4. Analyse and synthesise the role of ethical conformance, corporate govemance &
responsibility in providing ethical leadership
5. Analyse and evaluate the common and specific ethical issues for different managerial
functions in business
6. Evaluate the significance of different ideologies for ethical systemic analysis
7. Evaluate and apply ethical reasoning to international business dilemmas
8. Analyse an ethical dilemma
9. Synthesise a number of viewpoints and evaluate their relative significance
10. Apply ethical reasoning to make a defensible decision
Assignment task
The assignment task is in two parts, Part A and Part B. You should attempt
BOTH parts. Part A should be submitted to the Part A drop box on moodle,
Part B to the part B drop box. NOTE the deadline for both Parts is the same
(11 December 2019 at 1300 GMT). Your answers should be written in the form
of an essay.
Part A The graduate trainee’s dilemma
It is late August 2020. Sarah is a graduate trainee in a multi- national food retailer (BB's),
She joined the firm last year and is coming to the end of the training programme. She works
in a large team, and has good relations with everyone else on the team. She hopes to be
taken on as a permanent employee at the end of her training programme, however nat all
graduate trainees will be taken on because BB's has been negatively affected by the
Uncertainty surrounding Brexit. Unfortunately all the other graduate trainees also want to
stay with BB's too
Sarah is aware of climate change protests, including Extinction Rebellion, and while she is
not a member of that group, she strongly shares their concerns about climate change. From
the modules that she took at Oxford Brookes University as part of her business degree, she
knows that climate change is likely to have a significant impact nat only an poorer countries,
but also on supply chains and food production globally. There is now a call from climate
change activists for members of the public, including school children and workers, to join a
second global walk out for 1 hour at midday on 20 September 2020
Saran thinks that it is very important that she joins the strike and wants to encourage all her
colleagues to join it too. University friends who think the same way as she does, and are
employed in ather MNC, are emailing their colleagues, putting messages on facebook and
posters in staff kitchens to encourage a walk aut.
Saran is aware that her new line manager, Tony, is not sympathetic and has made very
negative comments about Greta Thunberg, school strikes and climate change concerns in
general
1As far as Sarah knows, colleagues in BB's did not take part in last year's walkout (she
joined the firm in October 2019), nor do they seem particularly concerned about climate
change. Climate change is not mentioned at all in BB's CSR reporting or corporate strategy
She is also worried about Tony's attitude, especially since he will have a say in whether she
is taken on permanently by BB's. The other graduate trainees do not seem to share her
cancems about climate change.
What action should Sarah take about the strike?
Note: Your answer should demonstrate a capacity for ethical reasoning and MUST:
1. Use the seven step ethical decision making framework that is used in class and
provided on moodle;
And
2. Discuss and apply the ethical theories of utilitarianism AND of Immanuel Kant in
using the seven step method.
The word limit for this essay is 2000 words and the essay is worth 75% of the module
marks.
Below are links to stories/events which provide some real life background to this type of
scenario. They should help you understand some of the ethical issues raised. You are
strongly advised to use these links as a starting point to research the scenario presented
along with the ethical issues that it raises in more depth before writing your assignment. You
should also undertake further reading on ethical theories and ideas, using the module
readings and your own research. Whatever sources are used MUST be cited
Remember that this is an essay about business ethics and not business strategy or legal
liability. You are being asked ta develop an ethical argument about what the right thing to do
would be in the scenario provided. Make sure you read the assessment criteria
Links
https: /www fern org.uk/research-library/climate-change-has-likely-already-affected-food-
production
https: /www torn org uk/research-library/arabica-coffee-production-risk-due-changing-climate
hitps:/globaiclimatestrike net/ [this link relates to the 2019 climate strike]
https: /www thequardian.com/technology/2019/sep/1 Ojjeff-bez0s-amazon-climate-strike-aec|
httos:/www.campaigncc.org/climate strike 20 september [this link relates to the 2019
climate strike]
The scenario in this assessment has been developed for educational purposes only. Any
similarity to situations or to persons living or dead is entirely coincidental.
12