Professional Documents
Culture Documents
UPDATE ITEMS
USE OF ANTIMICROBIAL SUBSTANCES PRODUCED BY BACTERIA
LACTIC ACID
IN THE PRESERVATION OF MEAT USE OF
LACTIC BACTERIAS
ON MEAT CONSERVATION
Sandra Milena Vásquez M. (1), Héctor Suárez M. (1) Sandra Zapata B. (2) (1) Department of Agricultural
ABSTRACT
The use of lactic acid bacteria (LAB) for food biopreservation has taken great importance nowadays due to its capacity for controlling
pathogenic and spoilage microorganisms. Application of biopreservative strains as well as extracts and metabolites produced by them have
demonstrated to control diverse undesirable microorganisms improving the enlargement of foods shelf-life and safety against bacteria that
can affect the consumerís health. This review involves aspects of food biopreservation and specifically of meat and meat products
susceptible of alterations and attacks of diverse microorganisms. Biopreservation methodologies of common use in foods are detailed as
well as more outstanding aspects of metabolites produced by LAB, making special emphasis on bac- teriocins, antimicrobial substances
that have demonstrated its effectiveness to control diverse microorganisms and have had successful application on foods. The use of
biopreservation is revised, considered as a technology barrier that combined with other conservation methods like refrigeration and joint to
good manufacturing practices can be an interesting option to diminish the addition of chemical preservatives, providing safe foods
naturally preserved.
This work was received on September 16, 2008 and accepted for publication on December 20, 2008.
64
USE OF ANTIMICROBIAL SUBSTANCES PRODUCED BY BACTERIA LACTIC ACID IN THE PRESERVATION OF MEAT
its antimicrobial products (4). Different studies have applied (crude extract), fermented liquor or concentrates obtained by the
biopreservation through the use of a natural microbiota such as growth of BAL producing bacteriocin in complex substrate. This
Lactic Acid Bacteria (BAL) isolated from dairy, meat, fish and method avoids the use of purified compounds that may have legal
vegetable products, using antibacterial properties, attributed to the regulation and saves costs in the purification of each compound.
end products of their metabolism such as lactic, acetic acid ,
hydrogen peroxide, diacetaldehyde, reuterine and bacteriocins (5). (4) Adding pure or semi-antagonistic substances such as the
The use of bacteriocins in the food industry can help reduce the bacteriocins produced by BAL. By using this method the bacteriocin
addition of chemical preservatives as well as the intensity of heat dose is more accurate and therefore more predictable. However, the
treatment. application is limited according to the regulations of each country
regarding food additives (5).
This update aims to bring together the most relevant aspects of The first two methodologies could be called in situ
biopreservation and cover some studies applied to meats and their biopreservation methods (by inoculation of the food system with the
derivatives in recent years using bacteriocins or substrates that bacteriocin-producing strain under conditions that favor its
contain them. production); while the last two would be ex situ methodologies (where
bacteriocin is produced outside the food under controlled conditions
and then applied to the food). In the case of using pure or semi-pure
FOOD BIOPRESERVATION antagonistic substances, it is necessary to use protein precipitation
Biopreservation refers to extending the shelf life of food and techniques adapted to the conditions of each laboratory, the
increasing microbiological safety using a natural or controlled production and precipitation of bacteriocin must initially be
microflora and its antibacterial products (4, 5). Biopreservation can standardized, until its reproducibility is guaranteed before application
be applied in food and specifically in meat by four basic methods (5, in food for ensure an adequate amount with sufficient inhibitory
6): power.
65
VÁSQUEZ S. Y COLS.
BAL crudes on the growth of spoilage and pathogenic inhibitory due to their lipophilic nature, since they can cross the cell
microorganisms have presented favorable results, which is why they membrane and dissociate in the cytoplasm. These molecules can
have been recently recommended by several authors as a exert two effects: on the one hand they interfere with cellular
Biopreservation method in food (7, 9 - 12). functions, such as substrate translocation and oxidative
phosphorylation, on the other hand, the dissociation of organic acids
causes the increase of protons inside the cell. When the
FUNCTION OF BACTERIA ACID concentration of protons exceeds the buffer capacity of the
LACTICS AND THEIR METABOLITES cytoplasm, they are transported outwards by means of a proton
IN THE BIOPRESERVATION pump, thus reducing the energy reserves of the cell. When these
Lactic Acid Bacteria reserves are depleted, the proton pump stops and the internal pH
In any of the biopreservation cases mentioned above, Lactic falls, which in turn causes denaturation of the proteins and
Acid Bacteria (BAL) are used, which comprise a high number of destabilization of other structural and functional components of the
gram-positive bacteria whose common characteristic is the cells,
production of lactic acid from carbohydrates. The group of lactic
bacteria associated with food include cocci of the genera:
lactococcus streptococcus, pediococcus, leuconostoc, and bacilli of
the genera Lactobacillus and Carnobacterium (13, 14).
Lactic bacteria can survive and develop in the presence of
relatively low pH unlike other microbial groups with respiratory
Moreira (15), mentions that this group of bacteria is probably metabolism, since they have a system of simultaneous transport of
the most abundant and widespread in nature, due to their ability to lactic acid and protons to the cell exterior, which in addition to
grow on a variety of substrates and under various biological contributing to the homeostasis of the internal pH, originates energy
conditions. Among lactic bacteria, the Lactobacillus group is the most (13).
important and heterogeneous, including species with very different
biochemical and physiological properties (16). Lactic bacteria do not Non-protein compounds: Among the non-protein compounds
need oxygen to grow, they are tolerant to the presence of CO2, that BALs produce during their growth is reuterine. This substance,
nitrites, smoke and relatively high salt concentrations and tolerate low unlike bacteriocins and peroxide, is only produced by Latobacillus
pH values. therefore, the conditions existing in vacuum-packed reutery, isolated from the gastrointestinal tract of people and animals;
meats, in cured meats and in meat products favor the growth of these Its toxic potential has not yet been evaluated, although by its nature
microorganisms. In vacuum packed meat the dominant there are doubts about its possible usefulness in the food industry. Its
microorganisms are Lactobacillus sp, antimicrobial activity is extremely wide, affecting gram positive, gram
negative bacteria, yeasts, molds and protozoa. Reuterin is formed
during the anaerobic use of glycerol and inhibits the activity of the
ribonucleotide reductase enzyme involved in DNA synthesis, which
determines its broad antimicrobial spectrum (3).
Organic acids: Organic acids contribute to the development of It works as an oxidant, producing free radicals that attack essential
flavor, aroma and texture of food, but also to its stability by inhibiting cellular components, lipids, proteins and DNA (20). The accumulation
disrupting microorganisms (19). The antimicrobial activity of organic of H 2 OR 2) in culture media, it is because BALs generally do not have
acids and pH is complementary, with the undissociated fraction of catalase (15). Hydrogen peroxide has been studied more widely in
organic acids having the highest activity raw milk, where the antimicrobial system "lactoperoxidase" is
generated, without
66
USE OF ANTIMICROBIAL SUBSTANCES PRODUCED BY BACTERIA LACTIC ACID IN THE PRESERVATION OF MEAT
However, despite its preservation potential, the poor viability of this according to its spectrum of inhibition only in two groups: A)
compound in food is recognized, since it can have detrimental effects Bacteriocins active against taxonomically related strains. B)
on its organoleptic quality causing rancidity of fats and discoloration Bacteriocins with a wide range of activity against gram positive
and greening reactions (3). bacteria.
Nisin exhibits inhibitory activity against microorganisms such as
Pseudomonas, Escherichia and Salmonella, but the effect is not
Bacteriocins observed, unless the lipopolysaccharide component of the external
This is the metabolite on which most of the studies have membrane of these microorganisms is altered, with treatments such
focused in recent years, and various investigations have been carried as osmotic shock or treatment with EDTA (25) . Recent studies also
out around its detection, production, purification, mode of action, show antagonistic activity of bacteriocins produced by gram positive
biochemical characterization, bactericidal properties, bacteria against gram negative microorganisms (26).
microorganisms. inhibited or sensitive and successful application in
food biopreservation (7, 9, 12, 21-24).
The term bacteriocinogenicity is defined as the ability of The spectrum of inhibition of bacteriocins or their extracts may
bacteria to synthesize and eliminate antagonistic proteins from other be affected according to the treatment they are subjected to, such as
microorganisms abroad, so it could be deduced that BALs have this lyophilization, concentration of the supernatant, purification and
well-defined characteristic. Bacteriocins are bactericidal proteins or neutralization, among others. In the particular case of bacteriocin
peptides synthesized in the BAL ribosome, the producer cell extracts, the activity is greater when they are concentrated, but it is
synthesizes a molecule that immunizes it against the bacteriocin necessary to take into account thermoresistance to avoid altering the
itself. Production occurs naturally during or at the end of the functionality of bacteriocin. In the case of plantaricin produced by
logarithmic phase of bacterial development, being directly related to lactobacillus plantarum LPBM10, purification can decrease activity
the biomass produced, (14, 15). and thermotolerance (11). Furthermore, the combined action of two
or more bacteriocins can considerably reinforce the inhibitory action
(27).
The bacteriocins of lactic acid bacteria are generally stable at
acidic or neutral pH, indicating an adaptation to the natural
environment of the bacteria that produce them. In addition, some Regarding the inhibition mechanisms used by bacteriocins, the
extracts of lactobacillus plantarum and lactobacillus brevis have formation of pores in the cytoplasmic membrane of sensitive cells
stability at heating at 50 and 80 ºC, a property that is important to seems to be a common mechanism of action, presented by
ensure the control of microorganisms in some processes of the food bacteriocins produced by lactic acid bacteria. The structure of these
industry (11). peptides, α-helix or β-laminar, would form two faces, one hydrophilic
and the other hydrophobic, creating oligomers that would cross the
Some authors have considered that the spectrum of inhibition of membrane forming pores, in which the apolar side of the molecule
these proteins is reduced, generally on taxonomically related would be close to the lipids of the membrane, and the polar side
microorganisms, so that they present bactericidal activity only against would face the center of the pore. As a consequence, a loss of K
sensitive strains (19). ions, ATP and, in some cases, amino acids and small molecules is
observed in general. The loss of these substances in turn causes a
García et al. (3) state that the susceptibility of Gram-negative loss of membrane potential, consumption of cellular energy reserves,
bacteria to bacteriocins produced by lactic acid bacteria is much decrease in DNA synthesis,
more limited and until recently there were no known bacteriocins
produced by food-derived lactic acid bacteria naturally active against
gram negative bacteria. The production of bacteriocins with a
relatively broad spectrum of inhibition is typical of bacteria of food
origin, including those of meat and its derivatives.
According to its definition, bacteriocins are inactivated by at
least one proteolytic enzyme, among which it is worth mentioning
those of pancreatic (trypsin and alpha-chymotrypsin) and gastric
Studies of some species of the genera Lactobacillus, (pepsin) origin (15), a characteristic that makes these bacterial
Streptococcus and staphylococcus produce bacteriocins against metabolites, safe substances to be included as biopreservatives in
gram negative bacteria (15). however Klaenhammer (18) classifies food, since they would be inactivated during
bacteriocins
67
VÁSQUEZ S. Y COLS.
its passage through the gastrointestinal tract without being absorbed that are used in the different techniques. The techniques normally
as active compounds and without causing, therefore, the risks related used to obtain the bacteriocins are: precipitation with ammonium
to the use of antibiotics. Studies of bacteriocins produced by sulfate (23,
lactobacillus curvatus LTH1174 in the survival of E.coli and Listeria in 32, 33), precipitation with trichloric acetic acid (11,
a dynamic model of the stomach and intestine, report that 14, 12), chloroform precipitation (14), column adsorption (29), among
bacteriocins are inactivated by digestive enzymes and the others. Likewise, other researchers work with the crude extract that
antagonistic effect on L. innocua is also evidenced. . (29). the bacteriocin contains after neutralization to inhibit the action of
Additionally, other bacteriocins have been found that are sensitive to organic acids (9, 10). The efficiency of each technique depends on
non-proteolytic enzymes, such as leukonocin S that is inactivated by the characteristics of the peptide with which it is worked and on the
an amylase ((30). amount of antagonistic substances produced.
68
USE OF ANTIMICROBIAL SUBSTANCES PRODUCED BY BACTERIA LACTIC ACID IN THE PRESERVATION OF MEAT
the number of microorganisms in the meat due to external CFU ml-1 in 24 hours at 20 ° C and in meat inoculated with the
contamination, requirements for specific components for their action, bacteriocinogenic strain, the viable number of Listeria remained more
among others. or less constant at 103 CFU ml-1 throughout incubation. Fadda et al.
The use of biopreservation should be considered only as an (36) evaluated the role of lactobacillus under refrigerated conditions
additional measure to good manufacturing practices during the and vacuum packaging in Argentine meat, concluding that the use of
processing, storage and distribution of meat. Furthermore, Lactobacillus strains may be of great importance due to their
bacteriocins should not be considered as inhibitors by themselves contribution during meat maturation. Other authors such as Raloff
since they act synergistically as an additional barrier with other (37) mention the development of a pediocin jelly, class II bacteriocin,
preservation methods, in which the combined effects of pH, that protect hot dogs from bacterial contamination. Furthermore,
temperature and oxygen availability simultaneously serve to preserve Riley and Wertz (38) hint that they have been used in cured meat,
food ( 7). milk, cheese and soybean paste.
important in recent years due to the ability to control pathogenic and disrupting
The application of Biopreservation in different meat foods, has metabolites produced by them, have been shown to have control over various unwanted
allowed to find a great diversity of microbial antagonisms and microorganisms, thus lengthening the shelf life of food and providing security against
increases in the shelf life of the products; Thus, Fiorentini et al. (9) bacteria that may affect consumer health. This review covers aspects of biopreservation in
evaluated the influence of the bacteriocins produced by Lactobacillus food and specifically in meat and meat products, susceptible to alteration and attacks by
plantarum on the shelf life of refrigerated beef, finding an increase of various microorganisms. The most common biopreservation methodologies used in food are
three days compared to the control. Enan (23) demonstrated the detailed, as well as more relevant aspects of the metabolites produced by lactic acid
inhibition of Clostridium perfringes LMG 11264 by UG1 plantaricin in bacteria, with special emphasis on bacteriocins, which are antimicrobial substances that
chicken, turkey and beef samples and concludes that plantaricin may have been shown to be effective in the control of various microorganisms and have been
be more effective than nisin in terms of its application in food and successfully applied to food. The use of biopreservation considered as a barrier technology
neutral and in wide temperature ranges; while nisin is only active at is reviewed, which combined with other conservation methods such as refrigeration and
acidic pH. linked to Good Manufacturing Practices can be an interesting option to decrease the
addition of chemical preservatives, providing safe food preservatives. two naturally. with
special emphasis on bacteriocins, which are antimicrobial substances that have been shown
to be effective in the control of various microorganisms and have been successfully applied
Suarez et al. (12), for their part, show the positive effect on the combined with other conservation methods such as refrigeration and linked to Good
useful life of fish fillets by a plantaricin obtained from a strain of Manufacturing Practices can be an interesting option to decrease the addition of chemical
lactobacillus plantarun LpBM10 isolated from fermented milk. Vignolo preservatives, providing safe food preservatives. two naturally. with special emphasis on
et al. (35) found that Lb. curvatus CRL705 can be used as a bacteriocins, which are antimicrobial substances that have been shown to be effective in the
bio-preservative culture in meat, after testing different amounts of L. control of various microorganisms and have been successfully applied to food. The use of
monocytogenes initial inoculum and the bio-preservative culture. biopreservation considered as a barrier technology is reviewed, which combined with other
Meat inoculated with L. monocytogenes showed rapid growth of the conservation methods such as refrigeration and linked to Good Manufacturing Practices can
pathogen, the number of viable cells increased from 3 X 103 to 8 x be an interesting option to decrease the addition of chemical preservatives, providing safe
69
VÁSQUEZ S. Y COLS.
January. FAO Food and Nutrition Paper No. 65. 1997. LPBM10 on the shelf life of fillets of the hybrid of cachama
piaractus brachypomus x colossoma macropomum vacuum
packed, VITAE 2008; 15 (1): (in print) URREGO VELÁSQUEZ,
2. 98/711
European
/ EC of
Union
12 November
(EU). Commission
1998 drawing
Decision
up the list of third
MC, CADAVID RO-
countries from which the import of fishery products is
13. JAS, LA Effect on the microbiological, sensory and rheological
authorized for human consumption, L337, 58 ± 60, 12
quality of the application of three different levels of lactic acid in
December. 1998 a cut of beef (Solomo Egg). Degree work Specialization in Food
3. DEZ,
GARCÍA,
PE Extension
T., MARTÍN,
of the R.,
shelf
SANZ,
life ofB.,
fresh
HERNÁN-
meat. I packaging in
Science and Technology . National university of Colombia.
modified atmosphere and use of lactic acid bacteria and
Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Medellín - Colombia. pp. 72.
bacteriocins, Rev Española Cienc Tecnol Al 1995; 35 (1): 1-18. 2005
LEWUS, C., MONTVILLE, T. Detection of bacte-
Four.
riocins produced by lactic acid bacteria. J Microbiol Meth 1991; 14. and
CACERES
characterization
FAIR, PEDRO
Bacteriocins
FELIPE.
produced
Isolation
by lactobacillus
13 (2): 145-150. plantarum LpBM10 in whey. Msc Biotechnology Thesis.
5. HUGAS, M. Bacteriocinogenic lactic acid bacteria
National University of Colombia, Faculty of Sciences. Medellin
for the biopreservation of meat and meat products. Meat Sci
1998; 49 (1): 139-150. Colombia. pp 84, 2007.
9. NANI
FIORENTINI
S. PORTOÂNGELA
ANNA CS
M.MAZO
SANT'ANNA
JACIARA
ER- 17. Antimicrobial
DABES, AC,activity
SANTOS,
of lactic
WLM, acid
PEREIRA
bacteria EM
isolated from meat
42-46 18.
70
USE OF ANTIMICROBIAL SUBSTANCES PRODUCED BY BACTERIA LACTIC ACID IN THE PRESERVATION OF MEAT
produced by lactic acid bacteria. FEMS Microbiol Rev 1993; 12: 29. TIAN,
GANZLEC
VOSSEN,
MICHAEL
VAN DER
G., HERTELA
JOS MBM,CHRIS-
HAMMESA, WALTER P.
39-86. Effect of bacteriocin-producing lactobacilli on the survival of
19. Biana
REQUENA,
of lacticT.,
bacteria.
PELAEZ production
C. Antimicro-
of bacteria,
activityRev Española
Escherichia coli and Listeria in a dynamic model of the stomach
Cienc Tecnol Al 1995; 35 (1): 19-44. and the small intestine, Int J Food Microbiol 1999; 48: 21–35.
20. MYUNG,
JANG HO-HYUK,
WHA KIM ANN
CHAN.2008
SUNG-HO,
Use DEOK
of hydrogen
KIM peroxide as an
30. duction
LEWUS of CBSUN,
an amylase-sensitive
S. Y MONTVILLE,
bascteriocin
TJ Pro-by an atypical
effective disinfectant to Actinobacillus ureae, Process Biochem
Leuconostoc paramesenteroid strain, Appl. Environ. Microbiol.
2008; 43: 225–228. OGUNBANWO ST, SANNI AL & ONILUDE
1992; 58: 143-149 ROSS RP, MORGAN, S., HILL, C.,
21. AA Characterization of bacteriocin produced by Lactobacillus
31. and
Preservation
Fermentation, Past, Present and Future, Int J Food Microbiol
plantarum F1 and Lactobacillus brevis OG1, J Biotech 2003; 2
(8): 219-227. BROMBERG RENATA., MORENO IZILD- 2002; 14: 3-16. GONZALEZ BEATRIZ, ARCA PILAR, MAY
22. INHA., LOPES ZAGANINI CÍNTIA; DELBONI ROBERTA 32. BALTASAR AND SUAREZ JUAN E., Detection, Purification, and
REGINA; FROM OLIVEIRA JOSIANE. Isolation of Partial Characterization of Plantainin C, a Bacteriocin Produced
bacteriocin-producing lactic acid bacteria from meat and meat by a Lactobacillus plantarum Strain of Dairy Origin, Appl
products and its spectrum of inhibitory activity, Brazilian J Environ Microbiol 1994; 60 (6): 2158-2163. REMIGER A,
Microbiol 2004; 35: 137-144. EIJSINK V, EHRMANN M,
33. SLETTEN K, NES I, VOGEL R. Purification and partial aminoacid
23. Gens
ENAN,
LMG
GAMAL
11264..inInhibition
Meat Samples
of Clostridium
of Chicken,
perfrin-
Turkey and Beef sequence of plantaricina 1.25ά and 1.25 ß two bacteriocins
by the Bacteriocin plantaricin UG1. International J Poultry Sci produced by Lactobacillus plantarum TMW1.25. J Appl
2006; 5 (2): 195-200. LADE HS, CHITANAND, MP. Microbiol 1999; 86: 1053-1058.
24. KADAM
GYANANATH,
TA Studies
G. On Some properties Of Bacteriocins
34. ofMARTINIS,
food borne ECP;
pathogens
FRANCO,
by bacteriocins
BDGM Inhibition
producing Leuconostoc
produced By Lactobacillus Species Isolated From Agro-Based
sp. and Lactobacillus sake isolated from linguiça frescal. Rev
Waste. J Microbiol 2006; twenty-one).
Microbiol 1997; 28: 284-287.
25. NAKLAENHAMMER.TR
STENVENS KASHELDON,
NisinBW,
treatment
KLAPES,
for the inactivation of
35. HOLGADO,
VIGNOLO,AR,
G., FADDA,
& OLIVER,
S., G.
KAIRUZ,
ControlMN,
of Listeria
Salmonella species and other gram-negative bacteria, Appl
monocytogenes in ground beef by lactokin 705, a bacteriocin
Environ Microbiol 1991; 57: 3613-3615.
produced by Lactobacillus casei CRL705, Int J Food Microbiol
TODOROV
26. tarum isolatedSD,
fromDICKS LMTproduces
molasses Lactobacillus plan- active against
bacteriocins 1996; 29: 397–402.
71