Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Page
Introduction 5
Verification of ITT in respect to other fatigue methods 5
Using ITT in practice 9
Other benefits of ITT 12
Conclusions 13
Acknowledgement 11
References 14
Appendix
Introduction
The Indirect Tensile Test (ITT) was introduced in Sweden more than 10 years ago.
A description of the ITT has been presented earlier and its practical advantages
and disadvantages have been discussed [1, 2, 3]. The ITT has been adopted by
ASTM (ASTM D 4123) and FAS (The Swedish Asphalt Pavement Association)
(FAS Method 454) for evaluating the elastic stiffness (resilient modulus) of
bituminous materials. In Sweden, thousands of specimens from various types of
bituminous mixes have been subjected to fatigue tests and tests to determine
elastic stiffness and tensile strength. Nowadays, the reliability of the ITT,
including fatigue test, is judged to be fully adequate for routine use by Operating
agencies. The VTI's test procedure for determination of fatigue Characteristics of
bituminous mixes is presented in the attached Appendix.
TD = Total deformation
RD = Resilient deformation
PD = Plastic deformation RD
Time
Figure 1 Definition Qfdaformations.
1000
Initial total strain (microstrain)
100
10
1000 10000 100000 1000000
Number of Ioads
A1000
.E
E
175
E
.9
E,
.E
E0: 100
E
.9
.E
.72
:E
"' 10
1000 10000 100000 1000000
Number of Ioads
FigureZ Efect of total and resilient stram on fatigue life prediction with
respect to temperature.
The strain from the ITT must be computed from the total strain in order to be
comparable with the fatigue results obtained with the flexural tests, especially in
regard to the effect of temperature or stiffness of the mixes. These results are in
agreement with the conclusions reported by Ruthand Olson [5] and Kim, Khosla
and Kim [6].
An investigation coordinated by Nordic collaboration (NVF) [7] was carried
out to find out the correlation between fatigue test methods used in northern
countries. A typical asphalt concrete (Ab 16t) from Norway has been tested by
four laboratories at ISOC. Specimens were manufactured with the California
Kneading Compactor. The resultsare presented in Figure 3. It is concluded that
the differences are primarily due to the test procedure, and the fatigue curves
obtained with the lTT do not differ from curves obtained with other methods.
.I
_I
_/I
H_/I
I'
II
1000 "'
./I
H
II
N
II
u
I
\.\l N
Il
.
§ hä.
§§\
100
L! 1 I l>
6
103 104 105 10
No. Of load
applications
107-_
E Momsmolh et al
- nz=35l 0
_ 4551:10
5 Rodhby 8. T:$3°F
'0 E Sterlmg
: :120.87
: K'f3.65l 'O
1 T: 77°
'05%
2 q
5 \
g lot: \\
D I
c - \
Ls - \ MOnusmum et al
_ \ nz : 9
Kå=|.78 x 10'6
IOL T : 40°F
: mKennedy et al \ Pc et 0'
_ mdureci 'ensaon \\ 02* 3.9 .2
w
:L
c.
'5
173
E
'52
100
1 000
W
:5.
c.
'§
*01
.72
i
100
No. of applications
Initial strain, pe
n=2.9 k=1.1E11
k = 14.1 E10
100
9aw - - - -
8+ - - - - - - - - - - -
*37:
7__ - _ _ _ . . . _ _ . _ _ . _ _ _ .
6 FTFITIH I Iilllli I lillill iiillln
Case 2 (details published at 4th Int. RILEM symposium 1997, ref. 14)
In order to study the performance of mixes used in roadbase layers, eight test
sections have been built into a newly constructed road. Accelerated pavement
testing by a Circular Test Track (Neste - Finland) and experiments in the
laboratory are the first part of this work, which is presented here. The bituminous
mixes used in two of the Test Track sections were from the same materials as
those used in the road sections. The reference mix (AG25/B180) is compared to a
modified stone mastic asphalt (SMA25) with highvoid ratio and similar to porous
asphalt. It is used as a roadbase layer in this work. Stiffness and fatigue properties
of cores drilled from the circular test sections have been determined in the
laboratory using Indirect Tensile Test. Both the test track and laboratory tests are
carried out at a temperature of 10°C. Fatigue lives of the mixes obtained in the
laboratory are compared with the results obtained from the Test Track.
The construction of pavements at the Test Track, installation of load cells and
strain gauges and the follow-up of the deterioration of the test pavements have
been performed and reported by Neste Oy and VTT (Technical Research Centre of
Finland) [13].
A comparison between Test Track and ITT results [14] has been made with
respect to initial transversal tensile strains measured by strain gauges at the bottom
of roadbase layers of the Test Track sections. Fatigue relationships of the roadbase
layers obtained by ITT are presented in Figure 8. Fatigue lives of the AG and
SMA layers have been obtained from their fatigue relationships at the initial
strains measured in the Test Track. The calculated fatigue lives show longer
fatigue life for the AG layer than the SMA layer. This is in agreement with the
conclusions from accelerated testing at the Test Track. The indirect tensile test has
ranked the tested mixes similar to accelerated testing. It has also proved to be a
1000 :m l rum
m SMAZS WAGZSt
= %
?3. 't as
ä *ä W
s å
ä år;
"53 \\ så e
ä N *a* t
l- i. 3%?
,å se
\ % Q
\
\\ '\
100 N -
1E+4 1E+5 1E+6
N0. of applications
Precision statements
Precision statements are not arranged. However, for homogeneous specimens it
has been shown that 10 specimens or even fewer are sufñcient for determination
of a fatigue curve.
Conclusions
The repeated-load indirect tensile test has been increasingly used in the last
decade. It has been investigated widely, primarily due to its practical advantages.
The disadvantage of this method is the accuracy of stiffness determination
because the stress distribution is only valid under ideal elastic conditions when the
behaviour of bituminous mixes is predominantly linear. Furthermore, the
Poisson's ratio must be assumed for the determination of strain across a horizontal
diameter.
On the other hand, the great advantages of the indirect tensile test are its
simplicity, speed and economy. Also, it can be used both by Operating agencies
and research institutes. The ITT is suitable for quality control and mix design.
Cylindrical specimens are used which are relatively easy to fabricate in the
laboratory or to drill from the road layer or a slab. The test has proved sufñciently
accurate for routine measurements.
Acknowledgement
This report is a part of the project "Deterioration of bituminous layer". The author
is grateful to the Department of Highway Engineering at the Swedish National
Road Administration for their ñnancing of this project.
BITUMINOUS MATERIALS
2 Principle
Load cell
Asphalt specimen
Extensometer
Deformation
strip
Loading strip
4 Specimen preparation
5 Test procedure
E
E _
C.
.9
Ti
E
8 2-_
(D
'0
3c
0
E _
o
I
_ ' Fracturelive
un_|_ _L_ _1_| | +
O HIIII I Illlllll I IIIIHI. I III III!
1E+4 1E+5
1E+2 1E+3
No. of load applications
ZP
(70 = --- ............................. ..1
ntD
(2.zni)[ 1+3v ]
a: ---- ............ .2
D 4+nv-n
Lf\/=(l35then
a: ZlAH
.-- ............ 3
D
TD = Total deformation
RD = Resilient deformation
PD = Plastic deformation
RD
'LÅPD
4 Time
Figure 4. Definition (lf the txnxil horizontal
deformation.
where
7 Report