- 308 -
CHAPTER VIL
MODERNIZATION:
In the earlier chapter, we have considered the
concept of social change and influence of educetion as
an instrument of social change. Here we are dealing
with the direction of sociel change towaris modernization
of the society. In this chapter, we shall try to explain
modernization and in the next chapter we shall consider
the part played by the teacher in the process of
modernization.
'Modernization' as a sociological concept is used
to denote the complex process of social change from the
‘traditional’ 4.e, inherited and accepted ways of
thinking and doing to 'modern' i.e. scientific and
rational behaviour based on knowledge. Modernization is
an historically inescapable and irretrievable process
of sotiel change which has been in a very wide sense
going on ever since man came out of ice-nge and discovered
use of fire.
"Modernisation is essentially a process of movement
from traditional or quasi-traditional order to certain
desired types of technology, associated ferm of social
structure, value-orientations and motivations ond norms.
It is not a simple process of imitation but the process
«309= 319 -
folloved without loss of identity of o particuler society.
Today the world is divided into developed anc the =
Gevcloping countries, which are slso sometimes colled the
unier+developed countries, the third world. This third
world contains its traditional framework and slowly on it
are ‘superimposed’ the modern especially western, -
industriel ideas which generally do not assimilate easily
but create new problems of adjustment.
As AsR.Desai expressed it, " The concept of
modernisation seeks to describe the period of transition
of human society during which man enters a nodern-rational
phase of acquiring skills and reaches a ncw level of
nestery over nature to construct his own social environment
bcsed on affluence and rationality
In order to understend social reality it is necessary
to imow the term " traditional" and "modem". As Talcott
Parsons” in his 'pattern variables’ approach puts it, the
ideal traditional society is morked by the norms of
partioularism, ascription, diffuseness, effectivity end
self-orientation. On the other had, the modern society is
characterised by universclism, achievement, pecificity,
4s Dube S.C. in Papers In Sociology of Educotion in en
article " Model tion and its tive demand,
n_ Socket: t eS.
In
2. Desai AR. - Erobhens of poderntsgtion of Underdeveloped
Societies - Neet for Revolution of Concepts.
3. Ref. Parsons Talcott: The Soclel SystemlNew York,
The "Free Press 1951 - Ps Sster .= 310 -
neutrality and collectvity, In addition to these
characteristics the traditional society is rural, nature-
bound, ritualistic, sacred and non-rational whereas
modem society is rational and secular®. for the
developing comtries the support behind these idesls is
mostly political as the people in
se countries are
incapable of bringing thea to actual reslities. It is
sherefore responsibility of the state to mobilize the
people actively towards the path of modernization. Thus
nodernization pre-supposes organised national effort.
At the individual level," modernization" refers
to the deeper chanje in man's attitude, way of thinking
and feeling a change in the whole aitisude towards life's
problems, the society and the universe. Ouc of the
outstanding marks of modern man 1s his readiness to new
experience snd his openness to innovation snd change.
Secondly he must be cepable of holding his opinions on
number of problems, Thirdly he shows acre awereness of the
diversity of attitude and opinion arowd him rether than
closing himself off in the belief thet the wrld is
wee 314
ct
* Parsons Talcott - Evolutionary Universal In Soci ety-
American Sociological Review, 1964 Vol.29, P.339.-31-
calculable and other people and institutions around
him can be relied on to fulfil and meet their obligations
and responsibilities. In brief, modern man is =
distinguished by his rational belief, scientific outlook,
readiness to master the environment and investigate
into mysteries of nature, his participation in social,
political activities and tolerance of views other than
his own.
It 4s clear that modern man is almost ciometrically
opposed to the traditional man. For a treditionel man,
there is no truth beyond his tradition and nothing good
beyond his traditional faith. He is averse to innovation
and experiment with new ideas or ways of thinking.
The term mdemization was used to characterize
the pattern of the developmentel process of the western
society es adopted or intended to be adopted by the
political leaders of the newly emerged nations. Two
other terms that are closely related to modernization
are westernization end industriali sation.
2012
4, A Jha - Modernization and the Hindu Socio-culture =
Observations for Delhi University Teachcrs.- 312 -
myesternization however means sheer imitation of
the sociel habits end conventions of the Europeans.
But « westernized mon may not necesserily be modernised
mon, though perhaps a ‘westernized' man is likely to
grow into modern man sooner than others ". About
westersization, S.C.Dube” has also pointed out that -
westernization appears to tie them ( the developing
countries) to an estetilished set of goals and an -
historically determined course : modernisation keeps
their choice open. He further states that, "... the
conno zation of industriglisation are overtly tecimological,
social ond cultural processes are considered under it
only by implication. Thus modemisation in economic
sphere means seperation of economic activities from the
troditional setting, increasing replacement of tools,
mechine and technology, growth of extensive sector of
secondar; and tertiary ( service) occupation, It indicates
growing spectelisation of economic roles and units of
econonie activities, Growing industrialisation is
a keyecharacteristic of economic modernisation"6,
Modernization implies a process wherein the society
develops en institutional structure capable of adjusting
see 313
5. Dube S.C. , Opeit P.%
6. Dube S.C. , Opcit PT- 313-
to continually changing problems and demands. A si:ift
in the social structure based on allocationof roles
on the principle of escription to the principle of
achievement and merit end thus qualitatively tran: forming
the vory basis of role-recruitment for all thc formal
organizations, Rationslity, humsnism, feasibility and
necessity of improvement in the conditions of human
lice in this world indicates cultural outlook of
modernization. Attitudes, values and motivations must
be
hanged to achieve modernization, and the institutional
arrongement must be rearranged,
Models of modernization are many and diverse,
Reinherd Bendix ( 1957) in his illuminating paper on
"Prodi tion and Modemity Reconsiderea"” gives more
importance to factors of timings and sequence in order
to understand the development of the process. Because
of these factors of timii and sequence, the process
of nodcrnisation is finique in every society.Moderni sation
cornot occur twice in the same wey in any socictyp at
the sane time, the consequence of modernisation und
industrielisation may be different in different socie$t pr.
7. Ref: Reinhard Bendix = Tradition and Modernity
Reconsidered + Som ve Studies in Socict Histor:
fol.X No.3 April, *
Symon Chodek - Societal Devel opment-Five approaches
with conclusions from Comparative Analysis.eT
Watt W.Rostow® came out with the thcory of stages
of economic growth, Rostow distinguished five stages of
economic growth + the traditional society, the situation
esteblishing pre-conditions for take-off, the take-off,
the drive of maturity and the age of high-nass-consumption.
Rostow assumes that the stage of teke-off is crucial for
chan, e from traditionsl to modern society. The situation
for take-off becomes ripe when
4n onslysis of the situation makes it clear that the
problem our society faces in the process of change tovords
modernity is the development of functional elite, Agent:
of change can be found in severel groups. In case of
educatio:, the policyemakers, the trustees and the teachers
ere such . There is a patterned difterence between
the policy-aakers on the one hand and the teacher on the
other, who cxecute the policy. In the school, it is
necessary to experiment with new ideas, to try new methods
and to explain it to the student", Time wes when teechers
took little account of the life of th school in relstion
to their work, snowed no serious professionel interest in
school groups .... ov as findings in group dynamics
becomes wisely “nown, a change is teking place, One iden,
a centrsl principle in change action 1s thet things go
better when the young sre involved in making decisions
which affect them™.2#
20S
23. Ibid p.105
ah. Cook Lei» and Cook eit. - 4 sociological Approach
To Educstion - Teta MecGruw Hill Publishing Cc.Ltd.,
Youbay, New Delhi - Third Bdaition. p. 299= 329 -
Irving Bernstein™ has pointed out the qualities
of chenge-agent as, " one qualification 1s expertness,
a broad ro
we of relevant knowledge ..... Another
qualification is good judgement..,. and a third is
fair-miniedness". The role of the change-agent is
described cs, "It is sxk wtt an attempt or many attenpt.
of e change-arent to get the ' feel’ of the things to
locate issues tentatively before any section is taker
Comltmeat. 40 chonye refers to pavtietpant attitudes
towards ce ise. attltude in favour of, opposed to or
indifferoat. Commitment rests upon perceptions, the
meanings things have for individuals and groups aad
Meanings a € orgasised into values .... Involvement and.
participation are keywords La every chargeeagent's
vocabulor;, slice it is by these processes tha! groups
grow stron, accomplish thetr aims, educete and reeducate
mewbers. I2 teachers feel siort anywhere, it is in filing
to see thet tiese ends cannot be hed by unverying
6
ce".
permissiv:
fo conclude,education can ovteain chanze toverds
mocernizaticn 1.c, as an instrument of chenge only wmcer
eee 30
— inne mee
25. Bernstet» Irving as quoted by Cook and Cook 9, 299
26. Cook 200 Cook, Qpekt Be 314- 330 -
certain minimal conditions -
*(a) a commitwent on the part of the agent of
change to the goal of change.
(b) relative clarify about the message of chan e
(c) uxictance of an objective situation on the
part of population as a whole", It is cleor
thot the teacher has to play a crucial rol.
in develop:
ag the right attitude and outlook necessery
to trausform the educaticnal instimtions into creative
cavironme ‘ts, helpful to children and the ade lescent in
their scli-fulfilment, If the teachers cuffer from the
backwara locking mind, they canenot hove forward lookt:
and libersliving influence on the leamers. Por this
pursose, the teschers mu. rise abeve the neriow idess
anc idess
ut caste, creed, comunity ete.
Convidering tae other side of the effectiveness
of teacher =» a change-agent, eminent sociologists and
educetionists have voincea out the actuel position of the
teacher, sloig with tne limitations due to social situations
which hisvers
iin to become 2 Successful chanze~avent.
“actually sec. Garis should nean rejection of only religious
element da
1d swdernization - keseys
zation of underdeveloped societies- Vol
Tod Cobtd. Bombay 1971- 31-
Secularism is based on firm acceptance of rationclity
as a guide to action. In case of individuslism similarly
it mcans individusl to develop his own criteria of
judgenent, or to make his own choice. In the absence of
clarify or in the ewent of non-acceptance of these values
by the teachers on the basis of their own individuel life
and action, all the prescription of ' progressive education|
becomes another set of rites observed in the form but
often violated in the spirit". 1t 1s not possible to
assert that the teacher will practise the values in his
life as he vowes. In this matter it is pointed out that,
" Teschers who wish to promote independent th nking
cannot hope to do so if they give no evidence of
independence in their own thinking nor they con hope to
do it, so long as they ‘help’ students to perform better
in examinations, by dictating them notes end model
answers. "29
Considering the teacher's position today as a
chance-agent, it is argued that the teachers today are
as a part of the society and cannot guide the society.
It is mentioned that, " .... they are interested in
woe 332
28. GoreM.s. Ibid
29. Gore M.S. Ibid= 3326
retaining their jobs, ensuring their promotions ond purely
non-academic activities which pay higher dividents in our
traditional society. The primary incentive of the teachers
is to have bread end butter, and since it is an easy going
dob ( they accept it). In case of women teachers they have
Joined to earn additional income for their fomilies. A
significant common feature of them all is the strong link
with the native, religious, social and cultural traditions
vhich are completely at variance with the intellectual
profession they have happened to join. They observe
religious rituals and family customs. Personal problems
are discussed in the staffroom rether than the -cademic
problems.(It follows that) the teachers, are members of
their society first and then teachers of modern knowledge.
Their conduct is conditioned consciously or unconscLously,
by their awareness that the knowledge they try to impart
in the classroom is the product of elien socicties and
more immediately relevant there then in their tradition-
bound society". >
With the above views, in the next chapter of the
present study, we are interested in knowing whether the
answers given by the teachers throw any light on the role
eee 333
3%. Adha, Opcit- 333 -
of tcachers as change-agent. The teachers are expected
to provide enlightenment in their students and in the
society ct large, With their own perception, we want
to know if they are aware of their role as chanze-egent.
tte eee