Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Actor Singer Dancer and Musician PDF
Actor Singer Dancer and Musician PDF
BACHELOR OF ARTS
Falmouth University, UK
Ryan Green 2
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Contents
List of Figures 5
List of Tables 5
Statement of Originality 6
Abstract 7
Acknowledgements 8
Introduction 9
Ryan Green 3
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Sweeny Todd 25
Hairspray 26
The Performer and Set Design 27
The Absent Performer 28
Coda 29
Conclusion 30
Appendices 32
Definitions 33
Musicians’ Union Theatre Employment Rules 35
The Expansive and Reductive Approach 36
References
Bibliography 38
Webography 40
Videography 41
Ryan Green 4
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
List of Figures
Figure 5 Lon Hoylt directs the cut-off of ‘You Can’t Stop the
Beat – Part 1’ 26
List of Tables
Musical Theatre 13
Ryan Green 5
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Statement of Originality
This document was submitted to Falmouth University’s Academy of Music & Theatre Arts, forming my
overall module submission for PER320: Dissertation, toward the degree of Bachelor of Arts with Honours
in Music specialising in Compositional Studies, in the Summer Term (Semester Two) 2013/14.
I hereby certify that I am the sole author of this dissertation and that no part of this dissertation has been
published or submitted for publication.
I confirm that the research and writing of this assignment are entirely my own and I have not plagiarised
any portion of this work. I have not worked with any other person inappropriately by lending notes,
papers, disks, files or other materials. I also consent to this work being stored electronically for use within
plagiarism detection systems in order to check the integrity of assessed work.
Signed:
Ryan Green 6
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Abstract
The orchestra is often the most underappreciated element of a theatre company. This dissertation explores
the role of the musician in both music theatre and musical theatre and aims to discover the extent of their
expanding or contracting roles in both a commercial context, such as Broadway or the West-End, and
non-commercial context, such as (off)-off-Broadway and off-West End. The timeframe of study is between
1969 and the present day. It will also highlight links to artists such as Marina Abramović. This dissertation
asks if the role of the musician working within music theatre and musical theatre becomes one that is so
extended that their job title is no longer appropriate. It outlines the musician’s historical role in theatre
and their differing responsibilities in opera, music theatre and musical theatre. This dissertation also
makes comparisons between musicians working in these two art forms.
Chapter One focuses upon the histories and theories of new music theatre and musical theatre, including
Gesamtkunstwerk and the historic roots from opera. Chapter Two focuses upon music theatre as a hybrid,
versatile art form that allows musicians to play a larger role in the creation and delivery of theatre
performance, while Chapter Three documents how musical theatre performers responsibilities are moving
away from the conventions traditionally found and the title of ‘actor’ or ‘musician’ are no longer
appropriate as the job roles have expanded. The chapter looks at the how writing of performance includes
set design and considers how this impacts on the audience’s experience of seeing a theatre work performed
is changing and musicians and the orchestra are further disappearing making a performance cleaner and
more ‘magical’.
This dissertation concludes that the role of the musician differs between the music driven theatres and that
the future of musical theatre is unclear because there are few new younger writers and producers willing to
invest both their reputation and finance into new performance art which does not fit a working
commercial formula.
Ryan Green 7
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Acknowledgements
There are several people whom I wish to acknowledge for their unwavering support whilst I was writing
this dissertation.
Firstly I would like to thank Dr Mike Rofe for pushing me out of my comfort zone not only as a
composer, but also as an academic writer. I would also like to thank him for the opportunity he gave to me
for allowing my transfer between courses during my second year.
I am most grateful to Dr Falk Hübner for allowing me to read a copy of his PhD thesis and his kind words
regarding my work.
Pandora James and Pam Duggan who, both, sat for countless hours, reading and re-reading my work. I
would also like to acknowledge the help of Rosie Sellwood, for her patience. I am also grateful to the staff
at University of Exeter, Streatham Campus Library who have dealt with my never-ending requests for
material, as well as the many other university libraries up and down the country who have kindly let me
borrow material from their collections.
To all my friends and colleagues: Becky Allman, Craig McKenzie, Cole Baker and Lilly Dahlen et al. for
making me smile and giving their support.
Ryan Green 8
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Introduction
This dissertation examines the changing role of musicians in music theatre since 1969 and in musical
theatre since 20051. It will argue that music theatre is a facilitator for experimental performance writing
and devising praxis that is not possible in other music driven theatres due to their popularity and their
working commercial formula. This dissertation focuses on music theatre and musical theatre as I feel these
two are the most related music-driven art forms. Through case-study methodology, the dissertation will
examine works where musicians play an extended role in the context of theatre.
Within this dissertation, I refer to the ‘musician’ as someone who plays a musical instrument in the theatre
and a ‘singer’ as someone who performs exclusively with their voice. An ‘actor’ is someone who performs a
story-telling role using a range of singing, dancing, acting technique.
It should be noted that musical theatre works are often referred to in the singular as a ‘musical’. It should
also be remembered that musical theatre and music theatre are two different art forms and are referred to
as thus throughout this dissertation. Music Theatre looks to the smaller-scale and experimental styles of
writing and performance whereas musical theatre is a mainstream music driven theatre genre, where
music is used purposely to describe feelings or further the story line.
My research hypothesis is: The role of the musician within music theatre and musical theatre has
become one, which is so extended that their job title is no longer appropriate.
Alongside musicians, actors are beginning to have extended roles. For example to be able to perform in
Pippin the actors must be able to master complex circus skills whilst dancing, singing and acting. Dancer’s
roles too are being expanded and contracted in different ways, for example, in Sasha Waltz’s insideout2
(2003), two dancers perform both a piece of choreography and a piece of sound/music with a singing saw
in-between them (Hübner, 2013: 8).
Throughout this dissertation, I refer to all theatre, in which music is the essential element as ‘music driven
1
I will also touch upon musicals prior to this but they will not be the main area of study.
2
With music by musikFabrik.
Ryan Green 9
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
theatre’. The image below shows a continuum of these theatres to which I am referring3:
3
Ballet, Review, Burlesque and Vaudeville are also music driven theatres but they are not the focus of this
dissertation.
Ryan Green 10
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
It is important to remember musical theatre was born out of opera lirica (sung work), more commonly
known as ‘opera’. Musicians in opera have often had a close relationship with the stage action although;
they too tend to accompany the action instead of becoming the audience’s main concentration.
Experimentation within opera came about when Wagner became a more prolific composer. Composers
such as Debussy and Britten experimented with pushing Wagnerian harmony5, emphasising a greater use
of dissonance.
Traditional operas contain long overtures and intermezzi’s where the shift of focus went from the stage
action (or non action) to the orchestra and the audience would show their appreciation for the complex
music played. As musical theatre moved away from operetta and became more like modern drama, and its
emphasis switched to storytelling instead of bells and whistles, the overture (which composers loved to
4
See Chapter 2.
5
For example: the ‘half diminished seventh’ / ‘Tristan chord’.
Ryan Green 11
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
‘An unscientific survey of 30 recent, current or forthcoming Broadway musicals reveals that only
7 (including “The Producers,” “Wicked,” “Spamalot” and “The Color Purple”) have an old-
fashioned overture’ (Green, 2006).
Many musicals still contain overtures and entr’actes where there is no visual on stage, however audiences
often talk over these. This may be due to impatience (Hischak, 2008) or the fact audiences pay vast
amounts of money to see it, visually on stage.
‘Smaller orchestras, lack of songfulness, shorter running times, all have contributed to the demise
of the overture. […] David Rockwell pointed out that, thanks to MTV, people now expect visuals
with their music. [...] [O]vertures need curtains, and many Broadway shows, including “The
Light in the Piazza,” […] no longer use them. As a result the full “Piazza” overture was only
played at the first few previews. “It seemed silly listening to lovely, lush melodies for five minutes
while staring at the half-lit set, waiting for something to happen”’ (Green, 2006).
Before the second half of the twentieth century, Brecht and Weill’s collaborations took on the presence of
musicians on stage in the work Die Dreigroschenoper (1928). Brecht’s theory of epic theatre - alienation
presented performers as actors to the audience, showing that they were merely to show that they were only
actors performing a role, which had been written (Hübner, 2013: 13).
‘Through alienation Brecht was attempting to remind the audience that what they were watching
was only a production put on by actors and shaped by the director. […] His use of a narrator
broke the imaginary fourth wall of the theatre and made the audience doubly aware of the
storytelling aspect found in theatre. He would also have the scenery changes done au vista or in
front of the audience, and allow the lighting instruments to be seen. Even special effects like
lightning and fog were not disguised’ (Petersen, 2012).
Around 1972, an agreement known as the ‘collective bargaining agreement’ called for a minimum
requirement of twenty-six musicians playing in the largest Broadway theatres and twenty for the smaller
theatres 6 (Meffe, 2011: 100). Composers would request a certain number of musicians with the
understanding that musicians may be dismissed should the show not perform well financially. Shows that
did not fulfill the minimum requirement would be forced to employ non-playing musicians, known as
‘walkers’ who would only visit the theatre to collect their pay-cheques. This impacted heavily upon the
musical theatre community and in 1975, the musicians’ union went on strike. At the end, new and lower
6
Please refer to Appendix B.
Ryan Green 12
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
minimums were put in place that were not tied directly to the theatre’s capacity (Meffe, 2011: 102). Big
musicals such as Sweeney Todd (2005) and Once (2011) have gone on to help coin the term ‘actor-
musician7’ which is now a widely accepted term particularly in New York. Other musicals such as The
Wedding Singer; Jersey Boys; Million Dollar Quartet; Rock of Ages and Betty Blue Eyes all use actors as
musicians and vice versa, or use the orchestra as a visual accompaniment essential to the plot of the show:
In new music theatre, the musician and actor tend to be one and the same person, partially due to the
smaller scale production aspects. It is often more economical to blur the lines between the musician and
performer hence the ‘performance artist’ becomes a more suitable title for such performers. This is also
sometimes due to artistic choice (As in Once). The term ‘multi-faceted musician’ is evident most in
popular music, where performers often sing, move and play instruments alongside building rapport with
their audience
The main difference between music theatre and musical theatre tends to be the music. Not all music
theatre works contain ‘music’ as such, but include sonic media, bio music, percussion and/or electronics,
whereas musical theatre works contain solid, mainstream music that tends to be memorable and popular
7
Lit.: ‘Actor cum musician’
Ryan Green 13
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
music based. Audiences, always respond differently to all types of music driven theatre. Musical theatre
audiences tend to grow up with certain musical albums passed down from parents to siblings. The most
popular shows such as Joseph... tour all round the country, usually every year, taking theatre to deprived
areas as well as the metropolises.
In regard to the role of musicians, I drew up this table to illustrate the differences for performers working
in music theatre and musical theatre:
Table 2: The differences for performers working in music theatre and musical theatre.
Musical theatre is probably the last music driven theatre genre to look to experimenting with music,
staging and the dynamics of theatrics. New musicals such as Next To Normal, Spring Awakening and
Wicked are beginning to look towards a new musical revolution, although none of these really push the
Ryan Green 14
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
boundaries of acceptability like music theatre works. The question might be asked: has musical theatre
experimented as far as it can before the work becomes more representative of music theatre? The answer is
not clear because of their audience’s expectation and financial risk of experimentation.
‘Off-off Broadway’ – where most experimenting takes place. ‘A complete rejection of commercial
theatre’ (Viagas, 2004: 72).
In New York, there are two divides between work being created, these strands are known as ‘Uptown’ –
where a more traditional culture resides and ‘Downtown’ (Off-Off or Off-Broadway) – where alternative
visual and performative art tends to be developed. These are not necessarily defined by buildings or
geographical locations, however, off-off-Broadway work is more commonly found in lofts and basements
where residence is illegal (Salzman & Desi, 2008: 229-230).
Gesamtkunstwerk
This theory is one, which links specifically to music theatre. The term refers to an all-embracing art form,
which includes poetry, sonic media, movement and multimedia in a singular performance All elements are
of upmost importance, as in music theatre where the sonic event created is as important as its context. I do
8
Broadway theatres to this day have a certain number of musicians that must be employed regardless of the work
playing in the theatre.
9
See Appendix C for more details.
Ryan Green 15
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
not wish to focus upon this concept but I need to have an awareness of it when writing extensively about
music theatre. It is not uncommon also, for new musical theatre works to incorporate new multimedia in
their performances.
Coda
Already, from this chapter, it is obvious that a musician’s role within the theatre arts is constantly
changing. Most extra work given by directors and producers tends to be within the field of music theatre.
As I previously wrote, opera has also undertaken several new dramatic changes in the way musicians are
deployed as stage performers. There is a fine line between the theatricalisation or musicalisation of a work
and absolute music theatre where material is created specific to one particular production. Music Theatre
and the concept of Gesamtkunstwerk are closely linked and it is often the practice for composers to aim
for this while writing new works.
10
Absolute music theatre is a term I propose for music theatre that has been devised or created using entirely fresh
material by a composer or devising group. It does not contain music by ‘external’ artists. All the material is created
anew for the production.
Ryan Green 16
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
This continuum puts into practice Hübner’s concept of the correct title given to a music theatre
performer. At the far left the musician is found to have an accompanying role only, with no additional
11
Interestingly, Goebbles is a fellow of Dartington College of Arts.
Ryan Green 17
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
responsibility, they are working solely as a musician. As the responsibility given increases, the musician
adds titles to his primary title for example: Musician/Actor, until they have so much extra responsibility
that they become a performance artist in title and in role.
The violinist’s part is most interesting here, as the performer who plays this is the representation of
Einstein himself. The performer must be able to memorise the entire score and perform through four acts
whilst remembering choreography and wearing full costume.
12
I use the term music theatre work here in the same way Glass does, however, the full score describes the work as
an ‘opera’.
13
‘/’ implies doubling of instruments.
Ryan Green 18
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Bow Down
Bow Down (1977) is a music theatre work, composed by Harrison Birtwistle. Within this work it has often
been suggested that the actors ‘are just as much musicians as the musicians are actors’ and that there is
only ‘a relatively slight difference in the emphasis’ between the two (Adlington in Beard, 2012: 302).
The piece is easy to stage, because it requires very few resources, and was devised during a strike at the
National Theatre. The score is a notation of the work created at the time but performers have much
Ryan Green 19
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
‘Bow Down tells the classic folk-talk [sic] of two sisters in love with [the] same man. The Dark
Sister drowns the Fair Sister, but the Fair Sister's body is found and turned into a musical
instrument which accuses the Dark Sister. As such it is akin to the folk-tale […] Mahler used in
Das Klagende Lied. Harrison's text conflates a variety of variants of the story including one in
Middle English which, sung by a blind harper, sort of starts and finishes the show’ (Planet Hugil,
2012).
The piece can be described as a macabre folk tale. The instrumentation reflects that of a ritual: Bamboo
flutes (tranverse & end blown); Oboe; Penny-Whistle; Claves; Wood Block; Sand Block; Afuche; Maracca;
Crotales; Sistrum; Tambourine; Chinese drum and Bodhran.
I would like the music to lay bare something of the history of the instrumentalists, which belongs
to the history of the working people. I would like the instrumentalists to interpret themselves
consciously, and to extend their scope, so that they see themselves as inhabiting a realm of
increased possibilities – possibilities of self-realization [sic] and self-liberation […] (Schmitt in
Adlington in Cook (ed.), 2005: 238).
There is much use of repeated rhythmic motifs with rhyming text. There are five actors and four
musicians, although, each performs from a collection of fourteen different instruments; the musicians
(numbered: 1, 4, 6 & 9) play between six and nine instruments each, the actors (numbered: 2, 3, 5, 7 & 8)
between three and five. No instruments are wholly dictated for the actors, but all nine players are given a
set of claves and a set of set of sand blocks. The musicians never leave their seats and actors 3 and 7 play
the roles of the Fair and Dark sisters and 8: the blind Harper (Beard, 2012: 302).
Alltag
Falk Hübner’s music theatre completely immerses the actor into the role of a ‘music-creator’14. He has
written many pieces where the musician is the primary performer and holds the audience’s attention
throughout the work.
Alltag (2007) as a piece, focuses upon the quotidian habits of a working musician. Hübner writes that he
was interested in the ‘phenomena […] of [their] profession in a self reflective view of the musician’
(Hübner, 2013: 26). The piece begins with an empty stage, not conventionally lit for a performance. The
audience enters and takes their seats and the musicians begin to enter the room, carrying their
14
N.B. As a performer not a composer.
Ryan Green 20
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
instruments, they head toward the stage and begin putting together their instruments. These elements are
those which are traditionally absent on a professional concert stage, all tuning and assembly of
instruments are carried out backstage and out of sight of the audience. The piece mixes spoken text with
musical performance, movement and comedy 15 . Here the musician truly has become the theatrical
performer by having their role expanded to encompass these non-traditional responsibilities not usually
expected of a concert musician. This technique could also be described as mimesis, which is the imitation
of real life in art (Salzman & Desi, 2008: 13).
Coda
Overall, I believe that music theatre has the greatest potential for development. Musicals tend to have a set
stylistic genre that composers are limited by due to the popularity of the genre and the financial risk at
stake in producing a show. It costs millions of dollars to produce a musical on Broadway making
experimentation very difficult. Music Theatre works are produced on smaller scales, usually (off-)off-
Broadway and off-West End, where there is a more accepting audience and less financial input is required
from investors.
I believe that new music theatre is a catalyst for experimental praxis, whereas musical theatre, opera and
pantomime have clear defined parameters, in which a commercial formula has been fashioned and one
which audiences respond positively and enthusiastically to. Music Theatre has no limits; it can be as large
15
Which could also be known as Gesamtkunstwerk.
Ryan Green 21
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
or as small as it likes16.
16
Although it is important to remember that music theatre works to experiment with, combine and incorporate
with the two elements ‘music’ or ‘sound’ and ‘theatre’ or ‘drama’ along side other multimedia elements such as
radio, projection, mime, magic and lighting.
Ryan Green 22
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Spring Awakening
Spring Awakening (2006) is a musical written by Duncan Shiek and Steven Sater. This musical is of
particular interest as the characters, Georg and Ilse, move from their roles as actors to musicians. These
two characters are marked in the computerised score to play piano on certain songs. In ‘My Junk’, it is
obvious that Georg should play as he is in a piano lesson with his tutor. In ‘Mirror Blue Night’, Ilse is
instructed to play, whether this is an artistic choice or not is unclear however, in this particular song the
musical director/main pianist is playing the harmonium. This might mean that the producers of the show
stipulated to the orchestrator that it would be un-economical to employ two full-time keyboardists,
therefore the actors must ‘swing18’ as necessary.
The orchestra is set to the back of the stage, the actors must pass through the musicians to gain access to
the stage, other than this there is no acknowledgement between any member of the orchestra and the cast,
with the exception of when the named characters must leave their roles on stage and play the piano. Both
Georg and Ilse are suddenly no longer just musical theatre actors but have taken on the role of a
‘performance artist’.
17
Green, R. 2014. Page 6.
18
A ‘Swing’ refers to an actor who must be able to cover anything up to six different parts and can be called at a
moment’s notice to go on stage. In this instance I refer to Ilse as a swing between musician and stage actor.
Ryan Green 23
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
During the actors’ down time, they sit to stage right in full view of the audience although, like the
orchestra, it is not lit constantly. Again, it is not clear whether the actors are to break character whilst off
stage, and it also comes down to different interpretations of the material by different
directors/performance companies.
Once
Once (2011) completely removes the separation between actor and musician. The musical relies entirely
upon its novelty of using actor/musicians throughout the show. In the layout of a bar, the set is also
remarkable as it is minimal and stays static throughout; it is also used (on Broadway) as a real bar during
the act interval and for pre-show drinks. Thirteen performers, twelve playing instruments play the Irish-
folk score composed by Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglova. The performers, here, are given character
names, costumes, movement and choreography, their transition between spoken word ‘acting’ and playing
of instruments is seamless.
Once has very strong music theatre inclinations. The music is not stylistic of musical theatre and the show
it is small in scale when compared to other Broadway musicals. The music is written for an
unconventional instrumentation combination, it is experimental in the way that the audience are invited
onto stage to drink pre-show and during the interval and the profession of musicians as performers is
blindingly obvious. Conversely, Once fits the musical theatre genre by having a two act structure with
interval and the performers sing, dance and act as in traditional musical theatre, also it is a very easy work
to replicate as seen in London. However, the songs do not always drive the story making me feel that this
work is more of play with songs.
Ryan Green 24
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Sweeney Todd
John Doyle is a Scottish theatre director, currently working on Broadway. In 2005 he directed a
production of Sweeny Todd. The production consisted of actor/musicians with the exception of Sweeny
himself. David Lennon19 said: ‘all the actors are the orchestra. They’re producing all the music for the
show. [...] [W]e see it as an opportunity to address future situations on Broadway where an actor would be
acting as a valid musician, [...] playing a part integral to the musical score’ (Lennon in Armburst, 2005).
Due to Equity rules, the agreement set the criteria under which the actors could be counted towards the
minimum requirement of musicians working in the Eugenen O’Neil Theater [sic].
‘We may not usually think of musical performance, apart from opera and musical theatre, as
entailing characterization in the conventional dramatic sense. Nevertheless, we must be
suspicious of any supposition that musicians are simply ‘being themselves’ on stage. [...] But two
other layers are imposed on that one because popular musicians […] enact both a star personality
(their image) and a song personality, the role that each lyric requires, and the pop star’s art is to
keep both acts in play at once’ (Auslander, 2004: 1).
There are several major differences between the London 2004/Broadway 2005 (both directed by Doyle)
and the London 2012 Production20, the main differences being the cast size and orchestration. Broadway
used a cast of ten actor/musicians who were the only performers in the show, whilst London used nine
principal characters and an ensemble of twenty-one, totalling thirty on stage alone21. The Broadway
production was more subtle in its orchestration, but relied heavily on the piano which didn’t suit the
atmosphere trying to be created.
19
Local 802’s president at the time. (American Federation of Musicians).
20
The production’s tryout was at Chichester Festival Theatre.
21
I could not find one electronic source that listed the musicians in the orchestra, which still astounds me, this
implies to me that musicians are not considered as important to the production as the cast, unlike opera where a
position such as first violin is a much coveted one.
Ryan Green 25
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Hairspray
Figure 5: Lon Hoyt directs the cut-off of ‘You Can’t Stop the Beat – Part 1’. (You Can't Stop The Beat –
Hairspray (Conductor Cam), 2013)
The conductor too plays an important extended role in new musical theatre. A keyboard part is more
commonly played by a pianist/conductor as in Hairspray (2002) on Broadway. With new methods of
communication they must conduct into a camera, which is relayed backstage for off-stage vocalists; it is
also relayed to most music desks within the pit. The band play to click tracks, also controlled by the
conductor, and the microphone to the conductors left, shown above, is linked to the orchestra’s
headphones to enable him to count in numbers and control vamps. In Hairspray, the pianist-conductor
also puts on a ‘sparkly’ jacket during the finale: ‘You Can’t Stop the Beat – Part 2.'
Ryan Green 26
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Orchestras in traditional opera and musical theatre were placed below the stage apron where occasionally
only the conductor could be seen to direct the stage performers whilst performing arias and ballads and
other numbers crucial to the story-telling of the show. In more recent years the orchestra pit has been
disappearing particularly in productions such as Cats, where a stage design dictated that a pit would create
a barrier between the stage performers and their audience22. This was therefore removed so that the stage
design – in this case a junkyard, spilt out of the proscenium and into the first few rows of seating, thus
allowing the work to feel more immersive. New contemporary musical theatre productions such as We
Will Rock You and Blood Brothers have the orchestra hidden within the set design to stage right and left,
suspended above the wings to prevent removing seats thus creating more tickets to sell. This also allows
more room for musicians who previously would have been in cramped and very hot quarters below the
stage. This placement also allows for the use of air conditioning, helping to keep instruments in tune
throughout the act. The conductors communicate with the orchestra and the cast via television monitors
placed above the musician’s desks so as to reduce strain on performers’ necks. Having monitors in stage
performers’ eye lines is also cleaner for the audience to watch; their view is not hindered by a conductor
waving their arms about, instead, cut- offs or buttons23 are more spontaneous and sharper, creating a more
unified sound.
In musicals such as Catch Me if you Can (2011, Broadway), the orchestra is set to the back of the stage and
act, purely as a concert band, the story is shown in ‘flash-back’ and performed as if the performers are
there purely to tell a story. In the final song of the show, Frank Abagnale Jr, the show’s protagonist, says
‘Goodbye’ to the audience; the lyrics are sung as if the whole performance is exactly that, a performance,
as if the show is purely for entertainment. Furthermore, the audience are not invited into the show’s
‘world’ but remain alienated throughout and the fourth wall is often broken. By having the orchestra
visible to the audience throughout, they are further reminded that they are watching a performance.
22
In Cats the fourth wall is often broken.
23
A ‘button’ is a chord (usually the final chord progression would follow a pattern similar to this: IV, V, I - I) at the
end of a song that signifies to the audience it’s over and prompts them to applaud.
Ryan Green 27
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Figure 6: Lyrics from ‘Goodbye’, Catch Me if You Can – (Shaiman & Wittman, 2011, 14)
Shawn Emamjomeh writes that ‘A live Broadway show […] breaths and changes on a nightly basis due to
myriad reasons,’ and ‘we have a remarkable medium in which performances are taped, edited, and frozen;
it’s called film’ (in Meffe, 2011: 110).
The question Hübner asks in his PhD thesis (2013: 141) is ‘does a theatre without performers mean the
end of theatre?’ My answer here is ‘possibly’. I believe that there is a fine line between an ‘art installation’
and ‘theatre’. I believe that in order for a theatre work to exist, it must engage live performers whereas an
Ryan Green 28
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
art installation requires no live performance24. The presence of the ‘human element’, even if it is not seen,
still makes a work ‘theatre’. On the other hand, fine art installations are works where there is no human
presence, music and design will already be prepared and left to run during the work, which is usually a
durational, static display which its intended audience may enter, and leave.
Coda
From this research it is clear that musicians do have a widening role in all music driven theatre genres
including opera, musical theatre and music theatre and directors and producers are asking more and more
of musicians and pushing them further towards becoming multi-disciplinary practitioners. It is also clear
that the title of ‘musician’ is no longer appropriate but is clearer to laymen who might not understand the
concept of a contemporary ‘performance artist’. Furthermore, the title ‘performance artist’ is one which
confuses people as it has connotations and links to experimental artists rather that those working in
mainstream media. It is also evident that the musician is still considered secondary to actors within
musical theatre even though music is considered the most important aspect of a musical show. However,
in opera and music theatre musicians as performance artists are very much in the forefront of the ‘action’
and remain the driving force behind works, especially where experimentation is prevalent and budgets are
tight. The concept of the orchestra pit is fast disappearing and cleaner, more modern methods of
conductor-orchestra-actor communication are suitable and more popular, nay becoming common
practice.
24
By live performers I refer to the presence of all those involved in putting a performance work on –
sound and lighting technicians, out-of-sight musicians and alike.
Ryan Green 29
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Conclusion
My research hypothesis was: The role of the musician within music theatre and musical theatre has
become one, which is so extended that their job title is no longer appropriate. From my research, I
believe this is proven. Musicians, in this work, are given so much extra responsibility that their initial
working title of ‘musician’ is no longer appropriate. This new hybrid performer is a singer, a dancer, an
actor, a musician and in some cases a circus performer and much more, which creates the title of
‘performance artist’. This is true of all music driven theatre, but it is in fact in music theatre the musician’s
role has been seen to be expanded or reduced the most.
From this dissertation, it is clear a musician is no longer just a musician when working in new music
theatre and some new musical theatre works. Theatre musicians already spend years training, honing their
craft, usually from a very young age. They sit examinations in theory and practice then study on university
level courses. Conductors and musical directors may even attend further education, however, Broadway
composers and directors are looking for even more from them. Musicians often have less time to learn
their books and there is often limited ensemble rehearsal time, which is often reserved for notes and
synchronisation not for learning parts (Jacobson, 2012).
In new music theatre, we are seeing that performers are working as multi-disciplinary artists, very much
like musical theatre. However, here, we are seeing that musicians are also having less responsibility over
control of their instruments or the sound that they produce. In musical theatre the orchestra were more
inclined to follow the singers who had more creative control over the way their arias or ballads were
performed. Historically, the orchestra or musicians would have the ultimate control over the overall
performance of an opera.
Although Hübner’s expansive and reductive approach is interesting, we must be weary of removing all
responsibility from the musician as we then change their professional identity. Music driven theatre
cannot exist without ‘music’. Actors and singers rely upon those who compose, orchestrate and perform
music. A music driven theatre work cannot exist without these major elements in place.
The future of musical theatre is unclear. There are few young British artists writing new work and the
West End is relying on revivals such as Miss Saigon as well as long running productions such as Les
Misérables and The Phantom of the Opera in order to keep attracting visitors. There are currently five big
Ryan Green 30
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Broadway-transfer musicals playing in London including: Once, The Book of Mormon and Wicked whereas
only one new British musical opened last year (2013) - Stephen Ward. The West End is struggling for new
work and currently straight plays are becoming more and more popular. Music Theatre too has an
uncertain future. This slightly confused art form tends not to be at the top of peoples’ choice of theatre,
mainly due to its experimental nature but also because of its links to opera and the ‘high-class’ perception
that theatre goers sometimes attribute it to. ‘Music Theatre’ is a phrase, which is commonly used
incorrectly as an umbrella term, and because of this, is often confused with musical theatre. For music
theatre to be fully accepted as a ‘household’ name: either the syntax needs to be clearer or a solid
explanation needs to be universally applied.
This dissertation agrees with, and confirms research already carried out by Dr Hübner. It will hopefully
feed into new, younger music theatre and musical theatre practitioners’ work, and will serve as a body of
research for reference. New music driven theatre is constantly looking for ways to change and develop.
Practitioners are endlessly searching for fresh ideas and ways to deliver effective performance that is
relevant to contemporary audiences. This dissertation has looked towards past and current practices but
can only speculate as to what the future holds for these exciting and dynamic art forms.
Ryan Green 31
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Appendices
A concise, academic description of Music Driven Theatre Art Forms and un-common/new terms
A few sample rulings from the American Musicians’ Union regarding minimums required for
Broadway theatres and the use of electronic instruments within musical performances.
Facsimiles of pages from Dr Falk Hübner’s PhD thesis regarding this approach.
Ryan Green 32
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Appendix A: Definitions
This appendix details definitions of terminology used within this dissertation. There is often much
confusion between music theatre and musical theatre. Reasons for this include not just the syntax of the
title given to such theatre works, but the often indistinct definitions of the two.
Music Theatre
Music Theatre is a small-scale, highly experimental, avant-garde art form. The term ‘music theatre’ is
relatively new to the art world. The term comes from a bastardisation of the German ‘Musiktheater’.
Walter Felsenstein coined this phrase in the 1940s (Bawtree in Watson, 2005: 11). The problem with this
phrase could be particular to the English language. The French inclinations of our language lead us to
consider ‘theatre’ to be syntactically foremost (Watson, 2005: 11). In simple terms music theatre could be
said to be a ‘desired sonic event’ involving the elements of music such as pitch; timbre; rhythm and
duration in a certain context such as ‘theatre’. This again can be broken down into gesture; text;
place/space or harmonic space (Vella, 2003).
Music Theatre is often wrongly used as an umbrella term where ‘theatre music’ or ‘music driven theatre’
should be used instead.
‘[‘T]heater music’ […] [T]he music one hears in accompaniment to a piece of theatre.’
Music Theatre is often created for idiosyncratic ensembles, which is often a barrier to revivals or repeat
performances (Devlin, 1992: 41) Music Theatre works don’t necessarily have to include ‘music’, but must
‘breathe a musical energy’, works are often devised with all production elements such as lighting, music,
movement, chorography thought about before performance. Within music theatre there tends to be no set
roles for performers to play. Actors become musicians and musicians become actors, although this is not a
significant or specific trait.
Ryan Green 33
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Appendix A: (Continued).
No higher precedence is given to music or theatre and capitalisation for one, means capitalisation for both,
i.e. ‘Music Theatre’ or ‘music theatre’.
Musical Theatre
Musical theatre has very clear boundaries, the work is based on popular music, ‘mainstream music’ if you
will, where the ‘show’ is driven by music, more specifically songs. The songs are only included to further
the story line or to show the development of a character’s dramatis personae. Very much like opera works,
musicals usually consist of two acts with an overture or a prologue and an entr’acte. It is not unusual for a
musical to contain only one act such as The Last Five Years, or First Date. In a musical, there is a clear
dramatic framework and they tend to lean toward contemporary subjects and quotidian characters
(Taylor, 2000: 332). Musical theatre first developed in the 1960s alongside music theatre, since then it has
incorporated the use of electronic instruments, but still very much relies upon using memorable melodies
and lush orchestrations which will encourage audiences to keep attending the theatre and buying the cast
recordings.
Gesamtkunstwerk
Gesamtkunstwerk is a Wagnerian concept meaning ‘all embracing art-form’, which some music theatre
works are described as, practically those whose composers, which take a multi-disciplinary approach to
creating work. The concept is similar to Autaud’s theory of ‘total theatre’ where all elements of theatre are
of upmost importance. Gesamtkunstwerk includes: poetry, music/sound, dance, movement, multimedia
such as radio, projection and any other creative material known.
End of Appendix A
Ryan Green 34
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Rule A
In the 1950s, it was common for every Broadway theatre, hotel and nightclub or entertainment
establishment to have a contract with the musicians’ union that dictated the minimum number of
musicians that must be employed in their ‘space’. In the earliest Local 802 collective files (dated 2nd
September 1963, minimums were based on the size of the theatre:
1. Where the theatre has between 1000 and 1100 seats, the orchestra shall consist of a minimum of
sixteen men.
2. Where the theatre has over 1100 seats, the minimum shall be twenty-five men.
3. Where the theatre has less than 1000 seats, the minimum number of men shall be fixed by the
union’s Executive Board.
‘The position of conductor too counted toward the minimum.’ (Meffe, 2011: 100)
Rule B
Electronic instruments such as the Moog, RCA Synthesizer, etc., shall not be used without the
express permission of the Local 802 Executive Board, Such permission shall be granted if use of
electronic instruments does not displace or diminish the earning capacity of any musician.
(ibid.)
End of Appendix B
Ryan Green 35
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
(ibid, 101)
Ryan Green 36
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Appendix C: (Continued).
(ibid, 144)
End of Appendix C
Ryan Green 37
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Bibliography
ARMBURST, R. 2005. 'Sweeny' Actors Joining Musicians. Back Stage, 9/1(35), 1-6.
AUSLANDER, P. 2004. Performance Analysis and Popular Music: A Manifesto. Contemporary Theatre
Review, 14(1), 1-13.
BEARD, D. 2012. Harrison Birtwistle’s Operas and Music Theatre. Cambridge; Cambridge University
Press.
COLE, B. 1972. Two Essays in Music Theatre. The Musical Times, Vol. 113(1547), 38.
COLLINSON, F. 1941. Orchestration for the Theatre. (Second Edition). London; The Bodley Head.
COKER, T. 2006. Dramma per Musica: Towards a New Music Theatre. PhD; University of Reading.
Volume 1; 39-46.
COOK, M. (Ed.) 2005. The Cambridge Companion to Twentieth-Century Opera. Cambridge; Cambridge
University Press.
DEVLIN, G. 1992. Beggar’s Opera: A Discussion Document on Small-Scale Touring Opera and Music-
Theatre in the U.K.. London; Calouste Gulbenkain Foundation.
GLASS, P. and. JONES, R. (ed.) 1987. Music by Philip Glass. (First Edition). New York; Harper & Row.
GREEN, R. 2014. Music Theatre: Concepts, Theories and Practices. (First Edition). Ross-on-Wye; Pineapple
Music Productions.
HEILE, B. 2006. Music of Mauricio Kagel. Aldershot, England; Burlington, VT: Ashgate.
HÜBNER, F. 2013. Shifting Identities: The Musician as Theatrical Performer. PhD; Leiden University.
KENDRICK, L., and ROESNER, D. (eds.). 2011. Theatre Noise: The Sound of Performance. Newcastle;
Cambridge Scholars.
MEFFE, R. 2011. How Many Musicians does it take? A History and Analysis of the Shrinking Broadway Pit
Orchestra. Studies in Musical Theatre, 5(1), 99-115.
Ryan Green 38
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Rebstock, M., and Roesner, D. (eds.). 2012. Composed Theatre: Aesthetics, Practices, Processes. Bristol;
Intellect.
SALZMAN, E., and DESI, T. 2008. New Music Theater: Seeing the Voice, Hearing the Body. Oxford;
Oxford University Press.
SATER, S. and SHEIK, D. 2006. Spring Awakening [MUSIC SCORE]. New York; Music Theatre
International.
SUSKIN, S. 2009. Sound of Broadway Music: A Book of Orchestrators and Orchestrations. New York;
Oxford; Oxford University Press.
TAYLOR, M. 2000. Music in Theatre: Towards a methodology for examining the interaction of music and
drama in the theatre works of the twentieth century. PhD; University of Exeter.
VIAGAS, Robert. 2004. The Back Stage Guide to Broadway. New York: Watson-Guptill Publications.
WATSON, J. 2005. Music theatre: approaches to a greater formal synthases. PhD; University of Exeter.
Ryan Green 39
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Webography
GREEN, J. 2006. 'What Happened to the Overture?' New York Times [ONLINE]. Available at:
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/01/theater/01gree.html?pagewanted=all&_r=. [Accessed: 13 February
2014].
HISCHAK, T. 2008. '“Overture . . . Dim the Lights”: The Fifteen Best Broadway Overtures' [ONLINE].
OUPBlog. Available at: http://blog.oup.com/2008/07/overture/. [Accessed: 13 February 2014].
JACOBSON, A. 2012. The role of the pit musician in musical theatre [ONLINE]. On A Good Review:
Theatre reviews and commentary from a musician’s perspective. Available at:
http://agoodreedreview.com/2012/12/24/pit-musicians-commentary. [Accessed: 27 February 2014].
Marina Abramovic Biography, Art, and Analysis of Works | The Art Story. 2014. Marina Abramovic
Biography, Art, and Analysis of Works | The Art Story. [ONLINE] Available at:
http://www.theartstory.org/artist-abramovic-marina.htm. [Accessed: 08 April 2014].
PETERSEN, J. 2012. 'Introduction to the Theatre'. University of Idaho [ONLINE]. Available at:
http://www.webpages.uidaho.edu/thea101/chapters/chapter_19.htm. [Accessed: 19 February 2014].
Planet Hugill - A world of classical music: Bow Down. 2012. Planet Hugill - A world of classical music:
Bow Down. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.planethugill.com/2012/06/bow-down.html. [Accessed: 04
March 2014].
SHAIMAN, M. and WITTMAN, S., 2011, Digital Booklet from Catch Me if You Can [ONLINE] Avalible
at: http://www.scribd.com/doc/202548804/catch-me-if-you-can-digital-booklet. New York; Ghostlight
Records. [Accessed: 5 April 2014].
SMITH, N. 2012. 'The Performer Portraying Einstein does Not Speak during the show, Though He does
Play the Violin’. Einstein on the Beach Hailed by Critics Despite Hiccups [ONLINE]. BBC. Available at:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-17993364. [Accessed: 16 February 2014].
Ryan Green 40
Actor, Singer, Dancer and Musician? BA Music
Videography
Rockgodpatrick. 2013. You Can’t Stop The Beat – Hairspray (Conductor Cam). [ONLINE VIDEO]
Available at: < http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lWdTxQz5dRo> [Accessed: 2 March 2014].
Ryan Green 41