Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lean Thinking in Healthcare: Review of Implementation Results
Lean Thinking in Healthcare: Review of Implementation Results
ISSN 1800-6450
Marija Kovacevic
Milos Jovicic LEAN THINKING IN HEALTHCARE:
Marko Djapan 1 REVIEW OF IMPLEMENTATION RESULTS
Ivana Zivanovic-
Macuzic Abstract: For over decade, automotive industry originated
lean concept has been successfully implemented in healthcare
systems as a management method and philosophy with main
focus on elimination of all types of wastes and looses in all
Article info: tasks and processes so that time, materials, resources and
Received 14.12.2015
medical procedures could be realized as effectively as it is
Accepted 02.02.2016
possible. As main result lean concept implementation ensured
UDC – 332.05 to healthcare organizations to focus on their main core
DOI – 10.18421/IJQR10.01-12 function and dedicate more time and efforts to patients without
additional costs for them or healthcare system. However, lean
implementation in healthcare could be much more difficult
than in standard industrial environment and there are
significant number of examples of lean in healthcare projects
that failed to gain any measurable results and sustainable
benefits from it. This paper presents review of some of the most
successful implementations of lean tools and principles in
healthcare organizations.
Keywords: lean, healthcare, kaizen
219
company, this concept represent Japanese Whelton, 2010). For example value-added
answer to challenges of western activities in healthcare system are
competition, especially from USA, and diagnosis of illness, treatments of injuries,
one of main busters that ensured performing of laboratory analysis. Related
economical growth of Japan after WWII. to previous, preparation activities for
Impressed by intensive growth of Japanese treatments and diagnosis procedures could
industry in relatively short period, be assumed as non-value added but
scientists from western countries perform necessary as they are not directly oriented
detailed studies in late 80's which lead to to patient but are mandatory in scope of
introduction of lean concept (known in previously mentioned, value-added
Japan as Toyota Production System) activities.
outside of Japan (Liker, 2004). Finally significant number of non-value
Today lean concept is widely accepted and added activities examples could be
implemented set of tools, methods and identified in each healthcare subject, like
techniques in numerous companies around all types of waiting, performing of
the world (Bortolotti et al., 2015). In its unnecessary jobs, delays etc. Inspired by
fundament lean represents philosophical Toyota "seven deadly wastes" (plus
approach towards management, focused on additional one defined by Liker, 2004)
identification and elimination of all types eight main types of wastes in healthcare
of wastes and loses and continuous could be identified, often summarized with
improvement (Womack et al., 2003). the acronym D.O.W.N.T.I.M.E (Graban,
Results of successfully introduced lean 2012):
concept could be evaluated by increased Defect (performing of wrong
value in production and business procedure),
processes, redesigned and prepared to Overproduction (unnecessary
offer customers exactly what they want in treatments, more than needed or
parallel with increased quality, improved before its needed),
safety, reduction of delays and failures. Waiting (patient or staff waiting's
From its purely industrial origin lean for various reasons),
concept found its way to other areas and No use of staff (underutilizing
sectors. Healthcare, as important and medical staff knowledge, skills
complex sector in every society, also and talents),
recognized importance and benefits of lean Transportation (unnecessary
implementation and today represent one of movement of patient, equipment,
most promising and prospective areas for staff),
further expansion in number of involved Inventory (excess medication,
hospitals and healthcare sectors from one unnecessary medical material and
side and variety of used tools, methods and equipment),
techniques from other (Mazzocato et al., Motion (employee walks to
2010). distant areas to get supply), and
For each healthcare subject waste could be Extra processing (generate
identified as anything that does not add duplicate documents, repetition of
value to healthcare service from the patient procedures, examinations, or
point of view, so it is extremely important performing medical procedures
to identify and recognize all activities that by staff with higher qualification
are value-added, than non-value added but than it is needed, etc).
necessary activities, and finally purely
non-value-added activities (Aherne and
221
proposals and implementation, transfer of VSM is one of most frequently used Lean
improvement implementation analysis and tools in healthcare organizations for
testing to originators of idea, respect to all analysis of current state or identifying
ideas no matter of size and impact areas of potential problems and
(Graban, 2012). development of a future state or creates
In initial phases of Lean implementation, solutions design for identified problems.
slow, continuous changing/improvement In its healthcare use, VSM is manly the
processes could sometimes be not effective diagrammatical representation of the
enough, when modification of kaizen patient’s journey through the system, and
approach is often used. So called Kaizen its ensure identifications of each individual
blitz, or Rapid Improvement Event (RIE), step in treatment and other medical
is a focused, fast performing and procedures, their value, duration,
significant changes initiating activity used interrelationship, process failures, staff-
for general modification and redesign of staff and staff-patient relationships, etc.
observed processes and identified (Sampalli et al., 2015). VSM has been
problems. The basic concept is to identify proofed as successful tool for initiating of
and quickly remove waste (Liker and healthcare system changes in order to
Meier, 2006). In practice a Rapid provide insight into system improvement
Improvement Event is generally completed opportunities and bring optimal level of all
in few days (1 to 5) and involves key basic three requirements for each
process participants focusing on solving a healthcare process and activity – price,
narrowly scoped process improvement quality and on-time delivery. VSM have
opportunity. also been widely used in reducing wait
times in emergency services (Eller, 2009).
Value-stream Mapping (VSM)
Visual Management
In its origin value-stream mapping (VSM)
is graphical, analytical tool that allow Coming from the fact that humans are
simple representation of flow for selected intensively visual beings and that majority
part of process, from its start (material of information's that we received and
purchase from supplier) to finish (final accept from environment comes through
product) (Learning to see). VSM show sense of seeing, Lean concept put
times and resources used in each step of significant importance on implementation
process, waiting's between steps, of visual management tools and techniques
inventories size, information and materials as a way for establishment of fully visual
flow, workforce performance in terms of workplace. The aim of Visual
cycle time per product (activity) and Management (VM) is to create a work
change-over time when switching between environment that is self-explaining, self-
products (activities). It is method that ordering, self-regulating and self-
facilitates the Defined VSM for one improving, where what is suppose to
process, showing present "as is" state, happen does, on time, every time because
represent base for analysis of week steps, of visual solutions (Galsworth, 2013). VM
bottle-necks, excessive inventories, is a concept of various visual tools (signs,
missing resources, misbalance in process colors, markings, info boards, lights, etc)
steps and definition of corrective actions on hospital premises to organize area,
for process redesign and reorganization for monitor work, appliances and equipment
achieving of necessary improvements and in use. Visual management reinforces
better process effectiveness. patients and employees safety because of
self-restraint feature.
The Virginia Mason Medical Center developed system called Virginia Mason
(VMMC), Seattle, USA which includes Production System (VMPS) (Furman and
Virginia Mason Hospital and a network of Caplan, 2007). This integral system was
primary and specialty care clinics initiate in based on total people involvement (TPI)
2002., program for general lean principle, understanding that medical and
implementation through introduction of self administrative staff are fully aware on
223
existing problems and have the best solutions Reduced inventory costs by $2
for them. VMMC uses several lean million through supply chain
improvement tools and techniques, such as expense reduction and
Rapid Improvement Events (RIE's) focused standardization efforts.
on rapid changes, Continuous improvement - Analyzing lean as system of thinking and
Kaizen events focused on incremental staff learning platform, rather than just set of
changes, 3P (Production, Preparation, tools, in paper (Ballé and Régnier, 2007)
Process) as a tool for complete process authors reported use of lean in a French Nord
redesign. During first eight years more than 92 hospital in project for reduction of a
850 continuous improvement activities were number of complex nursing issues, such as
performed involving staff, patients and medication distribution errors, catheter
guests infections, hospital-acquired infections,
Presented results (Furman and Caplan, 2007) bedsores, through implementation of 5S,
show that VMPS implementation ensured to standardized work, A3, etc. Over the first
VMMC respectable position in the top 1% of two years, the rates of such incidents per
all hospitals in the U.S. in terms of both patient were reduced by 45 percent.
quality of patient care and system efficiency, Lean inspired methods were used for
with numerous examples of achieved decrease hospital-wide central line
improvements: associated bacteraemia (CLAB) on the
Decreased the number of hours intensive care unit (ICU) at Allegheny
when the Emergency Department General Hospital, Pittsburgh, USA (Shannon
was closed and unable to receive et al., 2006). As CLABs are recognized, not
new patients by more than 90 as an inevitable product of complex ICU
percent. care, but the result of highly variable and
Reduced lab test results reporting therefore unreliable care delivery, two ICU's,
time to the patient by more than in this hospital, redefined the processes of
85%. care through redesign of system in order to
Increasing of patient safety through deliver reliable outputs with minimal
introduction of the Patient Safety variations that showed to be simulative
Alert system followed by reduced factor for infection spreading.
premiums for professional liability Based on lean principles and root cause
insurance by 56%. analyses, Perfecting Patient Care were
Nurse walking distance was established and applied to central line
reduced in the hospital by 750 miles placement and maintenance empowered the
per day, freeing up more than 250 workers to implement countermeasures
hours of staff time spent walking designed to eliminate the defects in the
for direct patient care. processes.
Increased productivity by 93% in a Processes redesign were prepared and
few selected model areas by implemented within just 90 days and within
introduction of kitting principle a first year CLABs decreased from 49 to 6
(creating kits containing frequently (10.5 to 1.2 infections per 1,000 line-days),
needed supplies). and mortalities from 19 to 1 (51% to 16%),
Using space more efficiently despite an increase in the use of central lines
ensures $11 million savings in and number of line-days. These results were
capital investment and freed an shown to be sustainable during prolonged
estimated 25,000 square feet of period of time.
space using better space designs.
Improving of blood draw and specimen
collection process for the Emergency
225
performance and efficiency (Kruskal et al., Performed project comes from fact that
2012). The goal of this implementation was patients who have delayed access to relevant
primarily to improve flow of patients with care, particularly those with complex
uninterrupted equipment function, but lean conditions (chronic illness and
transformation of work philosophy and multimorbidities) in further period become
workplace culture was done. Several lean frequent and demanding users of various
tools were used like Value stream mapping medical standard and emergency care (from
for visualizing the current state of a process primary care, community care, and acute
and identifying activities that add no value, care to professionals and specialists). This
root cause analysis, visual management imply main goal for this action to provide
techniques and boards, balanced scorecard timely and relevant access to care for
etc. population with high needs with additional
Improvements of patient workflow and target to remove waiting times for complex
significant time reductions in performing of and chronic illness care.
standard medical procedures are directly Integrated Chronic Care Service (ICCS) in
connected with significant financial savings. this hospital have near 10,000 patient visits
The pediatric multidisciplinary reconstru- each year. As a result of performed activities
ctive pelvic medicine clinic of Children`s waiting times for new patients have
hospital, Seattle, USA, (consisted of significantly reduced from approximately 13
pediatric specialists in urology, general months in 2012 to 2 months in 2014 with
surgery, gynecology, and gastroenterology) trend which imply that there will be no wait
has utilized lean methods to enhance times for new patients in 2015 to receive
operational efficiency and improve value for ICCS intervention. Remaining wait times
patients (Merguerian et al., 2015). was reduced by about 40% (from 48 to 29
Initial MD (medical doctor) preparation time weeks). Discharge rates for ICCS have
reduction from 8 min/patient to 6 improved significantly>10% since
min/patient, while MA (medical assistant) introduction of process changes, also referral
preparation time was increased from 9.5 rates increased by 20% since 2013 (Sampalli
min/patient to 20 min/patient. This time et al., 2015).
redistribution resulted in cost reduction of One of the first studies about implementation
41%, ($366 per patient). of lean healthcare methods in hospitals from
Continued improvements further reduced the countries outside of West Europe or USA
MA preparation time to 14 min and the MD was the study of Costa et al. (2015), with
preparation time to 5 min with a further cost presentation of results of lean
reduction to $194/patient (69%). Number of implementation in two Brazilian hospitals.
appointments per clinic was increased (Sterile services department and pharmacy -
without affecting quality as the valuable time hospital A and chemotherapy, surgery and
spent with each patient was not reduced. radiotherapy - hospital B). The lean system
was implemented trough two phases.
Value stream mapping (VSM) prove itself to
be very useful and thus frequently Instead of standard PDCA cycle, authors
implemented tool in lean healthcare for used DMAIC cycle (Define - Measure -
process analysis in present state, various Analyze - Improve - Control), originally
wastes and loses identification and definition derived from Six Sigma approach. In order
of improved process structure. VSM were to define the problems VSM was created and
used as core tool in program for wait time for its solving a Kaizen Event was
reduction in hospital in New Scotia, Halifax, conducted, including different tools as 5S,
Canada (Sampalli et al., 2015). Visual management and Kanban board for
the proper arrangement of materials and
References:
Aherne, J. & Whelton, J. (2010). Applying Lean in Healthcare: A Collection of International
Case Studies. Taylor & Francis Group.
Amasaka, K. (2015).Constructing A New Japanese Development Design Model - NJ-DDM -
Intellectual Evolution of an Automobile Product Design. TEM Journal, 4(4), 336-345.
Ballé, M. & Régnier. A. (2007). Lean as a learning system in a hospital ward. Leadership in
health services. 20(4), 33-41.
Bortolotti, T., Boscari, S. & Danese, P. (2015). Successful lean implementation: organizational
culture and soft lean practices. International Journal of Production Economics, 160, 182-201
Chan, H., Lo, S., Lee, L. , Lo, W., Yu, W., Wu, Y. , Ho, S., Yeung, R. & Chan, J. (2014). Lean
techniques for the improvement of patients' flow in emergency department. World Journal of
Emergency Medicine, 5(1), 24-8.
Costa, L.B., Filho, M.G., Rentes, A.F., Bertani, T.M. & Mardegan, R. (2015). Lean healthcare
in developing countries: evidence from Brazilian hospitals. International Journal of Health
Planning and Management, doi: 10.1002/hpm.2331. [Epub ahead of print]
Eller, AJ. (2009). Rapid assessment and disposition: applying LEAN in the emergency
department. Journal for Healthcare Quality, 31, 17–22.
Esain, A., Williams, S., & Massey, L. (2008). Combining planned and emergent change in a
healthcare lean transformation. Public Money and Management, 28, 21-6.
Fillingham, D. (2007). Can lean save lives? Leadership in health services, 20(4), 231-241
Furman, C. & Caplan, R. (2007). Applying the Toyota Production System: using a patient
safety alert system to reduce error. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety,
33(7), 376-386.
227
Galsworth, G.D. (2013). Visual Workplace/Visual Thinking: Creating Enterprise Excellence
through the Technologies of the Visual Workplace. Visual-Lean Enterprise Press.
Graban, M. (2012). Lean Hospitals: Improving Quality, Patient Safety and Employee
Engagement, CRC Press.
Iannettoni, M.D., Lynch, W.R., Parekh, K.R. & McLaughlin, K.A. (2011). Kaizen method for
esophagectomy patients: improved quality control, outcomes, and decreased costs. The
Annals of Thoracic Surgery, 91(4), 1011-1017.
Ikumaa, L.H. & Nahmens, I. (2014). Making safety an integral part of 5S in Healthcare. Work,
47, 243–251.
Jacobson, G.H., McCoin, N.S., Lescallette, R., Russ, S. & Slovis, C.M. (2009). Kaizen: a
method of process improvement in the emergency department. Academic emergency
medicine, 16(12), 1341-1349.
Kruskal, J.B, Reedy, A., Rosen, M.P. & Boiselle, P.M. (2012). Lean Approach to Improving
Performance and Efficiency in a Radiology Department. RadioGraphics, 32, 573-587.
Liker, J.K. & Meier, D. (2006). The Toyota Way Fieldbook. McGraw-Hill.
Liker, J.K. (2004). The Toyota Way: 14 Management Principles from the World's Greatest
Manufacturer. McGraw-Hill.
Merguerian, P.A., Grady, R., Waldhausen, J., Libby, A., Murphy, W., Melzer L. & Avansino,
J. (2015). Optimizing value utilizing Toyota Kata methodology in a multidisciplinary clinic.
Journal of Pediatric Urology, 11(4), 228e1-228e6.
Radnor, Z.J., Holweg, M. & Waring, J. (2012). Lean in healthcare: The unfilled promise?
Social Science & Medicine, 74(3), 364–371.
Sampalli, T., Desy, M., Dhir, M., Edwards, L., Dickson, R. & Blackmore, G. (2015).
Improving Wait Times to Care for Individuals with Multimorbidities and Complex
Conditions Using Value Stream Mapping. International Journal of Health Policy and
Management, 4(7), 459–466.
Sanders, J.H. & Karr, T. (2015). Improving ED specimen TAT using Lean Six Sigma.
International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance, 28(5), 428-40.
Shah, C.J., Sullivan, J.R., Gonyo, M.B, Wadhwa, A. & DuBois, M.S. (2013). Using Lean
Principles to Improve Screening Mammography Workflow. Radio Graphics, 33, 1505-1517.
Shannon, R.P., Frndak, D., Grunden, N., Lloyd, J.C., Herbert, C., Patel, B., Cummins, D.,
Shannon, A.H., O'Neill, P.H. & Spear SJ. (2006). Using real-time problem solving to
eliminate central line infections. The Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient
Safety, 32(9), 479-87.
Smith, G., Poteat-Godwin, A., Harrison, L.M. & Randolph G.D. (2012). Applying Lean
Principles and Kaizen Rapid Improvement Events in Public Health Practice. Journal of
Public Health Management and Practice, 18(1), 52-54.
White, B.A., Baron, J.M., Dighe, A.S., Camargo, C.A. Jr & Brown, D.F. (2015). Applying
Lean methodologies reduces ED laboratory turnaround times. American Journal of
Emergency Medicine, 33(11): 1572-1576.
Womack, J.P., James, P. & Daniel T. J. (2003). Lean Thinking. Free Press.
Young, F.Y.F. (2014). The Use of 5S in Healthcare Services: a Literature Review.
International Journal of Business and Social Science, 5(1), 240-248.
Ivana Zivanovic-
Macuzic
University of Kragujevac,
Faculty of Medical Sciences
Serbia
ivanaanatom@yahoo.com
229
230 M. Kovacevic, M. Jovicic, M. Djapan, I. Zivanovic-Macuzic