Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
Works Cited
Burroughs, John. Wake-Robin (kindle edition). Amazon Digital
Services, Inc., 2012.
Callenbach, Emest. “The Power of Words.” Ecological Literacy’
Educating Our Children for a Sustainable World. Ed.
Michael K, Stone & Zenobia Barlow. San Fran
Club Books, 2005. 41-44. Print.
Dickinson, Emily. The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson. Ed.
‘Thomas H. Johnson. Boston: Little, Brown, 1960.
Hu, Gengshen. “A Response to the Problem of “Translator-
Centeredness’.” Shanghai Journal of Translators 4 (2011):
7-9. Print.
Leng, Yuhong.
Theory?
s the Translator the Centre in Eco-Translation
shanghai Journal of Translators (3) 2011: 71-73.
‘Wang, Ning, “Eoo-Literature and Eoo-Translatology: Deconstruction
and Reconstruction.” Chinese Translators Journal 2 (2011)
10-15.
Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
A Study of the Popular Ecopoems as Textual
Resources for Ecological Approach to
Acquisition of ESL
Pratap Kumar Dash
Introduction
During the last seven decades, several experiments have
been conducted in the approaches of teaching and learning of
English as Second Language (ESL). These experiments are based
on the emerging needs of time and environment of the leamers in
different socio-cultural and temporal contexts. The changing world
scenario, the scientific, psychological, social inventions and theories
formulated by observation and experiments from time to time are
being pract 0 ESL classroom practices as bases of
support. The aim of all these is to enable the learners to acquire
Second Language (or English language in our case) effectively.
Variously, the mechanism of such experiments have been atiibuted
to imitation, innateness, cognition, and input, the process of attention,
consciousness, human information processing and operation of
memory system. Befittinely, these days, the ecological approach to
Second Language Acquisition (SLA) is in discussion. This happens
to be one of the utilitarian recognitions of the much adopted but
less recognised approach to SLA.
Worth saying, the teachers of ESL have been using various
reliable tools and teaching materials. Popularly, in Communicative
mn|
|
Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
Language Teaching (CLT) framework, including Content-based
approaches, Task-based Instruction and Altemative Participatory
“Approaches in relation to Multiple Intelligences, texts of specific
fields are used in the form of ESP/EGP/EAP etc. No doubt, the
texts of literature are also used as very useful and popular tools for
the purpose. Here in this context, its pertinent enough to say that
the literary texts, although other genres are there, importantly, the
texts of poetry as such, are full of multi-folded ecological texts and
contexts which have been effectively used for ESL acquisition until
now in an unrecognized way. But now, this needs to be highlighted
and organised to design materials for teaching and leaning of ESL.
For this, the two emerging dimensions viz. the ecopoems (or poems
of romantic ecology, green poems, earth poems, environ poems
tte.) as resources and the ecological approach to SLA as outlined
by Kramsch (2002) and Leo van Lier (2009) can be put together
to prepare curriculum frameworks at different levels.
Perspectives of ESL Acquisition through Ecological Approach
Under the broad concept of Vygotsky's Socio-cultural
‘Theory of Language Acquisition, Ecological Approach to ESL
earning is so to say a discovery in the respective field dealing
together with the environmental (ie, socio-cultural, natural) and
mental (ie. cognitive, heuristic, epistemological) conditions.
‘According to Leo van Lier (2009), an ecological approach can
views on language learning,
especially when ths ecological approach is znchored in an ecological
world: view. He says that the work of Vygotsky and Bakhtin,
dating fiom the early decades of the twentieth century illustrates an
-al approach to cognition, learning, and language (see
Lantolf 245)
{As he points out, an Ecological Approach to Language
m4
Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (20\4)
Learning (EALL) challenges the three premises that he has focused.
Firstly, it shifts the emphasis from scientific reductionism to the
notion of emergence. Instead of assuming that every phenomenon
can be explained in terms simpler phenomena or components, it
says that at every level of development properties emerge that
cannot be reduced to the prior levels. Secondly, ecology says that
not all of cognition and learning can be explained in terms of the
process that goes inside the head. Finally, an ecological approach
asserts that the perpetual and social activity of the leamer, and
particularly the verbal and nonverbal interaction in which, the leamer
engages, are central to an understanding of leaming. In other words,
ecologically they do not just facilitate leaning, they are learning in
a fundamental way.
From the ecological perspective, the leamer is immersed in
‘an environment full of potential meanings. These meanings become
available gradually as the learner acts and interacts within and with
this environment. Learning is not a holus-bolus or piecemeal
migration of meanings to the inside of the leamer’s head, but rather
tie development of increasingly effective ways of dealing with the
‘world and its meanings, Therefore, to look for learning is to look
at the active learner in her environment, not atthe contents for her
brain. (Lantolf 246).
Lier (2009) further discusses quoting Neisser (1992) that
learners are not empty heads that reverberate harmoniously with
environment. Rather it means that cognition and leaming rely on
both representational (schematic, historical, cultural, and so on)
and ecological (perceptual, emergent, action-based) processes and
systems. Language itself is therefore also both representational and
coological and its d , its structure, and its use are as focused
by Bakhtin (1981) are inherently dialogical.
usRavenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
The ecocentric or geocentric views or systems are
indigenous to peoples, that humans are a part of greater natural
order, or even a greater living system. This is called deep ecology.
Thus, ecology as a specific way to study cognition, language, and
learning brings the visual perception, cognitive development, and
acquisition of various social-natural contexts
‘Thus, itis assumed that an ecological linguistic acquisition,
of. language establishes relations (of thought, action, power) rather
than as objects (words, sentences, rules). It also relates verbal
utterances to other aspects of meaning making, such as gestures,
drawings, artifacts, etc. The totality of meaning making is semiotic
e nature-oriented discourses become increasingly
dialogic. The universal ecological themes are more communicative
than the writings containing various other subject matters.
Interms learning, language emerges out of semiotic activity.
The environment provides a ‘semiotic budget” (analogous to the
energy budget of an ecosystem which the active leamer
engages in meaning-making activities together with others.
Lier (2009) in this context analyzes the word ‘affordance’
in this context which was coined by the psychologist James Gibson
(1979) in Ecological Psychology that refers to a reciprocal
ip between an organism end a particular feature of its
Ifthe language leamer is active and engaged, s/he
vill perceive linguistic affordances and use them in linguistic action.
(Lantolf 252). s evident that ecology in its many forms
including the texts of literature (may be real or imaginary) form an
important context for the language leamers. Language leaming as
‘form of socialization helps develop evologization by virtue of making
176
Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
them develop cognitive and critical thinking, Hopefully, these are
the conducive for the acquisition of Second/Foreign Language too.
Learnability Factors in Ecoliterary Texts
In the context of English as a Second/Foreign Language,
itis very often noticed that students at different levels of English
Language Acquisition are neither efficient nor proficient or confident
like the native speakers, To further their apprenticeship to the
target language, the supplement of content-based, real world and
texts of literature are very vital. No doubt, they greatly depend on
the literary texts of various genres because this happens to be the
dependable and effective resources of getting into the socio-cultaral-
1 and environmental contexts to leam the target
‘open to more of scopes of understanding. interpreting,
analyzing and adding creative ideas. Literary texts are also prone
to.as much as participation and interaction including debating and
ased leaming techniques. To quote Duff
i, Genuine sample of a very wide range of styles, registers, and
text-types
iOpen to multiple interpretations
iii, Non-trivial and powerful motivator
‘There are enough of scopes for comparison and contrast, getting
pictures of life in different ways, full of socio-cultural, imaginary,
factual and moral repertoire. Literary texts create curiosity of
Teaming too,
is noticed that the literary genres based on ecowritings
possess more commonly communicative, natural, humanitarian and
universal languages. So, while the ESL leamers attempt to decode
7|
|
|
Ravenshast Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
‘minute observation of the movements of natural objects. In addition,
there are themes about some romantic, fanciful, chivalric, unique
experiential, historical, epical and ultural subject matters.
Also, in them, there lies underlying morality and message for
humanity. Although the poems reflect the times, places and persons
the poet’s personal, temporal and regional experiences, still
they constitute universal perceptions because natural elements
and environments are almost common sand
‘emotions, the images and languages are also in the cognitive domain
of the literary and linguistic spirit of the leamers of the target
.nguage. Empirical and experiential evidences are there in Indian
that the linguistic decoding from mother tongue to English
and vice versa and the formation of schem:
problem for the learners in this case specifically. For example,
being an Indian, when I read the poems of Wordsworth or Shelley
or Tennyson, simultaneously or as a prior background, I have
already enjoyed the nature pocms written in either Hindi, Bengali
ormy Mother Tongue (MT) like the poems of Rabindranath Tage
Gangadhar Meher,
Madhusudan Rao, R hore Bal, Mayadhar
Mansingh, Sachidananda Routray, Binod Nayak or Kuntala Kumari
anguage is decoding
innate to all, ecologically non-vulnerable and socio-culturally and
environmentally not complex, complicated or ambiguous. The feelings
and emotions in such poems are commonly shared in the comfort
zone of the linguistic domain. The translated texts of poems of the
populac n
and ESL cl
poets can be taken up for 2 parallel use both in MT
and
Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
translated text of ‘Autumn, 1958” by Sachi Routray (1916-2004)
cain be used as ecopoetic resources and can be compared to other
popular ecopoems such as John Keats’ ‘Ode to Autumn’ because
such poems have linguistic and social-cultural features suitable for
the ESL leamers to assimilate the overlapping textual signs of evo!
of the poems, ecological approach of ESL learning, and social
ecology.
In Second Language/Foreign Language teaching-leaming
classrooms, English poetry has no doubt a greater role in attracting
the attention of the ESL learners right from the nursery to the
tertiary level. [tis evident that children across the world start their
practice of leaming ESL for the popular nursery rhymes like
Macdonald's ‘Little White Lily’ and the like. The beau
mysterious images of nature impress the budding learners when
expressed in such poems. Although most of them are anonymous,
the frequently anthologized small and musical poems such as ‘Simple
“Buzz and Hum’, ‘O My Kitte
Gi
and the Bumble B
compesitions are fl
ani
‘How Do You Do Neighbor?", ‘The Fly
Lady Bird’ and hundreds of such
linguistic potentialities of active vocabulary
imple sentences suitable for the beginners of ESL to acquire.
on, their ecolinguistic textual configuration bound up with
‘musical harmony and simplicity which are conducive to ecological
mind set up of the learners too.
larly, the nature poems or poems of romantic ecology
bear the testimony of deep ecology as outlined in Wordsworth’s
181Ravenshawe Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
their language domain from mother tongue to the target language,
obviously they get adapted to the vocabulary and expressions
because they negotiate the meanings, texts, contexts and linguistic
levels are rather closer to them in comparison to the other types
of texts focusing complex materialistic, politicised life and society
or the so called fantasy or detective writings. I am sure that in
and lear, but in ecowritings,
they are inspired to learn developing their ecocentric discourse
features. For example, the abundant of ecopoems in English of
both 19" and 20" Century have already shown their dext
being meaningful ESL resources for classroom use.
Review of Literature
Kramsch (2002), while highlighting Ecological Approach
to Foreign Language Education, in a seminal article, focuses on the
increasingly multilingual and multicultural nature of global exchanges
leading to symbolic competence. He focuses on some of the key
terms like pluralistic intrinsic human relations, double-voicing nature
of human language, and diff crpretations of meaning like
‘meaning expressed through language on multiple timescales.
Similarly, Jarinen says that in Ecological Approach to Foreign
Language Leaming, context isthe primary provider of affordances
than mediate cognition by means of artifacts, such as language.
The practical implications of the views of language are a dynamic
system and language leaming is a dynamic, non-linear, unpredictable
and ongoing process on the basis of the concept of affordances
outlined by J. J. Gibson (1979)
Argo in another interet article discusses that the innovative
practices and ecological thinking/being/feeling combine to produce
Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
a site of resistance, of politics, of political resistance. In the
Postmodem world, we need to accept ecopoetics that constitute
aworl € are fully aware of interdependence of the
body upon its world for its health, a world that is now inextricable
from the body directly addressing an environment in crisis,
Rueckert (1995) says that the nature writings seem to be
stored energy. Its relevance does not derive solely from their
meaning, but from their capacity to remain active in any language
and to go on with the work of energy transfer, to continue to
function as an energy pathway that sustains life and the human
‘community
From the above review, itis noticed that their assumptions
regarding Ecological Approach to Language Acquisition and texts
of literature or specifically ecopoems can be brought closer to be
used in the ESL classrooms effectively because the factors like
“imbibing plural ic human relations’, “capacity to remain
in using language, and ‘affordance’ are indeed vested in the
ecopoetic texts
Importance of Ecopoems in ESL Teaching and Learning
Traditionally, the elements of nature have a profound
impression on the students instinctively through the Vedic ch
‘written in Sanskrit and the language of which i
the epies of both the East and the West; the folk songs and
Pastoral, impression on pupils being in academic curicalum befiting
‘o the universal mental and environmental set up. What’s more,
nature poems or ecopocms reveal the aesthetics of the clements of
natu like seasons, water, air, fire, flowers and fruits,
forests and animals, ruRavenshaw Jounal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
Ballads that the subject matters of the poems
a ‘ents and situations from common life, and to relate or
describe them, throughout, as far as, was possible in a selection of
language really used by men.’ Again he says that they constitute
“the primary laws of nature”, ‘humble and rustic life’, ‘elementary
feelings’, and ‘the passions of men are incorporated with the
beautiful and permanent forms of nature,’ The texts of the poetry
‘of many popolar poets in English contain ccoTinguistic features both
Right fiom the popular works of Chaucer to the
Rabindranath Tagore and Sarojini Naidu, the reflection of feelings
and imaginations emanating from and attuned to different ecological
backgrounds may be in the forms of association with wild organic
nature, agrarian and pastoral set ups and various carnivalesque
and subtle senses are prominently visible. The degree and subtlety
of ESL acquisition are there in the fact, style and language.
‘The Ecolinguistic Features of Eeopoems
‘This approach of language acquisition needs analysis with
evidence. For this purpose, some popular and much
anthologized nature poems have been analyzed here. The textual
quotations ofthe poems are mostly from The Big Book of Rhymes
and Norton Anthology of English Poetry (5! edition) respectively.
‘The ecolin formal and functional
properties of language according tothe linguistic levels of the text
e. we must look at the phonological and phonetic, morphological
and syntactic, semantic and pragmatic elements conducive for SLA.
Firstly, in terms of metrical phonology, the poems ae bi
rhythmic repetitions bearing the patterns mostly image/picture
i
Ravenshaw Journal of Literaty and Cultural Sudies 4 (2014)
creating lyrics with euphonic characteristics of alliteration and
assonance, Whether the ESL leamers say: ‘Twinkle, twinkle, li
ster’ or ‘Alone, alone, al, all alone’ or “Tiger, tiger buing bright’,
“Break, break, break’, ‘Up! Up! My friend’, ‘Sunshine on my
shoulders..”, there is simplicity in sound and rhythm for them. In
addition, many of such poems have been composed emphasizing
the poetic emotion directly inspired by nature with a creative,
artistic and intellectual 's spontaneity has made
the flow of language without artificiality and therefore universally
accessible. This repetition of syllables helps the Ieamers learn the
Janguage. It is also evident that nature poets have succeeded in
using the common prosodic meters of iambic and trochaic with
slight deviations at times and with t feet
‘are common in many other poetic pattems of other languages
m Blake, William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, John
PB. Shelley, A.L-Tennyson, Matthew Amold, Robert
Browning, Walt Whitman, R.W. Emerson, Robert Frost, R. N.
Tagore, Aurobindo
appreciable cu
and association of man with nature with sensual, intellectual,
and/ot mystical feelings. These are the
both the poet and the readers are connected uniformly. According
to Leech(1969), ‘The social relation between the participants (that
for the most part, between the author and his audience)
determines what we may call in a broad
183Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
the author dealt with two texts of ecopoems, one from romantic
ecology ic. ‘Ode on Intimations of Immortality’ by William
Wordsworth and the other by Mario Petrucci entitled
‘Deserted’(From Poetry: The Environment, Theme C:
Deforestation, Poem-10). This was a part of the study materials
prepared as two units of study in poetry section of a negotiated
syllabus for the paper of Literature for Fourth Year English Major
Education Brack, Sebha Univer
to enable the students with text interpretation
ary sensibility to the maximum extent. The class
consisted of 20 students between 20-21 age limits having average
proficiency level. The problem of most of the students was how to
understand the text and context; enjoy the poems; and get the
linguistic input in the Target Language. They were worried that
they had been feeling alienated from many poems they were taught
by then because they used to find themselves unrelated to the
subject-matters, socio-cultural set ups and the philosophical, moral
and satirical themes associated with those poems. Also, the semantic
and pragmatic aspects in such poems were difficult and do not
help them form complete schema. Thus, they had developed a
‘mechanical attitude towards such poems.
For the two selected texts of ecopoems, the text-based
CLT was adopted and both are studied in comparison. In pre-
teaching, they were told to develop a ‘biocentric’ approach based
on ‘animism’ and ‘deep ecology’ on the basis of ecoethical
significance relating to their own environmental context. They were
made to leam to accept the texts as in the words of Buell (2001)
‘acts of environmental imagination’ that may ‘affect the caring for
18s
Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Swudies 4 (2014)
presenting the settings for the poems In while-teaching, while making
‘them develop a close reading with think aloud strategy, the
teacher put emphasis on the application of techniques of creating
critical thinking with ecological imagery and eootropes, tracing the
morphological and syntactic coherence mainly based on ecocritical
‘theme. In post-teaching, the students were encouraged to give
their opinions about global and local comprehension of the themes
ofboth the poems. In addition, in the follow up activities, with the
‘guidance of the teacher, they debated getting themselves divided
into teams named as ‘urbanature’ and ‘ruranature’. In response to
the assignments like paraphrasing chunks and listiig the events of
the poems as class work in groups and homework of a comparative
appreciation of the poems, it was noticed that they used language
mostly expressive and social; and tones were overtly nostalgic,
personal with undertone of irony basically related to the hazards of
urbanization. The application of cognitive and affective skills and
verbal activities both in while teaching and post teaching were
satisfactory.
Postscript of the Case Method
Different models of SLA have been outlined related the
use of literary texts. According to the Information Processing Model,
leamers are found to process content words, then lexical items to
‘grammatical items for semantic information and then process more
‘meaningful morphology. According to Maley and Duff (1989), an
Integrated Model takes into account the linguistic, methodological
pects of teaching literature; and in the above
an overall estimation is formed that ecopoems can be
ving language proficiency; improving the
ige; and refining cognitive and creative aspects
189“A hundred years ago I was the her,
a friendly face to light a summer's mom,
and now my reputation stands at zero,
too much of me beams through a sky that’s tom, (in
poetry 2009)
‘These lines contain the positive and substantial elements of target
language leaming factors plus input, and thus the ecopoemns can be
hentic textual materials as
ies using
them, Apart from learning the language skills, explanation of
vocabulary and comprel question-answers, and other
language activities, they can be purposefully designed and used for:
i. Creating eco
among the leamers through ver
Improvement of the knowledge of survival
fe and surn ed to sustai
iii, Develop creative and critical
and Multiple Intelligences with the actvit
debating, discussion, presentation, role
environmental imagination, distinguishing ecological imagination and
reality etc.
iv, Develop nature appreciation, ecozesthetics and anthropocentric
views by bringing real life experiences and association with organic
nature into the ESL classrooms
related to the ecological concems in rea
190
Ravenshaw Journal of Literary and Cultural Suadies 4 (2014)
No doubt, the above listed points are very valuable'to inculcate
curiosity and develop natural interest to acquire target language
through Participation Metaphor (PM) among the students.
Conclusion.
said that mind je nature and nature is visible
mind and specifically, the bilingual mind possesses double-layered
linguistic code (i.e. both MT and L2) for that matter. So, using
‘ecopoems in the framework of the Ecological Approach to SLA
many prospective texts of poems in English and
the poems in the respective MTs written earlier as pastorals or
romantic poems or the ecocritical poems of our time can be used
as valuable tools bringing balance between fancy and reality. The
curriculum designers or the English language teachers can make a
modest and pragmatic attempt to take the major headings of ecology
like global warming, pollution, biodiversity, energy crisis,
the socio-cultural backgrat
anguage teaching and leaming a all the levels.
p the learners to get themselves involved in
meaning making and acquire supplement to the cognitive factors.
‘This design can be extended to selected texts of prose too. We
‘-based and specifically designed texts can develop
igences but even then, the texts of
ecopoems possess contents to develop ecocogniton and ecological
world view which is the need of our time
191Rovenshaw Journal of Literary dnd Cultural Studies 4 (2014)
Works Cited
‘Arigo, Christopher. “Notes towards an Ecopoetics: Revising the
Postmodern Sublime and Julian Spahr’s This Connect
of Everyone with Langs." hitp/www. arigoessayread pa
Web. 25 March 2013.
Buell, Lawrence. Writings for an Endangered World: Literature,
Culture, and Environment in the US. and Beyond,
Cambridge, M.A., and London: The Belnkap Press of
Harvard UP, 2001. Print.
Duff, A. & A. Maley, Literature, NY: OUP, 2008. Print,
Engelhardt, J, “Talking from Ecopoetry,” ASLE 2007, Web. 2
April 2013.
Ferguson, M. etal. The Norton Anthology of Poetry, NY: WW.
‘Norton and Company, 2005. Print.
Howarth, W.{“Some Principles of Ecocriticism.” The Ecocriticism
Reader: Landmarks in Literary Ecology. Ed. C. Glotfelty
‘and H. Fromm, London: The University of Georgia Press,
1 has Ecology to do with CLIL? An Ecological
and Language Integrated Leaming,”
CLIL Practice: Education and Culture. Web. 25 March
2013.
Walter, ed. The Big Book of Nursery Rhymes. London:
Blackie & Sons, Ltd, Project Gutenberg. Web. 4 Apr.
2
King, Graem, “Earth Poems”. hitp:/kingpoetry2009.com. Web.
10 Apr. 2013.
Kramsch, C. “Ecological Perspectives on Foreign Language
Education.” Plenary Paper presented at Berkley Language
Center, University of Califomia, 21 September 2007. Web.
25 March 2013.
192
‘Ravenshaw Journal, of Literary and Cultural Suedies 4
Leech, GN. A Linguistic Guide to English Poetry. London:
Longman, 1969. Print.
Lier, Leo van. “From Input to Affordance: S interactive
NY: OUP, 2009. Print.
Naidu, Sarojini. The Goldén Threshold. Globus Publishing: NY.
Web. 23 Feb. 2012.
iterature and Ecology: An Experiment in
m Reader: Landmarks in
Literary Beology. Ba. C. Glotfelty and H.Fromm, The
University of Georgia Press: London, 1995. Print
Tagore, Rabindranath, Classic Poetry Series, PoemHunter.com
“The World's Poetry Archive, 2004, Google Book Search
Web. 25 March 2013.
193