Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research Article
articleinfo
abstract
Article history:
Received 7 December 2017 Purpose: This study identifies the effects of the educational leadership of nursing unit managers on
Received in revised form team effectiveness and the mediating effects of organizational communication satisfaction; it highlights
2 March 2018 the importance of educational leadership and organizational communication and provides the data
Accepted 22 March 2018 needed to enhance the education capacity of managers.
Methods: The participants were 216 nurses working at unit with nursing unit managers of staff nurses at
Keywords: a
communication tertiary hospital located in Cheongju city, South Korea, and nurses who had worked for more than 6
leadership months at the same unit. This study was conducted using questionnaires on educational leadership,
nurse administrators team effec- tiveness, and organizational communication satisfaction. Data analysis was performed with
a t test, analysis of variance, Scheffe´ test, Pearson's correlation coefficient, and simple and multiple
regression analyses using SPSS, version 23.0. Mediation analysis was tested using Baron and Kenny's
regression analysis and a Sobel test.
Results: The mean score for the educational leadership of nursing unit managers was 3.74 (±0.68); for
organizational communication satisfaction, 3.14 (±0.51); and for team effectiveness, 3.52 (±0.49).
Educational leadership was significantly positively correlated with team effectiveness and
organizational communication satisfaction. Organizational communication satisfaction demonstrated a
complete mediating effect on the relationship between educational leadership and team effectiveness
(b ¼ .61,
p < .001) and was significant (Sobel test; Z ¼ 7.40, p < .001).
Conclusion: The results indicate that the educational leadership of nursing unit managers increases
communication satisfaction among nurses; this supports the idea that educational leadership can
contribute to team effectiveness. This suggests that the educational leadership and communication ca-
pacity of nursing unit managers must be improved to enhance the performance of nursing
organizations.
© 2018 Korean Society of Nursing Science, Published by Elsevier Korea LLC. This is an open access article
under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Introduction
management efficiency. In this rapidly changing medical environ-
ment, these organizations are focusing on strengthening their core
Modern hospital organizations are promoting specialization,
competencies and improving their relations to increase produc-
segmentation, modernization, and informatization to provide high-
tivity [1]. In particular, middle managers play the most pivotal role
quality health-care services that meet customers' expectations. In
in enhancing their efficiency.
addition, hospital organizations are making efforts to improve
Middle managers in nursing organizations drive the achieve-
their
ment of the goals of each nursing unit and hospital, as well as
improvement of performance. In particular, a nursing unit
manager is the core manager of a nursing unit and has the
* Correspondence to: Eun-Kyung Kim, RN, PhD, Department of Nursing, responsibility and authority to understand the purpose and
Chungbuk National University, 1 Chungdae-ro, Seowon-gu, Cheongiu, Chungbuk structure of the hospital and nursing department and to direct,
28644, Republic of Korea. coordinate, and evaluate nursing resource management and the
E-mail address: kyung11@cbnu.ac.kr performance of nursing activities [2]. In addition, nursing unit
*
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0986-5217
managers can significantly
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anr.2018.03.001
p1976-1317 e2093-7482/© 2018 Korean Society of Nursing Science, Published by Elsevier Korea LLC. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license ( http://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
100 E.H. Choi et al. / Asian Nursing Research 12 (2018) 99e105
affect the efficiency of overall hospital organization and the quality Setting and sample
of patient care. Therefore, nursing unit managers should have
management capabilities that can play a key role in professional The participants of this study were staff nurses working with
performance and in improving the capabilities of staff nurses. nursing unit manager for more than 6 months in a university
Nursing unit managers devote much time to educating patients, hospital with educational mission in the Cheongju city. For the
family caregivers, nursing staff, nursing students, local residents, multiple regression analysis, the sample size was estimated at a
and organizations, as well as coordinating and cooperating with power of .95, significance level of .05, medium-effect size of .15,
various departments inside and outside the hospital. The educa- and through 13 predictor variables using G*Power 3.1.9.2, a
tional leadership of nursing unit managers focuses on identifying program for statistical power analyses. The minimum number of
nurses' abilities and attitudes and managing activities and educa- samples required was calculated as 189 participants. Thus, 250
tion programs to improve tasks and nurses' job performance, question- naires were distributed in anticipation of missing
knowledge, and attitudes and to develop their professionalism to questionnaires. Of these, 242 completed questionnaires were
provide patients with quality nursing. The educational leadership collected (response rate: 96.8%). Ultimately, after excluding 26
of nursing unit managers has a positive effect on organizational questionnaires (dropout rate: 10.4%) with incomplete data, the
performance and team effectiveness, which can increase nurses' study analyzed data from 216 participants, which met the
job satisfaction and decrease their turnover intention. Its impor- minimum number of participants required for statistical testing.
tance has recently been emphasized [3].
The nursing unit is an independent unit operated by the nursing
Ethical considerations
unit manager and is affected by complex factors such as the envi-
ronment of each unit, characteristics of team members, diversity of Data collection was conducted after approval of the
resources, and interactions among organizational members [4]. Institutional Review Board of Chungbuk National University
These factors also affect team effectiveness. Rapid and smooth (Approval no. CBNU-201704-BMSB-426-01) belonging to the
communication between team members is essential for the team researcher to pro- tect the human rights of the research
effectiveness of a nursing unit [5,6]. participants. Researchers visited the nursing department at one
Organizational communication refers to the interactions be- hospital to request participation and to explain the purpose of this
tween organizational members to cooperatively achieve organiza- study and the contents of the questionnaires. A pre-educated
tional goals [7]. Organizational management can also be referred research assistant visited each nursing unit and explained the
to as communication management, and communication plays a purpose of the study to the staff nurses. Furthermore, data
cen- tral role in the operation of an organization [8]. According to collection process, guarantee of anonymity, autonomy of the
the results of previous studies on organizational communication, decision to withdraw, confidentiality, and data storage and
organizational communication satisfaction contributes to handling were explained to the participants. Nurses completed a
achieving goals and to organizational development by increasing
self-administered survey after consenting in writing to voluntarily
the job satisfaction of organizational members [5,9e11].
participate in this study. Each completed questionnaire was
Nursing unit managers must possess outstanding communica-
collected in a sealed envelope to ensure confi- dentiality. Collected
tion skills. Strong communication skills are important components
questionnaires were coded, input into the computer, and stored in
of effective leadership. A successful organization is one with col-
a lockable cabinet.
lective efficacy and a capability to develop and use resources to
accomplish goals that matter to all staff members through agreed-
upon processes [12]. Measurement
In previous studies, it was proved that the educational leader-
ship of the leader is an important factor for enhancing the team Educational leadership
effectiveness [3] and that there is a positive correlation between Educational leadership was measured using a tool revised by
organizational communication satisfaction, job satisfaction, orga- Ahn [3], which was based on the Principal Instructional Manage-
nizational commitment, and organizational effectiveness [13e17]. ment Rating Scale developed by Hallinger and Murphy. This scale
However, the present study is limited to the relationship between comprised 12 items, with three subscales, including task
the educational leadership, organizational communication satis- improvement activities, professional development, and education
faction, and team effectiveness of the nursing unit manager at the course management. Each item was rated on a five-point Likert
time when goal achievement and team performance are empha- scale ranging from “1¼ not at all” to “5 ¼ very much agree.” A
sized in nursing units. higher score indicated that nurses had a higher perception of the
This study aimed to identify the effects of organizational educational leadership of their nursing unit managers. This scale
communication satisfaction on the relationship between the was approved for use by the developer of the tool. In a study by
educational leadership of nursing unit managers and team effec- ¼ a .94. Cronbach a
Ahn [5], the reliability of this tool was Cronbach
tiveness to improve understanding of the importance of educa- in this study was .96.
tional leadership and organizational communication and provide
the basic data required to enhance managers' education capability. Team effectiveness
Team effectiveness was measured using a scale originally
developed by Hoegl and Gemuenden [18] and modified by Kim
Methods [19]. The scale comprised 16 items, with three subscales on per-
sonal growth, job effectiveness, and job efficiency. Each item was
Study design rated on a five-point Likert scale ranging from “1 ¼ not at all” to
“5 ¼very much agree.” A high score indicated higher team effec-
This is a cross-sectional descriptive study that aimed to inves- tiveness. The scale was approved for use by the developer. The
tigate the effects of the educational leadership of nursing unit reliability of each subscale was determined in a study by Kim [19]
managers on the team effectiveness of a nursing unit and the and was as follows: Cronbach a¼.89 for personal growth, .90 for
mediating effects of organizational communication satisfaction. job effectiveness, and .80 for job efficacy. Its reliability in a study
by Lee [20] was Cronbach a ¼ .93, and in this study, it was .90.
In
E.H. Choi et al. / Asian Nursing Research 12 (2018) 99e105 101
addition, in this study, the reliability of each subscale ranged from of current work unit, 56.9% were working in general wards,
.75 to .88. including internal medicine and surgery departments, and 43.1%
in special units, including the intensive care unit, emergency room,
Organizational communication satisfaction and operating room. The average clinical career of nurses was
Organizational communication satisfaction was measured using 5.26 years, and the clinical career in the current work unit was
a tool originally developed by Down and Hazen [21] and modified 3.41 years on average.
for nursing organizations by Park [5]. The tool comprised 24 items
for eight subfactors, including organizational perspective, organi- Differences in educational leadership, organizational
zational integration, personal feedback, supervisor communication satisfaction, and team effectiveness according to
communication, subordinate communication, media quality, demographic and job characteristics
horizontal communi- cation, and communication climate. Each
item was rated on a five- point Likert ¼ “1 not at
¼ scale ranging from Table 2 provides the results of the analysis of the differences in
all” to “5 very much agree.” A higher score indicated higher the educational leadership, organizational communication satis-
organizational communi- cation satisfaction among organizational faction, and team effectiveness of nursing unit managers according
members. The tool was approved for use in advance by the to their demographic and job characteristics. The overall mean
developer. The reliability of the tool in a¼study by Park [5] was score of educational leadership, organizational communication
Cronbach a .80. Cronbach a in this study was .91. satisfaction, and team effectiveness were 3.74, 3.14, and 3.52,
respectively.
Data collection The nurses who worked at general units showed statistically
higher score of educational leadership of nursing unit managers
The data collection period was from July 24 to August 25, 2017. (F ¼4.03, p < .001), organizational communication satisfaction
The purpose of the study was explained to the nursing unit man- (F ¼
5.05, p < .001), and team effectiveness (F¼ 2.94, p < .004)
agers who were asked to cooperate in the data collection process. than those who worked at special units. Organizational commu-
Research assistants were trained in advance on data collection nication satisfaction was higher for new nurses with less than 1
methods. The data were collected with only those nurses who year than nurses with more than 1 year of total clinical career
agreed with participating in the study. Nurses completed the (F ¼4.71, p .010).
¼ In addition, organizational communication
questionnaire in a meeting room in units for privacy. The average satisfaction was higher for nurses with less than 1 year than
completion time was approximately 15 minutes. nurses with more than 1 year of current work unit clinical career
(F ¼ 8.98, p < .001).
Data analysis
Table 2 Differences in Team Effectiveness, Organizational Communication Satisfaction, and Educational Leadership According to Sociodemographic and Work-Related Characteristics
(N ¼ 216).
Characteristics Categories Educational leadership Organizational communication satisfaction Team effectiveness
addition, these results are aligned with those of previous studies References
involving nurses [13e15], indicating that as employees were more
1. Lim SH, Park SG. A study on the effects of leadership types of middle manager
satisfied with organizational communication, their organizational
in hospital organization on organizational effectiveness. Korean Jpn J Econ Manag
commitment was higher. Stud. 2014;65:77e103. Korean.
On the other hand, the results for verifying the mediating 2. Kang CM, Chiu HT, Hu YC, Chen HL, Lee PH, Chang WY. Comparisons of self-
effects of organizational communication satisfaction on the ratings on managerial competencies, research capability, time management,
executive power, workload and work stress among nurse administrators.
relationship between the educational leadership of nursing unit J Nurs Manag. 2012;20(7):938e47.
managers and team effectiveness indicated that the effects of https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2834.2012.01383.x
educational lead- ership on the team effectiveness of staff nurses 3. Ahn YS. A study on the effect of the leadership of hospital middle
management on the staff nurse's job satisfaction and turnover intention
differed according to organizational communication satisfaction. [master's thesis]. Seoul: Sejong University; 2010. p. 1e174. Korean.
This implies that the organizational communication satisfaction as 4. Cohen SG, Bailey DE. What makes teams work: group effectiveness research
perceived by nurses mediated the educational leadership of from the shop floor to the executive suite. J Manag. 1997;23(3):239e90.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0149-2063(97)90034-9
nursing unit managers and team effectiveness, thus affecting team
5. Park J-H. Organizational communication satisfaction and job satisfaction for nurses in
effectiveness. In other words, the educational leadership of hospital setting [master's thesis]. Seoul: Ewha Womans University; 2002. p.
nursing unit managers can increase staff nurses organizational 1e84. Korean.
communication satisfaction to enhance team effectiveness. Nursing 6. Mayo AT, Woolley AW. Teamwork in health care: maximizing collective in-
telligence via inclusive collaboration and open communication. AMA J Ethics.
unit managers who demon- strate educational leadership 2016;18(9):933e40.
communicate repeatedely with their members and identify their https://doi.org/10.1001/journalofethics.2016.18.9.stas2-1609
concerns [17]. Also, unit managers work together in teams, 7. Go MJ, Go HN, Gwon MJ, Kim KM, Kim MH, Kim SO, et al. Interpersonal rela-
tionship and communication. Seoul: Gomunsa Press; 2014. p. 2e5.
engaging in the process of performance that promote deep team 8. Chen N. Internal/employee communication and organizational effectiveness: a
learning, leading to higher levels of staff achievement [30]. study of Chinese corporations in transition. J Contemp China. 2008;17(54):
The results of this studyconfirmed that the educational 167e89. https://doi.org/10.1080/10670560701693146
leadership 9. Lee GH. The impact of organizational communication and participative
decision-making on corporate performance. J Commun Sci. 2012;12(3):
of nursing unit managers affects team effectiveness via the organi- 268e300. Korean.
zational communication satisfaction of staff nurses. These findings 10. Chun M-H. Relationship of participants' characteristics and organizational
suggest that the educational leadership of nursing unit managers effectiveness on education program: mediating effect of communication. Korea
Contents Assoc Rev. 2016;16(6):394e403.
can contribute to team effectiveness by activating communications
https://doi.org/10.5392/JKCA.2016.16.06.394. Korean.
with nurses and increasing their satisfaction. If nurses' team 11. Kim SY, Lee GY, Baek SS. Influence of job characteristics and organizational
effectiveness increases, nursing performance will improve communication on the job satisfaction of hospital nurses. Health Soc Sci.
2013;33:135e59. Korean.
accordingly, and the quality of nursing services will be enhanced to
12. Manista SR. A case study of what really matters: examining educational leadership
increase patient satisfaction and ultimately maximize the and student achievement [dissertation]. Los Angeles: University of Southern California;
efficiency of hospitals. Therefore, the educational leadership of 2011. p. 1e166.
nursing unit managers is an important factor affecting 13. Lee NH. The influence of nurses' organizational communication on organiza-
tional commitment and turnover intention [master's thesis]. Chungju: Korea
organizational performance. National University of Transportation; 2013. p. 1e78. Korean.
14. Moon J-H, Kim S-H. The organizational communication's effect on organiza-
tional conflict and organizational commitment in early childhood education
Conclusion institution. J Early Child Educ Educare Welf. 2015;19(4):179e97. Korean.
15. Park Y-N, Choi Y-K, Ryu D-Y. Influence of organizational communication satis-
The present study found that the educational leadership of faction on job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and turnover intention:
focused on the mediated effects of interpersonal stress. J Korean Soc Dent Hyg.
nursing unit managers affected organizational communication
2015;15(5):797e804. https://doi.org/10.13065/jksdh.2015.15.05.797. Korean.
satisfaction among nurses and that organizational communication 16. Shockley-Zalabak P, Ellis K. Perceived organizational effectiveness, job satis-
played a mediating role in increasing team effectiveness. faction, culture, and communication: challenging the traditional view. Com-
Therefore, nursing unit managers can increase team effectiveness mun Res Rep. 2000;17(4):375e86.
https://doi.org/10.1080/08824090009388786
through education and training to enhance their effective 17. Marzano RJ, Waters T, McNulty BA. School leadership that works: from
educational leadership competencies and organizational research to results. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum
communication with nurses. Development; 2005. p. 89.
18. Hoegl M, Gemuenden HG. Teamwork quality and the success of innovative
projects: a theoretical concept and empirical evidence. Organ Sci. 2001;12(4):
Recommendations for future research 435e49. https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.12.4.435.10635
19. Kim BM. Development of scale for teamwork and determinants of teamwork
[master's thesis]. Seoul: Sungkyunkwan University; 2005. p. 1e108. Korean.
First, more studies are needed to verify the effects of 20. Lee S-M. Relationships of nurses' teamwork skills to team effectiveness in nursing units
educational leadership using diverse samples. Second, it is [master's thesis]. Busan: Catholic University of Busan; 2013. p. 1e56. Korean.
21. Down CW, Hazen MD. A factor analytic study of communication satisfaction.
recommended that further studies include various factors that
Int J Bus Commun. 1977;14(3):63e73.
affect educational leadership. Third, programs should be https://doi.org/10.1177/002194367701400306
developed to improve the communication satisfaction of nursing 22. Baron RM, Kenny DA. The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social
psychological research: conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations.
organizations, and studies to verify these effects should be
J Pers Soc Psychol. 1986;51(6):1173e82.
conducted. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.51.6.1173
23. Preacher KJ, Leonardelli GJ. Calculation for the Sobel test: an interactive
calculation tool for mediation tests [Internet]. Preacher KJ; c2010e2017 [cited
Conflicts of interest 2017 Oct 30]. Available from: http://quantpsy.org/sobel/sobel.htm.
24. Giri VN, Santra T. Analysing the association of leadership style, face-to-face
communication, and organizational effectiveness. Manag Lab Stud.
The authors declared no conflicts of interest.
2008;33(1):53e63.
25. Min S-H. The relations among principal's managerial leadership, educational
Acknowledgment leadership, transformational leadership and school organizational effectiveness
[dissertation]. Busan: Dong-A University; 2011. p. 1e154. Korean.
The authors would like to thank the hospital for its sincere
cooperation in the present study and the nurses for their
participa- tion in the survey for the development of the nursing
organization.
E.H. Choi et al. / Asian Nursing Research 12 (2018) 99e105 105
26. Kim S-S. Structural relationship of key factors in knowledge management that satisfaction and organizational commitment. Korean J Occup Health Nurs.
affect the organizational effectiveness of hospitals. J Korea Soc Health Inform 2014;23(2):55e66. https://doi.org/10.5807/kjohn.2014.23.2.55. Korean.
Stat. 2016;41(1):67e77. https://doi.org/10.21032/jhis.2016.41.1.67. Korean. 29. Creasap SA. The effects of mentoring and sustained reflection on educational
27. Korean Hospital Nurses Association. A survey on hospital nursing staffing 2015. leadership practice [dissertation]. Columbus: The Ohio State University; 2003. p.
Business report for Hospital Nurses Association. Seoul: KHNA; 2016. 1e242.
28. Jun SY, Rho HJ, Lee JH. The impact of organizational justice, empowerment on 30. DuFour R. What is a professional learning community? Educ Leadersh.
the nursing task performance of nurses: Focused on the mediating effect of job 2004;61(8):6e11.
Reproduced with permission of copyright owner. Further reproduction
prohibited without permission.