Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: Elder neglect, one of the 6 forms of elder maltreatment, MATERIALS AND METHODS
is difficult to diagnose and is underreported both in the scientific Twenty years of forensic files at the Medical University
literature and to law enforcement. Recognizing fatal neglect is even of South Carolina were reviewed and cases of elder death
more challenging especially with concurrent organic disease. Many examined. An elder was defined as 65 years of age or greater.
entities can mimic elder neglect, and many age-related changes can Cases that documented elder neglect as the cause of the death
result in pathology that may be confused with maltreatment. We were further analyzed as to victim age, sex, race, cause of
retrospectively reviewed all forensic cases of individuals age sixty- death, manner of death, location of incident, perpetrator,
five years and older which were referred for autopsy. Cases of fatal victim-to-perpetrator relationship, autopsy findings, and an-
neglect were analyzed as to age, sex, race, cause of death, location cillary studies.
of incident, perpetrator, victim-to-perpetrator relationship, and au-
topsy and ancillary findings. The cases studies totaled 8. The age
range was 74 to 94 years. Two were white, 6 black, one male, and
RESULTS
7 female. The causes of death were sepsis due to severe decubitus The total number of elder neglect cases examined
ulcers and severe dehydration. Five cases occurred in the victim’s was 8. Complete autopsies were performed on all cases
home, and 3 occurred in an institution (nursing home/care facility). (Table 1). The age range was 74 to 94 years. Seven were
In 5 cases, the perpetrators were family members. The pathophysi- women, and 1 was a man. The black:white ratio was 6:2.
ology of aging with respect to elder maltreatment is reviewed. The causes of death included sepsis due to severe decub-
itus ulcers (5 cases) and severe dehydration (3 cases).
Key Words: elder maltreatment, elder abuse, elder neglect, Cachexia was documented in 7 cases. The one case without
geriatric, forensic, autopsy, dehydration, sepsis cachexia was a small, thin woman (114 lbs), who was
(Am J Forensic Med Pathol 2007;28: 157–162) usually cared for by her nieces, but over a 2-week period,
an institution cared for her.
Electrolyte analysis was documented in all cases: 6
postmortem and 2 premortem. In the 3 cases with dehydration
as the cause of death, vitreous chemistry ranges were as
follows: sodium ⫽ 164 –180 mmol/L, chloride ⫽ 133–186
E ach year, millions of elderly persons suffer as the result of
maltreatment.1 As the number of elders age 65 and older
increases, the number of elder maltreatment cases is expected
mmol/L, and urea nitrogen ⫽ 76 –310 mg/dL. Tenting of the
skin, “stickiness” of the serosal surfaces, sunken orbits, and
to rise.2,3 Elder maltreatment can be divided into 6 categories: hard feces/fecal impaction were identified. Postmortem blood
physical abuse, sexual abuse, neglect, psychologic abuse, cultures were performed in 5 of the 8 cases and were positive
financial exploitation, and violation of rights.4 – 6 Elder ne- for Staphylococcus aureus, Enterococcus, Proteus penneri, P
glect is complex and sometimes fatal. The forensic patholo- mirabilis, and/or Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Postmortem cul-
gist and investigator need to be familiar with the typical tures of decubitus ulcers were reported in 3 of the cases and
victim, scenario, perpetrator, and significant autopsy findings. corresponded with blood culture positivity for P penneri,
The characteristic findings can be documented grossly, his- Pseudomonas aeruginosa, P mirabilis, and/or S aureus. Pre-
tologically, and by a variety of ancillary studies such as mortem blood cultures were performed in 2 cases, one of
full-body radiographs, toxicology, microbiology, and chem- which also had a premortem decubitus ulcer culture. The
istry. As important as documenting these findings is, so is the premortem cultures were confirmed by postmortem cultures.
understanding of certain pathophysiologic changes of aging (Table 2).
that can be mistaken for maltreatment. Toxicology was not performed in 2 cases, due to the
extended hospital stay and the lack of admission blood.
The remaining 6 cases were negative in 3 cases, positive
Manuscript received September 6, 2005; accepted November 14, 2005. for blood ethanol in 1 case (2.7 mg/dL, insignificant),
From the Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina. positive for subtherapeutic levels of phenytoin in the blood
Reprints: Kim A. Collins, MD, Department of Pathology, Forensic Section, in 1 case, and positive for oxycodone (100 ng/mL, thera-
Medical University of South Carolina, 165 Ashley Avenue, Charleston, peutic) and acetaminophen (15 g/mL, therapeutic) in the
SC 29425. E-mail: collinsk@musc.edu.
Copyright © 2007 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins blood in 1 case.
ISSN: 0195-7910/07/2802-0157 Other medical findings included cachexia (weight
DOI: 10.1097/PAF.0b013e31805c93eb ranges 63–114 pounds), contractures (⫻2), dementia (Alz-
The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology • Volume 28, Number 2, June 2007 157
158
Collins and Presnell
current retrospective study, 1 case was designated natural and 1 mass.26 Osteoporosis is common in elders, resulting in a
as accident. Both of these were cases of dehydration and ca- higher frequency of fractures.17,26 Vitamin D production is
chexia in an institution. Today, these 2 cases, just as fatal child decreased secondary to a decrease in the precursor 7-dehy-
neglect cases, would be ruled as homicide. drocholesterol.19 Proprioception and sensory input are im-
paired, resulting in more falls and a slower reaction to the fall.
Pathophysiology of Aging Organic diseases such as arrhythmia, diabetic neuropathy,
Age-related changes make the elder more prone to orthostatic hypotension, and osteoarthritis make the elder
injury and may result in physical findings that can be mis- susceptible to falls.23 Previous strokes can result in an im-
taken for elder abuse and neglect.3,23 The forensic investiga- paired gait, balance, and seizures.27 Fractures that are com-
tor and pathologist must be aware of such changes to properly monly seen in elders are hip (femoral neck), proximal hu-
assess inflicted neglect or trauma. The elder’s skin is atrophic, merus, and vertebrae.28 Rib fractures secondary to a fall or
with a 30%–50% decrease in epidermal proliferation.19,24 CPR are most commonly 4 –9.29 There is an overall loss of
The dermal-epidermal junction is flattened, with decreased subcutaneous fat, which can be confused for malnutrition/
interdigitations. The weakened supporting structure of blood starvation, predispose the elder to decubitus ulcers, and affect
vessels and capillary fragility often leads to large ecchymoses
the body temperature.17,26
with little trauma. Senile purpura is seen in 10%–20% of
Elders are prone to hypothermia and hyperthermia.30
elders, especially on the extensor surfaces. Previous sun
Hypothermia may occur in this group due to the decrease in
damage, with a decrease in elasticity and a history of steroid
the muscle mass and adipose tissue.31,32 The basal metabolic
cream use, also results in skin fragility. Organic diseases such
rate is decreased, as well as shivering. There is a decreased
as liver disease, acquired coagulopathies, and Cushing syn-
perception of temperature, including skin sensory percep-
drome can also cause purpura. Elders can have an acquired
tion.33 Vasoconstriction is decreased and the body’s overall
factor V and factor VIII deficiency due to spontaneous
antibodies.16 Platelets can also become dysfunctional. Drug- ability to regulate its temperature is impaired. Entities which
induced thrombocytopenia has been associated with digoxin, predispose an elder to hypothermia are diabetes mellitus,
diuretic, barbiturates. Anticoagulant medications can cause hypothyroidism, malnutrition, polypharmacy, liver disease,
easy bleeding. Some other drugs such as cimetidine potenti- adrenal and pituitary insufficiency, and cerebrovascular dis-
ate the action of anticoagulants.19 Cerebral atrophy is seen in ease.34 Medications such as benzodiazepines and narcotics
elders, increasing the likelihood of a subdural hemorrhage can impair thermoregulatory ability.35 Alcohol consumption
secondary to a fall. This is even more likely with acquired can cause vasodilation, which accelerates hypothermia.35
coagulopathies and anticoagulant medications. On the other Hyperthermia can also occur in this group. As elders have
end of the spectrum is the tendency for thrombosis. Throm- decreased vasoconstriction, they also have decreased vasodi-
bocytosis can be seen with iron deficiency, chronic inflam- lation. A major contributor to this is peripheral vascular
matory diseases, cancer, and infections. Elders can have an disease. Furthermore, cardiac output is decreased, so less heat
acquired lupus anticoagulant, which can lead to thromboses. is lost.30 The sweat response is decreased, promoting a rise in
Decubitus ulcers are a major problem in this age the core body temperature. As above, benzodiazepines can
group.17 With immobility, dementia, and incontinence, skin also cause hyperthermia as they impair thermoregulatory
ulcerations can occur in the most well-cared-for individuals. ability.35 If an elder is on diuretics and possibly has decreased
Pressure from prolonged positioning of the already compro- thirst sensation, volume depletion can result, which can
mised aged skin and subcutaneous tissue can cause significant produce dehydration with hyperthermia.30
breakdown. Fecal and urinary incontinence accelerate skin The overall cardiac output decreases with age, affecting
breakdown and provide a source for infection. Fecal incon- the physiology of many organ systems.26,30,36 A noticeable
tinence can be secondary to such entities as diabetes, anal effect includes decreased blood flow to the kidneys. The
sphincter function, inflammatory bowel disease, and demen- glomerular filtration rate is decreased, and water absorption is
tia. Oftentimes, the elder is not incontinent but is immobile, impaired. Dehydration can result from decreased water ab-
unable to go to the bathroom independently. Delay in wound sorption from the kidneys, decreased urine concentration
healing is noted especially in elders with diabetes mellitus ability (more water lost), decreased thirst sensation, and the
and peripheral vascular disease. Peripheral vascular stiffen- use of diuretics.30 We can see fecal impaction with dehydra-
ing, a natural change of aging, results in poor perfusion. tion secondary to decreased peristalsis, or a combination of
Elders have decreased cellular and humorally mediated im- the 2. Overall, the kidneys have a decreased ability to elim-
munity responses. The lymphocyte function is decreased, as inate waste, and with this we see a decrease in creatinine
well as the level of cytokines and interleukins.25 The de- clearance. This can have a detrimental effect on the elimina-
creased perfusion, poorly responsive immune system, and tion of toxins and drugs.
delayed wound healing prolong the period of ulceration and Gastric secretions and intestinal enzymes are decreased
increase the likelihood of sepsis. in the elder. This results in decreased absorption of nutrients
Full-body radiographs should be performed in cases of such as vitamin B12, folate, and iron. Peristalsis is decreased
suspected elder neglect. Such radiographs will delineate frac- and constipation is not uncommon. Forty percent to 60% of
tures, demineralization, and osteomyelitis.17 Elders have nursing home residents have been reported to have dyspha-
muscle atrophy, decreased flexibility, and decreased bone gia.37 Many elders have xerostomia (dry mouth) and tem-
poromandibular joint dysfunction, both preventing proper pathologist and investigator to a situation of elder neglect.
chewing and swallowing. Compounding this, many elders are The natural changes and pathophysiology of aging must be
edentulous. Malnutrition is a concern of the geriatric age understood so that elder neglect is not overcalled and so that
group.32 Elders have a decreased sense of taste, and up to elder neglect is not viewed as “just age” and ignored. Like
50% have a decreased sense of smell.19 Many medications fatal child neglect, fatal elder neglect is a homicide. Elders
can also disrupt taste. Various infections with inflammatory often have many natural diseases; however, the cause of
cytokines can cause anorexia. Even if the individual con- death may not be due to their diseases but due to active or
sumes proper nutrients, malabsorption can occur, resulting in passive neglect of a vulnerable individual by a caretaker.
weight loss and cachexia. Malabsorption can be the result of
aging of the gastrointestinal system, diabetes mellitus, or REFERENCES
hypothyroidism. 1. Dong XQ. Medical implications of elder abuse and neglect. Clin Geriatr
In women, vaginal bleeding and excoriation may be Med. 2005;21:293–313.
2. Cowen HJ, Cowen PS. Elder mistreatment: implications for public
seen secondary to decreased estrogen. This finding can be health dentistry. J Public Health Dent. 2001;61:131–137.
worrisome when differentiating sexual assault or poor hy- 3. Grossman MD, Miller D, Scaff DW, et al. When is an elder old? effect
giene.38 Decreased glycogen deposition causes an increased of preexisting conditions on mortality in geriatric trauma. J Trauma.
pH and promotes infection. Even in noncatheterized individ- 2002;52:242–246.
4. Program Resources Department, American Association of Retired Per-
uals, the prevalence of urinary tract infections is increased. sons, Administration on Aging, US Department of Health and Human
The pelvic structures and vaginal walls are weakened with Services. A Profile of Older Americans. Washington, DC: American
age, leading to cystocele and uterine prolapse. These 2 Association of Retired Persons; 1993.
structures can become very erythematous, with excoriation 5. Collins KA, Bennett AT, Hanzlick R. Elder abuse and neglect. Arch
secondary to friction, and appear traumatized, especially with Intern Med. 2000;160:1567–1568.
6. Silverman TN. Abuse of the elderly through fraud and deception.
postmortem drying. The pertinent endocrine and metabolic Psychiatr Hosp. 1983;14:104 –107.
changes associated with the geriatric population are acquired 7. Dolan V. Risk factors for elder abuse. J Insur Med. 1999;31:13–20.
diabetes mellitus, a decrease in estrogen, and hypothyroid- 8. Abyad A. Elder abuse: diagnosis, management, and prevention. Med
ism. Diabetes can result in poor wound healing, increased rate Interface. 1996;9:97–101.
9. Paris BE. Violence against elderly people. Mt Sinai J Med. 1996;63:97–
of infection, and neuropathy. Hypothyroidism is associated 100.
with malabsorption.39 Decreased estrogen can result in vag- 10. Breckman RS, Adelman RD. Strategies for Helping Victims of Elder
inal atrophy, bone resorption, decreased skin collagen, blad- Mistreatment. Newbury Park: Sage Publications; 1989:35–36.
der atrophy, and incontinence. 11. Hansberry MR, Chen E, Gorbien MJ. Dementia and elder abuse. Clin
Geriatr Med. 2005;21:315–332.
Very little research has been conducted on geriatric 12. Lachs MS, Pillemer K. Elder abuse. Lancet North Am Ed. 2004;364:
pharmacokinetics.40 Overall, there is a decrease in hepatic 1263–1272.
metabolism, as well as the renal clearance. Much of this is 13. Akaza K, Bunai Y, Tsujinaka M, et al. Elder abuse and neglect: social
believed to be secondary to organic diseases such as problems revealed from 15 autopsy cases. Leg Med (Tokyo). 2003;
5:7–14.
alcoholism, as opposed to decreased enzymatic pathways. 14. Joshi S, Flaherty J. Elder abuse and neglect in long-term care. Clin
A decrease in plasma cholinesterases has been documented, Geriatr Med. 2005;21:333–354.
especially in cases of pneumonia. Gastric alcohol dehydro- 15. Collins KA, Presnell SE. Elder homicide: a 20 year study. Am J Forensic
genases have decreased activity, so more alcohol is absorbed Med Pathol. 2006;27:183–187.
16. Collins KA, Bennett AT. Elder abuse. In: Froede R, ed. Handbook of
by the stomach (first pass). This results in a higher blood Forensic Pathology. Northfield, IL: College of American Pathologists;
alcohol concentration for amount consumed. Alcohol can 2003:257–263.
have a CNS effect, as well as coagulation and temperature 17. Iyer P. Liability of the care of the elderly. J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal
regulatory effects. Nurs. 2004;33:124 –131.
An impaired immune system predisposes the elder to 18. Harrell R, Toronjo CH, McLaughlin J, et al. How geriatricians identify
elder abuse and neglect. Am J Med Sci. 2002;323:34 –38.
other infections besides those of the skin. In addition, an 19. Duthie EH, Katz PR. Practice of Geriatrics. 3rd ed. Philadelphia, PA:
increased susceptibility to develop pneumonia is due to de- WB Saunders Co; 1998.
creased lung mechanics, decreased elastic recoil, decreased 20. Di Maio VS, Di Maio TG. Homicide by decubitus ulcer. Am J Forensic
chest wall compliance, decreased strength of the respiratory Med Pathol. 2002;23:1– 4.
21. Kayser-Jones J. Malnutrition, dehydration, and starvation in the midst of
muscles, decreased pulmonary reserve and PO2, and a de- plenty: the political impact of qualitative inquiry. Qual Health Res.
creased gag reflex resulting in a decreased ability to 2002;12:1391–1405.
cough.26,41 Aspiration is a common occurrence secondary to 22. Hanzlick RL. Medical certification of death and cause-of-death state-
this change in pulmonary physiology, dysphagia, and mental ments. In: Froede R, ed. Handbook of Forensic Pathology. Northfield,
IL: College of American Pathologists; 2003:31– 48.
pathology seen in this group. 23. Jacobs DG. Special consideration in geriatric injury. Curr Opin Crit
Creating new forensic expertise in geriatrics, similar to Care. 2003;9:535–539.
that in child abuse, would promote detection and accurate 24. Mandavia D, Newton K. Contemporary issues in trauma. Emerg Med
classification of cause and manner of death. Certain elders are Clin North Am. 1998;16:258 –274.
25. Mitchell FL, Metzler MR. Geriatric complications. In: Mattox KL, ed.
typical victims just as certain caregivers are typical perpetra- Complications of Trauma. New York: Churchill Livingstone; 1994.
tors. However, even when the case history is initially lacking, 26. Pudelek B. Geriatric trauma: special needs for a special population.
physical and laboratory findings should alert the forensic AACN Clin Issues. 2002;13:61–72.
27. Lugger KE. Dysphagia in the elderly stroke patient. J Neurosci Nurs. 34. Knobel B, Mikhlin A. Severe accidental hypothermia in an elderly
1994;26:78 – 84. woman. Harefuah. 2001;140:1014 –1017, 1119.
28. Schwartz AV, Nevitt MC, Brown BW Jr, et al. Increased falling as a risk 35. Taylor AJ, McGwin G Jr, Davis G, et al. Hypothermia deaths in
factor for fracture among older women: the study of osteoporotic Jefferson County, Alabama. Inj Prev. 2001;7:141–145.
fractures. Am J Epidemiol. 2005;161:180 –185. 36. Pugh KG, Wei JY. Clinical implications of physiological changes in the
29. Kane RS, Burns EA, Goodwin JS. Minimal trauma fractures in older aging heart. Drugs Aging. 2001;18:263–276.
nursing home residents: the interaction of functional status, trauma, and 37. Shanley C, O’Loughlin G. Dysphagia among nursing home residents: an
site of fracture. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1995;43:156 –159. assessment and management protocol. J Gerontol Nurs. 2000;26:35– 48.
30. Kenney WL. Thermoregulation at rest and during exercise in healthy 38. Collins KA. Sex-related deaths. In: Froede R, ed. Handbook of Forensic
older adults. Exerc Sport Sci Rev. 1997;25:41–76. Pathology. Northfield, IL: College of American Pathologists; 2003:243–256.
31. Young AJ, Lee DT. Aging and human cold intolerance. Exp Aging Res. 39. Pustorino S, Foti M, Calipari G, et al. Thyroid-intestinal motility
1997;23:45– 67. interactions summary. Minerva Gastroenterol Dietol. 2004;50:305–315.
32. Walrand S, Boirie Y. Optimizing protein intake and aging. Curr Opin 40. Crome P. What’s different about older people. Toxicology. 2003;192:
Clin Nutr Metab Care. 2005;8:89 –94. 49 –54.
33. Smolander J. Effect of cold exposure on older humans. Int J Sports Med. 41. Rossi A, Ganassini A, Tantucci C, et al. Aging and the respiratory
2002;23:86 –92. system. Aging. 1996;8:143–161.