Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2017 CONTINUUM Liver Disease and Neurology PDF
2017 CONTINUUM Liver Disease and Neurology PDF
International
Society for
Hepatic
West Encephalopathy
Haven and Nitrogen Suggested
Criteria Metabolism Description Operative Criteria
Unimpaired No encephalopathy Tested and proven
and no history of to be normal
hepatic encephalopathy
Minimal Covert Psychometric or Abnormal results
neuropsychological of established
alterations of tests psychometric or
exploring psychomotor neuropsychological
speed/executive functions tests without clinical
or neurophysiologic manifestations
alterations without
clinical evidence of
mental change
Grade 1 Covert Trivial lack of Despite being
awareness; euphoria oriented in time
or anxiety; shortened and space, patient
attention span; seems to have some
impairment of cognitive-behavioral
addition or subtraction; decay with respect
altered sleep rhythm to the standard on
clinical examination
or to the caregiver
Grade II Overt Lethargy or apathy; Disoriented for time
disorientation for time; (at least three of the
obvious personality following are wrong:
change; inappropriate day of the month,
behavior; dyspraxia; day of the week,
asterixis month, season,
or year) with or
without the other
mentioned symptoms
Grade III Overt Somnolence to Disoriented also for
semistupor; responsive space (at least three
to stimuli; confused; of the following
gross disorientation; wrongly reported:
bizarre behavior country, state
[or region], city,
or place) with or
without the other
mentioned symptoms
Grade IV Overt Coma Does not respond
even to painful stimuli
a
Modified with permission from American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases, European Association for the Study of the Liver.3 B 2014
The American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases. aasld.org/sites/default/files/guideline_documents/hepaticencephenhanced.pdf.
Other tests that have been evaluated dorsiflexing the wrists and fanning
in the diagnosis of minimal hepatic the fingers to visualize the flap of the
encephalopathy include continuous re- patient’s wrist. It presents at early
action time tests, inhibitory control stages of hepatic encephalopathy and
tests, computerized test batteries, the may be observed in other metabolic
psychometric hepatic encephalopathy encephalopathies. The pathophysiol-
score, and the repeatable battery for the ogy of asterixis remains unknown.
assessment of neuropsychological sta- Serum ammonia levels are typically
tus. While these various scales may be elevated in patients with a higher
useful in evaluating patients with mini- grade of encephalopathy. Measure-
mal encephalopathy, they should not ment of serum ammonia levels is
be considered as a replacement of more not useful in screening for hepatic
standard neuropsychological testing.6,7 encephalopathy in patients with
Asterixis, a form of negative myo- known chronic liver disease since lev-
clonus, is recognized by the lack of els do not correlate with the se-
ability to actively keep a position verity of the encephalopathy.8 Brain
followed by occurrence of irregular imaging, including MRI, is generally of
lapses of posture of different body little use in this group of patients,
parts. Clinically, asterixis is elicited by although patients with chronic liver
extending the patient’s arms while dysfunction may demonstrate regions
Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2017;23(3):762–777 ContinuumJournal.com 765
Copyright © American Academy of Neurology. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Liver Disease
KEY POINT
h Brain imaging is of T1 shortening involving the globus antibiotics (including rifaximin and
generally of little use in pallidus and substantia nigra, with oc- neomycin), lactulose, and nutritional
the diagnosis of hepatic casional involvement of the subthalamic therapies such as probiotics may be
encephalopathy,
nucleus, tectal plate, and hypothalamus, effective. Liver transplantation is con-
although patients with
felt to be related to manganese deposi- sidered the definitive treatment.5
chronic liver disease may
show T1-weighted
tion (Figure 7-19).1,3
Hepatic encephalopathy can be ACQUIRED NON-WILSONIAN
hyperintensities in the
basal ganglia thought to precipitated by numerous factors, in- HEPATOCEREBRAL
represent accumulations cluding infections; conditions that DEGENERATION
of manganese. lead to nitrogen overload, such as Acquired non-Wilsonian hepatocereb-
gastrointestinal bleeding and uremia; ral degeneration can occur in any
overuse of diuretics; use of sedatives patient with chronic liver failure. This
and hypnotics; constipation; and elec- condition was described by van
trolyte imbalance. Woerkem in 1914 and later described
Treatment of hepatic encephalopa- by Victor and Adams in 1965.10 This
thy is usually directed toward reducing clinical entity can be confused with
the production and absorption of the clinical picture seen in Wilson
ammonia in the intestine. Various disease. While irreversible, progressive
neurologic symptoms can be arrested
following liver transplantation. Clinical
symptoms are numerous, but patients
may show signs and symptoms that
can include parkinsonism, cognitive
decline, ataxia, apathy, somnolence,
myelopathy, dystonia, cranial dyskine-
sias, and chorea (Case 7-2).1,11,12
Acquired hepatocerebral degeneration
is associated with T1-weighted hyper-
intensities caused by manganese de-
position in the basal ganglia and
atrophic changes in the cerebral cor-
tex, basal ganglia, and cerebellum on
MRI.1,12Y14 It should be noted, how-
ever, that these findings may be seen
in any patient with chronic liver dis-
ease, with or without clinical signs of
hepatocerebral degeneration. Manga-
nese toxicity is believed to play a role
in the MRI findings and in the patho-
genesis of this condition. This syn-
drome can usually be differentiated
FIGURE 7-1 MRI in a patient with chronic liver disease. from Wilson disease as it begins in an
Axial T1-weighted MRI demonstrating
bilaterally symmetric pallidal hyperintensity, older age group, is not genetic in
thought to be related to manganese nature, and does not have the labora-
deposition.
tory findings seen in Wilson disease.
Reprinted with permission from Bathla G, Hegde AN, Patients do not have evidence of
Clinical Radiology.9 B 2012 The Royal College of
Radiologists. clinicalradiologyonline.net/article/S0009-
Kayser-Fleischer rings.12,13
9260(12)00484-9/fulltext. The toxic effects of manganese are
currently thought to contribute to the
KEY POINT
h Hepatic myelopathy manganese excretion, and early treat- tional disorders or some other meta-
must be differentiated ment can improve both parkinsonian bolic process. Conditions that might
from numerous other and dystonic symptoms.16 cause a metabolic myelopathy (eg,
causes of myelopathy. vitamin B12, copper, or vitamin E
Liver transplantation HEPATIC MYELOPATHY deficiency) should be considered in
may result in Another rare neurologic manifestation the differential diagnosis of hepatic
some improvement of chronic liver disease is hepatic myelopathy.17
of symptoms. myelopathy, which is typically asso- The diagnosis of hepatic myelopa-
ciated with portosystemic shunts that thy is one primarily of exclusion,
occur either spontaneously or are sur- although it should be considered in
gically created (transjugular intra- the presence of liver dysfunction. The
hepatic portosystemic shunt).17 Clinical differential diagnosis is very broad and
symptoms of spastic paraparesis de- includes all of the conditions that
velop insidiously, with slowly progres- might cause a spastic paraparesis.
sive weakness and spasticity in the MRI of the spinal cord is necessary to
lower extremities. Patients may be left exclude a compressive myelopathy or
wheelchair dependent as the para- other intrinsic/extrinsic cord disease.
paresis progresses. The upper extrem- Usually, imaging studies of the spinal
ities are not usually affected. Sensory cord in hepatic myelopathy are nor-
involvement is usually absent, although mal. Brain MRI has been reported to
some reports of posterior column show abnormalities of intracerebral
dysfunction exist. A small fiber distal corticospinal tracts; T1 hyperinten-
neuropathy has also been described, sities in the globus pallidus and
although this may be related to various putamen attributable to manganese
underlying causes of liver disease. On deposition have also been described
neurologic examination, patients show in patients with hepatic myelopathy.17
evidence of spasticity, hyperreflexia, and Early diagnosis may lead to earlier
bilateral extensor plantar responses.18 treatment that can arrest the progres-
Symmetric loss of myelin, primarily sion of hepatic myelopathy, although
in the lateral corticospinal tracts, has response to treatment is poor. Liver
been described histologically. Demye- transplantation has been reported to
lination in the anterior corticospinal be effective in some cases.19
tracts, posterior columns, and spino-
cerebellar tracts has also been de- ACUTE LIVER FAILURE
scribed. As the disease progresses, Fulminant hepatic failure has been
axonal loss is also seen, leading to defined as ‘‘a severe liver injury,
irreversible neurologic dysfunction. potentially reversible in nature and
Hepatic myelopathy seems to be with onset of hepatic encephalopathy
closely related to portosystemic shunt- within 8 weeks of the first symptoms
ing of blood, which may allow ammo- in the absence of preexisting liver
nia or other nitrogenous breakdown disease.’’20,21 Liver failure of this type
products to bypass the liver and cause results in abnormal liver function tests
damage to the spinal cord. Although and elevated serum ammonia levels.
hepatic myelopathy is typically associ- High serum ammonia levels are a
ated with repeated bouts of hepatic marker for more severe encephalopa-
encephalopathy, it may occur in the thy and development of cerebral
absence of hepatic encephalopathy. edema.8 Coagulopathy and multiorgan
Some possibility exists that hepatic failure also commonly occur in acute
myelopathy could be related to nutri- liver failure. Mortality may be as high
768 ContinuumJournal.com June 2017
KEY POINTS
h Wilson disease is caused Dr Bruno Fleischer (1903),26 who symptoms beginning as late as age 70
by mutation of the gene thought it was caused by deposition have also been described.16 Typical
ATP7B on chromosome of silver. The association of abnormal symptoms at the time of onset include
13q14 coding for the copper metabolism and Wilson dis- movement disorders, such as dystonia
protein ATP7B. ease was first described by Cumings27 or parkinsonian symptoms. A classic
Next-generation in 1948. Following this, trials of treat- wing-beating tremor may also be
sequencing of this gene ment for Wilson disease using the present. Dysarthria is also common
may be less time chelating agents dimercaprol and pen- with these movement abnormalities.
consuming and more icillamine were performed successfully. Tremors may be present at rest and
cost effective than older Today, the genetic cause for Wilson with action/intention. They are often
techniques in assessing
disease has been found. The disease jerky and may be associated with
the presence of this
is an autosomal recessive condition dystonia. Dystonia is seen in one-
genetic abnormality.
caused by the mutations of the ATP7B third of patients and may be general-
h Kayser-Fleischer rings gene on chromosome 13q14. This ized, segmental, focal, or multifocal.
may be absent in
gene codes for the protein ATP7B, Dysarthria and slow tongue move-
patients with Wilson
which enables incorporation of cop- ments may be associated with facial
disease who do not
have evidence of
per into apoceruloplasmin to form grimacing or risus sardonicus, a con-
neurologic involvement. ceruloplasmin. Abnormally low levels dition that was pictured in Wilson’s
of ceruloplasmin result because of original article.24 A parkinsonian pic-
the defective ATP7B protein. Since ture of bradykinesia, gait abnor-
ceruloplasmin levels are low, hepatic malities, and impairment of rapid
copper levels increase until the liver alternating movements may also be
can no longer store more. Copper typical. Usually a dystonic, ataxic, or
subsequently spills out, leading to parkinsonian syndrome is present.
pathologic effects on other organ More likely, a combination of these
systems. More than 500 mutations of features exists. These symptoms may
this gene have been found.16 Genetic also be associated with cognitive de-
testing has been helpful in diagnosing cline and behavioral changes, such as
this disorder, but the high number irritability, disinhibition, and changes
of mutations has greatly limited its in personality.16,31
use. Older techniques for gene analy- Wilson disease may present with
sis have been expensive and time only laboratory abnormalities of he-
consuming.28 A 2016 report, how- patic function, but clinical signs and
ever, indicates that the use of next- symptoms of acute or chronic liver dis-
generation sequencing may prove to ease are more likely. Symptoms of
be a reliable method for diagnosing hepatic encephalopathy can also be pres-
Wilson disease that will save both time ent early in the course of the disease.
and money.29 Kayser-Fleischer rings are caused
Wilson disease is a rare condition by copper deposition in the Descemet
reported to have a prevalence of 30 membrane and are best seen with
cases per 1 million. The incidence is slit-lamp examination. The presence
higher in Germany, Japan, and Austria of Kayser-Fleischer rings is common
and highest in Costa Rica.30 Higher when patients have neurologic involve-
incidence may be related to consan- ment and are practically pathognomonic
guinity and a possible founder effect.16 for Wilson disease, particularly in the
Symptoms of Wilson disease can be presence of low ceruloplasmin levels.
neurologic, hepatic, or psychiatric. Another ocular finding is the presence of
Onset is typically in the second or sunflower cataracts that are caused by
third decade, although neurologic copper deposition in the anterior and
770 ContinuumJournal.com June 2017
Typical Clinical
Symptoms and Signs Other Tests
Kayser-Fleischer rings Liver copper (in absence of cholestasis)
Present 2 95 times upper limit of normal (9250 mcg/g) 2
Absent 0 Normal 0
KEY POINTS
h Routine serum copper Wilson disease, the defective and min studies and, if possible, genetic
level is not particularly malfunctioning ATP7B protein cannot testing to identify presymptomatic
helpful in screening for incorporate copper molecules into individuals.16,31
Wilson disease since it apoceruloplasmin, which, in turn, re- Neuroimaging findings may also aid
measures total serum sults in low levels of ceruloplasmin. in the diagnosis of Wilson disease.
copper, which is bound Urinary copper levels are increased to Characteristic T2-weighted hyperin-
to ceruloplasmin. over 100 mcg/24 h in adults and more tensities are seen in the basal ganglia
Perhaps the best single than 40 mcg/24 h in children. Routine and ventrolateral thalamus. T1-weighted
screening test for serum copper level is not particularly signal changes have also been de-
Wilson disease is the helpful since it measures total serum scribed in the putamen, caudate, globus
24-hour urinary copper
copper, which is bound to ceruloplas- pallidus, thalamus, and midbrain.32 The
measurement.
min. Perhaps the best single screening face of the giant panda sign is de-
h With early diagnosis and test for Wilson disease is the 24-hour scribed as a classic MRI finding seen on
treatment, symptoms of urinary copper measurement. Free se- T2-weighted images in Wilson disease
Wilson disease can be
rum copper levels may not be available (Figure 7-233). This finding is caused
controlled. Treatment
routinely but are usually greater than by high signal in the tegmentum, hypo-
typically is with drugs
such as penicillamine,
200 mcg/L. Hepatic copper in patients intensity in the superior colliculus,
trientine, and other with Wilson disease is greater than and sparing of the red nucleus and
chelating agents. Oral 250 mcg/g dry weight. Kayser-Fleischer pars reticulata. However, this pattern
zinc can also be used rings may be absent in patients who was seen in only 14.3% of patients in a
to inhibit absorption have only hepatic disease but are 2010 study.34
of copper in the typically present in those with neu- Treatment of Wilson disease is a
gastrointestinal tract. rologic involvement. Families of lifelong endeavor because serum cop-
patients with Wilson disease should per levels cannot be controlled by
also be screened for Kayser-Fleischer limiting copper intake alone. Use of
rings and have copper and ceruloplas- chelating agents, such as penicillamine
FIGURE 7-2 T2-weighted axial MRI demonstrates (A) symmetric hyperintense signals in the
putamen, posterior internal capsule, and thalami (arrows), (B) ‘‘face of the giant
panda’’ in midbrain with high signal in tegmentum and normal red nuclei (arrows).
Reprinted with permission from Shivakumar R, Thomas SV, Neurology.33 B 2009 American Academy
of Neurology. neurology.org/content/72/11/e50.full.
KEY POINTS
h Fifty percent of patients also been reported with hepatitis A sel involvement in the cerebral white
with hepatitis C have infection. Similar neurologic problems matter may be associated with acute
mixed cryoglobulinemia. rarely occur in patients with hepatitis or subacute encephalopathy, causing
B infection.11 impairment of cognition, confusion,
h Hepatitis C is a
worldwide problem that
Chronic hepatitis C infection has dysarthria, and dysphagia.39
can cause numerous been associated with a number of Encephalomyelitis from cerebral
neurologic problems, neurologic problems. Hepatitis C in- and meningeal inflammation from
including fection is a global problem, affecting chronic hepatitis C infection may lead
cerebrovascular about 185 million people, with an to symptoms of spastic quadriparesis,
symptoms, problems estimated prevalence of 2.8% world- bladder and bowel dysfunction, and
with cognitive function, wide. 37 While the virus primarily sensory loss. Transverse myelitis and
inflammatory processes affects the liver, it is known to in- acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
affecting the spinal volve other organs and can be consid- have been reported as well.38,39
cord, and peripheral ered a systemic disease. Chronic Peripheral neuropathy may occur in
nerve pathology.
hepatitis C infection causes hepatic patients with mixed cryoglobulinemia.40
and systemic inflammation by way of Neuropathy is usually related to ische-
mechanisms that are immunologic as mic changes in the nerve associated
a consequence of B-cell proliferation, with distal symmetric sensory or senso-
circulating inflammatory cytokines/ rimotor polyneuropathy characterized
chemokines, and cryoglobulinemia. by burning feet, painful paresthesia,
Chronic infection may possibly in- and allodynia on examination. Large
crease the risk for type 2 diabetes fiber polyneuropathy is less frequent
mellitus, renal disease, cardiovascular but has been reported to occur.41 Mo-
disease, and rheumatologic disease. noneuropathy, mononeuritis multiplex,
Hepatitis C has been associated with and cranial neuropathy affecting the
neurologic and psychiatric symptoms abducens, facial, and motor trigeminal
in up to half of patients with the nerve has also been described.40,42
infection.38 Causation has not been About half of patients with chronic
conclusively demonstrated, but the hepatitis C infections develop psychi-
adverse effects of hepatitis C therapy atric symptoms. Cognitive difficulties
are a potential confounder. known as brain fog and symptoms of
Acute and chronic cerebrovascular depression and anxiety are common.
events occur more often in patients Fatigue is the most frequent symp-
with hepatitis C infection than in the tom, causing both physical and mental
general population. The infection in- exhaustion. This is often associated with
creases atherosclerosis by a number of difficulty with concentration, poor at-
mechanisms, including increases in tention span, feelings of depression, and
cytokines causing oxidative stress, somatic symptoms such as headache
homocysteinemia, insulin resistance, and myalgia. Sleep disturbances such as
and diabetes mellitus. Fifty percent of insomnia are also common. These
patients with hepatitis C have mixed symptoms seem to be more common
cryoglobulinemia. This may be associ- in women and older age groups.38,39
ated with the deposition of immune Hepatitis E infection is not com-
complexes in vessel walls leading to mon in Western developed countries,
occlusion of the vessel. Vasculitic but it has been reported as an emerg-
changes in the cerebral arteries can ing disease in the West and in Japan
cause ischemic strokes and symptoms and is more common than previously
of transient cerebral ischemia but recognized. It usually causes few sym-
rarely hemorrhagic strokes. Small ves- ptoms that cannot be distinguished
774 ContinuumJournal.com June 2017
13. Butterworth RF. Parkinsonism in cirrhosis: 26. Fleischer B. Zwei weitere fälle von grünlicher
pathogenesis and current therapeutic Verfärbung der kornea. Klin Monatsbl
options. Metab Brain Dis 2013;28(2): Augenheilk 1903;41:489Y491.
261Y267. doi:10.1007/s11011-012-9341-7. 27. Cumings JN. The copper and iron content of
14. Maffeo E, Montuschi A, Stura G, Giordana brain and liver in the normal and in hepato-
MT. Chronic acquired hepatocerebral lenticular degeneration. Brain 1948;71(pt 4):
degeneration, pallidal T1 MRI hyperintensity 410Y415. doi:10.1093/brain/71.4.410.
and manganese in a series of cirrhotic 28. Schilsky ML, Ala A. Genetic testing for
patients. Neuro Sci 2014;35(4):523Y530. Wilson disease: availability and utility. Curr
doi:10.1007/s10072-013-1458-x. Gastroenterol Rep 2010;12(1):57Y61.
15. Stamelou M, Tuschi K, Chong WK, et al. doi:10.1007/s11894-009-0084-5.
Dystonia with brain manganese accumulation 29. Németh D, Árvai K, Horváth P, et al. Clinical
resulting from SLC30A10 mutations: use of next-generation sequencing in the
a new treatable disorder. Mov Disord 2012; diagnosis of Wilson’s disease. Gastroenterol
27(10):1317Y1322. doi:10.1002/mds.25138. Res Pract 2016;2016:4548039. doi:10.1155/
2016/4548039.
16. Bandmann O, Weiss KH, Kaler SG. Wilson’s
disease and other neurological copper 30. Hevia FJ, Miranda M. The special problem of
disorders. Lancet Neurol 2015;14(1):103Y113. Wilson’s Disease in Costa RicaVan unexpected
doi:10.1016/S1474-4422(14)70190-5. high prevalence. Gastroenterol Int 1989;1:228.
31. Rodriguez-Castro KI, Hevia-Urrutia FJ,
17. Nardone R, Höller Y, Storti M, et al. Spinal
Sturniolo GC. Wilson’s disease: a review of
cord involvement in patients with cirrhosis.
what we have learned. World J Hepatol
World J Gastroenterol 2014;20(10):
2015;7(29):2859Y2870. doi:10.4254/
2578Y2585. doi:10.3748/wjg.v20.i10.2578.
wjh.v7.i29.2859.
18. Yin YH, Ma ZJ, Guan YH, et al. Clinical 32. Sinha S, Taly AB, Ravishankar S, et al.
features of hepatic myelopathy in patients Wilson’s disease: cranial MRI observations
with chronic liver disease. Postgrad Med J and clinical correlation. Neuroradiology
2009;85(1000):64Y68. doi:10.1136/ 2006;48(9):613Y621. doi:10.1007/
pgmj.2007.067371. s00234-006-0101-4.
19. Caldwell C, Werdiger N, Jakab S, et al. Use of 33. Shivakumar R, Thomas SV. Teaching
a model for end-stage liver disease exception NeuroImages: face of the giant panda and
points for early liver transplantation and her cub. Neurology 2009;72(11).e50.
successful reversal of hepatic myelopathy with doi:10.1212/01.wnl.0000344409.73717.a1.
a review of the literature. Liver Transpl 34. Prashanth LK, Sinha S, Taly AB, Vasudev MK.
2010;16(7):818Y826. doi:10.1002/lt.22077. Do MRI features distinguish Wilson’s
20. Bernal W, Wendon J. Acute liver failure. disease from other early onset
N Engl J Med 2013;369(26):2525Y2534. extrapyramidal disorders? An analysis of
doi:10.1056/NEJMra1208937. 100 cases. Mov Disord 2010;25(6):672Y678.
doi:10.1002/mds.22689.
21. Trey C, Davidson CS. The management of
fulminant hepatic failure. Prog Liver Dis 35. Poulas K, Koutsouraki E, Kordas G, et al.
1970;3:282Y298. Anti-MuSK- and anti-AChR-positive
myasthenia gravis induced by
22. Kandiah PA, Olson JC, Subramanian RM. d-penicillamine. J Neuroimmunol 2012;250(1-2):
Emerging strategies for the treatment of 94Y98. doi:10.1016/j.jneuroim.2012.05.011.
patients with acute hepatic failure. Curr
Opin Crit Care 2016;22(2):142Y151. 36. Pfeiffer RF. Wilson disease. Continuum
doi:10.1097/MCC.0000000000000291. (Minneap Minn) 2016;22(4 Movement
Disorders):1246Y1261. doi:10.1212/
23. Karvellas CJ, Todd Stravitz R, Battenhouse H, CON.0000000000000350.
et al. Therapeutic hypothermia in acute liver
failure: a multicenter retrospective cohort 37. Mohd Hanafiah K, Groeger J, Flaxman AD,
analysis. Liver Transpl 2015;21(1):4Y12. Wiersma ST. Global epidemiology of
doi:10.1002/lt.24021. hepatitis C virus infection: new estimates
of age-specific antibody to HCV
24. Wilson SAK. Progressive lenticular seroprevalence. Hepatology 2013;57(4):
degeneration: a familial nervous disease 1333Y1342. doi:10.1002/hep.26141.
associated with cirrhosis of the liver. Brain
38. Adinolfi LE, Nevola R, Lus G, et al. Chronic
1912;34:295Y309. doi: 10.1093/brain/34.4.295.
hepatitis C virus infection and neurological
25. Kayser B. Über einen fall von angeborener and psychiatric disorders: an overview.
grünlicher verfärbung des Cornea. Klin World J Gastroenterol 2015;21(8):
Monatsbl Augenheilk 1902;40:22Y25. 2269Y2280. doi:10.3748/wjg.v21.i8.2269.