Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CSU PHIL 110 Notes - Logical Analogies
CSU PHIL 110 Notes - Logical Analogies
Some toilet paper rolls are not things that are white
No things that are white are black things
---------
Some black things are toilet paper rolls
Arguing that is like arguing that No things that are white are black things, so some black things
are toilet paper rolls, because some toilet paper rolls are not things that are white.
8.
No [intellectuals (= I)] are [successful politicians (= SP)], because no [shy and retiring
People (=SR)] are successful politicians, and some intellectuals are shy and retiring
People.
No SR are SP
Some I are SR
----------------
No I are SP
Invalid, illicit minor