7972020
€
Inia through the fm lens
EcoPolitical
India through the film lens <
May 30, 2020
It is not far fetched to believe that films reflect the ‘mood’ of the nation. In this post | attempt
to analyse the Indian film landscape and break it down into bite sized pieces
To represent Indian films, | have used the Bollywood as the narrow definition. While this is
unfair to thriving film industries in every state | have done so only for the convenience, and not
out of disrespect. Bollywood also offers the additional benefit that Hindi films are consumed.
without subtitles in large parts of India where Hindi is not the primary language.
To represent the ‘mood’ | have taken the top netting film of each year since 1940 (80 years).
One can safely assume that the earnings of each film is representative of its acceptance
across the country. There has been a stupendous growth in how much the top film each year
makes. If one were to make an index of the earnings of the top grossing films with 100 as the
value in 1940, the value in 2019 of such an hypothetical index would be 56,527. For
perspective, the Dow Jones index rose from 131 to 28,538 in the same period. | have made the
below chart on a semi-log scale otherwise it simply looks parabolic.
Index of highest grossers
‘A common belief is that films have linearly reduced in length over the years, but this is not
entirely accurate. Films used be in the 140-150 minute ranae from 1940-1959. after which the
tps: ecopoliicalingia blogspot com/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html
sno7972020 Inia through the fm lens
< EcoPolitical Q
Minutes in tengtn;turtinatly cropping to~15U minutes wr the last ter" years:
Average runtime (mins)
While of limited academic value it is nevertheless interesting to see how much the top
grossing film makes in INR per minute of its run-time. The top earning film in the last decade
made $245,000 per minute of its reel, up from $60000 from the period 2000-2009. Note this is
still a far cry from Hollywood movies where Avengers:Endgame averaged over $15 million per
minute of its runtime, suggesting that there is a long revenue runway ahead for Indian films.
There truly is no business like show business.
Nett (Rs)/ minute of runtime
39.00.00
This exploding revenue of films is not entirely surprising given a large population and a hot
climate that makes film viewing on the weekends the primary source of entertainment for the
cee Diotareatieieiecime vel mcsulewa Lanse ten valasitebanisa Alamein concsaaiael omiSM AE
hips: ecopoliicalingia blogspot con/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html 2n07972020
€
Ina trough the fm tens
EcoPolitical
‘quality mall'space that was just T million Square feet jumped to 60 million Square feet by 20087
Please note that | am not saying that multi screens in malls were the only drivers of increased
film consumption (though | believe they did contribute a large chunk), but that they represent a
change in the Indian propensity to consume, which is also reflected in film viewing
‘Average Nett oftop films (Rs mn)
2000
2500
2000
2010-2018
But in this post | am not simply interested in the ‘business’ of films, but in how films shape
society, and how they are shaped by society. Note that | have not viewed 80 films for this post
in the interests of time and my sanity, but have read their synopsis to the extent | thought
necessary.
‘The period 1940-49 was characterized by ‘poverty’ being the main character in films. Usually it
dealt with both main protagonists being poor, or an odd film with one rich-one poor plot. The
film names were short, usually just one word and oddly intriguing enough to evince interest.
For example the top earning film of 1941 was named 'Khazanchi, a title that encourages me to
watch the film. The only top film in this decade with a two word title was Anmol Ghadi of 1946.
This decade also saw the first film of my list that was named after the lead female character
(Zeenat from 1945). Two stand out films in terms of broader plot were 'Khazanchi' which was
from the “mystery” genre and ‘Shaheed’ which had the backdrop of India’s freedom struggle,
and is the first ‘patriotic’ film on this list. Not surprising since it was released in 1948, a year
after India's freedom in 1947. This decade also saw the first appearance of Dilip Kumar on this
list in the love tragedy Jugnu in 1947.
The decade from 1950-59 saw a clear change from the ‘poverty’ focus. This is not to say that
poverty as a backdrop vanished from films but it was accompanied by a bit more in terms of
hips: ecopoliiclingia blogspot con/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html
ano61972020
€
Inia through the film lens
EcoPolitical
iran, 1onUWeU Up HY 1y99 Ly ANTAIRAH (WHE UIE TepeaeU SAMITTANAIRGN) WIEIE IS aOUTET Toya
ince affair with poor girl). Interestingly 1955 saw Shree 420
affair with roles reversed (rich
which is the first film on my list which shows a character moving to a city to make it big (but
then of course being cheated and drawn to crime). This decade was noteworthy for the
experimental forays that were loved by the audiences, whether it was the 1956 C.I.D.
(investigative), or Mother India (1957), the first film here that deals with nature versus nuture.
Reportedly, Mother India was made as a rebuff to the racist denigration of India and Indians by
an American novelist. Here's what | read regarding this incident on wikipedia’
‘tuys ete yo re yay te 8
But for me the standout film of this decade was 1958's Madhumati, which is the first
paranormal film dealing with past life, reincarnation and ghosts. Notably this was the joint
second highest earning film of the decade behind Mother India, tieing with Shree 420 for the
public's wallet. | must also mention Anari which was the first truly masala film on the list with
elements of several genres (class struggle, love story, separation, murder investigation). Anati
also introduced the quintessential Mrs. D'sa character, a benevolent non-Hindu who takes care
of aHindu.
1960-69 saw even more diversity in the stories being portrayed. Apart from Mughal-e-azam
which is well known as the highest earning film of this decade, there were several ‘firsts’,
Ganga Jamna (1961) was the first sibling rivalry film where the elder brother provides for the
younger brothers education. The younger brother becomes a police officer while the elder
becomes a ciminal. Sounds familiar? Yeah, this was the first of its kind to catch the public's
fancy. The decade also saw the success of Waqt, which was the first film that dealt with a
family being separated and later re-uniting. Another horror/thriller, Bees Saal Baad, released
during this decade. Another patriotic film called ‘Upkaar' was released in 1967. This was the
first film by Manoj Kumar that dealt with social issues, family planning, on differences between
westem and eastern culture, and evils of black-marketing, Another notable ‘first’ was the
action/adventure film Aankhen that introduced the concept of a vigilante group that fights the
nation’s enemies. It is also the first in this list to be shot in foreign locales.
htps:ecopoliicalingia blogspot con/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html
ano7972020
€
Inia through the fm lens
EcoPolitical
‘ari’ Mgaddar Wa’ Sikaridar“Gealt With This tHeMTie”" Seeta "aur Geeta "also Had the "additional
angle of having a female lead, and a double role. Amar Akbar Anthony was also the first film
on this list with the inter-religious bhaichaara narrative being attempted to be pushed (this
theme being introduced in 1959's Anari). Amitabh Bacchan dominated this decade by claiming
the top film spot from 1974 to 1979. Notably, 1971 and 1973 saw two very different films
being released with Haati Mere Saathi and Bobby. Note that the class struggle while still
present in the films, was no longer the primary driver for the script, and more subtly cloaked in
other narratives. What surprised me is how the public so wholeheartedly accepted the exact
same theme of separation and reunification almost every single year to the extent of making
these films the top grossers. One wonders if this theme was a source of comfort for a
generation that continued to see hardships despite years since independence. The familiarity
of the theme meant no nasty surprises for an audience that ‘wanted out' from daily stress, and
the eventual on-screen reunification gave hope to the masses that ‘eventually’ things would
work out for them too. Notably, this was the first decade since 1940 which did not see a
patriotism themed film that would top the charts. Interestingly the top film in 1974 was "Roti
Kapda aur Makaan" which roughly translates to “food, clothing, and shelter’. This was
noteworthy because not only was this the election slogan of Indira Gandhi, it also highlighted
how even neatly three decades of independence and virtually one party rule, the basic
necessities of life (just to sustain life) were the top concem of the people. And remember, it
was the fledgling middle class who was largely watching these movies, suggesting that even
the slightly well off identified with the struggle for the basic necessities of life. RKM also saw
the first appearance of Amitabh Bachan, albeit in a supporting role.
1980-89 saw influence of Amitabh Bacchan wane with only 2 films among the top grossers
including the ultra macho Mard in 1985 (in part perhaps due to this health issues after 1983)
The second film was 1983's Coolie which saw some of the most obvious communist
propaganda with the ‘sickle and hammer’ symbol banged right on the promotional posters.
Pethaps the apogee of Soviet influence on Indian politcians, and their control of the cultural
environment that began in the 1960s. This was also one of the first films that saw a Muslim
man as the main character with a Hindu sidekick. Its acceptance by the public bears
testimony to the social flexibility displayed by Indians in general. This decade saw two stand
out films, a) 1988's Mr. India which was the first scifi film about an invisible man and b)
‘Tezaab which was perhaps the darkest mainstream film to grace the screens. The film dealt
with angst of youth, broken dreams, dysfunctional families where fathers exploit daughters
etc. It was almost as a bounce back that 1989 saw relief with Maine Pyaar Kiya, an out and out
chocolate romantic film far removed from the action and darkness of Tezaab. This decade
belonged to Anil Kapoor who delivered the top films in 1986, 1987, and 1988. The only patriotic
il seeue Satbeual selene lana nt aheneoan On AMS acueret ana NeniANETA KRM OTLNOKSEUE AIAG!
htps:ecopoliicalingia blogspot com/2020/05/inci-through-ons. html
sno7972020
€
Inia through the fm lens
EcoPolitical
The 1990s saw India liberalizing and perhaps allowed the young population to relax a bit.
Poverty glorification stopped, or at least reduced in films. Romances, comedies, family love,
and similar dominated this decade. Dil, Saajan, Hum Aapke Hain Kaun, Dilwaly Dulhaniya Le
Jayenge, Kuch Kuch Hota Hain, Hum Saath Saath Hain, Raja Hindustani, were the kind of films
that found favour with audiences across the nation. The two standouts for me were 1993's
‘Aakhen which was a fun comedy caper film that did not focus on romance, and 1997's Border
that was the first film that directly dealt with Pakistan, India's enemy at the gates. But it was
clear that post liberalisation and the ending of the forced glorification of poverty, the public's
mood was rose tinted glasses and sepia tones. Also note that film makers were getting more
liberal with the titles, with some of them four words long, a far cry from the one word titles
from a few decades back.
Honestly 2000-2009 | was unable to spot any over riding themes. The lead actors of the
previous decades attempted to recapture their hey days by making romantic films like Veer
Zara, and Devdas. However, this decade saw a clear shift to a different kind of film making
towards films that veered between slapstick, almost nonsensical comedies (like 2005's No
Entry) and films that emphasized style over substance (Dhoom 2). Gadar from 2001 was the
only partiotic film made in this decade that was on the backdrop of a love story between a sikh
man and a muslim girl. The decade also saw the second mainstream scii film called Koi mil
gaya’, after Mr. India that had come 16 years prior. The fag end of the decade saw the
emergence of what | like to call overt agenda films, i.e. films that make certain life ideals
sound ‘cool’. 2009's 3 Idiots that furthered the idea of “pursuing one’s dreams at the cost of
stability" was one such in my opinion. This film is actually the second overt ‘agenda film’ by
‘Aamir Khan the leading actor. The first was Rang De Basanti, which attempted to cloak
anarchy as patriotism in 2006, in my opinion. So perhaps overt ‘agenda’ film making can be
regarded as the defining feature of this decade? Coincidentally, the earnings of the ‘patriotic’
hit film by decade are on average equal to, if not higher than the average earnings of other top
films of the decade, though with a declining trend.
htps:ecopoliicalingia blogspot con/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html
eno7972020 Inia through the fm lens
< EcoPolitical Q
Patriotic Film earnings/ Ave
The last decade (2010-2019) has been peppered with films that focused more on style than
substance, a trend that had been successfully experimented with in the prior decade
Dabangg, Bodyguard, Ek Tha Tiger, Dhoom 3, Bajrangi Bhaijaan, Tiger Zinda Hain, War, are all
examples of this theme. It almost feels like Indians do not want to deal with any sort of reality
at all. There were attempts to make some more overt propaganda films like 2014's PK, and
even 2012's Oh My God (which did not make it to the top, but deals with pushing ideology
cloaked in comedy, ike PK). | believe that this quality of film making is a direct consequence of
the ‘star system’ that has become entrenched in Bollywood since the emergence of Amitabh
Bacchan as a ‘superstar’ in the mid 1970s. In fact 37 years of the last 46 (since Amitabhis
Bacchanis first appearance on our topper list in Roti Kapda aur Makan in 1974), have seen
films starring just one of six actors! This trend has only become stronger in the recent years,
as can been seen from the below chart
No of top film years by lead actors
hips: ecopoliicalingia blogspot com/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html 7061972020
€
Inia through the film lens
EcoPolitical
But overall easy money (due to factors mentioned earlier - lack of other entertainment sources,
and not to mention the film being sold just on the basis of the ‘star face’) seems to have
disconnected films from reality. Or is this disconnection a reflection of society itself?
In conclusion it is worth mentioning that the emergence of online streaming services over the
last few years is an area worth examining for social implications. The emergence of a ‘richer’
middle class and access to cheap data plans has its own dynamics. To that extent one can
even argue that overt agenda peddling can be noticed from such web series because they can
be targeted better to audiences. Series such as Sacred Games, Ghoul, Delhi Crime, She, Lust
Stories, Godman, and | imagine many more have an agenda that is evident to anyone who
looks, Media and society have a feedback loop. Media is influenced by and also in turn
influences societies and it is an important space to be watched to not only observe India, but
also observe those who want to shape India in a certain way.
Data on highest earners run meet hasbeen taken rom mb cam
<
eo Unknown 9 June 2020 at
Wow! this is Amazing! Do you know your hidden name meaning ? Scratch here
to find your hidden name mea
REPLY DELETE
eo Enter your comment.
Panuilar naste fram this hla
hips: ecopoliicalingia blogspot cor/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html
ano7972020 Inia through the fm lens
< EcoPolitical Q
August 23, 2019
Rahguram Rajan (RR) is indeed a well known personality from the field of
global economics. The son of a bureaucrat in India, RR went on to study in
some of the most elite universities in the world. He came to be
READ MORE
The crux of the core: On Inflation, Exchange rates and Interest cuts
anuary 17,2019
‘Summary: Significantly flattening yield curves coupled with extremely low
inflation that is dampening business sentiment necessitates an aggressive
cutting of interest rates in India in conjunction with other mar -
READ MORE
CoronaVirus: Does data justify mass testing?
April 02, 2020
Ss sie As the world faces the brunt of the Chinese Coronavirus caused Covid19
disease there are calls for indiscriminate testing to be carried out by each
country to detect cases. While | am not a epidemiologist or st
READ MORE
G) Powered by Blogger
Tem images by Michael Ean
€
oro
hips: ecopoliicalingia blogspot com/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html61972020 Inia through the film lens
ARTHUR DENT
VISIT PROFILE
Archive v
Report Abuse
htps:ecopoliicalingia blogspot com/2020/05/incia-through-ons. html s0n0