Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—The requirement for complex motion control rotate smoothly and with low friction simultaneously with the
systems is steadily increasing in several emerging applications, straight-line movement of the machine.
such as robotics, machine tools, flexible manufacturing systems,
automotive, etc. Usually, the needed complex movements are There are three basic types of electrical machines with two
performed by several conventional electrical machines. The DoF: the surface (planar) motors with a flat structure [3], the
number of the actuating units, the required space to place them spherical motors [4] and the rotary-linear ones, having a
and their total price can be diminished by applying electrical cylindrical construction [5]. Generally, combined rotary-linear
machines with multiple degrees of mechanical freedom. The paper movements can be achieved by means of three actuator
is a survey of such rotary-linear motors, which can both rotate and topologies, as shown in Fig. 2 [6].
move on the axial direction, and in most of the cases they can
perform also o combined, helical motion.
I. INTRODUCTION
Industrial machineries with two degrees of freedom (DoF)
motion, as such boring machines, grinders, threaders and many x x
x
others are frequently used. Upon the classical approach, the two
kind of movements can be assured by two independent electrical
machines, a rotary and a linear one. The combined motion could x
be performed by means of low efficiency appropriate
mechanical arrangements and coupling devices. Therefore, there x x
parallel series integrated
is a real interest for a more efficient and space saving approach coupled coupled topology
consisting of the use of electrical machines which can develop Fig. 2. Two DoF actuator topologies [6]
both torque and axial force in a properly controllable manner
(see Fig. 1). The development of such rotary-linear machine To assure the complex movement, the most facile solution is
(RLM) is a genuine engineering challenge. Unfortunately, in this to use two parallel coupled conventional rotary and linear
topic only a few research groups are involved round the World. actuators. By means of this, the two motions are perfectly
independent. The main drawback of this approach is the high
space requirement, because the linear motor must move also the
entire rotary motor. The series coupled structure has two
separate stators with a common shaft, and therefore it is simpler.
The distance between the two stators must be at minimum the
linear stroke of the RLM. The control of these two types of
RLMs is quite simple, hence the two parts of the machine are
physically separated, and the different movements are
decoupled. The most compact and innovative topology is of the
Fig. 1. Electrical machines able to perform different types of motion [1]
third, the integrated one, which has only a single stator and
mover. In this case, the length of the stator does not depend on
D. Howe was the first researcher who underlined the
the linear stroke of the RLM. On the other hand, as the two types
industrial importance of multi degrees of freedom motors, as
of motion are magnetically linked; the two DoF movements can
counterparts of multiple electrical machines performing a single
be more hardly controlled independently. Another drawback of
type of motion [2].
this structure is that the two windings corresponding to the
Due to their particular movement, the RLMs require also different movements are placed in the common stator, thus its
specific linear-rotary bearings. These must avoid the shaft to manufacturing is more problematical [6].
3106
One of the simplest series coupled PM RLM was proposed
in [14]. Both parts of the cylindrical machine, those performing z
the linear and the rotational movements, are slotless PM
actuators with concentrated windings having a common mover
y z
(see Fig. 5). Two optical encoders are integrated into the
machine to measure the mover position on the two axes.
x
x
Fig. 7. Similarity between the tubular PM RLM and PM surface motor [18]
Rotary
actuator
Position
sensor
Linear
actuator
A first set of its coils were placed on the axial direction, to
ensure the rotation, while the other one was distributed
Fig. 5. Series coupled PM RLM [14]
circumferentially to provide the axial force [19], [20].
This PM RLM has some advantages, as the lack of cogging Several such RLMs were developed by P. Bolognesi and his
due to the slotless structure. The fully axial-symmetric structure collaborators [21], [22], [23]. These all were of modular
of the linear machine part enables an independency of the rotary construction, an efficient and relatively new approach in
motion. A basic drawback is its excessive length. electrical machines [24]. The simplest, three-phase variant with
A more compact PM RLM, with the two concentrically two stator modules is given in Fig. 8.
stacked actuators, was proposed by Jang et al. [15]. The mover Coil
comprises of two cylindrical Halbach arrays [16] of different
patterns, separated by a cylindrical iron core piece (see Fig. 6). Mover
core
A' B
magnetic r
C C' core
r
B' A
z Stator
z core
A B' Permanent
coil magnet
A'
C' C
Fig. 8. A modular integrated PM RLM [23]
B A'
3107
where y is the axial position of the mover, p the number of pole three-phase windings are placed. These can generate the axial
pairs, l the linear stroke and 0 the transformed magnetic flux direction magnetic flux. The mover has two iron core layers
at no-current condition. In the case of the currents, the A and B having among them helical-shaped alternatively and axially
subscripts are related to the two stator modules (module A and magnetized PMs.
B), and d and q to the two axes in quadrature. By analyzing Even if the iron cores of this RLM can be manufactured of
equation (1) it can be easily observed, that the axial force is easy-to-machine free-cutting steel with high permeability or of
linearly proportional to the difference between the two d-axis soft magnetic composites (SMCs) [29], the structure (including
currents components, while the torque generated by the RLM is the specially shaped PMs) seems complicated and requires
equal to a linear combination of q-axis currents with coefficients special fabrication technology. Moreover, this PM RLM can
that vary in complementary proportional way with the linear perform only helical movement (and not independently rotary
position. and linear one), which makes it to have limited application areas.
On the side, as a drawback, the great number of PMs required On another hand, this PM RLM has very high axial force
should be mentioned. In addition, from this great number of PMs density, since the thrust force is directly proportional to the
only a small amount is actively interacting with the stator air-gap area and inversely proportional to the air-gap length, this
currents at each moment of the motion, making these structures RLM has very high force density [28].
less efficient. Tanaka et al. proposed an axial length optimized PM RLM
To reduce the number of the PMs K. Guo et al. proposed to comprising of a helical-windings and two bobbins on its stator,
replace each second PM with a similar sized iron core piece [26]. and a shaft with surface mounted PMs. To achieve high power
Its rotor with the so-called interleaved poles (PMs swapping iron density the PMs were arranged in a Halbach array [30].
core pieces) is given in Fig. 9. C. Variable Reluctance Rotary-Linear Motors
Also, some of the variable reluctance (VR) type electrical
Ferromagnetic machines have they rotary-linear counterparts. These, as their
poles
rotational or linear variants, work upon the minimum magnetic
reluctance principle, namely that the passive salient mover
S
N travels in such an angular and linear position as to achieve a
N
S minimum reluctance position (when poles on both armatures are
Permanent
aligned) [31].
magnets
The RLM based on its most typical variant, the switched
Fig.9. PM RLM rotor with interleaved poles [26] reluctance motor (SRM), is also a potential candidate to provide
two DoF movement. This is due to its numerous appealing
This PM RLM has 3 stator stacks separated by non-magnetic features, as easy-to-manufacture rugged and robust construction,
rings, each module having 12 salient poles with concentrated low maintenance needs, simple power converter, wide speed
coils. The rotor has 12×16 poles (96 PMs and 96 made of iron range, etc. [32].
core). It was demonstrated, that for the proposed structure, even
if the quantity of the used PMs was reduced to the half, the power The rotary-linear SRM proposed in [33] is a simple but
density was not compromised. The comparison with the PM efficient combination of the rotational and linear SRMs. It has
RLM of similar sizes proposed in [18] revealed that back-emf, all the pluses of the SRMs: simple, but robust construction, low
torque and axial force are only diminished by round 15÷17% manufacturing and maintenance costs, high reliability and fault
[26]. tolerance, and easy control. In Fig. 11 the iron core of this
machine can be seen. The stationary part is comprising of 3
Upon a totally other approach, a helical PM RLM was equally shifted usual 8 poles SRM stators. Each of the stator
proposed by Y. Fujimoto et al. in [27]. The so-called screw poles have a concentrated coil wound around. The mover is also
motor has itself a unique spiral structure, as it can be seen in constructed in a modular way. It has usual 6 poles SRM rotor
Fig. 10. stacks placed on the shaft. Their number depends only on the
length of the intended axial displacement. The rotation or linear
movement of this RLM can be achieved by the adequate
supplying sequence of the stator coils.
Permanent
magnet
Stator core
Mover core
x Winding
Shaft
Fig. 10. The helical (screw) PM RLM [28] Fig. 11. The modular iron core of the rotary-linear SRM [33]
Both of its iron cores have a special helical shape with equal Upon another approach of the rotary-linear SRM, mainly
lead length. The stator has surface slots in which two distributed similar iron core pieces taken from the already known rotary or
3108
linear SRMs are used. In the motor proposed in [34] two separate III. COMPARISON OF DIFFERENT TYPES
sections assure the two movement types, as it can be seen in A comparison between the RLMs taken into study in this
Fig. 12. The three-phase motor part for the rotational movement paper should be of real interest. Without any doubt, the variants
is placed in the middle. Basically, it is a 6/4 poles common rotary with PMs have the higher torque/force density and efficiency
SRM. The single difference is that the stator stack length has among all RLMs. In addition, they are easier to model, control
twice that of the rotor, to be able to rotate at different axial and cool than the induction RLMs. On another hand, induction
displacements of the mover. The part of the motor which assures and VR RLMs have more robust, cheaper and easier to
the linear movement resembles with a two-phase transverse flux manufacture movers. In the case of the first ones, the movers can
linear SRM. Its two stator iron core stacks have 6 poles (as that be only simple conductors or conductive layers, while the VR
for the rotational motion). The two corresponding iron cores on RLMs all have totally passive movers [38].
the mover (placed on the two sides of the rotor stack) are simple
cylindrical ones. The main disadvantage of this structure is its The above-mentioned main advantages of the PM RLMs are
limited linear stroke. valid only if high-power rare earth metals-based PMs are
Stator for Mover stack for applied. Unfortunately, the use of these magnetic materials has
linear movement linear movement
some disadvantages. These are mainly due to their high prices,
lower maximum allowable temperature, low resistance to
Shaft corrosion, hard-to-predict price, rapid diminution of ore
z reserves, etc. [39].
IV. POSSIBLE APPLICATION AREAS
The most important application fields of the RLMs are in
Mover stack for Stator for
rotary movement rotary movement
Winding
industry, especially in those cases where complex, multiple DoF
motions are needed, but the space to place independent motors
Fig. 12. The rotary-linear SRM proposed by M.M. Nezamabadi et al. [34]
for each movement is not possible. Thus, RLMs can be used in
A similar machine, but with much longer stroke possibilities pick and place machines, for example to populate PCBs with
was developed by J.F. Pan et al. The main differences against electronic components [10], [40]. They can be also applied in
the previously detailed rotary-linear SRM is that it has 2 two robotics (for a press-fit assembly, or tracking a compound arc
salient pole rotational stack, and 3 for the linear motion, as it can conveyor section), boring machines, grinders, etc. [5], [41].
be seen in Fig. 13. The mover is a passive toothed cylinder. For Another possibility to employ RLMs is in automotive
independently controlling the two types of motion a simple but applications. RLMs had been designed for acting directly on the
efficient net torque methodology based decoupling method was shift rails of an automated manual transmission or of a dual
proposed [35]. clutch transmission to assist the suitable gear selection [42]. A
very interesting research is concerning the use of PM RLMs in
integrated driving and steering systems developed for electrical
vehicles. Here the RLMs has to both propel and steer the active
wheels of the vehicle [43].
Fig. 13. Pan's rotary-linear SRM [35] Of course, applications of RLMs can be found in several
other areas (including striking ones), too. For example a single
Also stepper motors were suggested in rotary-linear variants RLM can solve a part of the motion in a 5-axis grinding machine
[36], [37]. The RLM shown in Fig. 14 seems like the tool used in customized dental restorations [38].
well-known teethed rotating stepper motor of variable reluctance
type. Half of the stator poles are teethed axially, while the other V. CONCLUSIONS
ones on a perpendicular direction to this. The first mentioned set As it could be seen, a great variety of RLM variants were
of poles are used to generate the rotational movement, and the proposed in the literature. The author intended to include in the
other ones the linear one. As in the previously detailed case, all paper a mapping of the developed torques and thrusts, efficiency
the poles have concentrated coils wound around them. The rotor and power density of the RLMs taken into study, but such
comprises if two half teeth pitch shifted iron core stacks. They information was not available in most of the cases. He faced the
equally have teeth both on the circumference and axial direction same situation also in the case of the mover inertia, an important
to assure the dual motion for this RLM. By an adequate issue from the control point of view.
supplying of the stator, two DoF motion can be achieved [36].
RLMs being newcomers in the field of electrical machines
with special construction, their market penetration still needs
time, even if they could be used effectively in a great variety of
industrial applications. Their promising future can be a good
catalyzer of the further developments in this field.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This paper was supported by a grant of the Romanian
Fig. 14. Rotary-linear stepper motor [36]
National Authority for Scientific Research and Innovation,
3109
CCCDI – UEFISCDI, project number 21/2017 ERANET-LAC [23] P. Bolognesi, O. Bruno, F. Papini, V. Biagini, L. Taponecco, "A low-
SWTOMP, within PNCDI III. complexity rotary-linear motor useable for actuation of active wheels," in
Proc. Intern. Symp. on Power Electronics Electrical Drives Automation
and Motion (SPEEDAM '2010), Pisa (Italy), 2010.
REFERENCES
[24] L. Szabó, "Advancements in electrical machines design brought by the
[1] I. Benţia, L. Szabó, M. Ruba, "A rotary-linear switched reluctance motor modular construction," in Proc. 10th Intern. Conf. on Electrical Power
for automotive applications," in Proc. 20th Intern. Conf. on Electrical Drive Systems (ICEPDS '2018), Novocherkassk (Russia), 2018, pp. 35-
Machines (ICEM '2012), Marseille (France), 2012. 41.
[2] D. Howe, "Magnetic actuators," Sensors and Actuators A: Physical, vol. [25] P. Jin, H. Lin, S. Fang, S. Ho, "Decoupling control of linear and rotary
81, no. 1, pp. 268-274, 2000. permanent magnet actuator using two-directional transformation," IEEE
[3] L. Szabó, I.A. Viorel, "On a high force modular surface motor," in Proc. Trans. Magn., vol. 48, no. 10, pp. 2585-2591, 2012.
10th Intern. Power Electronics and Motion Control Conf. (PEMC '2002), [26] K. Guo, S. Fang, H. Yang, H. Lin, S. Ho, "A novel linear-rotary
Cavtat & Dubrovnik (Croatia), 2002, p. 384. permanent-magnet actuator using interlaced poles," IEEE Trans. Magn.,
[4] H.Y. Kim, H. Kim, D. Gweon, J. Jeong, "Development of a novel vol. 51, no. 11, 2015.
spherical actuator with two degrees of freedom," IEEE/ASME Trans. [27] Y. Fujimoto, T. Kominami, H. Hamada, "Development and analysis of a
Magn., vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 532-540, 2015. high thrust force direct-drive linear actuator," IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron.,
[5] E. Amiri, P. Gottipati, E.A. Mendrela, "3-D space modeling of rotary- vol. 56, no. 5, pp. 1383-1392, 2009.
linear induction motor with twin-armature," in Proc. 1st Intern. Conf. on [28] Y. Fujimoto, T. Suenaga, M. Koyama, "Control of an Interior Permanent-
Electrical Energy Systems (ICEES '2011), Newport Beach (USA), 2011, Magnet Screw Motor With Power-Saving Axial-Gap Displacement
pp. 203-206. Adjustment," IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 61, no. 7, pp. 3610-3619,
[6] K.J. Meessen, "Electromagnetic Fields and Interactions in 3D Cylindrical 2014.
Structures: Modeling and Application," Ph.D. Thesis, Eindhoven [29] L. Szabó, I.A. Viorel, V. Iancu, D.C. Popa, "Soft magnetic composites
University of Technology, Eindhoven (The Netherlands), 2012. used in transverse flux machines," Oradea University Annals,
[7] E.R. Laithwaite, M.T. Hardy, "Rack-and-pinion motors: hybrid of linear Electrotechnical Fascicle, pp. 134-141, 2004.
and rotary machines," Proceedings of the Institution of Electrical [30] S. Tanaka, T. Shimono, Y. Fujimoto, "Optimal design of length factor for
Engineers, vol. 117, no. 6, pp. 1105-1112, 1970. cross-coupled 2-DOF motor with Halbach magnet array," in Proc. Intern.
[8] J. Fleszar, E. Mendrela, "Twin-armature rotary-linear induction motor," Conf. on Mechatronics (ICM '2015), Nagoya (Japan) 2015, pp. 529-534.
IEE Proceedings B – Electric Power Applications, vol. 130, no. 3, pp. [31] G. Henneberger, I.A. Viorel, Variable Reluctance Electrical Machines.
186-192, 1983. Aachen (Germany): Shaker Verlag, 2001.
[9] E. Mendrela, J. Fleszar, E. Gierczak, Modeling of Induction Motors with [32] K.Á. Bíró, I.A. Viorel, L. Szabó, G. Henneberger, Special Electrical
One and Two Degrees of Mechanical Freedom. New York (USA): Machines (in Romanian). Cluj (Romania): Mediamira, 2005.
Springer Science & Business Media, 2003.
[33] I. Benţia, M. Ruba, L. Szabó, "On the control of a rotary-linear switched
[10] P. de Wit, J. van Dijk, T. Blomer, P. Rutgers, "Mechatronic design of a z- reluctance motor," in Proc. of the 5th Intern. Symp. on Comput. Intell. and
φ induction actuator," in Proc. 8th Intern. Conf. on Electrical Machines Intell. Inform. (ISCIII '2011), Floriana (Malta), 2011, pp. 41-46.
and Drives (EMD '97), Cambridge (UK), 1997, pp. 279-283.
[34] M. Nezamabadi, E. Afjei, H. Torkaman, "Design and electromagnetic
[11] E. Mendrela, E. Gierczak, "Double-winding rotary-linear induction analysis of a new rotary-linear switched reluctance motor in static mode,"
motor," IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. EC-2, no. 1, pp. 47-54, 1987. Applied Comput. Electromagn. Society Journal, vol. 31, no. 2, pp. 171-
[12] K. Kluszczynski, M. Szczygiel, "How to convert a factory-manufactured 179, 2016.
induction motor into rotary-linear motor? Part 1 Constructional issues " in [35] J.F. Pan, N.C. Cheung, G. Cao, "A rotary-linear switched reluctance
Proc. of the 15th Intern. Workshop on Research and Education in motor," in Proc. 3rd Intern. Conf. on Power Electronics Systems and
Mechatronics (REM '2014), El Gouna (Egypt), 2014. Applications (PESA '2009), 2009.
[13] T. Onuki, W. Jeon, M. Tanabiki, "Induction motor with helical motion by [36] S. Hirobumi, I. Takao, "Linear-rotary composite type stepping motor,"
phase control," IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 33, no. 5, pp. 4218-4220, 1997. Japan Patent JP 08-275484, 1996.
[14] K.J. Meessen, J.J.H. Paulides, E.A. Lomonova, "Analysis and design [37] R. Hammer, "Combined linear-rotary direct drive step motor," US Patent
considerations of a 2-DoF rotary-linear actuator," in Proceedings of the 5,093,596, 1990.
2011 IEEE International Electric Machines & Drives Conference
[38] M.K. Liebman, "Rotary-Linear Axes for High Speed Machining," Ph.D.
(IEMDC '2011), Niagara Falls (Canada), 2011, pp. 336-341.
Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge (USA), 2001.
[15] S.-M. Jang, S.-H. Lee, H.W. Cho, S.K. Cho, "Design and analysis of
[39] I. Boldea, L.N. Tutelea, L. Parsa, D. Dorrell, "Automotive electric
helical motion permanent magnet motor with cylindrical Halbach array,"
propulsion systems with reduced or no permanent magnets: An
IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 39, no. 5, pp. 3007-3009, 2003.
overview," IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 61, no. 10, pp. 5696-5711,
[16] J.-S. Choi, J. Yoo, "Design of a Halbach magnet array based on 2014.
optimization techniques," IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 44, no. 10, pp. 2361-
[40] Y. Yoshida, M. Mori, W. Kitagawa, T. Takeshita, "Design for cogging
2366, 2008.
torque reduction in two-degree-of-freedom cylindrical actuator," in Proc.
[17] J. De Boeij, E. Lomonova, A. Vandenput, "Modeling ironless permanent- 21st Intern. Conf. on Electrical Machines (ICEM '2014), Berlin
magnet planar actuator structures," IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 42, no. 8, pp. (Germany), 2014, pp. 478-483.
2009-2016, 2006.
[41] M. Rabiee, J.J. Cathey, "Verification of a field theory analysis applied to
[18] P. Jin, S. Fang, H. Lin, Z. Zhu, Y. Huang, X. Wang, "Analytical magnetic a helical motion induction motor," IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 24, no. 4, pp.
field analysis and prediction of cogging force and torque of a linear and 2125-2132, 1988.
rotary permanent magnet actuator," IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 47, no. 10,
[42] A. Turner, K. Ramsay, R. Clark, D. Howe, "Direct-drive rotary-linear
pp. 3004-3007, 2011.
electromechanical actuation system for control of gearshifts in automated
[19] A. Chitayat, "Rotary-linear actuator," US Patent 5,982,053, 1999. transmissions," in Proc. IEEE Vehicle Power and Propulsion Conf.
[20] M.R. Sogard, "2-dimensional electric motor," US Patent 6,455,956, 2002. (VPPC '2007), Arlington ( USA), 2007, pp. 267-272.
[21] P. Bolognesi, "Analysis of a novel rotary-linear permanent magnets [43] M. Bertoluzzo, P. Bolognesi, O. Bruno, G. Buja, S. Castellan, V. Isastia,
brushless machine," in Proc. 15th Intern. Conference on Electrical et al., "A distributed driving and steering system for electric vehicles
Machines (ICEM '2002), Brugge (Belgium), 2002. using rotary-linear motors," in Proc. Intern. Symp. on Power Electronics,
[22] P. Bolognesi, L. Taponecco, "FEM modeling of a rotary-linear brushless Electrical Drives, Automation and Motion (SPEEDAM '2010), Pisa
machine," in Proc. 17th Intern. Conf. on Electrical Machines (Italy), 2010, pp. 1156-1159.
(ICEM '2006), Chania (Greece), 2006.
3110