Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI: 10.1243/09544054JEM381
Abstract: Aluminium disc wheels intended for normal use in passenger cars are commonly
produced by gravity casting. If the cooling process and the initial temperature of the mould
are not well controlled, shrinkage cavity will occur after solidification, causing leakage in
the disc wheel. In this research, a casting simulation software is used to simulate the
casting process of aluminium wheels. The casting simulation is done iteratively until the
mould temperature converges to a stable temperature. A ‘shrinkage index’ (SI) is defined to
provide a quantified index of casting quality of aluminium wheels, based on the
phenomenon of liquid entrapped at the joints of rim and spokes of the wheel where
shrinkage cavity usually happens. This shrinkage index shows good correlation with the
aluminium wheel leakage test results. This paper also discusses the influence of cooling
process parameters on SI, including initial mould temperature, and geometry of the wheel,
which verifies engineers’ empirical data. This iterative simulation process and SI can be used
to predict the casting quality of aluminium wheels and to find the optimal parameters of the
casting process.
JEM381 IMechE 2006 Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014
204 Yeh-Liang Hsu and Chia-Chieh Yu
in which casting process modelling is combined with by experimental data that temperatures were mea-
other computer modelling to optimize cast com- sured from different positions. In the meantime,
ponent manufacturability. Shenefelt et al. [5] used they used a simple sample to study the effects of
‘criteria functions (CFs)’ based on thermal environ- cycle time, preheat temperature, and die coatings.
ment to provide a means for estimating shrinkage The current paper presents a case study of using
porosity within a casting. computer simulation for the casting process of alu-
In particular, the use of mould filling and solid- minium wheels of a local manufacturer in order to
ification commercial simulation software to investi- establish a process to find out the optimal cooling
gate the filling patterns, velocities, and temperature conditions to avoid shrinkage cavity. The ‘liquid
distributions, has become increasingly popular. entrap’ phenomenon at the joints of rim and spokes
Spittle et al. [6] used MAVIS, a heat transfer/ of the wheel during the casting process causes
solidification simulation package, to predict the shrinkage cavity of the final aluminium wheel. In
temperature distributions in a permanent mould. this research, a ‘shrinkage index’ (SI) is defined to
Drezet et al. [7] analysed a nominal ingot using describe the amount of entrapment of liquid. It
the finite element software ABAQUS to compare provides a quantified index of casting quality of
two different casting speeds and free mould designs aluminium wheels. The casting simulation is done
and obtained more uniform thickness. Kreziak et al. iteratively until the mould temperature converges
[8] utilized SIMULOR, a filling and solidification to a stable temperature.
simulation software, to simulate a quarter of an This paper starts by describing the simulation
automobile wheel cast. The results were validated model, the simulation process, and defining SI.
Correlation of the SI with the aluminium wheel
leakage test results of the local manufacturer is
then investigated using the iterative simulation.
Top mould The influences of cooling process parameters on SI
are then discussed, including initial mould tempera-
ture and geometry of the wheel.
Fig. 2 The finite element model of an aluminium wheel and its moulds
Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture JEM381 IMechE 2006
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014
Computer simulation of casting process of aluminium wheels 205
Four-noded tetrahedral elements are used. The mould is cooled down for 30 s, and the next casting
material used is AlSi7Mg (ASTM A356, JIS AC4C) cycle starts.
casting aluminium alloy, which can be found in Figure 3 shows the solidification process of a
ProCAST’s material database. The heat capacity of typical aluminum wheel (referred to as ‘Type A’ in
the alloy is 963 J/(kg K), and the latent heat is this paper) from ProCAST. After approximately
3.98 · 105 J/kg. Table 1 lists other thermal 150 s into the casting process, the liquid starts to
characteristics of the alloy, which are functions of be entrapped at the intersection between the spokes
temperature. and rim. At the positions indicated by the circles,
The boundary conditions of the simulation are the surrounding regions become solidified. Both
based on the wheel manufacturer’s real parameters. the central riser and the rim riser cannot provide
In casting, one or more of the following remedies liquid metal. The position of entrapped liquid is
are often used to prevent unfilled cavity: preheating coincident with a volume where the aluminium
the die, insulating some/all of the cavity surface wheel actually fails, as shown in Fig. 4.
with die coating, and increasing the filling velocity. The simulation shown in Fig. 3 assumes constant
In the current simulation, the temperature of the initial mould temperature everywhere. However,
melted alloy is 720 C. The cavity volume of the this is not true in reality. Figure 5 shows the
model is 7.474e3 m3, and the fill duration is 16 s. temperature distribution of the casting process
The filled velocity is 0.673 m/s through the sectional of an aluminium wheel simulated by ProCAST.
area of 0.693 m3. The die is preheated to 360 C, The temperature scale range is 250–466 C. During
while the ambient temperature is 30 C. For a coated the casting process, the temperature distribution
die with a metal–mould heat transfer coefficient of changes after filling, air cooling, water cooling, and
300 W/m2 C, the whole cavity can be filled in the casting out of cavity. In a continuous casting pro-
simulation. cess, this final temperature distribution of the
Figure 2 also shows the locations of air cooling mould becomes the initial temperature distribution
(by blowing cold air to the side mould) and water of the mould for the next casting.
cooling (by spraying water to the bottom mould). As mentioned earlier, Spittle et al. [6] used
In the simulation, cooling parameters are also MAVIS to predict the temperature distributions
based on the wheel manufacturer’s real parameters. in a permanent mould. The mould for the produc-
The heat transfer coefficient of air cooling is tion of AlSi7Mg alloy castings had been used
700 W/m2 C and its affected area is 4800 mm2. The to assess the influence of mould design modifi-
heat transfer coefficient of water cooling is cations and water cooling on the steady state
2200 W/m2 C and its affected area is 88 822 mm2. temperature distribution in the mould and the
The filling of melted metal completes after 16 s. freezing characteristics of the casting. Results
Air cooling starts at 66 s and continues until the matched very well between experiment and simula-
end of casting (240 s). Water cooling starts at 126 s tion, where a steady state was assumed to be
and lasts for 40 s. Finally, the casting wheel is achieved in any batch run without water cooling
picked out of the cavity at the end of casting. The after 20 castings.
JEM381 IMechE 2006 Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014
206 Yeh-Liang Hsu and Chia-Chieh Yu
Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture JEM381 IMechE 2006
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014
Computer simulation of casting process of aluminium wheels 207
Fig. 6 The maximum, minimum, and mean temperature of the casting mould in each simulation
JEM381 IMechE 2006 Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014
208 Yeh-Liang Hsu and Chia-Chieh Yu
Fig. 8 The portion of the wheel where shrinkage cavity usually happens
of nodes with solid fractions less than 0.7 at the Table 2 Comparison of leakage test data and SI
instant when both risers become invalid are
Type A B C-3 C-2 C-1
employed as the SI.
As discussed in the previous section, in this Total number of wheels tested 917 1135 1139 20 20
Number of wheels with leakage 86 203 316 8 12
research, the wheel casting process was simulated Leakage ratio % 9.4 17.9 27.7 40 60
continuously for ten cycles in order to reach a steady SI 20 73 111 122 132
state mould temperature. Figure 9 shows the SI of
these ten cycles for wheel Type A. SI is high for
the first several simulations, but soon converges to simulation. Types C-1, C-2, and C-3 are almost
approximately 20 at the eighth to tenth simulation. identical wheels with slightly different geometries,
This also shows that a reasonable simulation which will be discussed in later sections. The leak-
result can be obtained after a steady state mould age ratios of Type C-1 and C-2 were very high and
temperature is reached. were not approved for mass production. Therefore,
In aluminium wheel manufacturing, every casting there were only 20 test samples of Types C-1 and
wheel must pass a ‘leakage test’ to guarantee that C-2 available for testing. Types A, B, and C-3 are
the air will not leak through shrinkage cavities. The mass-produced wheels.
‘leakage ratio’ is the ratio of the number of wheels Figure 10 shows the relation between leakage
with leakage and the total number of wheels tested. ratio and SI. When SI is high, the leakage ratio will
Table 2 shows the test data for three types of wheels be high. If more data are accumulated, SI can be a
(Types A, B, and C) from the local aluminium wheel good index for predicting the leakage ratio in the
manufacturer and their corresponding SI from our leakage test.
Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture JEM381 IMechE 2006
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014
Computer simulation of casting process of aluminium wheels 209
Table 3 Effect of starting time of air cooling Table 5 Effect of initial mould temperature
Starting time 16–240 s 26–240 s 66–240 s 106–240 s 146–240 s Initial mould 300 C 330 C 360 C 390 C 420 C 450 C
SI 21 20 20 26 35 temperature
Liquid 163 s 164 s 164 s 164 s 164 s SI 20 21 20 30 39 41
entrapped Liquid 155 s 159 s 168 s 168 s 172 s 176 s
entrapped
JEM381 IMechE 2006 Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014
210 Yeh-Liang Hsu and Chia-Chieh Yu
Thickening
Fig. 11 The geometry and cross-section of wheel Type A Fig. 12 Thickened portion of the rim cavity
and Type C
Table 8 Different thickening of rim
Table 6 Cooling conditions of simulation Wheel type C-1 C-2 C-3
Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture JEM381 IMechE 2006
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014
Computer simulation of casting process of aluminium wheels 211
JEM381 IMechE 2006 Proc. IMechE Vol. 220 Part B: J. Engineering Manufacture
Downloaded from pib.sagepub.com at Akdeniz Universitesi on December 25, 2014