You are on page 1of 14

Commodity Price Risk Management

Prepared by Goldman, Sachs & Co.


February 2008
(212) 902-0776
1
Commodity Price Risk Management
Global Liquid Commodities Markets

Power
 Electricity (North America & Europe)
 Weather (North America & Europe)

Energy
 Natural Gas (North America & Europe)  Over 30 natural gas basis locations
 Crude Oil (Global)
 Crude Types
 Refined Products
 Nymex WTI
 NGLs (North America & Europe)
 WTS
 Coal
 LLS
 Petrochemicals and Plastics
 Brent
 Maya
 Mars
Metals
 Dubai
 Precious Metals: Platinum, Palladium, Rhodium, Gold, Silver
 Tapis
 Base Metals: Aluminum, Nickel, Lead, Copper, Alloy
 Midway Sunset
 Buena Vista
Agriculture Products and Soft Commodities  Refined Products
 Corn/Wheat/Soybeans/Soybean Oil/Palm Oil  Nymex Heating Oil
 Cocoa/Sugar/Cotton/Coffee  Nymex Unleaded Gasoline
 Lean Hogs  USGC Heating Oil
 USGC Jet Fuel
 USGC Diesel
Forest Products  Nymex Fuel Oil
 EIA/DOE Diesel
Freight
 NGL Locations
Carbon Emissions  Mt. Belvieu
 Conway
GSCI/Investor Products  US West Coast

2
I. Market Update

3
Crude Oil
Overview

 Throughout its trading history, crude oil prices have generally converged to $20 per barrel, the market determined equilibrium
price.
 Recent history, however, has seen the price of crude oil rise substantially as the market struggles to find a new equilibrium to
accommodate substantial increases in the marginal cost of production, as market supply has attempted to keep pace with
market demand.
 Despite supply-driven increases in long dated oil prices, the cost per marginal barrel of production has grown at an even
faster pace, making a material decrease in crude prices unlikely.
 Although crude oil producers have responded to increasing demand by increasing capacity, these marginal projects have
required expensive undertakings that will continue to impact on crude oil prices as global demand forces the market to seek
new supply sources.
 Meanwhile, global refining capacity has been unable to keep pace with rising petroleum product demand, boosting margins
for the last several years, and resulting in fundamental product tightness. *
Rising Cost Structure Global Refining Capacity
3324033828344223501335611362033679437386379773857639170
80 90
World Petroleum
Marginal cost is defined as the Demand
70 average of the highest cost (or 80 Global Refining
Capacity
bottom quartile) producers
60 70
Marginal

Million bbl/day
50 Costs
60
$/bbl

40
Long-dated oil prices 50
30
40
20 World Petroleum
Supply
30
10

20
0
66 68 70 72 74 76 78 80 82 84 86 88 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06
1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007E

*
Source: Goldman Sachs

4
Crude Oil
Fundamentals

 Fundamentals of the current market environment:


 Since the third quarter of 2007, Nymex WTI prices have increased as a result of declining US inventories and geopolitical
threats to supply.
 After hitting the $100 mark at the beginning of the year, crude oil prices have held firm, despite being pressured by last
week’s inventory build, a weakening US dollar, and fears of a US economic recession.
 Despite early January builds in US crude oil inventories, stocks remain at historically low levels.

Nymex WTI Crude Oil Historical Forwards US Crude Oil Inventories


100 370

90
350
80
330
70

Million bbls
$/gal

60 310

50
290
40
270
30

20 250
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2008 2007 2006 2005 2004

*Source: Goldman Sachs

5
Natural Gas Market
Fundamentals

 For most of the market’s history, Nymex natural gas has traded at $2-$4 per mmBtu as excess supplies relative to demand
kept natural gas at low price levels. However, similar to the crude oil market the natural gas market has seen structural price
changes. Increased demand, driven largely by the power sector and increased heating needs, has further supported the
rising consumption pattern for natural gas.
 GS Research is currently forecasting a Nymex natural gas price of $9.75 per mmBtu for the balance of 2008 and a $10.50 per
mmBtu price for 2009.
 Reasons for this view include:
 US LNG imports have declined dramatically since July due to increased Asian LNG demand on the back of nuclear
outages in Japan coupled with overall increasing power generation demand in Japan, China, and India.
 Nymex natural gas prices continue to lag both residual fuel oil and UK NBP prices.
 As long as the incremental US natural gas btu is sourced from LNG, a weak dollar, which has supported virtually all
other commodities including crude oil, agricultural products, and metals, should also support US natural gas prices.
 Carbon emission legislation (which we anticipate to happen no sooner than the end of 2012, in line with the expiration
of Kyoto) will be bullish for natural gas prices in the long term.
Historical and Forward Prompt Prices
20
Historical Forward
18
16
14
$/mmBtu

12
10
8
6
4
2
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Nymex Natural Gas New York Harbor 1% Fuel Oil UK NBP Natural Gas

*Source: Goldman Sachs **Fuel Oil converted at 6.23 mmBtu per 1 barrel

6
Natural Gas Liquids
Market Growth

 In the United States, NGL forward markets first began to develop in the late 1980s when various price reporting services (e.g.
OPIS, Argus, Platts) began recording prices for Mt. Belvieu, Texas ethane, propane, butane, and natural gasoline.
 Despite the existence of price reporting services, direct price risk management tools in liquids – particularly long-dated tools –
did not exist in a meaningful way until recently. In years past, in order to manage the floating product price risk, market
participants relied on the deeper liquidity of the oil market.
 Partially as a result of the lack of a deep, liquid forward market in light end products, NGLs historically traded in direct
correlation with the oil market.
 Increasing demand for energy in the United States analagously led to growth in the NGL market.
 1990: Total supply of NGLs in the US was approximately 2.2 million barrels per day.
 2.0 million barrels per day were domestically produced while the remainder was imported.
 1.55 million barrels per day were produced by gas plants with the rest produced by refineries.
 2000: Total US supply of NGLs grew to approximately 2.93 million barrels per day.
 2.67 million barrels per day of domestic production while the rest came from imports.
 1.91 million barrels per day were produced by gas plants with the rest produced by refineries.
 The growing US economy required additional sources of cheap energy spurring demand growth in the NGL market.
Specifically, increasing petrochemical demand for cheap energy led demand for NGLs to increase at a rate of over 3
percent per annum from 1990 to 2000. As prices in natural gas and the crude complex increased, additional uses for
NGLs were instituted, including gasoline blending and incremental home heating, which further spurred demand growth
in the NGL market.
 In 2000, forward markets began to develop in the US liquids markets. This forward market development allowed the liquids to
begin trading according to their own unique fundamentals.
 Many reasons for this development:
 Acquistion or project finance driven hedges – fixed prices needed
 Petrochemical feedstock risk management – e.g. ethane/propane versus naptha
 Refiners – gasoline blending
 Record processing (fractionation) spreads

7
Natural Gas Liquids
Recent Developments

 NGL prices have continued to rally on lower than normal US stock levels, strong petrochemical demand and robust
international markets.
 NGL forward curves currently project sustained high prices as fundamentals in the hydrocarbon carbon complex remain
bullish.

NGL Forwards*

2.40

2.20

2.00

1.80

1.60
$/gal

1.40

1.20

1.00

0.80

0.60
Feb-08 Jan-09 Dec-09 Nov-10
Mt. Belvieu Purity Ethane Mt. Belvieu TET Propane
Mt. Belvieu non TET Iso Butane Mt. Belvieu non TET Normal Butane
Mt. Belvieu non TET Natural Gasoline

*Source: Goldman Sachs

8
Oil, Natural Gas & NGLs†
Market Structure

 Tenor and Size:


— Nymex WTI crude oil forward markets trade daily out through December 2014. A standard Nymex WTI crude oil contract
is 1,000 barrels, also know as 1 lot. An average Nymex WTI crude oil trade is approximately 100,000 barrels per month
or 100 lots per month.
— Nymex natural gas forward markets trade daily out through December 2012. A standard Nymex natural gas contract is
10,000 mmBtus, also know as 1 lot. An average Nymex natural gas trade is 100,000 mmBtus per month of 10 lots per
month.
 Mt. Belvieu forward markets in NGL trade daily out 12-24 months. Liquidity beyond two years exists, but large and/or
long-dated transactions require a thoughtful execution strategy to ensure optimal pricing. Despite general tenor limitations,
it is possible to structure hedges in natural gas liquids extending out as far as eight years and regularly make two-way
markets in all five liquids 48 months forward. NGLs are generally quoted in $ per gallon and an average NGL trade is
approximately 20,000 barrels per month.
 Location
 The delivery point for physical Nymex WTI crude oil is Cushing, Oklahoma.
 The price of Nymex natural gas is determined on delivery at the Henry Hub in Louisiana, which serves as the nexus of 16
intra- and interstate natural gas pipeline systems. This pipeline system serves markets throughout the US East Coast, the
Gulf Coast, the Midwest, and up to the Canadian border.
 While the Argus, Platts, and OPIS publications post daily prices for multiple pricing locations, virtually all of the over-the-
counter forward market liquidity resides at Mt. Belvieu, Texas and virtually all forward contracts settle against OPIS. It is
possible to hedge NGLs at locations other than Mt. Belvieu, Texas, but forward liquidity is slight. Thus, most hedgers
exposed to NGLs in other US physical locations such as Conway, Kansas or the US West Coast, choose to hedge their
exposure using Mt. Belvieu, Texas prices in order to obtain better liquidity and highly correlated pricing.
 Hedge Tools:
 Tools available to hedge the oil, natural gas and NGL markets include, but are not limited to:
 Swaps – fixed price for a term
 Options – puts, calls, collars, etc.
 Spread Swaps & Options – frac spread swap & options, cross commodity spread swaps & options

Source: Nymex and Goldman Sachs

9
II. Hedging Strategies

10
Hedge Structures

Swap Call Collar


Description  Consumer buys  Consumer owns the right,  Consumer owns the right
commodity at a fixed price but not the obligation, to to buy commodity at the
in the future buy commodity at a fixed call strike, and may have
price in the future the obligation to buy
commodity at the put
strike in the future

Advantages  Full upside protection  Full upside protection  Can be zero cost upfront
 Full downside participation  Protects against upward
 Limited credit implications
price moves
 Maintains some downside
participation

Disadvantages  Consumer loses any  Upfront premium payment  Consumer loses potential
potential gain from gain below the put strike
downside price moves
 Credit support required
below the swap price
 Credit intensive
Net Price
Payoff Diagrams Hedged
Net Price Net Price
Hedged Hedged
Unhedged Unhedged Consumer receives
Unhedged
Swap Strike Price difference
Consumer Consumer
Price
receives receives
difference difference Put Strike
Swap
Consumer pays
difference
} Premium Paid Call Strike
Consumer pays
difference

*Source: Goldman Sachs Market Price Market Price Market Price

11
Key Hedging Considerations and Variables

Hedging Considerations

Terms Considerations

 Tenor  Short, medium or long term

 Volume  Percentage of consumption

 Commodities Hedged  Specifications and location

 Instrument  Swaps or Options

 Credit Support  Collateral requirements

Unhedged Risk

 Changes in prices on unhedged volumes

 Changes in the basis differentials (location and grade) between chosen hedge and actual purchases

 Changes in consumption patterns

12
Price Indications
Indications as of 2-26-08 Close of business

Nymex WTI Nymex Non-TET Non-TET Natural


Crude Oil Natural Gas Purity Ethane TET Propane Iso Butane Normal Butane Gasoline
Period ($/bbl) ($/mmbtu) ($/gallon) ($/gallon) ($/gallon) ($/gallon) ($/gallon)
Mar-08 $100.77 $9.21 $0.9500 $1.5125 $1.8150 $1.7600 $2.1950
Apr-08 $100.46 $9.25 $0.9375 $1.4850 $1.8050 $1.7350 $2.1900
May-08 $100.07 $9.27 $0.9275 $1.4825 $1.8050 $1.7350 $2.1825
Jun-08 $99.74 $9.33 $0.9175 $1.4825 $1.8085 $1.7385 $2.1750
Jul-08 $99.43 $9.40 $0.9100 $1.4855 $1.7835 $1.7435 $2.1700
Aug-08 $99.16 $9.46 $0.9050 $1.4895 $1.7750 $1.7500 $2.1650
Sep-08 $98.91 $9.47 $0.9015 $1.4935 $1.7800 $1.7575 $2.1600
Oct-08 $98.63 $9.54 $0.8980 $1.4975 $1.7850 $1.7650 $2.1550
Nov-08 $98.37 $9.82 $0.8945 $1.5015 $1.7875 $1.7725 $2.1550
Dec-08 $98.06 $10.15 $0.8920 $1.5055 $1.7950 $1.7800 $2.1550
Jan-09 $97.76 $10.38 $0.8895 $1.5095 $1.8010 $1.7860 $2.1550
Feb-09 $97.52 $10.35 $0.8745 $1.4895 $1.7760 $1.7610 $2.1475
Mar-09 $97.25 $10.08 $0.8595 $1.4545 $1.7460 $1.7260 $2.1400
Apr-09 $96.99 $8.68 $0.8445 $1.4095 $1.7085 $1.6785 $2.1325
May-09 $96.75 $8.59 $0.8395 $1.3945 $1.6935 $1.6635 $2.1250
Jun-09 $96.55 $8.65 $0.8370 $1.3945 $1.6935 $1.6635 $2.1175
Jul-09 $96.32 $8.71 $0.8345 $1.3970 $1.6920 $1.6670 $2.1100
Aug-09 $96.13 $8.76 $0.8320 $1.4015 $1.6870 $1.6720 $2.1050
Sep-09 $95.95 $8.77 $0.8295 $1.4065 $1.6925 $1.6775 $2.1000
Oct-09 $95.78 $8.83 $0.8270 $1.4115 $1.6985 $1.6835 $2.1000
Nov-09 $95.66 $9.13 $0.8245 $1.4165 $1.7050 $1.6900 $2.1000
Dec-09 $95.54 $9.48 $0.8220 $1.4215 $1.7115 $1.6965 $2.1000
Jan-10 $95.45 $9.69 $0.8220 $1.4280 $1.7180 $1.7030 $2.1000
Feb-10 $95.37 $9.70 $0.8095 $1.4105 $1.6905 $1.6755 $2.0925
Mar-10 $95.27 $9.47 $0.7970 $1.3805 $1.6580 $1.6380 $2.0850
Apr-10 $95.17 $8.38 $0.7845 $1.3455 $1.6280 $1.5980 $2.0775
May-10 $95.09 $8.33 $0.7845 $1.3390 $1.6230 $1.5930 $2.0725
Jun-10 $95.01 $8.39 $0.7845 $1.3415 $1.6230 $1.5930 $2.0675
Jul-10 $94.94 $8.44 $0.7845 $1.3445 $1.6220 $1.5970 $2.0675
Aug-10 $94.88 $8.50 $0.7845 $1.3490 $1.6170 $1.6020 $2.0675
Sep-10 $94.84 $8.52 $0.7845 $1.3540 $1.6220 $1.6070 $2.0675
Oct-10 $94.81 $8.59 $0.7875 $1.3595 $1.6280 $1.6130 $2.0675
Nov-10 $94.79 $8.87 $0.7910 $1.3650 $1.6340 $1.6190 $2.0725
Dec-10 $94.77 $9.19 $0.7945 $1.3705 $1.6400 $1.6250 $2.0775

Nymex Calendar Average WTI Crude Oil; Nymex Natural Gas Last 1 Day; Mt. Belvieu
NGLs settling vs. OPIS monthly average Source: Goldman Sachs

13
Disclaimer

This material has been prepared by personnel in the Equities or Fixed Income, Currency and Commodities Sales/Trading Departments of one
or more affiliates of The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. ("Goldman Sachs") and is not the product of the Global Investment Research
Department. It is not a research report and is not intended as such. All materials, including proposed terms and conditions, are indicative and
for discussion purposes only. Finalized terms and conditions are subject to further discussion and negotiation and will be evidenced by a
formal agreement. Opinions expressed are our present opinions only and are subject to change without further notice. The information
contained herein is confidential. By accepting this information, the recipient agrees that it will, and it will cause its directors, partners, officers,
employees and representatives to use the information only to evaluate its potential interest in the strategies described herein and for no other
purpose and will not divulge any such information to any other party. Any reproduction of this information, in whole or in part, is prohibited.
Except in so far as required to do so to comply with applicable law or regulation, express or implied, no warranty whatsoever, including but not
limited to, warranties as to quality, accuracy, performance, timeliness, continued availability or completeness of any information contained
herein is made. Opinions expressed herein are current opinions only as of the date indicated. Any historical price(s) or value(s) are also only
as of the date indicated. We are under no obligation to update opinions or other information. The information contained herein has been
prepared solely for informational purposes and is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any security or instrument
or to participate in any trading strategy. Further information on any of the securities, futures or options mentioned in this material may be
obtained upon request. Goldman Sachs does not provide accounting, tax or legal advice; however, you should be aware that any proposed
indicative transaction could have accounting, tax, legal or other implications that should be discussed with your advisors and or counsel. In
addition, we mutually agree that, subject to applicable law, you may disclose any and all aspects of any potential transaction or structure
described herein that are necessary to support any U.S. federal income tax benefits, without Goldman Sachs imposing any limitation of any
kind. Goldman Sachs, or persons involved in the preparation or issuance of this material, may from time to time, have long or short positions
in, and buy or sell, the securities, commodities, futures, options, derivatives or other instruments and investments identical with or related to
those mentioned herein....

Goldman Sachs International, which is authorized and regulated by the Financial Services Authority, has approved this material in connection
with its distribution in the United Kingdom and European Union. This document should not be distributed to ‘Private Customers’ as defined by
the FSA. Unless governing law permits otherwise, you must contact a Goldman Sachs entity in your home jurisdiction if you want to use our
services in effecting a transaction in the securities mentioned in this material.

 Commodity Risk Management.


— Goldman Sachs has been making long-dated markets for over 10 years. We routinely execute hedges on behalf of clients that extend
through 2010. Our product offerings include Crude Oil, Natural Gas, multiple grades of Gasoline, Heating Oil, Diesel, Jet Fuel, Naptha,
Fuel Oil, Electricity, Gold, Silver, Platinum, Palladium, Aluminum, Copper, Alloy, Lead, Nickel, NASAAC, Corn, Wheat, Soybeans,
Soybean Oil, Palm Oil, Cocoa, Sugar, Cotton, Coffee and Lean Hogs. Our over the counter swaps and options can be structured to
settle against the Nymex or one of the various regional price postings.
(C) Copyright 2007 The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. All rights reserved.

14

You might also like