Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Experience with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the breast remains limited. MRI studies
to date have shown that differentiation of carcinoma from certain benign breast changes can be
difficult.
The problem of suspected tumour recurrence in patients with known but treated breast
carcinoma is considered. Forty-five patients were studied, all having been treated by
lumpectomy combined with radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy. Suspicion of recurrence was
suggested by X-ray mammography or clinically by the presence of a recurrent breast mass,
breast pain, or nipple discharge. The principle differential diagnosis rested between post-
treatment fibrosis and recurrent tumour. Axial and sagittal images were obtained using T1- and
T2-weighted pulse sequence. Images were enhanced with intravenous gadolinium D T P A in
cases where there was a mass.
The tomographic format and inherent high soft tissue contrast provided by M R I are of
particular value in this situation. The morphological appearances of recurrent tumour, fibrosis,
and other p0st-radiation affects are described and compared. MRI allowed accurate
differentiation in the majority of case. In equivocal cases enhancement of mass lesions with
gadolinium D T P A provided excellent confirmatory evidence of recurrent turnout. Lewis-Jones,
H.G., Whitehouse, G.H. & Leinster, S.J. (1991). Clinical Radiology 43, 197-204. The Role of
Magnetic Resonance Imaging in the Assessment of Local Recurrent Breast Carcinoma
Early studies of breast MRI have shown considerable A General Electric Signa 1.5 Tesla system was used for
overlap in the appearances of breast carcinoma, breast the MRI investigations. For breast examinations the
dysplasia and benign breast disease (Ross et al., 1982; E1 patient lay prone in the magnet bore with the breast
Yousef et al., 1984; Heywang et al., 1987). X-ray suspended in a purpose built holder containing a 5 inch
mammography has been shown to be more sensitive than general purpose surface coil. A slice thickness of 5 mm
MRI in the detection of carcinoma (Turner et al., 1988) with a 2 mm gap was used. Tl-weighted axial sections
and for these reasons no clinical application for breast using a spin echo pulse sequence (TR-500 ms, TE-20 ms)
MRI has been demonstrated so far. The advent of and T2-weighted and proton density sagittal sections also
lumpectomy and radiotherapy with breast conservation using a spin echo pulse sequence (TR-2000 ms, TE-20 and
in the treatment of breast cancer (Montague et al., 1979, 80 ms) were performed initially. These images were
Fisher et al., 1985) has brought with it the problem of carefully inspected and, if a mass was demonstrated in the
suspected local tumour recurrence where clinical examin- breast, enhancement with gadolinium D T P A was per-
ation and conventional imaging are often equivocal due formed. Sequential fast scan single slice images at the
mainly to post-treatment fibrosis. relevant location were repeated at the rate of approxima-
tely two per minute for 8 rain following injection of
gadolinium. The single slice images obtained were gra-
PATIENTS AND M E T H O D S dient echo images (GRASS) using a T R of 200 ms, a TE of
13 ms and a flip angle of 90 ° to provide a 'T1 type' fast
Forty-five female patients (age range 27-81 years) with scan. Finally the initial Tl-weighted axial sequence was
suspected recurrent breast carcinoma were examined repeated, the entire MR study lasting approximately 40
prospectively by MRI. Forty-two had been treated by min.
lumpectomy combined with radiotherapy and three by The MR images were reported with only the clinical
lumpectomy alone. Four patients had received or were information and history available, except where referral
currently being treated by adjuvant hormonal or chemo- had been due to abnormal findings at routine mammogra-
therapy. Recurrence was suspected either following rou- phy in which case the relevant mammogram was
tine biannual X-ray mammography (nine patients) or inspected following the initial interpretation of the spin
clinically by the presence of a palpable mass (27 patients), echo images.
local breast pain (seven patients) or a nipple discharge Interpretation was based on our own initial experience
(two patients). Mammography had been performed as well as other information available in the literature (El
within the four weeks prior to MRI in 34 of the cases and Yousef et al., 1984, 1985; Dash et al., 1986; Heywang et
in the remaining 11 cases referral was direct to MRI, al., 1986; W e i n e r et al., 1986; Stelling et al., 1987).
rnammography having been performed routinely on a 6 Histological confirmation of diagnosis was obtained in
monthly basis but not immediately prior to M R I itself. those patients where clinical suspicion of recurrent malig-
Correspondence to: Dr H. G. Lewis-Jones, Magnetic Resonance nancy was high or where imaging itself suggested recur-
ResearchCentre, LiverpoolUniversity,PembrokePlace,P.O. Box t47, rence. Histological diagnosis was obtained in 24 of the 45
LiverpoolL69 3BX. cases studied. In the remaining 21 cases close clinical
198 CLINICALRADIOLOGY
RESULTS
(~)
@) (c)
Fig. 2 Recurrent t u m o u r in a patient 3 years following treatment. (a) A lobulated mass (arrow) close to the chest wall is shown, with an intermediate
signal on the proton density image (left) while the T2-weighted image (right) shows uneven signal with areas of high signal relative to muscle. These
signal changes are typical of recurrent tumour. (b) Axial fast scans through the turnout before (above) and after (below) intravenous gadolinium DTPA.
There is patchy but marked enhancement in parts of the t u m o u r (arrow). (c) Lateral m a m m o g r a m showing a poorly defined area of increased density
posteriorly in the breast (arrows) which was asymmetrical when compared with the contralateral breast. There is minimal architectural distortion with
no evidence of microcalcification.
A breast biopsy revealed recurrent poorly differentiated ductal adenocarcinoma.
tural distortion (Fig_ 3a). The tissue characterization cases. No underlying mass was shown in these cases but
studies, however, were in keeping with tumour (Fig. 3b) considerable distortion of breast architecture related to
rather than benign disease and given knowledge of lumpectomy scars, tenting of the underlying pectoralis
previous histology no error should be made. muscle (Fig. 5) and post-radiation skin thickening with
In 10 cases masses were shown whose morphology localized breast oedema were observed. Clinical follow up
suggested a recurrent tumour mass while tissue character- remained stable in all 11 cases over a mean period of 15
ization studies showed a signal intensity lower than months.
muscle on T 1- and T2-weighted images indicating that t h e Nine other benign masses were shown including six
masses were more likely due to fibrosis (Figs 4a, b). haematomas (Fig. 6), one abscess and two simple cysts
Histological confirmatf0n was obtained in three cases (Fig. 7). Histological confirmation by aspiration or
while in seven close clinical observation over a mean surgery was obtained in all but two small haematomas
period of 17 months remained stable. which remained stable at clinical follow up with no
Other post-treatment effects were demonstrated in 11 increase in size.
200 CLINICAL RADIOLOGY
DISCUSSION
(a)
(b) (c)
Fig. 4 Fibrotic mass demonstrated posteriorly in the breast 2 years after treatment. (a) Tl-weighted axial image shows low signal mass with spiculated
borders posteriorly in the breast (arrow) adjacent to pectoralis muscle. (b) The T2-weighted sagittal image shows the mass (arrow) to be of low signal on
this sequence also suggesting fibrosis rather than recurrent tumour_ (c) The lateral m a m m o g r a m shows a mass close to the chest wall with a spleulated
border, architectural distortion and the appearances of recurrent tumour.
A subsequent breast biopsy revealed no neoplastic tissue and the patient has remained stable at 24 m o n t h follow up.
for breast M R I at this current stage. In assessing patients results of M R I and subsequent histology or close clinical
for recurrent tumour there were a number of advantages follow up. M R I successfully detected all 11 recurrent
which could offset some of the pitfalls of M R I in the tumours giving 100% sensitivity but two false positive
breast. Firstly the site of operation was known so the studies resulted in a lower specificity of 94% although it
examination could be targeted to the relevant area. In should be noted that the number of patients in this study
addition we had prior knowledge of the patients previous is too small for these calculations to be valid.
histology and this proved to be of particular value in cases Recurrent tumour most commonly appeared as an
ofrecurrent mucinous adenocarcinoma where morpholo- irregular mass with radiating spicules associated with
gically the recurrent tumour would appear benign with distortion of breast architecture. Secondary signs of
well-defined lobulated borders. carcinoma such as skin thickening, skin retraction and
The study demonstrated good correlation between the nipple invertion were well demonstrated but of limited
202 CLINICAL RADIOLOGY
(b)
Fig. 6 - (a) Axial MR image showing large haematoma with 'mother of
pearl' appearance surrounded by low signal fibrous capsule. Tissue
characterization studies revealing high signal on T1- and T2-weighted
images confirmed that the mass was a haematoma. (b) The correspond-
ing m a m m o g r a m also demonstrates a dense spherical smooth walled
mass although not all its borders are completely distinct and crisp. The
appearances were felt on balance to be due to a large haematoma but
recurrence could not be excluded without biopsy.
(a) The mass was aspirated and chronic haematoma aspirated.
MRI IN THE ASSESSMENT OF RECURRENT BREAST CARCINOMA 203
p r o v e n o u t c o m e a n d m o d e o f referral. This revealed a Ebnor, F, Kressel, HY, Mintz, MC, Carlson, JA, Cohen, EK, Schiebler,
wide spread o f cases across the range of clinical risk. Only M, Gefter, W & Axel, L. (1988). Tumour recurrence versus fibrosis
in the female pelvis: differentiation with MR imaging at 1.5T.
five o f 13 cases of recurrence were evaluated as high risk Radiology, 166, 333 340.
a n d in a further seven cases high risk evaluation was E1 Yousef, SJ, Duchesneau, RH, Alfidi, RJ, Haaga, JR, Bryan, PJ &
associated with a benign outcome, suggesting that clinical LiPuma, JP (1984). Magnetic resonance imaging of the breast.
evaluation is indeed difficult in the p o s t - t r e a t m e n t breast Radiology, 150, 761 766.
of p o o r predictive value c o m p a r e d to M R I . E1 Yousef, SJ, O'Connell, DM, Duchesneau, RH, Smith, MJ, Hubay,
CA & Guyton, SP (1985)_ Benign and malignant breast disease;
It is believed that M R I with its t o m o g r a p h i c f o r m a t magnetic resonance and radiofrequency pulse sequences. American
a n d high soft tissue detail can clearly d e m o n s t r a t e masses Journal of Radiology, 145, 1 8.
within the p o s t - t r e a t m e n t breast a l t h o u g h differentiation Fisher, B, Bauer, M, Margolese, R, Poisson, R, Pilch, Y, Redmond, C et
of recurrent t u m o u r from p o s t - t r e a t m e n t fibrous masses al. (1985). Five year results ofa randomised clinical trial comparing
total mastectomy and segmental mastectomy with or without
can be difficult on m o r p h o l o g i c a l g r o u n d s alone. Tissue
radiation in the treatment of breast cancer. New England Journal of
characterization studies proved helpful in differentiating Medicine, 312, 665 673.
these two conditions while in equivocal cases enhance- Heywang, SH, Basserman,R, Fenzl, G, Nathrath, W, Hahn, D, Beck, R
m e n t with g a d o l i n i u m D T P A in this particular clinical et aL (1987). MRI of the breast-histopathologic correlation. Euro-
situation provided excellent c o n f i r m a t o r y evidence of pean Journal of Radiology, 7, 175-182.
Montague, ED, Guttierrez, AE, Barker, JL, Tapley, ND & Fletcher,
recurrent turnout. GH (1979). Conservative surgery and irradiation for the treatment
Currently M R I is costly a n d n o t widely available. of favourable breast cancer. Cancer, 43, 1058-1061.
M a m m o g r a p h y a n d u l t r a s o u n d c o m b i n e d with fine Nyman, RS, Rehn, SM, Glimelius,BLG, Hayberg, HE, Hemmingsson,
needle aspiration when indicated are likely to r e m a i n the AL & Sundstrom, CJ (1989). Residual mediastinal masses in
Hodgkin disease: prediction of size with MR imaging. Radiology,
initial investigations of choice. W e believe that gadoli- 170, 435-440_
n i u m e n h a n c e d M R I of the breast should be employed in Ross, RJ, Thompson, JS, Klm, K & Bailey, RA (1982). Nuclear
those cases where initial m a m m o g r a p h y has d e m o n - magnetic resonance imaging and evaluation of human breast tissue:
strated a mass a n d s u b s e q u e n t fine needle aspiration or preliminary clinical trials. Radiology, 143, 195-205.
biopsy has been negative for t u m o u r . The biopsy itself Stelling, B, Powell, DE & Mattingly, SS (1987). Fibroadenomas:
histopathologic and MR imaging features. Radiology, 162, 399-407.
m a y cause some a b n o r m a l appearances b u t M R I still has Turner, DA, Alcorn, FS, Shorey, WD, Stelling, CB, Mategrano, VC,
the ability to detect recurrent disease a n d in this way m a y Mertern, CW et al. (1988). Carcinoma of the breast: detection with
have a distinct role to play in the assessment of patients MR imaging versus xeroammography. Radiology, 168, 49-58.
with suspected recurrent breast carcinoma. Weiner, JI, Chako, AC, Merten, CW, Gross, S, Coffey, EL & Stein, HL
(1986). Breast and axillary tissue MR imaging: correlation of signal
intensities and relaxation times with pathologic findings.Radiology,
160, 299-305.
REFERENCES
Dash, N, Luptein, AR, Daffner, RH, Deeb, ZL, Sefczek, RJ & Schapiro,
RL (1986). Magnetic resonance imaging in the diagnosis of breast
disease. American Journal of Radiology, 146, 119-125.