You are on page 1of 62

Introduction

Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.


Case Studies

Atmospheric Entry Plasmas


Fı́sica dos Plasmas

Mário Lino da Silva, Bruno Lopez, Vasco Guerra and Jorge


Loureiro

Instituto de Plasmas e Fusão Nuclear


Instituto Superior Técnico, Lisboa, Portugal

March 10, 2014

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Case Studies

What are Atmospheric (Re)-Entry Plasmas

Typical Earth reentry profile Spacecraft entry in Mars Atmosphere (Artist Illustration)

Formation of a strong shockwave upstream of a spacecraft crossing


the upper atmospheric layers at hypersonic speeds.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Case Studies

Shockwaves as Plasma Precursors

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Case Studies

Comparison Between Entry and Laboratory Discharge


Plasmas

Reentry Plasma
Gas Discharge Plasma

1/2mv 2 ' 7/2kB Ttr


Tel = 1 − 3eV
v = [7 − 10km/s] ⇒
Ttr = [25, 000K − 60, 000K] V–e processes dominant
Ttr  Tvib Ttr  Tvib

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Case Studies

Plasma Radiation as a Spacecraft Design Driver

Radiative heating can be a major design driver for


large or high-speed (≥ 10km/s) entry vehicles
For lower entry speeds, radiative heating may
mandate additional thermal protections (e.g. base
heating for Martian entries)
Convective heating mostly depends on ground
species, radiative heating depends on excited species.
Larger uncertainties
Accounting for an additional spectral dimension with
grids with over 106 points. Very computationally
intensive CFRD simulations.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Case Studies

Main Drivers

Do we need to take radiation into account?


Optically thin or thick?
Coupling between flow and radiation?
Equilibrium or non-equilibrium radiation?
Selection of an appropriate radiative database
Other issues (precursor, photo-chemistry, photo-ionisation
processes)

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Case Studies

Aerothermodynamics of Entry Vehicles

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Case Studies

Aerothermodynamics of Entry Vehicles

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Engineering Correlations for Radiation

Engineering Correlations useful when exploring different EDL


scenarios
Exploratory parameters: Spacecraft sizing, atmospheric
profiles and composition, entry path and angle, aerodymamic
coefficients, etc...
Correlations then complemented with detailed CFRD
calculations for pre-selected Flight paths, at specific
representative entry points (∼5)

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Blackbody radiation limit

spectral emissivity of a gas has a


theoretical limit given by Planck’s
law
−1
2hν 3
  

Bν (T ) = 2 exp −1
c kB T

The spectral integration yields the


Stefan–Boltzmann Law:
The Sun’s emissivity is close to a blackbody
Z
Bν (T ) = σT 4
ν

Engineering correlations are based on this upper theoretical limit for the
emitted radiation

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Stagnation Streamline flux dependence on cone radius

Convective fluxes
Sutton and
hqGraves,iFay and Riddel correlations:
du
w

qconv =f dx s
q
2p−p∞
from Newtonian theory: du 1
 
dx s = R ρ
w
qconv ∝ √1
R

Radiative Fluxes
Eδ a R
w

Optically Thin shock layer: qrad = 2 with δ w ρs /ρ∞
w
qrad ∝R
Requirements for minimizing convective and radiative
heat fluxes are mutually exclusive
a
E: radiated power, half goes upstream, half to the wall. δ is the shock standoff. s: shock

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Stagnation Streamline flux dependence on entry speed

Convective fluxes
w 3
qconv ≈ 1/2ρ∞ u∞ Sta
w 3
qconv ∝ u∞

Radiative Fluxes
2
u∞
Ts = 2Cps ;
8
w u∞
qrad = σTs4 = (2Cps )4
w 8
qrad ∝ u∞

Radiation dominates above


10km/s
a
St: Stanton number

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Boltzmann and Goulard Numbers

Boltzmann number Bo−1 , Radiation/Convection ratio:

qrad σT 4
Bo−1 = =
qconv ρuCp T

Infinite slab approximationa . We also have Cp T w u∞ /2.

Goulard Number Γ, Radiative cooling parameter


w w
2qrad 2qrad
Γ= w
= 3
qconv 1/2ρ∞ u∞

σ: Stefan-Boltzmann constant
a
half the radiated power goes upstream, half to the wall

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Optically Thin and Optically Thick Limiting Cases

4σTs4 αδ
Optically Thin: Γn = ρ ∞ u∞ hs

16σTs4 α
Optically Thicka : Γk = 3ρ∞ u∞ hs

Γ < 10−3 : radiation is not important


10−3 < Γ < 10−2 : radiation is important but coupling is
not necessary
Γ > 10−2 : coupling of the radiation to the flowfield is
necessary
The absorption coefficient is related to the optical
transmissivity such that T = exp(−αδ). Transmissivity
goes from 100% (optically thin) to 0% (optically thick).
a
known as the Rosseland limit

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Radiative Transfer Regimes

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Computational Fluid Radiative Dynamics Simulations

Development of radiative databases


providing the spectral-dependent emission
εν and absorption α(ν) coefficients for
any arbitrary state of the plasma
Accounting for bound, bound–free
(photodissociation, photoionization,
photodetachment) and free-free
(Bremstrahlung) transitions
bound-bound transitions include atomic,
diatomic and polyatomic transitions
Radiative transfer equation is then solved
over the computational domain

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Development of Spectral Databases

atomic and polyatomic transitions


typically simulated from external
radiative databases (NIST, TopBase,
HITRAN)
diatomic transitions databases are
explicitely obtained using appropriate
quantum-mechanics models
continuum radiation calculated from
published absorption cross-sections
(e.g. TopBase for atomic
photoionization), or from Absorption Coefficient for a 97%CO2 –3%N2 Plasma in
Thermochemical Equilibrium at 5000K and 1bar
semi-empirical to exact cross-sections
for molecular continuum cross-sections

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Line-by-Line Models

“Collection” of lines which correspond to the overall quantum-allowed


radiative transitions between the internal levels of an atom/molecule.
Selection rules define the quantum-allowed transitions, which must respect
angular and spin momentum conservation for atoms and molecules.
Three key parameters:
1) Line position considering Planck’s Law: ν = Eu − El /hc;
2) Line intensity: Iν = Nu Aul ∆Eul ;
3) Line profile: F (ν − nu0 ), Voigt (sum of a Lorentz & Gaussian profile).
Radiative spectra obtained through the superposition of these overall lines.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Line-by-Line Models

“Collection” of lines which correspond to the overall quantum-allowed


radiative transitions between the internal levels of an atom/molecule.
Selection rules define the quantum-allowed transitions, which must respect
angular and spin momentum conservation for atoms and molecules.
Three key parameters:
1) Line position considering Planck’s Law: ν = Eu − El /hc;
2) Line intensity: Iν = Nu Aul ∆Eul ;
3) Line profile: F (ν − nu0 ), Voigt (sum of a Lorentz & Gaussian profile).
Radiative spectra obtained through the superposition of these overall lines.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Line-by-Line Models

“Collection” of lines which correspond to the overall quantum-allowed


radiative transitions between the internal levels of an atom/molecule.
Selection rules define the quantum-allowed transitions, which must respect
angular and spin momentum conservation for atoms and molecules.
Three key parameters:
1) Line position considering Planck’s Law: ν = Eu − El /hc;
2) Line intensity: Iν = Nu Aul ∆Eul ;
3) Line profile: F (ν − nu0 ), Voigt (sum of a Lorentz & Gaussian profile).
Radiative spectra obtained through the superposition of these overall lines.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Line-by-Line Models

“Collection” of lines which correspond to the overall quantum-allowed


radiative transitions between the internal levels of an atom/molecule.
Selection rules define the quantum-allowed transitions, which must respect
angular and spin momentum conservation for atoms and molecules.
Three key parameters:
1) Line position considering Planck’s Law: ν = Eu − El /hc;
2) Line intensity: Iν = Nu Aul ∆Eul ;
3) Line profile: F (ν − nu0 ), Voigt (sum of a Lorentz & Gaussian profile).
Radiative spectra obtained through the superposition of these overall lines.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Key Parameters
The fundamental equation for intensity

Iν = Nu Aul ∆Eul F (ν − ν0 )

can be decoupled in the following variables :

Nu : Level populations :
Either a Boltzmann equilibrium distribution, either through Collisional-Radiative
nonequilibrium models

Aul : Transition probabilities (Einstein Coefficients):


From ”ab-initio” or measured transition moments

∆Eul : Level energies:


Fitting and extrapolation of experimentally determined data

F (ν − ν0 ) : Line profile:
Voigt profiles accounting for Doppler and Collisional broadening (depends on the local
conditions of the plasma)

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Key Parameters
The fundamental equation for intensity

Iν = Nu Aul ∆Eul F (ν − ν0 )

can be decoupled in the following variables :

Nu : Level populations :
Either a Boltzmann equilibrium distribution, either through Collisional-Radiative
nonequilibrium models

Aul : Transition probabilities (Einstein Coefficients):


From ”ab-initio” or measured transition moments

∆Eul : Level energies:


Fitting and extrapolation of experimentally determined data

F (ν − ν0 ) : Line profile:
Voigt profiles accounting for Doppler and Collisional broadening (depends on the local
conditions of the plasma)

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

The SPARTAN Code

SPARTAN: Simulation of PlasmA Radiation in


ThermodynAmic Nonequilibrium
Simulation of Earth, Mars and Titan plasma radiation
63 atomic and molecular bound-bond, bound-free
(Photodissociation, Photoionization, Photodetachment),
and free-free transitions
SPARTAN Code Logo
Simulated species: C, C+ , C− , N, N+ , N− , O, O+ , O− ,
Ar, Ar+ , C2 , H2 , N2 , N+ +
2 , O2 , CN, CH, CO, CO , NH,
NO, OH, CO2
Code freely distributed under a Gnu Public License, see
http://esther.ist.utl.pt/

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Elementary Radiative Processes

Eu
6
hν -
hν - hν - hν -
hν -

? ?
El
spontaneous emission induced emission absorption
∂Nu ∂Nu ∂Nl
= −Nu Aul = −Nu Bul uν = −Nu Bul uν
∂t ∂t ∂t
M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas
Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Derivation of the Radiative Transfer Equation (RTE) (1/2)


Summing the three processes we have
∂Nu
= −Nu Aul + [Nu Bul − Nu Bul ]uν
∂t
In Radiative equilibrium the net variation is 0, and radiation is given by
the Planck Blackbody Law
−1
8πhν 3
  

uνo (T ) = exp − − 1
c3 kB T

we have

gl Blu = gu Bul
Aul 8πhν 3
=
Bul c3

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Derivation of the Radiative Transfer Equation (RTE) (2/2)


Integrating the expressions of the previous slide in volume from we obtain
the classical RTE equation:
dLν
cos θ = εν − αν Lν
dz
with
nu Aul hν
εν =
 4π 
gu hν
α(ν) = nu − nl Bul
gl c
which becomes the Beer-Lambert Law in 1D coordinates:
dIν
= ε − α(ν)Iν
dl
and after integration:
ε
Iν = [1 − exp(−α(ν)l)]
α(ν)
M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas
Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Ray-Tracing Methods for Space-Related Heat Transfer


Analysis

Ray-Tracing: An exact
method for determining the
quantities of photons which
irradiate a surface.

Z π/2 Z π
qν = Iν (θ, φ)cosθ sin θdθdφ
−π/2 0
ε
Iν = [1 − exp(−αl(θ))]
α0

Ray-tracing considers full 3D geometries, with the possibility of simpler


2D/1D slab geometries.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Ray-Tracing Methods for Space-Related Heat Transfer


Analysis

Ray-Tracing: An exact
method for determining the
quantities of photons which
irradiate a surface.

Z π/2 Z π
qν = Iν (θ, φ)cosθ sin θdθdφ
−π/2 0
ε
Iν = [1 − exp(−αl(θ))]
α0

Ray-tracing considers full 3D geometries, with the possibility of simpler


2D/1D slab geometries.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Ray-Tracing Methods for Space-Related Heat Transfer


Analysis

Ray-Tracing: An exact
method for determining the
quantities of photons which
irradiate a surface.

Z π/2 Z π
qν = Iν (θ, φ)cosθ sin θdθdφ
−π/2 0
ε
Iν = [1 − exp(−αl(θ))]
α0

Ray-tracing considers full 3D geometries, with the possibility of simpler


2D/1D slab geometries.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction
Engineering Correlations
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims.
Large-Scale CFRD Simulations
Case Studies

Ray-Tracing Methods for Space-Related Heat Transfer


Analysis
T (K)
8

4500
7
4000
6
3500
5
3000
Y(m)

4 2500

3 2000

1500
2
1000
1
500
0
0 5 10 15
X(m)

Complex flow geometries with millions of molecular spectral lines


M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas
Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Case Studies

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

IST-IPFN Participation is Space Exploration Programmes

Since 2004, IPFN has supported all the major European


planetary exploration Missions
Support to the Huygens Titan entry mission in 2004
Support to the Mars EXPRESS Observation of the PHOENIX
entry in 2008
Support to the upcoming Mars robotic exploration Mission
EXOMARS in 2016 and 2018
IPFN is developing a new generation European shock-tube
(ESTHER) for the support of planetary exploration missions
on a total funding of 2M Euros

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Huygens Titan Entry (2005)

60 half angle blunted cone


Base diameter: 2.7 m
Nose radius: 1.25 m
Entry module mass: 318.62 kg
Aerodynamic databases
developed by EADS between
1991 and 1995.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Huygens Heat Fluxes: Nominal Yelle Atmospheric Profile

Titan Composition: 95% N2 –5% CH4


Important Radiator species CN produced in the shock layer.
correlations do not work anymore.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Validation of Aerothermodynamic Databases: Shock-Tubes


Experiments

TCM2 Shock-Tube at Marseilles, France, was utilized for validating


the CFRD models used for Huygen’s Entry

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Acquisition Results: CN spectral time-resolved picture

Shot conditions :
Shock Tube
Classical mixture
pshock =200 Pa
Shock velocity
vshock =5680 m/s

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

40 Pa test rebuilding, Boltzmann

Non-equilibrium zone, 1s integration Temporal evolution

Validation of Aerothermal databases against simpler (1D,


time-dependent) representative flow conditions

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Coupled CFD-Radiative Simulations of Huygens Entry

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Influence of Radiation and Radiation Coupling

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Mars EXPRESS Observation of the PHOENIX Entry

ESA Mars EXPRESS Orbiter


provided support for PHOENIX
2008 Mars Entry
Mars EXPRESS Tracked
PHOENIX Entry with his onboard
instrumentation (First Attempt at
tracking an Entry from an
Onboard Satellite).

CFRD simulations prior to entry predicted the IR trail to be the most


emissive.
SPICAM VUV Camera and HRSC Visible Camera tracked the Entry.
IR Fourier Spectrometer could not be turned on due to power budget
constraints.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

CFRD Simulations of PHOENIX Entry

PHOENIX Temperature Profiles, t=203s Sample spectrum of the PHOENIX Plume

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


HRSC Observation in # 5647 during Phoenix EDL :
Nadir Context of Limb

195°° E, 81.5°° N: HRSC


SC ND, spatial resolution 12.5 m/pixel,
/ image width 18 km

SOWG 38, ESAC, Villafranca: HRSC Future Planning Hoffmann and Hauber 04 June 2008
HRSC Observation in # 5647 during Phoenix EDL :
Pointing during 144 SRC Frames

Phoenix always in center off frame


f based on latest available Kernel from
f 25 May

SOWG 38, ESAC, Villafranca: HRSC Future Planning Hoffmann and Hauber 04 June 2008
HRSC in # 5647 during Phoenix EDL : SRC 076

Uppermost limb haze


layers
y (detached
( haze
layer) enter FOV

SOWG 38, ESAC, Villafranca: HRSC Future Planning Hoffmann and Hauber 04 June 2008
HRSC in # 5647 during Phoenix EDL : SRC 096

Upper limb within FOV

SOWG 38, ESAC, Villafranca: HRSC Future Planning Hoffmann and Hauber 04 June 2008
HRSC in # 5647 during Phoenix EDL : SRC 116

Optically thick limb at


edge
g of FOV

•No hints for flash or


brightening
•Pointing and timing
seem to be correct

Î Phoenix not detected:


•Upper limit for energy
release
•Consistent with
continuous telemetry link

SOWG 38, ESAC, Villafranca: HRSC Future Planning Hoffmann and Hauber 04 June 2008
ExoMars Programme Mission Architecture
ExoMars Programme: two missions launched in 2016 and 2018.
• The 2016 mission consists of the Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) and the EDL Demonstrator Module (EDM)
• The 2018 mission consists of the Rover, accommodated inside a Descent Module (DM) and carried
to Mars by a Carrier Module (CM)
• Large international cooperation with Roscosmos and some contributions from NASA

2016 Mission 2018 Mission

Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO)


+
Carrier Module & Descent Module

Proton EDL Demonstrator Module (EDM) Proton Rover + Landed Platform


ESA UNCLASSIFIED – For Official Use
Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Radiative Transfer Towards Mars EXPRESS

Optical path Transmissivity Raddiation collected by one pixel of the Mars EXPRESS
instrumentation

Radiation in the VUV-Visible region was not detected, IR radiation was


predicted to be detected if the instrument had been switched on

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Spectral Database for CO2 –N2 Mixtures

CO2 Infrared
O2 Sch.–Runge
CO Infrared
O2 Sch.–Runge Cont. O Atomic
CO 4+
N2 1+ O Photoionization
CO 3+
N2 2+ C− Photodetachment
CO Angstrom
NO Gamma N− Photodetachment
CO Triplet
NO Beta O− Photodetachment
CN Violet
NO Delta CO2 Photoionization
CN Red
NO Epsilon N2 Photoionization
C2 Swan
NO Beta O2 Photoionization
C2 Phillips
C Atomic CN Photoionization
C2 Mulliken
C Photoionization CO Photoionization
C2 Deslandres–
D’Azambuja N Atomic NO Photoionization

C2 Ballik–Ramsay N Photoionization

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Radiative Power for CO2 –N2 Mixtures: Comparison With


Other Spectral Databases
12
10

10
10

8 CO2 IR
Radiative Power (W/m3)

10 Other Systems

6
10

4
10

2
10

0
10
1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000
Temperature (K)
Comparison of the overall temperature dependent radiative power of CO2 IR radiation (red) and for the other

radiative systems (black) for an atmospheric pressure, Martian-type CO2 –N2 plasma. Comparison is carried for the

SPARTAN code database (full lines) and the EM2C database (dotted lines).

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Example of a Ray Departing from the Afterbody Plume;


PH (1/2)

Intensity at ray departure


0 Intensity at ray arrival
10

−5
Intensity (W/m /cm )

10
−1
2

−10
10

−15
10

3 4 5
10 10 10
Wavelength (A)

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Example of a Ray Departing from the Afterbody Plume;


PH (2/2)

1 Intensity at ray departure


10
Intensity at ray arrival
Intensity (W/m /cm )
−1

0
10
2

−1
10

4.17 4.1705 4.171 4.1715 4.172 4.1725


Wavelength (A) x 10
4

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Comparison of Stagnation Streamline and Backcover


Shoulder Spectra; PH

VUV-Visible radiation higher for the stagnation streamline


points
For both points, CO2 radiation spectral intensity is several
orders of magnitude above Visible-VUV radiation

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Contribution of Radiative Fluxes above 1µm to the Overall


Radiative Power; Large Spacecraft Configuration
100

99.98

99.96
IR Radiation Contribution (%)

99.94

99.92

99.9

99.88

99.86

99.84 PH
PP
P28
99.82 P23
SHA
99.8
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
Wall Point

Values for the smaller spacecraft configuration are similar. Other studies in the scope
of the ESA TC3 testcase confirm such findings for CO2 –N2 mixtures (CN and C2
radiation less than 3% overall in the stagnation streamline point.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

The ESTHER Shock-Tube Project

European Shock Tube for High Enthalpy Research

European Space Agency project


International consortium, led by Instituto Superior Técnico, for the
development and comissioning of a shock-tube facility for planetary
exploration research in the high speed regime
Consortium partners include:
Fluid Gravity Eng. (Ermsworth, UK),
Université de Provence (Marseille, France),
Ingénieurie Systèmes Avancés (Bordeaux, France),
Moscow Institute for Physics and Technology (Moscow, Russia),
Instituto de Soldadura e Qualidade (Lisboa, Portugal),
Shock-Waves Laboratory (Aachen, Germany),
University of Manchester (Manchester, UK),
Université Blaise Pascal (Clermont–Ferrand, France),
Université Paris VI (Paris, France)

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Shock-Tube Characteristics

Facility capable of reproducing shock waves for gas mixtures simulating


the atmosphere of Earth, Mars and Venus (CO2 –N2 ), Titan (N2 –CH4 ).
High pressure reached in the driver section through the deflagration of a
high-pressure H2 –O2 mixture. This allows a quick-rise in pressure,
enabling 3–4 shots per day, but needs special precautions related to the
presence of explosive gases.
Shock velocities of v '4–12km/s, allowing the simulation of orbital (slow
speed) and interplanetary superorbital entry plasma flows.
High-speed automated diagnostics (MHz) for control, acquisition, and
collecting light emitted by the plasma.

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Shock-Tube Design (1/4)

High Pressure Driver Section

600 bar maxium working pressure High pressure ignition and safety
900 bar design limit system

Internal diameter 200mm Combustion gas preparation system


and induction system including
Outer diameter 360mm mixing, storage, valves, probes and
Internal length 1.5m gauges
Nominal mixture Gasket system with rupture pressures
70%He,20%H2,10%O2 60 to 600 bar
Initial pressure 10 to 50 bar

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Shock-Tube Design (2/4)

Compression Tube (or second stage)


Internal diameter 130mm
Outer diameter 150mm, length 6.5m
Initial pressure 0.1-0.5 bar (optimized for each run)
Gasket system with rupture pressures 5 to 25 bar

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Shock-Tube Design (3/4)

Working Section

Internal diameter: 80mm Pumping system: minimum pressure


outer diameter: 150mm of 10-8 mbar during cleaning
procedures, ensure known initial test
length from diaphragm to window: gas composition.
4m
Working gas preparation and
total internal length to the dump induction system including probes
tank: 5.4m and gauges.
Initial pressure 10 to 1000Pa Windows (UV/VUV transparent)
and window mounting system.
Shock speed / pressure measurement
M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN
system.
Reentry Plasmas
Introduction Titan Entry: Huygens
Correlations & High-Fidelity Sims. Mars Entry: PHOENIX and EXOMARS
Case Studies The ESTHER Shock Tube

Shock-Tube Design (4/4)

Dump Tank
Post window section lead in tube to dump tank
Pressure range, vacuum to 2bar pressure post shot.
Diameter: 1 m
Length: 3 m

M. Lino da Silva, B. Lopez, V. Guerra and J. Loureiro, IPFN Reentry Plasmas


Hypersonic Plasmas Laboratory
European Shock-Tube for High Enthalphy Research


Shock-Tube: A facility for reproducing the conditions of an atmospheric entry

Support to planetary exploration missions and meteoroids planetary protection research

2M€ total funding, 1,75M€ funding from the European Space Agency

First facility of its class to be built in the last 30 years in Europe, located at IST-IPFN

World class facility capable of reaching superorbital shock-speeds in excess of 10km/s

Facility Specifications

Length: 16m

Test-section diameter: 80mm

Shock Velocities: 4-12+ km/s

Pre-shock pressures: 0.1-100+


mbar

Planetary compositions: Air (Earth),


Outside view of the laboratory and view of the experimental hall
CO2-N2 (Venus, Mars), N2-CH4
(Titan)

ESTHER shock-tube
Example of a shock-induced plasma

You might also like