SAUDI 9-11 CASE - Court Opinion of Aug 27 2020 (Unsealed Sept 10)

Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-SN Document 6408
6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 1 of 40
&%$%%$$%#% &#%
$ &%#$%#% (* #
)

8</

$
%## #$%%%$
$!%#

! ##

)

$#%&#&83>/.$>+>/=+13=><+>/?.1/
'C:7GJ6GN I=:#>C<9DBD;+6J9>G67>6W+6J9>G67>6XDGI=:W#>C<9DBX
;>A:96BDI>DCJC9:GH:6A;DG6EGDI:8I>K:DG9:GG:<6G9>C<I=:9:EDH>I>DCHD;8JGG:CI6C9;DGB:G
+6J9>D;;>8>6AH+::&D 'C%6G8= I=:(A6>CI>;;HZM:8JI>K:DBB>II::H
W(HXDGW(A6>CI>;;HX;>A:96BDI>DCJC9:GH:6A>CDEEDH>I>DC6C968GDHH
BDI>DCID8DBE:A
,=:#>C<9DB;>A:9>IHG:EANJC9:GH:6ADC%6G8= ,=:DJGI=:A9DG6A6G<JB:CIDCI=:
BDI>DCHDC%6N ,=:DJGI*&,+>CE6GI6C9&!+>CE6GII=:#>C<9DBZH
BDI>DC6C9*&,+>CE6GI6C9&!+>CE6GI(A6>CI>;;HZ8GDHH
BDI>DCID8DBE:A
# &
,=>H86H:>H>C?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GN(A6>CI>;;H8DCI:C9I=6II=:DJGI=6H?JG>H9>8I>DC
DK:G+6J9>G67>6JC9:GI=:"JHI>8:<6>CHI+I6I:+EDCHDGHD;,:GGDG>HB8IW"+,X
&D 6I'C%6G8= I=: DCDG67A::DG<:6C>:AH;DJC9I=6I(A6>CI>;;H
6GI>8JA6I:96WG:6HDC67A:76H>HX;DGI=:DJGIID6HHJB:?JG>H9>8I>DC&D
%:BDG6C9JB:8>H>DC6C9'G9:GW%6G8='G9:GX 6I88DG9>C<AN (A6>CI>;;HL:G:
E:GB>II:9ID8DC9J8IWA>B>I:96C9I6G<:I:9?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GNXG:<6G9>C<ILD>C9>K>9J6AH
6=696A,=JB6>GN6C9'B6G6A6NDJB>!9 6I'C:8:B7:G 6HI=:E:G>D9D;

,=>H'E>C>DC6C9'G9:G=6H7::C;>A:9JC9:GH:6A>C>IH:CI>G:IN,=:DJGIL>AA>HHJ:6G:968I:9K:GH>DC
;DAADL>C<I=:G:HDAJI>DCD;(A6>CI>;;HZ*JA:D7?:8I>DCHIDI=:DJGIZH9:8>H>DC<G6CI>C<>CE6GI+6J9>
G67>6ZHBDI>DCIDH:6A+::&D
6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 2 of 40
9D8JB:CI9>H8DK:GN86B:ID68ADH: (A6>CI>;;H;>A:96A:II:G8DCI6>C>C<I=:>GEG:A>B>C6GN
9:EDH>I>DCA>HIL>I=6HI6I:B:CID;I=:H8DE:D;>C;DGB6I>DCI=6I(A6>CI>;;H>CI:C9ID:A>8>I;GDB
:68=L>IC:HH&DW(AH/>IC:HH$>HIX'C:7GJ6GN +6J9>G67>6;>A:96
BDI>DC;DG6EGDI:8I>K:DG9:GG:<6G9>C<D;I=:>C9>K>9J6AH>9:CI>;>:9DC(A6>CI>;;HZA>HI,=>H
'E>C>DC'G9:G699G:HH:HI=:#>C<9DBZHBDI>DC6C9(A6>CI>;;HZ8GDHH
BDI>DCID8DBE:A
+6J9>G67>68DCI:C9HI=6I6IA:6HIL>IC:HH:HDC(A6>CI>;;HZ/>IC:HHA>HI6G:CDI8JGG:CI
:BEADN::HD;+6J9>G67>67:86JH:I=:N6G:9:8:6H:9ILD>C9>K>9J6AH L:G:C:K:G:BEADN::H
D;+6J9>G67>6DC:>C9>K>9J6A DG6G:CDADC<:G:BEADN:97N+6J9>G67>6>C9>K>9J6AH
6G:H=>:A9:9;GDBI:HI>;N>C<JC9:GI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCDC>EADB6I>8*:A6I>DCH6C9I=:
.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCDCDCHJA6G*:A6I>DCH6G:8JGG:CIDG;DGB:G=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6AHL=D
=6K:CDJC>FJ: ;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:A6I>C<ID(A6>CI>;;HZ6AA:<6I>DCH6C9:><=I6G:7:NDC9I=:
H8DE:D;I=:A>B>I:9?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GN6JI=DG>O:97NI=:DJGI>C>IHEG>DGDG9:GH+6J9>
G67>6ZH:7GJ6GN BDI>DCW#+GX 6I';I=:>C9>K>9J6AH+6J9>G67>6
8DCI:C9H6G:H=>:A9:97NI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH H:K:C6G:6AHD;DGB:G:BEADN::H!9';I=:
>C9>K>9J6AH+6J9>G67>68DCI:C9H6G:H=>:A9:97NI=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C: :><=I6G:
6AHD;DGB:G:BEADN::H 6C9:><=I6G:6AHDH=>:A9:97NI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH!9
&% #&$
,=:DG:><C+DK:G:><C!BBJC>I>:H8IW+!X -+R EGDK>9:HWI=:HDA:
76H>H;DGD7I6>C>C<?JG>H9>8I>DCDK:G6;DG:><CHI6I:>C;:9:G6A8DJGIX=:IIG>K&:E6A*6HIG6
6C@ 9 9>G FJDI>C<G<:CI>C:*:EJ7A>8KB:G696 :HH+=>EE>C<
DGE -+ -C9:GI=:+! 6;DG:><CHI6I:>H>BBJC:;GDBHJ>IJCA:HH6
HE:8>;>8HI6IJIDG>AN9:;>C:9:M8:EI>DC6EEA>:H16EE>6%>99A:6HIDCHIGDKB>G6I:D;7J
=67> 9 9>G "+,8G:6I:96C:L:M8:EI>DCIDI=:+!+::

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 3 of 40
-+R !I6EEA>:HL=:C >C699>I>DCID>C?JGN 86JH6I>DC 6C996B6<:H 6EA6>CI>;;86C
H=DL6C68ID;>CI:GC6I>DC6AI:GGDG>HB>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H6C96IDGI>DJH68I7N6;DG:><C
HI6I: DG6CND;;>8>6A :BEADN:: DG6<:CID;I=6IHI6I:I6@:CL=>A:68I>C<L>I=>CI=6IE:GHDCZH
D;;>8: :BEADNB:CI DG6<:C8N+::%6G8='G9:G 6I
"J9<:6C>:AH;DJC96WG:6HDC67A:76H>HX;DGI=:DJGIID6HHJB:?JG>H9>8I>DCJC9:G
"+,DCI=:<GDJC9HI=6IW(A6>CI>;;H6AA:<:;68IHHJ;;>8>:CIIDH=DLI=6II=:N6C9I=:>G6<:CIH
L:G:;DAADL>C<>CHIGJ8I>DCH;GDBBDG:H:C>DGD;;>8>6AH>CI=:+6J9>B76HHNX!9 6I
88DG9>C<AN W(A6>CI>;;HH=6AA7:E:GB>II:9ID8DC9J8IA>B>I:96C9I6G<:I:9?JG>H9>8I>DC6A
9>H8DK:GN8G>I>86AID6CHL:G>C<L=:I=:G6C9IDL=6I:MI:CI,=JB6>GN 6NDJB> 6C9I=:>G
6<:CIHIDD@68I>DCH>C 6II=:9>G:8I>DCD;BDG:H:C>DG+6J9>D;;>8>6AH IDEGDK>9:6HH>HI6C8:
ID 6OB> %>=9=6G 6C9DI=:G=>?68@:GHX!9 6I
,=::9:G6A*JA:HD;>K>A(GD8:9JG:HI6I:I=6IW2E36GI>:HB6ND7I6>C9>H8DK:GNG:<6G9>C<
6CNCDCEG>K>A:<:9B6II:GI=6I>HG:A:K6CIID6CNE6GINZH8A6>BDG9:;:CH:6C9EGDEDGI>DC6AIDI=:
C::9HD;I=:86H:X:9*>K(7!C6+!86H: I=:DJGID;EE:6AH=6HB69:8A:6G
I=6I?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GND;6;DG:><CHI6I:H=DJA97:A>B>I:9+::>GHI>IN ,:M6H

DJHIDC
&K*6;>96>C6C@ 9 9>G%$I9K*:EJ7A>8D;G<:CI>C6
9
9>G G8=,G69>C<DGEK*:EJ7A>8D;8J69DG 9
9>G ,DEGDI:8I6;DG:><CHI6I:;GDBI=:W:ME:CH: >CIGJH>K:C:HH 6C9=6HHA:D;
A>I><6I>DC X68DJGIBJHI7:86JI>DJH>C6AADL>C<?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GNG8=,G69>C<DGE
96I ,=:DJGIBJHIDG9:G9>H8DK:GNW8>G8JBHE:8IAN6C9DCANIDK:G>;N6AA:<6I>DCHD;
HE:8>;>8;68IH8GJ8>6AID6C>BBJC>IN9:I:GB>C6I>DCX>GHI>IN 96I
+I>AA I=:DJGIBJHI8DC9J8I6W9:A>86I:76A6C8>C<XL=>A:B6C6<>C<9>H8DK:GN!9
(A6>CI>;;H=6K:6AG:69N:HI67A>H=:96G:6HDC67A:76H>H;DGI=:DJGIID6HHJB:?JG>H9>8I>DCDK:G

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 4 of 40
+6J9>G67>6 A:HH:C>C<I=:8DC8:GCI=6II=:DJGIL>AA>BEDH:9>H8DK:GND7A><6I>DCHDC6
EDI:CI>6AAN>BBJC:9:;:C96CIDC<G:HH=6H:MEG:HH:96HIGDC<>CI:G:HI>C<G6CI>C<;:9:G6A8DJGIH
?JG>H9>8I>DCL=:C6;DG:><CHI6I:8DBB>IH6IDGI>DJH68I>C8DCC:8I>DCL>I=6C68ID;I:GGDG>HB
L>I=>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H+::"+, R7 (J7$&D

+I6I W,=:
EJGEDH:D;I=>H8I>HIDEGDK>9:8>K>AA>I><6CIHL>I=I=:7GD69:HIEDHH>7A:76H>HIDH::@G:A>:;
6<6>CHI;DG:><C8DJCIG>:HI=6I=6K:EGDK>9:9B6I:G>6AHJEEDGIIDE:GHDCHI=6I:C<6<:
>CI:GGDG>HI68I>K>I>:H6<6>CHII=:-C>I:9+I6I:HX/=>A:I=:H:8DC8:GCH9DCDIC:<6I:I=:DJGIZH
D7A><6I>DCID8DC9J8IA>B>I:99>H8DK:GN I=:N:BE=6H>O:I=6I(A6>CI>;;HBJHI7:<>K:CI=:
9>H8DK:GNC:8:HH6GNID9:I:GB>C:>;"+,6EEA>:H+::+D8>QIQ&6I>DC6A:!C9JHIG>:AA:
QGDHE6I>6A:K-+>HIDJGI -+ CCDI>C<I=6I >C6CN8DB>IN
6C6ANH>H 8DJGIHH=DJA98DCH>9:GL=:I=:G6C>CI:G:HID;I=:-C>I:9+I6I:HLDJA97:JC9:GB>C:9
$&$$
%/=>3798C909<7/<7:69C//=
/1+6$>+8.+<.
+6J9>G67>66G<J:HI=6I6IA:6HID;I=:L>IC:HH:HDC(A6>CI>;;HZ/>IC:HH$>HI6G:
JC6K6>A67A:;DG9:EDH>I>DC7:86JH:I=:N6G:CDI8JGG:CI:BEADN::HD;+6J9>G67>6 6C96HHJ8=
+6J9>G67>6=6HCD8DCIGDADK:GI=:B6C986CCDIEGD9J8:I=:B;DG9:EDH>I>DCL>I=DJII=:>G
KDAJCI6GN8DCH:CI#+G 6IDG:><CC6I>DC6AHG:H>9>C<DJIH>9:I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H86CCDI7:
HJ7ED:C6:9IDI:HI>;NJC9:G:9:G6A*JA:D;>K>A(GD8:9JG:+::-C>I:9+I6I:HK#DGDA@DK
+JEE +&08>I>C<:9*G>B(:-+R-C>I:9
+I6I:HK"D=CEDAA 9 9>G+6J9>G67>6>H6AHDCDI6H><C6IDGNIDI=:
6<J:DCK:CI>DCDG6CNDI=:G8DCK:CI>DCI=6ILDJA96AADLI=:DJGIIDG:FJ:HI6HH>HI6C8:>C
H:8JG>C<I:HI>BDCND;>C9>K>9J6AHG:H>9>C<>C+6J9>G67>6#+G 6I

,=JH I=:DJGI

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 5 of 40
699G:HH:H(A6>CI>;;HZG:FJ:HIH;DG+6J9>G67>6IDB6@:>C9>K>9J6AH6K6>A67A:6HE6GINL>IC:HH:H
JC9:G:9:G6A*JA:D;>K>A(GD8:9JG: 6+::>9
-C9:G*JA: W2D3CAN6E6GINIDA>I><6I>DCB6N7:8DBE:AA:9ID<>K:I:HI>BDCNEJGHJ6CI
ID6CDI>8:D;9:EDH>I>DCX-+K;G6B$>C:H-+ $I9 * +&0
,=:+6J9><DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6AHDC(A6>CI>;;HZ/>IC:HH$>HI6G:CDIE6GI>:HIDI=:A>I><6I>DC
,=:NB6N =DL:K:G 7:HJ7?:8IID9:EDH>I>DC7NCDI>8:>;I=:N6G:8DCH>9:G:9ID7:I=::FJ>K6A:CI
D;:BEADN::HD;6E6GIN8DGEDG6I>DC+::<:C:G6AAN%8#:HHDCDGEK!HA6B>8*:EJ7A>8D;!G6C
* ;>C9>C<WCDG:6HDCIDEG:8AJ9:XI=:6EEA>86I>DCD;6*JA:
7CDI>8:ID!G6C9:HE>I:>IHHI6IJH6H6;DG:><CHDK:G:><CG6I=:GI=6C68DGEDG6I>DC(6GI>:H
JC9:G*JA: B6N7:CDI>8:9EJGHJ6CIID*JA: 7 DG(A6>CI>;;HWB6N>9:CI>;N6HE:8>;>8
D;;>8:G 9>G:8IDG DGB6C6<>C<6<:CIID7:9:EDH:96C9CDI>8:I=6IE:GHDCJC9:G*JA: 7X
;G6B$>C:H *6IH::6AHD-C>I:9+I6I:HK,=:DGDI=N%8AA>HI:G *
+&0:M6B>C>C<I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H 6H6E6GIN I=GDJ<=>IHB6C6<>C<6<:CIH
W238DGEDG6I::BEADN::DG6<:CIL=D9D:HCDIFJ6A>;N6H6CD;;>8:G 9>G:8IDG DG
B6C6<>C<6<:CIXW>HCDIHJ7?:8IID9:EDH>I>DC7NCDI>8:XJC9:G*JA: !9,=:E6GINH::@>C<I=:
9:EDH>I>DC=6HI=:7JG9:CIDW:HI67A>H=I=:HI6IJHD;I=:L>IC:HHX;G6B$>C:H *6I
JII=>H7JG9:C>HWBD9:HI X6C96CN9DJ7IH6G:G:HDAK:9>C;6KDGD;I=::M6B>C>C<E6GIN
J76>!HA6B>86C@K>I>76C@ & &D

.
*%, # /$ 6I
+&0 ,=:9:I:GB>C6I>DCD;69:EDC:CIZHHI6IJH6H6WB6C6<>C<6<:CIX>H
W9:I:GB>C:96HD;I=:I>B:D;I=:9:EDH>I>DC CDI6HD;I=:I>B:L=:CI=:68I>K>I>:H9>HEJI:9>CI=:
A>I><6I>DCD88JGG:9X*JC9FJ>HIK.6E>6CD+ * >CI:GC6A
8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9JIW8DJGIH=6K:B69::M8:EI>DCHIDI=>H<:C:G6AGJA: ;DG:M6BEA:L=:C6
8DGEDG6I>DCI:GB>C6I:H6CD;;>8:G>CA><=ID;E:C9>C<A>I><6I>DCX!9

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 6 of 40
W8DGEDG6I>DC86CCDI7:G:FJ>G:9IDEGD9J8:6;DGB:GD;;>8:GDG6<:CI;DG9:EDH>I>DC
H>C8:>I9D:HCDI=6K:8DCIGDADK:G=>BXDHH%;<DK J<DDHH &D

.

+ +% /$ 6I+&0"6C JIWI=>HGJA:>HCDILDD9:CAN
6EEA>:9*6I=:G 8DJGIHL>I=>C6C9L>I=DJII=>H9>HIG>8I=6K:69DEI:96YEG68I>86AZ6EEGD68=I=6I
Y;D8JH:HCDIDCANDCI=:;DGB6A8DCC:8I>DC7:IL::CI=:L>IC:HH6C9I=:E6GIN6II=:I>B:D;I=:
9:EDH>I>DC 7JI6AHDDCI=:>G;JC8I>DC6AG:A6I>DCH=>EHXJ76>!HA6B>86C@ /$
6I,=:9:EDC:CIWC::9CDI=6K:6;DGB6A6HHD8>6I>DCL>I=I=:8DGEDG6I>DCID7:9::B:9>IH
B6C6<>C<6<:CI$>@:L>H: I=:9:EDC:CIC::9CDI7:6HHD8>6I:9L>I=I=:8DGEDG6I>DC6II=:
I>B:D;=>H9:EDH>I>DCX$>77:NA6HH !C8K'C:>96 $I9 * &'=>D
>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9+JBB6G>O>C<I=>H6EEGD68= I=:>G8J>I=6HD7H:GK:9
DJGIH=6K:688DG9:9B6C6<>C<6<:CIHI6IJHID>C9>K>9J6AHL=DCDADC<:G:M:G8>H:9
6JI=DG>INDK:GI=:68I>DCH>CFJ:HI>DC6C9:K:CID>C9>K>9J6AHL=DCDADC<:G=:A9
6CN EDH>I>DC D; 6JI=DG>IN >C 6 8DGEDG6I>DC HD ADC< 6H I=DH: >C9>K>9J6AH G:I6>C:9
HDB:GDA:>CI=:8DGEDG6I>DCDG6IA:6HIB6>CI6>C:9>CI:G:HIH8DCHDC6CIL>I=G6I=:G
I=6C69K:GH:ID>IH>CI:G:HIH

DJC9>C<=JG8=D;+8>:CIDAD<ND;/6H=>C<IDC !C8K/:7HI:G 9
>G
::63-+>398>9!6+38>300=G!<9:9=/./:98/8>=
,=:E6GI>:H9DCDI9>HEJI:I=6I(A6>CI>;;HZEGDEDH:99:EDC:CIHLDJA9B::II=:WB6C6<>C<
6<:CIXI:HIL:G:I=:9:EDC:CIHHI>AAH:GK>C<>CI=:+6J9><DK:GCB:CI,=:DJGIL>AAI=:G:;DG:
6HHJB: 67H:CI:K>9:C8:DG6G<JB:CIIDI=:8DCIG6GN I=6I6AAL>IC:HH:H6I>HHJ: >;HI>AA
:BEADN:9 LDJA97:EGDE:GAN9:H><C6I:96H6CD;;>8:G 9>G:8IDG DGB6C6<>C<6<:CID;I=:
#>C<9DB,=:DCANED>CID;8DCI:CI>DC7:;DG:I=:DJGI>HL=:I=:GI=:#>C<9DBG:I6>CH8DCIGDA
DK:GI=:H:D;;>8>6AHCDLI=6II=:N6G:G:I>G:9DGCDADC<:GH:GK>C<>CI=:>G<DK:GCB:CIEDHIH,=:
FJ:HI>DC>HI=:G:;DG:L=:I=:GI=:H:;DGB:GD;;>8>6AH=6K:B6>CI6>C:9>CI:G:HIH8DCHDC6CIL>I=

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 7 of 40
G6I=:GI=6C69K:GH:IDI=:#>C<9DBZH>CI:G:HIH'CI=:G:8DG97:;DG:I=:DJGI (A6>CI>;;H=6K:
CDIHJ;;>8>:CIANH=DLCI=6I6AAD;I=:EGDEDH:99:EDC:CIHB::II=>HI=G:H=DA9
8DJGI>CI=>H9>HIG>8I=6H;DJC9;DGB:G:BEADN::HID7:B6C6<>C<6<:CIHL=:G:W2>3I
86CCDI7:9:C>:9I=6I2I=:;DGB:G:BEADN::H3HI6C9G:69NIDH:GK:I=:EA6>CI>;;H X6HDC:D;I=:
:BEADN::H6AG:69N9>96;I:G=>HG:H><C6I>DC!C9:E:C9:CI(GD9J8I>DCHDGEK$D:LZH !C8
* +&0CDI=:G8DJGI>CI=>H9>HIG>8I;DJC9I=6IW2I3=:8DCI>CJ:9
:BEADNB:CID;I=:;DGB:GB6HI:G6H68=>:;B6I:>C9>86I:HI=6I=>H>CI:G:HIH6G:HI>AA>9:CI>;>:9
L>I=I=:9:;:C96CI8DGEDG6I>DCXJGGNK+I6I:H%6G>C:DGED;:A6L6G: *
+&0+>B>A6GAN 6C:BEADN::L=DWG:I6>CH6EDH>I>DCL>I=I=:EA6>CI>;;HJ8=I=6I
=:G:B6>CHADN6AIDCDIDCANI=:8DGEDG6I>DC7NL=>8==:>HCDL:BEADN:97JI6AHDIDI=:DI=:G
2G:A6I:93EA6>CI>;;
8DGEDG6I>DCHXL6H;DJC9ID7:6B6C6<>C<6<:CIDHIDC>6<CDHI>8H
:K:ADEB:CIDGEK#DAAHB6C%6CJ;68IJG>C<D * %6HH
,=:#>C<9DB=6HHI6I:9I=6ID;(A6>CI>;;HZEGDEDH:99:EDC:CIH6G:CDI8JGG:CI
:BEADN::HD;+6J9>G67>67H:CI:K>9:C8:IDI=:8DCIG6GN I=:DJGI86CCDI;>C9I=6II=:H:
>C9>K>9J6AHH=DJA97:688DG9:9B6C6<>C<6<:CIHI6IJH,=:G:>HCD8DCI>CJ:9:BEADNB:CIID
HJ<<:HII=6II=:H:>C9>K>9J6AHB6>CI6>C>CI:G:HIH8DCHDC6CIL>I=I=:#>C<9DB 6C9I=:H:
>C9>K>9J6AH=6K:CDIH=DLC6L>AA>C<C:HHIDWHI6C9G:69NIDH:GK:XI=:#>C<9DB'CI=:
8DCIG6GN I=:#>C<9DB8DCI68I:9B6CND;I=:H:>C9>K>9J6AH6C9G:FJ:HI:9I=:>G6II:C96C8:6I6
9:EDH>I>DC 6C9I=:N9:8A>C:9I=:G:FJ:HI#+G 6I

H::6AHD;G6B$>C:H *6I

;>C9>C<I=6I;G6B9>9CDI=6K:8DCIGDADK:GDK:GH:6HEDGI6<:CIH7:86JH:WI=:G:=6H
7::CCDH=DL>C<I=6II=:N:K:GEGDK>9:9HLDGCI:HI>BDCN;DG;G6BL>I=DJI7:>C<G:FJ>G:9ID
9DHD7NHJ7ED:C6DGDI=:G;DGB6AEGD8:HH!C9::9 ILDD;I=:EGDEDH:99:EDC:CIH (G>C8:
79JA6O>O6C9(G>C8:6C96G L:G:6AA:<:9AN9:I6>C:97NI=:#>C<9DB:8A6G6I>DCD;+I:K:C*

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 8 of 40
(DJC>6C 96I:9%6G8= W(DJC>6C:8AXSS

,=:DJGI>HHJG:AN>CCDEDH>I>DC
ID9:I:GB>C:I=:6AA:<>6C8:HD;>C9>K>9J6AHL=DH:;G::9DBL6HEJI>C?:DE6G9N7NI=:>GDLC
<DK:GCB:CI,=:;68II=6I6C>C9>K>9J6A8DCI>CJ:HIDG:8:>K:<DK:GCB:CI7:C:;>IH H::(AHG 6I
>H>CHJ;;>8>:CI
%DG:DK:G WI=:8DCH:FJ:C8:D;G:FJ>G>C<9:EDH>I>DCHEJGHJ6CIIDCDI>8:X>HI=6I+6J9>
G67>6W8DJA97:H6C8I>DC:9;DG;6>A>C<IDEGD9J8:L>IC:HH:HL=D6G:>C;68I7:NDC9>IH8DCIGDAX
;G6B$>C:H *6I:9:G6A*JA:96JI=DG>O:HH6C8I>DCHL=:C:K:GW6E6GIN
6;I:G7:>C<H:GK:9L>I=EGDE:GCDI>8: 2;6>AH3ID6EE:6G;DG2I=:>GDLC39:EDH>I>DCX:9*>K(
9H::6AHDJKDCHDA>96I:99>HDCDD;&0 !C8

.
* (
/$ 6I+&0+:EI (A6>CI>;;H6G: >C:;;:8I 6H@>C<I=:DJGIID
I=G:6I:C6;DG:><CHDK:G:><CL>I=8DCI:BEIH6C8I>DCH>;>I9D:HCDI8DBEANL>I=A:<6AEGD8:HH:H
I=6I>I8A6>BH>I9D:HCDI6H8G>7:ID+::#+G 6IC(DJC>6C:8ASSU9:H8G>7>C<
K6G>DJH;G6B:LDG@H6C9EGD8:HH:H;DG8G>B>C6A86H:H6C9G:<>DC6A8DCK:CI>DCHD;L=>8=:>I=:G
I=:-C>I:9+I6I:HDG+6J9>G67>6>HCDI6E6GIN:86JH:!;>C9I=6ICDC:D;I=:L>IC:HH:H
FJ6A>;>:HDCI=:EG:H:CIG:8DG96H6B6C6<>C<6<:CI I=:DJGIL>AACDI9>G:8II=:#>C<9DB DC
E6>CD;H6C8I>DC IDEGD9J8:>C9>K>9J6AH;DG9:EDH>I>DCL=D=6K:G:;JH:9ID9DHDKDAJCI6G>AN
:M8:EI6HFJ6A>;>:97:ADL
B-/:>398=
DJGIH=6K:G:8D<C>O:96C:M8:EI>DCIDI=:B6C6<>C<6<:CIGJA:L=:CW68DGEDG6I>DC
I:GB>C6I:H6CD;;>8:G>CA><=ID;E:C9>C<A>I><6I>DCX*JC9FJ>HI *6I ,=>H:M8:EI>DC
EGDBDI:H;JC96B:CI6A;6>GC:HHL=:C6L>IC:HHJC:ME:8I:9AN>HG:BDK:9;GDBI=:G:68=D;6*JA:
CDI>8:(A6>CI>;;H6G<J:I=6I8:GI6>CL>IC:HH:HL:G:G:I>G:96;I:G(A6>CI>;;HC6B:9I=:B6H

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 9 of 40
B6I:G>6AL>IC:HH:H>CI=>H86H: 6C9I=6II=:#>C<9DB;6>A:9IDCDI>;NI=:DJGIDG(A6>CI>;;H>C
69K6C8:ID6AADLI=:>GI:HI>BDCNID7:EG:H:GK:9(AHG 6I

,.?66+26+3>2/8
(A6>CI>;;H;>GHI>9:CI>;>:9A"6>I=:C6H6E:GHDCD;>CI:G:HI>CI=:>G'8ID7:G
+JEEA:B:CI6AD8JB:CI*:FJ:HIHD;I=:#>C<9DB(AHM(A6>CI>;;HI=:CC6B:9A"6>I=:C
6H6L>IC:HH;DG9:EDH>I>DC>C:7GJ6GN 6IL=>8=I>B:(A6>CI>;;H6H@:9+6J9>G67>6ID
69K>H:6HIDL=:I=:G>I8A6>BHID7:JC67A:DGJCL>AA>C<IDEGD9J8:6CND;>IHEGDEDH:9L>IC:HH:H
;DG9:EDH>I>DC(AHM:8:B7:G >CI:GC6A%'!CDI:6H@HI=6IA"6>I=:C7:
I:GB>C6I:9;DG=6K>C<HJEEDGI:9I=:%JHA>BGDI=:G=DD9 6C96:7GJ6GN >CI:GC6A
%'!CDI:HI6I:HI=6IA"6>I=:CL>H=:9IDG:I>G:6II=6II>B:(AHMH A"6>I=:CZH
W6GAN*:I>G:B:CIXL6H:;;:8I>K:%6N (AHMICDI>B:9>9I=:#>C<9DB69K>H:
(A6>CI>;;HD;I=:;68II=6IA"6>I=:CL6HA:6K>C<>IH:BEADNDGI6@:6CN6K6>A67A:B:6HJG:HID
EG:H:GK:A"6>I=:CZHI:HI>BDCN(DJC>6C:8AS
/=>A:I=:DJGI>C>I>6AAN9:C>:9(A6>CI>;;HZG:FJ:HI;DG9D8JB:CI9>H8DK:GN6HIDA
"6>I=:CDC&DK:B7:G H::&D I=6IGJA>C<=6HCD7:6G>C<DC(A6>CI>;;HZ
:7GJ6GN G:FJ:HIID9:EDH:A"6>I=:C 6C9I=:#>C<9DBZH;6>AJG:ID69K>H:(A6>CI>;;HD;A
"6>I=:CZHG:I>G:B:CI,=:#>C<9DBZH;6>AJG:IDCDI>;N(A6>CI>;;H6HIDA"6>I=:CZH8=6C<:>CHI6IJH
HJEEDGIH(A6>CI>;;HZ6G<JB:CII=6IA"6>I=:CZHG:I>G:B:CIB6N=6K:G:A6I:9>CE6GIIDI=:E:C9>C<
A>I><6I>DC 6C96HHJ8= I=:DJGIL>AA9:I:GB>C:A"6>I=:CZHHI6IJH6H6WB6C6<>C<6<:CIX6HD;
I=:I>B:L=:CI=:68I>K>I>:H9>HEJI:9>CI=:A>I><6I>DCD88JGG:9 CDI6II=:I>B:D;I=:9:EDH>I>DC
+::*JC9FJ>HI *6I H::6AHD!J(DCI9:&:BDJGH6C9DK#DADC!C9JH
!C8 * .6 W,=:I>B>C<6C98>G8JBHI6C8:HD;29:;:C96CIZH3
G:6HH><CB:CIDGI:GB>C6I>DCD;>IH:BEADN::HG:C9:GI=:IGJ:HI6IJHD;I=:EGDEDH:99:EDC:CIH

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 10 of 40
=><=ANHJHE:8IX,=:DJGI=6H;DJC9A"6>I=:CID7:WBDG:H:C>DGI=6C,=JB6>GN6II=:
%>C>HIGND;!HA6B>8;;6>GH X6C9CDI:9I=6I=:B6N7:6W=><=:G
G6C@>C<+6J9>D;;>8>6AXL=D
<6K:>CHIGJ8I>DCHID6HH>HII=:=>?68@:GH"6CJ6GN 'E>C>DC'G9:GW"6CJ6GN'G9:GX
6IH6CN9DJ7IHG:<6G9>C<A"6>I=:CZHHI6IJH6G:G:HDAK:9>C;6KDGD;I=::M6B>C>C<E6GIN I=:
DJGIDG9:GHI=6II=:#>C<9DBEGD9J8:A"6>I=:C;DG69:EDH>I>DCJ76>!HA6B>86C@
/$ 6I
,.?66+26A+.
(A6>CI>;;H6AHDH::@ID9:EDH:79JAA6=AL69+::(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I(A6>CI>;;H
;>GHIA>HI:9AL696H6EGDEDH:99:EDC:CI>C:7GJ6GN +::(AHMII=6II>B:
(A6>CI>;;HG:FJ:HI:9I=6IWI=:#>C<9DB69K>H:JHL=:I=:G>I8A6>BHID7:JC67A:DGJCL>AA>C<
IDEGD9J8:6CND;I=:H:>C9>K>9J6AH;DG9:EDH>I>DCX!988DG9>C<IDI=:#>C<9DBZH"JAN
A:II:GIDI=:DJGI AL69H:GK:96H+6J9>G67>6ZHB76HH69DGID=>A:JCI>A%6G8=
+::&D88DG9>C<AN AL69L6HHI>AA:BEADN:97NI=:#>C<9DBL=:C
(A6>CI>;;H;>A:9I=:>G>C>I>6AL>IC:HHA>HI>C:7GJ6GN II=6II>B: I=:#>C<9DBH=DJA9=6K:
69K>H:9(A6>CI>;;HI=6IAL69ZH8DCIG68I:MI:CH>DCL6HID:C9DC:BDCI=A6I:G
,=:#>C<9DBL6H6AHD>C9:E:C9:CIAN6L6G:D;AL69ZHEDI:CI>6AG:A:K6C8:IDI=>H
A>I><6I>DC"J9<:6C>:AHZHDG9:G9:CN>C<+6J9>G67>6ZHBDI>DCID9>HB>HHG:;:GG:9ID6:7GJ6GN
B::I>C<6II=:DCHJA6I:L=:G:6NDJB>IDA9W6IA:6HIDC:E:GHDC=:L6HIG6K:A>C<XID
$DHC<:A:HIDE>8@JEK>H>IDGH H::%6G8='G9:G 6IC 6C9I=:
+::&D!ILDJA97:JC;6>G
ID9:EG>K:(A6>CI>;;HD;I=>HG:A:K6CI9:EDH>I>DC7:86JH:I=:#>C<9DB 8DCIG6GNID>IHD7A><6I>DCH
;6>A:9ID69K>H:(A6>CI>;;HI=6IAL69L6HG:I>G>C<>C ,=:DJGI;>C9HI=6IAL69 6H

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 11 of 40
I=:;DGB:G:EJINDJCH:A >H6WB6C6<>C<6<:CIXHJ7?:8IID9:EDH>I>DCCDI>8:6C9BJHI7:
EGD9J8:9
>2/<#/>3</. 003-3+6=
(A6>CI>;;H699>I>DC6AAN8A6>BI=6I#=6A>9AHH6; 79JA6O>OACF6G> %D=6B:9A
+6AB> 6C979JA6O>OABB6GWB6NHI>AA7:X+6J9><DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6AH(DJC>6C:8ASS
';I=:H:>C9>K>9J6AH ACF6G>=6HKDAJCI6G>AN6<G::9IDI:HI>;N#+M 6IA
+6AB>ZHI=G::
N:6GI:GB 688DG9>C<ID(A6>CI>;;HZDLC:K>9:C8: :C9:9DC"6CJ6GN (AH
M(A6>CI>;;HEGDK>9:CD:K>9:C8:;DGI=:>G8A6>BH67DJIAHH6;6C9ABB6G+:E6G6I:AN
(A6>CI>;;H8>I:6%6G8= *DN6A:8G::>HHJ:97N#>C<+6AB6CD;+6J9>G67>69>HB>HH>C<
,6L;>FA+J96>GN;GDB=>HEDH>I>DC6H:EJIN%>C>HI:GD;!HA6B>8;;6>GH(DJC>6C:8AS
'CI=>HG:8DG9 EG>C8>EA:HD;;6>GC:HH9DCDIHJEEDGI;>C9>C<I=6II=:H:>C9>K>9J6AHH=DJA9
7:9::B:9B6C6<>C<6<:CIH6C9I=6I+6J9>G67>6H=DJA97:8DBE:AA:9IDEGD9J8:I=:B;DG
9:EDH>I>DC(A6>CI>;;H=6K:CDI9:BDCHIG6I:9I=6II=:#>C<9DB@C:LI=6I(A6>CI>;;HLDJA97:
H::@>C<I=:H:>C9>K>9J6AHZ9:EDH>I>DCH6C9;6>A:9ID68IID6AADLI=:(A6>CI>;;HIDEG:H:GK:I=:>G
I:HI>BDCN,DI=::MI:CII=:(A6>CI>;;H7:A>:K: 76H:9DC:K>9:C8: I=6II=:H:>C9>K>9J6AH6G:
WHI>AAX:BEADN:97NI=:#>C<9DB (A6>CI>;;HB6NH::@6;;>96K>IH;GDBI=:#>C<9DB6II:HI>C<ID
I=:>G8JGG:CI:BEADNB:CIHI6IJH7H:CI:K>9:C8:HJ<<:HI>C<I=6II=:#>C<9DBG:I6>CH8DCIGDA
DK:GI=:H:>C9>K>9J6AH I=:DJGI*&,+I=:#>C<9DBZHG:FJ:HI;DG6EGDI:8I>K:DG9:G
%/=>3798C0<97?<</8>+8.9<7/<3:697+>3- 003-3+6=
%2/'3/88+98@/8>398=9898=?6+<+8.3:697+>3-#/6+>398=
,=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCDC>EADB6I>8*:A6I>DCHD;W.*X6C9I=:.>:CC6
DCK:CI>DCDCDCHJA6G*:A6I>DCHD;W.*X6G:>CI:GC6I>DC6AIG:6I>:HL>9:AN
68@CDLA:9<:96HI=:6JI=DG>I6I>K:HI6I:B:CID;>BBJC>IN6EEA>867A:IDG:A6I>DCH6BDC<C6I>DCH

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 12 of 40
+::-C>I:9+I6I:HKC<:G +JEE C&",=:.*>HI=:EGD9J8I
D;I=:-C>I:9&6I>DCHDC;:G:C8:DCDCHJA6G*:A6I>DCH L=>8=LDG@:9;GDB69G6;IEG:E6G:97N
I=:!CI:GC6I>DC6A$6LDBB>HH>DC*:EG:H:CI6I>K:H;GDBI=:<DK:GCB:CIHD;8DJCIG>:H
>C8AJ9>C<I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H 86B:ID<:I=:GID9G6;II=:;>C6A9D8JB:CI+::%DG6K&:L0DG@
9 9>G 8>I>C<$J@:,$:: .>:CC6DCK:CI>DCDCDCHJA6G*:A6I>DCH

,=:.*L6HG6I>;>:97NI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H>C+::>9DAADL>C<6H>B>A6G
EGD8:HH I=:.* 8D9>;N>C<WADC<HI6C9>C<EG>C8>EA:HD;8JHIDB6GN>CI:GC6I>DC6AA6LL>I=
G:HE:8IID9>EADB6I>8G:A6I>DCH XL6HG6I>;>:97NI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H>CGD>9N6E>I6A%<BI
$$K:CDB6G 9 9>G 8>I>C<,=>G9K:HHD8HK(:GB6C:CI
%>HH>DCD;*:EJ7A>8D;16>G:ID-C>I:9&6I>DCH 9 9>G
,=:9G6;I:GHD;I=:DCK:CI>DCHB69:8A:6GI=6II=:EJGEDH:D;I=:EG>K>A:<:H6C9
>BBJC>I>:HI=:G:>CW>HCDIID7:C:;>I>C9>K>9J6AH7JIID:CHJG:I=::;;>8>:CIE:G;DGB6C8:D;
;JC8I>DCH7N8DCHJA6GEDHIHDC7:=6A;D;I=:>GG:HE:8I>K:+I6I:HX.*EB7AH::6AHD.*
EB7A9>EADB6I>8>BBJC>IN>H>CI:C9:9WCDIID7:C:;>I>C9>K>9J6AH7JIID:CHJG:I=::;;>8>:CI
E:G;DGB6C8:D;I=:;JC8I>DCHD;9>EADB6I>8B>HH>DCH6HG:EG:H:CI>C<+I6I:HX,=:>BBJC>I>:H
6C9EG>K>A:<:H7:ADC<IDI=:H:C9>C<HI6I: CDI>C9>K>9J6A9>EADB6I>8DG8DCHJA6GD;;>8>6AH+::
:< *:EDGID;I=:DBB>HH>DCIDI=::C:G6AHH:B7AN -&D8 >C!!0!CIZA
DBBZC >BBJC>INW>CG:HE:8ID;68IHE:G;DGB:97N28DCHJA6GD;;>8:GH3>CI=:
:M:G8>H:D;I=:>G;JC8I>DCHX>HW6C>BBJC>INL=>8=I=:H:C9>C<+I6I:>HG:8D<C>O:96H
EDHH:HH>C<X*:EDGID;I=:DBB>HH>DCIDI=::C:G6AHH:B7AN -&D8 >C!!0
!CIZA$DBBZC >BBJC>IND;9>EADB6I>86<:CIHWB6N7:L6>K:97NI=:H:C9>C<
+I6I:6ADC:X,=:6GI>8A:HD;I=:DCK:CI>DCH6G:8DCH>9:G:9>CK>DA67A:+::<:C:G6AAN:6G9K

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 13 of 40
G::C: -+ CDI>C< >C69>H8JHH>DCD;I=:.* I=6IWIG:6I>:H6G:
G:8D<C>O:97NDJGDCHI>IJI>DC6HI=:HJEG:B:A6LD;I=:A6C9X
,=:8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DCH8DK:G:97NI=:.*>C8AJ9:WEGDI:8I>C<>CI=:G:8:>K>C<+I6I:
I=:>CI:G:HIHD;I=:H:C9>C<+I6I:6C9D;>IHC6I>DC6AH 7DI=>C9>K>9J6AH6C97D9>:H8DGEDG6I:
L>I=>CI=:A>B>IHE:GB>II:97N>CI:GC6I>DC6AA6LXW;JGI=:G>C<I=:9:K:ADEB:CID;8JAIJG6A
G:A6I>DCH7:IL::CI=:H:C9>C<+I6I:6C9I=:G:8:>K>C<+I6I:XW>HHJ>C<E6HHEDGIH6C9IG6K:A
9D8JB:CIHIDC6I>DC6AHD;I=:H:C9>C<HI6I:XW=:AE>C<6C96HH>HI>C<C6I>DC6AH 7DI=>C9>K>9J6AH
6C97D9>:H8DGEDG6I: D;I=:H:C9>C<+I6I:X6C9WE:G;DGB>C<6CNDI=:G;JC8I>DCH:CIGJHI:9ID6
8DCHJA6GEDHI7NI=:H:C9>C<+I6I:L=>8=6G:CDIEGD=>7>I:97NI=:A6LH6C9G:<JA6I>DCHD;I=:
G:8:>K>C<+I6I:DGIDL=>8=CDD7?:8I>DC>HI6@:C7NI=:G:8:>K>C<+I6I:X.*6GI6 7 9
: 6C9BDK:G:99>EADB6I>8;JC8I>DCH>C8AJ9:W2E3GDI:8I>C<>CI=:G:8:>K>C<+I6I:I=:
>CI:G:HIHD;I=:H:C9>C<+I6I:6C9D;>IHC6I>DC6AH L>I=>CI=:A>B>IHE:GB>II:97N>CI:GC6I>DC6A
A6LX263H8:GI6>C>C<7N6AAA6L;JAB:6CH8DC9>I>DCH6C99:K:ADEB:CIH>CI=:G:8:>K>C<+I6I:X
6C9W9:K:ADE>C<8JAIJG6AG:A6I>DCHX.*6GI7 9 6C9:,=:DJGID;
EE:6AH=6HW86JI>DC:96<6>CHI6C6GGDLG:69>C<XD;I=:.*ZH86I8=6AAEGDK>H>DC+::
#>C<9DBD;%DGD88DK-C>I:9+I6I:H &D

%
&+* /$ 6I
+&0:8 8>I>C< :6C:NKDKZID;+E6>C 9 9>G
,=:EG>K>A:<:H6C9>BBJC>I>:HD;I=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH6EEANIDI:HI>BDCN6C9
9D8JB:CIHG:<6G9>C<6AAW68IHE:G;DGB:9>CI=::M:G8>H:D;2D;;>8>6AHZ3;JC8I>DCHX6I
9>EADB6I>8DG8DCHJA6G;68>A>I>:H .*6GI.*6GI-C9:GI=:.* W263
9>EADB6I>86<:CI>HCDID7A><:9ID<>K::K>9:C8:6H6L>IC:HHX.*6GIW9>EADB6I>8
6<:CIX>H9:;>C:96HWI=:=:69D;I=:B>HH>DCDG6B:B7:GD;I=:9>EADB6I>8HI6;; X>:I=DH:
W=6K>C<9>EADB6I>8G6C@X!96GIH9

:W2/3>I=G:HE:8IID68IHE:G;DGB:97NHJ8=6E:GHDC>C

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 14 of 40
I=::M:G8>H:D;=>H;JC8I>DCH6H6B:B7:GD;I=:B>HH>DC >BBJC>INH=6AA8DCI>CJ:IDHJ7H>HIX
6;I:G69>EADB6I>86<:CIZH;JC8I>DCH:C9!96GI+>B>A6GAN JC9:GI=:.* W2B3:B7:GH
D;68DCHJA6GEDHI6G:JC9:GCDD7A><6I>DCID<>K::K>9:C8:8DC8:GC>C<B6II:GH8DCC:8I:9L>I=
I=::M:G8>H:D;I=:>G;JC8I>DCHX.*6GIW%:B7:GHD;I=:8DCHJA6GEDHIXB:6CH
W8DCHJA6GD;;>8:GH 8DCHJA6G:BEADN::H 6C9B:B7:GHD;I=:H:GK>8:HI6;;X!96GI<
W2/3>I=G:HE:8IID68IHE:G;DGB:97N68DCHJA6GD;;>8:GDG68DCHJA6G:BEADN::>CI=::M:G8>H:D;
=>H;JC8I>DCH >BBJC>IN;GDB?JG>H9>8I>DCH=6AA8DCI>CJ:IDHJ7H>HIL>I=DJIA>B>I6I>DCD;I>B:X!9
6GI
!<9-/.?<+6#/;?3</7/8>=09<>2/8@9-+>39890>2/'3/88+98@/8>398=
DGI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCHID6EEAN 69>EADB6IBJHI7:688G:9>I:96H69>EADB6I.:9
(&6C96:I6A $>I><6I>DCD;!CI:GC6I>DC6A>HEJI:H>C-+DJGIHR W,=:
:E6GIB:CID;+I6I:>CI:GEG:IHI=:.*ID6AADL>C9>K>9J6A9>EADB6IHID6HH:GI>BBJC>IN
DCI=:>GDLC7:=6AK:HX-C>I:9+I6I:HKA+=6G6; +JEE9 ,=:
>G8J>I=6H=:A9I=6IW2>3I>H:CDJ<=I=6I2I=:9>EADB6I3=6HG:FJ:HI:9>BBJC>IN I=6II=:
+I6I::E6GIB:CI=6HG:8D<C>O:9I=6II=:E:GHDC;DGL=DB>IL6HG:FJ:HI:9>H:CI>IA:9ID>I 6C9
I=6II=::E6GIB:CIZHG:8D<C>I>DC=6H7::C8DBBJC>86I:9IDI=:8DJGIX6GG:G6K6GG:G6
9 >GW2*3:8D<C>I>DC7NI=::M:8JI>K:7G6C8=VCDIID7:H:8DC9
<J:HH:97NI=:?J9>8>6GNV>H:HH:CI>6AID:HI67A>H=>C<9>EADB6I>8HI6IJHX-C>I:9+I6I:HK
$JBJB76 9 9>G8>I>C<*:HI6I:B:CI,=>G9D;DG:><C*:A6I>DCH$6L
D;I=:-C>I:9+I6I:HRDBB:CI6GN6I ,:CIG6;I&D W,=:8DJGIH6G:
9>HEDH:9ID688:EI6H8DC8AJH>K:D;I=:;68ID;I=:9>EADB6I>8HI6IJHD;6C>C9>K>9J6A8A6>B>C<6C
:M:BEI>DC I=:K>:LHI=:G:DCD;I=:EDA>I>86A9:E6GIB:CID;I=:>G<DK:GCB:CIX6GG:G6 9
6I>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 15 of 40
+6J9>G67>6=6HEGDK>9:9I=:DJGIL>I=6G8=>K:9K:GH>DCHD;I=:+I6I::E6GIB:CIZH
>EADB6I>8$>HI6C9$>HID;DG:><CDCHJA6G';;>8:H L=>8=8DCI6>CC6B:HD;B:B7:GHD;
9>EADB6I>8HI6;;6C9G:8D<C>O:98DCHJA6GD;;>8>6AHL=D6G::CI>IA:9IDI=:>BBJC>I>:HD;I=:
.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH&DH:: :< -+:EZID;+I6I: >EADB6I>8$>HI +JBB:G
=IIEH
HI6I:<DK67DJI4HI6I:8DCI68IH9>EA>HI HJBB:G4=IBAH6J9>
86E>I6A>O6I>DCDB>II:9,=DH:A>HIH>9:CI>;N6AAI=:>C9>K>9J6AH6HIDL=DBI=:#>C<9DB=6H
6HH:GI:9I:HI>BDC>6A>BBJC>INJC9:GI=:DCK:CI>DCH :M8:EI;DGILD6B76HH69DGHIDDI=:G
?JG>H9>8I>DCH L=D6G:8:GI6>CAN:CI>IA:9ID>BBJC>IN6HL:AA(A6>CI>;;H=6K:CDIEG:H:CI:96CN
:K>9:C8:IDI=:DJGII=6II=:8G:9:CI>6AHD;6CND;I=:H:A>HI:9D;;>8>6AH=6K:6I6CNI>B:7::C
G:KD@:9,=:DJGII=:G:;DG:;>C9HI=6II=:#>C<9DB=6HH6I>H;>:9>IH7JG9:CD;H=DL>C<I=6II=:
>C9>K>9J6AH6HIDL=DB>BBJC>IN>H7:>C<6HH:GI:96G:EGDE:GAN688G:9>I:9
#/=3.?+677?83>C&8./<>2/'3/88+98@/8>398=
(A6>CI>;;H6G<J:I=6IL=:C69>EADB6IZH;JC8I>DCH:C9 I=:N=6K:CDG:H>9J6A>BBJC>IN
>: I=:EG>K>A:<:H6C9>BBJC>I>:H6;;DG9:97NI=:IG:6I>:H8:6H:(A6>CI>;;H8A6>BI=6II=:
.*ZHG:H>9J6A>BBJC>INEGDK>H>DC GI>8A: 9D:HCDI6EEANIDGI>8A:ZHGJA:H
G:<6G9>C<L>IC:HHI:HI>BDCNG6I=:G >I6EEA>:HDCANIDW>BBJC>IN;GDB?JG>H9>8I>DC XJC9:G
GI>8A:(A6>CI>;;HZ%6G8= DEEDH>I>DCW(AHGX 6I+>B>A6GAN (A6>CI>;;H6G<J:I=6I
I=:.*ZHG:H>9J6A>BBJC>INEGDK>H>DC GI>8A: G:68=:HDCANID9>EADB6I>8E:GHDCC:A
>CHD;6G6HI=:N6G:I=:HJ7?:8ID;68>K>ADG8G>B>C6AHJ>IJC9:GGI>8A:I=:G:>HCDHJ8=
>BBJC>ING:<6G9>C<I=:D7A><6I>DCID<>K:I:HI>BDCN6H6L>IC:HHJC9:GGI>8A:!9

!;(A6>CI>;;H=6K::K>9:C8:I=6II=:8G:9:CI>6AHD;6CND;I=:>C9>K>9J6AHDCI=:H:6G8=>K:9A>HIHL:G:
HJ7H:FJ:CIANG:KD@:9 I=:NB6NEG:H:CIHJ8=>C;DGB6I>DCIDI=::E6GIB:CID;+I6I:6C9G:A6N6CN
;>C9>C<HIDI=:DJGI

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 16 of 40
!C>CI:GEG:I>C<6IG:6IN 8DJGIHW7:<>C23L>I=I=:I:MID;I=:IG:6IN6C9I=:8DCI:MI>CL=>8=
I=:LG>II:CLDG9H6G:JH:9X%DG6 96I>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9,=:I:GB
W>BBJC>INX>H9:;>C:96HI=:W;G::9DBDG:M:BEI>DC;GDB68=6G<: 9JIN D7A><6I>DC D;;>8: I6M
>BEDH>I>DC E:C6AIN DGH:GK>8::HE6H<G6CI:97NA6LID6E:GHDCDG8A6HHD;E:GHDCHX/:7HI:GZH
,=>G9&:L!CI:GC6I>DC6A>8I>DC6GN
H::6AHDA68@ZH$6L>8I>DC6GNI=
:99:;>C>C<>BBJC>IN6H6CW2:3M:BEI>DCX;GDBWE:G;DGB>C<9JI>:HL=>8=I=:A6L
<:C:G6AANG:FJ>G:HDI=:G8>I>O:CHIDE:G;DGBX,=:H:DG9>C6GNB:6C>C<HD;I=:I:GBW>BBJC>INX
:C8DBE6HHI=::M:BEI>DC;GDB<>K>C<I:HI>BDCN
,=>HB:6C>C<>H6AHDHJEEDGI:97NI=:8DCI:MI>CL=>8=I=:LDG9H6G:JH:9GI>8A:
D;I=:.*G:;:GHIDI=:WEG>K>A:<:H6C9>BBJC>I>:HX<:C:G6AANEGDK>9:9;DG>CGI>8A:H
6C9 >C9>86I>C<I=6II=:9G6;I:GH8DCH>9:G:96AAD;I=:H:EGDK>H>DCHIDDE:G6I:H>B>A6GANAHD
GI>8A:D;I=:.* 9>H8JHH>C<8G>B>C6A>BBJC>I>:H HI6I:HI=6ID;;>8:GHWH=6AACDI7:A>67A:
ID6GG:HI XI=:H6B:A6C<J6<:JH:9>CGI>8A:WA>67>A>INID<>K::K>9:C8:XDJGIH>CI=>H
9>HIG>8I=6K:>CI:GEG:I:9I=:8DBE6G67A:.*EGDK>H>DCHH>B>A6GAN+::.JA86C!GDC/DG@H
!C8K(DA>H=B:G>86C%68=>C:GNDGE +JEE +&0WGI>8A:D;
I=:2.*39:6AHL>I=I=:>BBJC>IND;Y9>EADB6I>86<:CIHZX!CG:EEA>86I>DCD;&D7D6 &D
%
"+% /$ 6I+&0'8I 6EEAN>C<.*GIZH
G:H>9J6A>BBJC>INEGDK>H>DCIDGIZHW>BBJC>IND;69>EADB6I;GDB<>K>C<I:HI>BDCNX
(A6>CI>;;H;JGI=:G8DCI:C9I=6IEGD8:9JG6AAN I=:;DGB:G+6J9><DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6AHDC
I=:>GA>HIBJHI6EE:6G6II=:>G9:EDH>I>DCH 6C9+6J9>G67>6B6NI=:CD7?:8IIDHE:8>;>8FJ:HI>DCH
DCEG>K>A:<:<GDJC9H(AHG 6I(A6>CI>;;H8>I:ID69>HIG>8I8DJGI>C,:M6HL=>8=;DJC9I=6I
W263AI=DJ<=;DG:><C9>EADB6IH6G:CDID7A><6I:9IDI:HI>;N 2I=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH39DCDI
EGDK>9:6<:C:G6A:M:BEI>DC;GDB<>K>C<I:HI>BDCNXDMK6AA6H%:M>86CDCHJA6I::C:G6A

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 17 of 40
&D
.

' /$ 6I&,:M 8>I>C<"D=C:AA6H:I6A
,G6CHC6I>DC6A$>I><6I>DC(G68I>I>DC:GZHJ>9:RR ,=6I8DJGI=:A9I=6II=:
D;;>8>6AB6NG:;JH:ID6CHL:GFJ:HI>DCHG:<6G9>C<=>H8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DCH 7JII=6II=:9:;:C96CIH
B6NCDIG:;JH:IDEGD9J8:I=:D;;>8>6A;DG9:EDH>I>DC!98DJGI>CI=>H>G8J>I =DL:K:G ;DJC9
I=6I9>EADB6I>86<:CIHZW;6>AJG:ID6EE:6G;DG9:EDH>I>DCH>CG:HEDCH:IDI=:EA6>CI>;;HZHJ7ED:C6
L6H:M8JH67A:XJC9:GGI>8A:D;I=:.*.JA86C!GDC/DG@H +JEE6I

,=>HDJGI6<G::HL>I=>IHH>HI:G9>HIG>8I8DJGI/>IC:HH:HI=:G:;DG:C::9CDI6EE:6G;DGI=:>G
9:EDH>I>DC>;I=:>GI:HI>BDCNLDJA9DCAN8DK:GB6I:G>6AI=6II=:DJGI=6H;DJC9ID7:EGDI:8I:9
7NI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH
$-9:/90>2/#/=3.?+677?83>C&8./<>2/'3/88+98@/8>398=
(A6>CI>;;H6G<J:I=6I:K:C>;I=:G:>HG:H>9J6A>BBJC>IN;DGL>IC:HHI:HI>BDCN +6J9>
G67>686CCDI7AD8@I=:I:HI>BDCND;>IHD;;>8>6AH67DJI68I>K>I>:HI=6I;6AADJIH>9:I=:>GA:<>I>B6I:
9>EADB6I>8;JC8I>DCH,D;G6B:>IH6C6ANH>H I=:DJGIIJGCHIDI=:G:A6I:99D8IG>C:D;
EGDH:8JIDG>6A>BBJC>INWEGDH:8JIDG:C?DNH67HDAJI:>BBJC>INL=:C=:68IHL>I=>CI=:
H8DE:D;=>HEGDH:8JIDG>6A9JI>:HX!B7A:GK(68=IB6C -+ W!;6
EGDH:8JIDG=69DCAN6FJ6A>;>:9>BBJC>INI=:I=G:6ID;HJ>I23LDJA9JC9:GB>C:
E:G;DGB6C8:D;=>H9JI>:HX!96I!CI=>H>CHI6C8: W>I=6H7::CI=DJ<=I>CI=::C97:II:GID
A:6K:JCG:9G:HH:9I=:LGDC<H9DC:7N9>H=DC:HID;;>8:GHI=6CIDHJ7?:8II=DH:L=DIGNID9DI=:>G
9JINIDI=:8DCHI6CI9G:69D;G:I6A>6I>DCX!96I>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9DJGIHW:M6B>C:
I=:C6IJG:D;I=:;JC8I>DCHL>I=L=>8=6E6GI>8JA6GD;;>8>6A=6H7::CA6L;JAAN:CIGJHI:9X
DGG:HI:GK/=>I: -+ DG:M6BEA: 8DJGIH=6K:;DJC9I=6IW69K>H>C<I=:
EDA>8:>CI=:>CK:HI><6I>K:E=6H:D;68G>B>C6A86H:29D:HCDIFJ6A>;N3;DG67HDAJI:>BBJC>INX
JGCHK*::9 -+ JGI=:GBDG: L=:G:6EGDH:8JIDG=6HW>CI:GIL>C:9=>H

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 18 of 40
:M:G8>H:D;6JI=DG>O:9EGDH:8JIDG>6A9>H8G:I>DCL>I=DI=:G JC6JI=DG>O:98DC9J8I67HDAJI:
>BBJC>IN=6H7::C9:C>:9X:GC6G9KDJCIND;+J;;DA@ 9 9>G
,=:DJGID;EE:6AH=6HH>B>A6GAN;DJC9I=6II=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCHZG:H>9J6A
>BBJC>IN>H9:H><C:9ID:CHJG:WI=::;;>8>:CIE:G;DGB6C8:D;I=:;JC8I>DCHD;9>EADB6I>8
B>HH>DCH X6C9>HWA>B>I:9ID6C6GGDLH:ID;68IHI=6I6G:8DBB>II:9W>CI=::M:G8>H:D;2I=:
9>EADB6IZH3;JC8I>DCH

X+L6GC6KA
L69> 9 9
>G :BE=6H>H>CDG><>C6A,=:G:>HCD>BBJC>IN;DGW68I>DCHI=6IE:GI6>CID2I=:
D;;>8>6AZH3=DJH:=DA9DGE:GHDC6AA>;:6C9I=6IB6NEGDK>9: 6I7:HI Y6C>C9>G:8IZG6I=:GI=6C6
Y9>G:8I7:C:;>IIDZ9>EADB6I>8;JC8I>DCHX!96I

>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9W238IH
>C8>9:CI6A6C9>C9>HE:CH67A:ID9>EADB6I>868I>K>I>:H>C8AJ9:DCANHJ8=68IH6H6G:9>G:8IAN
>BEJI67A:IDI=:HI6I:DG>C:MIG>867ANI>:9ID69>EADB6IZHEGD;:HH>DC6A68I>K>I>:HX!96I
DCH>HI:CIL>I=I=:.*ZHI:MI6C99G6;I>C<=>HIDGN I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H I=GDJ<=I=:+I6I:
:E6GIB:CI =6HA>B>I:9I=:6EEA>86I>DCD;G:H>9J6A>BBJC>INIDWD;;>8>6A68IHDCANX!9
DJGIH6EEAN6ILD
E6GII:HIL=:C9:I:GB>C>C<L=:I=:G6C68IL6HWE:G;DGB:9>CI=:
:M:G8>H:D;8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DCHX>GHI WI=:DJGIBJHI9:I:GB>C:I=6II=:68I>DCHD;I=:8DCHJA6G
D;;>8>6AH>BEA>86I:9HDB:8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DC+:8DC9 I=:68IH;DGL=>8=I=:8DCHJA6GD;;>8>6AH
H::@>BBJC>INBJHI7:E:G;DGB:9>CI=::M:G8>H:D;I=:8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DCH>CFJ:HI>DCXDG9K
A:B:CI +JEE +&0+DIDB6NDG " 6;;Z999>G
>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCH6C9FJDI6I>DCB6G@HDB>II:9!CB6@>C<I=:H:9:I:GB>C6I>DCH 8DJGIH8DCH>9:G
WI=:HJ7?:8I>K:>CI:CID;I=:8DCHJA6GD;;>8>6A 76H:9DCD7?:8I>K::K>9:C8: >CE:G;DGB>C<I=:
68IL=:I=:GI=:68I;JGI=:G:9HDB:;JC8I>DCD;I=:8DCHJA6I:L=:I=:GI=:68I>HD;6
YE:GHDC6A8=6G68I:GZI=:H:G>DJHC:HHD;I=:68I6C9I=:67H:C8:DGEG:H:C8:D;6B6A>8>DJH

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 19 of 40
BDI>K:>CI=:E:G;DGB6C8:D;I=:E6GI>8JA6G68IX-C>I:9+I6I:HKDA: +JEE
(6
W!C699>I>DC I=:DJGIB6N8DCH>9:GL=:I=:GI=:68I>HE6GID;6EGDADC<:98DJGH:D;
8G>B>C6A8DC9J8IX!9>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9 DL:K:G W2>3C8DC9J8I>C<I=>H6C6ANH>H L:
BJHICDI?J9<:L=:I=:GI=:JC9:GAN>C<8DC9J8I68IJ6AAND88JGG:9 DGL=:I=:G>IL6HLGDC<;JA
*6I=:G DJG8DCH>9:G6I>DC>H6;JC8I>DC6ADC:X+L6GC6 96I>CI:GC6AFJDI6I>DCB6G@H
6C98>I6I>DCHDB>II:9W2/3:ADD@23IDI=:D7?:8I>K:68IH>CFJ:HI>DC CDII=:INE:D;
>C?JGN6AA:<:9XGO6@K-C>I:9&6I>DCH 9 C9>G 8>I>C<D:K
(=>AA>EH 9 9>G,=:DJGID;EE:6AH:MEA6>C:9I=6II=>HD7?:8I>K:
I:HIE6G6AA:AHI=6I>CI=:EGDH:8JIDG>6A>BBJC>IN8DCI:MI+::>9
,=:WEG:8>H:I6H@7:;DG:I=:DJGIX>HIDWH8GJI>C>O:I=:2368IHD7?:8I>K:AN6C9:K6AJ6I:
L=:I=:GI=:N;6AAL>I=>CI=:2>C9>K>9J6AZH3D;;>8>6A;JC8I>DCHHJ7?:8IID2I=:>G3G:H>9J6A>BBJC>INX
A+=6G6; +JEE96I,=:DJGICDI:H 6II=:DJIH:I I=6II=:G:>HWA>IIA:86H:A6L6HID
L=6I8DCHI>IJI:H68DCHJA6G;JC8I>DC X6C9WI=:G:6G:CD8A:6GGJA:HI=6I9:;>C:L=6I68I>DCH
8DCHI>IJI:YE:G;DGB>C<ZI=::M:G8>H:D;8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DCHXDG9 +JEE6I

,=:
DJGI6AHDG:8D<C>O:HI=6I"J9<:6C>:AH:MEA>8>IANE:GB>II:99>H8DK:GNG:<6G9>C<L=:I=:GA
,=JB6>GN6C9A6NDJB>L:G:W;DAADL>C<>CHIGJ8I>DCH;GDBBDG:H:C>DGD;;>8>6AH>CI=:+6J9>
B76HHNX%6G8='G9:G 6I/=>A:68IHI6@:CW>CI=:G:<JA6G8DJGH:D;>BEA:B:CI>C<6C
D;;>8>6AEGD<G6BDGEDA>8ND;I=:B>HH>DCX6G:EGDI:8I:97NI=:DCK:CI>DCH +L6GC6
+JEE96I 68IHI=6I>BEA>86I:68DCHJA6G;JC8I>DC7JIL:G:CDIWE:G;DGB:9>CI=::M:G8>H:
D;I=:8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DC>CFJ:HI>DCX9DCDIG:8:>K:I=:EGDI:8I>DCHD;I=:DCK:CI>DCHDG9
+JEE6I,=:DJGIL>AAC::9ID9:8>9:I=:H:>HHJ:HDC6IDE>8

7N
IDE>8 L>IC:HH
7N
L>IC:HH
76H>H

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 20 of 40
'CI=:EG:H:CIG:8DG9 I=:G:6G:DCANI=G::L>IC:HH:H67DJIL=DBI=:#>C<9DB6HH:GIH
>BBJC>INJC9:GI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH 7JIL=D6G:CDIEGDI:8I:97NI=:;DGB:G:BEADN::DG
=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C:H=B:9A)6II6C 79JAA6=AL69 6C9+6B>A!7G6=>B
#+G EEM/=>A:I=:DJGIL>AA699G:HHDCANI=:H:L>IC:HH:H I=:DJGIZH6C6ANH>H
H=DJA9EGDK>9:=:AE;JA<J>96C8:IDI=:E6GI>:HG:<6G9>C<6CNDI=:GEDI:CI>6A9:EDC:CIH

$+736,<+237
,=:DJGI86C<>K:DCANA>B>I:9<J>96C8:G:<6G9>C<+6B>A!7G6=>B76H:9DCI=:
9:H8G>EI>DCH8DCI6>C:9>C(A6>CI>;;HZ/>IC:HH$>HI(DH>C<=><=
A:K:AFJ:HI>DCHIDA!7G6=>B
67DJIA6NDJB>ZHHI6IJH6II=:DCHJA6I:A>@:AN9D:HCDI>C;G>C<:DCA!7G6=>BZH8DCHJA6G
9JI>:H+::#>C<9DBD;%DGD88D /$ 6IW>CFJ>G>:2H3>CID=><=

A:K:A <:C:G6A
FJ:HI>DCH67DJI6L>IC:HHZHEDH>I>DC6II=:DCHJA6I:9DCDIHIG>@:I=>HDJGI6H6C>CFJ>GN
67DJII=:Y:M:G8>H:D;23;JC8I>DCHZI=6I>HEGDI:8I:97NGI>8A:X DL:K:G FJ:HI>DCH67DJI
A6NDJB>ZHK>H>IH6C9E=DC:86AAHIDI=:DCHJA6I: L>I=DJI>C;DGB6I>DCH=DL>C<I=6II=:H:
68I>K>I>:H9>9CDI>CKDAK:68IH>CI=::M:G8>H:D;68DCHJA6G;JC8I>DC 6G:A>@:ANEG:8AJ9:97NI=:
DCK:CI>DCH+::(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6IDGL>IC:HH:HHJ8=6HA!7G6=>BL=:G:8:GI6>CIDE>8H
D;FJ:HI>DC>C<B6N;6AADJIH>9:I=:H8DE:D;I=:L>IC:HHZHG:H>9J6A>BBJC>IN I=:L>IC:HH:HBJHI
6EE:6G;DG9:EDH>I>DC6C9D7?:8I>DCHH=DJA97:B69:DC6FJ:HI>DC
7N
FJ:HI>DC76H>H
27/.6"+>>+8
,=:DJGI86CD;;:GHDB:BDG:<J>96C8:8DC8:GC>C<A)6II6C,DI=::MI:CII=6IA
)6II6C>CI:G68I:9L>I=A"6GG6=>CI=:E:G;DGB6C8:D;GDJI>C::B76HHN9JI>:H FJ:HI>DCH

,=:DJGI>HCDI>C8AJ9>C<>CI=>H86I:<DGN6CNL>IC:HHL=DBI=:DJGI9D:HCDI;>C9ID;6AAJC9:GI=:
=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C: 7JIL=DBI=:#>C<9DB=6HCDIN:I6H@:9IDH>I;DG9:EDH>I>DCKDAJCI6G>AN
+=DJA96CND;I=DH:>C9>K>9J6AH6<G::ID7:9:EDH:9 I=:E6GI>:HH=DJA98DC9J8II=:9:EDH>I>DC>C
688DG96C8:L>I=I=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH<J>96C8:EGDK>9:9>CI=>HH:8I>DC6C9G6>H:6CN9>HEJI:9>HHJ:H
IDI=:DJGI6II=6II>B:

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 21 of 40
G:<6G9>C<A"6GG6=ZHW96N
ID
96NLDG@X6II=:B76HHN6C9=>HWGDA:>CDK:GH::>C<I=:#% X
(AH/>IC:HH$>HI6I >BEA>86I:I=:9>EADB6I>8;JC8I>DCD;W2G3:EG:H:CI>C<I=:H:C9>C<+I6I:>C
I=:G:8:>K>C<+I6I:X.*6GI6)J:HI>DCH8DC8:GC>C<
6C9FJ:HI>DCH8DC8:GC>C<
>BEA>86I:I=:9>EADB6I>8;JC8I>DCD;
W2E3GDI:8I>C<>CI=:G:8:>K>C<+I6I:I=:>CI:G:HIHD;I=:H:C9>C<+I6I:2YH3C6I>DC6AHX.*
6GI7)J:HI>DCH8DC8:GC>C<
>BEA>86I:I=:9>EADB6I>8;JC8I>DCD;W2E3GDBDI>C<;G>:C9ANG:A6I>DCH
7:IL::CI=:H:C9>C<+I6I:6C9I=:G:8:>K>C<+I6I: 6C99:K:ADE>C<I=:>G8JAIJG6A
G:A6I>DCHX.*6GI:,=>H6C6ANH>H9D:HCDIEG:8AJ9:(A6>CI>;;H =DL:K:G ;GDB
>CFJ>G>C<6HIDL=:I=:GI=:H:68IHL:G:E:G;DGB:9>CI=::M:G8>H:D;I=:9>EADB6I>8;JC8I>DCH>C
FJ:HI>DC!BBJC>INDCAN6II68=:H>;I=:NL:G:HDE:G;DGB:9,=:DJGICDI:H 6H6C:M6BEA:
I=6I9D8JB:CIHHJ8=6H6E:GHDC6A8=:8@B69:DJI7NA+6AADJBIDI=:#>C<6=69%DHFJ:
(AHM G:EG:H:CI68IHI=6IB6NCDI=6K:7::CE:G;DGB:9>CI=::M:G8>H:D;68DCHJA6G
;JC8I>DC:K:C>;68DCHJA6G;JC8I>DCL6H>BEA>86I:9
(A6>CI>;;H6AHD>C9>86I:I=6I
)J:HI>DCH8DC8:GC>C<
IDI=::MI:CII=:N8DC8:GC68I>DCHE:G;DGB:9>CI=:
:M:G8>H:D;6CD;;>8>6A;JC8I>DC 6G:>BE:GB>HH>7A:JC9:GGO6@ L=:G:I=:DJGID;EE:6AH
;DJC9I=6IW6AA:<6I>DCH>CKDAK:2>C<3E:GHDCC:AB6C6<:B:CI9:8>H>DCH;6AA23L>I=>CI=:6B7>ID;

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 22 of 40
I=:9:;:C96CIHZEGD;:HH>DC6AG:HEDCH>7>A>I>:HXGO6@ 96IN8DCIG6HI D;;>8>6AHZ
;6AH:8A6>BHI=6IA,=JB6>GN9>9CDI=6K:686GG:<>HI:G:9L>I=I=:HI6I:D;6A>;DGC>6 L=:C=:
>C;68I=69DC:8DCIG6GNID+I6I::E6GIB:CIG:<JA6I>DCH H::(AHM 6I+I6I:

9DCDI
>BEA>86I:69>EADB6I>8;JC8I>DC+::#>C<9DBD;%DGD88D /$ 6I;>C9>C<
I=6IG:<6G9>C<W8DC9J8IEA6>CANEGD=>7>I:97NI=:A6LH6C9G:<JA6I>DCHD;I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H
I=:G:86C7:CD8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DCI=6I>H>BEA>86I:9X>CI:GC6AFJDI6I>DCB6G@HDB>II:9
!C#>C<9DBD;%DGD88D I=:8DBEA6>CI6AA:<:9I=6IILD8D
8DCHE>G6IDGHW=>G:9H:K:G6A
>A>E>CDC6I>DC6AHIDLDG@6H9DB:HI>8LDG@:GH6C9;6GB=6C9H 7JI>CHIGJ8I:9I=:BID6EEAN;DG
-+K>H6H7N;6AH:ANG:EG:H:CI>C<I=6II=:N=697::C=>G:9IDLDG@6II=:DCHJA6I:X /$
6I(A6>CI>;;HZ:M=>7>IHH=DLI=6I A,=JB6>GN
L=D=>BH:A;HI6I:9I=6I=:DCANHE:CI DG D;=>HI>B:LDG@>C<6II=:DCHJA6I:
(AHM 6I/=>A:I=:;68IE6II:GCH>C#>C<9DBD;%DGD88D6C9I=:
EG:H:CI86H:6G:CDI>9:CI>86A >C7DI=86H:H;6AH:G:EG:H:CI6I>DCHL:G:B69:G:<6G9>C<I=:;68IH
HJGGDJC9>C<>C9>K>9J6AHZ9>EADB6I>8HI6IJH+::(AHM 6I+I6I: <G6CI>C<A,=JB6>GN
:CIGN>CIDI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H6H6W8DCHJA6G:BEADN::XLDG@>C<6H6CW69B>C>HIG6I>K:D;;>8:GX
+6J9>G67>6=6H6G<J:9I=6I%DGD88D>H9>HI>C<J>H=67A:7:86JH:W2I3=:-+C:K:GH6>9
I=6I+6J9>G67>6L6H:C<6<:9>C8G>B>C6A68I>K>IN>CH:C9>C<I=:H:E:DEA:DK:GL>I=9>EADB6I>8
8G:9:CI>6AHX%6N GZ<,G

,=:FJ:HI>DC7:;DG:I=:DJGI =DL:K:G >HCDI
L=:I=:GI=:JC9:GAN>C<8DC9J8IL6HLGDC<;JA+::+L6GC6 96I,=:DJGIC::9CDI
G:68=6CN?J9<B:CI67DJIL=:I=:G8G>B>C6A68I>K>IND88JGG:9IDCDI:I=6II=:+I6I::E6GIB:CI
B69:8A:6GID+6J9>G67>6I=6I>I9>H6EEGDK:9D;;6AH:G:EG:H:CI6I>DCHG:<6G9>C<>IH9>EADB6I>8
E:GHDCC:A+::(AHM 6I+I6I: >C;DGB>C<+6J9>G67>6I=6IW>;2,=JB6>GN3>HCDI

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 23 of 40
:BEADN:97NI=:DCHJA6I: 6&DI>;>86I>DCD;,:GB>C6I>DCH=DJA97:HJ7B>II:9(AHM
+I6I::E6GIB:CIEG:HHHI6I:B:CII=6I>C9>K>9J6AHWCDI:C<6<:9>CI=:8DC9J8ID;69B>C>HIG6I>K:
DGDI=:G9JI>:HL>I=>CI=:B76HHNX6G:WCDI:CI>IA:9ID9>EADB6I>8HI6IJHX
C68II=6I
WI6@:H69K6CI6<:D;I=:EG>K>A:<:HD;I=6IEDH>I>DC9D:HCDIHJ99:CANB6@:>I68DCHJA6G
;JC8I>DCXDA: +JEE6I(A6>CI>;;HB6NI=:G:;DG:6H@FJ:HI>DCH67DJI;6AH:
G:EG:H:CI6I>DCHB69:G:<6G9>C<I=:688G:9>I6I>DCD;+6J9>EGDE6<6IDGH 6HADC<6HI=DH:FJ:HI>DCH
9DCDI8DC8:GCD;;>8>6AHZ9:8>H>DC
B6@>C<E:G;DGB:9>CI=::M:G8>H:D;D;;>8>6A;JC8I>DCH
,.?66+26A+.
(A6>CI>;;HH::@ID6H@AL6967DJII=:96I:I=6IA6NDJB>L:CIIDI=:$DHC<:A:H
DCHJA6I:>C:6GAN %6N GZ<,G

+6J9>G67>68DCI:C9HI=6I6B::I>C<IDG:C:L6E6HHEDGI
LDJA9>C9>HEJI67AN>CKDAK:I=:8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DCD;W>HHJ>C<E6HHEDGIHIDC6I>DC6AHD;I=:
H:C9>C<+I6I:X#+99:C9JB 6I.*6GI9,=:DJGI6<G::HI=6IFJ:HI>DCH
8DC8:GC>C<I=:>HHJ6C8:D;6E6HHEDGI >C8AJ9>C<I=:;68ID;L=:I=:G>IL6H>HHJ:9 6G:EGDI:8I:9
7NI=:DCK:CI>DCHJI(A6>CI>;;H9DCDI>CI:C9ID6H@6CNI=>C<67DJII=:E6HHEDGI>IH:A;H@>C<
AL69IDH>BEAN8DC;>GBI=:96I:D;I=>HB::I>C< L=>8="J9<:6C>:AH:MEA>8>IANG:;:G:C8:9

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 24 of 40
>C=>HDE>C>DC6JI=DG>O>C<?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GN 9D:HCDI>BEA>86I:6CN8DCHJA6G;JC8I>DC+::
%6G8='G9:G 6IC (A6>CI>;;H6G:I=:G:;DG:E:GB>II:9ID6H@AL69ID8DC;>GBI=:96I:
D;I=:B::I>C< 6C9ID6H@L=:I=:GI=:G:L:G:6CNDI=:GCDC
8DCHJA6GEJGEDH:H;DGI=:K>H>I
/:9=3>398=90?<</8>9<9<7/<312#+853819@/<87/8> 003-3+6=
/1+6$>+8.+<.
+6J9>G67>66G<J:HI=6ID;I=:>C9>K>9J6AHDC(A6>CI>;;HZ9:EDH>I>DCA>HI6G:8JGG:CIDG
;DGB:G%>C>HI:GHDG=:69HD;9>EADB6I>8DG8DCHJA6GB>HH>DCH DCANILDD;L=DB8JGG:CIANH:GK:
>CEDH>I>DCH6II=:G6C@D;6867>C:I
A:K:AB>C>HI:G6C9L=DH:I:HI>BDCN>HCDIEG:8AJ9:97N
.>:CC6DCK:CI>DC!BBJC>I>:H#+G 6I,=:#>C<9DB6G<J:HI=6II=:G:6G:CD
:M8:EI>DC6A8>G8JBHI6C8:HL6GG6CI>C<I=:9:EDH>I>DCD;I=:H:8JGG:CIDG;DGB:G=><=
G6C@>C<
D;;>8>6AHJC9:GI=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C:;>GHI:HI67A>H=:9>C-C>I:9+I6I:HK%DG<6C
L=:G:I=:+JEG:B:DJGIGJA:9I=6II=:+:8G:I6GND;<G>8JAIJG:H=DJA9CDI7:8DBE:AA:9ID
I:HI>;NIDG:HE:8IWI=:>CI:<G>IND;I=:69B>C>HIG6I>K:EGD8:HHX-+
,=:DJGID;EE:6AH;DGI=:+:8DC9>G8J>I:HI67A>H=:9I=:G:A:K6CIHI6C96G9>C
$:9:GB6CK&0:EZID;(6G@H*:8G:6I>DC L=:G:>ID7H:GK:9I=6I8DJGIH=6K:ADC<=:A9
WI=6I6=><=
G6C@>C<<DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6AH=DJA9CDIUU67H:CI:M8:EI>DC6A8>G8JBHI6C8:HUU7:
9:EDH:9DG86AA:9IDI:HI>;NG:<6G9>C<I=:G:6HDCH;DGI6@>C<D;;>8>6A68I>DC9 9
>G W ><=

G6C@>C<D;;>8>6AH XI=:8DJGI:MEA6>C:9 W6G:<:C:G6AANH=>:A9:9;GDB
9:EDH>I>DCH7:86JH:I=:N=6K:<G:6I:G9JI>:H6C9I>B:8DCHIG6>CIHI=6CDI=:GL>IC:HH:H!;8DJGIH
9>9CDIA>B>II=:H:9:EDH>I>DCH HJ8=D;;>8>6AHLDJA9HE:C96C>CDG9>C6I:6BDJCID;I>B:I:C9>C<
IDE:C9>C<A>I><6I>DCX!9>CI:GC6AFJDI6I>DCB6G@H6C98>I6I>DCDB>II:9"D>C>C<H:K:G6ADI=:G
8DJGIHD;6EE:6AH I=:>G8J>I=:A9I=6IWID9:EDH:6=><=
G6C@>C<<DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6A 6E6GIN
BJHI9:BDCHIG6I::M8:EI>DC6A8>G8JBHI6C8:H?JHI>;N>C<I=:9:EDH>I>DCU;DG:M6BEA: I=6II=:

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 25 of 40
D;;>8>6A=6HJC>FJ:;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:A6I:9IDI=:A>I><6I:98A6>BHDGI=6II=:C:8:HH6GN
>C;DGB6I>DC86CCDI7:D7I6>C:9I=GDJ<=DI=:G A:HH7JG9:CHDB:DG>CIGJH>K:B:6CHX!9,=:
DJGI6AHDI6@:H>CID688DJCIL=:I=:G(A6>CI>;;HW>9:CI>;NL>I=E6GI>8JA6G>INI=:>C;DGB6I>DCI=:N
C::923X!9
W/=:I=:G6CD;;>8>6A>H6=><=
G6C@>C<<DK:GCB:CID;;>8:G>H9:I:GB>C:9DC686H:
7N
86H:76H>HX%8&6B::K%6HH68=JH:IIH &D

+ /$ 6I
%6HH%6N >CI:GC6AFJDI6I>DCB6G@HDB>II:9W,=:9D8IG>C:>H8:GI6>CANCDIA>B>I:9ID
8DCHI>IJI>DC6AD;;>8:GHD;I=:-C>I:9+I6I:HX!9,=>H9:H><C6I>DC=6H<:C:G6AANDCAN7::C6EEA>:9
=DL:K:G ID<DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6AHL=D6G:6II=:W6E:MXD;I=:>GDG<6C>O6I>DC+:8M8=
DBBZCKDBBDC/6NH%:6CHD;I=:-+ DJH:D;*:EG:H:CI6I>K:H +JEE9
+&0 H::D<6CK>IND;DHIDC 9 HI>G
DHIDCB6NDG>H6=><=
G6C@>C<<DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6A!CG:-C>I:9+I6I:H 9
I=>GIIDGC:N:C:G6A6C9:EJINIIDGC:N:C:G6A6G:=><=
G6C@>C<<DK:GCB:CI
D;;>8>6AH
W,=>H9D8IG>C:6EEA>:HID7DI=8JGG:CI6C9;DGB:G=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6AHX%DG>6=K6C@
D;=>C6$I9 +JEE9 +&0 W+J7?:8I>C<;DGB:GD;;>8>6AH9:8>H>DC
B6@>C<EGD8:HH:HID?J9>8>6AH8GJI>CN6C9I=:EDHH>7>A>IND;8DCI>CJ:9E6GI>8>E6I>DC>CA6LHJ>IH
N:6GH6;I:GA:6K>C<EJ7A>8D;;>8:LDJA9H:GK:6H6H><C>;>86CI9:I:GG:CIIDFJ6A>;>:986C9>96I:H;DG
EJ7A>8H:GK>8:XI=:G:;DG: ID=6K:B:6C>C< WI=:EGDI:8I>DCHBJHI8DCI>CJ:JEDCI=:D;;>8>6AZH
9:E6GIJG:;GDBEJ7A>8H:GK>8:X-C>I:9+I6I:HK/6A

%6GI+IDG:H &D
.
"(%
/$ 6I%9%6G JI W263AI=DJ<=I=:9D8IG>C:6EEA>:HID;DGB:G
D;;>8>6AH I=:;68II=6II=:N6G:CDI8JGG:CI=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6AH>H6;68IDGL=:C8DCH>9:G>C<

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 26 of 40
L=:I=:GI=:>C;DGB6I>DC86C7:D7I6>C:9I=GDJ<=A:HH7JG9:CHDB:B:6CH6C9L=:I=:GI=:
9:EDH>I>DCL>AA>CI:G;:G:L>I=I=:D;;>8>6AZH<DK:GCB:CI9JI>:HX%DG>6= +JEE96I
,=:DJGIL>AA6AHD6EEANI=>H9D8IG>C:ID;DG:><CB>C>HI:GHH:GK>C<>CG6C@H:FJ>K6A:CIID
=><=
A:K:A-+<DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6AH,=:>G8J>I >C6?JG>H9>8I>DC6A6C6ANH>HJC9:GI=:
DG:><C+DK:G:><C!BBJC>I>:H8I ;DJC9;DG:><CB>C>HI:GHID7:I=::FJ>K6A:CID;-+867>C:I
A:K:AD;;>8>6AH;DGI=:EJGEDH:HD;I=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6AH9D8IG>C:!CG:(6E6C9G:DJ 9
>GW(G>C8>EA:HD;8DB>IN9>8I6I:I=6IL:688DG9I=:H6B:G:HE:8IID
;DG:><CD;;>8>6AH6HL:9DIDDJGDLCXW,=JH 67H:CIHDB:H=DL>C<D;C::9;DGDG6AI:HI>BDCN
;GDBI=:%>C>HI:GH XI=:>G8J>I;DJC9I=6II=:W9>HIG>8I8DJGI:GG:9>C6JI=DG>O>C<I=:>G
9:EDH>I>DCHX!9
::63-+>398>9!6+38>300=G!<9:9=/./:98/8>=

?<</8> 003-3+6=
+ $2/352,.?6<+27+86$?.+3=
+6J9>G67>68A6>BHI=6IA+J96>H>H68JGG:CI%>C>HI:GD;+I6I: I=::FJ>K6A:CID;6
867>C:I
A:K:AD;;>8>6A#+G 6I#+M 6IA+J96>H>H8JGG:CIANI=:>B6BD;I=:
G:6I%DHFJ:D;%:886!9(A6>CI>;;HH::@ID9:EDH:A+J96>H7:86JH:=:6II:C9:9I=:G6C9
'E:C>C<D;I=:#>C<6=69%DHFJ:W#%XDCI=:DG9:GHD;I=:#>C<6C9K>H>I:9I=:-C>I:9
+I6I:H>C 6C9 =DHI:97NA+DL6>A:B6C9HEDCHDG:97N(G>C8:79:A6O>O(AH
/>IC:HH$>HI 6I!C =:K>H>I:9I=:#%L>I=A+DL6>A:B6C9B:IL>I=A,=JB6>GN
6C9A,=JB6>GNHJ7B>II:96G:FJ:HI;DG;JC9>C<IDA+J96>H;DGI=:#%ZH!B6B L=DL6HA
,=JB6>GN=>BH:A;!9
(A6>CI>;;H=6K:CDI9:BDCHIG6I:9I=6IA+J96>HW=6HJC>FJ:;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:A6I:9
IDI=:A>I><6I:98A6>BHDGI=6II=:C:8:HH6GN>C;DGB6I>DC86CCDI7:D7I6>C:9I=GDJ<=DI=:G A:HH

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 27 of 40
7JG9:CHDB:DG>CIGJH>K:B:6CHX$:9:GB6C 96I &:>I=:GA+J96>HZHK>H>IIDI=:
#%CDGA,=JB6>GNZHG:FJ:HI;DG;JC9>C<;DGI=:#%ZH!B6B=6K:6CN7:6G>C<DCL=:I=:G
A,=JB6>GNDGA6NDJB>WIDD@68I>DCH>C 6II=:9>G:8I>DCD;BDG:H:C>DG+6J9>
D;;>8>6AH IDEGDK>9:6HH>HI6C8:IDXI=:=>?68@:GHX&D 6I,DI=::MI:CII=6IA
,=JB6>GNZH;JC9>C<G:FJ:HI>HG:A:K6CI6I6AA I=6I>C;DGB6I>DC86C7:D7I6>C:9I=GDJ<=A:HH
7JG9:CHDB:B:6CH+:: :< *6NBDC9K>IND;&:L0DG@ &D

.
$,++$
/$ 6I+&0;>C9>C<9:EDH>I>DCHD;;DGB:G(DA>8:DBB>HH>DC:GHID7:
>BEGDE:GL=:G:I=:H6B:>C;DGB6I>DC8DJA97:D7I6>C:97N9:EDH>C<ADL:GA:K:AHJE:GK>HDGH
, $+6/238,.?6+D3D6=2$2+352
+6J9>G67>68A6>BHI=6IAH=
+=6>@=>H68JGG:CI%>C>HI:GD;+I6I: I=::FJ>K6A:CID;6
867>C:I
A:K:AEDH>I>DC#+G 6I#+M 6IAH=
+=6>@=L6HI=:%>C>HI:GD;
!HA6B>8;;6>GHW%'!X9JG>C<I=:G:A:K6CII>B:E:G>D9(A6>CI>;;H6AA:<:I=6I=:6EEGDK:9I=:
:MI:CH>DCD;A,=JB6>GNZH6HH><CB:CIIDI=:#%6C9A,=JB6>GNZHEGDBDI>DC>C 6C9
I=6I=:L6HG:HEDCH>7A:;DG>BEA:B:CI>C<I=:EG:
+6J9>EG68I>8:D;D7I6>C>C<9>EADB6I>8
HI6IJH;DG%'!ZHCDC
9>EADB6I>8G:A><>DJHD;;>8>6AH>CH>9:I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H >C8AJ9>C<A
,=JB6>GN(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I(A6>CI>;;H6AA:<:I=6IAH=

+=6>@==6H@CDLA:9<:D;I=:
:A:B:CIHL>I=>CI=:%'!6C9DI=:G+6J9><DK:GCB:CI6<:C8>:HI=6IHJEEDGI:96A)6:967:;DG:
6C9=:IDD@6C68I>K:GDA:>CI=:EDHIG:K>:LD;A,=JB6>GNZHGDA:>CEGDK>9>C<
HJEEDGIIDI=:=>?68@:GH!9>C6AAN (A6>CI>;;H6AHD6AA:<:I=6IAH=

+=6>@==:AE:9;DJC9I=:A
6G6B6>C!HA6B>8DJC96I>DC!9
(A6>CI>;;HZ:M=>7>IHHJEEDGII=:>G8DCI:CI>DCI=6IAH=
+=6>@=B6N=6K:JC>FJ:;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 28 of 40
H%>C>HI:GD;!HA6B>8;;6>GH I=:=:69D;I=:DG<6C>O6I>DCBDHI
9>G:8IAN>BEA>86I:9>C(A6>CI>;;HZ6AA:<6I>DCH >I>HEDHH>7A:I=6IDCANAH=
+=6>@=W86CHE:6@IDX
WI=:G6I>;>86I>DCD;2,=JB6>GNZH38DC9J8IX%6N GZ<,G

!I>HA>@:AN 6H
HJ8= I=6IAH=
+=6>@=W=6HJC>FJ:;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:A6I:9IDI=:A>I><6I:98A6>BHDGI=6I
I=:C:8:HH6GN>C;DGB6I>DC86CCDI7:D7I6>C:9I=GDJ<=DI=:G A:HH7JG9:CHDB:DG>CIGJH>K:
B:6CHX$:9:GB6C 96I ,=:DJGI688DG9>C<AN;>C9HI=6IAH=

+=6>@=>HCDI
EGDI:8I:97NI=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6AHEG>K>A:<:
- (+63.?52+<3+8.$++.6+,<//8
J@=6G>>H68JGG:CIB76HH69DG;DG+6J9>G67>6 6C9A"67G::C>H68JGG:CIDCHJA
:C:G6A;DG+6J9>G67>6#+M 6I(A6>CI>;;H>9:CI>;NJ@=6G>6H6;DGB:GK>H6:BEADN::
L=DBA,=JB6>GNLDG@:9L>I=DC6G:<JA6G76H>H6II=:DCHJA6I: 6C9A"67G::C6HHDB:DC:
L=DBA,=JB6>GNLDG@:98ADH:ANL>I=6II=:DCHJA6I:6C9
(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I !C$:9:GB6C I=:DJGI;DJC9I=6I(A6>CI>;;HW9>9CDI
>9:CI>;NL>I=E6GI>8JA6G>INI=:>C;DGB6I>DCI=:NC::9:9 CDG9>9I=:N8DCI:C9I=6I2I=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6AH3=69;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:67DJII=:A>I><6I:98A6>BHDGI=6II=:G:A:K6CI
>C;DGB6I>DC8DJA9CDI7:D7I6>C:9:AH:L=:G:X$:9:GB6C 96I 'CI=:G:8DG97:;DG:
I=:DJGI (A6>CI>;;H=6K:CDIEG:H:CI:9:M8:EI>DC6A8>G8JBHI6C8:HID?JHI>;NI=:9:EDH>I>DCHD;
J@=6G>DGA"67G::C

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 29 of 40
. 27/.38,.?6+D3D6"+>>+8
+6J9>G67>68A6>BHI=6IA)6II6C>H8JGG:CIAN6%>C>HI:GD;+I6I:#+M 6I
(A6>CI>;;H8A6>BI=6IA)6II6C 6HI=:;DGB:GB76HHN=>:;D;+I6;; E:GHDC6AANDK:GH6LBJ8=
D;A"6GG6=ZH96N
ID
96NLDG@ 6C9=6HE:GHDC6A@CDLA:9<:D;A"6GG6=ZHGDA:G:<6G9>C<I=:
#% A,=JB6>GN 6C9A%J=6CC6(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I(A6>CI>;;H6AHD8A6>BI=6IA)6II6C
L6HI=:8DC9J>I>CH>9:I=:B76HHN;DG8DBBJC>86I>DCHL>I=(G>C8:79JA6O>OG:<6G9>C<
9>G:8I>DCH6C9;JC9>C<;DGI=:#%6C9A,=JB6>GN!9(A6>CI>;;H

,=:H::M=>7>IHH=DLI=6IA)6II6CA>@:AN=6HJC>FJ:;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<HDB:D;A"6GG6=6C9A,=JB6>GNZHG:A:K6CIEG:
68I>K>I>:H6C9
6CNEDHI
G6I>;>86I>DCD;I=:>G8DC9J8I,=>H9>H8DK:GN>HE6GI>8JA6GANG:A:K6CI7:86JH:+6J9>
G67>6ZH9D8JB:CI9>H8DK:GNG:<6G9>C<A"6GG6=EGD9J8:9CD9D8JB:CIH;GDBI=:N:6G
+::(AH+:8DC9%DI>DCIDDBE:A 6I:9"6CJ6GN 6I/=:G:68DJGI;>C9HI=6II=:
G:A:K6CI<DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6AW=6HJC>FJ:;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:A6I:9IDI=:A>I><6I:98A6>BH >I
C::9CDIB6@:6H:E6G6I:;>C9>C<I=6II=:C:8:HH6GN>C;DGB6I>DC86CCDI7:D7I6>C:9I=GDJ<=
DI=:G A:HH7JG9:CHDB:DG>CIGJH>K:B:6CHX&:L0DG@K-C>I:9+I6I:H:EZID;DBB:G8:
+JEE9 FJDI>C<$:9:GB6C 96I >CI:GC6AFJDI6I>DCB6G@HDB>II:9

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 30 of 40
,=:DJGI;>C9HI=6IA)6II6C>HCDIEGDI:8I:9JC9:GI=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C:A
)6II6CZH9:EDH>I>DC =DL:K:G H=DJA97:A>B>I:9IDIDE>8H67DJIL=>8=I=:DJGI=6H;DJC9
67DK: I=6I=:9D:HCDIG:I6>CG:H>9J6A>BBJC>INJC9:GI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH
9<7/< 003-3+6=
/=:C6EEAN>C<I=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C:ID;DGB:GD;;>8>6AH I=:DJGI688DG9H
A:HHL:><=IDL=:I=:GI=:>C;DGB6I>DC86C7:D7I6>C:9I=GDJ<=A:HH7JG9:CHDB:B:6CH6C9
L=:I=:GI=:9:EDH>I>DCL>AA>CI:G;:G:L>I=I=:D;;>8>6AZH<DK:GCB:CI9JI>:H+::%DG>6=
+JEE96I ,=:DJGI6AHD;>C9HI=:EDA>8NG:6HDC>C<7:=>C9I=:9D8IG>C: >:I=6I
E6GI>8>E6I>DC>CA6LHJ>IHN:6GH6;I:GA:6K>C<EJ7A>8D;;>8:LDJA9H:GK:6H6H><C>;>86CI9:I:GG:CIID
FJ6A>;>:986C9>96I:H;DGEJ7A>8H:GK>8: H::/6A
%6GI+IDG:H /$ 6I ID86GGN
A:HHL:><=I>CI=:8DCI:MID;;DG:><C<DK:GCB:CIH L=:G:I=:DJGI=6HA>IIA:>CH><=I>CIDI=:
EGD8:HH:H6C9>C8:CI>K:H7:=>C9:CIGN>CIDEJ7A>8H:GK>8:/=:G: 6H=:G: I=:G:>H6AHDCD
A>@:A>=DD9D;H:G>6A67JH>K:A>I><6I>DC I=:DJGI;>C9HI=6I;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:A6I:9IDI=:
A>I><6I:98A6>BHID7:HJ;;>8>:CI 6C9$:9:GB6CZHW:M8:EI>DC6A8>G8JBHI6C8:HXI:HIID7:B:I
L=:G:I=:A>I><6I:98A6>BH6G:D;=><=EJ7A>8>CI:G:HI6C9I=:G:6G:A>B>I:9DI=:GDEEDGIJC>I>:H;DG
9>H8DK:GN
,=:DJGIJC9:GHI6C9HI=6IL>I=I=::M8:EI>DCD;A>>C79JAG6=B6CA#=6A6; I=:
;DAADL>C<L>IC:HH:H=6K:CDI>C;DGB:9I=:#>C<9DBL=:I=:GI=:NL>AAKDAJCI6G>ANH>I;DG6
9:EDH>I>DC88DG9>C<AN I=:DJGIL>AA6HH:HHL=:I=:GI=:;DAADL>C<L>IC:HH:HEGDE:GAN;6AA
JC9:GI=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C: L>I=I=:JC9:GHI6C9>C<I=6II=:#>C<9DBL>AA6H@6CN
L>IC:HH:HL=DBI=:DJGI;>C9HIDCDI7:EGDI:8I:97NI=6I9D8IG>C:IDKDAJCI6G>ANH>I;DG6
9:EDH>I>DC,=:DJGIL>AACDI6HH:HHL=:I=:GA#=6A6;ZHI:HI>BDCN>H76GG:9JC9:GI=:=><=

/=>A:AL69=6H6AHDCDI>C;DGB:9I=:#>C<9DBL=:I=:G=:L>AAH>I;DG9:EDH>I>DCKDAJCI6G>AN I=:
DJGIDG9:GHI=6I=:7:EGD9J8:9;DG9:EDH>I>DCEJGHJ6CIIDI=:6C6ANH>H67DK:

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 31 of 40
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C: 7:86JH:A#=6A6;=6H6;;>GB6I>K:ANG:;JH:9IDKDAJCI6G>ANI:HI>;N 6C9
I=:DJGI9>9CDI;>C9 67DK: I=6I#=6A6;B6N7:8DBE:AA:9ID6EE:6G6H6B6C6<>C<6<:CI
HJ7?:8IID9:EDH>I>DC7NCDI>8:+::#+M 6IDG6CNL>IC:HH7:ADLL=DBI=:DJGI
;>C9H>HCDIEGDI:8I:97NI=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C:7JIL=DH:I:HI>BDCNB6N7:EGDI:8I:9
7NI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH I=:#>C<9DBH=DJA9G:FJ:HII=:>G9:EDH>I>DCKDAJCI6G>AN6C96CN
FJ:HI>DC>C<H=DJA9EGD8::9>C688DG96C8:L>I=I=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH<J>9:A>C:HH:IDJI67DK:
+ !<38-/+8.+<38$?6>+838,.?6+D3D6$+?.
(A6>CI>;;H6G<J:I=6I(G>C8:6C96G I=:;DGB:G+6J9>B76HH69DG DK:GH6LI=:LDG@D;
A,=JB6>GN6C9A"6GG6=6C9=6HJC>FJ:E:GHDC6A@CDLA:9<:D;I=:GDA:HI=:NL:G:6HH><C:9
7NI=:#>C<9DB(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6IH::
(A6>CI>;;H6AHD6AA:<:I=6I(G>C8:6C96G=6H9>G:8IE:GHDC6A
@CDLA:9<:67DJII=:9:8>H>DCD;I=:%>C>HIGND;DG:><C;;6>GHIDEGDK>9:9>EADB6I>88DK:G;DG
EGDE6<6IDGHLDG@>C<>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H(AH/>IC:HH6I

/=>A:+6J9>G67>6E:GHJ6H>K:AN6G<J:HI=6II=:H:9D8JB:CIH9DCDIHJ<<:HII=6I(G>C8:
6C96GDK:GH6LI=:LDG@D;A"6GG6=6C9A,=JB6>GN #+99:C9JB6I
(A6>CI>;;HZ
:M=>7>IHCDC:I=:A:HH>C9>86I:I=6I(G>C8:6C96GA>@:AN=6H;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<: 6HI=:
B76HH69DG6II=:I>B:I=:H::K:CIHIG6CHE>G:9 >CIDI=:GDA:I=6IA,=JB6>GNL6H6HH><C:97N
I=:#>C<9DB6C9I=:9>EADB6I>88DK:GEGDK>9:9IDI=:EGDE6<6IDGH88DG9>C<AN (A6>CI>;;H=6K:

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 32 of 40
B:II=:>GG:FJ>G:97JG9:CJC9:G$:9:GB6C6H6EEA>:97NI=:DJGIID;DGB:GD;;>8>6AHIDH=DL
W:M8:EI>DC6A8>G8JBHI6C8:HX?JHI>;N>C<(G>C8:6C96GZH9:EDH>I>DC
, ,.?66+26A+.
(A6>CI>;;H6AA:<:I=6IAL69 I=:;DGB:G:EJINDCHJA>C$DHC<:A:H L6HI=:
G:EG:H:CI6I>K:D;I=:!HA6B>8;;6>GH9:E6GIB:CI6II=:DCHJA6I:6C9G:EDGI:9IDA"6GG6=(AH
/>IC:HH$>HI 6I(A6>CI>;;H6AHD6AA:<:I=6IAL69>H6L6G:D;A6NDJB>ZHHI6IJH6II=:
DCHJA6I:6C9A6NDJB>ZHK>H>IH6C9E=DC:86AAH>C"6CJ6GN
:7GJ6GN !9
(A6>CI>;;H;JGI=:G
6AA:<:I=6I
AL69 6C9:EJINDJCH:A A>@:AN=6H;>GHI

=6C9@CDLA:9<:
G:<6G9>C<A6NDJB>ZHHI6IJH6C9GDA: H6I>H;N>C<I=:$:9:GB6CI:HI6H6EEA>:97NI=:DJGIID
;DGB:GD;;>8>6AHDGI=:E:GB>HH>7A:8DCIDJGHD;AL69ZH9:EDH>I>DCJC9:GI=:.>:CC6
DCK:CI>DCH H::I=:6C6ANH>H6IE6<: HJEG6
- 92+77/.6$+669?7
A+6AADJB>HI=:;DGB:GDCHJA:C:G6A>C$DHC<:A:HA,=JB6>GNIDA9I=6I
DBB>HH>DCI=6I=:G:EDGI:99>G:8IANIDA+6AADJB+::(AHM 6IA+6AADJBG:8:>K:9
6C99>HIG>7JI:9I=:#>C<9DBZH;JC9>C<;DGI=:#%6C9EGDK>9:9G:<JA6GG:EDGIH67DJII=:#%
ID(G>C8:79JA6O>O(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I(AHMH H=DL>C<I=6IA+6AADJBH:CI6

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 33 of 40
E:GHDC6A8=:8@IDI=:#%>CI=:6BDJCID; WID9:A>K:GI=::BEADN::H688GJ:9H6A6G>:H
JCI>AI=:6BDJCI>HG:8:>K:9;GDBI=:D;;>8:XD;(G>C8:79JA6O>O DCI=:96NI=6IA6NDJB>
K>H>I:9I=:DCHJA6I:6C9I=:96N7:;DG:A6NDJB>;>GHIB:IL>I=I=:=>?68@:GH
+6J9>
G67>68DCI:C9HI=6II=:DJGI=6HGJA:9I=:;JC9>C<D;I=:%DHFJ:ID7:W>GG:A:K6CIX#+
99:C9JB 6IJII=:DJGIDCANHI6I:9I=6IWI=::K>9:C8:2G:<6G9>C<(G>C8:79JA6O>OZH
>CKDAK:B:CI>CI=:%DHFJ:ZH;JC9>C<3>HIDDI6C<:CI>6AID(A6>CI>;;HZ6AA:<6I>DCHID

X"JAN 'E>C>DC'G9:GDC(A6>CI>;;HZ%DI>DCIDDBE:A
W%,'G9:GX 6I:BE=6H>H699:9,=:DJGI9>9CDI;>C9I=::K>9:C8:ID7:>GG:A:K6CI
:CI>G:AN
(A6>CI>;;H6AHD8A6>BI=6IA+6AADJBE:GHDC6AANB:IL>I=I=:+I6I::E6GIB:CI>C'8ID7:G
ID9>H8JHHA,=JB6>GNZHHI6IJH6II=:DCHJA6I:6C9A,=JB6>GNZHK>DA6I>DCD;+I6I:
:E6GIB:CIGJA:H76GG>C<=>B;GDB9G>K>C<6EG>K6I:K:=>8A:L>I=DJI9>EADB6I>8A>8:CH:EA6I:H
(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I(AHM 6I+I6I: 6C9+I6I: '8ID7:G A:II:G;GDBI=:+I6I:
:E6GIB:CIIDA+6AADJB>CFJ>G>C<67DJIA,=JB6>GNZHEDH>I>DC(A6>CI>;;HZ8DC8:GCH
G:<6G9>C<I=:I>B>C<D;A+6AADJBZHE:GHDC6AE6NB:CIIDI=:#% 6C9A+6AADJBZHE:GHDC6A
>CKDAK:B:CIL>I=I=:+I6I::E6GIB:CIG:<6G9>C<A,=JB6>GN>C HJ<<:HII=6IA+6AADJB
=6HJC>FJ:;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:HJ;;>8>:CIIDH6I>H;NI=:$:9:GB6CI:HI6H6EEA>:9ID;DGB:G
D;;>8>6AH
. !<38-/,.?6+D3D38+2+.38,.?6+D3D
(G>C8:79JA6O>O>H6;DGB:G%>C>HI:GD;+I6I:L=DL6H 688DG9>C<ID(A6>CI>;;H >CI:<G6AAN
>CKDAK:9>CI=:8G:6I>DC ;JC9>C< B6C6<:B:CI 6C9DE:G6I>DCD;I=:#%(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I
(A6>CI>;;H6AHD6AA:<:I=6I

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 34 of 40
,=:DJGI=6H;DJC9
I=6IW(A6>CI>;;H6G::CI>IA:9IDG:8DG9H8DC8:GC>C<,=JB6>GNZH:BEADNB:CI6C98DBE:CH6I>DC
I=:+6J9><DK:GCB:CIX%,'G9:G 6I,=:DJGI=6H6AHD<G6CI:9(A6>CI>;;HZBDI>DCID
8DBE:AI=:#>C<9DBIDWEGD9J8:9D8JB:CIH;GDBI=:<DK:GCB:CI';;>8:HD;(G>C8:79JA6O>O
G:<6G9>C<=>H6HH><CB:CIH6C98DBE:CH6I>DCD;,=JB6>GNX%6N 'E>C>DC'G9:G 6I
(A6>CI>;;HB6ND7I6>C9D8JB:CIHG:A:K6CIIDI=>H>HHJ:;GDBI=:#>C<9DBJI6H(G>C8:
79JA6O>O>H6;DGB:GD;;>8>6A I=:DJGI<>K:HA:HHL:><=IIDL=:I=:GI=:>C;DGB6I>DC86C7:
D7I6>C:9I=GDJ<=A:HH7JG9:CHDB:B:6CH(A6>CI>;;H=6K:I=:G:;DG:H6I>H;>:9I=:>G$:9:GB6C
7JG9:C7NH=DL>C<I=6I(G>C8:79JA6O>OA>@:AN=6H;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<I=:8DCI:MI
D;I=>HIG6CH;:GD;;JC9HID,=JB6>GN
/ +DC/.,<+2376+DC/.
A%6ON:9L6HI=:JAIJG6AII68=P>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H(A6>CI>;;H6AA:<:I=6I6I(G>C8:
6C96GZHG:FJ:HI A%6ON:9L6H6HH><C:96;I:GIDG:HEDC9IDFJ:HI>DCH67DJIA
6NDJB>ZHGDA:>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H 6C9I=6IA%6ON:9=6H@CDLA:9<:DCI=6IHJ7?:8I(AH
/>IC:HH$>HI 6I
(A6>CI>;;H;JGI=:G6AA:<:I=6IA%6ON:9HJE:GK>H:9
I=:+6J9>+IJ9:CIZHAJ7HHEDCHDG:97NI=:+6J9><DK:GCB:CII=6IL:G:G:<JA6GAN6II:C9:97NA
,=JB6>GN6C9A6NDJB>6C9L:G:JH:97NI=:+6J9><DK:GCB:CIIDBDC>IDGI=:68I>K>I>:HD;
>IH8>I>O:CH>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H!9
8JAIJG6A6II68=P>HCDI
6867>C:I
A:K:AD;;>8>6AL>I=H>B>A6GG6C@ID6%>C>HI:GD;+I6I:88DG9>C<AN I=:DJGI9D:HCDI
;>C9I=6II=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C:6EEGDEG>6I:AN6EEA>:HIDA%6ON:9!C6CN:K:CI

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 35 of 40
(A6>CI>;;HZ:K>9:C8:HJ<<:HIHI=6I%6ON:9A>@:AN=6H;>GHI
=6C9@CDLA:9<:G:<6G9>C<6NDJB>ZH
GDA:>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H
0 ,.?<<+27+838?<7+86$2+2<3+8.92+77/.38+3D
6$2+<30

(A6>CI>;;H6AA:<:I=6IA+=6=G>6C9A+=6G>;L:G:B:B7:GHD;I=:*DN6ADBB>II::
:HI67A>H=:96;I:GID>CK:HI><6I:6C9:HI67A>H=8DCIGDAHDK:GI=:H:8DC9B:CID;E:GHDCC:A
;GDBI=:%'!IDB76HH>:H6C9DCHJA6I:H;DAADL>C<6AA:<6I>DCHD;HJEEDGIEGDK>9:97N
%'!E:GHDCC:A;DG6A)6:966C9DI=:GI:GGDG<GDJEH(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I

,=:DJGI=6H
;DJC9I=:*DN6ADBB>II::ZH B::I>C<ID7:G:A:K6CIIDI=:?JG>H9>8I>DC6A>CFJ>GN7:86JH:
I=:DBB>II::W>CKDAK:H+6J9>G67>6ZHG:K>:L6C9EDI:CI>6AG6I>;>86I>DCD;,=JB6>GNZHLDG@X
%,'G9:G 6I!CA><=ID;I=:DJGIZHEG>DG;>C9>C<H 6C9I=:G:;JH6AD;DI=:GB:B7:GHD;I=:
*DN6ADBB>II::IDH>I;DG9:EDH>I>DC H::#+M 6I I=:DJGI;>C9HI=6IA+=6=G>6C9A
+=6G>;YHI:HI>BDCN>HCDIEG:8AJ9:97NI=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C:
' /:9=3>398=908.3@3.?+6=/C98.>2/$-9:/90?<3=.3->398+63=-9@/<C
/:9=3>398=908.3@3.?+6=,9?>(297>2/9?<>/83/.9-?7/8>3=-9@/<C
+ ./66$+.2+8?>+/,6$?.+3<C+8.$2+<30+>3523
+6J9>G67>68DCI:C9HI=6II=:9:EDH>I>DCHD;A+69=6C A+J96>GN 6C96I>@=>6G:
EG:8AJ9:97NI=:DJGIZHEG>DGGJA>C<H9:CN>C<9D8JB:CI9>H8DK:GN&D 6I"6CJ6GN
'G9:G 6I
*:<6G9>C<A+69=6C6C9A+J96>GN I=:DJGI;DJC9I=6IW2<3>K:CI=:DJGIZH
D7A><6I>DCID8DC9J8I?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GNC6GGDLAN(A6>CI>;;HZHJEEA:B:CI6A9D8JB:CI
G:FJ:HIHG:<6G9>C<+69=6C6C9+J96>GN6G:>C6EEGDEG>6I:X"6CJ6GN'G9:G 6I *:<6G9>C<
6I>@=> I=:DJGI;DJC9I=6I>ILDJA9WCDIDG9:G7GD69 JCI6>ADG:99>H8DK:GN>CI=:H:
8>G8JBHI6C8:HX!9 6I!CI=:DJGIZH%6N 'E>C>DC'G9:GW%6N'G9:GX
8DCH>9:G>C<(A6>CI>;;HZBDI>DC;DGG:8DCH>9:G6I>DCG:<6G9>C<I=:>G9D8JB:CI9>H8DK:GNG:FJ:HIH

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 36 of 40
I=:DJGI6<6>C;DJC9I=6IW(A6>CI>;;H=6K:CDI:HI67A>H=:9I=6I9>H8DK:GNG:<6G9>C<+69=6C6C9
+J96>GN>HL>I=>CI=:A>B>IHD;I=>HDJGIZH?JG>H9>8I>DC6A>CFJ>GN X7JICDI:9I=6IWI=>H=DA9>C<
9D:HCDIB:6CI=6I(A6>CI>;;HB6NCDI6H@FJ:HI>DCH9JG>C<>IHJE8DB>C<9:EDH>I>DCHD;+6J9>
<DK:GCB:CID;;>8>6AHG:<6G9>C<+69=6C6C9+J96>GNX%6N'G9:G 6I
,=:;68II=6II=:DJGI;DJC9I=6I(A6>CI>;;H=69CDI:HI67A>H=:9I=6I9D8JB:CI9>H8DK:GN
L6HL6GG6CI:9G:<6G9>C<I=:H:D;;>8>6AH9D:HCDIB:6CI=6II=:DJGIEG:8AJ9:9I=:>G9:EDH>I>DCH
,=:9:EDH>I>DCHD;DI=:G>C9>K>9J6AHG:<6G9>C<A+69=6C6C9A+J96>GN HJ8=6H(G>C8:
%D=6BB:9>C+6AB6C>C%D=6BB:9A+6J9 6G:6AHDCDIEG:8AJ9:97NI=>HDJGIZHEG>DG
GJA>C<H(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I,=:HI6C96G9D;G:A:K6C8:;DG9:EDH>I>DCHLDJA97:>BEDHH>7AN
=><=>;DCANI=DH:67DJIL=DB7GD699D8JB:CI9>H8DK:GNL6HL6GG6CI:98DJA97:9:EDH:9,=:
DJGII=:G:;DG:&!+I=:#>C<9DBZHBDI>DCG:<6G9>C<A+69=6C A+J96>GN 6I>@=> 6C9
A+6J9
, !<9:+1+>9<=38+6309<83+0<97

(A6>CI>;;H6AHDH::@ID9:EDH:W263CNEGDE6<6IDG:BEADN:97N+6J9>G67>6L=DLDG@:9
>CH>9:I=:+I6I:D;6A>;DGC>6;GDB
XG:<6G9>C< 7GD69AN I=:>GH8DE:D;:BEADNB:CI
8=6>CD;8DBB6C9 96N
ID
96NLDG@ 6C9DK:GH><=ID;,=JB6>GN 6NDJB> %J=6CC6 +69=6C
+J96>GN 6C96I>@=> 6HL:AA6H>CKDAK:B:CIW>CI=:EADIIDEGDK>9:HJ7HI6CI>6A6HH>HI6C8:IDI=:
=>?68@:GHX(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I+6J9>G67>68DCI:C9HI=6II=:H:EGDEDH:99:EDH>I>DCH
6G:EG:8AJ9:97NI=:DJGIZHDE>C>DCH9:CN>C<9>H8DK:GNG:A6I>C<ID,=JB6>GNZHHJE:GK>H>DCD;
6A>;DGC>6EGDE6<6IDGH#+G 6I %,'G9:G 6I

,=:DJGI86CCDI6HH:HH
(A6>CI>;;HZG:FJ:HI>CI=:67H:C8:D;6CN>C;DGB6I>DCG:<6G9>C<HE:8>;>8EGDE6<6IDGHL=DB
(A6>CI>;;HH::@ID9:EDH: 6C9I=:G:6HDCH(A6>CI>;;HH::@ID9:EDH:I=DH:>C9>K>9J6AH(A6>CI>;;H
6G:L:A8DB:ID>9:CI>;N6C9EG:H:CI>C9>K>9J6AEGDE6<6IDGHIDI=:DJGI;DGEGDEDH:99:EDH>I>DCH

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 37 of 40
'CI=:EG:H:CIG:8DG9 I=:DJGIG:6;;>GBH>IHDE>C>DCI=6I:K:C>;A,=JB6>GNB6N=6K:
HJE:GK>H:9+6J9>EGDE6<6IDGHLDG@>C<>C6A>;DGC>6 I=6IW9D:HCDIB:6CI=6I,=JB6>GN9>G:8I:9
I=6I>C9>K>9J6AID6>9I=:=>?68@:GH X6C99:C>:H(A6>CI>;;HZG:FJ:HIDCI=DH:<GDJC9H!9 6I

/:9=3>398=908.3@3.?+6=#/1+<.381!9=>
8@/=>31+>3@/+>/<3+6
+ E9627/.F+8.E+49<2+63.F+2+,3>2
+6J9>G67>66G<J:HI=6II=:9:EDH>I>DCHD;WDA=B:9X6C9W%6?DG#=6A>9X6G:
EG:8AJ9:97NI=:DJGIZHEG>DGGJA>C<H9:CN>C<9>H8DK:GND;EDHI
>CK:HI><6I>K:B6I:G>6A
>C8AJ9>C<>C;DGB6I>DC67DJII=:DBB>HH>DC>CI:GK>:LHD;A6NDJB>6C9A,=JB6>GN
#+G 6I (A6>CI>;;H6G<J:I=6IWDA=B:9X6C9W%6?DG#=6A>9 XL=D6II:C9:9I=:
DBB>HH>DC!CI:GK>:LHD;A6NDJB>6C9A,=JB6>GN G:HE:8I>K:AN BJHI7:9:EDH:9ID
8DC;>GBI=:HI6I:B:CIHA6NDJB>6C9A,=JB6>GNB69:9JG>C<I=:>G>CI:GK>:LH(DJC>6C
:8AS(A6>CI>;;H8A6>BI=6II=:G:EDGIHD;I=:>CI:GK>:LH8DCI6>CHI6I:B:CIHI=6I6G:
8DCIG69>8I:97NDI=:G9D8JB:CIHDGDI=:GL>IC:HHHI6I:B:CIH 6C9I=:#>C<9DB=6HG:;JH:9ID
EGD9J8:I=:IG6CH8G>EIHDGG:8DG9>C<HD;I=:>CI:GK>:LHID8DC;>GBI=:HI6I:B:CIHD;A6NDJB>
6C9A,=JB6>GN!9
,=:DJGIEG:K>DJHAN9:C>:9(A6>CI>;;HZG:FJ:HIH;DG+6J9>G67>6ZHWG:8DG9>C<H
IG6CH8G>EIH IG6CH8G>EI>DCH 6C9CDI:HXG:<6G9>C<I=:DBB>HH>DC>CI:GK>:LHD;A6NDJB>
6C9,=JB6>GN ;>C9>C<I=6I(A6>CI>;;HW=6K:6AG:69ND7I6>C:99:I6>A:9B:BDG6C96;GDBI=:
DBB>HH>DC X6C9I=:7JG9:CD;EGD9J8I>DC>H=><=7:86JH:W(A6>CI>;;HH::@688:HHID6;DG:><C
HDK:G:><CZH>CI:AA><:C8:;>A:HX%,'G9:G 6I

,=DH:8DC8:GCH6EEAN:FJ6AAN=:G: >;CDI
BDG:HD 7:86JH:(A6>CI>;;HH::@688:HHID6;DG:><CHDK:G:><CZH>CI:AA><:C8:D;;>8>6AHI=:BH:AK:H
L=DH:>9:CI>I>:H6G:EGDI:8I:9,=:DJGIG:>I:G6I:H>IH;>C9>C<I=6I(A6>CI>;;H=6K:6AG:69N

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 38 of 40
G:8:>K:99:I6>A:9B:BDG6C96;GDBI=:DBB>HH>DC 6C9(A6>CI>;;H86CG6>H:6CN
8DCIG69>8I>DCHIDA6NDJB>6C9A,=JB6>GNI=:BH:AK:H
, =+7+38$+?.6(+2,3+8.$++.38+8=26 7+<3
A/6=7> D;I=:%>C>HIGND;!CI:G>DG 6C9A'B6G> D;I=:(G:H>9:C8ND;:C:G6A
!CI:AA><:C8: L:G: 688DG9>C<ID(A6>CI>;;H B:B7:GHD;I=:*DN6ADBB>II::,DI=::MI:CII=6I
(A6>CI>;;HD7I6>C688:HHIDDI=:GB:B7:GHD;I=:*DN6ADBB>II:: HJ8=6HA+=6=G>6C9A
+=6G>; I=:DJGI;>C9HI=:7JG9:CD;I=:9:EDH>I>DCHD;A/6=7>6C9A'B6G>IDDJIL:><=I=:>G
K6AJ:JC9:G:9:G6A*JA:D;>K>A(GD8:9JG:76C9>CI:GC6I>DC6A8DB>INJI>;(A6>CI>;;H
9DCDI=6K:688:HHID6CNDI=:G*DN6ADBB>II::B:B7:GH I=:DJGI6JI=DG>O:HI=:9:EDH>I>DCH
D;A/6=7>6C9A'B6G>HDA:ANG:<6G9>C<I=:*DN6ADBB>II::DCI=:<GDJC9HI=6II=:>G
I:HI>BDCNG:<6G9>C<I=6I:MI:GC6A7D9N 6C9CDII=:LDG@D;I=:>GDLCB>C>HIG>:H >H:FJ>K6A:CIID
I=:EGD9J8I>DCD;9D8JB:CIH=:A97N 7JICDI8G:6I:97N 6;DG:><CHDK:G:><CZH>CI:AA><:C8:
6<:C8N+::&D 6I

' /:9=3>398=90E&8589A8F7:69C//=
6:+<63
(A6>CI>;;H8DCI:C9I=6I#6GA>>H68DCIG68IB6C6<:GL=D>BEA:B:CI:9I=:(ZH9:8>H>DCH
G:<6G9>C<A6NDJB>ZHH:8DC9B:CIH G:C:L6AH 6C9E6NH86A:(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I(A6>CI>;;H
;JGI=:G8DCI:C9I=6I#6GA>L6HI=:DCANE:GHDC>9:CI>;>:97N+6J9>G67>6>C>IH>CI:GGD<6IDG>:H6H
A6NDJB>ZHHJE:GK>HDG!9+6J9>G67>68DCI:C9HI=6I 76H:9DC6G:6HDC67A:>CK:HI><6I>DC
#6GA>L6HCDI6C:BEADN::D;+6J9>G67>6 6C9I=6I+6J9>G67>69D:HCDI=6K:8DCI68I
>C;DGB6I>DC;DG%G#6GA>#+M 6I,=:G:8DG9HJ<<:HIH =DL:K:G I=6I+6J9>G67>6ZH
8DC8AJH>DCHG:EG:H:CI>IH>CI:GEG:I6I>DCD;I=::K>9:C8: CDII=:G:HJAIHD;6EGDE:GAN8DC9J8I:9
>CK:HI><6I>DC

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 39 of 40
,=:#>C<9DB>H8DGG:8II=6I#6GA>H><C:969D8JB:CII=6I8A6>B:9I=6I=:L6H6
G:EG:H:CI6I>K:D;6AA6=K8D(AHM 6I JI6AA6=K8DZH=6>GB6CHJ7H:FJ:CIAN
;>A:96A:II:G8A6>B>C<I=6II=>HL6H>C688JG6I: 6C9I=6I#6GA>L6H>C;68I6C:BEADN::D;I=:
#>C<9DB!9 6I

,=:#>C<9DB8DCI:C9HI=6II=::BEADN::HDCI=:8DCIG68I;DG
L=>8=6AA6=K8DL6HI=:8DCIG68IDG6II=:I>B:L:G:E6>97N6AA6=K8D 8>I>C<(A6>CI>;;HZ
M=>7>I 6I 7JII=6I9D8JB:CI>H6(;DGBHI6I>C<I=6II=:E6NH86A:>HWE:GI=:
>CHIGJ8I>DCHD;>G:8IDG:C:G6A (X+6J9>G67>68A6>BH L>I=DJI:K>9:C8: I=6II=:(
W9>9CDIG:<6G9XI=:H:8DCIG68I:BEADN::HW6H(:BEADN::HX#+99:C9JB 6I
88DG9>C<AN I=:DJGIDG9:GHI=:#>C<9DBIDJC9:GI6@:699>I>DC6AHI:EHID9:I:GB>C:I=:
>9:CI>IND;#6GA>ZH:BEADN:G6C9>CFJ>G:L=:I=:G#6GA>L>AAH>I;DG9:EDH>I>DC
+3=+66?2+88+
(A6>CI>;;H8DCI:C9I=6IA%J=6CC6L6H6C:BEADN::6C9;G>:C9D;A,=JB6>GN L=D=6H
:N:L>IC:HH@CDLA:9<:D;A,=JB6>GNZH96NID96N68I>K>I>:H;DGI=:#>C<9DB7:86JH:=:A>K:9
L>I=A,=JB6>GN>CI=G::9>;;:G:CIAD86I>DCH>C$DHC<:A:H>C
(AH/>IC:HH$>HI 6I
+6J9>G67>68A6>B:9>I=697::CJC67A:ID>9:CI>;NA%J=6CC66C96<G::9IDJC9:GI6@:
699>I>DC6A:;;DGIHIDAD86I:=>B#+M 6I%6N GZ<,G

,=:
#>C<9DBHJ7H:FJ:CIANAD86I:9A%J=6CC6 6C9=:=6H6<G::9ID6EE:6G;DG69:EDH>I>DC
&D
&$
!CHJBB6GN ;DGB:G:BEADN::HL=D9:8A>C:ID7:9:EDH:9KDAJCI6G>ANC::9CDI6EE:6G
;DG69:EDH>I>DC L>I=I=::M8:EI>DCHD;79JAA6=A"6>I=:C6C979JAA6=AL69,=:
8DCHJA6G6C99>EADB6I>8D;;>8>6AH;DGL=DB+6J9>G67>66HH:GIHI=:EGDI:8I>DCHD;I=:.>:CC6
DCK:CI>DCHG:I6>CG:H>9J6A>BBJC>IN 7JIDCAN6HID68I>K>I>:HI=6IL:G:8DC9J8I:9>C

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 40 of 40
;JGI=:G6C8:D;I=:L>IC:HH:HZD;;>8>6A9JI>:H+J8=L>IC:HH:HB6N7:6H@:9FJ:HI>DCH67DJI
68I>K>I>:HI=6IL:G:CDIJC9:GI6@:C>C;JGI=:G6C8:D;I=:>GD;;>8>6A9JI>:H 6H9:H8G>7:967DK: 6C9
D7?:8I>DCHB6N7:AD9<:9DC6FJ:HI>DC7NFJ:HI>DC76H>HL=:G:I=:#>C<9DB7:A>:K:HHJ8=
68I>K>IN>HEGDI:8I:97NI=:DCK:CI>DCH,=:DJGI699G:HH:HI=:9:EDH>I>DCHD;L>IC:HH:HDK:G
L=DBI=:#>C<9DB6HH:GIHI=:=><=
G6C@>C<D;;>8>6A9D8IG>C:DC6CD;;>8>6A
7N
D;;>8>6A76H>H6H
DJIA>C:967DK:,=:DJGIH>B>A6GAN699G:HH:HI=:9:EDH>I>DCHD;L>IC:HH:HL=DBI=:#>C<9DB
8A6>BH6G:7:NDC9I=:H8DE:D;?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GNDC6CD;;>8>6A
7N
D;;>8>6A76H>H
/>I=>C96NHD;I=>H'G9:G I=:E6GI>:H6G:9>G:8I:9IDB::I6C98DC;:G6C9EG:H:CI?D>CI
DGH:E6G6I:EGDEDH6AHIDI=:DJGIG:<6G9>C<I=:H:FJ:C8>C<6C9AD<>HI>8HD;I=:9:EDH>I>DCH
HJ7?:8IIDI=>H'G9:G+::&D ,=:DJGIG:>I:G6I:H>IH:ME:8I6I>DCI=6II=:E6GI>:H
BDK:;DGL6G9>BB:9>6I:ANL>I=CDC
E6GIN6C99D8JB:CI6JI=:CI>86I>DC9:EDH>I>DCHCDIHJ7?:8I
IDI=>H'G9:G+::>988DG9>C<AN I=:DJGI&!+L>I=DJIEG:?J9>8:+6J9>G67>6ZHA:II:G
BDI>DC;DG6H8=:9JA>C<DG9:G,=:A:G@D;DJGI>HG:HE:8I;JAAN9>G:8I:9IDI:GB>C6I:I=:<6K:A
6I&D
,=:DJGI*&,+>CE6GI6C9&!+>CE6GI+6J9>G67>6ZHBDI>DC;DG6EGDI:8I>K:
DG9:G 6C9*&,+>CE6GI6C9&!+>CE6GI(A6>CI>;;HZ8GDHH
BDI>DCID8DBE:A,=>H'G9:G
>HG:HIG>8I:9IDI=:;DAADL>C<86H:E6GI>8>E6CIH(A6>CI>;;HZM:8JI>K:DBB>II::H #>C<9DBD;
+6J9>G67>6 6AA6=K8D,G6CHG67>6 6C9I=::9:G6AJG:6JD;!CK:HI><6I>DC
$ ##

, J<JHI
&:L0DG@ &:L0DG@

SAUDI 9-11 CASE - Court Opinion of Aug 27 2020 (Unsealed Sept 10)

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

SAUDI 9-11 CASE - Court Opinion of Aug 27 2020 (Unsealed Sept 10)

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-SN Document 6408

6444 Filed 08/27/20 Page 1 of 40

+6J9>D;;>8>6AH +::&D  'C%6G8=   I=:(A6>CI>;;HZM:8JI>K:DBB>II::H

&D  6I 'C%6G8=   I=: DCDG67A::DG<: 6C>:AH;DJC9I=6I(A6>CI>;;H

6GI>8JA6I:96WG:6HDC67A:76H>HX;DGI=:DJGIID6HHJB:?JG>H9>8I>DC &D 

%:BDG6C9JB:8>H>DC6C9'G9:GW%6G8='G9:GX 6I 88DG9>C<AN (A6>CI>;;HL:G:

6=696A,=JB6>GN6C9'B6G6A6NDJB> !9 6I 'C:8:B7:G   6HI=:E:G>D9D;

:68=L>IC:HH &D W(AH />IC:HH$>HIX 'C:7GJ6GN   +6J9>G67>6;>A:96

G67>6ZH:7GJ6GN   BDI>DCW#+G X 6I ';I=:>C9>K>9J6AH+6J9>G67>6

8DCI:C9H6G:H=>:A9:97NI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH H:K:C6G:6AHD;DGB:G:BEADN::H !9 ';I=:

6AHD;DGB:G:BEADN::H 6C9:><=I6G:6AHDH=>:A9:97NI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH !9

,=:DG:><C+DK:G:><C!BBJC>I>:H8IW+!X - +  R  EGDK>9:HWI=:HDA:

76H>H;DGD7I6>C>C<?JG>H9>8I>DCDK:G6;DG:><CHI6I:>C;:9:G6A8DJGI X=:IIG>K &:E6A*6HIG6

6C@  9 9>G  FJDI>C<G<:CI>C:*:EJ7A>8K B:G696 :HH+=>EE>C<

DGE - +   -C9:GI=:+! 6;DG:><CHI6I:>H>BBJC:;GDBHJ>IJCA:HH6

HE:8>;>8HI6IJIDG>AN9:;>C:9:M8:EI>DC6EEA>:H 16EE>6%>99A:6HIDCHIG D K B>G6I:D;7J

=67>  9 9>G   "+,8G:6I:96C:L:M8:EI>DCIDI=:+! +::

- +  R  !I6EEA>:HL=:C >C699>I>DCID>C?JGN 86JH6I>DC 6C996B6<:H 6EA6>CI>;;86C

HI6I: DG6CND;;>8>6A :BEADN:: DG6<:CID;I=6IHI6I:I6@:CL=>A:68I>C<L>I=>CI=6IE:GHDCZH

D;;>8: :BEADNB:CI DG6<:C8N +::%6G8='G9:G 6I

L:G:;DAADL>C<>CHIGJ8I>DCH;GDBBDG:H:C>DGD;;>8>6AH>CI=:+6J9>B76HHN X!9 6I

9>H8DK:GN8G>I>86AID6CHL:G>C< L=:I=:G6C9IDL=6I:MI:CI,=JB6>GN 6NDJB> 6C9I=:>G

6<:CIHIDD@68I>DCH>C 6II=:9>G:8I>DCD;BDG:H:C>DG+6J9>D;;>8>6AH IDEGDK>9:6HH>HI6C8:

ID 6OB> %>=9=6G 6C9DI=:G =>?68@:GH X!9 6I

C::9HD;I=:86H: X:9* >K ( 7 !C6+!86H: I=:DJGID;EE:6AH=6HB69:8A:6G

I=6I?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GND;6;DG:><CHI6I:H=DJA97:A>B>I:9 +::>GHI>IN ,:M6H

&  K *6;>96>C6C@   9 9>G %$I9 K *:EJ7A>8D;G<:CI>C6 

9>G   ,DEGDI:8I6;DG:><CHI6I:;GDBI=:W:ME:CH: >CIGJH>K:C:HH 6C9=6HHA:D;

A>I><6I>DC X68DJGIBJHI7:86JI>DJH>C6AADL>C<?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GN G8=,G69>C<DGE

 96I  ,=:DJGIBJHIDG9:G9>H8DK:GNW8>G8JBHE:8IAN6C9DCANIDK:G>;N6AA:<6I>DCHD;

HE:8>;>8;68IH8GJ8>6AID6C>BBJC>IN9:I:GB>C6I>DC X>GHI>IN   96I

+I>AA I=:DJGIBJHI8DC9J8I6W9:A>86I:76A6C8>C<XL=>A:B6C6<>C<9>H8DK:GN !9

L>I=>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H +::"+, R7 (J7 $ &D 

6<6>CHI ;DG:><C8DJCIG>:H I=6I=6K:EGDK>9:9B6I:G>6AHJEEDGI IDE:GHDCHI=6I:C<6<:

QGDHE6I>6A:K - + >HI DJGI - +  C CDI>C<I=6I >C6CN8DB>IN

KDAJCI6GN8DCH:CI #+G 6I DG:><CC6I>DC6AHG:H>9>C<DJIH>9:I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H86CCDI7:

HJ7ED:C6:9IDI:HI>;NJC9:G:9:G6A*JA:D;>K>A(GD8:9JG: +::-C>I:9+I6I:HK #DGDA@DK

  +JEE  +  & 0 8>I>C<:9 * G>B ( :- +  R-C>I:9

+I6I:HK "D=CEDAA  9   9>G  +6J9>G67>6>H6AHDCDI6H><C6IDGNIDI=:

H:8JG>C<I:HI>BDCND;>C9>K>9J6AHG:H>9>C<>C+6J9>G67>6 #+G 6I

JC9:G:9:G6A*JA:D;>K>A(GD8:9JG: 6 +::>9

ID6CDI>8:D;9:EDH>I>DC X- + K ;G6B$>C:H-+ $I9  *    +  & 0

,=:NB6N =DL:K:G 7:HJ7?:8IID9:EDH>I>DC7NCDI>8:>;I=:N6G:8DCH>9:G:9ID7:I=::FJ>K6A:CI

D;:BEADN::HD;6E6GIN8DGEDG6I>DC +::<:C:G6AAN%8#:HHDCDGE K !HA6B>8*:EJ7A>8D;!G6C

 *      ;>C9>C<WCDG:6HDCIDEG:8AJ9:XI=:6EEA>86I>DCD;6*JA:

JC9:G*JA: B6N7:CDI>8:9EJGHJ6CIID*JA: 7 DG(A6>CI>;;HWB6N>9:CI>;N6HE:8>;>8

D;;>8:G 9>G:8IDG DGB6C6<>C<6<:CIID7:9:EDH:96C9CDI>8:I=6IE:GHDCJC9:G*JA: 7 X

;G6B$>C:H  *  6IH::6AHD-C>I:9+I6I:HK ,=:DGDI=N%8AA>HI:G  * 

 +  & 0 :M6B>C>C<I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H 6H6E6GIN I=GDJ<=>IHB6C6<>C<6<:CIH

W238DGEDG6I::BEADN::DG6<:CIL=D9D:HCDIFJ6A>;N6H6CD;;>8:G 9>G:8IDG DG

B6C6<>C<6<:CIXW>HCDIHJ7?:8IID9:EDH>I>DC7NCDI>8:XJC9:G*JA: !9 ,=:E6GINH::@>C<I=:

9:EDH>I>DC=6HI=:7JG9:CIDW:HI67A>H=I=:HI6IJHD;I=:L>IC:HH X;G6B$>C:H  *  6I

 JII=>H7JG9:C>HWBD9:HI X6C96CN9DJ7IH6G:G:HDAK:9>C;6KDGD;I=::M6B>C>C<E6GIN

J76>!HA6B>86C@K >I>76C@ &  &D 

+  & 0   ,=:9:I:GB>C6I>DCD;69:EDC:CIZHHI6IJH6H6WB6C6<>C<6<:CIX>H

A>I><6I>DCD88JGG:9 X*JC9FJ>HIK .6E>6CD+  *         >CI:GC6A

8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9 JIW8DJGIH=6K:B69::M8:EI>DCHIDI=>H<:C:G6AGJA: ;DG:M6BEA:L=:C6

H>C8:>I9D:HCDI=6K:8DCIGDADK:G=>B XDHH%;< D K J<DDHH &D 

+ +%  /$  6I+  & 0 "6C   JIWI=>HGJA:>HCDILDD9:CAN

6EEA>:9 *6I=:G 8DJGIHL>I=>C6C9L>I=DJII=>H9>HIG>8I=6K:69DEI:96YEG68I>86AZ6EEGD68=I=6I

9:EDH>I>DC 7JI6AHDDCI=:>G;JC8I>DC6AG:A6I>DCH=>EH XJ76>!HA6B>86C@  /$

B6C6<>C<6<:CI $>@:L>H: I=:9:EDC:CIC::9CDI7:6HHD8>6I:9L>I=I=:8DGEDG6I>DC6II=:

I>B:D;=>H9:EDH>I>DC X$>77:NA6HH !C8 K 'C:>96 $I9  *   &  '=>D

>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9 +JBB6G>O>C<I=>H6EEGD68= I=:  >G8J>I=6HD7H:GK:9

+6J9>D;;>8>6AH+::&D 'C%6G8= I=:(A6>CI>;;HZM:8JI>K:DBB>II::H

&D 6I'C%6G8= I=: DCDG67A::DG<:6C>:AH;DJC9I=6I(A6>CI>;;H

6GI>8JA6I:96WG:6HDC67A:76H>HX;DGI=:DJGIID6HHJB:?JG>H9>8I>DC&D

%:BDG6C9JB:8>H>DC6C9'G9:GW%6G8='G9:GX 6I88DG9>C<AN (A6>CI>;;HL:G:

6=696A,=JB6>GN6C9'B6G6A6NDJB>!9 6I'C:8:B7:G 6HI=:E:G>D9D;

:68=L>IC:HH&DW(AH/>IC:HH$>HIX'C:7GJ6GN +6J9>G67>6;>A:96

G67>6ZH:7GJ6GN BDI>DCW#+GX 6I';I=:>C9>K>9J6AH+6J9>G67>6

8DCI:C9H6G:H=>:A9:97NI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH H:K:C6G:6AHD;DGB:G:BEADN::H!9';I=:

6AHD;DGB:G:BEADN::H 6C9:><=I6G:6AHDH=>:A9:97NI=:.>:CC6DCK:CI>DCH!9

,=:DG:><C+DK:G:><C!BBJC>I>:H8IW+!X -+R EGDK>9:HWI=:HDA:

76H>H;DGD7I6>C>C<?JG>H9>8I>DCDK:G6;DG:><CHI6I:>C;:9:G6A8DJGIX=:IIG>K&:E6A*6HIG6

6C@ 9 9>G FJDI>C<G<:CI>C:*:EJ7A>8KB:G696 :HH+=>EE>C<

DGE -+ -C9:GI=:+! 6;DG:><CHI6I:>H>BBJC:;GDBHJ>IJCA:HH6

HE:8>;>8HI6IJIDG>AN9:;>C:9:M8:EI>DC6EEA>:H16EE>6%>99A:6HIDCHIGDKB>G6I:D;7J

=67> 9 9>G "+,8G:6I:96C:L:M8:EI>DCIDI=:+!+::

-+R !I6EEA>:HL=:C >C699>I>DCID>C?JGN 86JH6I>DC 6C996B6<:H 6EA6>CI>;;86C

D;;>8: :BEADNB:CI DG6<:C8N+::%6G8='G9:G 6I

L:G:;DAADL>C<>CHIGJ8I>DCH;GDBBDG:H:C>DGD;;>8>6AH>CI=:+6J9>B76HHNX!9 6I

9>H8DK:GN8G>I>86AID6CHL:G>C<L=:I=:G6C9IDL=6I:MI:CI,=JB6>GN 6NDJB> 6C9I=:>G

6<:CIHIDD@68I>DCH>C 6II=:9>G:8I>DCD;BDG:H:C>DG+6J9>D;;>8>6AH IDEGDK>9:6HH>HI6C8:

ID 6OB> %>=9=6G 6C9DI=:G=>?68@:GHX!9 6I

C::9HD;I=:86H:X:9*>K(7!C6+!86H: I=:DJGID;EE:6AH=6HB69:8A:6G

I=6I?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GND;6;DG:><CHI6I:H=DJA97:A>B>I:9+::>GHI>IN ,:M6H

&K6;>96>C6C@ 9 9>G%$I9K:EJ7A>8D;G<:CI>C6

9>G ,DEGDI:8I6;DG:><CHI6I:;GDBI=:W:ME:CH: >CIGJH>K:C:HH 6C9=6HHA:D;

A>I><6I>DC X68DJGIBJHI7:86JI>DJH>C6AADL>C<?JG>H9>8I>DC6A9>H8DK:GNG8=,G69>C<DGE

96I ,=:DJGIBJHIDG9:G9>H8DK:GNW8>G8JBHE:8IAN6C9DCANIDK:G>;N6AA:<6I>DCHD;

HE:8>;>8;68IH8GJ8>6AID6C>BBJC>IN9:I:GB>C6I>DCX>GHI>IN 96I

+I>AA I=:DJGIBJHI8DC9J8I6W9:A>86I:76A6C8>C<XL=>A:B6C6<>C<9>H8DK:GN!9

L>I=>CI=:-C>I:9+I6I:H+::"+, R7 (J7$&D

6<6>CHI;DG:><C8DJCIG>:HI=6I=6K:EGDK>9:9B6I:G>6AHJEEDGIIDE:GHDCHI=6I:C<6<:

QGDHE6I>6A:K-+>HIDJGI -+ CCDI>C<I=6I >C6CN8DB>IN

KDAJCI6GN8DCH:CI#+G 6IDG:><CC6I>DC6AHG:H>9>C<DJIH>9:I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H86CCDI7:

HJ7ED:C6:9IDI:HI>;NJC9:G:9:G6A*JA:D;>K>A(GD8:9JG:+::-C>I:9+I6I:HK#DGDA@DK

+JEE +&08>I>C<:9*G>B(:-+R-C>I:9

+I6I:HK"D=CEDAA 9 9>G+6J9>G67>6>H6AHDCDI6H><C6IDGNIDI=:

H:8JG>C<I:HI>BDCND;>C9>K>9J6AHG:H>9>C<>C+6J9>G67>6#+G 6I

JC9:G:9:G6A*JA:D;>K>A(GD8:9JG: 6+::>9

ID6CDI>8:D;9:EDH>I>DCX-+K;G6B$>C:H-+ $I9 * +&0

D;:BEADN::HD;6E6GIN8DGEDG6I>DC+::<:C:G6AAN%8#:HHDCDGEK!HA6B>8*:EJ7A>8D;!G6C

* ;>C9>C<WCDG:6HDCIDEG:8AJ9:XI=:6EEA>86I>DCD;6*JA:

JC9:GJA: B6N7:CDI>8:9EJGHJ6CIIDJA: 7 DG(A6>CI>;;HWB6N>9:CI>;N6HE:8>;>8

D;;>8:G 9>G:8IDG DGB6C6<>C<6<:CIID7:9:EDH:96C9CDI>8:I=6IE:GHDCJC9:G*JA: 7X

;G6B$>C:H *6IH::6AHD-C>I:9+I6I:HK,=:DGDI=N%8AA>HI:G *

+&0:M6B>C>C<I=:-C>I:9+I6I:H 6H6E6GIN I=GDJ<=>IHB6C6<>C<6<:CIH

W238DGEDG6I::BEADN::DG6<:CIL=D9D:HCDIFJ6A>;N6H6CD;;>8:G 9>G:8IDG DG

B6C6<>C<6<:CIXW>HCDIHJ7?:8IID9:EDH>I>DC7NCDI>8:XJC9:G*JA: !9,=:E6GINH::@>C<I=:

9:EDH>I>DC=6HI=:7JG9:CIDW:HI67A>H=I=:HI6IJHD;I=:L>IC:HHX;G6B$>C:H *6I

JII=>H7JG9:C>HWBD9:HI X6C96CN9DJ7IH6G:G:HDAK:9>C;6KDGD;I=::M6B>C>C<E6GIN

J76>!HA6B>86C@K>I>76C@ & &D

+&0 ,=:9:I:GB>C6I>DCD;69:EDC:CIZHHI6IJH6H6WB6C6<>C<6<:CIX>H

A>I><6I>DCD88JGG:9XJC9FJ>HIK.6E>6CD+ >CI:GC6A

8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9JIW8DJGIH=6K:B69::M8:EI>DCHIDI=>H<:C:G6AGJA: ;DG:M6BEA:L=:C6

H>C8:>I9D:HCDI=6K:8DCIGDADK:G=>BXDHH%;<DK J<DDHH &D

+ +% /$ 6I+&0"6C JIWI=>HGJA:>HCDILDD9:CAN

6EEA>:9*6I=:G 8DJGIHL>I=>C6C9L>I=DJII=>H9>HIG>8I=6K:69DEI:96YEG68I>86AZ6EEGD68=I=6I

9:EDH>I>DC 7JI6AHDDCI=:>G;JC8I>DC6AG:A6I>DCH=>EHXJ76>!HA6B>86C@ /$

B6C6<>C<6<:CI$>@:L>H: I=:9:EDC:CIC::9CDI7:6HHD8>6I:9L>I=I=:8DGEDG6I>DC6II=:

I>B:D;=>H9:EDH>I>DCX$>77:NA6HH !C8K'C:>96 $I9 * &'=>D

>CI:GC6A8>I6I>DCHDB>II:9+JBB6G>O>C<I=>H6EEGD68= I=:>G8J>I=6HD7H:GK:9

6HHJB: 67H:CI:K>9:C8:DG6G<JB:CIIDI=:8DCIG6GN I=6I6AAL>IC:HH:H6I>HHJ: >;HI>AA

G6I=:GI=6C69K:GH:IDI=:#>C<9DBZH>CI:G:HIH'CI=:G:8DG97:;DG:I=:DJGI (A6>CI>;;H=6K:

:BEADN::H6AG:69N9>96;I:G=>HG:H><C6I>DC!C9:E:C9:CI(GD9J8I>DCHDGEK$D:LZH !C8

* +&0CDI=:G8DJGI>CI=>H9>HIG>8I;DJC9I=6IW2I3=:8DCI>CJ:9

L>I=I=:9:;:C96CI8DGEDG6I>DCXJGGNK+I6I:H%6G>C:DGED;:A6L6G: *

+&0+>B>A6GAN 6C:BEADN::L=DWG:I6>CH6EDH>I>DCL>I=I=:EA6>CI>;;HJ8=I=6I

:K:ADEB:CIDGEK#DAAHB6C%6CJ;68IJG>C<D * %6HH

:BEADN::HD;+6J9>G67>67H:CI:K>9:C8:IDI=:8DCIG6GN I=:DJGI86CCDI;>C9I=6II=:H:

9:EDH>I>DC 6C9I=:N9:8A>C:9I=:G:FJ:HI#+G 6I

9DHD7NHJ7ED:C6DGDI=:G;DGB6AEGD8:HH!C9::9 ILDD;I=:EGDEDH:99:EDC:CIH (G>C8:

79JA6O>O6C9(G>C8:6C96G L:G:6AA:<:9AN9:I6>C:97NI=:#>C<9DB:8A6G6I>DCD;+I:K:C*

(DJC>6C 96I:9%6G8= W(DJC>6C:8AXSS

<DK:GCB:CI,=:;68II=6I6C>C9>K>9J6A8DCI>CJ:HIDG:8:>K:<DK:GCB:CI7:C:;>IH H::(AHG 6I

;G6B$>C:H *6I:9:G6A*JA:96JI=DG>O:HH6C8I>DCHL=:C:K:GW6E6GIN

6;I:G7:>C<H:GK:9L>I=EGDE:GCDI>8: 2;6>AH3ID6EE:6G;DG2I=:>GDLC39:EDH>I>DCX:9*>K(

9H::6AHDJKDCHDA>96I:99>HDCDD;&0 !C8

/$ 6I+&0+:EI (A6>CI>;;H6G: >C:;;:8I 6H@>C<I=:DJGIID

I=6I>I8A6>BH>I9D:HCDI6H8G>7:ID+::#+G 6IC(DJC>6C:8ASSU9:H8G>7>C<

FJ6A>;>:HDCI=:EG:H:CIG:8DG96H6B6C6<>C<6<:CI I=:DJGIL>AACDI9>G:8II=:#>C<9DB DC

I:GB>C6I:H6CD;;>8:G>CA><=ID;E:C9>C<A>I><6I>DCXJC9FJ>HI 6I ,=>H:M8:EI>DC