Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spontaneous Cholecystopleural - Fistula Leading
Spontaneous Cholecystopleural - Fistula Leading
research- article2019
JOR0010.1177/2055116919830206Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery Open ReportsVanDevent er and Cuq
Case Report
Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery Open
Abstract
Case summary A 13-year-old spayed female domestic shorthair cat presented with pleural effusion and
suspected triaditis. Intake vitals and leukocytosis were consistent with a diagnosis of systemic inflammatory
response syndrome. Biochemical analysis confirmed a pleural fluid-to-serum bile ratio consistent with a diagnosis
of biliothorax. Abdominal ultrasound failed to identify a definitive gall bladder but noted a hypoechoic tubular
structure ventral to the liver and contacting the diaphragm. Thoracic ultrasound identified a hyperechoic structure
contacting the diaphragm at the same location. Thoracoabdominal CT scan identified a fluid-dense tubular
structure extending from ventral to the liver, through a diaphragmatic defect and directly communicating with the
pleural space, suspected to be an abnormal gall bladder. The cat was humanely euthanized, and post-mortem
analysis confirmed a cholecystopleural fistula arising from the gall bladder with multifocal abscesses, mixed
inflammatory hepatic infiltrates and small-cell gastrointestinal lymphoma. Culture of the abscess isolated
Parabacteroides merdae, meeting the reported feline criteria for sepsis.
Relevance and novel information To our knowledge, spontaneous cholecystopleural fistula formation leading to
biliothorax and sepsis has not been previously reported in the cat. This case highlights a novel sequela of gall
bladder disease in this species, and biliothorax should be a differential diagnosis for pleural effusion in cats with
evidence of cholecystitis or triaditis.
Keywords: Biliothorax; cholecystopleural fistula; triaditis; sepsis; systemic inflammatory response syndrome; SIRS
RI 0–5.13 μmol/l) and an elevated feline pancreas-specific University of Guelph, Guelph, ON, Canada
lipase (Spec fPL-Feline test; IDEXX Laboratories) (15.0
Corresponding author:
μg/l; RI 0–3.5 μg/l). A complete blood count (CBC) was Gretchen M VanDeventer DVM, Aspen Meadow Veterinary
unremarkable. The cat was treated as an outpatient with Specialists, 104 South Main Street, Longmont, CO 80501,
amoxicillin–clavulanic USA Email: gmv32@cornell.edu
Creative Commons Non Commercial CC BY-NC: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License (http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits non-commercial
use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and
Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
2 Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery Open Reports
Figure 1 Right lateral thoracic radiograph depicting normal Figure 3 Abdominal ultrasound image depicting tubular structure
thorax at initial presentation to the primary veterinarian ventral to and, questionably, arising from the right liver
despite acute dyspnea
irritation. An incidental thyroid adenoma and small-cell the pancreatitis and cholangiohepatitis. Alternatively, an
intestinal lymphoma were also identified. A sample of the episode of acute pancreatitis may have developed in the face
abscess exudate was submitted for bacterial culture, which of small-cell gastrointestinal lymphoma with subse-quent
isolated Parabacteroides merdae. cholangiohepatitis. While triaditis is well described,
progression to a cholecystopleural fistula is not well
Discussion documented.
Biliothorax, also termed bilothorax or bile pleuritis, is a rare None of the previously reported cases of biliothorax in
condition in which bile accumulates within the pleural space. veterinary patients isolated a positive bacterial cul-ture.
Although gross appearance of the pleural effusion can raise Although ante-mortem cytological evaluation of the pleural
suspicion for this condition, definitive diagnosis is based on a fluid identified suppurative but not septic inflammation, post-
ratio of the pleural fluid-to-serum bilirubin concentration that mortem bacterial culture of the abscess isolated P merdae.
is >1.2,3 In the present case, the fluid was a thick yellow–
orange color, and the ratio was >28 (pleural fluid bilirubin: The Parabacteroides species were recently divided from
286 μmol/l; peripheral blood bilirubin: 10 μmol/l), the Bacteroides species,15 and these groups consti-tute the
confirming the diagnosis of biliothorax. most common anaerobic bacteria isolated from hepatic and
biliary bacterial cultures in cats, dogs and humans, 16–18 and
Isolated case reports of biliothorax have previously been are also among the most common bac-teria isolated from
described in five dogs and three cats, all of which were due feline pyothorax.19 Although the Parabacteroides species
to traumatic or iatrogenic injuries. 4–11 The most commonly have not been identified as spe-cific pathogens in cats, the
reported cause for this condition has been diaphragmatic and closely related Bacteroides spe-cies have been implicated in a
biliary tree laceration secondary to gunshot wounds, 4–7 while variety of health conditions in humans, including septic
one cat developed the condi-tion after bite wounds led to peritonitis, meningitis and endocarditis, and have evolved
diaphragmatic injury and gall bladder herniation. 8 A cat was strategies for bile toler-ance.20 Although P merdae was
also reported to develop iatrogenic biliothorax as a identified on culture of the abscess, it is unknown whether it
complication of a thoracostomy tube placement. 9 Two further was acting as a pathogen alone or in combination with
dogs devel-oped biliothorax in the absence of overt another bacterial species that was inhibited or killed by the
diaphragmatic injury, one after vehicular trauma led to prior antibiotic therapy, or alternatively was an incidental
rupture of the extrahepatic biliary tract, 10 and the other after a colonizer, with the abscess formed by a separate species that
chole-cystectomy surgery.11 Of these cases, concurrent bile was inhibited or killed by the antibiotics.
peritonitis was identified in four cases secondary to direct
trauma to the biliary tree.4,6,8,10 None of these cases, however, It has been well established in veterinary species that
involved a biliothorax associated with devel-opment of a septic bile peritonitis has a significantly higher mortality rate
spontaneous cholecystopleural fistula sec-ondary to than sterile bile peritonitis, with 27% and 100% sur-vival,
cholecystitis. respectively.21 Given the rarity of the condition, no similar
studies are available comparing septic biliotho-rax and
Cholecystitis is a relatively common condition in cats, and aseptic biliothorax in animals; however, it is rea-sonable to
has been extensively reviewed.12,13 Although chole-cystitis anticipate a similar pattern.
can occur as a unique pathology, in this case the patient was Diagnosis of sepsis involves meeting the criteria for SIRS
suspected based on serum biochemistry and post-mortem with concurrent positive bacterial infection based on
histopathologic changes to have developed triaditis: cytologic, histologic, microbial or serologic tests. 1 The
concurrent inflammation of the pancreas, liver and small patient in this case met the criteria for SIRS based on leuko-
intestine. Triaditis can develop from primary pancreatitis cytosis and on tachycardia and tachypnea that did not respond
leading to intestinal inflammation and reac-tive to early fluid resuscitation, and also fulfilled the criteria for
cholangiohepatitis due to the close proximity of the common sepsis based on the positive bacterial culture obtained from
bile duct and pancreas in the duodenum, or from chronic the post-mortem abscess sample. Sepsis has been associated
gastrointestinal inflammation leading to reactive pancreatitis with substantial morbidity to various organ systems, as well
and cholangiohepatitis. 14 Regardless of the inciting cause, as mortality rates ranging from 20–79% in cats. 1,22–25
inflammation in the region of the pancreatic and common Hypochloremia, which was docu-mented in this case, has
bile ducts can predispose ani-mals to bacterial infection of been associated with a negative prognosis in cats with
the biliary tree via both ret-rograde migration of jejunal sepsis.26 Cats also appear uniquely sensitive to pulmonary
bacteria and via translocation from hepato-biliary-enteric damage secondary to SIRS and sepsis compared with dogs, as
circulation.12 the lungs are a major source of bacterial clearance and
In this case chronic intestinal inflammation secondary to inflammatory reaction in this species.27,28 The patient in this
small-cell lymphoma was identified on post-mortem report did have suspicion for pulmonary thromboemboli on
examination, which may have been an inciting cause for CT scan, which is a
VanDeventer and Cuq 5
reported complication of SIRS and sepsis and corroborates Funding The authors received no financial support for the
our suspicion of sepsis in this case.1 This likely contributed to research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
the instability exhibited under general anesthesia, and was
ORCID iD Gretchen M VanDeventer https://orcid.org/ 0000-
considered a poor prognostic indicator.
0002-2681-055X
Biliothorax has also been described uncommonly in
human medicine, generally secondary to the develop-ment of References
a biliopleural fistula, although it has also been rarely reported 1 Brady CA, Otto CM, Winkle TJ, et al. Severe sepsis in cats: 29
as a complication of bile peritonitis in the face of an intact cases (1986–1998). J Am Vet Med Assoc 2000; 217: 531–535.
diaphragm.2,3 Causes for fistula formation include iatrogenic
injury secondary to diag-nostic and therapeutic 2 Strange C, Allen ML, Freedland PN, et al. Biliopleural fis-tula
interventions,29,30 thoracoab-dominal trauma,31 parasitic liver as a complication of percutaneous biliary drainage: experimental
disease,32–34 and suppurative and non-suppurative biliary tract evidence for pleural inflammation. Am Rev Respirat Dis 1988;
obstruc-tions.2,35–37 Spontaneous cholecystopleural fistulae 137: 959–961.
most commonly develop in human patients due to 3 Dosik MH. Bile pleuritis: another complication of percu-
taneous liver biopsy. Am J Digest Dis 1975; 20: 91–93.
suppurative biliary tract obstruction or chronic chole-cystitis
4 Bellenger CR, Trim C and Summer-Smith G. Bile pleuritis in a
secondary to gallstones.35,36,38 Successful man-agement has dog. J Small Anim Pract 1975; 16: 575–577.
been reported following prompt medical and surgical 5 Davis KM and Spaulding KA. Imaging diagnosis: biliopleural
therapy,35,39 but prognosis is poor if diag-nosis and treatment fistula in a dog. Vet Radiol Ultrasound 2004;
are delayed, as biliothorax can lead to severe manifestations 45: 70–72.
of a systemic inflamma-tory response and death.38,39 6 Murgia D. A case of combined bilothorax and bile peri-tonitis
secondary to gunshot wounds in a cat. J Feline Med and Surg
2013; 15: 513–516.
The prognosis for biliothorax in veterinary patients has 7 Bartolini F, Didier M, Ludica B, et al. What is your diagno-sis?
been reported to be excellent, with all eight previ-ously Pleural effusion in a dog with a gunshot wound. Vet Clin Pathol
2015; 44: 333–334.
described cases surviving to discharge, although case
8 Mullins RA, Barandun MA, Gallagher B, et al. Non-iatrogenic
selection bias may have influenced this reported outcome.
traumatic isolated bilothorax in a cat. JFMS Open Rep 2017; 3: 1–
Two of these cases were managed with medi-cal therapy 6.
alone,10,11 while six underwent surgical inter-vention. 4–9 It is 9 Wustefeld-Janssens BG, Loureiro JF, Dukes-McEwan J, et al.
ultimately unknown whether medical or surgical therapy Biliothorax in a Siamese cat. J Feline Med Surg 2011;
would have been successful in the pre-sent case; however, 13: 984–987.
multiple factors contributed to a potentially worse prognosis 10 Barnhart MD and Rasmussen LM. Pleural effusion as a
than that noted in previous cases, including the development complication of extrahepatic biliary tract rupture in a dog. J Am
of sepsis and associ-ated complications. Prolonged empiric Anim Hosp Assoc 1996; 32: 409–412.
therapy and delayed diagnosis of the gall bladder abscess that 11 Guillaumin J, Chanoit G, Decosne-Junot C, et al. Bilotho-rax
following cholecystectomy in a dog. J Small Anim Pract 2006; 47:
led to the cholecystopleural fistula and biliothorax likely also
733–736.
contributed to the patient’s worse prognosis.
12 Center SA. Disease of the gallbladder and biliary tree. Vet
Clin Small Anim 2009; 39: 543–598.
13 Neer TM. A review of disorders of the gallbladder and
Conclusions extrahepatic biliary tract in the dog and cat. J Vet Intern Med
This case highlights a novel sequela of gall bladder disease in 1992; 3: 186–192.
the cat: biliothorax secondary to a spontane-ous 14 Simpson KW. Pancreatitis and triaditis in cats: causes and
treatment. J Small Anim Pract 2015; 56: 40–49.
cholecystopleural fistula. Given the importance of early
15 Sakamoto M and Benno Y. Reclassification of Bacteroides
diagnosis and intervention in these cases, bilio-thorax should
distasonis, Bacteroides goldsteinii and Bacteroides mer-dae as
be a differential diagnosis for develop-ment of pleural Parabacteroides distasonis gen. Nov., comb. Nov., Parabacteroides
effusion in patients with evidence of cholecystitis or triaditis. goldsteinii comb. Nov. and Parabacte-roides merdae comb. nov.
Delayed intervention may increase the risk of development of Int J Syst Evol Microbiol 2006; 56: 1599–1605.
SIRS or sepsis, which may negatively affect the prognosis. 16 Wagner KA, Hartmann FA and Trepanier LA. Bacterial culture
Although treatment was not pursued in this case, results from liver, gallbladder, or bile in 248 dogs and cats
extrapolation from human medicine suggests that surgical evaluated for hepatobiliary disease: 1998–2003. J Vet Intern Med
debride-ment, cholecystectomy and closure of the defect 2007; 21: 417–424.
would be indicated. 17 Sheen-Chen S, Chen W, Eng H, et al. Bacteriology and
antimicrobial choice in hepatolithiasis. Am J Infect Control 2000;
28: 298–301.
18 Tabata M and Nakayama F. Bacteriology of hepatolithia-sis.
Conflict of interest The authors declared no potential
Prog Clin Biol Res 1984; 152: 163–174.
conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or
publication of this article.
6 Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery Open Reports
19 Love DN, Jones RF, Bailey M, et al. Isolation and charac- 30 Neff CC, Müller PR and Ferrucci JT. Serious complications
terisation of bacteria from pyothorax (empyaemia) in cats. Vet following transgression of the pleural space in drainage
Microbiol 1982; 7: 455–461. procedures. Radiology 1984; 152: 335–341.
20 Wexler HM. Bacteroides: the good, the bad, and the nitty- 31 Oparah SS and Mandal AK. Traumatic thoracobiliary
gritty. Clin Microbiol Rev 2007; 20: 593–621. (pleurobiliary and bronchobiliary) fistulas: clinical and review
21 Ludwig LL, McLoughlin MA, Graves TK, et al. Surgical study. J Trauma 1978; 18: 539–544.
treatment of bile peritonitis in 24 dogs and 2 cats: a retro- 32 Amir-Jahed AK, Sadreih M and Farpour A. Thoracobilia: a
spective study. Vet Surg 1997; 26: 90–98. surgical complication of hepatic echinococcosis and amebiasis.
22 Sergeeff J, Armstrong PJ and Bunch SE. Hepatic abscesses in cats: Ann Thorac Surg 1972; 14: 198–205.
14 cases (1985–2002). J Vet Intern Med 2004; 18: 295–300. 33 Roy DC, Ravindran P and Padmanabham R. Bronchobili-ary
23 Costello M, Drobatz K and Aronson L. Underlying cause, fistula secondary to amebic liver abscess. Chest 1972; 62: 523–
pathophysiologic abnormalities, and response to treat-ment in 524.
cats with septic peritonitis: 51 cases (1990–2001). J Am Vet Med 34 Stables GI, Irving HC, Simmons AV, et al. Case report:
Assoc 2004; 225: 897–902. hepatobronchial fistula complicating amoebiasis, treated by
24 Waddell L, Brady C and Drobatz K. Risk factors, prognos-tic percutaneous catheter drainage. Clin Radiol 1991; 44: 354–356.
indicators, and outcome of pyothorax in cats: 80 cases (1986– 35 Delco F, Domenighetti G, Kauzlaric D, et al. Spontaneous
1999). J Am Vet Med Assoc 2002; 221: 819–824. biliothorax (thoracobilia) following cholecystopleural fistula
25 Barrs V, Allan G, Beatty J, et al. Feline pyothorax: a retro- presenting as an acute respiratory insufficiency: successful
spective study of 27 cases in Australia. J Feline Med Surg 2005; 7: removal of gallstones from the pleural space. Chest 1994; 106:
211–222. 961–963.
26 DeClue EA, Delgado C, Chang C, et al. Clinical and immu- 36 Gaur P and Webb ALB. Cholecystopleural fistula in a 71-
nologic assessment of sepsis and the systemic inflamma-tory year-old man with symptoms of pneumonia and pleu-ral
response syndrome in cats. J Am Vet Med Assoc 2011; 238: 890– effusion. Hosp Physician 2009; 5: 7–10.
897. 37 Boyd DP. Bronchobiliary an bronchopleural fistulas. Ann
27 Kuida J, Gilbert RP, Hinshaw LB, et al. Species differences in Thorac Surg 1977; 24: 481–487.
effect of gram negative endotoxin on circulation. Am J Physiol 38 Cunningham LW, Grobman M, Paz HL, et al. Cholecys-
1961; 200: 1197–1202. topleural fistula with cholelithiasis presenting as a right pleural
28 Shutzer KM, Larsson A, Risberg B, et al. Lung protein leak- effusion. Chest 1990; 97: 751–752.
age in feline septic shock. Am Rev Respir Dis 1993; 147: 1380– 39 Navsaria PH, Adams S and Nicol AJ. Traumatic thora-
1385. cobiliary fistulae: a case report with a review of current
29 Sarr MG, Smith GW and DeLeon EF. Biliary bronchial fistula
management options. Injury 2002; 33: 639–643.
after right hepatic lobectomy. Arch Surg 1985; 120: 1376–1380.