#' /+%-',0,"+95#+#/%+"#/(5#/0%+/#+
(" -5&#+-#20" +-#+$%/+(#&5$,%",-%-#/+(" (,%/+-#+&%-%+ "-#2%',#20 +- >
';/0,& P+/,2+#'!%": =+%&L+0%'!,;2+*5#:%+52+(%(#$+,'( "0%20#+$%+:$ !%>
$,D%&,B2=+$%+&5%$+0,#2-#+%+,'("#:2%"+$ +95#+5/5%$'#20#+/#+6%+#20#2-,- +
& ' +#/(%&, /+(" (, /+ +#7&$5/,3 /+-#$+Q-#"#&6 +,20#"2 R=+& ' +L'!,0 +
2%05"%$+-#+5!,&%&,B2+-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+(%"%+%-#20"%"/#+C( "+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

#8#&0 +-#+$%+"#%$,-%-+("L&0,&%+,2#7&5/%!$#C+#2+$%+0#2-#2&,%+&%-%+3#D+
'L/+%&#205%-%+1+" !5/0%+-#+$%+& 2/0"5&&,B2+-#+52+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%>
0,3 +:$ !%$A+.2+$%+#/#2&,%+-#+52+-#"#&6 +-#+#/0#+0,( =+/#+'5#3#+& 2+3,: "+
$%+85#"D%+#7(%2/,3%+95#+%( "0%2+$%/+"#$%&, 2#/+#& 2B',&%/+#20"#+/5*#0 /+
-#+-,8#"#20#+8%&05"%=+95#+& 0,-,%2%'#20#+0"%/(%/%2+$%/+8" 20#"%/+-#+$ /+
#/0%- /+1+95#=+2#&#/%",%'#20#=+%0"%#2+6%&,%+/@+%+$ /+"#95#",',#20 /+1+$%/+
& 2/#&5#2&,%/+*5"@-,&%/+(" (,%/+-#$+-#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+#2+%0#2&,B2+
%+$%+- !$#+"#%$,-%-+95#+& 2/0%20#'#20#+"#&$%'%+$%+("#/#2&,%+-#+$%/+%->
',2,/0"%&, 2#/+(?!$,&%/+#2+$ /+-,8#"#20#/+(%@/#/=+#2+0%20 +$#/+& ""#/( 2-#+

_! \$7#0! 0&! 106'I! %0! %4B,0#0! &'! &0:14#'! (0! ($%! $7#'%! (0! Q'+40&! D'#:E'`X0&'5$! C40! $*#0:0+! 4+'!
-,%,T+!,+10B#'&!(0&!*0+T60+$W!>%#($,%*#?6,'%-"6* #(& 2(4#$%&6(-6*$ '96,@* 6!S=&,'+3'!"(,1$#,'&V!5!
42(4#$%&6(& (*5 #$,6($" '96!S.'#':'%W!84+(':,T+!Q'+40&!D'#:E'`X0&'5$I!RPPZV>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 MT %&05%"+0%20 +& ' +#$+/5*#0 +-#+& 20" $+/ !"#+$%/+%&0,3,-%-#/+-#/($#:%-%/+
( "+$ /+(%"0,&5$%"#/=+%/@+& ' +!%* +#$+" $+-#+%:#20#+#& 2B',& +#2+$%/+
852&, 2#/+-#+,20#"3#2&,B2+#2+$%+#& 2 '@%+'#-,%20#+%&05%&, 2#/+-,"#&>
0%/A+U#" +0%'!,;2=+%+0"%3;/+-#$+#/0@'5$ +1+8 '#20 +%+$%+,23#"/,B2+1+$%+
",#20%&,B2+:#2#"%$+-#$+-#/%"" $$ +#& 2B',& +1+/ &,%$+-#+$ /+(5#!$ /=+#/+
52%+852&,B2+%+"#&%$%"+#$+/,#'("#+(" -5&,"+#$+"#& 2 &,',#20 +1+$%+"#/>
(5#/0%+%-#&5%-%+1+ ( "052%+%+$%+,2#$5-,!$#+("#/#2&,%+-#+$%/+:%"%20@%/+
&,5-%-%2%/=+#2+$ +"#8#",- +%+$%+-#!,-%+(" 0#&&,B2+1+"#/(#0 =+$ +95#+& 2>
-5&#+%+$%/+0;&2,&%/+-#+& 20" $+*5"@-,& +/ !"#+$ /+%&0 /+1+& 2-5&0%/+-#+$%+
%-',2,/0"%&,B2=+1+%+$%+& 2/#&5#20#+"#/( 2/%!,$,-%-+-#$+./0%- + +-#+/5/+
852&, 2%", /=+/#:?2+/#%+#$+&%/ A
./+%/@+& ' +#2+$%+%&05%$,-%-+"#/5$0%+2 +/ $ +8%&0,!$#+/,2 +2#&#/%", +%&#(>
0%"+C%$+,:5%$+95#+"#& 2 &#"+1+6%!$%"+-#&,-,-%'#20#+%&#"&%+-#$+%/52>
0 C+ $%+ %(%",&,B2+ -#+ 52+ 3#"-%-#" + Q#/(%&, + %-',2,/0"%0,3 + :$ !%$R=+ #$+
&5%$+& '( "0%+%$:52%/+,'($,&%&, 2#/+( 0#2&,%$'#20#+( $@0,&%/+%+$%+(%"+
-#+ 0"%/+ ,'($,&%&, 2#/+ -#+ 2%05"%$#D%+ 2 "'%0,3%+ 95#+ :,"%2+ #2+ 0 "2 + %+
$%+%(%",&,B2+-#+52%+:# :"%8@%+' $-#%-%+#2+(#"8,$#/+0#25#/+#2+/5/+0"%>
D /+,2,&,%$#/=+(#" +95#=+&%-%+3#D=+%(%"#&#2+& 2+'%1 "+-#8,2,&,B2+#2+/5/+
"%/: /+6%&,%+$%+-#8,2,&,B2+(" :"#/,3%+-#+52%+/5#"0#+-#+: !#"2%2D%+:$ >
!%$+95#+-,85',2%+$%/+$@2#%/+-5"%/+-#+&%0#: "@%/+%20#", "'#20#+%!/ $50%/+
#2+/5+8 "'%0 +C& ' +( -"@%+/#"+$%+/ !#"%2@%C=+1+95#+%(520%+6%&,%+
#/0%-, /+95#+%-',0#2+/,2+-,8,&5$0%-+#/&#2%", /+-#+Q/5("%2%&, 2%$,-%-R+
(#"%0,3%+C-,/0,20%+-#+$%/+&$L/,&%/+"#$%&, 2#/+,20#"2%&, 2%$#/+#20"#+#/>
0%- /+ +/5*#0 /+-#+-#"#&6 +,20#"2%&, 2%$C=+'#-,%20#+#$+#'($%D%',#20 +
-#&,-,- + -#+ "#$%&, 2#/+ *5"@-,&%/+ #20"#+ %-',2,/0"%&, 2#/+ 1+ &,5-%-%2 /=+
%-',2,/0"%- /=+("#/0%- "#/+ +5/5%", /+-#+-,8#"#20#/+52,-%-#/+#/0%0%$#/=+
-#+-,3#"/%/+2%&, 2#/+1+(%@/#/=+95#+%&0?#2+#+,20#"%&0?#2+#2+52+#/&#2%", +
#& 2B',& =+/ &,%$+1+*5"@-,& >(?!$,& +95#+$#/+#/+& '?2A+<#+#/0 +/ 2+8,#$+
"#("#/#20%&,B2=+#2+& 2-,&, 2#/+/5(#", "#/+%+$%+#7(#&0%0,3%+#7(#",'#2>
0%$=+$%/+"#%$,-%-#/+95#+6 1+-@%+%( "0%2+$ /+(" &#/ /+-#+,20#:"%&,B2+C ",>
:,2%$'#20#+#& 2B',&%+1+$5#: +( $@0,&%=+(#" +/,#'("#+& 20%2- +& 2+#$+
/5!/0"%0 +*5"@-,& C+95#+%$&%2D%2+$%+& 2/ $,-%&,B2+-#+" !5/0 /+1+/B$,- /+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

#/&#2%", /+& ' +(5#-#+/#"+$%+j2,B2+.5" (#%+ =+#2+52%+#/&%$%+-#+,20#2>

/,-%-+5+ !*#0,3 /+-,8#"#20#/=+#$+&%/ +-#$+I#"& /5"=+#+,2&$5/ +$%+-,3#"/,-%-+
-#+'#&%2,/' /+'5$0,$%0#"%$#/+-#+'#2 "+(" 1#&&,B2+ ":%2,D%0,3%+ +,2/0,>
05&, 2%$=+(#" +95#=+#2+0 - +&%/ =+($%20#%2+("#3,/, 2#/+-#+,20#""#$%&,B2+
95#+& '(" '#0#2+$%+("#/#2&,%+-#+$%/+%-',2,/0"%&, 2#/+(?!$,&%/A
<#+#/0#+' - =+#/+$B:,&%'#20#+8%&0,!$#+C1+'#0 - $B:,&%'#20#+%&#"0%>
- C+#$+%! "-%*#+-#+$%/+!%/#/+',/'%/+-#+& 28,:5"%&,B2+-#+#/%/+25#3%/+
'%2,8#/0%&, 2#/+95#=+:#2#"%-%/+#2+$%+85#"D%+,'(5$/ "%+-#+$ /+&%'!, /+
(" 3#2,#20#/+ -#$+ -#/%"" $$ + :#2#"%$+ -#+ $%+ / &,#-%-+ #2+ /5/+ #7("#/, 2#/+
0#&2 $B:,&%/+1+#& 2B',&%/=+& 2-5&#2+-,"#&0%'#20#+%+$%/+%-%(0%&, 2#/+
1+0"%2/8 "'%&, 2#/+-#+$ /+&#20" /+-#+( -#"+1+:#/0,B2+(?!$,&%+#2+8%3 "+
-#+$ /+25#3 /+"#95#",',#20 /+,'(5#/0 /+%+$%+: !#"2%!,$,-%-+#2+:#2#"%$=+
Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420
 TT

$%+&5%$+0,#2#=+& ' +%2-%',%*#+ ":%2,D%0,3 +1=+%$+',/' +0,#'( =+& ' +

/ ( "0#+ (#"%0,3 +1+'#&%2,/' +852&, 2%$=+%+$%/+%-',2,/0"%&, 2#/+(?!$,>
&%/+95#+ (#"%2+#2+$ /+-,/0,20 /+(%@/#/+C& 2+/5/+(%"0,&5$%",-%-#/+#/(#>
&@8,&%/C=+ (#" =+ #2+ 0 - + &%/ =+ !%* + $%+ ;:,-%+ -#+ 52 /+ (",2&,(, /+ 1+ 52%/+
Mk
0;&2,&%/+52,8 "'#/+#2+/5+ ",:#2+1+& 2+"#8#"#20#/+6,/0B",& /+& '52#/+#2+ SOBRE LA
COMPLEJIDAD
/5+:;2#/,/A
DEL ESTADO Y LAS
.2+$%/+8 "'5$%&, 2#/+& 2&#(05%$#/+(",'%",%/+-#+#/0%/+25#3%/+%(" 7,'%> CONTRATACIONES
&, 2#/+&,#20@8,&%/+/ !"#+#$+8#2B'#2 =+#2& 20"%' /+($%20#%',#20 /+-#+ ADMINISTRATIVAS
#/0#+( "0#V ABOUT THE
COMPLEXITY OF
K%+ & 2&#(05%$,D%&,B2+ -#$+ -#"#&6 + %-',2,/0"%0,3 + :$ !%$+ ("#/5( 2#+
THE STATE AND
$%+ #7,/0#2&,%+ -#+ 52%+ %-',2,/0"%&,B2+ :$ !%$+ + 0"%2/2%&, 2%$A+ X / 0" /+
ADMINISTRATIVE
/ /0#2#' /+ 95#+ #7,/0#+ /58,&,#20#+ &%20,-%-+ -#+ %-',2,/0"%&,B2+ :$ !%$+ 1+ CONTRACTS
0"%2/2%&, 2%$+& ' +(%"%+( -#"+,-#20,8,&%"+6 1+#2+-@%+52+Q#/(%&, +%->
',2,/0"%0,3 +:$ !%$R+'5$0,8%&;0,& =+( !$%- +-#+3%", /+-,3#"/ /+0,( /+-#+
,2/0,05&, 2#/+"#:5$%0 ",%/+%-',2,/0"%0,3%/+1+-#+3%", /+0,( /+-#+#20,-%-#/+
95#+/ 2+$ /+/5*#0 /+-#+$%+"#:5$%&,B2=+,2&$51#2- +2 +/ $ +./0%- /=+/,2 +
0%'!,;2+,2-,3,-5 /=+#'("#/%/=+1+dXJ/+`/,&bA+`ab+.20#2-#"+%+$%+: !#">
2%2D%+:$ !%$+& ' +52%+8 "'%+-#+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+2 /+(#"',0#+"#8 "'5$%"+
'5&6%/+-#+$%/+("# &5(%&, 2#/+& '52#/+/ !"#+$%+$#:,0,',-%-+-#+$%/+,2/>
0,05&, 2#/+,20#"2%&, 2%$#/+-#+52+' - +'L/+#/(#&@8,& +1+8 &%$,D%- A+X /+
(" ( "&, 2%+52%+-,/0%2&,%+&"@0,&%+?0,$+/ !"#+$%/+#70#2-,-%/+-#'%2-%/+-#+
-;8,&,0+-#' &"L0,& /+-#+#/0%/+,2/0,05&, 2#/=+%+'#25- +/ !"#-,'#2/, >
2%-%/A+H%'!,;2+-#/3@%+$%+%0#2&,B2+-#+$ /+%&%-;',& /+-#+$%+: !#"2%2D%+
:$ !%$+%+3%", /+'#&%2,/' /+-#+*11,-&'*<%!%'?+#2+$%+0 '%+-#+-#&,/, 2#/+
%-',2,/0"%0,3%/=+,2&$51#2- +#2+#$+-#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+95#+#+$ /+/,/>
0#'%/+- ';/0,& /+ (#"%2+%$+$%- =+%5295#+2 +#2+8 "'%+,2-#(#2-,#20#=+
-#+$ /+(" &#/ /+-#' &"L0,& /+&$L/,& /+& ' +$%/+#$#&&, 2#/+1+#$+& 20" $+
(%"$%'#20%", +1+("#/,-#2&,%$A+./0%+,23#/0,:%&,B2+"#/%$0%+-#+52+' - +?0,$=+
6%/0%+95;+(520 +$ /+'#&%2,/' /+(" &#-,'#20%$#/+-#+(%"0,&,(%&,B2+1+-#+
"#3,/,B2=+95#+/#+-%2+( "+/5(5#/0 /+#2+$%+%&&,B2+%-',2,/0"%0,3%+- ';/0,>
&%=+8%$0%2+%+2,3#$+:$ !%$A+4$+',/' +0,#'( =+$%+,23#/0,:%&,B2+,23,0%+%$+-#>
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

/%"" $$ +-#+(" &#-,',#20 /+,2/0,05&, 2%$#/=+(",2&,(, /+1+"#&5"/ /=+%5295#+

2 +& 2+#$+ !*#0,3 +-#+& 2/0"5,"+52%+-#' &"%&,%+:$ !%$+& '($#0%'#20#+
6#&6%+1+-#"#&6%+\95#+#/+6 1+#2+-@%+,$5/ ", _TA

I I . EL CONTRATO ADMINISTRATIVO COMO INSTRUMENTO

NECESARIO
.$+ #/&#2%", + C&"#&,#20#'#20#=+ & '($#* + 1+ :$ !%$,D%- C+ %$+ &5%$+ 2 /+
6#' /+"#8#",- +#2+$%/+$@2#%/+%20#", "#/+,2& "( "%+#2+/5+& 20#70 +0 - +#$+

N! F-#!70+BI!a0+0(,:1I!J,:$!F+-25;!5!b,:<'#(!a>!2/0)+/>!F"&!%4#B,6,0+1$!(0&!;0#0:<$!'(6,+,%1#'1,-$!
B&$7'&H>!"+!42(*5 !6(7 , -86(%&'"*"#$,%$"!6(<261%2( *()'=,"-%(>%$"*%>!a40+$%!=,#0%W!"(,1$#,'&!b0%!
X47&,:'!=#B0+1,+'!SbX=VI!RPPMI!//>!R_!5!OZ>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 Ml %"/#2%$+-#+'#&%2,/' /+-#+%&05%&,B2+95#+& ""#/( 2-#+#'($#%"+%$+./0%>
- =+%+0"%3;/+-#+$%+852&,B2+%-',2,/0"%0,3%A+./+#2+#/#+%"/#2%$+,2/0"5'#20%$+
(%"%+$%+:#/0,B2+%-',2,/0"%0,3%+(?!$,&%+- 2-#+/#+5!,&%+$%+' -%$,-%-+(" >
(,%+-#$+2#: &, +*5"@-,& +95#+& ""#/( 2-#+%+$ /+& 20"%0 /+%-',2,/0"%0,>
3 /=+( "+$ +95#+"#/5$0%=+ !3,%'#20#=+52%+&%0#: "@%+2#0%'#20#+*5"@-,&%=+
(#"0#2#&,#20#+%$+- ',2, +-#$+<#"#&6 A+),2+#'!%": =+2 +6%1+95#+ $3,-%"+
95#+0%$#/+&%0#: "@%/+*5"@-,&%/+2 +& 2/0,051#2+8,2#/+#2+/@+',/'%/P+( "+#$+
& 20"%", =+/5+#7,/0#2&,%+ !#-#&#+%+"%D 2#/+1+"#95#",',#20 /+-#+ "-#2+
("L&0,& =+-#+2%05"%$#D%+852&, 2%$=+%+&51 +&%!%$+&5'($,',#20 +1+"#%$,D%>
&,B2+#8,&%D=+("#/0%2+&%5&#/+8 "'%$#/+-#+&#"0#D%+1+& 28,%!,$,-%-A
<#/-#+#/0#+L2:5$ +-#$+%2L$,/,/=+%(%"#&#+#2+(",'#"%+$@2#%+#$+0"%0%',#20 +
*5"@-,& >( /,0,3 + -#$+ %/520 A+ .3,-#20#'#20#=+ &%-%+ "-#2%',#20 + *5"@>
-,& +( /,0,3 +#/0%!$#&#+#$+";:,'#2+-#+%&05%&,B2+95#+3,2&5$%+%$+%(%"%>
0 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +-#$+./0%- +1=+*520 +%+#$$ =+$%/+"#:5$%&, 2#/+"#$%0,3%/+%+
$%/+&%0#: "@%/+-,/(5#/0%/+(%"%+/5+#'($# +-#/-#+#/%+8 "'%+-#+%&05%&,B2A+
<#20" +-#+#/0%/+&%0#: "@%/=+%(%"#&#+#$+& 20"%0 =+& 2+$ +&5%$+$ /+%/(#&0 /+
& 2&"#0 /+-#$+%/520 +0#2-"L2+/,#'("#+52+"#8#"#20#+( /,0,3 +& 2+$%/+(%">
0,&5$%",-%-#/+95#+/ 2+(" (,%/+-#+#/#+ "-#2%',#20 +& 2&"#0 +95#=+-#/-#+
$5#: =+2 + !*#0%+2,+,'(,-#+52%+%(" 7,'%&,B2+:$ !%$+95#+/#+-#/%"" $$#+
'#-,%20#+#$+#'($# +-#+&%0#: "@%/+& 2&#(05%$#/+ +0#B",&%/+-#+%(" 7,'%>
&,B2=+& ' +$%+95#+%6 "%+("#0#2-#' /+#2/%1%"A
.2+#/0#+ "-#2+-#+,-#%/=+#/+ ( "052 +"#& "-%"+%$+'#2 /+%$:52%/+"#8#"#2>
&,%/+%&#"&%+-#$+ ",:#2+1+$%+0"%1#&0 ",%+!L/,&%+,2,&,%$+ (#"%-%+(%"%+$%+8 ">
'%&,B2+-#+$%/+&%0#: "@%/+*5"@-,&%/=+/ !"#+0 - +#2+#$+#/(#&0" +-#$+<#"#&6 +
%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+#2+0%20 +-,/&,($,2%+-#+"#&,#20#+%(%",&,B2+#2+& '(%"%>
&,B2+& 2+ 0"%/+"%'%/+-#$+<#"#&6 =+(",2&,(%$'#20#+& 2+#$+<#"#&6 +&,3,$+
C0%$+& ' +/#+6%+'#2&, 2%- +%20#/C=+1+& 2+'5&6 +'%1 "+"%DB2+#2+
0%20 +95#+$%+&%0#: "@%+*5"@-,&%+!%* +%2L$,/,/+#/+-#+0%2+/,:2,8,&%0,3%+#20,>
-%-=+& ' +/5&#-#+& 2+$%+8,:5"%+-#$+& 20"%0 A
E,#"0%'#20#=+#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+( "+,28$5* +-#+/5+(" (,%+#/#2&,%+
/5/0%20,3%=+2%&#+1+/#+-#/%"" $$%+-#+52%+'%2#"%+/,2+-5-%+#/(#&,%$'#20#+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

/,2:5$%"=+(5#/+#2+-#8,2,0,3%+/,:2,8,&%+$%+$,',0%&,B2+%$+#*#"&,&, +-#+( -#"+

#2+!#2#8,&, +-#+$%+$,!#"0%-=+(5#/0 +95#+5!,&%+/5/+"%@&#/+#2+0#'%/+852-%>
'#20%$#/+& ' +$ +/ 2+$%/+"#$%&, 2#/+#20"#+#$+#/0%- +1+$ /+&,5-%-%2 /=+
#$+#28"#20%',#20 +#20"#+%50 ",-%-+1+$,!#"0%-=+%/@+& ' +#$+3@2&5$ +#20"#+
/ &,#-%-+#+,2-,3,-5 A+H - +#/0 =+-#/-#+$5#: =+%0"%#+$%/+"#/,/0#2&,%/+2%05>
"%$#/+-#+$ /+',/' /+&#20" /+-#+#*#"&,&, +-#$+( -#"+95#+/#+,20#20%+$,',0%"A
<#/-#+ #$+ (520 + -#+ 3,/0%+ :# :"L8,& =+ 2 + 6%1+ -5-%+ -#+ 95#+ #$+ <#"#&6 +
%-',2,/0"%0,3 +0,#2#+/5+ ",:#2+#2+g"%2&,%A+.2+%($,&%&,B2+-#+$%/+& 2/,>
-#"%&, 2#/+%20#/+#7(5#/0%/=+#/0 +2 /+& 2-5&#+%+,2& "( "%"+#$+#20 "2 +
( $@0,& +1+$%/+&,"&52/0%2&,%/+("L&0,&%/+95#+& 28,:5"%2+#/#+#3#20 =+%+8,2+-#+
-,/8"50%"+-#+52%+%("#&,%&,B2+'L/+ +'#2 /+,20#:"%$+-#$+8#2B'#2 =+(5#/+
2 +/#+0"%0%+-#+52+(" -5&0 +(" 3#2,#20#+-#+52%+#$%! "%&,B2+&#""%-%=+-#+
Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420
 TT

52%+3 $520%-+& 2&$5/,3%+1+52,8 "'#=+/,2 +-#+52+(" &#/ +/ &,%$=+& /%+95#+

$#+,'( 2#+52%/+-#0#"',2%-%/+/ $5&, 2#/+("L&0,&%/=+$%/+&5%$#/+& 28,:5"%2=+
%+/5+3#D=+52+-,/#O +(%"0,&5$%"+C'%/+2 +2#&#/%",%'#20#+?2,& C=+-#$+
&5%$=+%+8,2+-#+&5#20%/=+-#",3%+$%+( /,!,$,-%-+&,#"0%+-#+95#+%(%"#D&%2+3%>
MM
",%&, 2#/+-#+"#/(5#/0%/+#2+-,3#"/ /+ "-#2%',#20 /+95#=+%0#2-,#2- +%+/5/+ SOBRE LA
(" (,%/+"#%$,-%-#/=+2 +/#+%(%"0%2+-#+$%+& 2&#(&,B2+'#-5$%"+-#$+<#"#&6 + COMPLEJIDAD
DEL ESTADO Y LAS
%-',2,/0"%0,3 A
CONTRATACIONES
<#+#/#+' - + &5""#+& 2+#$+&%/ +-#$+E 2/#* +-#+./0%- +8"%2&;/=+95#+ ADMINISTRATIVAS
%(%"#&#+& ' +$%+/ $5&,B2+ ":%2,D%0,3%+1+852&, 2%$+("L&0,&%+(%"%+#$+& 2> ABOUT THE
0" $+-#$+J !,#"2 +( "+'#-, +-#+52%+3@%+-,/0,20%+%+$%/+#/0%!$#&,-%/+#2+ COMPLEXITY OF
#$+ "-#2%',#20 +*5"@-,& +8"%2&;/+-#$+' '#20 +(%"%+%($,&%&,B2+-#$+<#> THE STATE AND
"#&6 +&,3,$+1+-#$+<#"#&6 +& '?2=+$ +95#+& 20",!51#+C-#&,/,3%'#20#=+ ADMINISTRATIVE
-#/-#+#/0%+(#"/(#&0,3%C+%+$%+,-#20,8,&%&,B2+1+%50 2 '@%+-#$+<#"#&6 + CONTRACTS
%-',2,/0"%0,3 A
4/@+$ +( 2#+-#+'%2,8,#/0 +U" /(#"+m#,$+&5%2- +"#$%0%+#$+/5":,',#20 +1+$%+
#3 $5&,B2+-#+$%/+(",'#"%/+#0%(%/+-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +#2+$ +95#+
&%$,8,&%+& ' +/5+Q("#6,/0 ",%RV+
`ab+X +/,#2- +52+3#"-%-#" +B":%2 +*5-,&,%$+1+$,',0L2- /#+%+("#(%"%"+
$%/+-#&,/, 2#/+-#$+h#8#+-#+./0%- =+#$+E 2/#* +-#+./0%- +(#"'%2#&@%+%$+
'%":#2+-#+$%/+-,/( /,&, 2#/+-#$+EB-,: +E,3,$A+<#+%6@+95#+85#/#+"L(,-%>
'#20#+#/0%!$#&,-%+$%+2 +%($,&%&,B2+-#+$%/+2 "'%/+-#$+EB-,: +"#8#"#20#+%+
%""#2-%',#20 +-#+/#"3,&, =+& 20"%0 /+1+"#/( 2/%!,$,-%-+#2+$ /+$,0,:, /+#2+
95#+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+%&05%/#+& ' +(%"0#A+)5/0"%@-%+%+$ /+0",!52%$#/=+$%+
%-',2,/0"%&,B2+/#+3#@%+0%'!,;2+85#"%+-#$+& 20" $+-#$+-#"#&6 +&,3,$A+n+#/+
%/@+& ' +#$+E 2/#* +-#+./0%- +8 "*B=+%&05%2- +%20#+&%-%+&%/ +& 2&"#0 =+
$%/+"#:$%/+%($,&%!$#/+%+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2=+1+& ' +/#+8,"'B+$%+#7,/0#2&,%+-#+
52+-#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +%50B2 ' P+#/+-#&,"+-#+52+-#"#&6 +95#=+&,#">
0%'#20#=+( -"@%+0#2#"+%$:52%+/#'#*%2D%+#2+-#0#"',2%- /+(520 /+& 2>
&"#0 /+& 2+#$+-#"#&6 +&,3,$=+(#" +95#+2 +-#",3%!%+/5+%50 ",-%-+-#$+EB-,>
: +E,3,$A+.$+E 2/#* +-#+./0%- +6%+/#:"#:%- +#$+-#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

& ' +52%+:$L2-5$%+/#:"#:%+/5+6 "' 2%V+$%+*5",/-,&&,B2+6%+("#&#-,- +%$+

-#"#&6 +1=+/,2+%95#$$%=+;/0#+2 +65!,#/#+2%&,- +`abRkA

E 2+#$$ =+/#+-#/0%&%+$%+85#"0#+&%":%+-#+("%:'%0,/' +95#+%& '(%O%+%$+

(" &#/ + -#+ & 2/0"5&&,B2+ -#$+ <#"#&6 + %-',2,/0"%0,3 + #2+ :#2#"%$+ 1+ -#+
'5&6%/+-#+$%/+,2/0,05&, 2#/=+,2/0"5'#20 /+ +0;&2,&%/+95#+%$ *%=+$ +95#=+
%+/5+3#D=+"#%8,"'%+#$+&%"L&0#"+,2/0"5'#20%$+95#+/5!1%&#+#2+/5+#7,/0#2&,%P+
-#$+',/' +' - +95#+/5&#-#=+& 2+'%1 "+ +'#2 "+,20#2/,-%-=+& 2+("L&>
0,&%'#20#+0 -%/+$%/+"%'%/+-#$+<#"#&6 A
./+ -#+ !/#"3%"+ 95#+ $%+ "#8#"#2&,%+ -#+ m#,$+ / !"#+ $%+ ("#&#-#2&,%+ -#+ $%+
*5",/-,&&,B2+ %$+ Q-#"#&6 R+ $ + #/+ #2+ $ + "#8#",- + %+ $%+ -,/&,($,2%+ #/(#&@8,&%+

Z! 3'-&6(X#$%/0#>!42(7 , -86(%&'"*"#$,%$"!6>!Q'(#,(W!@'4#4%I!?MNZI!/>!RO>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 SNN -#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +C-#+$%+-,/&,($,2%+*5"@-,&%+95#+& 20",!51#+
-#&,/,3%'#20#+%+& 2/0"5,"+#2+$%+"#%$,-%-+("L&0,&%C+1=+& 2+#$$ =+-#/-#+
$5#: =+0%'!,;2+$%+*5",/("5-#2&,%+-#$+E 2/#* +-#+./0%- +%20#&#-#+%+$ /+
,2/0"5'#20 /+ $#:%$#/+ 95#+ Q8 "'%$,D%2+ 2 "'%0,3%'#20#R=+ -#+ '%2#"%+
(" :"#/,3%=+ $%/+ ,2/0,05&, 2#/+ 1+ &%0#: "@%/+ 95#+ (%/%2+ %+ /#"$#=+ #20 2&#/=+
/,/0#'L0,&%'#20#+ (" (,%/+ -#/-#+ #$+ #28 95#+ -#$+ "-#2%',#20 + *5"@-,& +
( /,0,3 =+( "+,2/#"0%"/#+#2+/5+#/0"5&05"%+/,/0;',&%A+X +%/@=+-#/-#+$5#: =+
%$+<#"#&6 +& ' +#/0"5&05"%+"#:5$%0 ",%+:#2#"%$=+2,+'5&6 +'#2 /+& ' +
&,#2&,%=+& ' +-,/&,($,2%+-#$+& 2 &,',#20 A+X +-#!#' /+(#"-#"+-#+3,/0%+
95#+$%+ !"%+&"#%0,3%+-#$+E 2/#* +-#+./0%- +C& ' +$%+-#+&5%$95,#"+ 0" +
&5#"( +5+B":%2 +852&, 2%",%$+- 0%- +-#+8%&5$0%-#/+-#&,/ ",%/+ +& 2/5$>
0,3%/C+-#/&%2/%=+#2+-#8,2,0,3%=+#2+$%+85#"D%+-#+&"#%&,B2+&,#20@8,&%=+#2+#$+
& 2 &,',#20 +1+#2+$%+& 2/0"5&&,B2+- &0",2%",%+95#=+-#/-#+#$+(520 +-#+
3,/0%+%&%-;',& =+( 2#2+#2+("L&0,&%+/5/+0,05$%"#/A
X + !/0%20#=+$ +95#+%6 "%+,20#"#/%+-#/0%&%"+#2+"#$%&,B2+& 2+#/0#+(52>
0 +#/+#/#+0"L2/,0 =+95#+%&#20?%+/5/+%/(#&0 /+-#+ "-#2+("L&0,& =+6%&,%+$%+
& 28 "'%&,B2+-#+$%/+,2/0,05&, 2#/=+,2/0"5'#20 /=+0;&2,&%/+1+&%0#: "@%/+
95#+/#+,2/0%$%2+#2+#$+& 20#70 +/5/0%20,3 +-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +1+
95#+& 20",!51#2+-#&,/,3%'#20#+#2+/5+& 28,:5"%&,B2+1+%-%(0%&,B2+& 2/>
0%20#+C-#20" +-#+$ /+&5%$#/+/#+#2&5#20"%=+#2+$5:%"+-#/0%&%- =+$%+8,:5"%+
-#$+& 20"%0 C=+0%$+& ' +/5&#-#+#2+"#$%&,B2+& 2+$ /+:"%2-#/+"#0 /+95#+
($%20#%2+%+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%+%& 20#&,',#20 /+-#+"#$#3%2&,%+,2 >
&5$0%!$#=+ & ' + 6%2+ /,- + $%/+ J5#""%/+ I52-,%$#/+ -#$+ /,:$ + (%/%- + 1+ $%/+
& 28" 20%&, 2#/+!;$,&%/+'L/+&#"&%2%/+#2+#$+0,#'( +1+#$+,'(%&0 +95#+6%2+
:#2#"%- +/ !"#+$%+#& 2 '@%=+$%+( $@0,&%+1+#$+<#"#&6 +#2+:#2#"%$A+4-#>
'L/=+1+%5295#+2 +( /#%2+#$+',/' +&%"L&0#"+-#3%/0%- "+95#+$ /+%& 20#>
&,',#20 /+%20#/+'#2&, 2%- /=+$ /+%3%2&#/+0#&2 $B:,& /+1+/5/+,28$5#2&,%/+
/ !"#+$ /+2#: &, /+1+$%+: !#"2%!,$,-%-+& 2/0,051#2+0%'!,;2+,'(%&0 /+-#+
& 2/,-#"%&,B2+#2+& 2-,&, 2#/+-#+(%DA
<#+%6@=+-#+$%+2#&#/,-%-+5+ ( "052,-%-+,'(5#/0%+ +(#"',0,-%+C/#:?2+/#+
0"%0#+#2+&%-%+&%/ C+( "+$%/+&,"&52/0%2&,%/+("L&0,&%/+-#+0 - + "-#2=+#/+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

-#+- 2-#+/#+-#/("#2-#+$%+,2& "( "%&,B2+-#+$%+0;&2,&%+& 20"%&05%$+#2+$%+

%-',2,/0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%+& ' +52%+&5#/0,B2+Q0#B",&%'#20#+%-',0,-%+( "+
$%+- &0",2%=+%& :,-%+/,2+"#/#"3%/+( "+$%+*5",/("5-#2&,%=+& "" ! "%-%+( "+
$%+("L&0,&%+%-',2,/0"%0,3%+1=+#2+25#/0" + "-#2%',#20 +*5"@-,& >( /,0,3 =+
& 2/%:"%-%+( "+$%+E 2/0,05&,B2+1+( "+$%/+$#1#/Rl=+& 2+$ +&5%$+/#+"#/%$0%=+
( "+52+$%- =+#$+&%"L&0#"+,2/0"5'#20%$+-#+$%+0;&2,&%+& 20"%&05%$=+1=+( "+#$+
0" =+& 2/#&5#2&,%$'#20#=+$%/+(%"0,&5$%",-%-#/+95#+#2+/5+&%0#: ",D%&,B2=+
0"%0%',#20 + 2 "'%0,3 + 1+ "#/(5#/0%+ *5",/("5-#2&,%$+ %(%"#D&%2+ #2+ &%-%+
"#%$,-%-+2%&, 2%$A+4+#/0 +6%1+95#+%O%-,"=+(%"%+& '($#0%"+%-#&5%-%'#20#+
#$+(%2 "%'%=+#$+-%0 +&,#"0 +/ !"#+$%/+,28$5#2&,%/+95#+$%+0#2-#2&,%+2%05"%$+

c! <)+>)2( ,)/)6! G4E%! "+#,C40>! >%( $ 6,;%( & 2( -6*$,%$6( %&'"*"#$,%$"!6( *( 2%( &6-$,"*%A( 2 <"#2%-".*( B(
C5,"#9,5& *-"%(! * D62%*%#>!.'#':'%W!D$70#+':,T+!(0&!;,%1#,1$!80(0#'&I!?MNcI!/>!?_>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 TT

%$+ ,20#"&%'!, + -#+ #7(#",#2&,%/+ (" 3 &%+ 1+ %&#20?%+ & ' +#/&#2%", + -#+
/,:2 +&5$05"%$V+$%+:$ !%$,D%&,B2=+#$+& 20%&0 +,2'#-,%0 +#20"#+"#%$,-%-#/+
-,3#"/%/=+ 52+ 8#2B'#2 + 95#+ %(%"#&#+ & ' + '%"&%+ #2+ $%+ "#%$,-%-+
& 20#'( "L2#%+1=+#2+(%"0,&5$%"=+#2+$ /+(" &#/ /+-#+,20#:"%&,B2+%+$ /+95#+
SNS
1%+6#' /+6#&6 +'#2&,B2A+H%$+& ' +%8,"'B+#$+(" 8#/ "+h ":#+)%$ ' 2,+%$+ SOBRE LA
#/05-,%"=+("#&,/%'#20#=+%$+%/520 +-#+$ /+& 20"%0 /+%-',2,/0"%0,3 /+#2+#$+ COMPLEJIDAD
DEL ESTADO Y LAS
& 20#70 +-#+$ /+(" &#/ /+-#+,20#:"%&,B2V+
CONTRATACIONES
`ab+0 - +(" &#/ +-#+,20#:"%&,B2+"#:, 2%$+& 2/0,051#=+852-%'#20%$'#2> ADMINISTRATIVAS
0#=+52+(" &#/ +&5$05"%$A+`ab+$%+,20#:"%&,B2+/ $ +( -"L+"#%$,D%"/#+&5%2- + ABOUT THE
/#+3%1%+& 28 "'%2- +52+/,/0#'%+-#+3%$ "#/+& '52#/+#20"#+$ /+%&0 "#/+ COMPLEXITY OF
-#$+(" &#/ =+95#+,2&$51#+52%+3,/,B2+-#$+'52- +#2+#$+95#+/#+3,3#+1+6%&,%+ THE STATE AND
#$+&5%$+/#+("#0#2-#+,"=+1+95#+#$+(" (, +(" &#/ +/#%+,20#"2%$,D%- +& ' + ADMINISTRATIVE
!5#2 +( "+#/ /+',/' /+&,5-%-%2 /+-#+$ /+(%@/#/+',#'!" /+-#+$%+52,B2MA CONTRACTS

.2+#/0#+(520 +#2& 20"%' /+$%+& 23#":#2&,%+-#+-,3#"/ /+#$#'#20 /+95#+

%'#",0%2+/#"+& 2/,-#"%- /+#2+& 20#70 A
U "+52%+(%"0#=+%(%"#&#+$%+& 2/0"5&&,B2+-#+$%+&%0#: "@%+-#$+Q& 20"%0 +%->
',2,/0"%0,3 R+-#20" +-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+&%0#: "@%+95#+/ $ +/#+
(5#-#+#20#2-#"+&%!%$'#20#+%(#$%2- +%+$%+"#3,/,B2+6,/0B",&%=+$%+&5%$=+%+
/5+3#D=+2 /+,2-,&%+52+ ",:#2+&%":%- +-#+"%D 2#/+("L&0,&%/=+-#+"#/(5#/0%/+
("L&0,&%'#20#+ & 15205"%$#/+ 95#+ & ,2&,-#2+ #2+ $%+ 8B"'5$%+ & 20"%&05%$+
& ' +'#&%2,/' +%-#&5%- +%20#+&,"&52/0%2&,%/+95#+( -"@%2+& 2/,-#"%">
/#+-,%'#0"%$'#20#+ (5#/0%/+#2+%0#2&,B2+%+&%-%+#7(#",#2&,%+2%&, 2%$A+.$+
(" 8#/ "+I#,$L2+J,$+( 2#+-#+'%2,8,#/0 +#2+8 "'%+& 2052-#20#+1+("#&,/%+
0%$+"#8#"#20#+&5%2- +%2%$,D%+#$+& 20"%/0#+-#+$%+("#( 2-#"%2&,%+#20"#+#$+
#'($# +("#3%$#20#+-#$+%&0 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 + +-#+$%+50,$,D%&,B2+-#$+& 2>
0"%0 +#2+852&,B2+-#+$%/+&,"&52/0%2&,%+#2+95#+/#+#2&5#20"#+#$+: !,#"2 A+
<#/-#+#$+(520 +-#+3,/0%+-#+/5+/ ( "0#+#& 2B',& +1+#$+(520 +-#+#95,$,!", +
-#+( -#"+#20"#+#$+./0%- +1+$%+/ &,#-%-=+I#,$L2+& 20"%/0%+$%+-,8#"#2&,%+
#20"#+$%+ (&,B2+-#+4$#'%2,%=+95#+ (0%+( "+8 "0%$#&#"+#$+#'($# +-#+$%+
-#&,/,B2+52,$%0#"%$+C#$+%&0 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 C+1+$%+#3 $5&,B2+!",0L2,&%=+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

2 "0#%'#",&%2%=+8"%2&#/%+1+#/(%O $%V+
.2+J"%2+o"#0%O%+#$+0",528 +-#$+(%"$%'#20%",/' +#/+0#'("%2 A+K%+#7>
(#",#2&,%+ -#+ E" 'G#$$+ 3%&52B+ -#+ $%+ 0#20%&,B2+ -#+ 52%+ #7&#/,3%+ & 2>
&#20"%&,B2+-#+( -#"+#*#&50,3 A+.$+- :'%+-#+$%+-#' &"%&,%=+$%+(",'%&@%+
-#$+ (5#!$ =+ #/0L2+ #2+ #$+ 2%&,',#20 + ',/' + -#$+ ./0%- + %'#",&%2 A+ .2+
g"%2&,%=+ %5295#+ 'L/+ 0%"-@%'#20#=+ /#+ $$#:%+ #2+ Skl]+ %+ $%+ ,2/0%5"%&,B2+
-#+52%+"#(?!$,&%+(%"$%'#20%",%V+.$+./0%- +/#"L+$%+!5":5#/@%+0",528%20#A+
4$#'%2,%+,"L+( "+-#"" 0#" /+-,/0,20 /A+K%+/5("#'%&@%+-#$+#/0%- +/ !"#+$%+
/ &,#-%-+0#2-"L+52+852-%'#20 +,-# $B:,& +Cf#:#$C+1+52+,2/0"5'#2>
0 +( $@0,& +Co,/'%"pC+6!$6+'*/,$"+$!*$("*!%N*1%E&$/"$!*$%/"*$:,(*!$,$G'%1*O+

M! 2)&","#-I! d$#B0! G4,%>! F.$+1#'1$%! '(6,+,%1#'1,-$%H>! "+! b$70#1$! Q>! GT/03! .'7'+'! S:$$#(,+'($#V>!
E6*$,%$6#( #9 -"%2 #( *( 2(#"<26(FFG>!a40+$%!=,#0%W!=70&($`X0##$1I!?MMMI!/>!LPR>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 SNW / /0#2-"L+#$+(",'#" A+K%+3,"05%$,-%-+-#$+)(%&1%)%,$:,&I(A-%1,+/#"L+-#/(#>
*%-%+( "+#$+E%2&,$$#"+1+"#/(%$-%-%+( "+/5/+;7,0 /+,20#"2%&, 2%$#/A+K%+/ >
&,#-%-+%$#'%2%+&%(,05$%+%20#+#$+./0%- A+K%+8 "0%$#&,-%+4-',2,/0"%&,B2+
-#$+ 2%&,#20#+ ,'(#", + %$#'L2=+ 2,+ ,-# $B:,&%+ 2,+ #& 2B',&%'#20#=+ #/0L+
%&5&,%-%+( "+$%+2#&#/,-%-+-#+(%&0%"+& 2+$%+/ &,#-%-+(%"%+#$+-#/%"" $$ +
-#+/5/+%&0,3,-%-#/A+h5/0%'#20#+$%+& 20"%",%+#/+$%+/,05%&,B2+-#+./(%O%+%+$ +
$%": +-#+0 - +#$+/,:$ +Y[YA+j2+./0%- +-;!,$=+( $@0,&%+1+#& 2B',&%'#20#+
%20#+:"5( /+(#95#O /=+(#" +%&0,3 /=+-#+!5":5#/@%+2%&, 2%$+ +%20#+$ /+
,23%/ "#/+#70"%2*#" /P+52%+4-',2,/0"%&,B2+#2-#5-%-%=+%-#'L/=+( "+$%/+
:5#""%/+&%"$,/0%/A+.2+#/0%/+&,"&52/0%2&,%/=+#$+& 20"%0 +3,#2#+%+/#"+#$+(520 +
-#+52,B2+#20"#+./0%- +1+/ &,#-%-=+%95@=+%$+'#2 /=+252&%+0%*%20#'#20#+
/#(%"%- /A+.$+& 20"%0 +/#"L+$%+/%$,-%+2 "'%$+(%"%+$%+"#%$,D%&,B2+-#+$%/+
!"%/+1+$ /+/#"3,&, /+(?!$,& /+"#&$%'%- /+,2/,/0#20#'#20#+( "+$%+/ &,#>
-%-=+/#:?2+0#/0,' 2, +#7("#/,3 +-#+$ /+- &5'#20 /+-#+$%+;( &%A+n+#/+
95#+&5%2- +#$+./0%- +2 +(5#-#+,'( 2#"/#+%+$ /+(%"0,&5$%"#/+(%&0%+& 2+
#$$ /A+ K%+ 0;&2,&%+ & 20"%&05%$+ (" ( "&, 2%+ #20 2&#/+ %+ $ /+ (%"0,&5$%"#/+
8 "0%$#&,- /+52%+:%"%20@%+%+,'%:#2+1+/#'#*%2D%+%+$%+-#$+<#"#&6 +&,3,$SNA

K +&,#"0 +#/+95#+%+(%"0,"+-#+$%+#0%(%+6,/0B",&%+#2+$%+95#+/#+5!,&%+#$+/5">
:,',#20 +-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+/,:2%-%+( "+,'( "0%20#/+&%'!, /+
( $@0,& /=+& ' +$ +85#" 2+$%+[2-#(#2-#2&,%+-#+$%/+& $ 2,%/+2 "0#%'#",&%>
2%/+1+$%+c#3 $5&,B2+g"%2&#/%=+0%'!,;2+ (#"%" 2+0"%2/8 "'%&, 2#/+#& >
2B',&%/+:$ !%$,D%-%/+1+:$ !%$,D%- "%/=+95#+/#+#7("#/%2+#2+$%+c#3 $5&,B2+
[2-5/0",%$+1+/5/+& 2/#&5#2&,%/+-,"#&0%'#20#+3,2&5$%-%/+%+$%+(" -5&&,B2+
1+#$+%3%2&#+0#&2 $B:,& =+(#" +95#=+,:5%$'#20#=+,'(%&0%2+#2+#$+#/(#&0" +
/ &,%$+1+%!"#2+(%/ +%+$%+(5#/0%+#2+#/&#2%+-#+& 2&#(&, 2#/+8,$ /B8,&%/+95#+
#'(5*%2+%+52%+("#/#2&,%+%&0,3%+1+-,2L',&%+-#$+./0%- =+#$+&5%$+-#'%2-%+
#$+#'($# +-#+,2/0"5'#20 /+-#+2#: &,%&,B2+#2+8 "'%+/ /0#2,-%+#+,""#>
3#"/,!$#=+#/&#2%", +#2+#$+&5%$+#/+#$+& 20"%0 +C%/@=+/,2+%-*#0,3%&, 2#/C=+
-#/-#+$5#: =+$%+8,:5"%+(%"%-,:'L0,&%+#2+#/%+0#2-#2&,%A
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

I I I . S U J E TO, F O R MA S Y CO N T R O L, E N U N CO N T E X TO
COMPLE JO
K%+(" :"#/,B2+-#$+./0%- +6%&,%+' -%$,-%-#/+1+' -5$%&, 2#/+-#+%&05%>
&,B2+95#+!5/&%2+/,2&" 2@%+852&, 2%$+1+#8,&,#20#+& 2+$%+-,2L',&%+-#+$%/+
'%2,8#/0%&, 2#/+/ &,%$#/=+( $@0,&%/+1+#& 2B',&%/+C1+95#=+%+/5+3#D=+%(%>
"#&#2+1+/#+-,852-#2+#2+$%+:# :"%8@%+!%* +#7("#/, 2#/+/#',B0,&%/+&%-%+3#D+
'%/+ /,',$%"#/=+ $ + 95#+ & 2-5&#+ %$+ #'($# + -#+ 52+ $#2:5%*#+ 52,8 "'#C+
%""%/0"%+%+$%+& 28,:5"%&,B2+-#+52%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%+& 2+(#"8,$#/+
-,8#"#20#/+%+$ /+95#+' -5$%" 2+/5+,'%:#2+#2+#$+/5":,',#20 +-#+/5+& 2>
&#(&,B2+,2,&,%$=+& 2+$ +95#=+-#/-#+$5#: =+0%'!,;2+/#+"#-#8,2#+#2+/5/+(%>
"L'#0" /+& 2&#(05%$#/+$%+-,/&,($,2%+*5"@-,&%+95#+$%+0,#2#+& ' + !*#0 A++

?P!,'-&%#(!-&I!d$%A!G4,%>!FX'#'!4+'!#0:$+%1#4::,T+!($B6e1,:'!(0!&$%!:$+1#'1$%!'(6,+,%1#'1,-$%H>!)*5%,"6(
&%(H%-52$%& (&%(7 , "$6(&%(I*"! ,#"&%& (&%(E6,5K%I!JK!cI!RPP_I!/>!_?PI!G'!.$#4f'>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 TT

n%+m#,$+$ +( 2#+-#+'%2,8,#/0 +%$+"#8$#7, 2%"+/ !"#+#$+,'(%&0 +95#+(" >

-5&#2+/ !"#+$%/+,2/0,05&, 2#/+*5"@-,& >%-',2,/0"%0,3%/+$ /+&%'!, /+ (#>
"%- /+#2+.5" (%+& ' +& 2/#&5#2&,%+-#+$%+(",'#"%+:5#""%+'52-,%$V+Q4$+
& '#2D%"+$%+(",'#"%+:5#""%+'52-,%$=+#$+-#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +6%!@%+
SN^
1%+%-95,",- +/5+(#"/ 2%$,-%-+(" (,%A+),2+#'!%": =+#/ +2 +/,:2,8,&%+95#+ SOBRE LA
COMPLEJIDAD
2 + 6%1%+ &5"",- + 2%-%+ -#/(5;/+ -#+ SMWNA+ .8#&0,3%'#20#=+ $ /+ &%'!, /+
DEL ESTADO Y LAS
#& 2B',& /+1+/ &,%$#/+(" 3 &%" 2+'51+"L(,-%'#20#+52%+:"%3#+&",/,/+-#+
CONTRATACIONES
&"#&,',#20 =+-#+$%+95#+#$+-#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +& ',#2D%+%&05%$'#20#+
ADMINISTRATIVAS
%+-#/#'!%"%D%"/#+`abRSSA+
ABOUT THE
.2+#/0#+/#20,- =+$%+0#2-#2&,%+/#+'%2,8,#/0%+8"%2&%+1+%!,#"0%'#20#+#2+/@2> COMPLEXITY OF
0 '%/+0%$#/+& ' +#$+,2&"#'#20 +-#+%&0,3,-%-#/+#& 2B',&%/+( "+(%"0#+-#$+ THE STATE AND
./0%- =+ +$%+(" :"#/,3%+-#/%(%",&,B2+-#+$%/+$@2#%/+"@:,-%/+95#+'%"&%!%2+ ADMINISTRATIVE
$%+8" 20#"%+/5/0%20,3%+-#$+/#"3,&, +(?!$,& +& 2+$%+,2& "( "%&,B2+-#+(%"0,> CONTRACTS
&5$%"#/+%":%- /+-#+("#"" :%0,3%/+%20#/+' 2 ( $,D%-%/+( "+$%+%-',2,/0"%>
&,B2=+$ +95#+%! 2%+#2+8%3 "+-#+52%+'%1 "+(#2#0"%&,B2+-#+&%0#: "@%/+(" >
(,%/+-#$+<#"#&6 +(",3%- +#2+$%+:#/0,B2+(?!$,&%=+& /%+95#+6%&#+0%'!%$#%"+
$%+& 2&#(&,B2+-#$+/#"3,&, +(?!$,& +& ' +(,$%+852-%'#20%$+95#+/ ( "0%+#$+
#-,8,&, +& 2&#(05%$+-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 A
)#+ %!"#+ 'L/+ 0%"-#+ C%5295#=+ -#/-#+ $5#: =+ /,2+ #/0%"+ -#/3,2&5$%- + -#+
Q%95#$$ /+$ - /RC+52%+&$%"%+1+:#2#"%$,D%-%+-#",3%+-#+$%+:#/0,B2+(?!$,&%+
6%&,%+$%+%($,&%&,B2+-#+' $-#/+&,3,$,/0%/+ +'#"&%20,$,/0%/=+0"%-,&, 2%$#/+ +
2 3#- / /=+95#+& 2-5&#2+%+$ +95#+/#+,-#20,8,&B+& ' +52%+Q65@-%+-#$+
<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 R+' 20%-%+/ !"#+$%/+0"%2/8 "'%&, 2#/+95#+/#+-#>
",3%2+-#+$%/+( $@0,&%/+-#+(",3%0,D%&, 2#/+1+-#/"#:5$%&,B2=+$ +95#+& 2-5&#+
%+#20#2-#"+95#+Q#$+U -#"+`/,&b+6%+-#/&5!,#"0 + 0"%/+'%2#"%/+-#+%&05%"A+
I%2#"%/+95#=+-#/-#+$5#: =+2 +(%/%2+( "+#$+-#"#&6 +4-',2,/0"%0,3 =+95#+
2 +/ $ +#"%+#$+-#"#&6 +(#2/%- +(%"%+$%+4-',2,/0"%&,B2=+/,2 +0%'!,;2+#$+
-#"#&6 +-#+$%+:%"%20@%+-#$+%-',2,/0"%- =+3@%+/ '#0,',#20 +1+/5*#&,B2+-#+
$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+%+-#"#&6 RSWA
4$+"#/(#&0 =+2 +&%!#+-5-%=+#2+&5%20 +%+$%+("#/#2&,%+-#8,2,0,3%+1+:#2#"%>
$,D%-%+-#+$%+0#2-#2&,%=+-#+95#+%6 "%+C( "+#$+0"%2/&5"/ +-#$+0,#'( C+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

%-95,#"#+ $%+ &5%$,-%-+ #7(#",#2&,%+ 3,3,-%=+ 'L/+ 95#+ $%+ -#+ #7(#&0%0,3%+ +
8#2B'#2 + #2+ -#/%"" $$ =+ 0%$+ & ' + $ + '%2,8#/0%!%+ .-5%"- + J%"&@%+ -#+
.20#""@%V
4""%2&%+#$+8#2B'#2 =+&%-%+3#D+'L/+3,/,!$#=+-#+$%+0#20%&,B2+-#+%- (0%"+
(%"%+$%/+4-',2,/0"%&, 2#/+$ /+' - /+(",3%- /+-#+:#/0,B2=+$ +95#+,'($,&%+
52%+ 2-%/*$ /"!$ 0"("12,$ @/:%&%+'(*'%.,A+ ./%+ ("L&0,&%+ #/+ & 2 &,-%=+ / !"#+
0 - + %+ (%"0,"+ -#+ $%+ :#2#"%$,D%&,B2+ -#$+ /,/0#'%+ -#+ #'("#/%/+ (?!$,&%/=+
95#+ & ',#2D%+ #2+ #$+ (#"@ - + -#+ #20"#:5#""%/+ 1+ /#+ :#2#"%$,D%+ & 2+ $%/+

??!3'-&I!X#$%/0#>!^7>!:,1>A!/>!O?>
?R!2A'%0! 2"+-)#"( !)+5>)I! d$%A! "4B0+,$>! 7 #, <52%-".*A( 9,"!%$"D%-".*( B( 7 , -86( %&'"*"#$,%$"!6>!
a$&$f'W!b0'&!.$&0B,$!(0!"%/'f'I!?MMOI!/>!R>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 SNi 2%&, 2%$,D%&, 2#/+ -#+ $%+ ( /0:5#""%+ 1+ ( "+ #$+ #8#&0 + -#+ $%/+ - &0",2%/+
/ &,%$,/0%/A+ U#" + $ + /,2:5$%"+ -#$+ 6#&6 + %6 "%+ #/05-,%- + 3,#2#+ -#+ $%+
%($,&%&,B2+-#+#/0%/+0;&2,&%/=+2 +%+#'("#/%/+,2-5/0",%$#/+ +& '#"&,%$#/=+
/,2 +%+3#"-%-#" /+/#"3,&, /+(?!$,& /+'%0#",%$#/+95#+2 +#/+,'%:,2%!$#+95#+
(5#-%2+852&, 2%"+/,2+/ '#0#"/#+%$+<#"#&6 +U?!$,& +`abS^A

46 "%+!,#2=+$ +95#+%+25#/0" +' - +-#+3#"+"#/5$0%+'L/+-#/0%&%!$#+-#+$%+

#7(#",#2&,%+%$5-,-%+#/+$%+#/0"#&6%+3,2&5$%&,B2+#20"#+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+
(?!$,&%+1+$%+-,2L',&%+/ &,%$=+#& 2B',&%+1+( $@0,&%+#2+$%+95#+$#+& ""#/>
( 2-#+%&05%"=+95#+/#+& 23,#"0#=+#20 2&#/=+#2+#$+#/&#2%", +95#+& 28,:5"%+
/5+#20 "2 +2%05"%$+1+(" (, A+U#" =+%-#'L/=+0%'!,;2+/#+& 23,#"0#+#2+#$+
& '!5/0,!$#+2#&#/%", +(%"%+/5+(5#/0%+#2+'%"&6%+1+852&, 2%',#20 +%-#>
&5%- P+ 52+ 852&, 2%',#20 + 95#+ / $ + &5""#+ #2+ 0;"',2 /+ /%0,/8%&0 ", /+
&5%2- +/5+-,/#O +%"95,0#&0B2,& +1+/5+,2:#2,#"@%+/#+%-%(0%2+%+$%/+-#'%2>
-%/+ (#"%0,3%/+95#+#/#+#20 "2 +#7,:#A
.$+#'($# +-#+52%/+5+ 0"%/+0;&2,&%/+#/+(%"0#+2%05"%$+-#$+-,2%',/' +- 2-#+
/#+-#/#235#$3#+$%+%&&,B2+%-',2,/0"%0,3%+-#$+./0%- =+1+& '("#2-#"$ +%/@+
& 2-5&#+%+#20#2-#"+$ +"#$%0,3 +-#+#$$%/+',/'%/=+( "+85#"D%+-#+/5+2%05"%>
$#D%+,2/0"5'#20%$A+H%$+& /%+/5&#-#=+-#+'%2#"%+& 2/0%20#=+#2+$%+#3 $5&,B2+
-#$+8#2B'#2 +95#+/,:2,8,&%+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%+1=+& 2+#$$ =+-#+$%/+
&,#2&,%/+95#+/#+ &5(%2+-#+/5+#/05-, A+4/@+& ' +$%/+,2/0,05&, 2#/+*5"@-,& +
(",3%-%/+6%2+#3 $5&, 2%- +6%&,%+52+/#20,- +/ &,%$=+$%/+95#+2%&#2+#2+#$+
&%'( +-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +/#+'%0,D%2=+/#+%-%(0%2+ +/ 2+/5/0,05,>
-%/+( "+8,:5"%/+95#+%! 2%2+#2+8%3 "+-#+'#* "#/+"#2-,',#20 /+("L&0,& /+
-#+"#%$,D%&,B2+-#+$%+:#/0,B2A+E ' +6%&#+3#"+.2",95#+c,3#" +n/#"2+"#8,>
",;2- /#+%+%$:52%/+&%0#: "@%/+95#+2 /+( -"@%2+(%"#&#"+(;0"#%/+#+,2& 2>
' 3,!$#/+#2+/5+& 2&#(&,B2+1+#/0"5&05"%=+Q$%+(" (,#-%-+1+$%+$,!#"0%-+-#+
,2-5/0",%+1+& '#"&, +(,#"-#2+/5+&%"L&0#"+%!/ $50 =+1+/#+3#2+"#$%0,3,D%-%/+
1+"#& 2 &,-%/+/ $ +#2+$%+'#-,-%+#2+95#+%15-%2+%+$%+& '52,-%-RSi=+#2+
3,"05-+-#+/5+%-%(0%&,B2+%+$%/+#7,:#2&,%/+-#+52+'52- +&%'!,%20#A
X + !/0%20#+$%+3%",%!,$,-%-+1+$%+%-%(0%!,$,-%-+("#/#20#/+#2+#$+8#2B'#>
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

2 +-#+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%+95#+/#+"#8$#*%+-#+8 "'%+,2#$5-,!$#+#2+#$+
&%'( +-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +1+/5/+,2/0,05&, 2#/=+%(%"#&#2+& '>
( 2#20#/+#/0%!$#/=+& 2/0%20#/=+95#+(#"',0#2+ !/#"3%"+$%+,-#20,-%-+-#$+
0#'%A
4/@=+#2+#$+%/520 +-#+$ /+& 20"%0 /+Q-#$+./0%- R+C +$ /+& 20"%0 /+#2+$ /+
&5%$#/+ (%"0,&,(%+ #$+ ./0%- + (%"%+ #$+ &5'($,',#20 + -#+ /5/+ 8,2#/C=+ ,2-#>
(#2-,#20#'#20#+ -#$+ :"%- + -#+ ,20#2/,-%-+ 95#+ *5#:5#2+ $ /+ & '( 2#2>
0#/+-#+<#"#&6 +(",3%- +#2+52+' '#20 +-#0#"',2%- =+%(%"#&#2+/,#'>
("#+ & '( 2#20#/+ -#+ "-#2+ *5"@-,& + (?!$,& + & ' + $ + / 2+ 52+ Q/5*#0 R++

?O!!)+5>)(1'('#/'++>)I!"(4'#($>!X#T&$B$!'!&'!$7#'!(0!Q>!.<,+:<,&&'I!a>!G$3'+$!5!\>!;0&!\'+3>!L5 !%#(
9 ,#9 -$"!%#(& 2(7 , -86(%&'"*"#$,%$"!6M(:, #( #$5&"6#>!Q'(#,(W!?MMR>
?L!42( 7 , -86( %&'"*"#$,%$"!6( B( 2%#( , 2%-"6* #( *$, ( 9%,$"-52%, #M! \0-,&&'W! 9+%1,141$! D'#:E'! ^-,0($I!
)+,-0#%,('(!(0!\0-,&&'I!?MNMI!/>!?_>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 TT

\%-',2,/0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%_+& 2+(%"0,&5$%",-%-#/+*5"@-,&%/+#2+/5+#/0"5&05>
"%+C$%+ ":%2,D%&,B2+%-',2,/0"%0,3%+1+$ /+(",2&,(, /+95#+$%+",:#2=+#20"#+
#$$ /=+(",2&,(%$'#20#=+& '(#0#2&,%+1+*#"%"95@%C=+95#=+%-#'L/=+#/0L+,2>
#$5-,!$#'#20#+3,2&5$%- +%+52%/+Q8 "'%/+ +' - /+852&, 2%$#/+-#+%&05%"R+
SN]
\(" &#-,',#20 /+%-',2,/0"%0,3 /_+95#+-#+2,2:52%+'%2#"%+(5#-#+ !3,%"+ SOBRE LA
COMPLEJIDAD
/,+("#0#2-#+$ :"%"+$%+(" -5&&,B2+-#+-#&,/, 2#/+3L$,-%/+#2+<#"#&6 =+$ +
DEL ESTADO Y LAS
95#+ /#+& '($#'#20%+ & 2+'#&%2,/' /+ -#+Q& 20" $R+*5"@-,& +,20#"2 + 1+
CONTRATACIONES
#70#"2 +\"#&5"/ /+%-',2,/0"%0,3 /+1+& 20" $+*5",/-,&&, 2%$_A+K%+("#/#2>
ADMINISTRATIVAS
&,%+-#+#/0 /+& '( 2#20#/+/#+'%20,#2#+,2%$0#"%!$#+C1+& 2+0 - +#$+3,: "+
:#2#"%- "+-#+& 2/#&5#2&,%/+*5"@-,&%/C+%+$ +$%": +-#+0 -%/+$%/+'%2,8#/> ABOUT THE
0%&, 2#/+95#+/5( 2#+$%+%($,&%&,B2+-#+$%+0;&2,&%+& 20"%&05%$A+./+-#&,"=+#2+ COMPLEXITY OF
THE STATE AND
$%+8 "'%&,B2+-#$+& 20"%0 =+(%"0,&5$%"'#20#+( "+$ +95#+& ""#/( 2-#+%+$%+
ADMINISTRATIVE
-#&,/,B2+-#+& 20"%0%"+1+$%+/#$#&&,B2+-#$+& 20"%0,/0%=+-5"%20#+$%+#*#&5&,B2+
CONTRACTS
-#$+& 20"%0 =+1=+8,2%$'#20#=+#2+"#$%&,B2+& 2+$%/+' -%$,-%-#/+-#+& 20" $+
C(",' "-,%$'#20#+( "+$ +95#+%0%O#+%+$%/+8 "'%/+*5-,&,%$#/C=+& ' +'%>
2,8#/0%&,B2+-#+$%+:%"%20@%+-#+$%+"#$%&,B2+*5"@-,& >%-',2,/0"%0,3%A
./0 /+& '( 2#20#/=+95#+"#/5$0%2+,2#$5-,!$#/+(%"%+$%+& 28 "'%&,B2+-#+$%+
8,:5"%+ !*#0 +-#+%0#2&,B2=+& ""#/( 2-#2=+#2+/5+ ",:#2+1+#2+/5+0"%0%',#2>
0 =+%+$ /+#/(%&, /+#(,/0#' $B:,& /+(" (, /+-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+
& 2+,2-#(#2-#2&,%+-#+$%+&%0#: "@%+8 "'%$+C(?!$,&%+ +(",3%-%C+#2+$%+
95#+ ( -%' /+ 5!,&%"+ & 23#2&, 2%$'#20#+ $ /+ -,/( /,0,3 /+ 2 "'%0,3 /+
95#+"#/5$0#2+%($,&%!$#/=+(5#/+-#!#' /+0#2#"+("#/#20#+95#+Q& 2/0"5,"+/B$ +
%+(%"0,"+-#+$ /+0#70 /+$#:%$#/+#/+0%20 +& ' +"#252&,%"+%+& '("#2-#"+&%>
!%$'#20#+/5+/#20,- RS]A+4-#'L/=+& ' +& 20",!5&,B2+'#0 - $B:,&%+#/(#>
&,%$'#20#+3%$, /%+(%"%+$%+& '("#2/,B2+-#+#/0 /+8#2B'#2 /=+#/+ ( "052 +
"#& "-%"+$%+#7,/0#2&,%+-#+$%+0;&2,&%+-#+$%/+& 2#7, 2#/+& ' +'#&%2,/' +
-#+,20#:"%&,B2+#2+#$+/,/0#'%+-#$+<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 =+& 28 "'#+%+$%+
&5%$+2 "'%/+-#$+<#"#&6 +(",3%- +(5#-#2+"#:,"+#2+#$+&%'( /+-#$+<#>
"#&6 +(?!$,& +1+3,&#3#"/%=+'#-,%20#+Q#23@ /R+-#+$%/+2 "'%/+-#+52 +%+
0" +/,/0#'%=+0%$+& ' +/5&#-#+#2+#$+&%'( +-#$+<#"#&6 +,20#"2%&, 2%$+
(",3%- =+ +!,#2+'#-,%20#+$%+%($,&%&,B2+-#+2 "'%/+-#+<#"#&6 +(",3%- +
( "+ 852&, 2%", /+ %-',2,/0"%0,3 /+ C( "+ #*#'($ =+ $%+ &#$#!"%&,B2+ -#+ 52+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

'%0",' 2, C=+ +$%+%($,&%&,B2+-#+$%/+& 2-,&, 2#/+#/0%!$#&,-%/+#2+0#7>

0 /+$#:%$#/+%-',2,/0"%0,3 /+95#+/ 2+& 2-,&, 2%20#/+-#+$%+%($,&%&,B2+-#$+
<#"#&6 +(",3%- +#2+$%/+%&0,3,-%-#/+95#+-#/($,#:%+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2STA+
.2+/@20#/,/=+#$+%/520 +'#-5$%"+#/+95#+$%+Q' 3,$,-%-R$(#"0#2#&#+%+$%+#/#2>
&,%+-#+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%+1=+#2+& 2/#&5#2&,%=+#/+& 2/5/0%2&,%$+%$+
<#"#&6 +%-',2,/0"%0,3 +-#+- 2-#+-#",3%+/5+/#"3,-5'!"#+"#/(#&0 +%+$%+
( "052,-%-+1+/5+&#"&%2@%+1+%(#: +%+$%+-,2L',&%+( $@0,&%=+95#+/#+6%&#+

?_!,'-&%#( !-&6! d$%A! G4,%>! 42( 9,6- #6( & ( 2%( & ?"*"-".*( & 2( 7 , -86( %&'"*"#$,%$"!6>! Q'(#,(W! "%:40&'!
J':,$+'&!(0!=(6,+,%1#':,T+!XY7&,:'I!?MNZI!/>!LZ>
?N!2A'%0W! ,"&'2( 5)07'/6! =+1$+,$>! FG0::,$+0%! (0! ;0#0:<$! '(6,+,%1#'1,-$H>! + !"#$%( & ( 2%( H%-52$%&(
& ( E" *-"%#( N5,;&"-%#( B( /62;$"-%#>! JY60#$! cLI! )+,-0#%,('(! .0+1#'&! (0! 20+0340&'I! ?MMRI! />! cO! 5!
%,B4,0+10%I!.'#':'%>

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420

 SNT ("#/#20#+#2+/5+#/(#&,%$+/#2/,!,$,-%-+(%"%+"#/( 2-#"+%+$%+#3 $5&,B2+-#+$%/+
"#%$,-%-#/+/ &, #& 2B',&%/SkA
./+%&L+- 2-#+-#/0%&%+$%+& '($#*,-%-+& ' +0#$B2+-#+8 2- +-#$+#/&#2%>
", +- 2-#+-#/%"" $$%+/5+%&05%&,B2+$%+%-',2,/0"%&,B2+(?!$,&%=+& 2+"%/: /+
%&#205%- /+1+&%-%+3#D+'L/+:$ !%$#/+#2+25#/0" +0,#'( =+( "+$ +95#+$%+
%-#&5%-%+& '("#2/,B2+-#+$ /+(" !$#'%/+1+%$&%2&#/+-#+$%+0;&2,&%+& 2>
0"%&05%$+-#/($#:%-%+( "+#$+./0%- +-#!#+%&5'5$%"+%+$ /+& 2 &,',#20 /+
%2&$%- /+ %+ $%/+ &%0#: ",D%&, 2#/+ *5"@-,&%/+ #/0",&0%'#20#+ 6%!$%2- =+ $%+
%("#&,%&,B2+&,#20@8,&%+-#$+8#2B'#2 +#/#2&,%$V+/5+& '("#2/,B2+& ' +52+
/,/0#'%+& '($#* A

+
ARMANDO RODRÍGUEZ GARCÍA

?Z!,'-&%#(!-&I!d$%A!G4E%>!O9(-"$M

Derecho PUCP, N° 66, 2011 / ISSN 0251-3420