You are on page 1of 10

journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345

Available at www.sciencedirect.com

ScienceDirect

j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e : w w w. e l s e v i e r. c o m / l o c a t e / j ff

The biological activity of fermented dairy


products obtained by kombucha and
conventional starter cultures during storage

D. Hrnjez *, Ž. Vaštag, S. Milanović, V. Vukić, M. Iličić, Lj. Popović,


K. Kanurić
Faculty of Technology, University of Novi Sad, Novi Sad, Serbia

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Article history: The effects of kombucha inoculum as a new starter culture for milk fermentation were in-
Received 3 April 2014 vestigated, during 14 days of storage. The antioxidant capacity, angiotensin converting enzyme
Received in revised form 10 June (ACE) inhibitory activity, degree of proteolysis (DP), content of vitamin C as well as sensory
2014 properties of kombucha fermented milk, were analysed and compared with fermented milk
Accepted 16 June 2014 products obtained by commercial probiotic (ABT-10) and yoghurt (YF-L812) starter cul-
Available online 12 July 2014 tures. The kombucha fermented milk product (K) showed similar trend of changes in pH,
DP and sensory properties as products obtained by probiotic (P) and yoghurt (Y) starters.
Keywords: Significant ACE inhibitory was determined in all fermented products, which increased during
Fermented dairy products storage. Kombucha product had the highest ACE activity (63.43%) at the end of storage com-
Kombucha pared with probiotic and yoghurt products. In all products, higher 2,2’-azino-bis-(3-
ACE inhibitory ethylbenzthiazoline-6-sulphonic acid) (ABTS) than 1,1-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH) radical
Antioxidative capacity scavenging activity was determined, while both activities slightly decreased during storage.
Vitamin C Based on estimated biological activity the kombucha product can be considered as an in-
novative fermented dairy product suitable for human nutrition.
© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Tamime, Hassan, Farnworth, & Toba, 2007; Tripathi & Giri, 2014).
1. Introduction On the other hand, the use of non-conventional, functional
starter cultures holds great promises to manufacture various
The consumption of yoghurt has a long tradition in many coun- yoghurts with desirable technological, nutritional and benefi-
tries, with its general acceptance as a healthy and nutritious cial health advantages (Tripathi & Giri, 2014). Recent research
food. Nowadays, production of yoghurt with elevated ben- studies have focus on naturally occurring bioactive compo-
efits on human health has become one of the major focuses nents in fermented milk products, such as bioactive peptides
in dairy industry, as current trends on the market are towards (Korhonen, 2009; Urista, Fernandez, Rodriguez, Cuenca, & Jurado,
development of functional foodstuffs, especially fermented milk 2011). Nowadays, bioactive peptides have gained increasing at-
products. Over the past years, yoghurt has been proved as an tention for human health promotion and deferment of age-
ideal food to be fortified with diverse functional ingredients, related diseases (Kittiphattanabawona, Benjakul, Visessanguan,
such as vitamins, probiotics, prebiotics (Sadeq et al., 2013; & Shahidi, 2013).

* Corresponding author. Tel: +381 21485 3719; fax: +381 21450 413.
E-mail address: dajana@tf.uns.ac.rs (D. Hrnjez).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jff.2014.06.016
1756-4646/© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345 337

Milk proteins are well-known precursors of peptides


exerting antioxidant, antihypertensive, antimicrobial, 2. Materials and methods
immunomodulatory, anticancer, mineral-binding and opioid ac-
2.1. Materials
tivity (Chibuike & Aishwarya, 2014; Korhonen, 2009;
Samaranayaka & Li-Chan, 2011). These peptides can be re-
All the chemicals used for the experiments were of analyti-
leased during fermentation of milk by proteolytic starter cul-
cal grade. DPPH (2.2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazy), angiotensin-I
tures or by addition of proteolytic enzymes. A number of these
converting enzyme (ACE) from rabbit lung, N-hippuryl-His-
peptides may be available in the final products, primarily de-
Leu hydrate were obtained from Sigma (St. Louis, MO, USA),
pending on the proteolytic capacity of microorganisms taking
m-phosphoric acid (Riedel-de Haën, Seelze, Germany), aceto-
part in milk fermentation. So far, in fermented milk prod-
nitrile, acetic acid and vitamin C (J.T. Baker, Deventer, Holland)
ucts, such as cheese and yoghurt, the potential antihyperten-
HPLC grade.
sive (namely, angiotensin I converting enzyme, ACE inhibitory)
peptides have been mostly studied (Gonzalez-Gonzalez, Gibson,
& Jauregi, 2013; Papadimitriou et al., 2007). 2.2. Methods
For centuries, kombucha has been known as a consor-
tium of yeasts (Pichia, Zygosaccharomyces, Saccharomyces, 2.2.1. Sample production
Schizosaccharomyces, Saccharomycodes, Brettanomyces, Fermented milk products were manufactured in laboratory con-
Torulaspora and Candida) and acetic acid bacteria (Acetobacter ditions, from pasteurised (72 °C (161 °F) for 15 seconds) and
and Gluconobacter) (Chen & Liu, 2000; Trovatti, Serafim, Freire, homogenised milk with 2.8% fat (Dairy Subotica, Subotica,
Silvestre, & Neto, 2011; Zhang, Zhang, & Xin, 2011). Other- Serbia).
wise, novel research has indicated the significant presence of The following starter cultures were used for milk
lactic acid bacteria (LAB) (Marsh, O Sullivan, Hill, Ross, & Cotter, fermentation:
2014; Wu, Gai, & Ji, 2004; Zhang et al., 2011). Marsh et al., (2014)
suggested that Lactobacilli are more prevalent in kombucha 1. Kombucha inoculum – Kombucha was cultivated on black
than was previously understood, particularly at the later stages tea (Camellia sinensis – oxidised, 1.5 g L–1) with saccha-
of fermentation. The same authors found Lactobacillus rose concentration of 70 g L–1. The tea was cooled at the
kefiranofaciens subsp. kefirgranum as the more abundant room temperature, after which inoculum from a previ-
genera of LAB in kombucha culture. Petrušić, Radulović, ous fermentation was added in concentration of 10%. In-
Paunović, and Obradović (2011) also showed presence cubation was performed at 25 ± 2 °C for 7 days (Malbaša
of Lactobacillus plantarum, Streptococcus thermophilus, et al., 2009b). Kombucha inoculum in concentration of
Streptococcus bovis, Streptococcus lutetiensis, Brevibacterium 10% (30 mL) was applied for milk fermentation. Total
sp. as a constituents in kombucha inoculums on black number of viable cells was as follows: approximately
tea. 5 × 104 of yeast cells per cm3 of the reaction mixture and
Kombucha has been traditionally used for fermentation of approximately 2 × 105 of bacteria cells per cm3 of the men-
sweetened black or green tea (Dufresne & Farnworth, 2000; Teoh, tioned mixture (Lončar, Kanurić, Malbaša, Ðurić, &
Heard, & Cox, 2004). Kombucha fermented product contains Milanović, 2013).
ethanol, carbon dioxide, a high concentration of acid (glu- 2. Probiotic starter culture, ABT-7 – lyophilised probiotic
conic, acetic and lactic) and a number of other health-promoting culture – Probio-Tek® contains LA-5®, Lactobacillus aci-
metabolites. Therefore, it is considered to be beneficial dophilus, BB-12®, Bifidobacterium, Streptococcus thermophilus
beverage in cases of: digestive ailments, diabetes, (Chr. Hansen, Hørsholm, Denmark).
hypercholesterolaemia, high blood pressure, combating stress 3. Yoghurt starter culture – lyophilised yoghurt culture YF-
and cancer as well as body vitalisation, among others (Aloulou L812 contains Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacil-
et al., 2012; Guttapadu, Yang, & Wieger, 2000; Houda, Amina, lus delbrueckii ssp. bulgaricus (Chr. Hansen).
& Emna, 2012; Jayabalan et al., 2011; Semantee, Ratan, &
Parames, 2013; Thummala, Ramachandran, Jagadeesan, & Commercial starters were added according to manufactur-
Uppala, 2013). Recent studies presented the technological and er’s specification, 0.005 g 100 g−1. All samples were produced
nutritional potential of kombucha as an innovative starter in triplets at 42 °C. Fermentation was continued until pH = 4.5
culture in dairy industry (Iličić et al., 2012; Malbaša, Lončar, were reached. Then samples were cooled to 4 °C, homog-
Milanović, & Kolarov, 2009a; Vukic et al., 2014). As the result enized by mixing, packed in polypropylene glasses and stored
of milk fermentation by kombucha inoculums, products similar in refrigerator at 4 ± 1 °C. Depending on the used starter culture
to yoghurt or kefir are produced (Iličić et al., 2013; Milanović different samples were produced. The samples were labelled
et al., 2008, 2012). as K0, K7, K14, P0, P7, P14, Y0, Y7, and Y14. Letters K, Y, P
The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of indicate used starter culture (K – kombucha, P – probiotics,
kombucha inoculum as a new starter culture for milk fermen- Y – yoghurt) and number 0, 7 and 14 indicate the day of
tation, during 14 days of storage. The antioxidant capacity, an- storage.
giotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitory activity, degree Chemical quality was tested in fermented dairy products after
of proteolysis (DP), content of vitamin C as well as sensory prop- production using the following methods (Carić, Milanović, &
erties of kombucha fermented milk, were analysed and com- Vucelja, 2000): dry matter (DM) (IDF/ISO 21A:1982): milk fat (MF)
pared with fermented dairy products obtained by commercial according to Gerber (IDF 105:1981); total proteins (TP) (IDF
probiotic (ABT-10) and yoghurt (YF-L812) starter cultures. 20:1962); ash (A) (IDF 90:1979);
338 journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345

pH values were determined using a pH-meter (pH Spear, where A is the amount of HA in reaction without an inhibi-
Eutech Instruments Oakton, England). tor, B is the amount of HA in reaction with potent inhibitor,
Total acids content was determined as titratable acidity. After while A0 and B0 are the respected blanks (where HCl was added
removing CO2 from the fermentation broth, a sample of 20 mL in the test tube before the enzyme solution).
was taken and titrated with 0.1 mol L−1 of NaOH, while phe-
nolphthalein was used as an indicator and calculated in g L−1 2.2.5. ABTS+. radical cation decolourisation assay (TEAC)
lactic acid according to equation: The radical scavenging activity was determined by the ABTS+.
decolourisation assay as described by Re et al. (1999). The
m lactic acid (gL−1 ) = ( VNaOH × CNaOH × Mlactic acid 1000) × 50 (1) bleaching rate of ABTS+. solution was monitored in the pres-
ence of the prepared water-soluble extracts at 734 nm, using
2.2.2. Preparation of water-soluble extracts (WSEs) of T80/T80+ UV-Vis spectrophotometer (PG instruments LTD).
fermented dairy products Briefly, 0.2 mL of sample (containing 0.5, 0.75, 1.5 and 1 mg mL−1
The WSEs were prepared according to Shori and Baba (2013). proteins) was added to 2 mL of diluted ABTS +. solution
Each sample (10 g) was mixed with 2.5 mL distilled water and (A734nm = 0.7 ± 0.02) and the absorbance reading was taken up
the pH was adjusted to 4.0 using 1 M HCl. The yoghurt was then to 10 min. Appropriate solvent blanks were run in each assay.
incubated in water bath (45 °C) for 10 min and the precipi- In the same way, a standard Trolox curve was prepared with
tated proteins were removed by centrifugation at 10,000 g for known Trolox concentrations. The percentage decrease in ab-
10 min, 4 °C. The supernatant was collected and the pH ad- sorbance at 734 nm at 10 min was calculated and plotted as
justed to 7.0 using NaOH (0.5 M), followed by another centrifu- function of potential antioxidant or Trolox concentrations. The
gation (10,000 g, 10 min, 4 °C). The supernatant was collected Trolox equivalent antioxidant coefficient (TEAC) was calcu-
and refrigerated until further analysis. lated by dividing the absorbance percentage inhibition versus
antioxidant concentration slope by the Trolox plot slope and
2.2.3. Determination of the degree of proteolysis was expressed as mmol TEAC per mg of proteins in hydroly-
Degree of proteolysis was measured as the percentage of con- sates (mmolTEACmg−1).
centration of proteins soluble in 8% TCA. Briefly, 0.85 mL of each
sample was mixed with 0.4 mL of 25% TCA and the mixture 2.2.6. DPPH• (2.2-Diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl radical)
was left at 4 °C, for 30 min. Thereafter, the mixture was cen- scavenging activity assay
trifuged at 14,100 g (Ependorf Mini Spin Plus) for 5 min. The The free radical scavenging activity (RSA) of protein extracts
obtained supernatant was filtered through membrane syringe was evaluated using the DPPH• scavenging activity assay as de-
filter with diameter pore of 0.45 µm and analysed to deter- scribed by Morales and Jimenez-Perez (2001). In brief, an aliquot
mine the protein content by the method described by Lowry, of sample (200 µL) was added to 1 mL of a daily-prepared so-
Rosenbrough, Fair, and Randall (1951), using bovine serum lution of DPPH• (74 mg L−1) in ethanol. The mixtures were shaken
albumin as the standard protein. The DP value was calcu- for 5 min at room temperature, centrifuged at 12 × 4 g
lated as the ratio of 8% TCA-soluble protein and total soluble (Eppendorf Mini Spin plus) for 5 min and the absorption was
proteins, expressed as a percentage. measured at 520 nm (T80/T80+ UV-Vis Spectrophotometer PG
instruments LTD). The concentration of DPPH• in the reaction
2.2.4. ACE inhibitory activity mixture was calculated from the calibration curve. The DPPH•
The ACE inhibitory activity of the water-soluble extracts was scavenging activity, expressed as antiradical activity (RSA) was
performed according to Yoshie-Stark, Bez, Wada, and Wasche calculated as follows (Eq. 3):
(2004). In each assay, a sample (at different concentration) was
incubated at 37 °C for 80 min with hippuryl-His-Leu (HHL) in ⎛ [DPPHb ] − [DPPHt ]⎞
% RSA = ⎜ ⎟⎠ × 100 (3)
0.2 mol L−1 potassium phosphate buffer containing 300 mmol L−1 ⎝ [DPPHb ]
NaCl (pH 8.30) and ACE solution. The final concentrations of
the HHL and ACE were 10 mmol L−1 and 25 mU mL−1, respec- where [DPPHb] is the concentration of DPPH• in blank (in the
tively. The reaction was stopped by adding 110 µL of 1 mol L−1 presence of buffer instead of protein extract) and [DPPHb] is
HCl. The hippuric acid (HA) liberated from HHL was quanti- the concentration of DPPH• in the sample (in the presence
fied with reverse-phase high performance liquid chromatog- protein extract), after 10 min of reaction.
raphy (RP-HPLC). 20 µL of the solution was injected directly onto
Zorbax Eclipse XDB (Agilent Technology, Santa Clara, CA, USA)- 2.2.7. Determination of vitamin C
C18 column (4.6 Id × 150 mm, 5 µm, 80 Å) to separate HA from One gram of fermented milk sample was transferred into a
HHL. The column was eluted with 50% methanol and 0.1% 10 mL volumetric flask and filled up with 3% solution of
trifluoroacetic acid (in water), with flow rate of 1 mL min−1, at m-phosphoric acid, in 8% solution of acetic acid. The ob-
22 °C. The absorbance of the eluate was measured at 228 nm. tained solution was mixed for 5 min and vitamin C was ex-
From the chromatograms, the peak area (corresponding to HA) tracted. Then the solution was filtered through filter paper (blue
was integrated, and the amount of HA in the samples was quan- label) and through membrane syringe filter (with diameter pore
tified. The ACE inhibition activity was calculated as follows of 0.45 µm) and the filtrate was used for HPLC analysis of
(Eq. 2): vitamin C. Agilent 1100 system (USA) with C-8 column and
diode array detector (DAD) was used for determination. A mobile
( A − A0 ) − (B − B0 ) phase was ammonia-acetate solution (0.1 M; pH 5.1) with flow
ACE inhibitory activity (% ) = (2)
( A − A0 ) rate of 0.4 mL min−1 and column temperature was 37 °C. Vitamin
journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345 339

Table 1 – Chemical composition of milk and fermented milk products obtained by yoghurt, probiotic and kombucha
starter cultures.
Chemical Milk Probiotic starter (P) Yoghurt starter (Y) Kombucha starter (K)
characteristics
pH 6.8 ± 0.00 4.57 ± 0.01 4.52 ± 0.03 4.54 ± 0.02
TTA (lactic acid mg/mL) – 7.38 ± 0.04 7.24 ± 0.04 7.11 ± 0.02
Dry matter (%) 11.56 ± 0.08 12.0 ± 0.02 11.91 ± 0.07 11.60 ± 0.09
Milk fat (%) 2.8 ± 0.001 2.8 ± 0.002 2.8 ± 0.001 3.0 ± 0.001
Total proteins (%) 3.08 ± 0.02 3.07 ± 0.04 2.98 ± 0.06 2.77 ± 0.05
Ash (%) 0.71 ± 0.001 0.75 ± 0.0016 0.73 ± 0.003 0.69

C was used as a standard. All analyses were performed in At the end of the milk fermentation, the pH values in the
triplicate. products varied from 4.52 to 4.57 (Table 1). In the first week
of storage the pH was not changed significantly, while all
2.2.8. Sensory analysis samples had a sharp decrease in pH during the second week
Sensory analysis of the samples was carried outlying expert (Fig. 1a). The decrease in pH was followed by simultaneous in-
committee (10–15 trained panellists selected from University crease in titratable acidity (expressed as lactic acid content)
staff members). The five point system and the descriptive (data not showed). In general, higher acidification rate was ob-
method with assessing the scoring range from 1 to 5, was used. served in the P and K samples compared with Y sample. At
Sensory evaluations determined by the coefficient of impor- the end of the storage, the pH values in the P, K and Y prod-
tance for appearance – 1, colour – 2, flavour – 3, consistency – ucts reached 4.00, 4.10 and 4.35, respectively, which indicate
4 and taste – 10. The single complex indicator which reflects the products’ stability.
the overall sensory quality expressed as % of the maximum In part, the post-acidification of the fermented milk prod-
quality was obtained by adding the single score. Dividing this ucts is undesirable process; hence it could be consequence of
value by the sum of coefficients of interest (20) a weighted metabolism of microorganisms. Some microorganisms (e.g.
average score is obtained, which expresses the overall quality some lactic acid bacteria) can remain active even at cold storage
of the product. (Considine, Healy, Kelly, & McSweeney, 2000). In accordance with
the literature, these results also revealed that type of starter
2.2.9. Colour measurement culture affects the different post-acidification rate of final prod-
The colour of fermented dairy products is determined by pho- ucts, although further analysis is required to evaluate the re-
toelectric tristimulus colourimeter CHROMAMETER CR-400, sponsible microorganisms. Nevertheless, the results indicated
Konica Minolta CRA33 extension. It works by measuring re- that kombucha inoculum could ensure manufacturing of fer-
flected colour and colour differences of different surfaces values mented milk product with similar physicochemical charac-
of the fermented milk products (whiteness (L-), red/greenness teristics and acidity with respect to conventional starter
(a-), and yellow/blueness (b-)). The software SpectroMagic cultures. The significant influence (P ≤ 0.05) of combined effect
NXPROQCver 2.0 was used for the results processing. of starter culture and day of storage on pH value was
observed.

2.2.10. Statistics 3.2. Degree of proteolysis


All chemical analyses and assays were performed in tripli-
cate for all produced samples (n) and values were expressed The extent of proteolysis was evaluated based on the index
as average value. Univariate treatments of the data were per- of 8% TCA soluble proteins and expressed as degree proteoly-
formed by analysis of variance (ANOVA), using “Statistica 9” sis (DP). The combined effect of storage time and starter cul-
software program. Duncan’s multiple range tests were per- tures on DP is presented in Fig. 1b.
formed to evaluate significant differences among the studied Yoghurt as a type of fermented dairy product is not ex-
parameters. Differences among analysed parameters of pro- pected to have high extent of proteolysis, which is in accor-
duced samples with different starter cultures were consid- dance with the obtained results. Compared with the raw milk,
ered statistically significant when P ≤ 0.05. by the end of fermentation the DP increased from 1.7 ± 0.02
in raw milk to 2.25 ± 0.034% in Y, 2.35 ± 0.041% in P and
2.56 ± 0.151% in the K product. During the cold storage the value
3. Results of DP increased in all samples, with significant variations among
them (Fig. 1b). The probiotic product had a continuous in-
3.1. Physicochemical characteristics of fermented crease of DP during the whole storage period, reaching the final
milk products value of 3.56 ± 0.162% after 14 days of storage.
The kombucha and yoghurt products showed very similar
The chemical composition of milk and obtained fermented dairy trend in the change of DP, it increased during the first week
products are shown in the Table 1. Regardless the starter cul- and without significant change during the second week of
tures, the fermented milk products were not significantly dif- storage. The final values of DP were 2.77 ± 0.039 and
ferent in dry matter, fat, proteins and ash content. 2.61 ± 0.071% in the K and Y samples, respectively.
340 journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345

Fig. 1 – The changes during the storage period in: (a) pH value, (b) degree of proteolysis (DP). (c) IC50 values of the
angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitory activity; (d) content of vitamin C.

The results showed that interaction of factors starter 3.3. ACE inhibitory activity
culture*day of storage had significant (P < 0.005) impact on DP
(Fig. 1b). As the extent of proteolysis mainly depends on the ACE (EC 3.4.15.1) plays a central role in the regulation of blood
proteolytic enzymes of starter cultures (Shah & Ravula, 2001), pressure through the production of the potent vasoconstric-
it is evident that probiotic starter more likely produce protease/ tor, angiotensin-II, and the degradation of the vasodilator, bra-
peptidases compared with K and Y samples. However, lower dykinin. Captopril and other synthetic ACE inhibitors, used in
DP values in K and Y samples may be considered as the result the clinical treatment of hypertension, could have some un-
of symbiosis occurring among the bacteria populations. For in- desirable effects to humans (Acharya, Sturrock, Riordan, &
stance, S. thermophilus may be utilising the peptides and amino Ehlers, 2003). Therefore, natural ACE inhibitory food compo-
acids liberated by L. bulgaricus and thus instead of being ac- nents have gained great importance. Food protein derived pep-
cumulated, they are further consumed (Slocum, Jasinski, tides, such as casokinins and lactocinins, have shown great
Anantheswaran, & Kilara, 1988). promise as functional food ingredients with potential to control
Generally, it was observed that the probiotic starter induced hypertension.
the highest rate of changes in both, pH and proteolysis, the The ACE inhibitory activity of WSEs was examined by means
yoghurt starter had the lowest, while the product with of the protein concentration range from 0.2 to 1 mg mL−1 in the
kombucha inoculum had values of these parameters within test tube. In all samples ACE inhibitory activity was deter-
this range. This could be additional conformation that the mined at day 0, and further increased during the whole storage
kombucha inoculum is suitable for fermented milk produc- period. After production, the kombucha starter showed lower
tion, compared with conventional starter cultures. ACE inhibitory activity (46.27 ± 0.694%; P < 0.05) than the prod-
journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345 341

Table 2 – Radical scavenging activity (mean ± SD) of water-soluble extracts (WSE) measured by DPPH (2,2-diphenyl-1-
picrylhydrazyl) and ABTS [2,2′-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic acid)] methods during the storage.
Day of storage AADPPH % ABTS %
Yoghurt Probiotic Kombucha Yoghurt Probiotic Kombucha
0 day 9.4586 ± 0.301a
13.2299 ± 0.043b
17.8832 ± 0.172c
50.6542 ± 0.323a
47.4733 ± 0.21b
41.0446 ± 0.123c
7 day 9.8844 ± 0.381a 19.4951 ± 0.645b 12.3175 ± 0.373c 54.8991 ± 0.541a 50.1879 ± 0.78b 36.2129 ± 0.112c
14 day 6.1131 ± 0.301a 4.95742 ± 0.043b 7.4817 ± 0.344c 51.7405 ± 0.810a 43.0556 ± 0.25b 39.1016 ± 0.189c
a,b,c
Means in the same row with different alphabets are significantly different (P < 0.05).

ucts with yoghurt and probiotic starters (48.48 ± 0.724 and of free radical on biological molecules such as proteins, lipids
51.70 ± 1.034%, respectively). and DNA may be considered as the onset of several chronic
After 7 days of storage all samples had similar values of ACE diseases (Chandrasekara & Shahidi, 2011). The ability of
inhibitory activity, showing an increase after the second week. kombucha fermented milk product to scavenge different radi-
The sample with kombucha starter had the highest ACE in- cals: hydroxyl radical, superoxide radical anion and reducing
hibition (IC50 = 0.25 mg mL−1) on the 14th day of storage, while power were previously attributed to the phenolics, flavo-
there were no significant differences between Y14 and P14 noids, vitamin C and vitamins B presented in the kombucha
sample, reaching IC50 approximately 0.33 mg mL−1 (Fig. 1c). The inoculums (Jayabalan, Subathradevi, Marimuthu, Satishkumar,
calculated IC50 values are in accordance with the results pre- & Swaminathan, 2008).
sented by other research (Donkor, Henriksson, Vasiljevic, & All analysed samples showed significant scavenging ability
Shah, 2007; Hernandez-Ledesma, Miralles, Amigo, Ramos, & against ABTS+ radical cation. The highest activity was deter-
Recio, 2005; Papadimitriou et al., 2007). Donkor et al. (2007) also mined in the yoghurt (TEAC value 6.74 mmol mg−1) product, fol-
reported an increase of the inhibitory activity after the second lowed by probiotic (6.34 mmol mg −1 ) and kombucha
week of storage for both probiotic and control yoghurt, even (5.40 mmol mg−1) products. After the first week of storage a slight
though in the probiotic sample the activity decreased after the increase of the activity was observed in the Y and P products.
first week. Conversely after the second week of storage the activity de-
In this study, different starter cultures led to differences in creased in all samples and significantly lower values were re-
ACE inhibitory activity in fermented products (Fig. 1c). This con- corded compared with day 0. The highest TEAC value
firms that proteinase and peptidase activity of starter cul- (7.49 mmol mg−1) was observed in the sample Y7.
tures may affect the milk protein breakdown to various extents The DPPH RSA in K sample (Table 2) was significantly higher
and thus can yield a wide range of peptides with functional (P > 0.05) after production (17.88 ± 0.17%) than in Y and P samples
properties, such as ACE inhibitory activity. Nevertheless, there (9.46 ± 0.3 and 13.23 ± 0.04% respectively). Kombucha starter used
was not a clear correlation between the trend of changes in for milk fermentation improved DPPH RSA during refriger-
DP and ACE inhibitory activity in any product, but both these ated period due to its own antioxidative capacity (Jayabalan
parameters increased during storage. The ACE inhibitory pep- et al., 2008; Vitas, Malbasa, Lončar, & Grahovac, 2013). The trend
tides are known to be di-, tri- and oligopeptides. Conse- of DPPH activity differs among the samples, but as the ABTS
quently, it is likely possible that during storage the short ACE RSA, it decreased during the second week of storage. The
inhibitory peptides were derived from initially produced longer kombucha samples showed the highest DPPH RSA (P < 0.05) after
peptides, while their concentration did not reflect on the TCA 14 days of storage (7.48 ± 0.34%) compared with Y14 and P14
soluble index used for DP quantification. Also it should be taken samples (6.11 ± 0.3 and 4.96 ± 0.04%, respectively).
into consideration that not only peptides exert ACE inhibi- Using ABTS radical cation, the free RSA of all samples were
tory activity. The concentration of ionic Ca also could affect between 36% and 55%, while with DPPH radicals the activi-
the ACE inhibition, depending on its concentration (Gonzalez- ties were below 18%. The difference between the DPPH and
Gonzalez et al., 2011). Some polyphenol compounds could also ABTS RSA could be partially due, to previously reported dis-
have this activity and this should be further investigated. Even advantages of DPPH if used for hydrophilic antioxidants, such
observed weak in vitro antihypertensive activities, milk derived as protein hydrolysates (Chang, Wu, & Chiang, 2007; Tang et al.,
bioactive peptides are considered as ‘pro-drugs’ that serve as 2010). This mostly refers to the fact that the DPPH can be dis-
precursors of ACE inhibitors during physiological proteolysis solved only in organic media (especially in alcoholic media),
(Chibuike & Aishwarya, 2014). This study, however, indicate that which can lead to precipitation of proteins whose activity is
all used starter cultures may have potential in development analysed. On the contrary, ABTS can be solubilised in aqueous
of antihypertensive fermented milk product. and organic media; thus, radical scavenging activities of both
hydrophilic and lipophilic compounds can be measured (Tang
3.4. Antioxidant activity et al., 2010). Our results, which are in agreement with these
findings, suggest that the ABTS method was more appropri-
The RSA of the water-soluble extracts of fermented milk prod- ate than the DPPH assay for the measurement of antioxidant
ucts was evaluated by the ABTS+. and DPPH radical assays. Both activity of fermented milk WSEs.
assays indicate the ability of substances to act as electron Overall, our results revealed that various starter cultures had
donors or H atom donors in free radical reactions. The attempt different influences on RSA of fermented products, mea-
342 journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345

sured by either ABTS or DPPH method. As there was a lack of


correlation between DP and radical activities, bioactive pep-
tides cannot be assumed as only components responsible for
antioxidant activity. At least, they had not been in the con-
centration in which they influenced the overall antioxidant ca-
pacity of extracts. This suggests that some other components
such as phenol compounds, and vitamins should be further
investigated as potential contributors to the antioxidative ca-
pacity, as those components are suggested as important an-
tioxidants (Samaranayaka & Li-Chan, 2011; Zhong, Ma, &
Shahidi, 2012).

3.5. Vitamin C

Natural antioxidants such as vitamin C and tea extracts have


Fig. 2 – Sensory analyses of fermented dairy products
already been investigated and commercialised as alterna-
during storage period.
tives to synthetic antioxidants in food (Shahidi, 2000). In con-
tribution to the antioxidative potential, the content of vitamin
C was analysed in fermented dairy products. The highest
content of vitamin C after production was recorded in sample
K0 (0.5457 ± 0.017 mg 100 g−1) followed by P0 (0.4404 ± 0.014 mg
3.7. Colour assay
100 g−1) and Y0 (0.4078 ± 0.013 mg 100 g−1). Fermentation by
In addition to sensory evaluation, the colour measurements
komucha showed an increase of vitamin C due to the pres-
were performed on the samples by means of the CIE and CIE
ence of vitamin C in kombucha inoculum in concentration of
Lab colour system. Reflectance spectroscopy quantifies the
0.5096 ± 0.02 mg 100 g−1. Refrigerated storage had profound effect
colour in terms of tristimulus values, which are calculated in
on vitamin C content and it decreased in all samples, by 18.2,
a CIE L, a, and b colour spaces. The L* serves as the psycho-
8.7 and 26.8% in probiotic, yoghurt and kombucha samples, re-
metric correlation of perceived lightness ranging from white
spectively. These results are consistent with the research re-
(100) to black (0), which can be described using the terms strong,
ported by Oberman (1985) who found that fermentation by lactic
moderate and pale, along a grey scale.
acid bacteria resulted in a marked decline in content of vitamin
In contrary to the sensory evaluation (which is more sub-
C. In spite of the decline of vitamin C content after 7 and 14 days
jective methods), significant differences in colour (CIE and CIE
of storage, it still remained significantly higher (P < 0.05) in the
Lab system) between samples obtained by probiotic, yoghurt
sample obtained by kombucha starter than the samples pro-
and kombucha starters are evident (Table 3). Brightness (Y) of
duced using probiotic and yoghurt starter cultures. (Fig. 1d).
samples was from 63.51% in K0 up to 67.03% in Y0 and it was
It is important to emphasise that, sample K14 (sample on the
not significantly (P < 0.05) changed during the storage period.
14th day of storage) did not have significantly (P < 0.05) differ-
The whiteness values (L) of all fermented dairy samples were
ent content of vitamin C compared with sample produced by
not changed during 14 days of storage but it was significantly
yoghurt starter after production (Y0). This high content of
(P < 0.05) higher in samples obtained by the yoghurt and
vitamin C in kombucha product during the storage may con-
probiotic starters than the kombucha starter.
tribute to the antioxidant activity of the new type of fer-
Red/greenness (a-) values of all samples increased after
mented dairy product. Furthermore, significant correlation
7 days of storage and it declined though prolonged storage
between the highest values of antioxidant activities and the
period until the 14th day. The yellowness/blueness (b) value of
quantity of vitamin C in all samples was noticed. The samples
samples had similar trend such as a values. Storage time had
obtained by kombucha had the highest correlation between
a significant effect on the b values of the products. The b values
the RSADPPH and vitamin C content (R2 = 0.997).
of samples significantly declined during storage (P < 0.05). It is
evident that kombucha samples had the highest values of b
3.6. Sensory analysis coefficient and the smallest values of the a coefficient due to
colours of added inoculums.
The sensory evaluations of fermented dairy products are shown
in Fig. 2. No significant differences were observed in appear-
ance, flavour, taste, and overall preference scores between the
three groups of fermented dairy products. Even though, the con- 4. Conclusion
sistency and taste score was greater in Y0 and P0 samples than
in the K0 sample. The kombucha fermented dairy product had Fermented dairy product obtained by kombucha inoculum is
a characteristic, distinctive mild sour, refreshing taste and con- appropriate new product which could increase assortment of
spicuous aroma. However, prolonged storage period up to functional food. During the storage, the fermented milk product
14 days showed that kombucha inoculums affected the con- obtained by kombucha (K) showed similar trend in changes of
sistency and flavour which were reduced in Y and P samples, pH, degree of proteolysis (DP) and sensory properties as prod-
but increased in K sample. ucts with conventional probiotic (P) and yoghurt (Y) starters.
journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345 343

Table 3 – Effect of different starter culture on the color of fermented dairy products during storage assayed by (a) CIE
system, (b) CIE LAB system.
(a)
Sample CIE system
Y (%) λ (nm)
1 day 7 day 14 day 1 day 7 day 14 day
Milk 66.08 ± 0.04 – – 566.57 ± 0.03 – –
P 66.91 ± 0.018 67.46 ± 0.05 66.98 ± 0.04 569.19 ± 0.03 568.53 ± 0.04 569.79 ± 0.01
Y 67.03 ± 0.32 67.22 ± 0.06 66.76 ± 0.19 569.39 ± 0.04 568.65 ± 0.05 569.65 ± 0.01
K 63.51 ± 0.03 64.76 ± 0.08 64.49 ± 0.09 571.72 ± 0.01 571.05 ± 0.01 571.54 ± 0.04

(b)
Sample CIE LAB
L A B
1 day 7 day 14 day 1 day 7 day 14 day 1 day 7 day 14 day
Milk 85.04 ± 0.02 – – –3.3 ± 0.02 – – 5.86 ± 0.03 – –
P 85.46 ± 0.09 85.73 ± 0.03 85.50 ± 0.02 −2.94 ± 0.02 3.09 ± 0.01 2.67 ± 0.01 6.90 ± 0.02 6.67 ± 0.02 6.79 ± 0.01
Y 85.52 ± 0.17 85.62 ± 0.03 85.38 ± 0.02 −2.92 ± 0.02 3.00 ± 0.02 2.75 ± 0.04 7.03 ± 0.02 6.58 ± 0.02 6.85 ± 0.02
K 83.71 ± 0.17 84.36 ± 0.04 84.22 ± 0.01 −1.97 ± 0.01 2.21 ± 0.02 2.06 ± 0.02 7.09 ± 0.02 6.93 ± 0.02 7.12 ± 0.01

Significant ACE inhibitory activity was determined in all fer- Aloulou, A., Hamden, K., Elloumi, D., Ali, M. B., Hargafi, K.,
mented products, which increased during the storage. Still, the Jaouadi, B., Ayadi, F., Elfeki, A., & Ammar, E. (2012).
samples obtained by kombucha inoculum had the highest ACE Hypoglycemic and antilipidemic properties of kombucha in
alloxan-induced diabetic rats. BMC Complementary and
inhibitory (63. 43%) after 14 days of storage. This study, however,
Alternative Medicine, 12, 12–63.
indicated that all used starter cultures may have potential in Carić, M., Milanović, S., & Vucelja, D. (2000). Standard methods of
development of antihypertensive fermented milk product. The analysing milk and dairy products. Novi Sad: University of Novi
high content of vitamin C in kombucha fermented dairy prod- Sad, Faculty of Technology.
ucts during the storage contributed to the DPPH antioxidative Chandrasekara, A., & Shahidi, F. (2011). Bioactivities and
capacity of the new type of fermented dairy product. In all antiradical properties of millet grains and hulls.
Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 59,
samples, higher 2,2’-azino-bis-(3-ethylbenzthiazoline-6-
9563–9571.
sulphonic acid) (ABTS) than 1,1-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl
Chang, C. Y., Wu, K. C., & Chiang, S. H. (2007). Antioxidant
(DPPH) radical scavenging activity was established, while both properties and protein compositions of porcine haemoglobin
activities slightly decreased after the second week of storage. hydrolysates. Food Chemistry, 100, 1537–1543.
The differences in colour, flavour and consistency were ob- Chen, C., & Liu, B. Y. (2000). Changes in major components of tea
served among the three groups of fermented dairy products fungus metabolites during prolonged fermentation. Jornal of
after 14 days of storage. Even more, after 14 days of storage Applied Microbiology, 89, 834–839.
Chibuike, C. U., & Aishwarya, M. (2014). Mechanisms of food
kombucha fermented dairy product had the highest overall
protein-derived antihypertensive peptides other than ACE.
sensory quality. Based on these results, the kombucha inocu-
Journal of Functional Foods, 8, 45–52.
lum could ensure the manufacture of fermented dairy product Considine, T., Healy, A., Kelly, A. L., & McSweeney, P. L. H. (2000).
with similar physicochemical, distinctive sensory and pro- Proteolytic specificity of elastase on bovine as 1-casein. Food
nounced bioactive characteristics with respect to conven- Chemistry, 69, 19–26.
tional yoghurt starters. Donkor, O. N., Henriksson, A., Vasiljevic, T., & Shah, N. P. (2007).
Proteolytic activity of dairy lactic acid bacteria and
probiotics as determinant of viability and in vitro
angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitory activity in
fermented milk. Le Lait, 87(1), 21–38.
Acknowledgements
Dufresne, C., & Farnworth, E. (2000). Tea, kombucha and health: A
review. Food Research International, 33, 409–421.
Authors want to thank Ministry of Education, Science and Gonzalez-Gonzalez, C., Gibson, T., & Jauregi, P. (2013). Novel
Technological Development of Republic of Serbia for the fi- probiotic-fermented milk with angiotensin I-converting
enzyme inhibitory peptides produced by Bifidobacterium
nancial support of research presented in this article, Project
bifidum MF 20/5. International Journal of Food Microbiology, 167,
No. 46009. 131–137.
Gonzalez-Gonzalez, C. R., Tuohy, K. M., & Jauregi, P. (2011).
Production of angiotensin-I-converting enzyme (ACE)
REFERENCES
inhibitory activityin milk fermented with probiotic strains:
Effects of calcium, pH and peptides on the ACE-inhibitory
activity. International Dairy Journal, 21, 615–622.
Acharya, K. R., Sturrock, E. D., Riordan, J. F., & Ehlers, M. R. (2003). Guttapadu, S., Yang, Z., & Wieger, K. (2000). Kombucha
ACE revisited: A new target for structure-based drug design. fermentation and its antimicrobial activity. Journal Agriculture
Nature Review Drug Discovery, 11, 891–902. Food Chemistry, 48, 2589–2594.
344 journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345

Hernandez-Ledesma, B., Miralles, B., Amigo, L., Ramos, M., & Petrušić, M., Radulović, Z., Paunović, D., & Obradović, D. (2011).
Recio, I. (2005). Identification of antioxidant and ACE- Isolation and identification of lactic acid bacteri from
inhibitory peptides in fermented milk. Journal of the Science of kombucha tea. Conference Join Event, Proceedings,
Food and Agriculture, 85, 1041–1048. 180–186.
Houda, B., Amina, B., & Emna, A. (2012). Antimicrobial effect of Re, R., Pellegrini, N., Proteggente, A., Pannala, A., Yang, M., & Rice-
kombucha analogues. LWT – Food Science and Technology, 47, Evans, C. (1999). Antioxidant activity applying an improved
71–77. ABTS radical cation decolorization assay. Free Radical and
Iličić, M., Kanurić, K., Milanović, S., Lončar, E., Djurić, M., & Biology Medicine, 26, 1231–1237.
Malbaša, R. (2012). Lactose fermentation by Kombucha – a Sadeq, H. A.-S., Amin, I., Mohd, Y. M., Shuhaimi, M., Rokiah, M. Y.,
process to obtain new milk – based beverages. Romanian & Fouad, A. H. (2013). Prebiotics as functional foods: A review.
Biotechnological Letters, 17(1), 7013–7021. Journal of Functional Foods, 5, 1542–1553.
Iličić, M., Milanović, S., Carić, M., Vukić, V., Kanurić, K., Ranogajec, Samaranayaka, A. G. P., & Li-Chan, E. C. Y. (2011). Food-derived
M., & Hrnjez, D. (2013). The effect of transglutaminase on peptidic antioxidants: A review of their production,
rheology and texture of fermented milk products. Journal of assessment, and potential applications. Journal of Functional
Texture Studies, 44, 160–168. Foods, 3, 229–254.
Jayabalan, R., Chen, P. N., Hsieh, Y. S., Prabhakaran, K., Pitchai, P., Semantee, B., Ratan, G., & Parames, C. (2013). Effect of Kombucha,
Marimuthu, S., Thangaraj, P., Swaminathan, K., & Yun, S. E. a fermented black tea in attenuating oxidative stress
(2011). Effect of solvent fractions of kombucha tea on viability mediated tissue damage in alloxan induced diabetic rats. Food
and invasiveness of cancer cells – Characterization of and Chemical Toxicology, 60, 328–340.
dimethyl 2-(2-hydroxy-2-methoxypropylidine) malonate and Shah, N., & Ravula, R. (2001). Freezing conditions frozen out. Dairy
vitexin. Indian Journal of Biotechnology, 10, 75–82. Industry International, 1–7.
Jayabalan, R., Subathradevi, P., Marimuthu, S., Satishkumar, M., & Shahidi, F. (2000). Antioxidants in food and food antioxidants. Die
Swaminathan, K. (2008). Changes in free-radical scavenging Nahrung, 44, S158–S163.
ability of kombucha tea during fermentation. Food Chemistry, Shori, A. B., & Baba, A. S. (2013). Antioxidant activity and
109, 227–234. inhibition of key enzymes linked to type-2 diabetes and
Kittiphattanabawona, P., Benjakul, S., Visessanguan, W., & hypertension by Azadirachta indica-yogurt. Journal of Saudi
Shahidi, F. (2013). Inhibition of angiotensin converting Chemical Society, 17, 295–301.
enzyme, human LDL cholesterol and DNA oxidation by Slocum, S. A., Jasinski, E. M., Anantheswaran, R. C., & Kilara, A.
hydrolysates from blacktip shark gelatine. LWT – Food Science (1988). Effect of sucrose on proteolysis in yogurt during
and Technology, 51(2013), 177–182. incubation and storage. Journal of Dairy Science, 71,
Korhonen, H. (2009). Milk-derived bioactive peptides: From 589–595.
science to applications. Journal of Functional Foods, 1, Tamime, A. Y., Hassan, A., Farnworth, E., & Toba, T. (2007).
177–187. Structure of fermented milks. In A. Y. Tamime (Ed.),
Lončar, E., Kanurić, K., Malbaša, R., Ðurić, M., & Milanović, S. Structure of dairy products (pp. 134–169). Singapore: Blackwell
(2013). Kinetics of saccharose fermentation by Kombucha. Publishing.
Chemical Industry and Chemical Engineering Quarterly, Tang, X., He, Z., Dai, Y., Xiong, Y. L., Xie, M., & Chen, J. (2010).
doi:10.2298/CICEQ121113016L. Peptide fractionation and free radical scavenging activity of
Lowry, O. H., Rosenbrough, N. J., Fair, A. L., & Randall, R. J. (1951). zein hydrolysate. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 58,
Protein measurement with the Folin–phenol reagents. The 587–593.
Journal of Biological Chemistry, 193, 265–275. Teoh, A. L., Heard, G., & Cox, J. (2004). Yeast ecology of kombucha
Malbaša, R., Lončar, E., Milanović, S., & Kolarov, Lj. (2009a). Use of fermentation. International Journal of Food Microiology, 95, 119–
milk–based kombucha inoculum for milk fermentation. Acta 126.
Periodica Technologica, 40, 47–53. Thummala, S., Ramachandran, A., Jagadeesan, A., & Uppala, S.
Malbaša, R., Milanović, S., Lončar, E., Ðurić, M., Carić, M., Iličić, M., (2013). Down regulation of signalling molecules involved in
& Kolarov, Lj. (2009b). Milk–based beverages obtained by angiogenesis of prostate cancer cell line (PC-3) by kombucha
Kombucha application. Food Chemistry, 112, 17. (lyophilized). Biomedicine & Preventive Nutrition, 3,
Marsh, A. J., O Sullivan, O., Hill, C., Ross, R. P., & Cotter, P. D. (2014). 53–58.
Sequence-based analysis of the bacterial and fungal Tripathi, M. K., & Giri, S. K. (2014). Probiotic functional foods:
compositions of multiple kombucha (tea fungus) samples. Survival of probiotics during processing and storage. Journal of
Food Microbiology, 38, 171–178. Functional Foods, 9, 225–241.
Milanović, S., Kanurić, K., Vukić, V., Hrnjez, D., Iličić, M., Trovatti, E., Serafim, L. S., Freire, C. S. R., Silvestre, A. J. D., & Neto,
Ranogajec, M., & Milanović, M. (2012). Physicochemical and C. P. (2011). Gluconacetobacter sacchari: An efficient bacterial
textural properties of kombucha fermented dairy products. cellulose cell-factory. Carbohydrates Polymers, 86,
African Journal of Biotechnology, 11(9), 2320–2327. 1417–1420.
Milanović, S., Lončar, E., Djurić, M., Malbaša, R., Tekić, M., Iličić, Urista, M., Fernandez, R., Rodriguez, R., Cuenca, A., & Jurado, T.
M., & Duraković, K. (2008). Low energy kombucha based (2011). Review: Production and functionality of active peptides
beverages. Acta Periodica Technologica, 39, 37–46. from milk. Food Science and Technology International, 17,
Morales, F. J., & Jimenez-Perez, S. (2001). Free radical scavenging 293–317.
capacity of Maillard reaction products as related to color and Vitas, J., Malbasa, R., Lončar, E., & Grahovac, J. (2013). The
fluorescence. Food Chemistry, 72, 119–125. antioxidant activity of kombucha fermented milk
Oberman, H. (1985). Fermented milks. In B. J. B. Wood (Ed.), products with stinging nettle and winter savory.
Microbiology of fermented foods (Vol. 1, pp. 167–195). London: Chemical Industry & Chemical Engineering Quarterly,
Elsevier Applied Science Publishers. 19, 129–139.
Papadimitriou, C. G., Vafopoulou-Mastrojiannaki, A., Vieira Silva, Vukic, V., Hrnjez, D., Kanuric, K., Milanovic, S., Ilicic, M., Torbica,
S., Gomes, A.-M., Francisco, M. X., & Alichanidis, E. (2007). A., & Tomic, J. (2014). The effect of kombucha starter culture
Identification of peptides in traditional and probiotic sheep on the gelation process, microstructure and rheological
milk yoghurt with angiotensin I-converting enzyme (ACE)- properties during milk fermentation. Journal of Texture Studies,
inhibitory activity. Food Chemistry, 10, 647–656. doi:10.1111/jtxs.12071.
journal of functional foods 10 (2014) 336–345 345

Wu, W., Gai, B., & Ji, B. (2004). Study on the isolation and Zhang, H., Zhang, Z., & Xin, X. (2011). Isolation and identification
identification of microbes of kombucha. Journal of Food Science, of microorganisms from kombucha fungus culture. Journal of
4, 10. Beijing Union Univiversity, 2, 11.
Yoshie-Stark, Y., Bez, J., Wada, Y., & Wasche, A. N. (2004). Zhong, Y., Ma, C. M., & Shahidi, F. (2012). Antioxidant and
Functional properties, lipoxygenase activity, and health antiviral activities of lipophilic epigallocatechin gallate
aspects of Lupinus albus protein isolates. Journal of Agriculture (EGCG) derivatives. Journal of Functional Foods, 4,
and Food Chemistry, 52, 7681–7689. 87–93.

You might also like