Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Inestabilida Posterior Del Hombro
Inestabilida Posterior Del Hombro
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Posterior shoulder instability Williams and Edwards 387
occur during activity. Weakness or fatigue of the shoulder Figure 1 Bernageau view of an offensive lineman with
symptomatic recurrent posterior instability
with activity is also reported. Determining when the
patient becomes symptomatic (i.e. in the follow-through
after pitching) is a key to appropriate diagnosis.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
388 Shoulder
Thirty shoulders were reviewed retrospectively. A con- the posteroinferior capsule. The trans-rotator cuff portal
comitant labral tear was found in only five patients allows a superior-to-inferior view of the posterior glenoid
whereas posterior capsular laxity was the prevailing lesion and labral repair through the anterior and posterior portals.
in 100% of the patients. Over a mean 30-month follow-up Five patients treated using this accessory portal were
an overall 13% recurrence rate was described. When presented with excellent results at an average 24-month
voluntary dislocators were removed from the results follow-up.
the recurrence rate decreased to 8%. The authors con-
clude that involuntary posterior instability is due prim- Krackhardt et al. [22] present an arthroscopic modifi-
arily to capsular laxity and that open capsular plication cation of the McLaughlin procedure [23]. The subsca-
reliably restores function and stability. pularis tendon is mobilized and attached to the bed of
the reverse Hill–Sachs lesion using suture anchors. The
Arthroscopic posterior stabilization was reported by defect is filled with the subscapularis tendon preventing
Bradley et al. [9] in the largest published series of recurrent dislocation from mechanical impingement.
patients with unidirectional posterior instability. One
hundred shoulders were treated initially with a conser- Posterior shoulder instability associated with glenoid
vative-therapy protocol that failed; 53% had a distinct bone loss requires glenoid augmentation using a bone
traumatic event. Forty-four underwent capsulolabral pli- block [24,25]. Arciero and Mazzocca [26] describe a
cation without suture anchors, 39 capsulolabral plication technique of obtaining a bone block locally from the
with suture anchors, and 17 capsulolabral plication with posterior acromion for reconstruction of the posterior
suture anchors and plication sutures. At the time of glenoid. Five patients treated using this technique with
surgery 66% were noted to have posterior capsular laxity, short-term follow-up demonstrated improved stability.
and 57% had an element of labral injury (either a com-
plete or incomplete tear). Eighty-nine percent of patients Thermal capsulorrhaphy
returned to sports, with 67% returning to their preinjury The benefits of thermal capsulorrhaphy may not be
level. Eight of the 11 failures opted for revision surgery outweighed by the risks that include treatment failure,
and two-thirds had signs of inferior or multidirectional capsular destruction, neurovascular injury, and articular
instability at the time of revision. Also, 75% of the failures cartilage damage [27,28]. Based on literature review,
were treated with only plication sutures without suture Miniaci and Codsi [27] recommend situations in which
anchors due to the lack of obvious labral injury. Potential thermal devices should not be used or should be used
pitfalls noted in this report were the positive correlation with restraint. Thermal capsulorrhaphy is associated
of failure with incorrect diagnosis and poor repair with a high failure rate in multidirectional instability in
strength. Overall, arthroscopic posterior capsular stabil- patients without superior labrum, anterior-to-posterior, or
ization was concluded to be an effective procedure. Bankart lesions. Primary posterior shoulder instability
in patients with a voluntary positional component is a
Bottoni and colleagues [20] published a retrospective contraindication to using thermal devices. The efficacy
review of 31 shoulders, 19 treated arthroscopically and of thermal treatment in patients with unidirectional
12 open. All patients failed an initial course of physical instability and associated superior labrum, anterior-to-
therapy. Open procedures included labral repair using posterior, or Bankart lesions is currently undetermined.
suture anchors and posterior capsulorrhaphy. Arthro- Finally, treatment of microinstability in the throwing
scopic stabilization included labral repair with suture athlete is associated with mixed results using thermal
anchors, capsular plication, and rotator interval closure. capsulorrhaphy and it should be used with caution [27].
One patient in each group reported recurrent instability
following surgery and three patients (one open and Figure 2 (a) Arthroscopic view of a posterior Bankart lesion and
two arthroscopic) reported a fair outcome hampered by (b) completed arthroscopic capsulolabral repair
activity limitation and pain. Twenty-six patients had a
good or excellent outcome and returned to previous
activities. In conclusion, anatomic capsulolabral repairs
through open or arthroscopic approaches yield improve-
ment in stability and function.
Technical notes
Over the past year three technical notes concerning the
treatment of recurrent posterior shoulder instability have
been published: two arthroscopic procedures and one open
procedure. Costouros et al. [21] present an alternate Reprinted with permission from Gartsman GM. Shoulder arthroscopy.
Philadelphia: WB Saunders, 2003. pp. 96, 99.
arthroscopic viewing portal to improve visualization of
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Posterior shoulder instability Williams and Edwards 389
Figure 3 Preoperative and postoperative images of posterior instability treated with iliac-crest-bone block
(a) Posterior glenoid bone loss in a patient with symptomatic posterior subluxation, (b) postoperative anteroposterior view of autogenous iliac crest
bone block placement to the posterior glenoid, and (c) postoperative axillary view.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
390 Shoulder
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.