Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Original Article
ABSTRACT
Background: Symptoms of depression and anxiety are known to be associated with
cardiac events. Anxiety is an independent predictor of both cardiac events and increased
health care consumption and accounts for the relationship between depressive symptoms
and prognosis. Psychological Symptoms need to be considered in the risk stratification and
treatment of coronary artery disease (CAD) patients. Materials and Method: A non
experimental research design was utilized to assess the psychiatric morbidity in a sample
of 60 patients with CAD, attending the outpatient clinic of the Department of Cardiology
of a tertiary hospital in Punjab. Symptom checklist -80 was used to assess the psychological
deficits. Analysis and interpretation of the data was done using descriptive and inferential
statistics. Results: Out of 60 patients, 39.9% of patients had symptoms of moderate
depression and 7.70% had severe depressive symptoms. 12.5 % patients had severe anxiety
and 39.41% had moderate anxiety symptoms. Anger hostility in both moderate and severe
range was observed in 10.14 % of the subjects. Moderately severe depression and anxiety
was higher in males as compared to females and the difference was statistically significant.
(p=0.024 & p=0.0424). Females had significantly higher anger hostility than males
(p=0.0176). Mean score on additional symptoms was 2.71± 4.14 and 5.21± 4.52 among
male and female patients respectively. On an average, depression and anger hostility
were significantly more in patients with co morbid medical illnesses (p=0.0066), recent
invasive procedure undertaken (p=0.03) and who were living alone (p=0.039).
Conclusions: Our study concludes that CAD can lead to various psychiatric disorders,
which further can complicate the course and outcome of the primary disease itself.
Moreover the cost of treatment of CAD and its complication can further worsen the
psychiatric disorder. Psychiatric disorders also lead to poor compliance and follow up in
CAD patients.
Key words: Psychiatric morbidity, CAD, symptom check list (SCL)-80
considered as a pathogenic factor in post-MI 25% of patients develop this disorder, which is also
patients 8 . Minor depression and depressive associated with poorer medical outcomes.
symptoms also have a negative effect on prognosis
in cardiac patients9. The increased risk of cardiac Material and Methods
events may extend to patients with symptoms of For the present study, a non experimental
negative affect other than depression10,11. Depre- research design was utilized to assess the psychiatric
ssion has been identified as a risk factor for the morbidity among CAD patients. The study included
development of cardiovascular disease and for 60 subjects randomly selected from the CAD
recurrent cardiac events and mortality among those patients attending the outpatient clinic of the
with established coronary artery disease (CAD).14,15 Department of Cardiology. Selection of field was
Depression is commonly present in patients done because of reasons such as familiarity with
with CAD and is independently associated with the setting, availability of subjects, administrative
increased cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. approval, and economy of time, money, energy and
Screening tests for depressive symptoms should be willingness of study subjects to participate in the
applied to identify patients who may require further study. CAD included conditions like stable angina,
assessment and treatment. This multispecialty unstable angina and post MI.
consensus document reviews the evidence linking Informed consent was taken. Purposive
depression with CAD and provides recommen- sampling technique was used to collect the data. A
dations for healthcare providers for the assessment, detailed medical and psychiatric history was taken
referral, and treatment of depression.16 and cardiovascular examination done for each
Recognition and treatment of major depression patient. Sociodemographic profile was recorded.
is crucial, especially for patients after MI. Not only History of any invasive cardiac procedure in the
do depressed patients experience great difficulties past like coronary artery bypass graft (CABG),
in problem solving and coping with challenges, but percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty
depression adversely affects compliance with (PTCA) and coronary angiography was taken. The
medical therapy and rehabilitation and increases independent variables included age, gender, marital
medical comorbidity. Minor depressive disorder is status, duration of illness, number of admissions in
also associated with significant functional last one year, and the monthly expenditure on
impairment and substantial increases in health care medicine was also recorded.
utilization.17,18 A Symptom Checklist-80 (SCL-80) was used
There is a growing body of research on to assess the psychological deficit. Standard scoring
psychosocial factors in patients who have patterns were used to assess the outcome. SCL -80
undergone heart transplantation (HTx).19 Findings score were later subjected to ICD-10 criterion to
indicate high prevalence rates for moderate and evaluate the clinical psychiatric diagnosis. Analysis
severe levels of depression in the waiting period20, and interpretation of data was done by using
in the first year after successful HTx21, and on long- descriptive and inferential statistics as mean, mean
term follow-up22,23. Earlier studies have reported percentage, S.D, T-test, Mann Whitney and Chi
that coping styles and social support may be square test.
significant predictors of morbidity and mortality in
Results
patients awaiting HTx24,25 and also after successful
HTx.26-28 The study included 60 patients, 41 males and
Among CAD patients the rates of depression 19 females. 30 patients had clinical diagnosis of
range from 7%–40%. In this population, depression unstable angina, 34 were post MI and 4 had stable
is associated with poorer medical outcomes and angina. 25% of patient had average an duration of
quality of life, medication non adherence and is a CAD of 3 years and 28.33% of 10 years. More than
consistent predictor of mortality post MI. Patients two admissions were noted in 46% subjects while
who have suffered MI are also at risk for 50.70% of patient had two admissions in last one
experiencing symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress year due to decompensation in cardiac status. 55%
Disorder. In the first year after MI, as many as 8%– of the patients had undergone at least one invasive
Socio-Demographic Profile
Male Total % Female Total %
Marital Status
Married 36 41 87.80488 16 19 84.21053
Unmarried 0 41 0 19 0
Widower 5 41 12.19512 3 19 15.78947
Av. Amount Spent on Med per Month
< 1000 3 41 7.317073 1 19 5.263158 5.263158
1000 - 2000 26 41 63.41463 14 19 73.68421 73.68421
> 2000 12 41 29.26829 4 19 21.05263 21.05263
Av. Income per month
< 5000 3 41 7.317073 3 19 15.78947
5 - 10,000 4 41 9.756098 2 19 10.52632
10-15,000 2 41 4.878049 5 19 26.31579
15-20,000 3 41 7.317073 4 19 21.05263
> 20,000 29 41 70.73171 4 19 21.05263
Clinical Diagnosis
Stable Angina 2 41 4.878049 2 19 10.52632
Unstable Angina 15 41 36.58537 5 19 26.31579
Post MI 24 41 58.53659 12 19 63.15789
Duration of Illness 10 41 24.39024 2 19 10.52632
< 1 year 10 41 24.39024 5 19 26.31579
1-3 yrs 6 41 14.63415 4 19 21.05263
4-6 yrs 6 41 14.63415 0 19 0
7-9 yrs 9 41 21.95122 8 19 42.10526
> 10 yrs 10 41 24.39024 2 19 10.52632
No. of adm in last year
Nil 7 41 17.07317 2 19 10.52632
One 20 41 48.78049 5 19 26.31579
Two 10 41 24.39024 5 19 26.31579
Multiple 4 41 9.756098 7 19 36.84211
Delhi Psychiatry Journal 2011; 14:(2) © Delhi Psychiatric Society 239
DELHI PSYCHIATRY JOURNAL Vol. 14 No.2 OCTOBER 2011
39.9% subjects whereas 7.70% had severe Weiss and Marmar found that on multiple
depressive symptoms. 12.5% patients had severe logistic regression analysis depression was
anxiety and 39.41% had moderate anxiety significantly related to 18- month cardiac mortality,
symptoms. Anger hostility in both moderate and even after controlling for other significant
severe range was observed in 10.14 % subjects. multivariate predictors of mortality (previous MI,
Moderately severe depression and anxiety was Killip class, frequency of premature ventricular
higher in males as compared to females and the contractions [PVCs]) (p = .003).41
difference was statistically significant. (p = 0.024 The IES is a 15-item self-report questionnaire
and p = 0.0424). Females had significantly higher consisting of two subscales measuring experiences
anger hostility than males (p = 0.0176). Mean score of avoidance and intrusion related to the traumatic
on additional symptoms was 2.71 ± 4.14 and 5.21 event. Good reliability and validity have been
± 4.52 among male and female patients respectively. reported in multiple studies. A high score on the
On an average, depression and anger hostility were IES was shown to be associated with increased risk
significantly more in patients with comorbid for non adherence to medical recommendations,
medical illnesses (p = 0.0066), recent invasive cardiovascular admissions, and a higher cardio-
procedure undertaken (p = 0.03) and who were vascular risk profile in patients with cardiovascular
living alone (p = 0.039). On other subscale of SCL- illnesses40, 41.
80, no major abnormality was found. In our study 39.9% of patients had symptoms
of moderate depression and 7.70% had severe
Discussion
depressive symptoms. 12.5 % patients had severe
There is a well established relationship between anxiety and 39.41% had moderate anxiety
anxiety, depression and CAD30, which may be due symptoms. As compared to females, males had more
in part to the poor risk factor profiles, including moderately severe depression (p=0.024) and anxiety
diet, smoking and exercise. Previous studies have (p = 0.0424).
shown that cardiac rehabilitation improves Depression as a Risk Factor for Ischemic Heart
symptoms of anxiety and depression in patients with Disease. The notion that having a psychiatric illness
CAD31,32. The prevalence of depression in CAD such as major depression increases one’s risk for
patients ranges from 16% to 25% and from 10% to developing ischemic heart disease remains
29% for anxiety disorders. Anxiety and depression controversial and has been often intuitively
can affect heart rhythms and blood pressure, elevate “explained” by the hypothesis that persons with
insulin and cholesterol levels and increase the psychiatric disorders generally have other risk
incidence of smoking, with highly anxious patients factors for the development of CAD. Studies with
at 3-6 times greater risk of MI and sudden death.33 the most rigorous methods that are prospective in
A comprehensive study, the National design, have used structured clinical interviews or
Comorbidity Study, reported lifetime prevalence diagnostic instruments, have included other risk
rates of major depression and dysthymia of 13% factors for CAD in their analysis (such as
and 5%, respectively34. Point prevalence rates of hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, nicotine and
major depression in primary care outpatients range other substance abuse, and physical inactivity), and
from 2% to 16% and from 9% to 20% for all controlled for demographic factors (such as age,
depressive disorders35,36 and are even higher in sex, and socioeconomic status). Nearly all the recent
medical inpatients; 8% for major depression and studies document increased cardiovascular
15% to 36% for all depressive disorders.37,38 morbidity and mortality in patients with depressive
Frasure-Smith and colleagues38,39 found depre- symptoms or major depression, thereby implicating
ssion to be a significant predictor of mortality (p - depression as an independent risk factor in the
0.001) in 222 patients 6 months after MI. Depre- pathophysiological progression of CAD, rather than
ssion remained a significant predictor of mortality merely a secondary emotional response to the
(p – 0.01), even after multivariate statistical illness. Such large epidemiologic studies may use
methodology was used to factor out the effects of self report instruments, rather than clinical
left ventricular dysfunction and previous MI. interviews, to evaluate the importance of psycholo-
240 Delhi Psychiatry Journal 2011; 14:(2) © Delhi Psychiatric Society
OCTOBER 2011 DELHI PSYCHIATRY JOURNAL Vol. 14 No.2
gical factors in predicting CAD. Assessments of this This alteration could involve either increased
type are typically added to large, multiple risk factor sympathetic stimulation, which has been linked to
studies in which population-based samples are the occurrence of arrhythmias and sudden death, or
followed up prospectively. The advantage of using impaired vagal control, which has also been linked
“dimensional” measures of depression (rather than to increased cardiac mortality. With respect to the
a categorical diagnosis of major depression) is the latter possibility, reduced vagal control has been
increased statistical power to detect smaller linked to impaired, vagally mediated baroreflex
“effects.” However, such epidemiologic data are not control of the heart. Such impairment appears to be
equivalent to clinical data42. a particularly important risk factor for sudden
death. Along these lines, a recent study reported
Pathophysiological Mechanisms of depression
reduced baroreflex cardiac control in patients
Considerable evidence indicates that depre- with anxiety, but prospective work is needed to
ssion has both behavioral and direct pathophysio- determine whether this is a common operative
logical effects. With respect to behavioral mechanism for sudden deaths among patients with
mechanisms, depression is associated with both anxiety syndromes. Individuals with anxiety
unhealthy lifestyle behaviors, such as smoking, and disorders are prone to unhealthier lifestyle
poor patient compliance. Direct pathophysiological behaviors; however, the lack of correlation between
effects of depression involve at least 3 mechanisms. anxiety syndromes and myocardial infarction (a sign
First, depression is accompanied by hypercorti- of underlying atherosclerosis) suggests that, at least
solemia. Associated findings include attenuation of among initially healthy individuals, this behavioral
the adrenocorticotropin hormone response to association is not a significant pathogenic
corticotropin-releasing factor administration, mechanism. It is conceivable, nonetheless, that this
nonsuppression of cortisol secretion after behavioral association could be of importance
dexamethosone administration, and elevated among CAD patients manifesting anxiety42.
corticotropin-releasing factor concentrations in the Brydon et al, found participants with higher
cerebrospinal fluid of depressed patients. hostility scores had heightened systolic and diastolic
Second, depressed individuals may develop blood pressure (BP) reactivity to tasks (both P <
significant impairments in platelet function, .05), as well as a more sustained increase in systolic
including enhanced platelet reactivity and release BP at 2 h post-task (P = .024), independent of age,
of platelet products such as platelet factor 4 and ß- BMI, smoking status, medication, and baseline BP.
thromboglobulin. The combination of hypercorti- Hostility was also associated with elevated plasma
solemia and enhanced platelet function establishes interleukin-6 (IL-6) levels at 75 min (P = .023) and
the theoretical basis for explaining the 2 h (P = .016) post stress and was negatively
proatherogenic effects of depression. In addition, correlated with salivary cortisol at 75 min (P =
reduced heartrate variability and impaired vagal .034). Hostility was measured using a 39-item
control have been reported among depressed abbreviated version of the Cook Medley Hostility
patients. These findings suggest that depressed Scale (CMHS)43.
patients may also be subject to enhanced In our study anger hostility was observed in
arrhythmogenic potential42. 10.14 % in both moderate and severe range. Females
Pathophysiological Mechanism of anxiety had significantly higher anger hostility as compared
to males (p = 0.0176). ). Mean score on additional
The association between anxiety and sudden symptoms was 2.71 ± 4.14 and 5.21 ± 4.52 among
death, but not MI, suggests that ventricular male and female patients respectively. On an
arrhythmias may be the mechanism for cardiac average, depression and anger hostility were
death among individuals with anxiety disorders. In significantly more in patients with comorbid
support of this hypothesis, it has been observed that medical illnesses (p = 0.0066), recent invasive
individuals with anxiety disorders have reduced procedure undertaken (p = 0.03) and those who
heart rate variability. Hence, there may be a were living alone (p = 0.039). On other subscale
pathological alteration in cardiac autonomic tone. of SCL-80, no major abnormality was found.
Delhi Psychiatry Journal 2011; 14:(2) © Delhi Psychiatric Society 241
DELHI PSYCHIATRY JOURNAL Vol. 14 No.2 OCTOBER 2011
or even early death after MI. Future studies should Med 1999; 61 : 666–675.
focus on women to assess gender-specific 8. Honig A, Lousberg R, Wojchiechowski F, et
psychosocial and physiologic measures. Which al. Depression following a first heart infarct:
treatment modalities (psychotherapeutic vs similarities with and difference from ‘ordinary’
psychopharmacologic or a combination) will be depression. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd 1997; 141:
most effective in patients with recurrent or more 196–199.
severe depression remains to be determined. 9. Penninx BWJH, Beekman ATF, Honig A, et al.
Treatment studies may also assess the relationship Depression and cardiac mortality: results from
between depression and subsequent compliance a community-based longitudinal study. Arch
with medication and risk factor modification for Gen Psychiatry 2001; 58 : 221–227.
CVD. Illumination of the interplay between central 10. Carney RM, Freedland KE, Jaffe AS.
nervous system, platelet, and cardiovascular Depression as a risk factor for coronary heart
processes, particularly in those patients with CVD disease mortality. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2001;
and major depression, will undoubtedly lead to the 58 : 229–230.
development of new treatment modalities that will 11. Denollet J, Brutsaert DL. Personality, disease
not only improve these patients’ quality of life but severity and the risk of long term cardiac events
potentially decrease their morbidity and improve in patients with a decreased ejection fraction
long-term survival rates. after myocardial infarction. Circulation 1998;
97 : 167–173.
References
12. Ladwig KH, Roll G, Breithardt G, et al. Post
1. Rozanski A, Blumenthal JA, Kaplan J. Impact infarct depression and incomplete recovery 6
of psychological factors on the pathogenesis of months after acute myocardial infarction.
cardiovascular disease and implications for Lancet 1994; 343 : 20–23.
therapy. Circulation 1999; 99 : 2192–2217. 13. Creed F. The importance of depression
2. Hemingway H, Marmot M. Evidence based following myocardial infarction. Heart 1999;
cardiology: psychosocial factors in the 82 : 406–408.
aetiology and prognosis of coronary heart 14. Carney RM, Freedland KE. Depression,
disease. Systematic review of prospective mortality, and medical morbidity in patients
cohort studies. BMJ 1999; 318 : 1460–1467. with coronary heart disease. Biol Psychiatry
3. Kubzansky LD, Kawachi I, Spiro A, et al. Is 2003; 54 : 241–7.
worrying bad for your heart? A prospective 15. Carney RM, Blumenthal JA, Catellier D, et al.
study of worry and coronary heart disease in Depression as a risk factor for mortality after
the Normative Aging Study. Circulation 1997; acute myocardial infarction. Am J Cardiol
95 : 818–824. 2003; 92 : 1277–81.
4. Barefoot JC, Helms MJ, Mark DB, et al. 16. Lichtman et al. Depression and Coronary Heart
Depression and long-term mortality risk in Disease. Circulation 2008; 118 : 0-0.
patients with coronary heart disease. Am J 17. Skodol AE, Schwartz S, Dohrenwend BP, et al.
Cardiol 1996; 78 : 613–617. Minor depression in a cohort of young adults
5. Carney RM, Blumenthal JA, Stein PK, et al. in Israel. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1994; 51 : 542-
Depression, heart rate variability, and acute 551.
myocardial infarction. Circulation 2001; 104 : 18. Wells KB, Stewart A, Hayes RD, et al. The
2024–2028. functioning and well-being of depressed
6. Musselman DL, Tomer A, Manatunga AK, et patients: results of the Medical Outcomes
al. Exaggerated platelet reactivity in major Study. JAMA 1989; 262 : 914-919.
depression. Am J Psychiatry 1996; 153 : 1313– 19. Cupples S, Dew MA, Grady KL, et al. Report
1317. of the psychosocial outcomes workgroup of the
7. Carney RM, Freedland KE, Veith RC, Jaffe AS. nursing and social sciences council of the
Can treating depression reduce mortality after International Society for Heart and Lung
an acute myocardial infarction? Psychosom Transplantation: Present status of research on
Delhi Psychiatry Journal 2011; 14:(2) © Delhi Psychiatric Society 243
DELHI PSYCHIATRY JOURNAL Vol. 14 No.2 OCTOBER 2011
40. Briere J. Psychological Assessment of Adult 43. Lena Brydon, Philip C. Strike, Mimi R.
Posttraumatic States. Washington, DC: Bhattacharyya, et al. Hostility and physiological
American Psychological Association; 1997. responses to laboratory stress in acute coronary
41. Weiss D, Marmar C. The Impact of Event Scale syndrome patients. J Psychosom Res 2010
- Revised. In : Wilson J, Keane T, eds. Assessing February; 68(2) : 109–116.
Psychological Trauma and PTSD. New York: 44. Gerin W, Pieper C, Levy R, Pickering TG.
The Guilford Press; 1997. Social support in social interaction: a moderator
42. Alan Rozanski, James A. Blumenthal, Jay of cardiovascular reactivity. Psychosom Med
Kaplan. Impact of Psychological Factors on the 1992; 54 : 324–336.
Pathogenesis of Cardiovascular Disease and 45. Zuzana Skodova, Iveta Nagyova, Jitse P, et al.
Implications for Therapy. Circulation 1999; 99 Socioeconomic inequalities in quality of life
: 2192-2217. and psychological outcomes among cardiac
patients. Int J Public Health 2009; 54 : 233–
240.