COVID-19 STUDENTS FACULTY BUSINESSES ALUMNI & DONORS RESOURCES FRANÇAIS

ABOUT EDUCATION RESEARCH LIFE AT SCIENCES PO ADMISSIONS & FINANCIAL AID

Home | News | “Populism, clientelism and corruption often work in sequence”

Research Sciences Po

“POPULISM, CLIENTELISM AND CORRUPTION OFTEN WORK IN SEQUENCE”

Dimitri Sotiropoulos, associate professor at the University of Athens and visiting professor at the Laboratory for Interdisciplinary Evaluation
of Public Policies at Sciences Po, analyses the causes of the crisis of democracy in Greece.

In your view, what are the main reasons for the crisis of democracy in Greece?

The causes of the crisis of democracy in Greece are intertwined with the causes of the Greek economic crisis. The latter resulted from the
compounded e!ects of the global "nancial crisis, the exhaustion of the Greek “model of production” based on tourism, agriculture, outdated
services and a costly public sector, and the mismanagement of Greece’s public "nances which were completely derailed in 2007-2009.

The panicked and socially insensitive manner in which austerity measures have been implemented since 2010 deepened a pre-existing
problem with Greek democracy, namely the glaring gaps in political representation. Before the onset of the crisis, governments
systematically favoured selected business circles and strong groups of insiders, such as liberal professions and the relatively better-
protected employees of the public sector. These groups were over-represented in parliament and the unions and consistently bene"ted
from the favouritism of both the socialist (Pasok) and conservative (New Democracy) governments.

The same trend is visible today, under the odd government coalition of the radical left (Syriza) with the far right (the Anel party), which caters
to the interests of public-sector employees at the expense of private-sector employees.

A recent example is the combination of the Syriza-Anel government’s re-hiring in 2015 of all the former public employees of the state TV and
radio channel (‘ERT’, foolishly shut down by the conservatives in 2013) and this government’s decision to restrict the total number of private
nationwide TV channels to four.

Your recent research focuses on the association between populism, clientelism and corruption on the one hand,
and a decrease in the quality of the democracy on the other. Could you explain this link?

Many people study populism as a political discourse but there has been less attention paid to how populism governs, that is, how populist
parties formulate and implement policies after they win elections. The experience of Greece and of many other Eastern European countries
shows that populism can undermine both the stability of the economy and democratic liberties.

The stability of the economy is undermined because populists often employ a misconceived Keynesian policy: the state’s intervention in the
economy is not designed to revive the economy or to achieve income redistribution, but to selectively enhance the income of favoured
groups, e.g., old-age pensioners, regardless of whether they are most needy or not. The economy is undermined when populists in power
follow this very selective policy even when the state’s "nances do not allow it or the international economic environment is adverse.

Democratic liberties are undermined because populists’ concept of democracy does not include the usual checks and balances between the
parliament, the government, the judiciary and the independent authorities, as well as the mass media. Populists try to marginalise, if not
fully control, all other democratic institutions outside the government.
Clientelism also has negative economic e!ects and undermines democratic legitimacy. This is because clientelistic governments spend state
resources in a completely irrational manner in order to increase public sector recruitments and to hand out subsidies and bene"ts to their
voters. Clientelism also undermines democracy because the citizens who are excluded from the spoils system come to identify democratic
institutions, such as public administration or the welfare state, with vehicles of political discrimination.

Populism, clientelism and corruption are analytically distinct but, in practice, often work in sequence to produce undesirable economic and
political e!ects.

What part has Europe played in the management of the Greek crisis?

While the primary responsibility for the outbreak and mishandling of the crisis lies with Greece, the role of the EU has been problematic in
more than one respect. Greece’s partners in the EU were slow to understand that the Greek crisis could spill over and threaten the Euro
zone. So the "rst problem with the EU’s reaction was a delay in making decisions in response to the Greek crisis.

A second problem was the EU authorities’ long-term tolerance of successive Greek governments with regard to the fact that until 2010
Greek governments were piling up public debt, while Greek exports lagged far behind imports and the state was unable or unwilling to tax
the population.

The third problem with the EU’s management of the crisis was that the EU formulated a front-loaded austerity programme requiring
excessively heavy and numerous austerity measures in a very short time span. With the bene"t of hindsight, we can say today that some
austerity was necessary given the deplorable condition of Greek state "nances in 2010. Yet a better balance between such an unavoidable
austerity measures, some protection of the weaker strata of society and structural reforms of the Greek economy would have probably
been a more e#cient and less unjust strategy.

The "nal problem was that the EU did not alter the mix of policies forced upon Greek society when poverty levels and unemployment rates
soared.

What are the lessons that France should learn from Greece to avoid populism, particularly for the 2017 election?

Greece is not in a position to be giving France advice. However, as a citizen and in the spirit of camaraderie, I would suggest that French
voters should be alert to the perils of populism, regardless of whether it comes from the left or the right.

Populists win points because they make things look simple; they di!use a simplistic political discourse based on a simple opposition
between the current bad situation and an idyllic future situation that will allegedly materialise when they bring down the domestic elite and
push out foreigners.

All populists appear to talk and act in a way that revitalises democracy. In practice, they are masters of political exclusion, i.e., they
systematically exclude whole political institutions, which is rarely perceived before they come to power but is bitterly understood once they
have won.

Interview by Juliette Seban, Administrative Director of LIEPP

Related links

Learn more about Dimitri Sotiropoulos

Learn more about the Laboratory for Interdisciplinary Evaluation of Public Policies at Sciences Po

Photo: Athens, Greece Jan. 25, 2015

10.19.2016
Credits: @ Kostas Koutsaftikis / Shutterstock.com.

Filter content

Careers Startup 07.01.2020

A DEEP DIVE INTO THE HEART OF THE STARTUP NATION

After a trip to Silicon Valley in 2017 and to the MIT in 2019, the Centre for Entrepreneurship’s third Learning
Expedition took participants to Israel, a country equivalent in size to a French département that has the highest
number of startups per capita in the world (1 in 6,000). What are the reasons for this “entrepreneurial miracle”,
and how does it work? Loanne Guérin and Laura Salesse ("rst and second year students respectively in the
Master’s in Finance and Strategy), two of the twelve students chosen to take part in the adventure, tell us about
their experience.

More

Partnership Sciences Po 06.29.2020

MOBILITY AS A CATALYST FOR RESILIENCE AND RENEWAL

International academic mobility has been a cornerstone of universities dating back as far as the 12th and 13th
centuries when they began to $ower throughout the European continent. With a clear understanding of the
multiple bene"ts of academic mobility and the rich and diverse learning environment it created, the University
of Bologna, the oldest university in Europe, adopted the Constitutio Habita, an academic charter that ensured
and protected the rights and free movement of a traveling scholar in the pursuit of education. The widely
referred to concept of “academic freedom” today stems from the idea of this charter.

More

#KeepLearning Research 06.29.2020

BASIC RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN EPIDEMIC, ECONOMY, AND

INEQUALITIES
The public debate on the current economic crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic has focused on rich countries.
But how is this crisis truly “global”? What are the current inequalities with developing countries? Here is an
overview with Jérôme Sgard, Professor of Political Economy at the Centre for International Studies (CERI) at
Sciences Po and specialist in the construction and regulation of markets.

More

Education Portrait 06.26.2020

STUDY ABROAD IN BUENOS AIRES: FLORA’S URBAN DREAM

At Sciences Po, all third-year undergraduate students spend a mandatory year abroad studying at one of our
478 partner universities or pursuing an internship. After two years on our Paris campus, Flora Cerda chose to
spend her third year at the Universidad Católica Argentina in Buenos Aires. In this video, she tells us about her
experience and how it helped reinforce her passion and interests, and better de"ne her choice of Master’s and
future career goals.

More

Financial Aid Portrait 06.24.2020

“ACQUIRING NEW LENSES”

Aditi Chatradhi, originally from California, is a student in the dual BA program between Sciences Po and
Columbia University. In spring 2020, she was awarded the Henri de Castries scholarship, which is open to
students in the dual BA degrees between Sciences Po and Columbia University or UC Berkeley. Below is an
excerpt from one of her personal statements about her transition to France and her experience in the program.

More

#KeepLearning Research 06.22.2020

A PHD IN ECONOMICS: INTERVIEW WITH SERGEÏ GURIEV

Are you interested in pursuing a PhD in Economics? A key discipline taught at the undergraduate level,
economics is also one of the pillars of research at Sciences Po. Sergeï Guriev, Full Professor at the Economics
Department in Sciences Po, director of studies in Economics at the Doctoral School, o!ers some advice and
insights.

More

Education Portrait 06.17.2020

AFIA KWAKWA: THE DRIVE TO CREATE A BETTER WORLD

A"a Kwakwa is a student in the joint JD/LL.M. programme between Columbia Law School and Sciences Po Law
School. She was recently selected by the International Court of Justice to participate in the 2020-21 Judicial
Fellow programme. Interview on her brilliant journey so far and her drive to make impactful change in the
world.

More

Education Student Life 06.15.2020

SCIENCES PO STUDENT SERVICES: HELPING ALL OUR TALENTS TO

SUCCEED
Succeeding as a student isn’t just about your studies! From accommodation and visas to health and accessibility,
Sciences Po sta! support students across a whole range of issues. We work hard to free our students of all
unnecessary di#culties so that they can complete their studies without hassle and make the most of this
unique period in their lives. Our personalised student services are available to students at every stage of their
degrees and can be adapted to the full range of their circumstances and needs. Hear more about them from
Sciences Po’s Director of Students and Teachers’ Support and Services, Francesca Cabiddu.

More

Student Life 06.15.2020

BECOME THE POLITICAL PHOTOGRAPHER OF THE YEAR

As we launch the fourth annual Political Photograph Competition (FR), which is now open until the 15
September 2020 to all those wishing to enter, the judges remind us that taking a good political photograph is
not a question of subject so much as one of seeing- a way of perceiving the often surprising world in which we
live, one which goes beyond elections and street manifestations. Here are our three pieces of advice for those
thinking of entering.

More

Portrait Scholarships 06.12.2020

MEET ZINA AKROUT, LAUREATE OF THE 2020 MAX LAZARD AWARD

Zina Akrout is a graduate student in the Master’s of Public Policy at the School of Public A!airs and has been
awarded the Max Lazard Prize to carry out her project “Berbers of Tunisia”. Interview on her journey so far,
distinctive for her unbounded curiosity and in its strong international dimension.

More

More News

CONTACT & MAP NEWSROOM LEGAL NOTICE

27, rue Saint Guillaume - 75337 Paris Cedex 07

Tel: +33 (0)1 45 49 50 50 | Fax: +33 (0)1 42 22 31 26