Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IIM K ’S FINA N CI A L
NEW SL E T T ER
20TH MARCH, 2008
FROM FY DESK
INSIDE THIS ISSUE:
1$ = Rs. 40.348
BUDGET BIG FYTE
Inflation 5.11% 6TH MARCH 2008 | AMPHI,IIMK
BSE -8.67% (17-20 Budget Big FYte was the first formed and presented were budget. Some of the points
Mar) event for the new FY coordina- discussed. that were discussed at stretch
tors. This is a panel discussion were agricultural waivers and
This year the panel discussion
MARKET WATCH where budding analysts from tax schemes.
saw an enthusiastic participa-
IIMK come and present their
tion from three teams Alok & The teams were well sup-
views and opinions on the
Arpit, Divy & Gaurav G and ported by enthusiastic partici-
16 budget.
15 Ashish A & Rohit. The one and pation from the audience.
14 Prior to the event pre budget half hour session saw the
sessions were held where the teams discuss on various top-
details of how a budget is ics related to the just released
IIMK’S FINANCIAL NEWSLETTER Page 2
BUDGET ANALYSIS
One of the top priorities for government CRR will also be critical in curbing inflation.
was taming inflation which remained at taken major initiatives in agriculture, educa-
around 5%. Rise in crude oil prices, dismal To boost growth, the FM emphasized on tion, public health, employment. To improve
performance of agriculture and excessive consumption front by relaxing tax slabs for infrastructure, which still remains the biggest
capital inflows were major drivers for infla- public and cutting excise duty and CENVAT. bottle-neck for India‘s high speed growth, FM
tion. The allotment to agriculture has been stressed on creation of more PPPs (Public
done to increase supply side along with FM‘s decision of 60,000 crore debt waiver Private Partnerships) and also approved 5
inclusive growth. came after a dismal 2.4% growth in agricul- billion $ in SPV (Special Purpose Vehicle),
ture. Since modus operandi of financing whose funds will be used in infrastructure.
Increase in (STCG) Short Term Capital this waiver was ambiguous, share prices of
Gains Tax from 10 to 15% has been done most national banks fell steeply as the Rupee appreciation has badly hit Indian
to monitor capital inflows and check specu- general sentiment in the stock market was exports sectors like IT sector. To curb this, an
lative flows which cause volatility in capital that this waiver will result in significant exchange traded currency features market
market. This also means that FIIs and in- cash outflow for these banks. will be developed to hedge the currency risk.
vestors involved in short selling pay higher
taxes. Steps taken by RBI using SLR and To emphasize on inclusive growth, FM has
A capital gain is income derived from the government taxes fully any gain that they Take for example, the capital gains tax paid
sale of an investment. A capital investment realize if the investment has a positive on a pharmaceutical stock. The value of that
can be a home, a farm or a family busi- return. But the government allows only stock is based on the discounted present
ness . The capital gain is the difference partial tax deduction if the venture goes
value of all of the future proceeds of the
between the money received from selling sour and results in a loss.
the asset and the price paid for it. company. If the company is expected to earn
There is one other large inequity of the Rs.100,000 a year for the next 20 years, the
There are many irregularities imbedded in capital gains tax. It represents a form of sales price of the stock will reflect those
the current tax treatment of capital gains. double taxation on capital formation. This returns. The "gain" that the seller realizes
One is that capital gains are not indexed is how economists Victor Canto and Harvey from the sale of the stock will reflect those
for inflation: the seller pays tax not only on Hirschorn explain the situation:
future returns and thus the seller will pay
the real gain in purchasing power but also
on the illusory gain attributable to inflation. capital gains tax on the future stream of
A government can choose to tax either the
The inflation penalty is one reason that, income. But the company's future
value of an asset or its yield, but it should
historically, capital gains have been taxed Rs.100,000 annual returns will also be
not tax both. Capital gains are literally the
at lower rates than ordinary income. taxed when they are earned. So the
appreciation in the value of an existing
Rs.100,000 in profits is taxed twice--when
Another irregularity of the tax is that indi- asset. Any appreciation reflects merely an
the owners sell their shares of stock and
viduals are permitted to deduct only a por- increase in the after-tax rate of return on
when the company actually earns the in-
tion of the capital losses that they incur, the asset. The taxes implicit in the asset's
whereas they must pay taxes on all of the come. That is why many tax analysts argue
after-tax earnings are already fully re-
gains. That introduces an unfriendly bias in that the most equitable rate of tax on capital
flected in the asset's price or change in
the tax code against risk taking. When gains is zero.
taxpayers undertake risky investments, the price. Any additional tax is strictly double
taxation.
FOR—We believe they are not as 3> The amount would be offset back their due, FM is punishing
Annual Financial Statement –
bad as they look like because of against oil bonds which would them and setting up a wrong
A statement of estimated
following reasons: be spread over a period of 3 precedent. Secondly, deciding
receipts and expenditure in
1> They would help the banks years. Moreover the banks get only on basis of land‘s size is
respect to every financial year
to transfer their bad loans to rebate on the interest of the only considering partial POV.
– April 1 to March 31
government thereby boosting bad loans. So only a portion of Climate, soil fertility, irrigation
their lending capacity and re- the amount needs to be given facilities, etc are also as signifi- Cess – Additional to the basic
ducing their NPAs since almost afresh by the government. cant, but these have been ne-
tax liability, levied to meet
all of these loans will definitely - Alok and Arpit glected in selecting the needy
specific expenditure
go bad. So this would help farmers. Also, this waiver does
b a n k s FACE 2 FACE not help those farmers who Consolidated Fund – Most
have taken credit from private important government fund,
2> Farmers who would get the agencies instead of govern-
which shows the revenues
benefit can again get fresh ment. And the biggest issue is
AGAINST— The huge debt raised, money borrowed and
loans which would help them the ambiguity involved with fi-
pump in fresh money for agricul- waiver given to farmers gives nancing this waiver which has revenues from loans given by
ture. This would definitely boost out wrong signals from the gov- got stock market diving. government
p r o d u c t i o n . ernment. Firstly, instead of - Ashish and Rohit
awarding farmers who gave Contingency Fund – This 500
crore fund, which meets any
urgent and unforeseen expen-
FIN-TERESTING PAST diture, is at the disposal of the
President
1997 MBA from Harvard University New tax schemes introduced Excise Duty – A tax levied on
July 4 – NASA‘s Pathfinder and wore his trademark white New incentives given for invest- consumption of certain goods
probe lands on Mars shirt and gold bordered dhoti. ment by FIIs and NRIs Fiscal Deficit – Excess of total
Jul y 25 – KR Narayanan, the This man was Palaniappan Lowering of excise and customs expenditure over total non
first member from the Dalit Chidambaram, the then finance duties borrowed receipts
caste sworn in as President minister of India. Electronic equipment like televi- Fringe Benefit Tax (FBT) – In
August 31 – Princess Diana In 1996, Chidamabaram pre- sion became cheaper addition to wages, perquisites
dies in a car crash in Paris sented his first budget which Mass consumption items like or fringe benefits are paid to
September 5 – Mother Theresa was described by most as lack- toiletry, coffee etc became the employee. These are
dies of heart failure lustre. In 1997 he did a turn cheaper taxed under FBT
The year 1997 saw several ma- around. The Budget laid down a Overall, it was a ‗Dream Budget‘ Service Tax – Tax on services
jor events which shaped the road map for reforms. It was when it was announced, but rendered. Divided into direct
world for the good or the bad. In aligned with what he said after- later on it turned out to be a and indirect tax
India, one such event happened wards, ―The dream of 1997 was nightmare. Why, you ask? Let‘s Subsidies – Financial assis-
on February, the 28th. The Union a signal to the world that we are leave that for some other day tance provided by the Govern-
budget was presented on this ready to come out of our cocoon ment to individuals to be com-
petitive
day and it was termed as path and join the world.‖ The major
breaking or more popularly as points in the budget were as T-bills – Bonds with maturity
less than year, primarily is-
the ―Dream Budget‖. follows:-
sued to meet short term reve-
The United Front, led by Janata Lowering of income tax rate to nue and expenditure mis-
Dal with H. D. Deve Gowda as 30% matches.
the Prime Minister took over the VDS to harness ‗black money‘
country‘s affairs in the year announced
1996. Also part of this coalition Sops for the capital market.
was an individual, who was a Existing tax schemes modified,
Page 4
Mail us at fy@iimk.ac.in
Financially Yours (FY) is the
finance interest group of IIMK.
FINANCIALLY YOURS The prime objective of FY is to
promote and develop an inter-
est in the field of finance.
Mridul M 9946103226
Through a variety of activities
Rohit J 9946102149
all round the year like holding
Saurabh K 9946102142
sessions, competitions, orga-
Viral S 9946660709 nizing seminars for Horizons
and management events for
We thank Reshma Umbarje for her Backwaters, FY facilitates the
valuable contributions learning process and encour-
age friendly competition
among fin enthusiasts.
With this issue of the newsletter we invite articles/interesting facts from the readers. This would be the first platform of sharing knowl-
edge amongst all the fin enthusiasts. Further look forward for suggestions and ideas for the coming academic year so that we can
plan accordingly.
FIN TRIVIA 1
1 4 5 2 7
Across: Down:
3
1. Liabilities > assets (7) 2. Contract where you pay a premium and 6 10 11
3. Gifts/bonds with redemption rate beyond 15 the latter will pay for some events (9)
years (5) 4. Excise Duty on _______ cars reduced to 8
6. Cost advantages that a firm obtains due to Nil (Union Budget 2008) (8)
9
expansion (Abbrv.) (3) 5. FTSE 100 index (7)
1
8. Capital gain + Dividend (Abbrv.) (3) 7. Public sector company having securities 3 12
9. A right by which you can possess goods of listed on stock exchange (6) 14
another until the latter fulfills the obligations (4) 11. ________ Income : Dividends obtained Solutions for Fin Trivia—
10. Money put aside by organizations to repay a by Shareholders out of post tax profits of UK
Newsletter (Reshma)
bond issue (Abbrv.) (2) companies (7) 1M 9A T I 18F 10A