Professional Documents
Culture Documents
by KYY INVESTOR
Chapter 1:
Malaysian Companies
are Not the Same
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
1.1 Long-term Value Investing (or Buy-and-Hold Strategy) Does Not Work in
Malaysia Stock Market
Well, his investing journey actually began in 1983 after he had his heart bypass
surgery in London. Whilst recuperating in Harley Street Hospital, he read from
the newspaper that the Hong Kong stock market crashed because the then
British Prime Minister, Margret Thatcher, failed to secure the extension of
British rule of Hong Kong. The British had a 99 years lease of Hong Kong and a
part of Kowloon. The lease was about to expire, and China would soon take
back Hong Kong.
Koon recalled many Hong Kong investors were afraid of the arrival of the
Government of China. So they sold their holdings as quickly as possible, which
resulted in the stock market crashed. Everything was on cheap sale. The Hang
Seng Index (HSI) went below 1000, and HSBC was selling below HK$10 per
share. At that time, he was not so good at picking stocks. He did not even know
how to invest for long term, or short term, or timing the market. He just bought
stocks that went down the most in terms of percentage using his business sense.
You can say that he started this business blindly. As soon as China agreed to
offer 50 years extension of capitalist system, the Hong Kong stock market
rebounded, and he sold all the shares he bought initially with more than 200%
profit. With all the proceeds, he bought HSBC, and other better-known shares.
After about two years, he made so much money that he could afford 46% of
Kaiser Stocks and Shares Limited, a stock broking company in Hong Kong,
which gave him margin finance, and helped him made more profit.
After the short experience in Hong Kong, he decided to retire as the Managing
Director of Mudajaya, and relinquished his roles in other organisations to focus
on his investments. He always asks himself “Why should I work so hard when it
is so easy to make money from the stock market? Moreover, all my profit is tax
free, and I don’t have any management problem. I do not need to deal with
people, which I find most difficult.”
After his retirement, he had more free time to read, and learn about investing.
He began learning the investment philosophies of Warren Buffet, Peter Lynch,
Benjamin Graham, and others. But, most of the books preach long-term value
investing. They encourage investors to buy good, and profitable companies on
the cheap, and hold them for long term. No doubt the results of those gurus are
astounding, and their investing philosophies are solid. But Koon failed to
emulate their results even though he had adhered to their advice, and followed
their methods closely for several years.
Page | 2
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
When Koon analysed the root cause of his average return, he found out that the
problem lies not with the approaches of those gurus, but with the characteristics
of Malaysian companies/stocks. Whilst the buy-and-hold strategy works in US
stock markets, it failed Koon (and may also fail us) in Malaysia, as most of the
public listed companies in Malaysia do not meet the investing criteria of these
gurus. The main reason is that Malaysian companies are not the same.
I know some of you, especially those long-term value investors who have
invested in US markets for several years, may not agree with Koon’s study. But
if you think the same winning formula use by those Gurus can be used in
Malaysia stock market, think again. Well, let me explain to you why the buy-
and-hold strategy may also fail you in Malaysia.
Page | 3
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
Unlike the products offered by Google, Boeing, and Intel, most of the
products offered by Malaysian companies do not have strong patent
protection. Due to their lack of creativity and innovation, competitors
can produce the same kinds of products to compete with them, head-to-
head, without spending a dime on research and development, or having
much trouble of replicating the same type of products, and need not to
even worry about any legal actions will be taken against them for
exploiting the technologies.
Page | 4
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
During its industry downturn, especially right after the peak of its cycle,
the supply of its products will outpace the demands of its products, as
all of the industry players take loan to expand their capacities at an
exceedingly fast rate. The supply glut issue will result in the
companies’ performance begin to go downhill. Some highly leveraged
companies with a few quarters of abysmal performance would go into
liquidation if their balance sheets are not strong enough to weather the
downturn.
As an investor, Koon does not like to buy a stock when its company is
in financial trouble, no matter how cheap its share price is, because its
share price will go down continuously, and the pain of holding the
loser is excruciating. Even if the company has the ability to survive the
disaster, it may take a very long time to get the business back to its past
glory, and some investors may not even have a chance to see light at
the end of the tunnel.
Page | 5
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
that have strong political ties with Barisan Nasional government were
pummelled mercilessly when the market opened on 14 May 2018, as
investors ditched the stocks for some other stocks due to their gloomy
earnings prospect. The share prices of these stocks took a nosedive
when the opening bell rang, and continued to be sold down over the
next few of days. If anyone owned any of the stocks until early May
2018 and refused to sell them, he or she could only witness their share
prices plunge continuously.
Even if you believe that a stock is very cheap, you should not buy and
hold it for long term. You need to pay attention to its profit growth
prospect, the actions of its management, and the main shareholders, its
share price movement, the company’s development, and its business
performance continuously. When the situation has turned sour, you
should run for cover.
Page | 6
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
bear fruits, not all public companies are so generous. In fact, some of
the companies are run by crooks. They are lack of integrity, and are not
trustworthy. They get paid (in forms of salary, bonus, and allowances)
before the shareholders. They make money at the expense of their
shareholders by trading their own stocks with insider information.
When the business stops growing, they will begin to distribute their
shares to uninformed shareholders. When the business begins to
deteriorate, they will give misleading information to shareholders, and
sell their stake aggressively. If the value of the company is higher than
their market capitalisation, when the market turns bad, they will take
the companies private through selective capital reduction, or takeover
offers when the share prices are at depressed levels. That is how they
make themselves wealthier. At the same time, it leaves the buy-and-
hold long-term value investors on the losing side of the game.
Further, when the companies are small and growing, they preserve the
cash (retained earnings) for expansion. When the companies do well,
they milk the cash cow at the expense of the minority shareholders.
That is why many of them refuse to pay dividends even though the
Page | 7
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
If you understand the nature of most Malaysian stocks, you will not be
holding them for too long. The chance is that investors tend to lose
money for holding the stocks for long term, as the future of these
companies are full with uncertainties. Also, compared to mature
markets, the stocks market of Malaysia is more volatile in nature.
The share price of a stock is more stable, and could grow steadily for
decades if the company has an ability grow its revenue and profits
continuously, and pay growing dividends. The traits can be found
easily in those established US companies such as Coca-Cola, General
Dynamics, VF Corporation, Walmart and AT&T, which have
economic moat, the ability to grow their earnings continuously, and can
afford to pay increasing dividends. But, this is not the case in Malaysia.
Unlike those U.S. companies, most Malaysian companies do not have
stable earnings, let alone having a progressive dividend policy.
The main reason of this problem is that most of the companies behind
Malaysian stocks are young firms. These young companies, which are
still in their infancy stage, cannot afford to distribute their profits as
dividends to investors, as the retained earnings need to be reinvested
into the business for upgrade and expansion purposes. Unfortunately,
no immediate return can be expected when the money is reinvested to
venture into upstream or downstream business, to acquire other
companies, and for other expansion purposes.
Page | 8
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
When people are optimistic about the future of a stock, they will buy it
aggressively. Share price can shoot through the root during the early
stage of an event development such as the invention of an innovative
product, signing of a lucrative contract, discovery of a new drug or
finding of a giant oil deposit, as enormous amount of money are poured
into the respective stock instantaneously. Also, when the company
performs well, the share price of a stock will be on an uptrend. The
market can be filled with a lot of investment crazes that offer
tremendous upside gain due to hype. But the excitement wanes when
everyone who intended to pile into the stock has done so, and smart
money managers have begun to pile out. If you do not take your money
off table when its share price is near the peak of an uptrend, someone
else will. When a company fails to deliver expected results, reports
decreasing earnings, or shows a series of abysmal performance, its
value will then begin to evaporate, and risk-averse investors will trim
their positions, or dispose their stake aggressively, then you would be
witnessing your holding falls in value like a stone if you refuse to sell
the stock.
Page | 9
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
Geraldine Weiss stressed that “each stock must be studies and evaluated
according to its own unique profile of dividend yield, one that has been
established over several investment cycles.” But, many of the stocks listed on
Bursa Malaysia are inconsistent in paying their dividends, if not unable to pay
dividends. If you insist on investing based on the dividend yield profile of a
company, many good opportunities would be slipping through your fingers.
Now, the question is if most of the public companies in Malaysia do not meet
the selection criteria of these investment gurus, does it mean that we should
stash our cash under the mattress? Of course NO! That’s the worst approach in
money management.
If the long-term investing approach preach by those gurus are not applicable in
Malaysia stock market, what should we do then?
Well, after many years of hard work, Koon eventually managed to pull all the
resources he has gathered, including the basic accounting principles, wisdom of
some investment gurus, chart patterns, and his prior experience in business
world, to develop a method that enables him to make money from Malaysian
stock market. The method emphasises on searching for stocks with high
earnings growth potential, which have delivered two quarters of increased
earnings. Then he will buy them when they are still cheap, and their share prices
are about to rise, or have gained momentum. Doing so does not only improve
the chance of making money, but it also shortens the time needed for the market
to recognise the values of the stocks.
Page | 10
Malaysian Companies are Not the Same
Chapter Summary
Buy-and-hold and long-term value investing method may not provide you a
satisfactory return for investing in Malaysia stock market.
The reason why the buy-and-hold strategy may fail you is that Malaysian
companies are not the same with those in the U.S.
The best way to make money in Malaysia stock market is by searching for
stocks with high earnings growth potential, which have delivered two
quarters of increased earnings, and buying them when their share prices are
about to rise, or have gained momentum, and sell them when they fail to
meet your investment criteria.
Page | 11
Chapter 2:
Basic Knowledge of
Fundamental Analysis
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
“We have observed that the money managers who have achieved long term market
beating results in this business, Walter Schloss, Warren Buffett, Bill Ruane and Rick
Cunniff, Mario Gabelli and John Neff, all have an investment philosophy based on
their definition of value. Our booklet, ‘What has worked in investing’, shows that both
in the US and internationally, basic fundamental value criteria produce better than
market returns over long periods of time.”
Christopher Browne
Page | 2
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
“I always start off my research by reading companies’ annual reports and then
the footnotes to their numbers. I need to be satisfied about the integrity of the
numbers and the honesty of the accounting before I look further. If there is a
number that is incomprehensible, I throw the report into the wastebasket and
move on. If you look at Enron’s footnotes in the 1990s, they were just
incomprehensible. If investors had read those footnotes carefully, I don’t think
anyone would have invested in Enron stock.”
Jean-Marie Eveillard
2.1.1 Why You Should Read Quarterly Financial Statements and Annual
Reports?
Page | 3
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Page | 4
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
• The next item we have to pay attention to is its gross profit, which is
the profit netted out with after taking the cost of goods sold (or cost
of sales) into account. The cost of goods sold is the total costs of
producing the products which include, but are not limited to, raw
material costs, utility bills, machinery maintenance costs, wages and
etc. If we compare the gross profit with revenue, we will get gross
profit margin. Decreasing gross margin signifies increasing raw
material prices, wages and maintenance costs. In addition, it shows
that the management is unable to control the cost of sales.
• The second profit comes after gross profit is known as profit before
tax (PBT). It is the profit obtained by subtracting operating expenses
(such as depreciation and amortisation, and selling, general and
administrative expenses), interest expenses, and other expenses from
and adding other incomes to the gross profit. Depreciation refers to
reduction in tangible asset value (i.e. car, furniture, machinery
Page | 5
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
• The last profit is called net profit, which is also known as the bottom
line, or profit net of tax. It is obtained by subtracting income tax
from the profit before income tax. High net profit is although
pleasing, we should not look at the figure alone. It does not tell us a
complete story until we do some comparisons with the profits of the
company in the past five or ten years, the profits of its competitors,
and with its own revenue. An increased profit is an indicator of
business growth, which will normally lift its share price up. If the
net profit is higher than those of its competitors, it implies that the
management is very competitive.
Page | 6
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
buy the stocks is when the businesses return to profit, and when
their profits are growing again, or if you can be very sure that the
company will make more profits next year than this year.
Figure 2.1: Income Statement of Latitude Tree Holdings Berhad for the Financial
Year Ended 2013
Source: Bursa Malaysia
Page | 7
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
• Balance sheet (refer to Figure 2.2A and Figure 2.2B), also known as
the statement of financial position, is a statement showing the
ending balances of a company’s assets, liabilities and shareholders’
equity. It can be divided into two main sections. In general, current
assets and non-current assets constitute the first section. Current
liabilities, non-current liabilities and shareholders’ equity, on the
other hand, constitute the second section. The sum of components in
the first section must be equal to that in the second section.
• Current assets are the assets that can be converted to cash within
twelve months, which generally comprise of inventories, trade
receivables, cash and cash equivalents, short-term investments,
amounts due from associates, prepaid expenses, bank deposits, tax
recoverable and etc.
• Non-current assets are the assets that are mostly not intended for
sale, and cannot be converted to cash easily within twelve months,
which include property, plant, and equipment, associate companies,
or investment in subsidiaries, intangible assets, long-term
investments, and etc. Intangible assets are non-physical assets but
are valuable to the business, which include goodwill, brand
recognition, franchises, patents, trademarks, copyrights, and other
intellectual properties.
• Current liabilities are the liabilities that must be paid within twelve
months; which encompass trade payables, accrued expenses, short-
term borrowings, tax payable, and other current liabilities.
• Non-current liabilities are the liabilities that will only due after
twelve months, which include long-term borrowings, deferred tax
liabilities, and bonds.
Page | 8
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Figure 2.2A: Balance Sheet of Latitude Tree Holdings Berhad for the Financial Year
Ended 2013 (Part 1)
Source: Bursa Malaysia
Page | 9
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Figure 2.2B: Balance Sheet of Latitude Tree Holdings Berhad for the Financial Year
Ended 2013 (Part 2)
Source: Bursa Malaysia
Page | 10
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
• The statement of cash flows (refer to Figure 2.3A and Figure 2.3B)
summarises how money is spent and brought into the company by
its management. The report can be divided into three main sections,
namely cash flow from operating activities, cash flow from
investing activities, and cash flow from financing activities. Note
that negative cash flow indicates that the company spends more
money than it generates. If the company spends more than it brings
in, its cash balance at the end of the year will be decreased.
• Cash flow from investing activities records the money received from
the disposal of assets or investments and money spent on the
acquisition of plant, property, and equipment.
Page | 11
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Page | 12
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Figure 2.3A: Cash Flow Statement of Latitude Tree Holdings Berhad for the Financial
Year Ended 2013 (Part 1)
Source: Bursa Malaysia
Page | 13
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Figure 2.3B: Cash Flow Statement of Latitude Tree Holdings Berhad for the Financial
Year Ended 2013 (Part 2)
Source: Bursa Malaysia
Page | 14
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Just like a human’s wellbeing, a business will not be thriving if its finance is in
chaos. Likewise, our chance of winning a bet would be very slim if we invest in
a company in deep financial trouble or a company with no earning growth
potential. Avoiding this type of companies will help protecting our hard-earned
money, and will smoothen our path to achieving financial freedom.
Below are some useful metrics, which we can use to determine if the financial
health of a company is in a favourable condition, and if the business is
performing well prior to making judgement.
2.2.1 Profitability
Page | 15
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
There are two types of profit growth rate. The first type is called
year-over-year profit growth rate, or profit growth rate (YoY),
which measures the growth rate of profits from one year to another.
This type of profit growth is important in moving short-term stock
price. The second type, on the other hand, is called the compound
annual growth rate of profit, or profit growth rate (N-year CAGR),
which measures the constant growth rate of profits over a specific
number of years. The latter is important in increasing long-term
shareholders’ value.
Page | 16
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Note that not all industries share the same range of return on equity,
as some businesses require only little assets, whilst others require
large infrastructure investment. Therefore, we need to compare the
return on equity of the company with that of the industry average to
get a better picture on how it fares against its competitors. Also, we
must look at the trend of the company’s return on equity over the
past ten years. Down-trending return on equity may point to the
inability of the management to sustain its past performance.
2.2.2 Solvency
Below are two useful metrics, namely Debt-to-EBITDA ratio and Debt-to-
equity ratio, which we can use to assess the solvency level of the business.
EBITDA
= Net Profit + Interest + Taxes + Depreciation and Amortisation
Page | 17
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
2.2.3 Liquidity
Two of the financial ratios investors usually use to assess the liquidity of a
company are current ratio, and quick ratio.
Page | 18
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Quick ratio is also known as an acid-test ratio. Just like current ratio,
quick ratio measures the ability of a company to meet its short-term
financial liabilities. However, inventories are omitted in quick ratio
calculation, as inventory could not be readily converted into cash.
The higher the turnover, the higher the number of times inventory is
sold in a year, the higher the efficiency of a company is in managing
its resources. However, unreasonably high turnover is not good for a
company as it implies insufficient inventory, which may result in a
loss in business.
Low inventory turnover, on the other hand, may suggest that the
company is overstocking, suffering from obsolescence or deficiency
in the finished goods. Nonetheless, a sudden drop in the turnover is
not always bad. At times a company may increase its inventory if
the management anticipates market shortages or rapidly rising prices
of certain goods. As investors, we should read the comments of the
management provided in the financial reports in conjunction with
Page | 19
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
or
Page | 20
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
2.3 Do Not Forget the Details of Financial and Annual Reports and Company
Announcements
“The best advice I ever got was on an airplane. It was in my early days on Wall
Street. I was flying to Chicago, and I sat next to an older guy. Anyway, I
remember him as being an old guy, which means he may have been 40. He told
me to read everything. If you get interested in a company and you read the
annual report, he said, you will have done more than 98% of the people on Wall
Street. And if you read the footnotes in the annual report you will have done
more than 100% of the people on Wall Street. I realized right away that if I just
literally read a company's annual report and the notes -- or better yet, two or
three years of reports -- that I would know much more than others. Professional
investors used to sort of be dazzled. Everyone seemed to think I was smart. I
later realized that I had to do more than just that. I learned that I had to read
the annual reports of those I am investing in and their competitors' annual
reports, the trade journals, and everything that I could get my hands on. But I
realized that most people don't bother even doing the basic homework. And if I
did even more, I'd be so far ahead that I'd probably be able to find successful
investments.”
Jim Rogers
Page | 21
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
One of the reasons why most retail investors lose money in the stock market is
that they are reluctant to read the announcements, financial statements, and
annual reports of the stocks in which they have interests. Most of them buy and
sell stocks based on rumours. As a result, they lose their hard-earned money for
punting on news with low reliability. Even if they are willing to read the
financial statements, most of them do not have the patience to read the entire
reports, and all announcements. Skimming through the documents does not only
hinder investors capturing the essence of the reports, and companies’ progress,
many of the hidden gems will also be missing out.
Below are some important details, which we can obtain from the reports, and
announcements if we are willing to spend time going through the documents.
Page | 22
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
By scrutinising the section, we can tell how the firm’s profits are derived,
the type of products the firm sells, the geographical market of the firm,
and the impact of the strategy the management have implemented. Also,
we will be able to identify the high-performing businesses within the firm,
and to make a better prediction on the revenues and profits for the next
few quarters.
2.3.4 Number of Shares Owned by the Management Team and the Thirty
Largest Shareholders
Page | 23
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
circulating in the market, the faster the share price soars when the
business performs better in future. Further, we would be rewarded
handsomely if we spot any super investors or gurus owning the stock, and
if we buy it below its intrinsic value.
Page | 24
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
After analysing the business performance of a company and adding the stock in
our shortlist, we must perform stock valuation prior to placing an order. This is
to prevent us from paying an extortionate price for the stock. No matter how
good the company is, our investment return will be greatly reduced if we pay an
unreasonably high price for the stock. Therefore, stock valuation acts as the
second defence line to protect our lifetime savings.
That being said, it does not mean that we should use a very complex model in
our valuation work. According to Benjamin Graham, “in 44 years of Wall Street
Page | 25
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
experience and study I have never seen dependable calculations made about
common stock values, or related investment policies that went beyond simple
arithmetic or the most elementary algebra. Whenever calculus is brought in, or
higher algebra, you could take it as a warning signal that the operator was
trying to substitute theory for experience.” When we use a multi-variable model
with Greek symbols in your analysis, the likelihood of making mistakes will be
higher. Instead of focusing on the economic moat of a business and its
performance, we will just be concentrating on the precision of variables used for
valuation. As a result, our attention will be diverted to the wrong direction and
our investment thesis will be jeopardised. After all, stock valuation only helps
us find an approximate value of the business, gives our rational side a chance to
guard our investment and allows us to buy a stock at a price less than what it is
worth. Hence, the process should not be made too complicated.
When we plan to start a business, we will usually begin our planning work
by determining the income we can expect from the business. After that,
we will calculate the number of years it takes for us to get back the capital
we invest in the business. Similarly, when it comes to stock valuation, we
should, first of all, find out the company’s current earnings, current
earnings per share and future earnings and future earnings per share.
Using the data, we should subsequently find out how long the company
needs to earn you back the price you pay for the stock. If the duration is
too long, it is highly likely that the stock is overvalued.
Page | 26
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
the current stock price in relation to the expected earnings per share.
To determine the forward price-to-earnings ratio, we must be able to
make an educated guess, or prediction about the future earnings of
the business. Again, it can only be accurately predicted if we
understand the business.
Having said that, research studies show that investors who buy only
low P/E stocks are not always ended up winning. Stock prices
seldom drop without a cause. As investors, we should figure it out
why the price, and P/E of the stock are so low. If we pay attention to
the company’s announcements, and read its financial statements,
and annual report closely, we should be able to find out the reason.
If, indeed, the share price falls without a valid reason, the demand
for its products is high and the company’s earnings are on an
uptrend, then we should not be afraid to buy the stock.
Note that not all high dividend stock investments will be your
winning bets. Since dividend yield is calculated based on the
dividends paid last year, the yield tends to go up when the stock
price falls during industry downturn. Being investors, we should
find out if the dividend payment is sustainable by looking at the
current earnings, earning potential, and cash flow of the firm. The
yield will fall, and its price may drop further if the company is
unable to maintain its dividend payment.
Page | 27
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Page | 28
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Page | 29
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
“You must thoroughly analyze a company, and the soundness of its underlying
businesses, before you buy its stock; you must deliberately protect yourself
against serious losses.”
Benjamin Graham
Latitude Tree Holdings Berhad is one of the multi-bagger stocks in which Koon
previously invested, and it constituted a substantial chunk of his portfolio in
2013, 2014 and 2015. When he initially shared his investment thesis on Latitude
with people, it was not well received, as they did not understand the business of
the company, and did not bother to know about its financial performance. Most
of them took punts on either stock market rock stars, or stocks in hot sectors.
After two years, it was proved that Latitude was a better investment. Its stock
price soared alongside the increasing profits, and stronger business performance.
It still makes people wondering how Latitude provided such a spectacular return
to its shareholders.
In this section, let us study why Latitude was a good investment in 2013, 2014,
and 2015, and how Koon assessed Latitude. I hope this simple, yet practical
method will help you discover multi-baggers stocks in Bursa Malaysia in future,
and help us achieve financial freedom sooner after learning about it.
Page | 30
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Middle East countries. The United States, being the largest market of
Latitude, accounted for 92% of its revenue in 2013.
Remark: one of the advices of Koon is to look for businesses that we can
understand because we have to be able to make an educated guess about
their future earnings. The more complex a business is, the more uncertain
our projections will be. Moreover, it is harder for an incompetent
management to make big mistake to affect the bottom line of a simple
business.
• Profitability
First of all, we must make sure that the business made more profits
this year than last year, and will earn more profits next few years
than this year before placing our bet.
It can be clearly seen from the calculation above that the net profit
of Latitude in 2013 had increased by 117.22% from Rm 14.753
million to Rm 32.046 million. The figure was higher than that of its
4-year CAGR profit growth rate, 24.79%, and that of the industry
average, 26.62%. The surge was an early indicator showing that the
company’s net profit had started to grow rapidly in 2013, and had
grown faster than the profit growth of its competitors.
Page | 31
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Return on equity
= Net profit attributable to shareholders / Shareholders’ equity
= (Rm 24,366,000 / Rm 232,061,000) × 100%
= 10.50%
Figure 2.4: USD-MYR Currency Exchange Rate Chart from 2012 to 2017
Page | 32
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
90,000,000 12.00%
11.02%
80,000,000
9.88% 10.00%
70,000,000 9.46%
60,000,000 8.00%
7.20%
50,000,000 6.49% Net profit
6.00%
40,000,000 Net profit margin
0 0.00%
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Year
Figure 2.5: Net Profit and Net Profit Margin of Latitude from 2009 to 2016
600,000,000 20.00%
18.00%
500,000,000
Shareholders' equity (Rm)
16.00%
Return on Equity (%)
14.00%
400,000,000
12.00%
Shareholders' Equity
300,000,000 10.00%
Return on Equity
8.00%
200,000,000
6.00%
4.00%
100,000,000
2.00%
0 0.00%
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Year
Figure 2.6: Return on Equity and Shareholders’ Equity of Latitude from 2009 to 2016
Page | 33
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
• Solvency
Debt-to-EBITDA ratio
= Debt / EBITDA
= Rm 98,533,000 / Rm 56,894,000
= 1.73
Debt-to-Equity ratio
= Debt / Shareholders’ Equity
= Rm 98,533,000 / Rm 232,061,000
= 0.42
Page | 34
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
3.33
3.50
2.50 2.18
Ratio (times)
2.00 1.73
Debt to EBITDA Ratio
Debt to Equity Ratio
1.50
0.93
0.81
1.00 0.63 0.70 0.69
0.58
0.49 0.42
0.50 0.28 0.22 0.17
0.00
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Year
• Liquidity
Also, we must not forget to assess the company’s ability to pay its
short-term obligations. It can be done by determining the current
ratio and quick ratio of the stock.
Current ratio
= Current assets / Current liabilities
= Rm 228,528,000 / Rm 160,081,000
= 1.43
Quick ratio
= (Current assets – Inventories) / Current liabilities
= (Rm 228,528,000 – Rm 89,653,000) / Rm 160,081,000
= 0.87
As can be seen in Figure 2.10, the current ratio and quick ratio of
Latitude were lower than those of the industry averages. The current
ratio and quick ratio of Latitude in 2013 were at 1.43 and 0.87,
respectively. The current ratio and quick ratio of the industry
averages, on the other hand, were at 1.83 and 1.20, respectively. As
the management continued to pay back its debts, and continued to
build up its cash level, the current ratio and quick ratio of Latitude
improved significantly (refer to Figure 2.9), which reached the
levels of 2.62 and 1.78, respectively, in 2016.
Page | 35
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
3.00
2.62
2.50
2.03
2.00 1.78
Ratio (times)
1.63
1.43 Current Ratio
1.28 1.33
1.50
1.14 1.09 1.14 Quick Ratio
1.05
0.81 0.87
1.00
0.67 0.66
0.58
0.50
0.00
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Year
Figure 2.9: Current Ratio and Quick Ratio of Latitude from 2009 to 2016
• Activity Ratio
However, its inventory turnover ratio, 5.51, was slightly lower than
that of the industry average, 6.10. Given the increasing orders in
2013, it was sensible that the management kept more inventories so
they could fill the new orders quickly once they received them, and
to prevent shortage of stock due to unforeseen circumstances.
Page | 36
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Compared to its peers, its receivables turnover ratio, 14.72, was far
higher than that of the industry average, 6.92. This was a good sign
showing that the management were efficient in collecting its credit.
• Cash Flow
Just like managing our personal finances, we must make sure that
the company can continue its operation without running out of cash.
Therefore, we must analyse the free cash flow and operating cash
flow to sales ratio of the firm.
Page | 37
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Industry
Description 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Average (in 2013)
Revenue (Rm) 397,378,000 506,866,000 500,664,000 517,863,000 493,687,000 163,715,000
Net profit (Rm) 13,213,000 36,483,000 19,741,000 14,753,000 32,046,000 9,259,000
Net profit attributable to shareholders (Rm) 14,009,000 27,730,000 12,471,000 9,840,000 24,366,000 8,958,000
Adjusted earnings per share (Rm) 0.1441 0.2853 0.1283 0.1012 0.2507 0.1041
Net profit margin (%) 3.33% 7.20% 3.94% 2.85% 6.49% 5.66%
Profit growth (year over year, %) 0.00% 176.11% -45.89% -25.27% 117.22% 26.62%
Return on equity (%) 7.89% 14.45% 6.36% 4.69% 10.50% 8.19%
Debt-to-EBITDA ratio (times) 3.33 2.18 2.68 2.65 1.73 1.42
Debt-to-equity ratio (times) 0.63 0.70 0.58 0.49 0.42 0.17
Current ratio (times) 1.14 1.28 1.09 1.14 1.43 1.83
Quick ratio (times) 0.67 0.81 0.58 0.66 0.87 1.20
Total asset turnover ratio (times) 1.09 1.17 1.22 1.25 1.10 1.12
Inventory turnover ratio (times) 6.65 6.61 5.91 6.80 5.51 6.10
Receivables turnover ratio (times) 12.82 13.56 14.16 12.46 14.72 6.92
Free cash flow (Rm) 37,467,000 8,781,000 -11,990,000 22,938,000 47,594,000 9,194,000
Operating cash flow to sales ratio (times) 0.11 0.08 0.05 0.07 0.11 0.08
Adjusted dividend per share (Rm) 0.0387 0.0667 0.0200 0.0300 0.0630 0.0275
Price to earnings ratio (P/E) 6.40 9.31
Dividend yield (%) 3.94 2.84
Figure 2.10: Summary of Latitude Tree Holdings Berhad’s Financial Performance
Page | 38
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
To avoid paying too much for sellers, and avoid overpaying for what the
business is worth, Koon always makes sure that the Price-to-Earnings
ratio or forward Price-to-Earnings ratio of his stock does not exceed 10,
and does not exceed that of the industry average.
Price-to-Earnings ratio
= Share price / Earnings-per-share
= Rm 1.60 / Rm 0.25
= 6.40
Page | 39
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
Chapter Summary
Cash flow statement: cash flow from operating activities, cash flow
from investing activities, and cash flow from financing activities
i. Profitability:
Profit growth rate, net profit margin, return on equity
ii. Solvency:
Debt-to-EBITDA ratio, and debt-to-equity ratio
iii. Liquidity:
Current ratio, and quick ratio
Page | 40
Basic Knowledge of Fundamental Analysis
v. Cash flow:
Free cash flow, and operating cash flow to sales ratio
Do not ignore the details of financial and annual reports, and important
announcements
Latest development
Page | 41
Chapter 4:
The Biggest Behavioural
Pitfalls in Investing
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
The followers of Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) believe that the market is
always efficient, and stocks always trade at their fair value. According to this
group of investors, any changes in the fundamentals of a stock will immediately
be reflected in the price of the stock, thus making it impossible for investors to
outperform the market. However, based on Koon’s study, this is not always the
case. If the market is indisputably efficient, as advocated by the professors of
EMH, there would be no chance for those successful investors like him to
exploit any arbitrage opportunities, gain in price difference from stock
investments, and beat the market in the long run. In actual fact, the majority of
his wealth is amassed through the acquisition of substantial stakes in
undervalued companies with massive profit growth potential, and the disposal
of those overvalued ones with no or low profit growth potential in visibility.
Page | 2
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
Below are some common behavioural biases investors always fall prey to in
investing.
People always allow their emotions to take over rational thinking and
seldom use logical system to process information especially when they
are in emotionally unstable state. This situation is commonly seen
when people are in fear during bear attacks. When they are bombarded
with noise, and mentally overloaded as price plunges, the risk level
they perceive will be raised, and their faith is wavering, even though
the facts remain unchanged. Their Amygdalae (according to the study
of neuroscientists at the California Institute of Technology, Amygdala
– two almond-shaped clusters of tissue located in the centre of the brain
– is a part of the human’s limbic system that supports the functions
such as behaviour, long-term memory and emotional processing) will
induce fear, thus causing them to be conservative, and ignore bargains.
They will either avoid the stocks completely (even if the investments
are clearly high probability bets), or dump whatever they hold until the
feeling of fear subsides. The latter is akin to throwing the baby out with
the bath water, and in this situation, value is completely ignored. The
over-reaction of hitting the panic button at every Sen/Ringgit drop, and
disposing all their holdings at dirt cheap prices is the reason why
people always buy dear and sell cheap. And this problem is commonly
suffered by people who trade very often.
Page | 3
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
steel stocks have been making new historic highs every week. Koon
told me that the people he meets everywhere as well as the people he
exchanges opinions with in forums are optimistic about steel-related
companies’ future. When he advised people to be cautious, as the
oversupply of property in every city of Malaysia will affect the
earnings of some steel manufacturers, a few stubborn commenters even
asked him to shut up. According to him, this is a clear sign of allowing
greed to take over rational thinking. When the companies report
decreasing earnings later, their prices will definitely plummet, and this
group of investors is vulnerable to a loss due to the oversupply problem.
“Too many people buy stories or trends - they don't buy businesses.”
Donald Yacktman
Page | 4
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
this quarter, and face some oversupply problem, the media may frame
the situation positively by just highlighting the positive development of
the company. They would frame it in a way that “despite the tough
operating environment and uncertainty, Company XYZ managed to
sustain its profitability for the current financial year, and the
management is endeavouring to continue improving their operating
efficiency. We envisage the future outlook of the business to be
positive.” Any intelligent readers who assess the company’s profit
growth potential from a business perspective, and study its financial
reports should notice that the recent quarter’s financial loss has been
muted, and been replaced with annual earnings in the statement.
Further, they should be aware that oversupply is a serious issue. In this
case, clearly, the analyst or media is telling a story with some hidden
agendas. If anyone gives the story the benefit of the doubt, he or she
would be suffering a loss in the investment when the price drops.
Page | 5
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“Frequently the crowd is mistaken because they are not acting on the
basis of any superior information but are reacting, themselves, to the
principle of social proof.”
Robert Cialdini
As much as following the crowd makes investors feel safe, the herd
behaviour will not help them make money in investing. It is impossible
for us to achieve an exceptional result by following the crowd. Most of
investing ideas shared by the group members are inferior in quality.
Even if the investing idea that we follow is a terrific one, we can only
expect an average outcome since the prize has to be shared by so many
winners. Further, studies show that investors who follow the crowd
buying in euphoria (usually when the market is at its peak), and selling
in panic (usually when the market is at its trough) always end up with a
disastrous investment outcome.
Page | 6
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
has demonstrated again and again that most economists too failed to
foresee crisis arriving when the market was still in euphoria.
4.1.4 Impatience
Most of them do not aware that the cost of trading in and out actively is
so expensive that it could reduce their investment return substantially if
they do not control their behaviour. In addition, they have to pay a
higher price for a stock since they are not willing to wait for the right
time to buy it. Likewise, they will miss the opportunity to win big since
they sell their stock too soon before the price reaches its peak. If you
are a patient investor, and can empathise with market participants, you
would get it at a fire sale price and sell it near its peak. Patience is the
key to successful investing, but not many people realise it. That is why
Charlie Munger always says “the big money is not in the buying or the
selling, but in the waiting.”
“You have to have the courage of your convictions. That’s what you
are getting paid for. This is the time when I really earn my money.”
Bruce Berkowitz
We always see people blame god (or fate) for not giving them any
opportunity to make money, and to prosper. But, in actual fact, we
always see people hesitate to seize opportunities when they are given
chances to buy good stocks at fair prices. They have a proclivity to
procrastinate when opportunities arise. When the stocks in their watch
list meet their selection criteria, instead of scooping up the incredible
bargains immediately, they hesitate and procrastinate. They waste time
pondering over the companies’ survivability, thinking if they should
still buy the stocks, and calculating how much money they should
allocate for the investments, and so on and so forth. Also, sometimes
they will wait for the companies to show a few consecutive quarters of
Page | 7
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
earning growth before they are prepared to buy the stocks. Eventually,
when other investors gobble up the shares, the value quickly vanishes
into the thin air, and the opportunities are gone. That’s why Buffett said
in 2008 that “if you wait for the robins, spring will be over.”
Another reason why people fail to grab opportunities is that they fall
prey to anchoring bias. Investors always anchor their decisions to
outdated analyses, all-time low, or all-time high, and their previous
buying or selling price of a stock. For example, if a stock’s 52-week
low is Rm 0.50/share, most conservative investors would not be willing
to buy the stock at Rm 0.70/share, even though the business is worth
Rm 1.00/share (apparently undervalued), and it has a tremendous profit
growth potential. They would still fix their target buying price at Rm
0.50/share – the price they had missed out last time. Likewise, people
are very likely to buy a stock when it touches its 52-week low – Rm
0.50/share, even though its earnings have been decreasing, the value
has dropped to Rm 0.20/share, and there is no reason whatsoever to
buy the stock, which may put a dent in their portfolio. Another
interesting finding that I discovered is that if people sold a fast-growing
company at Rm 1.00/share a few years ago, it is very unlikely that they
will buy back the stock at Rm 2.00/share even though the stock is
undervalued.
Also, people are averse to loss, and hesitate to pull trigger after losing
money in an investment. According to Kahneman and Tversky, “the
pain of losing is psychologically about twice as powerful as the
pleasure of gaining.” Their self-defence mechanism will kick-in when
dealing with the same stocks they have suffered some losses before,
even though the stocks have a great upside potential. For example, after
losing money in a stock a couple of years ago, some investors will
hesitate to buy back the stock, even though the fundamentals of the
business have improved, and the company has reported increasing
earnings. Koon recalled that when he bought Eversendai in 2017, many
of his friends advised him not to touch the stock, as some of them lost
money in the investment a few years ago. They have got a phobia to
invest in the company, and would ignore the profit growth potential of
the stock even though the fundamentals of the business had shown
some signs of improvement.
Page | 8
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
not the short-term movement of stock price. Statistics show that stocks
are relatively cheap every time after the market crash. The worst is
always behind us when the markets bottom out. And the best time for
bargain hunting and accumulating fast-growing stocks is when they
turn the corner, or when there is blood in the streets. If we hesitate for a
minute, our rewards will be gone in no time.
Page | 9
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“Never act upon wishful thinking. Act without checking the facts, and
chances are that you will be swept away along with the mob.”
Jim Rogers
Just like gamblers, some investors also have a tendency to invest with
wishful thinking. Many of them do not invest with realistic
expectations and focus on facts; rather this group of investors lives on
wishful thinking. They follow their friends falling for the popular
myths that everyone believes. Moreover, they pay high prices for non-
performing assets, and wish that the stock prices will go higher, and
expect other fools to buy the trashes from them generously. They
should know that this type of situation is untenable, and the trend is
subject to reversal when the market wakes up one day to realise that the
stocks are unworthy of their money. Another scenario is that they buy
some good stocks at attractive prices, and then set their expected return
unrealistically high, and they wish that the market will reward them
generously for the investments. Whilst the market may sometimes be
irrational in their willingness to pay for the good assets, very often
having a disappointment for investing with unrealistically high
expectations is evitable.
Further, the investors who take a greater risk after suffering some
losses always invest with wishful thinking. They will buy more shares
with a greater sum of money after losing money in a stock in the hope
that they can win back the money they have lost in the previous
investment. As they increase the sum of their investment, they are
actually taking revenge after getting clobbered by their failed
investment, let their anger influence their judgement, and wish that the
stocks, which have reached new lows, will rebound. That is why they
buy even more shares, and up the ante as the price keeps falling. And
they wish that the rebound will occur soon. They are definitely
unprepared for the any unforeseen circumstances. If the stock price
falls lower, they will definitely be in financial trouble if they buy using
margin finance. Bear in mind that what goes up must come down, but
what comes down may not necessarily go up. Making judgements
based on a false notion, and without having evidence to support our
hypotheses is a dangerous move. Stocks seldom fall to their historic
lows for no reason. The companies are either suffering from financial
distressed, or facing oversupply problem. Never expect a troubled
company to pull a rabbit out of its hat, unless there is sufficient
evidence showing that the problem has been addressed with business
expansion, and earnings growth in the pipeline. In investing, there is no
magic dust to bail us out for our mistakes. Do not take a greater risk
after a loss. If you insist on doubling your stake in your failed bet when
the stock price falls, you must make sure that you know the root cause
of your failure, and that the odds are now stacked in your favour prior
to committing more capital to the investment.
Page | 10
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“……people are more likely to keep what they start with than to trade”
Richard Thaler
Page | 11
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
with his or her original possession, he or she will eventually miss out
on a good investment opportunity.
4.1.9 Overconfidence
Whilst both genders generally exhibit the same trait, studies show that
overconfident is more prominent in men than in women. Male hormone
always leads men to be more confident, and to make high-risk gambles.
In comparison, men trade more frequently (and often excessively) than
women, and men suffer lower returns with higher trading costs. They
always believe that the investing decisions they make are right, even
though sometimes they may not know what exactly are they doing, and
may not be aware of the presence of some blind spots and the
consequences of their decisions. Women, on the other hand, are more
likely to acknowledge their ignorance if they do not know anything
about a company, and are more risk-averse in making any investing
decisions.
Page | 12
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“We were also well aware of the dangers of what social psychologists
call confirmatory bias, in other words the tendency to collect all the
information that agrees with your position and to ignore the
information that doesn't. Behavioural theory teaches that the best
antidote to this bias is to listen to the opposite side of the case and then
dispassionately to identify the logical flaws in the argument.”
Barton Biggs
Page | 13
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
That said, it is not hard to beat the market in the long-haul game. As
those active investors, such as professional money managers, day
Page | 14
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“The first thing you have to know is yourself. A man who knows himself
can step outside himself and watch his own reactions like an observer.”
George Goodman (pseudonym Adam Smith)
Page | 15
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
Very often the failure of people in investing has been stem from not
having a good understanding of themselves. How can anyone formulate
a viable investing plan, rule and strategy for himself or herself if he or
she does not even know his or her own personality, strengths and
weaknesses? We always hear people call themselves long-term
investors, but they behave like short-term traders. They trade so
frequent that their portfolio turnover ratio is very often greater than one,
and the transaction costs will eat into their lifetime savings. Some of
the people wanted to follow those über-investors like Koon, Glenn
Greenberg, Charlie Munger and etc. to put all their eggs in only a few
baskets and watch the baskets closely, but they do not have the
stomach for concentrated investing. They do not have the discipline to
perform due diligence, to devote effort for soul searching, unable to
demonstrate the abhorrence of action, and cannot hold stocks for long-
term. After building a substantial position in a stock, they feel uneasy,
are unable to sleep well, and intend to exit their position as soon as
possible. As they dispose their holdings hastily when the stocks are
declining in price (or selling below their buying prices), their portfolios
will suffer a loss.
Page | 16
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
Having discussed about how stumbling into behavioural pitfalls can lead us
astray, we can deduce that investing is more to do with the art – of dealing with
human emotions and behaviours – and less to do with the science. Our emotions
such as greed, fear, joy, pride, exuberance, frustration, impatience, and anxiety
can be great obstacles to our success in investing. Our swing of mood, irrational
thoughts, biases, fallacies, illogical decisions, illusions, paradoxes, and self-
defence mechanisms can affect the outcomes of our investments. The
combination of the above-mentioned pitfalls is a perfect recipe for the
devastating outcome.
“The psychologist far more than the economist may be of help in deciding when
to buy”
Philip Fisher
Page | 17
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
There are many ways we can do to get to know ourselves better. One of
the methods to understand our persona is by taking Myers–Briggs Type
Indicator (MBTI) test. The test is specifically designed to identify our
preferences, attitudes, and psychological functions (extraversion,
sensing, thinking, judgment, introversion, intuition, feeling, perception
and etc.), and help defining our temperament (sanguine: enthusiastic,
active, and social; choleric: independent, decisive, goal oriented;
melancholic: analytical, detail oriented, deep thinker and feeler; and
phlegmatic: relaxed, peaceful, quiet) Source: Wikipedia. In general,
extroverted investors, with thrill-seeking gene and opportunity-oriented
strategies, like Peter Lynch, Robert Arnott and Mark Mobius, do
exceptionally well in bull markets. On the other hand, introverts like
Warren Buffett, Jeremy Grantham, Charles Schwab, and Bill Miller,
who are mostly contrarian, passive, thorough, careful, risk-averse, calm
and patient investors and enjoy in solitude, do better in bear markets.
Page | 18
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“If you took our top fifteen decisions out, we’d have a pretty average
record. It wasn’t hyperactivity, but a hell of a lot of patience. You stuck
to your principles and when opportunities came along, you pounced on
them with vigor.”
Charlie Munger
Study shows that unemotional investors who stick to their own golden
rules and game plans always walk-away with magnificent and
covetable returns. Moreover, sticking to our rules allows us to sense
danger early so that we do not put our capital at risk. Our investing
rules indirectly provide us a strong defence system, in which the rules
usually dictate the conditions and criteria each stock must meet before
it qualifies a place in our portfolios, such as the potential of business
expansion, future earnings’ trajectory, enterprise value and earnings
multiples, profit margins, cash flow trend, financial heath, and
management’s integrity, so that we can be sure of the odds are not
stacked against us.
Further, following our own rules can help addressing terminal paralysis
– a syndrome of inability to pull trigger when an opportunity arises –
and to prevent us from falling into the trap of representation bias – a
tendency to judge the probability of an event or a hypothesis based on
the resemblance of the event or hypothesis to the commonsense data
and past memory. For example, in the case of representation bias,
turnaround companies are often stereotyped as doomed-to-failure
businesses. Their potential to revive and thrive is often overlooked by
the market and is regarded as an impossible thing. However, that is an
area where enormous return could be expected if the turnaround
company that we invested in does exceptionally well. Therefore,
sticking to our rules is very important to investing success. Had Koon
not stuck to his golden rule, and had he allowed his vision be clouded
by the cognitive bias, he would have missed out on many good
opportunities.
Page | 19
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“The only way to gain an edge is through long and hard work."
Li Lu
Page | 20
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
Most importantly, never follow any tips from our friends, analysts’
reports or news blindly. We should maintain our intellectual
independence, and rely on our research work. Our friends are more
likely to be wrong than right. Study shows that about 90% people lose
money in the stock market. Our friends may not be willing to come to
our rescue when we are “stranded” in the depressed counter later for
listening to their tips. Analysts, on the other hand, always report
something good to support their own interests. Do not fall victim to
their traps. Additionally, their forecasts are seldom right. Be more
sceptical and take the reports with a pinch of salt. Some of them have
very little or no skin in the game. They are paid to write for the
companies or syndicates. Moreover, some of the tips given by opinion
makers and market pundits are inaccurate ones. They may be hyping
the stocks that they intend to sell soon. Whilst the news reported by
media may not be outdated ones, the positive factors may have already
been priced into the stocks when we buy them. Smart traders will exit
their positions once the news is released. Keep in mind that market
participants always buy the rumours and sell the news. Therefore, we
should be wary when we are dealing with the type of stocks, especially
those in a rigged market, that have gone up substantially before any
good news are released.
Page | 21
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“You must have the patience and conviction to stick with what is, by
definition, an unpopular bet.”
Whitney Tilson
People will feel nervous when their holdings plummet in price, or get
greedy when their holdings are in winning positions. They always
overreact to noise. When their friends shout “buy the stock before it
shoots up”, they have a tendency to go big into the stock. Instead of
following our friends, we should keep a level head when the market is
in the state of panic or jubilation. Study showed that level headed
investors always make wiser investment decisions than people who are
less emotionally intelligent. Also, price volatility is a part of the
investing game. If we can ignore price fluctuation and the noise, keep
our sanity, and be prudent when making important decisions, we will
do well in our investments.
People also always fail to pull trigger on their investing ideas, as they
spend too much time thinking about the company’s future when
opportunity arises. Likewise, they will be hesitating to sell their
holdings or cut loss when the fundamentals of the business have
changed, as they gamble on with a hope that their losses will be
recovered when the share prices rebound. To prevent procrastination,
we should buy immediately when a stock meets our criteria and sell
immediately when its fundamentals have changed. We should not hold
on the losers when their business fundamentals have changed. For
Page | 22
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“You need to probe a whole raft of numbers and facts, searching for
confirmation or contradiction.”
John Neff
Page | 23
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
have been found with rats infested in the engines. Whether or not we
find the reports sensible, we should perform our own due diligence
before buying into the stocks. In many cases, the morsels left may not
be worth our money.
Page | 24
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
on the roof suddenly yelling to his company, “let’s get out of here,”
just before the house explodes, and then it turns out he wasn’t aware of
when he was doing it, but his feet were warm and that was the cue that
triggered the sense that something very dangerous was going on just
underneath them.” According to Professor Kahneman, even
experienced statisticians use intuition and heuristics to solve problems
generally, instead of the complex mathematical models they have
mastered.
That said, relying solely on our intuitions can lead to some cognitive
biases in some situations. For example, an investor who relies heavily
on his or her intuition, refuses to pay heed to counterfactual analyses
Page | 25
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
and contradictory views (which will mar his or her hypotheses), and
insists that his or her intuition indicates that the same patterns will be
repeated again are highly susceptible to overconfidence bias, which
may result in a mediocre performance. Therefore, we should avoid
making judgements purely based on gut instinct, or purely use
heuristics as a solution to our problems (as heuristics can sometimes
turn into harmful biases). We should guard it with logical thinking as
well as with adequate research and analysis. Experience can only help
us to a certain extent; it cannot solve all of our problems. The most
important thing is to avoid extrapolating unrelated experience to our
decision-making process. It will result in pareidolia.
Also, despite the fact that the combination of intuitions and heuristics
works well under general circumstances and help investors make sound
decisions, new investors are not encouraged to follow their intuitions.
Their experience in this field is too little to help them make good
decisions. It takes effort and years of experimentation and experience
to form the database in their minds and reliable intuitions. Therefore,
new investors are usually advised to perform due diligence – by
conducting sufficient research and analysis – prior to placing their
wagers on stocks, and should continue doing so until a massive wealth
of experience and expertise in this area are accumulated to enable the
reliable intuitions be formed.
Page | 26
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
“You keep an open mind, keep trying to learn, stay humble and keep
trying to learn from your mistakes and other people's mistakes.”
Ken Shubin Stein
People always fall prey to self-serving bias. They ascribe their success
to their own talents and hard-work, and point the finger at external
factors for their failures. For example, some of the managers always
push blames to their subordinates for their teams’ poor performance in
order to avoid accountability. This type of cognitive bias is not just
commonly seen in the workplace, but it is also typically observed in the
Page | 27
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
field of investing. It is a sad but true fact that all of us are imperfect.
Nonetheless, people simply refuse to own up to committing their
blunders, when they have erred in their decisions, due in part to their
big ego and embarrassed perception.
Whilst all these efforts seem to humble us, they actually prevent us
from repeating the same slipups, and pave the way for us to be
successful in investing. Further, humility, which encourages us to avoid
distorting facts, and evidences to conform to our views, or justify our
errors, and make inference and judgements based on facts, indirectly
make us a rational investor. Also, it prevents our decisions, and
investments to be ravaged by our ego, harmful emotions, and other
psychological biases. For example, I noticed that people often refuse to
admit their slipups and feel embarrassed to buy back the stocks they
have sold by mistake earlier, even though the growth of the companies
is still intact. In addition, status quo bias also prevents them from
buying back what they have sold earlier. If they can see their cognitive
bias, are willing to admit their mistakes, and buy the stocks back
immediately, they should be able to capitalise on the opportunity, and
make a heck a lot of money out of it.
Page | 28
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
does not produce any direct positive return to our investments. But
human is sometimes forgetful and vulnerable to mood swings. Our
fluctuation of mood involuntarily changes the way we perceive the
market, and has an influence on our trades. For example, when our
investments produce some paper gains, we tend to become happy, and
allow the emotion to overcome our rationality. Hence, we tend to take a
higher risk, and buy a lot more shares than our original plan when their
prices go up. Do not forget that our mood is contagious. The crowd
will also be elated, and buy even more shares when the price shoots
through the roof. When the price takes a nosedive later we regret our
decisions. If we do not keep a journal of our investing activities, where
do we get the recollection of how the blunders were made when we
want to review our past decisions in future?
In our journal, we can jot down our investment ideas, research findings,
buying and selling prices for each stock, cut loss points, reasons of
buying or selling the stocks, emotional expressions or feelings, and
physical responses when we buy them. It should be noted that the
journal should not be served reporting functions or be used to vent our
frustration. If managed wisely, a good journal does not only allow us to
review our decisions, know our states of mind, spot patterns, examine
our competency, reflect on our mistakes, and prevent us falling into the
same snares in the future, it also helps us discover ourselves through
the “psychological mirror” and connect us to our inner world, including
our wisdom, and objectives in life, and enhance our learning. By
understanding ourselves better, we can refine our investing rules, and
formulate a suitable strategy, and form a comprehensive checklist that
could guide us better in our investing journey.
Page | 29
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
When the market takes a nosedive, we must use our mental power to
control our emotions, remain upbeat and stay calm even after suffering
some losses. Stick to our investing rules and keep improving them. Our
rules are the only weapon that can help us accumulate wealth in
investing. Paying attention to the fluctuation of stock prices will not
make us rich. Of course, we still need to have the courage to pull
trigger when opportunity arises. The ability to execute a trade timely
with conviction is essential to successful investing.
Last but not least, we must keep learning, reviewing our past
investments and focus on improvement. Read more investing-related
books when we are free. Benjamin Franklin once said “an investment
in knowledge pays the best interest.” By continuing to learn, we
understand ourselves better. We will discover more of our weaknesses.
Additionally, it expands the arena and façade areas of our Johari
windows, and reduces our mental blind spots. Keep in mind that our
learning does not end when we leave college. According to John J.
Ratey, a clinical associate professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical
School, “The human brain’s amazing plasticity enables it to
continually rewire and learn – not just through academic study, but
Page | 30
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
Page | 31
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
Chapter Summary
Impatience
Overconfidence
Poor self-awareness
Page | 32
The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing
Maintain humility
Page | 33
Chapter 3:
Basic Concepts of
Technical Analysis
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
3.1 What is Technical Analysis and Why You Should Learn About It?
“I always laugh at people who say "I've never met a rich technician" I love that!
It’s such an arrogant, nonsensical response. I used fundamentals for 9 years
and got rich as a technician.”
Martin Schwartz
Page | 2
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
“Since the market tends to go in the opposite direction of what the majority of
people think, I would say 95% of all these people you hear on TV shows are
giving you their personal opinion. And personal opinions are almost always
worthless … facts and markets are far more reliable.”
William O'Neil
Remember, human can tell lie, but charts do not lie. Also, people’s opinions
have very little value. Charts, on the other hand, show the amount of money
investors put on the table for their willingness to wager on the future of the
companies. Hence the change of price trend of a stock tells a better, and often a
more reliable, story about the change of the fundamentals, and future of a
company. We do not have to listen to anyone’s comments, including those from
market pundits, or analysts to make our final decisions. Personal opinions, and
comments are worthless. Just look at the trading records, or chart patterns. The
stock market is always ahead of the real economy. Any developments to the
economy will be first reflected on price charts before the effect is felt by the
general public. In addition, smart money managers, usually those experienced
analysts who are fairly accurate in their forecasts, would have invested heavily
into some high growth companies, and therefore the price would have gone up
in tandem with their business activities before the growth is reflected in their
cash flow, and income statements. Likewise, the same group of money
managers would have closed out their positions when they smell something
wrong before it is reflected in the financial statements of the company.
Technical indicators, in this case, would have given us some early warning
signals about the shift of sentiment before the impact is felt by the general
public, and would enable us to take action earlier than the crowd.
Page | 3
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
That said, we should not rely solely on technical analysis in stock picking, and
investing. It neither provides us a guarantee of 100% accuracy nor ensures us
any profitable trades. Technical analysis can only be used as a guideline to
determine a good entry or exit point. We must use it in conjunction with other
techniques, and strategies to help us find the best stocks with profit growth
potential at the best price so that we can build, and exit our position without
leaving too much money on the table.
In this chapter, we will look at some basic and useful technical analysis tools,
and indicators, which can be used to determine good entry and exit prices of a
stock, and to study its price strength.
The types of chart commonly used by investors and traders in technical analysis
can be divided into three main types, namely Line Chart, OHLC Bar Chart, and
Candlestick Chart.
Line Chart
Line chart is the simplest form amongst the charts used by investors. It consists
of many single data points, which are connected in series to form a continuous
line, or a chart. This type of charts is commonly used by Malaysian investors to
study the price pattern of stocks, and the charts can be obtained from Bursa
Malaysia. The main advantage of the charts is that they are easy to read
compared to some other forms of charts. However, line charts are not very
informative. Other than providing closing prices, they do not tell us how volatile
the share price movement is in a particular trading session. Also, a lot of
important information such as the highest and lowest prices of the trading
session, trading range, and price gaps are not included in the charts.
Below is a sample line chart of V.S. Industry Berhad share price from January
2014 to July 2014. The y-axis indicates its share price, whereas the x-axis shows
Page | 4
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
the trading period. The chart is also overlaid with trade volume information (at
the bottom of the chart).
Figure 3.2.1: Line Chart of V.S. Industry Berhad, from Jan 2014 to Jul 2014
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 3.2.2: OHLC Bars for Positive and Negative Trading Sessions
Page | 5
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Below is a sample OHLC bar chart of V.S. Industry Berhad share price from
January 2014 to July 2014. The y-axis indicates its share price, whereas the x-
axis shows the trading period. The chart is also overlaid with trade volume
information (at the bottom of the chart).
Figure 3.2.3: Bar Chart of V.S. Industry Berhad, from Jan 2014 to Jul 2014
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Candlestick Chart
As the name implies, candlestick charts comprise of candlesticks with various
lengths, to form a chart. Some candlesticks have got thin line(s) above or/and
below the real bodies, which are known as upper wick (or upper shadow) and
lower wick (or lower shadow), respectively. Compared to the two chart types
discussed above, candlestick chart is a more popular type of chart nowadays.
The size and colourful nature of the candlesticks enables users to spot price
patterns, and early reversal signals rather quick, and to make analysis easier.
From the chart we can tell if the share price is generally on uptrend, downtrend,
or going sideways. Also, we can tell whether the current trend is likely to
resume, or reverse in the near future. In addition, candlestick charts are more
informative compared to line charts. Every candlestick contains the information
of open, close, highest and lowest prices for a particular trading session. Further,
we can get the trading price range info (difference between lowest and highest
prices) from the candlestick.
Page | 6
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
A white (or green) candlestick, on the other hand, shows a positive trading
session/day. The closing price of a positive trading session is higher than the
opening price. It indicates that the bulls or buying pressure dominated the
trading session.
Below is a sample candlestick chart of V.S. Industry Berhad share price from
January 2014 to July 2014. The y-axis indicates its share price, whereas the x-
axis shows the trading period. The chart is also overlaid with trade volume
information (at the bottom of the chart).
Page | 7
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.2.6: Candlestick Chart of V.S. Industry Berhad, from Jan 2014 to Jul
2014
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
“I believe the very best money is made at the market turns. Everyone says you
get killed trying to pick tops and bottoms and you make all your money by
playing the trend in the middle. Well for twelve years I have been missing the
meat in the middle but I have made a lot of money at tops and bottoms.”
Paul Tudor Jones
Page | 8
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Page | 9
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Page | 10
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.2.2: Bearish Harami, Ucrest Berhad, on 23 Jan 2018 (Zoom-In View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 3.3.2.3: Bearish Harami, Ucrest Berhad, from Sep 2017 to Nov 2018
(Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 11
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.3.3: Gravestone Doji, BP Plastic Holding Berhad, From Jul 2015 to
Oct 2017 (Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 12
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.4.2: Shooting Star, George Kent Berhad, on 02 Mar 2018 (Zoom-In
View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 13
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.4.3: Shooting Star, George Kent, from May 2017 to Nov 2018
(Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 14
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.5.3: Hanging Man, AMMB Holding Berhad, from Aug 2012 to Jan
2016 (Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 15
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.6.2: Tweezer Top, Jaya Tiasa Berhad, on 22 Nov 2016 (Zoom-In
View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 3.3.6.3: Tweezer Top, Jaya Tiasa Berhad, from Jul 2016 to May 2018
(Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 16
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Page | 17
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Page | 18
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.8.3: Bullish Harami, Malaysia Airports Holdings Berhad, from Oct
2014 to Nov 2017 (Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 19
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.9.2: Dragonfly Doji, OCK Group Berhad, on 26 Aug 2015 (Zoom-In
View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 3.3.9.3: Dragonfly Doji, OCK Group Berhad, from Jun 2015 to May
2017 (Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 20
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
3.3.10 Hammer
Hammer candlestick pattern is usually found near the support level, or at the
trough of a declining price trend, as the initial selling pressure is subsequently
met with a great buying pressure. After the bears drag the share price to the
lowest point the bulls fight back strongly, which eventually forces the share
price closes near the opening price. As a result, a long lower wick, at least twice
the length of the candlestick body, is seen below the candlestick body. The real
body can be a white- or black-coloured body. The longer the wick, the stronger
the bullish signal. If you plan to buy on the cheap, a close above the top of
hammer’s real body the next trading session is probably a good entry point
during a short-term correction, or at the bottom of a chart.
Page | 21
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.10.3: Hammer, Tenaga Nasional Berhad, from Apr 2011 to Jul 2014
(Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 22
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.3.11.3: Tweezer Bottom, MISC Berhad, from Jul 2011 to Jan 2016
(Zoom-Out View)
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
What we have studied so far are just some commonly seen candlesticks. There
are many more types of bullish and bearish candlestick pattern, such as dark
cloud cover, rising sun, evening star, evening doji star, falling window, morning
star, morning doji star, three black crows, three white soldiers, bearish 3-method,
bullish 3-method, three inside down, three inside up, piercing pattern, and etc. if
you are interested to know about these candlesticks, you may learn about them
from Japanese candlestick patterns’ books.
Note: whilst most of the bearish reversal patterns do have a bearish candlestick,
or a few bearish candlesticks formed at the peak, we should not be terrified by
the negative candlesticks, as not of them signify the peaking of a long-term
uptrend. Likewise, we should not start buying a stock simply because a bullish
candlestick appears at the bottom of a chart, as it does not give us any guarantee
Page | 23
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
that a long-term uptrend will begin soon. We need to study them in conjunction
with other technical indicators in our analysis to make an informed judgement.
A support line is the level where investors and traders will buy aggressively,
which prevents the share price declines further temporarily. Conversely, a
resistance line is the level where people will sell like there is no tomorrow when
share price hits a particular point, which prevents the share price rises
continuously.
One of the reasons why support and resistance are formed is due to presence of
cognitive biases. For example, a trader who intends to build a position in a stock
but refuses to buy it at Rm1.00/share initially, would change his or her mind
later to buy it at Rm1.00/share if it descends to that level again after watching
the share price rose to Rm1.10, due to anchoring bias. As a result, strong
support is formed at Rm1.00 level as the trader together with other buyers who
missed the previous buying opportunity will join the buying spree when the
share price declines to Rm1.00, preventing it from falling further and causing
the share price held up steadily at Rm1.00 for a while.
Likewise, a trader who plans to exit his or her position, but reluctant to sell at
Rm2.00/share initially, will then grab the offer when the share price return to
Rm2.00/share level after the stock trades below Rm2.00/share for an extended
period of time. As a result, the resistance level is formed, at Rm2.00 price zone,
as the trader together with other sellers who missed the previous selling
opportunity will sell when its price ascends to Rm2.00, preventing it from rising
further and causing the share price to fluctuate around Rm2.00 for a while.
In this section, we will just focus on the concept of support and resistance. Other
cognitive biases will be discussed in greater detail in the latter chapter called
“The Biggest Behavioural Pitfalls in Investing”.
Page | 24
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
in the near future. The higher frequency the resistance line is touched by the
share prices, the greater significance the resistance is.
“In a bull market it is better to always work on the bull side; in a bear market,
on the bear side.”
Charles Dow
When the economy is booming, or in a bull market, stocks tend to perform well,
as demand is greater than supply; the resistance of the stocks is generally weak,
and their support is very strong. Therefore, most stocks tend to show a series of
higher lows and higher highs (refer to Figure 3.4.3). These signs indicate that
the trend is generally up. Conversely, during a correction, or a bear market, the
support of a stock’s price is generally weak, and its resistance is very strong.
Therefore, the respective stock will be displaying a series of lower highs and
lower lows (refer to Figure 3.4.2). This is an indicator of a downtrend market.
By mastering the concept, we will be able to capture the best buying opportunity
after the market capitulates, and when an upside breakout occurs. Also, it allows
us to exit our position when the downside breakout occurs. We are able to
Page | 25
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
change our direction when reversal occurs if we pay enough attention to the
signals given by the indicators.
If you have missed out an opportunity to buy a stock when a breakout occurs
earlier on, do not be disheartened. Usually when an upside breakout occurs with
a strong volume, the old resistance line would immediately become a new
support line. You may wait for a pullback near the new support level, as people
Page | 26
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
who intend to cash in their profits after the breakout would sell it down for you
to buy at the new support level. Likewise, you do not have to be nervous if you
have missed out an opportunity to sell your shares when a downside breakout
occurred earlier on. Usually when a downside breakout occurs, the old support
line will become a new resistance line. You may sell your stock near the
resistance level, as unwise “bargain hunters” would buy it and push the share
price up to the resistance region.
Trading volume is the number of shares traded every minute, day or month,
depending on the period that you choose. For instance, in a daily price chart,
each bar shown in the bar chart below share price indicates the number of shares
bought and sold in a specific day.
To beginners, other than showing them the number of shares change hand in a
particular trading day, trading volume has no other functions. In actual fact, the
importance of trading volume extended beyond the main function of indicating
the activity level of a stock.
For example, the volume data can be used to confirm the validity of a breakout.
As we know, trade volume is generated due to the buy sell activities of traders.
These activities are induced mainly by human emotions such as greed and fear,
which may cause market participants to push the share price up aggressively,
and sell down a stock in panic, respectively. If the accompanying trading
volume is low, the breakout is more likely to be a whipsaw, as interested buyers
are not aggressive enough in pushing the price upward. When the interest falters,
the breakout fails. Therefore, shrewd traders always use trading volume as a tool
to confirm a trend breakout. They would not commit their money if the volume
is too low, as the breakout could be a false one. Whilst a high volume breakout
is an ideal case, we should not discount the breakout if the trade volume is flat.
Sometimes the trade volume only picks up a few days after the breakout. Also,
we could not expect to have a high volume breakout for a stock if the trade
volume of its industry or the general market is light.
Also, learning how to read volume chart allows us avoid illiquid stocks. Many
of the stocks listed on Bursa Malaysia are illiquid stocks. These stocks cannot
be easily sold in the open market due to lack of buyers or interest in the stocks.
Page | 27
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
According to Koon, selling a stock with low trading volume is a difficult task. It
would take us weeks, if not months, to exit our position in the stock completely,
and very often with a loss, if we hold any illiquid stock.
Moving Average (MA) is one of the most useful tools in technical analysis that
we should not disregard. In the past, market technicians have to calculate
moving average data manually in order to draw MA lines, which is a tedious job.
Thanks to the invention of computer software and smart phone apps, we can
now access to the MA line chart at our fingertips, which has made analysis
easier for all investors. Moving average can be divided into three main types,
namely simple moving average (SMA), exponential moving average (EMA),
and weighted moving average (WMA).
Simple moving average (SMA) indicates the average price of a stock within a
specific period of time. For example, if we select 5-day SMA for a stock, our
charting software will take the sum of the stock’s closing prices over the past 5
days and divide the figure by 5. Whilst most of the computer programmes have
this tool or function built into their charting system, which allows users to plot
the SMA line within seconds, we may also calculate it ourselves using the SMA
formula below.
P + P2 + ...... + P5
5-day SMA = 1
5
Just like SMA, Weighted Moving Average (WMA) also shows the average
price of a stock over a period of time, but it applies more weight to the recent
data and less weight on distant past data. Since WMA gives more weight to the
recent share prices, it responds faster to the change in the share price and it is
more sensitive to share price movement than SMA. Below is the formula of 5-
day WMA.
5 4 3 2 1
5-day WMA = P5 + P4 + P3 + P2 + P1
15 15 15 15 15
Similar to WMA, Exponential Moving Average (EMA) also put more weight to
the recent past data. But it uses a more complex formula. In order to calculate
EMA, first of all, we need to calculate the SMA for the initial EMA.
Subsequently, we calculate the multiplier using the following formula
2
Multiplier = , where N is the period used.
N +1
Next, we determine the latest EMA using the following formula,
EMA = Closing Price – EMA (previous day) × Multiplier + EMA (previous day)
Note that the longer the period of time we select, the slower the moving average
responds to the change in share price. Conversely, the shorter the period of time
we select, the faster the moving average responds to the change in share price.
Page | 28
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Some of you must be wondering now which period of time is the best indicator
you should use to keep track of share price movement. Well, actually there is no
exact answer to the question. But as a rule of thumb, if you are a short-term
trader, you may want to consider using 5-day, 10-day, 20-day, 30-day moving
averages. If you are a long-term investor, I would suggest that you consider
using 50-, 100-, 150- and 200-day moving averages. Also, you may combine
four lines together, and then use the long-term MA lines crossover to devise
your strategy, and the short-term MA lines crossover to develop your buy and
sell tactics. This guideline is just a simple strategy for beginners to help them hit
the ground running, and is by no mean the only approach to increasing your
chance of making a profitable trade or investment. You may experiment with
some other moving averages, and with different time periods to find the set of
MA lines that is more suitable for you.
In general, medium- and long-term investors will buy a stock when its 50-day
moving average (DMA) line crosses up through the 200-DMA line, which is
also known as golden cross. They will exit their positions when the 50-day
moving average line of a stock crosses down through the 200-day moving
average line, which is known as death cross. Let us take Figure 3.6.1 as an
example; golden cross, and death cross formed in Jan 2017, and Nov 2017,
respectively. Had anyone bought Eversendai at Rm 0.610 when the golden cross
appeared, and sold it at Rm 0.885 when the death cross formed, he or she would
have made 45% gain out of the investment.
The reason why market technicians buy a stock when a golden cross forms is
that smart investors would have built a large position in the stock near the base,
and continue to buy when a company’s business grow, thus causes the share
price to rise. Bear in mind that a growing company with good performance is
more likely to continue thriving. Take a manufacturing firm as an example,
when its industry starts booming, the company is likely to get more and more
contracts, and is able to expand its capacity due to rising demand. When its
earnings grow in corresponding to the growing orders, so does its share price.
Page | 29
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
On the other hand, selling a stock when a death cross signal is triggered is also
important that it will protect our capital and profit. An overvalued stock will
experience a price drop until it reaches its value zone. Also, a company with
some serious problems, such as having a financial difficulty, or facing
oversupply problem, is more likely to continue showing dreadful performance.
When the correction, and problem begins, well-informed and smart investors
will start disposing their shares, which will result in the 50-DMA line crosses
down through the 200-DMA line. That is a good window for shareholders who
still hold on to the stock to escape.
“Big money is made in the stock market by being on the right side of the major
moves. The idea is to get in harmony with the market. It’s suicidal to fight
trends. They have a higher probability of continuing than not.”
Martin Zweig
The trend is our friend, do not bet against it. A stock will continue to be in
downtrend until the trend is broken, that is when its share price is either going
sideways or heading upward. In other words, a trend will continue in its original
direction until something forces it to change its direction. For example, the
business of a poorly managed company will continue to deteriorate until a
competent management team steps in to turn the business around. Investors who
refuse to heed to the signal is more likely to see their stock plunging
continuously.
In general, the trend line of 200-DMA usually reflects the underlying business
and financial health of a company; whilst the trend line of 50-DMA reflects
some new developments in the company. Moving averages with shorter time
frames mostly reflect market expectations on the company, and the occurrence
of random event which may lead to a change of the company’s business.
Also, MA lines can be used as support and resistance lines. In a bull market, 50-
DMA and 200-DMA lines can be used as support lines. Share price crosses
below the MA lines may be signalling some weakness, or indicating that the
trend has changed. Let us use the chart below (Figure 3.6.2) as an example; the
uptrend of KESM was still intact until its SMA50 (50-day SMA or 50-DMA)
and SMA200 (200-day SMA or 200-DMA) support lines are breached. Had
anyone paid enough attention to its MA lines, they would have made some good
money out of the trend. In a bear market, however, 50-DMA and 200-DMA
lines are used as resistance lines. Share price crosses above the MA lines may
be indicating that the trend has changed. That said, the MA lines cannot be used
as a sole indicator to judge if a trend has reversed. We should also use it in
conjunction with a few other tools such as chart patterns, and momentum
indicators to confirm the trend.
Page | 30
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
“To be a good trader, you need to trade with your eyes open, recognize real
trends and turns, and not waste time or energy on regrets and wishful thinking.”
Alexander Elder
In general, stock price moves in trend. That’s why common patterns can be
spotted easily in stock charts. But not many people pay attention to the patterns.
Most gamblers, and fundamental analysts do not look for chart patterns to trade.
If we are willing to devote some effort to learn how to read chart patterns, and
spend time to interpret them we would have a better grasp of mass psychology,
and would have the odds stacked in our favour. For instance, we can initiate a
position when the breakout of a pattern occurs, and then set a stop loss point (in
order to get us out in case if the market goes against our bet) and close the
position out when trend has reversed. Without further ado, let us have a look at
the common chart patterns we should not miss.
Page | 31
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
accompanied by a high volume) like this pattern is a good selling window. Once
the neckline is broken, the previous support level will become a new resistance
level, as sellers who missed the previous selling opportunity will rush in to sell
it when share price approaches the level again in the near future.
Figure 3.7.1.2: Double Tops, Prolexus Berhad, from to Feb 2015 to Sep 2016
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 32
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
the share price meets its resistance and the price retraces, thus forming the right
shoulder. The head-and-shoulders top pattern is confirmed when the neckline (a
line drawn across the left and right armpits) or support is broken down with a
close below the line. The volume at the breakdown point is usually quite high. If
you intend to exit your position in the stock, a close below the downside
breakout (breakdown) point is a good selling window for you to get out of your
position.
Page | 33
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
descending order) until breakout occurs. Volume is usually quite high at the
downside breakout point, where selling pressure is pretty strong.
Remark: whilst the price usually breaks out downward, it may sometimes go in
opposite direction. If the share price breaks out upward (above the descending
resistance line), it then signals the start of a bullish trend. As traders and
investors, we must always pay attention to the direction where the breakout
occurs prior to making our trade decision.
Figure 3.7.3.2: Descending Triangle, Aeon Berhad, from Jan 2018 to Dec 2018
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 34
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Page | 35
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.7.5.2: Bearish Symmetrical Triangle, A-Rank Berhad, from Sep 2016
to May 2018
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 36
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Page | 37
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
it, you may use the range as a guideline to set your price target, where you may
exit your position when your price target is reached.
Figure 3.7.7.2: Double Bottoms, British American Tobacco Berhad, from Feb
2018 to Jul 2018
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 38
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
found a window to get in, the breakout actually provides you a good opportunity
to buy it at a very low risk. After buying the stock, if you do not intend to hold it
for long-term, you may use the height between head and neckline as a guideline
to estimate how high the share price can reach, and use it to plan for your exit.
Page | 39
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
charts of uptrend stocks. It gives the stocks chances to take some breathers
before they continue the ‘marathon’. If you have missed the boat earlier on, but
still want board it, this is an opportunity for you to catch it when the breakout
happens. That said, you should not act hastily. It is advisable that you wait
patiently at the sideline until the breakout occurs when you see this type of chart
pattern. If you have sold your shares by mistake earlier on, you may buy back
the shares to take advantage of the bullish momentum. If you plan to add to your
position, the breakout also provides you an opportunity to buy more at a lower
risk level. For traders who have no plan to hold the stock for long term, you
may use the height of its base as a guideline to set your price target, where you
can exit your position when the price is reached.
Remark: whilst the price usually breaks out upward, it may sometimes go in
opposite direction. If the share price breaks down or breaks out downward
(below the rising support line), it then signals the start of a bearish trend.
Figure 3.7.9.2: Ascending Triangle, Apex Healthcare Berhad, from Jun 2016 to
Aug 2018, from Jan 2017 to Jul 2017
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Page | 40
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
3.7.11 Cup-with-Handle
A Cup-with-Handle pattern is a bullish pattern signalling the continuation of the
previous bullish trend after a period of share price consolidation, as selling
pressure dissipates, and buying pressure regains its lost ground. A close above
the breakout point (and old high) confirms the pattern. Volume tends to be high
Page | 41
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
at the breakout point, as there is more enthusiasm from eager buyers than
pessimism from disheartened sellers. It usually happens due to some new
developments, positive news announcements, or a change in market sentiment.
You may start building a position in the stock, add to your profitable position,
or even buy back the shares you have sold earlier on when the breakout happens.
Remark: breakdown may occur within a short period of time after the breakout
if the cup with handle formation is an improper base. Therefore, we should also
pay attention to the formation of the cup.
Figure 3.7.11.1: Cup-with-handle, Malaysia Steel Works Berhad, from Jan 2016
to Nov 2016
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
People will turn greedy when the share price of a stock keeps rising to an
irresistible level. Likewise, investors will feel anxious, and become panic when
the share price sinks like a stone. Of all the indicators we have learnt so far,
none of them could give us a guarantee that the emotions of market participants
have changed. Therefore, we need another set of indicators to confirm the
signals of change in human emotions.
Page | 42
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Below are some useful leading and lagging momentum indicators that can help
us get a better grasp of mass psychology, and increase our probability of finding
the next uptrend stock near the inflection point, or buying an uptrend stock near
the turning point of a minor correction before the share price surging upward
again, by assessing the change in human emotions when people turn greedy.
Let’s use Figure 3.8.1.1 as an example for discussion. If you had bought
Mycron Steel when its MACD line (light blue) is above the base line and
crosses above the signal line (orange) at Rm 0.590/share, and sold it when its
MACD line (light blue) crosses below the signal line (orange) at Rm
0.895/share, you would have made 51% profit out of the trade.
Figure 3.8.1.1: MACD-Signal Line Crossover, Mycron Steel Berhad, from Aug
2016 to Oct 2016
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Another function of MACD line is to find out if the trend is about to reverse, by
spotting the divergence between MACD line and share price movement. For
example, even if the share price shows higher highs, when the MACD line
forms lower highs, it reveals that the current price trend is unsustainable, and
reversal is likely to happen in near future. This is a bearish signal. If you intend
Page | 43
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
to exit your position, you may get ready to dispose your shares when a bearish
candlestick appears subsequently.
Let us use the previous example, Mycron Steel, for discussion. We can see from
Figure 3.8.1.2 that its MACD had formed a lower high (from late Sep 2016 to
early Nov 2016) even though its share price kept showing higher highs. The
divergence was a warning sign indicating that the prevailing uptrend was
unsustainable. Had any of its investors paid an attention to the signal, they
would have exited their position in the end of Oct 2016 without leaving much
money on the table.
Figure 3.8.1.2: Price-MACD Divergence, Mycron Steel Berhad, from Sep 2016
to Dec 2016
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Let us take a look at the chart of CIMB share price (Figure 3.8.2.1) below. The
RSI of CIMB crossed below the oversold line in mid-Jan 2016, but its share
Page | 44
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
price kept falling until late Jan 2016. The price only ceased falling when RSI
crosses above the oversold line (RSI 30) in late Jan 2016. The RSI then moved
upward until it crossed above the overbought line and subsequently crossed
below the line in mid Mar 2016. Had anyone bought it at Rm 3.94/share when
the RSI line crossed above the oversold line, and sold it at Rm 4.75/share when
the RSI line crossed below the overbought line, he or she would have made
about 20% profit within two months. Not too shabby though.
Figure 3.8.2.1: Price-RSI crossover, CIMB Group Holdings Berhad, from Oct
2015 to May 2016
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Similarly, the divergence concept can be applied when using RSI indicator. The
trend is about to reverse when the divergence between RSI and share price
movements occurs. For example, even though the share price of a stock shows
lower lows when it is on a downtrend, if its RSI shows higher lows, it reveals
that the current price trend is unsustainable, and reversal is likely to happen in
near future. That is a bullish signal. If we plan to build a position, we may get
some dry powder ready, and buy it when a bullish candlestick appears.
Let us use the same example, CIMB Group Berhad, for discussion. From the
chart below (Figure 3.8.2.2), we can see that even though the share price of
CIMB kept falling from Jun 2015 to Jan 2016, its RSI had ceased making more
lower lows. That was an early sign of trend reversal. Had any investor paid a
close attention to the indicator in Jan 2016, he or she would have made some
money out of the reversal.
Page | 45
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.8.2.2: Price-RSI Divergence, CIMB Group Berhad, from Mar 2015 to
Jan 2017
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
The example below (Figure 3.8.3.1) shows that the share price of Dialog Group
increased about 22% when its ROC was having a positive momentum from 17
Dec 2014 to 22 Dec 2014.
Page | 46
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.8.3.1: ROC-Baseline Crossover, Dialog Group Berhad, from Nov 2014
to Feb 2015
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
The divergence concept can also be applied here when using ROC indicator.
The trend is about to reverse when divergence between ROC and share price
movements occurs. For example, even though the share price of a stock shows
lower lows when it is on a downtrend, if the ROC shows higher lows, it reveals
that reversal is likely to happen in near future. That said; do not take it for
granted, especially when the share price of a stock starts advancing. When the
price starts to advance, ROC will be surging to a very high level, the subsequent
advance may probably not be able to produce a higher ROC. If you sell the
stock after getting a lower but positive ROC, you may be kicking yourself later
for selling it too early, when the share price continues to advance again. You
should use the indicator in conjunction with other indicators to make an
informed judgement.
Let us use the same example, Dialog Group Berhad, for analysis. The surge of
its share price was actually not an accident. In fact, before the surge, its ROC
had made a couple of higher lows from 9 Dec 2014 to 16 Dec 2014 even though
its share price went downhill. That was a sign of impending trend reversal.
Page | 47
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Figure 3.8.3.2: Price-ROC Divergence, Dialog Group Berhad, from Oct 2014 to
Feb 2015
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 3.8.4.1: Price-A/C Relationship, Favelle Favco Berhad, from Oct 2013 to
Apr 2014
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 3.8.4.1 above shows that the share price of Favelle Favco Berhad was on
an uptrend when its A/C indicator showed a positive gradient, as investors had
been accumulating it from the end of 2013 to mid-Feb 2014.
Page | 48
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Whilst A/C indicator support and confirm share price movement most of the
time, divergence does occasionally occur. When it happens, we need to pay a
close attention to the share price movement and confirm the signal using other
momentum indicators. More often than not when share price climbs higher, but
A/C indicator is on a downtrend, then the share price is likely to fall later.
Likewise, even when share price continues to fall lower, but the momentum
indicator is on an uptrend, then the share price is likely to rise later. Remember,
the divergence, when occurs, always tells a different story even if share prices
continue to move higher or lower.
Figure 3.8.4.2: Price-A/C Divergence, Favelle Favco Berhad, from Nov 2013 to
Oct 2014
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Let us use the same example, Favelle Favco Berhad, for discussion again. We
can see from Figure 3.8.4.2 that after its A/C reading peaked in mid-Feb 2014,
the indicator had begun to fall even though its share price was still making
higher highs. That was an early warning showing that the uptrend was not
sustainable.
What we have discussed earlier in this chapter are just some basic tools in
technical analysis every serious investor should know. Actually there are many
other tools, such as ADX Line, Chaikin Money Flow (CMF), Force Index,
Money Flow Index (MFI), On Balance Volume (OBV), Stochastic Oscillator
and etc., can be used to determine the momentum of share price movement. If
you are interested to learn more about these indicators, you may learn them
from technical analysis books. But, mind you, just because you are using more
tools in your analysis does not mean that you will be getting better results.
When it comes to investing, more is not always better. It all depends on your
skill level, and competency in using those tools. In fact, good chartists or
successful technicians only use a few simple tools they are good at to study
trends and analyse share price movement, and trade with conviction when a
reliable signal (or a confluence of several signals) is spotted. Most importantly,
Page | 49
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
you need to know which type of investor you are. Are you a scalper, a day
trader, a swing trader, or a long-term investor? Choose a set of tools that is
suitable for you.
Again, we cannot stress enough the importance of volume in all the above-
mentioned trends. Never underestimate the importance of trading volume, and
the volume of buy and sell queue orders. A valid breakout is usually
accompanied by a high trade volume. Without having an unusually high volume
to support a share price movement, the breakout might be a whipsaw, or a false
signal, as people are not buying in greed. The trend is not sustainable and it
might reverse soon due to the lack of momentum.
“I believe that good investors are successful not because of their IQ, but
because they have an investing discipline.”
Stanley Druckenmiller
“After spending many years in Wall Street and after making and losing millions
of dollars I want to tell you this: It never was my thinking that made big money
for me. It was always my sitting.”
Jesse Livermore
“Don’t be a hero. Don’t have an ego. Always question yourself and your ability.
Don’t ever feel that you are very good. The second you do, you are dead… my
guiding philosophy is playing great defence. If you make a good trade, don’t
think it is because you have some uncanny foresight. Always maintain your
sense of confidence, but keep it in check.”
Paul Tudor Jones II
Another important advice from Koon is not to let our ego affect our judgements
and decisions. If we realise that the trend has gone against us, just cut loss, and
move on. Do not be a kamikaze investor in the stock market. “There are old
soldiers and there are bold soldiers, but there are no old, bold soldiers.” Cut
loss will protect most of our capital so that we can live to fight another day.
Last but not least, technical analysis is not a perfect tool. Just like fundamental
analysis, it too has its own flaws. How can we invest our hard-earned money in
a stock based its share price movement alone without even knowing who is
running the company, and if the future of the company is bright? If we want to
Page | 50
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
be able to sleep well at night whilst leaving our money to work for us in the
stock market, we also need to tap into the power of our experience, business
sense, and intuition in the judgment making process before deciding to invest in
a company.
Page | 51
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
Chapter Summary
The three main types of charts commonly used in technical analysis are Line
Chart, OHLC Chart, and Candlestick Chart.
A support line is the level where traders will come in to buy aggressively,
which prevents the share price declining further temporarily. Conversely, a
resistance line is the level where people will sell like no tomorrow when
share price hits a particular point, which prevents the share price rising
continuously.
Smart traders also use support and resistance determine the validity of a
trend so that they won’t play on the wrong side of the game.
Trading volume does not only indicate number of shares change hand over a
period of time, it also can be used to confirm the validity of a breakout, and
the significance of a trend. Further, it allows traders to avoid illiquid stocks.
Short-term traders and long-term investors also use fast- and slow-moving
MA lines crossover to find good buying and selling points and use the line
as a support or resistance line to determine whether a trend has changed.
Page | 52
Basic Concepts of Technical Analysis
When using momentum indictors, do not just focus on signal line crossover,
we should also pay attention to the direction of share price movement and
the indicator’s trendline. When the divergence ensues, it always tells a
different story even if share price continues to move higher or lower.
Just because you are using more tools in your analysis does not mean that
you will be getting better results. When it comes to investing, more is not
always better. It depends on your skill and competency levels in using those
tools. In fact, good chartists or successful technicians only use a few simple
tools they are good at to study patterns and analyse share price movement.
Most importantly, do not to let your ego affect your judgments and
decisions. If you realise that the trend has gone against you, just cut loss and
move on. Cut loss will protect most of your capital so that you can live to
fight another day.
Just like fundamental analysis, technical analysis is not a perfect tool. You
also need to tap into the power of your experience, business sense, and
instinct in the judgment making process.
Page | 53
Chapter 5:
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
How to be a Superinvestor:
“Investment success does not require glamour stocks or bull markets. Judgment and
fortitude were our prerequisites. Judgment singles out opportunities, fortitude enables
you to live with them while the rest of the world scrambles in another direction.”
John Neff
People are keen to know how Koon attains such a spectacular performance, and how
he makes so much money in the markets. They must be thinking that he got the level
of mastery in investing because of his inborn talent. As far I know, the wealth Koon
has amassed so far is mostly from the effort he puts in to learn and earn from his
businesses and investments. Albert Einstein once said “genius is one percent talent
and ninety-nine percent hard work.” Of course, it is good to have an aptitude for
investment, but we still need to devote a lot effort to nurture the investing talent
within ourselves before we can become a good investor. No one is born a
superinvestor. It takes knowledge, skills, correct actions, patience, and experience,
and lots of trainings to be a superinvestor. These are the main ingredients that we need
to excel in investment. Even those well-known superinvestors took years, if not
decades, to acquire, practice, and refine their knowledge, learn from their mistakes,
form their investing philosophies, and learn to control their emotions before they
achieved their current status and results.
For example, during market crash in 1961-1962, Carl Icahn lost all the money he
earned since his Army days. But he later on said that, “going broke was good, because
I grew so much from it and realized that I had to learn more than anybody else about
something.” By acquiring the right recipe, and working hard, he staged a series of
striking rebounds after the crash, and he eventually became one of the most successful
investors in the world. With a $16.6 billion net worth under his belt, he was ranked
number 55 in Forbes 2017 Billionaires List.
Similarly, the Great Depression and stock market crash in 1929 nearly wiped John
Maynard Keynes out financially. But he got back stronger in the game after the crisis,
and after refining his philosophy by switching from top-down investing method
(macro strategy, which is relying on the predictions of economic performance to
choose stocks in the industries that generate the highest returns) to bottom-up value
investing approach (which is selecting stocks based their intrinsic values, dividend
yield rates, cash flow, future earnings, and business prospects). His innovative style,
recognition of mass psychology, and animal spirits play in the market, and long-term
investing method enabled the funds he managed, including the endowment fund of
King’s College, Cambridge, the fund of the National Mutual Fund Society, the fund
of the Provincial Insurance Company, and the personal funds of his friend, family and
himself, grew exceptionally well, and outperformed market indexes almost every year
thereafter, except 1938 and 1942.
By now some of you must be thinking that one has to be very skilful at predicting the
next market crash (or boom) to be a successful investor. Far from it – none of the
superinvestors, at least not that I heard of, have the ability to predict short-term
market movement. The competitive advantage they possess over ordinary people is
their positive learning attitude, high mental strength, solid financial knowledge, and
high self-awareness. Therefore, to be a superinvestor, we do not need to master the
Page | 2
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
skills of predicting the next market crash, or short-term market movement. What we
need is to mimic the traits, habits and behaviours of superinvestors, and follow the
advice given by Koon, based on his years of observation, and his personal experience,
below. Once we have appreciated, embraced them, and have them ingrained in our
DNA, nothing can stop us multiplying our wealth; only the sky is the limit.
“Rather than guessing where the market or the economy may be headed, here is a
little rhyme to help you remember a better way to decide when to buy stocks:
When stocks can be found at cheap prices,
the time is ripe to buy.
When appropriate values cannot be found,
the market is too high.”
Charles Brandes
5.1 Trait 1: Ability to Buy Stocks Whilst Others are Panicking and Sell Stocks
Whilst Others are Euphoric. Be an Intelligent Contrarian Investor
“The time to get greedy is when everybody’s running for the hills with fear.
That’s usually a great time to get the greed going.”
Bruce Berkowitz
There is a famous axiom in the investment world that the market is driven by
two factors: greed and fear. When the economy improves, people become
bullish about the market. The greed in people will boost their confidence level,
stimulate their risk-seeking behaviour, encourage them to chase the winners,
and result in poor decision making. As they assume that the stocks are on the
fast track to profit growth, and are fixated to short term gains, they are more
than willing to pay enormous premium for the growth, which results in the
prices of the stocks being bid up to an overvalued level. Unfortunately, over the
long run, the business performance of most growth stocks in Malaysia tends to
revert to the mean, as their profit margins eroded when more and more
unforeseen competitions arrive to share the piece of pie. Ignorant investors who
bid up the stocks to astronomical levels at later-stage are then vulnerable to
huge financial loss.
During bear attack, when stock prices take a nosedive, the innate fear of losing
in human will be triggered. The self-defence mechanism then kicks in
immediately. People will suddenly become risk averse. In addition, the
exaggerated bad news cast over the media will result in stress and overloading
of brain’s capacity. When the emotions are combined with the herding mental
shortcut (belief of following other people selling is safer than doing it
differently), it leads to panic selling, as the depressed investors unwittingly
allow their emotions to overcome rational thinking in the decision-making
Page | 3
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
process. This is the reason why the speed of share price falling is much faster
than that of rising, and the portfolios of people who sell in panic during
financial crisis are always severely damaged.
Superinvestors, on the other hand, understand that the market cycle and the
mood of market participants resemble the movement of the pendulum swinging
back and forth to the extremes of its arc. By staying the course and staying sane,
they are able to see a wider market view clearly, and able to avoid those dire
mental pitfalls. During market crash, when everyone is in a panic state, they
remain unemotional, cool and calm. They know that no matter how gloomy the
weather is, when the dark cloud overcasting the sky disappears, the earth will be
brightly lit again. They know that the market can experience many boom and
bust cycles, but it will not collapse. And no matter how severe the damage
caused by the financial turmoil, given some time, good companies will
eventually return to their glory day again. Therefore, superinvestors are able to
seize the opportunity to buy aggressively with conviction when stock prices
plunge. When the crowd is in a euphoric state, the superinvestors are happy to
sell their stocks at higher prices, even if they could not sell them at the peaks,
and they then spend the lonely time sitting on their cash to wait for another
perfect time to swing their bat again. Instead of following the crowd, stories,
fads or hypes, they follow their selection criteria, investment philosophies, focus
on risk management, and stay level-headed.
That said, it does not mean that superinvestors will buy all kinds of undervalued
stocks. In any depressed markets, good bargains can be found effortlessly. If
they split their money evenly to buy all the undervalued stocks in the market,
not much of fund can be allocated for the truly good stocks with high growth
potential. Instead of buying all the undervalued stocks, superinvestors buy them
selectively. They pick only one or just a handful of remarkable stocks that meet
their selection criteria, and buy them as much as they possibly can. For example,
they look for high-probability events, and they only buy those undervalued
stocks that they understand the businesses well, companies with trustworthy
management, and businesses with strong competitive advantage, and most
importantly stocks with tremendous profit growth potential in large quantities.
By being intelligent contrarian investors, they can be sure of their winning
possibility even before the deals are executed.
5.2 Trait 2: A Great Investor is One Who is Obsessive about Playing the Game
and Wanting to Win. These People Do Not Just Enjoy Investing; They Live
It
“We wake up every morning and go to sleep each night thinking about stocks.
When you are as focused and obsessed as we are, you develop certain tenets
about investing.”
Mario Gabelli
Page | 4
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
“Very few people had the tenacity I had. I’m a very competitive guy. Passionate
or obsessive, whatever you want to call it. And it’s in my nature that whatever I
do, I try to be the best.”
Carl Icahn
According to studies, most people do not enjoy investing even though they trade
stocks. If you ask any of the people you meet in stock brokerage house what
motivates them to buy or sell stocks, I am very sure the answer -- and the only
answer -- you will get is “to make some money”. Neither they have a set of
rules to guide them in investing nor do they have any clearly-defined
methodologies to buy or to sell stocks. They trade stocks with gambling-like
emotion. They buy on news. Most of them do not know that before any good
news is released; the price of a stock has gone up substantially. That is probably
the worst time to buy stock. The worst thing is that some of them even refuse to
cut loss when the stock falls and they realise that they have made mistakes.
They hope that the price of their holding will rebound, so that they get to sell it
at their breakeven price. By the time when they decide to sell the stock, as they
have frustratingly held the underperforming stock for a long period of time, the
stock price is probably at its lowest level. All in all, they are not making money
from stock trading, but are funding their trading with their lifetime saving or
with the money earned from their day jobs. How can we expect someone who
keeps losing money in stock trading to enjoy playing the game?
Superinvestors enjoy what they are doing. They know their circle of competence,
and they know how to increase their odds of winning in the game. They are loss
averse, and always do their best to reduce the risk, or to protect their capital.
Therefore, they only invest in companies they can understand the businesses
well, and companies with profit growth potential so that they get to enjoy the
snowball effect of wealth accumulation. Further, they never stop learning about
investing. They spend most of their time reading and acquiring knowledge.
They keep refining their philosophies, skills, methods, and strategies. They
perform post-mortem on all their trades, so that they can improve their results,
and become better investors. Moreover, they constantly study their failures, be it
in analysis, or in decision making process. Because of their passion and
Page | 5
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
Despite their wealth, they do not stop investing. Why? Because their main focus
is not on money, but rather on their objectives and targets, to test their
philosophies, and to leave a great legacy. They know that if they follow their
golden rules, and the path they have chosen, the monetary reward is beyond
their imagination when they reach their destination. To them, money is just a
scorecard, and a form of reward for their brilliant ideas, and magnificent
philosophies, and making tonnes of money is not their main goal. The amount
of money they need to enjoy the freedom and independence is far lesser than
what they possess. That is why Koon donates so much money to schools, and
universities, and for needy people and society. Sir John Templeton once said
“Do something where you’re performing a real service for people. It’ll be a
success. I like investment counselling. And I like helping others. It gives you
pleasure you can’t get spending thousands of dollars.” Therefore, earning
tonnes of money is not their priority in investing. If money is their main
motivator, they would have stopped investing after becoming millionaires, but
they did not stop – and will never stop.
5.3 Trait 3: A Good Investor is One with Willingness to Learn from His or Her
Past Mistakes and to Analyse Them
“While most others seem to believe that mistakes are bad things, I believe
mistakes are good things because I believe that most learning comes via making
mistakes and reflecting on them.”
Ray Dalio
“Granted, we all make mistakes. The important thing about making errors in
judgement is the ability to admit those errors. If you grow into adulthood unable
to acknowledge your mistakes - in life, as well as investing - you will learn your
lessons the hard way. Only when you recognise your mistakes will you be able
to make corrections necessary to put yourself on the right path.”
Jim Rogers
Page | 6
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
Superinvestors are no different from ordinary investors; they also make a lot of
mistakes in their investments, and are not afraid of making mistakes. Jean Paul
Getty once said there is nothing shameful in making mistakes once, but
repeating the same mistakes is a disgrace. Therefore, superinvestors constantly
look out for their own biases and flaws in their investing philosophies, critically
analyse their theses and decisions, ready to admit and correct their mistakes,
appraise them, and avoid them in the future, so that they do not compound them.
This is the reason why Bruce Berkowitz said “We spend a lot of time on
mistakes and asking why we make them. It’s great for the investment process.”
And at the Value Investing Congress of 2009, David Einhorn shared the practice
with people that “when something goes wrong, I like to think about the bad
decisions and learn from them so that hopefully I don’t repeat the same
mistakes”.
However, most people never learn from their past mistakes. This is apparent
during bull markets. They tend to repeat the same mistakes again and again, and
become arrogant after pocketing some profits from their recent bets. Their fear
of loss has evaporated. Their egos have grown so big that hardly any sincere
advice and invaluable opinions can get into their head until they experience
another great setback. Their inflated confidence will lead to overestimation of
ability, and underestimation of risks. As the winning streak continues, they have
the propensity to put all dangers behind them, break their own investment rules,
ditch their old philosophies again, and join the herd singing “this time is
different”. In fact, the self-serving bias is a hindrance to seeing the imminent
danger, and the reality is the history still repeats itself. Most of them will not see
the disaster coming until the moment they are about to fall off the cliff one by
one like lemmings. It is undeniable that winning big is so easy and the
temptation is so irresistible when stock price soars, but how many people
managed to pull the hand brake timely at the edge of the cliff. Before 1997 --
Asian financial crisis, money invested in any stocks, including those hot stocks
with businesses bleeding financially, could be easily turned into “gold”. But
how many people managed to walk away happily after the bubble burst?
Page | 7
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
Some of the superinvestors, on the other hand, like to keep a journal or a diary
of their investing records for self-reflection. They understand that human
memory is only suitable for remembering stories, but not good at recording facts.
By keeping a journal of the information of stocks he or she purchases, his or her
emotional state and mood before making decision, and how the decisions are
arrived at for the investments, he or she can reflect on his or her past mistakes,
so that he or she is not susceptible to the same mistakes. Moreover, he or she
can regulate his or her mood, and control his or her emotions, so that he or she
won’t repeat the same mistakes again in the future.
“Forgive yourself for your errors. Don’t become discouraged, and certainly
don’t try to recoup your losses by taking bigger risks. Instead, turn each mistake
into a learning experience. Determine exactly what went wrong and how you
can avoid the same mistake in the future.”
John Templeton
5.4 Trait 4: An Inherent Sense of Risk Based on Common Sense. You Must
Have the Common Sense to Realize the Risk of Buying Any Share Which
Has Gone up A Lot and When All the Analysts are Recommending Buy.
Always Take an Analyst Report with a Pinch of Salt
“Economics and markets cycle up and down. Whichever direction they’re going
at the moment, most people come to believe that they’ll go that way forever.
This thinking is a source of great danger since it poisons the markets, sends
valuations to extremes, and ignites bubbles and panics that most investors find
hard to resist.”
Howard Marks
"It is our opinion that the consensus view finds comfort in groupthink and
therefore pays little attention, if any, to the historical accuracy of the agencies
publishing these estimates."
Arnold Van Den Berg
Very often people buy or sell shares solely based on their projections, charts or
news. For example, speculators make their purchase decisions based on the
assumption that the share prices will grow continuously without even using
some common sense to examine the risk levels of the investments. This over-
optimism problem always results in overpaying for a stock, and underestimating
valuation risk.
Similarly, some analysts perform valuation only based on the balance sheet or
using those financial models with complex formula, five-decimal-place numbers
and all sorts of Greek symbols. Some chartists, on the other hand, make buy
calls solely based on the charts with the underlying business performance and
companies’ future largely ignored. If we buy stocks in uptrend motion or stocks
with a healthy balance sheet, but with no profit growth potential, or with
oversupply problem, the money that we pour into the investment will not be
working productively for our wealth, and the likelihood of losing money is
fairly high.
Page | 8
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
Whilst it is good to read some economic news and analyst reports to keep
ourselves abreast of world development and to get some investment ideas, we
should not accept the entire information, news, and analysts’ projections without
processing them. Be wary of the flaws in analysts’ projections and views.
Always take analysts’ reports or news with a grain of salt, and be sceptical of
the so called “experts”, especially when they express optimism about the future
of a company. we have seen many people who reacted quickly to news and
analysts’ reports ended up having their fingers burned. Making buying or selling
decisions immediately after reading news and reports is not investing, it is
called gambling. Gambling is a dangerous game, which is highly susceptible to
psychological biases.
5.5 Trait 5: Great Investors Have Confidence in Their Own Convictions and
Stick with Them, Even When Facing Criticism
“To succeed as a contrarian you must recognize what the crowd believes, have
concrete justification for why the majority is wrong, and have the patience and
conviction to stick with what is, by definition, an unpopular bet.”
Whitney Tilson
“Soros has taught me that when you have tremendous conviction on a trade,
you have to go for the jugular. It takes courage to be a pig. It takes courage to
ride a profit with huge leverage.”
Stanley Druckenmiller
“Because I became worried about the Japanese stock market in the late 1980s
due to its gigantic credit boom, we sold all of our Japanese stocks in mid-1988.
Some investors questioned us for pulling out from the second largest stock
Page | 9
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
market in the world, but I said it’s better to take some money off the table than
to participate in market mania. Obviously, I was wrong and unhappy in the next
18 months because the market went up another 30 percent, but in 1990 when the
market collapsed, we owned nothing in Japan and our decision was proved
logical.”
Jean-Marie Eveillard
In late 1990s, when the whole world embraced the speedy advancement in
Information Technology, and when people believed that the revolution would
also change the doctrine of conventional investment method, and that a new
approach assessing investment based on growth model should be employed, a
minority group of people adamant that they would shun high tech stocks, and
would continuously look for undervalued stocks ditched by Mr. Market. This
group of investors is no others except value investing followers. And most of
them are superinvestors, who had millions, if not billions of dollar assets under
their management. According to Bill Ruane, one of the superinvestors Warren
Buffett mentioned in his essay called the Superinvestors of Graham-and-
Doddsville, “The recipe for delivering superior long-term performance requires
equal parts of picking the right stocks and avoiding the wrong ones. We were
not even tempted to join the recent speculative frenzy in the dot.com sector.” At
the same time, near the peak of the dot com boom, Jean-Marie Eveillard said “I
would rather lose half my shareholders than lose half my shareholders’
money,” as he believed technology stocks were overvalued, and he foresaw the
Dot Com bubble would burst soon.
Not only did the media criticise them for their old-fashioned investment style,
many of their clients also puzzled why did not they buy a single share of those
fabulous technology stocks. Their answers to the public were that they really
concerned at the high valuation of those information technology stocks, and that
they only invested in stocks they have an edge and with low risk. They insisted
that only when having informational, analytical and psychological advantages
over the crowd would they deploy their capital for the investment. Following
the crowd to chase those glittering stocks was not the game in which they would
participate. Their convictions were later proved right when the internet bubble
burst, and their funds achieved double-digit returns in the same year. Their due
diligence and convictions did not only protect them from the loss of capital, but
it ensured that the odds were in their favours before they committed their capital.
In his interview with Ronald Chan in 2012, Jean-Marie Eveillard mentioned that
“Our fund had total assets of around $6 billion in 1997, but by 2000 it was
down to $2 billion. I was unhappy, but I constantly reminded myself that I was
acting in the best long-term interests of our investors, so I had to do the right
thing. When the mania was over, investors came back and praised our
discipline. The fund [the First Eagle Global Fund] today has a size of close to
$30 billion.”
The Dot Com mania mainly stems from the emotional, cognitive errors and
psychological biases of human. Human’s greed and fear is the root cause of
bubble forming and bursting. Financial losses or economic recession is just a
by-product of the crisis, not the root cause. The similar type of nightmare will
always come back to haunt people again and again in different contexts. For
Page | 10
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
example, the subprime crisis in 2008, and Asian financial crisis in 1998 began
with greed and ended with fear. If we stick to a sound approach, have faith in
our convictions, only buy fundamentally good stock with growing profits and
profit growth potential, maintain our belief, even in the face of peer pressure,
stay sane, and are not easily swayed by market sentiments, or any other fishy
stories, we are not only able to detect bubbles, but are also able to capitalise on
human’s psychological biases to make tonnes of money in the stock market in
the future.
“If you stay rational yourself, the stupidity of the world helps you.”
Charlie Munger
“You need to divorce your mind from the crowd. The herd mentality causes all
these IQ’s to become paralyzed. I don’t think investors are now acting more
intelligently, despite the intelligence. Smart doesn’t always equal rational. To
be a successful investor you must divorce yourself from the fears and greed of
the people around you, although it is almost impossible.”
Warren Buffett
Common stock is the best financial tool for rational investors to amass their
fortune over the long haul, but the worst vehicle for irrational investors to even
preserve their wealth. The discrepancy between the traits of these two types of
investors (rational and irrational investors) is that the former always stick to
their dispassionate analysis, whereas the latter allow their emotions to control
their judgement. As a result, irrational investors cannot think clearly in their
decision-making process. This behaviour is very evident during bear stampede
that this group of investors always busy despondently dispose all their holdings
whilst the clear headed superinvestors keep hunting for undervalued stocks in
the same market.
One of the reasons why people cannot think clearly, and sell stocks panicky
during market crash is that they do not know the actual worth of the businesses
when they bought the stocks. According to studies, most of the investors do not
like to read financial reports; many of them do not even bother to understand the
companies’ businesses. They buy the stocks solely based on hope that the stocks
will decuple in a few weeks. During economic crisis, when everyone rushes to
sell the stocks, and analysts also give strong sell recommendations; there is no
Page | 11
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
reason for them not to liquidate their positions hastily, as the hope has vanished
into thin air.
Another factor why people are captive to the bias is that they use emotions in
their decision-making process. In comparison to the systematic and logical
approach, this method yields quicker results and is effortless. Instead of
performing due diligence, such as analysing the underlying business
performance, profit growth prospects, and value of the business, this system
uses some mental short-cuts based on similarity and familiarity to judge what
the market will do next. For example, when the system receives some negative
news of a stock, it will link the news to price fall, and will trigger the fear of
losing money. In such case, the most natural reaction the system will take is to
sell the stock quickly without investigating further. The massive disposal of a
stock will then lead to its price plunging. Likewise, the fear of loss also causes
people to ignore bargain. Therefore, this group of investors tends to lose their
lifetime savings in a very short cycle, and is unable to capture the rare
opportunity when the stock price running out of control. This is the reason why
Walter Schloss advised people “try not to let your emotions affect your
judgment. Fear and greed are probably the worst emotions to have in
connection with the purchase and sale of stocks.”
As Koon recalled, in 1983 when the Hong Kong stock market crashed, as China
Government gave notice to the British Government to take back the sovereignty
of Hong Kong, the Hang Seng Index went down below 1,000. The fear that the
“Chinese Communists” were going to rule Hong Kong led to the massive
disposal of shares in the market as if there were no more tomorrow. He
identified one of the undervalued stocks called HK Realty & Trust. Before the
crash, it was selling at HK$ 13.60, and during the crash it was selling at
HK$ 3.60 per share. Moreover, its audited accounts showed that its cash value
per share was HK$ 10.00. During the crash, he bought the stock as much as he
possibly could. As soon as China granted a 50-year extension of the lease, the
market rebounded and HK Realty & Trust shot up above HK$ 15.00, so as most
of the other counters. The market had a new lease of life, and every investor
quickly jumped in to buy. As his holdings went higher, he could buy more
shares on margin finance, and the rest is history. The opportunity for him to
make a mint during the crash was mainly attributed to the greed and fear in
people. Had the market been more rational responding to the news, and been
able to overcome the psychological pitfall, it would have not been possible for
Koon to earn so much to afford 46% of stake in Kaiser Stock & Shares Co Ltd.
“To be a very successful investor you have to be able to avoid some natural
human tendencies to follow the herd. The stock market is going down every day
your natural tendency is to want to sell. And the stock market is actually going
up every day your tendency is to want to buy. So in bubbles you probably should
be a seller. In busts you should probably be a buyer. You have to have that kind
Page | 12
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
“The value investor sees this volatility and says, “What a great opportunity.”
However, the masses generally say, “This stock is way too risky, I’ll pass.” We
are full believers in the “buy low, sell high” investment philosophy, so to us this
would be a great opportunity.”
Arnold Van Den Berg
Every investor wishes to receive a windfall gain from his or her stock
investment. However, the fact is, not many people can win in stock investing.
Why is it so?
One of the reasons why so many people lose money in the stock market is that
they allow their investment thought and decision making processes to be
influenced by their emotions. For instance, when a company reports a sudden
drop in profit, they will be sceptical about the company’s future, and
immediately sell the stock without probing further what drives the cost up or
causes its profit drop. The hasty decision without further thought is always the
biggest regret of investors when the stock he sold shows increasing profits in the
following quarter and next year.
Gamblers, on the other hand, would sell their original holdings to buy some hot
stocks if they heard from their neighbours or brokers that the stocks would be
doubled in three months, even though some of the original holdings they
disposed are high yield stocks with bright profit growth prospect. Coincidentally
Christopher Browne also shares the same finding with us. In his book titled The
Little Book of Value Investing, Browne stated that “Most people seek
immediate gratification in almost everything they do including investing. When
most investors buy a stock, they expect it to go up immediately. If it doesn’t, they
sell it and buy something else.” The myopia always leads to ignorance of the
underlying business, and overemphasis of short-term gain. What they are
interested in is making a quick profit. Most of them hope to become millionaires
overnight. When the hot stocks lose momentum and head south, the late comers
will be spooked by the selloff, and tend to sell immediately at a loss. Therefore,
it is hardly surprising that some people have never even won a dime in their
investments.
Page | 13
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
their investment thought easily. They do not follow the crowd buying any hot
stocks. They know what the crowd doing is wrong. This statement is further
supported by Robert Cialdini’s finding that “quite frequently the crowd is
mistaken because they are not acting on the basis of any superior information,
but are reacting, themselves, to the principle of social proof.” Superinvestors
will not stray from their principles, and golden rules. What they normally to do
are buying a handful of stocks with marvellous profit growth potential
according to their plans after performing due diligence, and then they watch the
stocks unfold their fantastical tales themselves patiently, and let their prices
increase gradually. Their investment horizon is usually two years or even longer.
And they understand that there will be some peaks and troughs along the way.
That’s why they adhere to the principle of 7Ps -- Proper Planning and
Preparation Prevents Piss Poor Performance. Regardless of market volatility,
they always stick to their investing rules, investment philosophies, and methods
even when they are facing criticism.
Page | 14
Seven Traits of Superinvestors
Chapter Summary
Trait 1: Ability to buy stocks while others are panicking and sell stocks
while others are euphoric. Be an intelligent contrarian investor.
Trait 2: A great investor is one who is obsessive about playing the game and
wanting to win. These people do not just enjoy investing; they live it.
Trait 3: A good investor is one with willingness to learn from his or her past
mistakes and to analyse them.
Trait 4: An inherent sense of risk based on common sense. You must have
the common sense to realize the risk of buying any share which has gone up
a lot and when all the analysts are recommending buy. Always take an
analyst report with a pinch of salt.
Trait 5: Great investors have confidence in their own convictions and stick
with them, even when facing criticism.
Page | 15
Chapter 6:
KYY’s Golden Rule and
Complementary Guidelines
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
“Try to find a business that you can understand, that’s not particularly
complicated, that has a successful long-term track record, makes an attractive
profit and can grow over time.”
Bill Ackman
In this chapter, we will discuss the golden rule, and complementary guidelines
developed by Koon after refining his investing philosophy for three decades.
The method has been proved profitable and sound through numerous tests in
sideways, bull and bear markets. It has helped him build massive wealth so he
can donate more and more for good causes. In addition, the method has
benefitted many of his disciples.
The method is very simple, and does not require one to have an MBA or a PhD
in finance to achieve a good result. Only the discipline to follow his golden
rules closely and complementary guidelines, and the ability to control emotions
are the quality needed to be a successful investor in Malaysia stock market.
6.1.1 Buy Stocks with Profit Growth Potential, which Have Delivered
Two Consecutive Quarters of Increasing Earnings
Page | 2
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
The task of finding a company with profit growth potential may, at the
start, seem challenging for many novice investors with weak business
acumen, but if we persist in our quest for the prospect by asking
ourselves if the future profits of the business will be higher than its
recent profits and past profits, we should be able to find the answer.
The process will prompt us to search for catalysts embedded in the
business, and to identify the competitive advantages the company
possesses, and with which we will be able to make an informed
judgement, and enjoy a higher probability of success.
Page | 3
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
Page | 4
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
“We don’t get into things we don’t understand. We buy very few things, but we
buy very big positions. Know what you own, own a few and buy a lot.”
Warren Buffett
“Soros has taught me that when you have tremendous conviction on a trade, you
have to go for the jugular. It takes courage to be a pig. It takes courage to ride
a profit with huge leverage.”
Stanley Druckenmiller
Buying profitable stocks with bright earnings growth prospect helps protecting
the value of our capital, buying and selling them at the right prices and at the
right times help reaching our destination faster. Therefore, the complimentary
guidelines are as important as his golden rule.
6.2.1 Only Buy the Stocks that You Can Understand Their Businesses
Page | 5
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
The answers to all these questions will tell us a lot about the company’s
future. The future of the company is likely to be bleak, and the
potential growth of the business is almost none if the negative answers
far outstrip the positive answers. With the effort devoted to
understanding each of the businesses, we stand a higher chance of
finding a fabulous investment, even though terrific companies or
outstanding management teams are hard to come by.
Please note that, whilst the businesses and the corporate structures of
most companies are easy to understand, some are pretty complicated
for common men, especially novice investors, to understand well. If
you happen to come across any company that is too hard for you to
understand its business, just give it a miss and move on to the next one.
6.2.2 Make Sure that the Companies have A Good Track Record of
Making Money
Page | 7
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
However, for the same stock with the same amount of earnings, if we
pay Rm 20 for each of the shares, the P/E would be 20. In other words,
it would take the company 20 years to earn us back the amount of
money we have invested in the stock. The return is estimated about 5%
per year, which is far lower than that of the former.
Please note that what we discussed just now was P/E concept, not
projected P/E. To calculate the projected P/E of the stock, we need an
estimated or projected EPS, instead of the recent past EPS. The recent
past EPS does not tell us what will happen to the firm in the next
twelve months or in the future. We cannot drive forward looking in the
rear view mirror, even though the rear view mirror is clearer than the
windscreen. The market does not care about the past EPS. Therefore,
we can only use the information of the recent past quarters as a
guidance. Ultimately our investment success still depends very much
on our ability to accurately forecast the future earnings of the firm, and
to find out how cheap the stock is, based on its current price. To
precisely estimate the projected P/E of a company, we must be able to
make an educated guess on its future EPS. Therefore, understanding
the business of a company plays an important role in determining the
earning power of a firm. We could not capture an opportunity timely
when it arises, if we choose to ignore the business of a company.
Page | 8
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
wonderful price, we get a lot more shares for our money, and our
wealth will grow instantly. But done at a wrong price, our investment
will sink like a stone. Each time when we overlook the value of a
company or buy an overpriced stock, our investment return will be
jeopardised. In order to achieve our goal faster, we should look for
stocks with projected P/E lower than 10. The projected P/E multiple
limit of 10 does not only help increasing our rate of investment return,
it also allows us to close out without badly hurt if the tide turns against
your original investment thesis or if your forecasted EPS gets terribly
off, and help reducing some other unforeseen risks.
Most of the eminent investors like Carl Icahn, George Soros, Robert
Kiyosaki, Bill Gross, Stanley Druckenmiller, J. Paul Getty, used
leverage to their edge. With leverage, they created more value for the
money entrusted by their investors as well as built their own fortunes
faster.
Whilst novice investors are not encouraged to use margin facility in the
beginning stage of stock investment, he or she should learn how to use
it through pre-mortem and subsequently review the process
continuously. Once he or she has acquired sound investment
knowledge, have gained sufficient experience to make high conviction
investments, and have the ability to devise a winning strategy, he or she
may start using leverage to his or her advantage.
Page | 9
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
The most prudent way to manage the margin loan is to refrain from
buying stocks up to the allowable limit. When the companies we own
report increasing profits, their share prices and our collateral value will
follow along; this will allow us to buy more shares. If you are tempted
to buy with the increased collateral value, you may go ahead to do so,
but do not borrow more than the allowable limit.
6.2.6 Sell Some that were Previously Bought Using Margin Loan
Page | 10
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
our shares is when they start reporting diminishing profits, or when the
demand for their products has shown some deterioration signs. Stock
prices will sink into red when the companies show poor performance.
If we refuse to sell the losers and keep them longer in our portfolios,
we do not just pay high amount of interest for the loan; our portfolios
would also be vulnerable to margin calls.
Share prices seldom drop without a cause. There are many reasons why
share prices decline. But two of the main causes, deemed important by
the market, are lower profits (or financial loss), and higher supply than
demand. The price of a stock will be losing its ground when its
earnings begin to decelerate, or if the company reports financial losses.
Similarly, the share price will take a nosedive if the industry in which
the company get involved plunges into recession out of sudden due to
supply glut problem.
Novice investors have been warned by Koon many a time about the
danger of buying down trending stocks or catching a falling knife, yet
many of them pay no heed to his advice. As a result, they risk their
hard-earned money to the permanent loss of capital when the company
reports losses continuously, becomes a PN17 company, or files for
bankruptcy protection. In the light of the consequences, we should
avoid down-trending stocks at all costs.
When the price of a stock starts to fall, no one knows when the price
will be bottoming out under such circumstances. Even a company, with
a strong management team, that suffers temporary setback due to
industry downturn, and that is less susceptible to bankruptcy risk will
not be spared from the same fate. It will keep trending downward, and
may fall below its underlying value to an irrational level. What is
worse, the stock may even take a very long time to bounce back to the
Page | 11
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
previous level, and may never recover at all. If we buy the stock on the
way down, we are literally putting good money after bad, our capital
would be locked in the stock for a long period of time, and we would
suffer emotional pain when the price keeps hitting new lows.
According to John Maynard Keynes, the market can stay irrational
longer than we can stay solvent. Many good opportunities will just be
passing us by when our capital is locked in the money-losing stock.
Buying a stock at the right price, if not the lowest price, is so important
that it provides us a margin of safety, which protects us from any
unforeseen circumstances. Selling the stock at the highest price is
equally important so we can maximise our gain, and it allows us to
achieve our goal sooner. However, both processes require us to be
patient.
Even if we managed to buy a stock at the best price, it does not mean
that we will be able to rake in the highest profit from the investment.
Koon has shown this concept to his followers many times that three
people who begin a competition by buying the same stock at the same
price can end up returning home with three different rates of return.
The first person, who shares the philosophy and strategy of traders by
watching the stock market and chart diligently and trade frequently,
realises his or her gain after the share price has gone up by 20%, and
buy it back at a higher price when the subsequent buying signal is
triggered again. The second person, who is a very well-informed
professional investor, sells his or her stock after the share price has
gone up by 100%. The third person, who is an entrepreneur and a
superinvestor, holds on to his or her existing shares and keeps buying
more shares using margin loan when the company continues to report
growing profits. He or she only closes out his or her position when the
company shows reduced earnings after riding the uptrend for years.
Amongst three investors, the first person can only expect a mediocre
return. Every time when he or she trades, he or she does not only pay
more commissions or transaction fees, he or she also fails to capitalise
on the opportunity to ride the uptrend fully when the company keeps
reporting increasing profits. The second investor, on the other hand,
can expect a better rate of return as he or she holds the stock longer
than the trader and sells it at a higher price. However, he or she refuses
to buy back the stock after selling it, even though he or she realises
later that the stock still has plenty of upside potential, as he or she
Page | 12
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
becomes risk averse when the stock has appreciated considerably and is
reluctant to admit his or her mistake by buying back the stock at a
higher price. The third investor, who can wait patiently, will enjoy the
highest gain as he or she possesses the composure to deal with stock
price fluctuation and focuses mainly on the profit growth prospect of
the company. To amplify his or her return, he or she uses the shares as
collateral to buy more shares when the company continues to increase
its profits.
People tend to get nervous during bear attack. When investors are in
panic state, the news of market tumble or share price collapse will
bypass the prefrontal cortex (an area where rational thoughts are
conceived) since the forebrain section has been starved of oxygen and
nutrient due to stress and overload. It will result in the signals be sent
to medulla directly. The autonomic nervous system is subsequently
triggered, and heuristics are then used to ease the cognitive load by
disposing stocks on hand as fast as possible. This system is very
helpful when a person is in an emergency state such as during fire
breakout, explosion, earthquake and accident. The self-defence action,
however, always leads to cognitive biases and disastrous investment
outcomes. We have seen it many times that people who dumped stocks
at nonsensically low prices during bear market regretted later when the
prices of the stocks recovered, as far as panic selling is concerned. That
is why even most wonderful stocks can be purchased at bargain prices
during market crashes. If you can control your emotion you should
know when to buy, and when to sell, and you should be able to make a
heck of a lot of money at the big moments.
Page | 13
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
The success of all gurus in stock investment is not credited to their high
intelligence quotient or their unparalleled knowledge in investment, but,
by and large, attributed to their ability to control their emotions well
and to invest with conviction. According to Warren Buffett, investing
is not a game where the guy with the 160 IQ beats the guy with the 130
IQ. He added further that once you have ordinary intelligence, what
you need is the temperament to control the urges that get other people
into trouble in investing. Opportunities come infrequently, when it
rains gold, put out the bucket not the thimble. During bear attacks,
most of the investment gurus become fearless; when everyone is fearful.
During bull runs, they stand firmly on the rational ground when
everyone is flooded with euphoria. They are willing to go against the
crowd to buy more shares of good companies at lower prices when
Page | 14
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
There are several reasons why we should not own more than eight
stocks in your portfolio. The first reason is that the additional stocks we
add into the portfolio will not reduce the risk significantly. Moreover, it
may reduce the overall gain of our portfolio. Suppose we have a
portfolio consists of eight stocks worth Rm 10,000 with an overall gain
of 20%, we add another eight stocks worth Rm 10,000 with an average
gain of 5% into our original portfolio the following week, and our
overall gain will eventually be reduced to 12.5%.
The second reason why we should not own more than eight stocks in
our portfolio is that the more stocks that we own in our portfolio, the
lesser the amount of time and effort we can allocate to monitor the
performance of each stock or each business. If we limit the number of
stocks in our portfolio to a maximum of eight carefully selected
companies, it does not only save us more time, we can also keep track
of their progress easily. All businesses have different challenges and
obstacles at different times to overcome. If you can keep track of them,
you will know when to buy and when to sell to make more profit.
Page | 15
KYY’s Golden Rule and Complementary Guidelines
Chapter Summary
Complementary guidelines
i. Only buy the stocks that you can understand their businesses
ii. Make sure that the companies have a good track record of making
money
vi. Sell some that were previously bought using margin loan
x. Control your emotion of fear, greed, ego and over confidence. Logical
thinking is the key to successful investing
Page | 16
Chapter 7:
The Art of
Concentrated Investing
The Art of Concentrated Investing
One of the most important investment strategies we should learn from Koon is
concentrated investing, which is referred to as investing in a limited number of
securities, with odds are in our favour. If you are a follower of Koon, you would
have noticed that Koon is in the camp of concentrated investing, and he does not
like the idea of broad diversification. According to him, the only way to make
big money is by betting on either one stock or a few promising stocks, which
have shown two consecutive quarters of earnings growth and have demonstrated
revenue and profit growth potential. He does not only practice it religiously; he
preaches the concept of concentrated investing to all his followers.
You might be wondering how many stocks you must own in order to be
considered concentrated investing. According to Koon, as a rule of thumb, one
should hold no more than three stocks in three different segments if the size of
the portfolio is not too big, generally less than Rm 100,000. But, if the size of
the portfolio is larger than Rm 100,000, the investor may put the money in more
baskets in order to spread out the risk of the overall investments. That said, it is
not advisable to hold more than eight stocks in the portfolio, as Koon believes
that we may have difficulty to achieve satisfactory return, and may have a hard
time to monitor all of them. Even though as large as a few hundred million
ringgit the size of Koon’s portfolio is, he has never owned more than eight
stocks at a time. In fact, he always tries to limit his major investments to just
three stocks.
It is worth noting that Koon is not the only one who adopts the investing
concept; many shrewd and successful investors, including Jim Rogers, Mark
Minervini, Kristian Siem, George Soros, and Stanley Druckenmiller, to name a
few, also do the same. They pick only a few stocks that they have conviction in,
and make sure that the odds are skewed in their favour before they wager their
entire fund in the stocks. This is how they invest in the markets, and how they
make their fortune.
“Soros has taught me that when you have tremendous conviction on a trade, you
have to go for the jugular. It takes courage to be a pig. It takes courage to ride
a profit with huge leverage. As far as Soros is concerned, when you’re right on
something, you can’t own enough.”
Stanley Druckenmiller
For astute investors, concentrated investing is the best way to maximise gains,
and to grow wealth. Successful people have a tendency to invest fully in a few
of businesses they dedicate their lifetime effort to. This practice is very common
in world of business, where we see most of the successful businessmen or
businesswomen are very focused in their undertaking. They spend their time and
Page | 2
The Art of Concentrated Investing
energy on what matters the most, and have their money invested only in the
companies they founded. For example, in Malaysia, the wealth of Public Bank’s
Chairman Teh Hong Piow, Hartalega’s founder Kuan Kam Hon, and Press
Metal’s CEO Koon Poh Keong is all tied to their stakes in their own companies,
and the performance of their stocks. The reason why they do so is that they
know their own businesses much better than they know about other companies,
and that concentrating their bet in just a few companies is a better way to
growing wealth. Similarly, in investing, concentrated investing is also an
excellent approach to magnifying gains if we have good investment ideas, we
know exactly how the companies make money, and we are on the right side of
the game.
Since stepping into the stock markets, we have seen countless of people going
from rags to riches within a short period of time, and have witnessed people
falling into bankruptcy in the blink of an eye. Having observed nearly all the
emotions of people in the stock markets, and having seen their reactions
following their losing trades, truth be told, we believe that the approach –
concentrated investing – may not be suitable for everyone.
Page | 3
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Investors who bet blindly might get a nasty shock if they are not mentally
prepared for any unforeseen circumstances. As they follow the advice of some
securities analysts or market pundits blindly when these so-called financial
experts pound the table on a stock, the investors may not be aware of the
presence of uncertainties and risks associated with the stock. When share price
tanks or a disaster breaks out, their confidence is shaken, and they will be
suffering from stress, anxiety, depression or/and insomnia. Consequently, their
normal everyday lives are disrupted by the mental illness. In the preceding
chapter, we have studied the finding of Kahneman and Tversky that the
magnitude of pain experienced by human when losing money is greater than
that of joy when winning the same amount of money. If one is unable to deal
with the mental stress or handle other psychological challenges, it is best to
avoid this type of investing game.
Also, people who have a poor record of financial planning definitely should not
try their luck with this type of game. The stock market is a dangerous battlefield.
Without having a viable investing strategy, sound investing philosophy, high
emotional intelligence, and good money management skills, making the
concentrated investing attempt is akin to playing Russian roulette. There would
be no back-out, and your life savings would turn into dust if you fail. Can you
imagine how your family members would live when the life savings, which can
be used to provide comfortable life to them and to provide quality education for
your children, disappear down the rathole?
Page | 4
The Art of Concentrated Investing
put forth some effort to learn, and follow the guidelines outlined below, you are
less likely to lose money in the game. Also, the strategy enables you to hit the
ground running faster than you would otherwise.
First thing first, pick the stocks with bright earnings growth prospect
that have reported two consecutive quarters of increasing profits. If the
slogan for success in real estate investing is “location, location,
location”; for stock investing, it must be “earnings growth, earnings
growth, earnings growth”. Based on Koon’s observation, however,
most investors and investment professionals overly concentrate on
balance sheet, dividend yield, and technical analysis, and fail to notice
the importance of profit growth. They do not think like a businessman.
But the best way to mint money in the stock market is to invest like a
businessman in companies with high profit growth prospect. To be
really successful in investing, one must be willing to venture like an
entrepreneur, and focus on the profit growth prospect of a company.
Out of a thousand-plus counters in Bursa Malaysia, we must pick only
a few stocks that have truly tremendous profit growth potential and get
stronger sequentially each quarter.
But mind you, in the world of business and investing, any of the
outcomes is possible. Our judgments may sometimes go wrong due to
some unforeseen circumstances such as natural disasters, sabotage,
sudden reversal of governmental policies, and etc. The stock market
may crash after we have built our position, and the prices of our stocks
may fall. Nonetheless, if we invest in stocks with incredible profit
growth potential underpinned by the combination of near-term and
long-term catalysts, based on something we know best and with high
level of confidence, we are less likely to lose money. The least we will
not be stuck with something that we have never wanted to hold in our
portfolio. In addition, it will reduce the downside risk of our
investments.
Page | 5
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Please note, however, that not all stocks with projected P/E lower than
10 are cheap stocks. Many cyclical stocks are traded at low projected
P/E multiples at the peak of their up cycles, especially when their
earnings have been rising for several quarters or years. According to
Peter Lynch, “Buying a cyclical after several years of record earnings
and when the P/E ratio has hit a low point is a proven method for
losing half your money in a short period of time.” In order to ensure
that a stock is truly cheap, we need to estimate the ballpark figures of
the company’s earnings for the next couple of quarters or years, using
some business sense, prior to estimating its projected P/E. If the
earnings growth is not sustainable, it is highly unlikely that its share
price will increase. Once we have found a bargain stock, we can begin
to invest in the stock if we believe that its growth is on the cards.
Otherwise, we should wait patiently for the right time to swing for a
home-run.
Page | 6
The Art of Concentrated Investing
During correction, the stock market is rife with negative news and bad
sentiments. What we need is an unwavering confidence in our
investing principle. Ignore those scaremongers who often spread
frightening bad news, especially during market correction. Do not be
afraid to buy when we have found a good one. After discovering the
gem, we must monitor its progress and share price, and then buy the
stock immediately once our price target is hit. Remember, to score a
home run, we need to position ourselves right, and hit the ball hard
when the opportunity arrives.
“More money is lost listening to brokers than any other way. Trading
requires an intense personal involvement. You have to do your own
homework.”
Michael Marcus
Koon always says, “No share can continue to go down for whatever
reason and no share can keep climbing up and up indefinitely for
whatever reasons.” At some point, the stock will take a short rest prior
to resuming its trend. When the price of a stock goes up too fast within
a very short period of time and the slope is too steep, its resistance will
increase, as selling pressure builds up. When it approaches the
resistance zone, we can cash in a fraction of our profit by selling some
of our shares into strength. Then we jump right back in near the
Page | 7
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Scenario 1: buy-and-hold
Let’s suppose that Koon buys 10,000 units of a promising stock, DEF,
at Rm 0.50 / share with Rm 5,000 initial investment, as shown in the
table below. Koon holds the stock until it is fully valued and then sells
it at Rm 1.10 / share for Rm 11,000, which gives him just a gain of Rm
6,000 or 120%.
Page | 8
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Note that our success in trading around a core position lies in our
ability to interpret market participants’ emotions. For example, when
the pendulum has shifted too much in the direction of greed, we must
get ready to sell, and then prepare to buy back the shares when the
market is in fear, in order to increase gain. To do so, we can use
Turning Point Investing principle or Fibonacci Extension and
Retracement method to determine the best time to take further actions,
such as increasing our position.
Page | 9
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Technical analysis is one of the tools we can use to find the turning
point of a stock. We can start buying it back when its resistance is
broken. The resistance is typically broken when bulls prevail over
bears and when their earnings have improved, as either their businesses
have expanded or the recovery of their industries has started to gain
traction. The breakout usually heralds a round of upward move. Taking
some calculated risk by buying shares at the inflection point can be a
rewarding one.
Chart Patterns:
Page | 10
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 11
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 12
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 13
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 14
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 15
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 16
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 17
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Momentum Indicators
Page | 18
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 19
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Page | 20
The Art of Concentrated Investing
7.4.6 Be Patient
Having the ability to identify good companies can only help us find the
right horse, it is patience that can get us to the place where we want to
be ultimately. After identifying an undervalued stock, we have to wait
patiently to buy it. Our investments will be jeopardised if we act hastily
in the stock market. Warren Buffett once said “the stock market is a
device for transferring money from the impatient to the patient.”
Page | 21
The Art of Concentrated Investing
principles, and should be happy with the outcomes of our effort. Even
if it does not turn out the way we wanted it to be, we chalk it up to
experience.
Bear in mind that the market hates negative news and uncertainty, and
it is short-sighted. People have a tendency to sell their holdings
immediately when market sentiment turns sour. As a result, they have
to pay higher prices to buy back the same stocks when there are any
good news later. If we invest in a promising stock with the objective to
magnifying gains, but we dispose it before the share price rising due to
mental stress, we are literally following the herd shooting ourselves in
our foot. Remember, the market can be at times inefficient, but it
cannot always be wrong. When thinking goes deeper, ignorance
recedes. The true value of a stock will be reflected in its price one day
when its earnings grow, and the negative sentiments wane.
“Stock trading is not an on-off business; moving from cash into equities
should be incremental. You should start off with pilot buys by initiating
smaller positions than normal; if they work out, larger positions should
be added to the portfolio soon thereafter. This toe-in-the-water
approach helps you keep you out of trouble and building on your
successes. If you’re not profitable at 25% or 50% invested, why move
up to 75% or 100% invested or use margin?”
Mark Minervini
Page | 22
The Art of Concentrated Investing
To begin with, we can use 20% - 35% of our money to buy a stock like
Koon, and set aside 65% - 80% of the money as a “war chest”. As the
name implies, the fund allows us to buy more shares on the cheap
when the price goes lower (note: do not buy until the stock turns up)
after our initial purchase if the profit growth prospect of the company
remains intact. Also, we can use the money to add more shares into our
portfolio when the price continues to rise as the company continues to
report increasing earnings until it does not grow anymore or when the
fund is the exhausted. However, the amount of money allocated for
each successive batch of shares should be lesser to prevent the cost
rises significantly.
Example:
Let’s suppose that we have Rm 100,000 in our account, and we would
like to invest in a stock called ABC. We can buy the stock in seven
batches as follow.
Page | 23
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Am
oun
t:
Rm Rm
Amount:
1,5
7,200
00
Amount: Rm 9,800
Share price: Rm 0.70
Amount: Rm 13,000
Share price: Rm 0.65
Amount: Rm 16,500
Share price: Rm 0.60
Amount: Rm 22,000
Share price: Rm 0.55
Amount: Rm 30,000
Share price: Rm 0.50
If we invest using margin trading account like Koon, we may use the
additional margin from our unrealised profits to buy more shares as the
share price goes higher. The advantage of using this system is that the
amount of each successive purchase will automatically be smaller.
Therefore, we do not have to worry that the cost may be rising too fast.
This concept is also known as pyramiding. That said, we must not use
up to the maximum allowable limit of the margin finance. Always
allow some room in case the share price suddenly drops unexpectedly.
Note: if you are the breadwinner of your family, you need to set aside
an emergency fund – six to twelve months of your family’s monthly
expenses. Prior to making any investment decisions, it is advisable that
you take your family’s needs into consideration when making capital
allocation. No matter how great the deal you discover, you should not
touch the money in the fund under any circumstances. A blow to your
investment can sink your family into financial hardship. Therefore, you
must make sure that your family is protected financially before
pursuing your new adventurous investment journey.
Invest our hard-earned money in a wrong company can be even more painful
than stashing our cash under the mattress. You certainly do not want to have
Page | 24
The Art of Concentrated Investing
sleepless nights for investing in a losing stock. The best solution is to have those
unsuitable companies removed from your watch list at the beginning of the
process.
Below are the types of companies Koon usually avoids betting his money with
For example, crude oil price dropped about 40% (from $115 to $70)
within six months in the second half of 2014 due to oversupply
problem, as US shale producers ramped up production, OPEC refused
to scale back on production, and the demand of oil from China shrank.
As a result, the earnings of many oil and gas companies sank into red
between 2014 and 2018, with some going into liquidation later on.
Holding on to their shares could be very painful, and the road to
recovery was not smooth. The shareholders would see their stocks
continued to get clobbered and their accounts continue to bleed.
Sometimes, the shareholders may not have a chance to see light at the
end of the tunnel. To avoid being stuck in the stocks that will go
nowhere for years, it is best to shun this type of companies before
recovery begins.
Page | 25
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Do not touch any stocks that we cannot understand their businesses and
structures within ten minutes. Based on Koon study, if we do not
understand the businesses, estimating their earnings can be very
difficult, let alone valuing their businesses. The higher the complexity
of a business and ownership structure is, the lower the accuracy of our
projections can be. Also, this type of companies is rarely efficient.
When available resources are split over several businesses, with no
relationship at all, hardly this type of companies can grow at a fast pace,
as the synergistic effect is lost.
Most of the great businesses like Public Bank, Liihen, Gamuda, Yinson,
IJM, Favelle Favco, Supermax, Dayang, Dialog, V.S. Industries, and
etc do not have complicated structures. Their structures are quite
simple. Anyone looking at them can understand the businesses and
organisations fairly quickly. As they are focused and do not go beyond
the areas of their core competencies. They possess some forms
competitive advantage over their competitors. When they perform well,
their values will grow noticeably, so are their stock prices.
One is unable to turn a great investment into a big profit unless he or she can
sell his or her shares at good prices. In this case, finding the right time to sell a
Page | 26
The Art of Concentrated Investing
7.6.1 Take Some Profit off the Table if the Share Price Goes Up Too
Fast
There are many indicators we can use to judge if the share price of a
stock has gone up too fast. Amongst the commonly used indicators, the
following three indicators, which we have discussed in Chapter 3, are
the most popular ones,
• Price curve. We may sell some when its share price begins to
show the sign of exhaustion or retracement after it surges up,
far above 10-day EMA line, as the temporary buying frenzy or
euphoria has waned.
• Momentum indicator. We may sell some shares when
momentum indicator (i.e. RSI or Stochastic indicator) crosses
below the overbought line.
• Bearish candlestick pattern. We may sell some when a bearish
candlestick pattern (i.e. bearish engulfing, tweezer top,
hanging man, bearish Doji star, shooting star, etc.) appears
near the peak of recent advance.
Page | 27
The Art of Concentrated Investing
7.6.3 Liquidate Your (Long) Position when Any of The Stocks Reports
Two Consecutive Quarters of Decreased Profits
The best time to sell a stock is when the company reports two
consecutive quarters of decreased profits. That is, usually, the time
when the share price of a company would start falling down seriously.
Koon usually starts selling some of his shares when the stock he owns
shows a quarter of reduced profits to reduce his margin loan, and will
sell them aggressively when it reports two consecutive quarters of
decreased earnings until he has no more share left in his trading
accounts.
Sometimes parting with our favourite stock can be very painful, especially when
the value of our stock and our account are under water. But, in order to protect
our capital, we need be objective and have our emotions detached from the
stock whilst investing. Below are the situations in which we need to be decisive
to get out immediately when our investment goes wrong.
Bear in mind that our investment criteria is the best defence system in
our investment. We are susceptible to a loss if we ignore the warning
signal. According to Koon, every time when he ignores his golden rule,
his fund will wind up suffering a drawdown.
Page | 28
The Art of Concentrated Investing
7.6.5 Do Not Hesitate to Cut Loss if Their Share Prices Hit Your Stop
Loss Points
Similarly, we must not hesitate to cut loss if the share prices of our
stocks fall below our cut loss points, and if we realise that we have
made some mistakes in our judgements earlier on. Unless we are very
sure that the decline has got nothing to do with the business
fundamentals, we should not let our emotions affect our judgements
and decisions.
“If a position doesn’t feel right as soon as you put it on, don’t be
embarrassed to change your mind and get right out.”
Michael Marcus
Keep in mind that cut loss will minimise our loss and protect our
capital. In general, price decline for an undervalued stock with a bright
profit growth prospect is rarely more than 10% during a normal
correction, especially when it is under accumulation and when weak
hands are eliminated. A pullback of more than 10% for an undervalued
stock with high profit growth potential signifies that there is a problem
in the company. Our loss would be widened if we refuse to get out of
our position in the stock when its share price begins to take a nosedive.
When a stock takes a beating, it is unlikely that its share price will
rebound anytime soon. Even if the company’s management expresses
positively about the future of the company, do not hold your breath. It
is better to cut loss and use the sale proceeds to invest in other
promising stocks.
“The elements of good trading are cutting losses, cutting losses and
cutting losses. If you can follow these three rules, you may have a
chance.”
Ed Seykota
Example:
Let’s suppose that we initially invest in a stock called ABC. After six
months, we realise that we had made some mistakes in our estimation
earlier on, and that the share price falls continuously as its business
continue to deteriorate. If we adhere strictly to the cut loss rule by
limiting our loss to only 10%, and we use the proceeds to buy another
high-growth stock, let’s call it XYZ, which will provide us a return of
30% after six months, we will be netting 17% (gain) end of the day
despite losing some money in our first investments.
Calculation:
Total return = (100% − 10%) (100% + 30%) − 100%
= (90%) (130%) − 100%
= 17%
Page | 29
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Further, cut loss approach helps us avoid losing too much of money in
a stock. The more we lose, the more difficult it gets to recover from the
loss. Bear in mind that we need to make a 100% return for every 50%
of the capital that we lose to get back to our starting point. Below is the
table showing the percentage of gain needed to break-even.
The old adage still remains true today that “Your first loss is your best
loss.” Therefore, if we do not want to see a small loss snowballs into a
huge loss, we must adhere to our cut loss rule strictly.
Page | 30
The Art of Concentrated Investing
Chapter Summary
Special event
Be patient
Down-trending stocks
Page | 31
The Art of Concentrated Investing
When to sell?
Take some profit off the table if the share price goes up too fast
Liquidate your (long) position in the stocks when they report two
consecutive quarters of decreased profits
Don’t hesitate to cut loss if the share prices of your stocks hit your stop
loss points
Page | 32
Chapter 8
(Bonus Chapter):
The Winning Formula of
Ooi Teik Bee
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
8.1 Introduction
The name of Ooi Teik Bee may be new to some of you; he has actually
established his reputation in Malaysia stock market through the Yearly Stock
Pick Competition, organized by i3investor.com, and for topping the table a few
years. In addition, he has been working as a remisier for more than 25 years, and
has survived several devastating financial crises, and has helped his clients
make lots of money in Malaysia stock market.
Over the past seven years Ooi’s personal investments have generated about
2,087% profit for his portfolio. The returns on investment (ROI) of his portfolio
over the past seven years were mostly above 20%, except 2018. Below is the
table of his portfolio performance. Had anyone followed his stock selections
closely, he or she would have made a great fortune out of Ooi’s
recommendations.
Apart from providing stock recommendations to his clients, Ooi also helps some
of them manage their funds. He had also helped Koon managing some of
Koon’s money, about Rm 12 million, in 2016, for a year, and he generated
about Rm 10 million (or 83.33%) profit for the account Koon entrusted to him.
Some of you may be wondering why Koon let Ooi manage his money whilst he
has hit so many home runs and has made so much money in stock investment.
The answer is: for insurance purposes. As we have learned earlier that no one is
infallible. Koon understands that, just like us, he can make mistakes too. Having
Ooi to manage to some of his money is actually of great help to him in
minimising loss and maximising gain. Whilst the investing philosophy of Ooi
may differ slightly from that of Koon, Ooi’s approach actually provides a
perfect complement to Koon’s method. That is why, even until today, Koon
always consults him before buying (and selling) shares. Ooi will highlight red
flags, threats which can jeopardise Koon’s investments, offer his opinions, show
Koon the charts patterns, and support and resistance levels of the stocks, and
point out the overlooked areas, where special attention needs to be paid, before
Koon places his bets. In other words, Ooi is acting like Koon’s sounding board.
Well, the main objective of this chapter is not to promote Ooi’s service to you,
nor to tell you how spectacular his performance is, but to share with you his
winning formula and investing philosophy, which I hope will give you some
ideas in selecting stocks, to improve your strategy, and to help you make some
money in Malaysia stock market. Of course, if you also find it a sound
Page | 2
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
investment approach after reading this chapter, but are unable to practice it due
to your hectic work schedule, you may engage him to manage some of your
money.
The system was developed and fine-tuned based on his decades of experience in
the stock market. Having survived the three major market crashes enables him
to build a robust investing system, which does not only perform well in bull
market, but remains profitable in bear market. The model applies both technical
and fundamental analyses in picking stocks. Since the system requires
companies to pass technical analysis screening process followed by fundamental
analysis screening stage to be considered good stocks, those counters selected
using the system are not only uptrend stocks with strong momentum, their
financials are also fundamentally sound. According to Ooi, the upside of stocks
selected using this system is greater than 50%, whereas their risk level is less
then 10%. Thus, the system creates plenty of positive asymmetrical risk reward
opportunities for him, and allows him to enjoy a higher overall return on
investment.
The main drawback of the system, compared to some other trading systems, is
that it requires investors to hold those stocks for three to six months. Sometimes
it may go beyond twelve months, depending on the price levels of the stocks
and the paces of their share price movement. Hour-to-hour and day-to-day price
fluctuations are usually ignored since investors using this system only jump on
the bandwagon when an uptrend starts, and close their positions when the trend
comes to an end. In addition, they find it difficult to predict the movements of
share price within a few hours, and to earn enough to offset the trading
commissions. That is the reason Ooi always says Rome was not built in a day.
The second element of his winning streak is his ability to follow the system
religiously. It is not an easy task. If doing it is so easy, everyone would have
made a fortune in the stock market after acquiring the investing rules and model.
This is what differentiates Ooi from average investors. Doing so usually
requires discipline, right temperament, positive attitude and hardwork. For
example, one must be patient to wait for the perfect breakout situation to
develop, be able to invest with conviction when the market is quiet, and be
willing to spend time studying the businesses of companies at home when other
people are having fun with their friends after office hours.
Page | 3
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Ooi always says “Human can lie, but charts don’t lie.” One of the reasons that
the information provided by charts is more reliable than human’s words is that
charts are the trails of money movement. Chart patterns can only be formed
when there are flows of capital into and out of a stock. And he never takes any
CEO’s words for granted, as he knows the words coming out from CEO’s
mouth are sometimes not trustworthy, and The CEO can spin a story with which
the trend does not in sync. For example, the CEO can tell a very beautiful story
of the company’s business in front of journalists, whilst his/her family members,
friends and smart money are selling their shares aggressively during the same
period of time. When the share price of a stock declines continuously that is a
sign showing that the business is facing some challenges or difficulties, and Ooi
will immediately remove the stock from his watch list. According to Jesse
Livermore, “often I have observed that the Chief Executive Officer of most
companies is little more than a cheerleader, who has only one job with regard
to the market. He must assure and reassure the shareholders that everything is
fine – if sales are down he tells the shareholders that the decline in sales is
nothing more than a slight problem due to some temporary reason. If profits are
down he assures the shareholders there is nothing to worry about since the
company has already reached and made adequate plans to recapture their
profitability.” That is the reason Ooi always says “Never trust anyone in stock
market, trust yourself only.”
Page | 4
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
their entry and exit. That is why Ooi always says “Theory and practical are not
the same in stock market…I am just interested in the trend and what the market
wants,” and “it is not up to us to determine the market price, it is Mr Market.”
To him, it does not pay to argue with the market. Therefore, he always gives
priority to the signals given by chart patterns. His strategy is to buy good stocks
at the right time, not when they are near the bottom.
“Big money is made in the stock market by being on the right side of
the major moves. The idea is to get in harmony with the market. It’s
suicidal to fight trends. They have a higher probability of continuing
than not.”
Martin Zweig
Page | 6
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
The third method is to find stocks with share prices above their 200-
day Moving Average lines, and at the same time their short-term
Moving Average (MA) lines must be trending upward. Take, Figure
8.3.1.3, for example, the share price of Dayang Enterprise was in an
upward movement when it crosses above 200-day moving average line
on 7 February 2019. At the same time, its 20-day EMA (yellow
coloured) line was also slopping up. Also, its share price was above its
20-day EMA line.
“You should look for stocks making new price highs as they break out
of price consolidation areas (or bases). Why? Because this is the point
where most really big price advance begins, and is the time where the
probability of a significant price move is the greatest.”
William O’Neil
Page | 7
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
That said, you should not confuse anticipating a breakout with buying
after the breakout. In investing, Ooi does not like to buy based on what
he anticipates to happen in the future, because no one knows when the
breakout will happen, and there is a likelihood that it may never happen
at all. This is the reason why Ooi insists on having the signal of a
breakout from his system prior to performing fundamental analysis and
determining the intrinsic value of the stock. Jesse Livermore once said
“it’s okay to mentally anticipate the action of the market, or a stock,
but take no action until the market has confirmed that you are correct,
by its action: Don’t anticipate market moves with your hard-earned
cash.”
Also, Ooi will look at the trade volume of the stock on the day of the
breakout compared to its volume moving average (VMA) line. The
reason is that if the trade volume on the breakout day is low, the
breakout is more likely to be a fakeout or false breakout. A breakout in
low volume is generally a bad sign, as buying interest, which breaks
the resistance level, is not so great that the stock may go into correction
very soon after the breakout when sellers come in to sell it down
aggressively. That is why you should look for stocks that break out in
high volume.
“In a bull market it is better to always work on the bull side; in a bear
market, on the bear side.”
Charles Dow
Page | 8
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
In geography class, we learned that a rising tide can lift all boats. A
bullish sector is comparable to a rising tide. If you want to select a
stock that will go up in value, you need to make sure that it is in a
booming industry so that it can make more money next year than this
year. According to Bill O’Neil, “the majority of leading stocks are
usually in leading industries.”
“Stocks fluctuate together, but prices are controlled by values in the long run.”
Charles Dow
Page | 9
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
consistently in the stock market after 2009, when he adopted both technical and
fundamental analyses in his stock screening/picking process.
Without further ado, let us take a look at the important metrics of fundamental
analysis that Ooi usually pays attention to in his stock selection process.
Bill O’Neil once said “There is absolutely no good reason for a stock
to go anywhere in big, sustainable way if current earnings are poor.”
So, the key to making profitable investments is to ensure that stocks in
your portfolio are companies with growth, which are generating more
and more profit every quarter.
In order to do so, Ooi usually looks for stocks with the growth of profit
greater than 10% in his screening process. Any stocks with profit
growth rate lower than 10% will automatically be weeded out from his
watch list. The reason why he does so is to select only proven stocks,
which have delivered solid performance continuously rather than
risking his money unnecessarily in some speculative stocks, which may
tumble anytime when the market turns bearish. Moreover, the growing
profits are a good catalyst, which may propel share prices upward when
the market turns bullish.
There are two methods of searching for companies with profit growth
greater than 10%. The first method is by comparing the annual profits
of a company year-over-year (YoY). Let us use the data provided in the
table below, Table 8.4.1.1, for illustration purpose. The annual profit of
Company A in 2017 and 2018 were $410 and $463, respectively. In
this case, the profit growth that Company A achieved in 2018 was
12.93%. The second method is by comparing the quarter profits of the
same company year-over-year. For example, Company A made $110 in
Q4 Y17 and $122 in Q4 Y18. In this case, the profit growth that
Company A achieved in the Quarter 4 of 2018 was 10.91%.
Page | 10
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Note: make sure that all non-recurring items such as one-time profits or
assets disposal gains are omitted from the profits before making
comparison.
Page | 11
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
When performing the screening work, Ooi looks for stocks with share
price 30% lower than their Graham Numbers. For example, if the
calculated Graham Number of a stock is $1.00/share, Ooi would only
give it a serious consideration if its share price is lower than
$0.70/share. The reason of doing so is to ensure that the stock is
undervalued, and the room for decline is small.
Page | 12
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
For example, let us suppose that a fruit seller offers to sell you his fruit
shop for Rm 500,000. The business can generate a fixed amount of Rm
100,000 cash flow stream every year for 10 years, and your expected
rate of return is 5%.
We can use the basic formula of DCF to estimate the value of the
business, and the formula of margin of safety (MOS) to judge whether
the shop is worth your money.
CF1 CF2 CF3 CFn
DCF = + + + ... + , where
(1 + r ) 1
(1 + r ) 2
(1 + r ) 3
(1 + r ) n
CF = Cash Flow,
r = required rate of return.
CP
MOS = 1 − , where
IV
CP = Current Price,
IV = Intrinsic Value (or DCF in this case).
500,000
MOS = 1 −
772,173
MOS = 35.25%
From the calculation, we can tell that the business is worth Rm 772,173
and it is safe to buy the shop at Rm 500,000 from the fruit seller.
E D
WACC = Re + Rd (1 − T ) , where
V V
E = Market capitalisation,
V = Total value of capital (equity and debt),
Re = Cost of equity,
Page | 13
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Ooi always says “We should look at future growth rather than
historical growth (of a company)” The reason is that the stock market’s
mechanism, like driving a vehicle, is a forward-looking mechanism. No
one is able to drive by looking at rear-view mirror. Similarly, investors
will not be able to make big money in the stock market by focusing on
the historical growth data of a company. The data can only be used as
guidance, and should not be used for estimating a company’s future
value. Therefore, investors must learn to forecast the future earnings of
a company, so that they always get themselves a head of the crowd.
In this process, Ooi looks for stocks with forecasted earnings (or EPS)
greater than their current earnings (or EPS). New, hot and innovative
products, superior services, change in management practice, growing
demand of products, changes in currency exchange rate, pricing power,
number of contract awards received and growing market share are
amongst the areas where Ooi always focuses on, as they may bring
higher revenue and profit to the companies.
“V.S. has been supplying this coffee maker (GMCR) since the second
half of 2014. It is the reason that the profit of Q1 2015 jumped up.”
Page | 14
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
He was right that V.S.’s earnings would be growing at a rapid rate, and
he made nearly 800% profit out of this deal.
“Look at the latest result of Pohuat. all export orientated stocks will do
well because of the strong USD and weak RM.”
Note that whilst high EPS and low PER (or P/E) is a perfect
combination, sometimes Ooi would pay a slightly higher price for the
profit growth potential if he believes that it is worth paying more for
the stocks. He once said “the stock market is always forward looking,
high PER does not mean this stock cannot be a good buy. It is growth
that matters most.” The reason is that low PER stocks may get cheaper
and cheaper if the stocks have no growth potential, or the companies
are in sunset industries, or the businesses are going downhill. And, it
seldom pays to put your hard-earned money in this kind of stocks.
Other than the screening criteria discussed above, Ooi also looks at several
technical indicators for signals to support his buy decisions. Sometimes when
any of the indicators shows that the time for hunting to is not ripe yet, he will
wait at the sideline until the time arrives.
He prefers to buy stocks (in his watch list) when their MACD lines
cross above MACD Signal lines, especially when the MACD lines are
above the level of zero. When the MACD line of a stock crosses above
its MACD Signal line, it indicates that the stock is turned bullish.
When the MACD line of a stock is above its centreline (or the level of
zero), it shows that its fast-moving average (12-day EMA) line is above
Page | 15
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
its slow-moving average (26-day EMA) line and the upside momentum
is strong.
Figure 8.5.1.1: Share price of Thong Guan Industries Berhad from May
2016 to September 2016
Source: ChartNexus
Note that whilst he usually judges the bullish level or bearish level of a
stock based on its daily MACD readings, sometimes, he would also
look at its weekly MACD readings to determine if the bullish level or
bearish level of the stock is still strong or weak.
8.5.2 Force Index colour changes from green to blue and the value is
above zero
FI uses price and volume to determine the power of a price move. The
stronger the share price move and the higher the trade volume, the
higher the FI reading is. As the indicator takes volume into account,
buying a stock when price breaks above its resistance level with a high
FI reading would give Ooi a higher chance of making a winning bet
and lower his probability of having a false breakout.
Ooi likes to buy stocks in his watch list when the FI reading of the
stock changes from negative reading (green colour or below zero) to
positive reading (blue colour or above zero). When the reading is above
Page | 16
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
zero, it shows that the price upward move is strong with high buying
pressure.
Figure 8.5.2.1: Share price of Uzma Berhad from Jan 2019 to April
2019
Source: ChartNexus
Page | 17
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
20-day EMA is the average price of a stock over the past twenty days,
but places a greater weight to recent data. When share price of a stock
breaks above 20-day EMA line, it shows that buying pressure is high,
and buyers are willing to pay more to own the stock for some reason.
When Ooi buys a stock, he prefers to have the share price of the stock
broken above its 20-day EMA line before buying it. The reason is that
when share price breaks above 20-day EMA line, its momentum is
strong, and it is likely to go higher and higher, which will indirectly
reduce Ooi holding period of the stock, and give him a higher rate of
return.
Note that in a volatile market, share price may fluctuate along the 20-
day EMA line.
I know what you may be thinking right now – have your finger on the
buy button when the share price of a stock is about to break above the
20-day EMA line and buy the stock before Ooi builds his position.
Page | 18
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Wait a moment! That is not the only signal he looks for before buying a
stock. Sometimes, he would also wait for its 20-day EMA crosses over
70-day SMA, which is also known as (intermediate-term) Golden
Cross, before buying it.
According to Ooi “If the trend (of a stock) is strong enough, the 20-day
EMA will cross above the 70-day SMA, and it is likely to continue its
upward move.” For inexperienced investors, who always try to pick the
bottom and ended up being trapped in sideways markets or downtrend
stocks, the Golden Cross signal (20-day EMA crosses above 70-day
SMA) is a powerful signal you should not ignore. The signal will
ensure that your investment is, more often than not, in a profitable
position. The chance of losing money in your investment will be
reduced significantly.
Page | 19
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
No wise trader and investor will buy a stock at almost one price right at the
beginning of the process with only one approach. The risk of losing big is high
if one dashes into the stock market without testing the environment’s
temperature, and trades without a set of profitable strategies. Likewise, Ooi will
not buy a stock in large quantity at one price with only one strategy. From my
observation, he usually buys stocks in several orders at different prices, and with
different methods. Below are some of his favourite buying strategies.
Ooi usually places his first order for a stock when breakout happens.
The breakout can be a breakout of a congested zone, or a consolidation
range, or a chart pattern. That is the point where resistance line is
broken with weak bears overwhelmed by aggressive bulls.
Page | 20
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
In the previous section, we have learned that knowing when to buy is important
to protecting our capital, but it is more crucial to know when to call it quits.
This is the secret of making big money in the stock markets, and it is
particularly true for investing in Malaysia market. Every successful investor
knows the importance of this theory and practices it religiously. Of course, Ooi
is of no exception.
To Ooi, investing in stocks is like doing business. Shares are always regarded as
merchandise. Therefore, he does not keep them in a vault. He would sell them if
the stocks are deemed overpriced, or have no longer met his investing criteria.
That being said, he does not sell it at almost one price. He would sometimes sell
them when the stocks are still advancing, about to reverse, or have gone up too
fast. If he believes that the stocks fail to meet his criteria, he would exit his
positions immediately or even cut loss as soon as he found out the problem.
That is the reason he always says “buying stock is simple, but selling stock
requires some skill.” Below are some of his selling strategies.
8.7.1 Sell partially when share price has gone up too fast
“Repeatedly, I have sold a stock while it was still rising – and that has
been one reason why I have held onto my fortune. Many a time, I might
Page | 21
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
have made a good deal more by holding a stock, but I would also have
been caught in the fall when the price of the stock collapsed.”
Bernard Baruch
Ooi is very clear that his objective is to make money in the stock
market, and that he will not lose much money for taking partial profit.
Therefore, he would sell it into strength if a stock has risen too fast or
too soon. He would then buy it back during correction if the uptrend is
still intact.
The things he usually pays attention to are the movement of share price
and trade volume. According to him “Stock price will correct after it
hits 100% gain.” The reason is that there is some emotionalism
involved in the price advance, and that smart money would have started
to distribute their shares to late comers. Therefore, he would begin to
realise some gain if any of his stocks has gone up too much from its
base. Also, when the advance of share price is far greater than forty-
five degrees, or when it spikes up, or has enormous move, it may be a
time that he would to take some profit off the table.
8.7.2 Exit completely when a stock fails to meet his investing criteria
Ooi always says “Buying shares must be slow, selling shares must be
fast.” If any of his stocks fails to meet his investing criteria, he would
not hesitate to sell it. When it happens, he will dispose the stock
immediately, even if the stock still seems strong.
For example, if the share price of a stock has shot up too far above its
intrinsic value, he would exit his position quickly, as there is too much
extremism involved in the price advance. Of course, the share price
Page | 22
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
may go up further, but we cannot always sell at the highest price. It’s
very difficult to predict the market top. When the price of a stock is
overshot to the upside, but its earnings fail to catch up, it is highly
likely that the price will tumble as soon as the earnings report is
released. Therefore, it is better to sell before the stampede begins.
There is a Wall Street adage that says “Bulls make money and bears
make money, but pigs get slaughtered.” The pigs are usually referred to
those foolish people who dabble in the markets without knowing what
is really going on.
Also, Ooi would exit his position if a stock delivers two quarters of
decreased earnings. In his reply to one of his followers in mid-2015, he
stated that “There is no growth (in Naim). Hence I will not be
interested in this stock. I selected it in early 2015 because its PER was
low. The last two quarter (earnings) results were not good, hence I
avoid it now.” The share price of Naim Holdings Berhad fell from Rm
2.50 (in mid-2015) to Rm 0.80 (in 2019) after his disposal of Naim
shares. If you are also a follower of Koon, you should have learned
from Koon that EPS (or earnings) is the most powerful catalyst to
move share price. When its EPS (or earnings) goes up, the share price
will also go up. Likewise, when the EPS goes down, the share price
will also go down. This is the reason Ooi folds his cards immediately
when a stock fails to produce two quarters of increased earnings.
Further, Ooi will liquidate his position when the share price of a stock
crosses below its 200-day SMA and major support line. Of all the
moving average lines, 200-day SMA line is the most powerful one. It
acts as a strong support for an uptrend stock. If the price of a stock
reverses and crosses below the moving average line, it signifies that
supply is greater than demand, and a downtrend or sideways market is
likely to begin soon. You do not have to wait until 200-day SMA line
turns down to sell your stock. You can do it immediately once its share
price crosses below the moving average line.
“The secret for winning in the stock market does not include being
right all the time. In fact, you should be able to win even if you are
right only half the time. The key is to lose the least amount of money
possible when you are wrong. I make it a rule never to lose more than
a maximum of 7% on any stock I buy. If a stock drops 7% below my
purchase price, I will automatically sell it at the market – no second-
guessing, no hesitation.”
William J. O’Neil
Ooi always says “There is no 100% sure win (investment) in the stock
market.” No matter how much due diligence we have performed in the
early stage of the investing process, we are not invulnerable to
cognitive and emotional biases, unpredictable bear attack, and any
unforeseen matters. Therefore, he is prepared to cut his losses short,
Page | 23
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
always and without hesitation, if any of his initial purchases turn out to
be a bad one.
“Why do most traders lose money? Because they would rather lose
money than admit they’re wrong. What is the ultimate rationalization
of a trader in a losing position? “I’ll get out when I’m even.” Why is
getting out even so important? Because it protects the ego. I became a
winning trader when I was able to say, “to hell with my ego, making
money is more important.”
Marty Schwartz
He always set his cut loss point and criteria before he gets in. The
reason of doing so is to have his investments decision be made
unemotionally, and be as objective as possible. Pride and ego have no
say whatsoever in his investment decision making process. When share
price falls below his cut-loss point, he will press the brake immediately
without arguing with the market. He understands that when the trend
goes against him, he must fold his cards; there is no reward for arguing
with the market.
“If you don’t bet, you can’t win. If you lose all your chips, you can’t
bet.”
Larry Hite.
The reason that he cuts his losses early is to prevent them getting too
large to give him a nightmare. Every big loss usually starts as a small
loss, and then it grows bigger after a while. When the share price of a
stock starts falling, it may go lower and lower, and no one knows how
low it can go. That is why superinvestors follow the rules of cutting
their losses short and letting their winners run religiously. They just
have to take care of the downside; the upside will take care of itself.
Ooi once said “I expect a few losses in my investments. As long as
those losses are kept at 10%, it is acceptable to me. It’s the overall
return that counts. As long as my winning probability is maintained at
70%, any small losses won’t cause a significant damage to my
portfolio.”
“I will often sell a stock if it doesn’t go up shortly after I buy it. Even
though it has not gone down, if the stock doesn’t do what I expected it
to do, that’s reason enough to step aside and re-evaluate. When a stock
you have bought falls below your purchase price, it is telling you have
made an error – at a minimum in timing.”
Mark Minervini
Page | 24
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Also, he would sell a stock, even at a loss, if its share price does not
move within three months. He does not fall in love with any of his
stocks. He believes that if a stock stays put after some time, there must
be something wrong with the stock. He used the following metaphor to
explain to his followers when being asked why he sold his stock at a
loss.
“Just imagine that your horse is injured, do you think it still can run
and be the champion? The answer is no,” and “when one of its legs is
injured, the horse will never be able to win a race. We should replace it
with a better horse.”
8.8 Use Elliott Wave Principle to Determine the Direction of Price Action
In order to determine the position he is in, and the direction of price action of
his stock or the general market, Ooi, more often than not, applies Elliott Wave
Principle in his analysis.
Elliott Wave is actually a share price pattern theory developed by Ralph Nelson
Elliott in mid-1930s. According to Elliott, share prices of stocks usually move
in certain repetitive patterns like ocean waves. Formation of the waves is mainly
due to swings in investor’s emotion, psychology, or behaviour.
The patterns can be divided into two main types, namely uptrend pattern and
downtrend pattern. Each of the trend patterns can be broken down into five
waves, namely Wave 1, Wave 2, Wave 3, Wave 4, and Wave 5. The trend
patterns usually begin with Wave 1 and ends with Wave 5. Wave 1, Wave 3,
and Wave 5 are impulsive waves, whereas Wave 2 and Wave 4 are corrective
waves. In general, the corrective waves have three smaller waves, which are
labelled as Wave A, Wave B, and Wave C. That said, sometimes the correction
may get complicated, which would result in the formation of a flag pattern or
descending channel, pennant, or sideways consolidation pattern. Therefore, you
need to be flexible when analysing the pattern of a trend.
Page | 25
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Figure 8.8.1 shows the normal Elliott Wave pattern during a bull run. At the
beginning of a new bull market, the formation of Wave 1 is usually not very
obvious, as the public and media do not show much interest in the stock, except
smart money. The stock will subsequently experience a retracement, which is
known as Wave 2. Note that the lowest point of Wave 2 must not be lower than
the lowest point of Wave 1. The percentage of the correction is generally
between 38.2% and 61.8% of Wave 1’s price difference. Depending on the
situation of supply and demand, sometimes the retracement may be lower than
38.2% of Wave 1, and other times it may be higher than 61.8% of Wave 1, but it
will not exceed 100% of Wave 1.
After the brief pullback, the stock will advance again. This impulsive wave is
known as Wave 3, and is the strongest move amongst the three impulsive waves.
The price difference of Wave 3 is generally 61.8% higher than that of Wave 1.
Therefore, the highest point of Wave 3 is always above the highest point of
Wave 1. During this time, a lot of sell-side analysts will begin to cover the stock
and you will also see some talking heads discussing about the company’s
business and earning prospect. Therefore, the trade volume in Wave 3 will
increase significantly, and is the highest one amongst the 5 waves.
Page | 26
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
and if the market shows overconfidence in the stock, but it is always shorter
than 161.8% of Wave 3’s length. In comparison, the trade volume in Wave 5 is
lower than that in Wave 3. This will result in a bearish divergence, rising prices
with declining volumes. During this time, the shares of smart money have
almost been distributed to those late comers, and the trend is about to reverse
soon.
Note that the ratios of 14.6%, 23.6%, 38.2%%, 50.0%, 61.8%, 76.4%, 85.4%
and 100.0% are called Fibonacci ratios, which are discovered by Leonardo
Fibonacci da Pisa in the 13th century. Elliott noticed the relationship between
Fibonacci ratios, wave length, and mass psychology, and he recognised the
importance of Fibonacci ratios when he studied the patterns of those waves.
Therefore, he integrated the ratios into his Wave principle.
By arming himself with the knowledge of Elliott Wave Theory, Ooi can tell the
direction of a stock or the market, where the price of a stock or the market is
likely to go, and devise suitable strategies to capitalise on the price trend to
maximise his return.
You can have the above-mentioned stock selection criteria coded into your
algorithmic trading system, and let your computer and smart-phone trade for
you, but you would not be able to emulate the performance of Ooi if you do not
understand his investing principles. It is the guiding principles, which Ooi spent
a few decades to develop, influence the outcome of his investments. Therefore,
we must also study the investing principles of Ooi in order to understand how
he makes his investment decisions, and how he achieves the striking
performance.
“If the investment game were all about numbers and calculations, then, in theory,
given the computer programs available these days, you should be able to punch
in the right criteria and make money all the time. It doesn’t work that way.”
Thomas Kahn
When a stock slides downward, there must be a good reason for the
decline, and no one knows when the trend will reverse. There is a high
possibility that the price may never return to your original purchase
price. Therefore, Ooi always advises his clients to stay at the sidelines
instead of pounding their hard-earned money down the rat hole when a
stock is on a downtrend.
Page | 27
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
“It’s much easier to stay out of trouble now than to get out of trouble
later.”
Warren Buffett.
Also, Ooi would study the Return on Equity (ROE) and Return on
Invested Capital (ROIC) of the company in order to assess the
efficiency of the management in managing their capital and assets. The
higher the figures, the higher the management’s efficiency is in
allocating their resources. He prefers to buy highly efficient companies,
which are able to produce ROE and ROIC higher than 10% and 12%,
respectively. Of course, this is just a guideline and is not a hard-and-
fast rule to determine if a stock is a good buy. Sometimes, he would
purchase a stock even though its ROE and ROIC do not meet his target
(i.e. stocks in cyclical industries) if he believes that the company’s
business is booming, and is generating higher and higher cash flow.
“The only way to gain an edge is through long and hard work.”
Li Lu
“If you don’t work very hard, it is extremely unlikely that you will be a
good trader.”
Bruce Kovner
If you want to know the secret of Ooi making so much money in the
stock market, the answer is hardwork. Hardworking may also be the
best word to describe about him. He is a hardwork believer. He always
Page | 28
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
says hard work beats talent. He told his followers that “I work 12 hours
a day everyday on (studying) KLSE stocks alone, including weekend.
Investing is what I am most passionate about. I do not want to miss any
of the precious opportunities. I came from a very poor family, and
earning money is very important to me. I also do not want my clients to
lose money and opportunities,” and “writing the Weekly Market
Outlook Report alone would take me more than 5 hours. I need to
spend the whole Saturday or Sunday morning, locked inside my private
room, to write it without anyone to disturb me. I treasure my reputation.
I want to ensure that my report is value for (my clients’) money. It
takes a lot of hard work and sacrifice. I hope all my subscribers will
get the best out of me.” Also, he always says he could not sleep well if
his clients lose money. That is why he works so hard.
Page | 29
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Unlike small investors, who can buy and sell a stock easily without
causing a significant move in its share price, Ooi has a large sum of
money under his management. Each time when he wants to buy and to
sell his stock, he will have some difficulty building and closing his
position if the market liquidity of the stock is low. For example, if the
liquidity of a stock is low, he would have difficulty finding buyers
without lowering his asking price when he sells the stock. Also, when
he sells a stock, its share price will fall continuously. By the time he
disposes all his shares, the price will be very low, and his average
selling price will be reduced greatly. Hence, before buying a stock, he
also looks at the record of its trade volume. If the liquidity is low, he
would rather give it a miss. In 2017, he told one of his friends that
“Superlon passed my stock selection criteria. The only problem is the
volume is too thin. I have many followers, it is difficult to get out when
we want to sell.” In that case, he could only watch the opportunity
slipped through his fingers.
“The big money is made by the sitting and the waiting – not the
thinking. Wait until all the factors are in your favour before making a
trade – follow the Top Down Trading rules. Once a position is taken
the next difficult task is to be patient and wait for the move to play out.”
Jesse Livermore
After buying a stock, Ooi will hold it, and wait for three to six months.
And he always advises his followers to avoid getting in to and out of
the market every day, and to avoid taking profit too early. When they
trade too often, they do not only pay hefty amount of money in
commission to their brokers, they also miss the opportunity to make big
money when the stock moves upward in a significant way. Moreover,
when they take profit too early, they give the opportunity for their
Page | 30
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
“Those who cannot adjust to change will be swept aside by it. Those
who recognize change and react accordingly will benefit.”
Jim Rogers
Page | 31
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Below is his advice for people who consider using margin finance in
their investments. “Look at your trading history in last 5 years. If you
are in a winning position, then you are qualified to use it. If you are
still in a losing position, you are not encouraged to use it. Margin
finance is like a machine gun, if you have the skill to use it, it is a very
useful and effective tool. If you do not have the special skill to handle it,
it will kill you and your love ones. Please learn the special skill and
you must prove to yourself that you can make money from stock market
consistently year after year before using it. Note that you cannot use
margin finance in a bearish market, you will end up with a big loss. So,
never use margin finance if the overall market is bearish. Use it only in
bull market to maximize your gain. In addition, you should use margin
finance for a short period of time only, and you should not keep your
share under margin financing for 365 days. My advice is to avoid
keeping your shares in margin account for more than three months.
You must be disciplined if you want to use margin finance. If you do
not have a good money management skill, please avoid using margin
financing. Also, if margin of safety of your stock is less than 30%, you
should not use margin loan for the stock.”
Other than using margin loan, Ooi also trades warrants to maximise his
return. When he buys warrants, he will look at the values of the
warrants. According to his study, “A warrant trading at a discount is
one that nobody is interested in. In general, a warrant is ‘in the money’
when the stock it attached to is on a downtrend. Most of the times, no
one is interested in the stock and warrant for a reason that we do not
know.” Therefore, he tries to shun those warrants trading at a discount
to their underlying values and look for those trading at a premium to
their stocks. In one of his replies to one of his follower, he said “I do
not care much about dividend, I aim for capital gain. Dividend is only
a bonus to me. Generally, I like warrants trading at a premium; I do
not like warrants trading at a discount. Warrants trading at a premium,
most of the time, are the warrants with an uptrending stock and the
stock must be very bullish.”
Page | 32
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Other than applying fundamental analysis and technical analysis, and having the
ability to control his emotions and maintain discipline, Ooi also capitalises on
his Chinese Astrology knowledge such as WuXing theory (the five basic
elements: metal, water, wood, fire, and earth) and BaZi (the four pillars of
destiny) to determine the most suitable periods of time and the best areas, when
and where he should make his investments, in order to increase his chance of
making winning bets.
According to WuXing theory, the five elements – metal, water, wood, fire, and
earth – will interact with each other when they come in contact together. Two
predominant effects produced by them are generating and overcoming effects.
For example, water will nourish wood when rain water falls on plants, but it will
extinguish fire when they come in contact together. The diagram below depicts
how they interact with other elements and the impacts these elements will cause
when they come in contact together.
Before Chinese New Year, Ooi would usually study Chinese Lunar Calendar,
which is also known as JiaZi Calendar, to find out to which element the
following year belongs and to which element each month in the year belongs.
The objective of this study is to choose some suitable sectors, which are more
likely to perform in the year or in certain months, for his investments in that
particular year, and to determine which stocks should be removed from his
portfolio.
Page | 33
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Other than WuXing theory, he also studies his BaZi to find out his own destiny.
By understanding his own potential, he can deploy his strategy wisely. Just like
a cyclical business, every one of us will experience the inevitable ups and
downs in life. Ooi believes that if he could reduce his losses to the lowest
possible level in his down years, and maximise his returns with the use of
leverage during good times, he would be able to amass a huge fortune in
investment in his life.
Page | 34
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Chapter Summary
Ooi’s investments have generated about 2,087% profit from 2013 to 2019.
Other technical indicators and signals Ooi uses to support his buy decisions
Force Index colour changes from green (below 0) to blue (above 0),
Page | 35
The Winning Formula of Ooi Teik Bee
Exit completely when a stock fails to meet his investing criteria, and
Ooi also uses Elliott Wave principle to determine the direction of a price
action
There are two types of pattern, namely uptrend pattern and downtrend
pattern,
The objective is to reduce his losses in his down years, and maximise
his returns with the use of leverage during good times.
Page | 36
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Chapter 9:
Case Study 1 -
V.S. Industry Berhad
Page | 1
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Prior to investing in a stock, Koon would look at the business, and earnings
growth prospect of the company. In addition, he would also assess the
efficiency, and capability of its management, and the value of the stock
compared to its share price.
When Koon first invested in the stock, the company continued to expand
its capacity and product lines aggressively to meet the needs of its existing
and new customers.
Having a good understanding of the business and its outlook is not enough,
we must also analyse the financial health of the company and buy it below
its fair price. To judge the financial status of V.S. Industry, we need to
study the profitability, solvency, liquidity and activity ratio of its business.
• Profitability
First of all, we must make sure that the business made more profits
this year than last year and will earn more profits next few years
than this year before placing our bet.
Page | 2
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
It can be seen from the calculation above that the net profit growth
rate of V.S. Industry in 2013 was maintained around 20%. This is an
indicator showing that the company was able to grow its business at
a constant rate, around 20%. Also, in 2013 it had developed a few
new key customers, which was expected to contribute significantly
to the top and bottom lines, and the growth of V.S. Industry.
Moreover, the strengthening of USD against MYR would benefit
V.S. Industry. As a result, the net profit of V.S. Industry shot up to
Rm 53.63 million in 2014, and Rm 132.74 million in 2015 (refer to
Figure 9.1).
Page | 3
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Return on equity
= Net profit attributable to shareholders / Shareholders’ equity
= (Rm 43,910,000 / Rm 479,646,000) × 100%
= 9.15%
• Solvency
Debt-to-EBITDA ratio
= Debt / EBITDA
= Rm 361,757,000 / Rm 92,027,000
= 3.93
Debt-to-Equity ratio
= Debt / Shareholders’ Equity
= Rm 361,757,000 / Rm 479,646,000
= 0.75
Page | 4
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
• Liquidity
Also, we must not forget to assess the company’s ability to pay its
short-term obligations. It can be done by determining the current
ratio and quick ratio of the stock.
Current ratio
= Current assets / Current liabilities
= Rm 686,454,000 / Rm 591,893,000
= 1.16
Quick ratio
= (Current assets – Inventories) / Current liabilities
= (Rm 686,454,000 – Rm 177,760,000) / Rm 591,893,000
= 0.86
The current ratio and quick ratio of V.S. Industry in 2013 were 1.16
and 0.86, respectively, which were slightly lower than those of the
industry average, 1.25 and 0.94, respectively. But the company still
managed to maintain them at a manageable level, and had no
problem in meeting its short-term obligations.
• Activity Ratio
Page | 5
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Its inventory turnover ratio, 6.55, was lower than that of the industry
average, 8.75. As the management foresaw more orders would be
coming in near future, it was sensible that the management kept
more inventories so they could fill the new orders quickly once they
received them and to prevent shortage of stock. Moreover, fifty six
days of inventory on hand signified that the inventory moved fairly
quickly.
Compared to its peers, its receivables turnover ratio, 2.84, was lower
than that of the industry average, 3.91. This was an anomaly as the
company took a month longer than usual to collect the receivables.
But the company quickly corrected it by increasing the turnover
ratio to 3.83 the following year.
• Cash Flow
Just like managing our personal finances, we must make sure that
the company can continue its operation without running out of cash.
Therefore, we must analyse the free cash flow and operating cash
flow to sales ratio of the firm.
Page | 6
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Page | 7
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Industry
Description 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Average (in 2013)
Revenue (Rm) 1,026,818,000 1,201,992,000 1,163,911,000 1,715,082,000 1,936,885,000 434,957,148
Net profit (Rm) 27,721,000 37,390,000 43,910,000 53,633,000 132,739,000 14,104,333
Earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and
95,712,000 95,275,000 92,027,000 119,548,000 239,218,000 35,382,928
amortisation, EBITDA (Rm)
Adjusted earnings per share (Rm) 0.0149 0.0201 0.0236 0.0288 0.0712 0.0166
Net profit margin (%) 2.70% 3.11% 3.77% 3.13% 6.85% 3.24%
Profit growth (year over year, %) 14.13% 34.88% 17.44% 22.14% 147.50% -64.34%
Equity (Rm) 393,609,000 410,491,000 479,646,000 526,160,000 777,034,000 162,236,056
Return on equity (%) 7.04% 9.11% 9.15% 10.19% 17.08% 8.69%
Debt (Rm) 134,829,000 138,008,000 361,757,000 409,791,000 412,208,000 96,059,991
Debt-to-EBITDA ratio (times) 1.4087 1.4485 3.9310 3.4278 1.7231 2.7149
Debt-to-equity ratio (times) 0.3425 0.3362 0.7542 0.7788 0.5305 0.5921
Current ratio (times) 1.3149 1.2751 1.1598 1.1687 1.4605 1.2532
Quick ratio (times) 1.0318 0.9977 0.8594 0.7945 1.0697 0.9423
Total asset turnover ratio (times) 1.3298 1.4125 0.8287 1.1053 1.0438 1.1284
Inventory turnover ratio (times) 11.7718 11.4938 6.5477 6.3570 7.1012 8.7481
Receivables turnover ratio (times) 5.0520 3.7849 2.8352 3.8322 3.8685 3.9071
Capex 43,268,000 40,360,000 31,394,000 55,704,000 64,302,000 12,828,452
Operating cash flow 94,277,000 34,111,000 19,666,000 46,368,000 56,452,000 19,621,586
Free cash flow (Rm) 51,009,000 -6,249,000 -11,728,000 -9,336,000 -7,850,000 6,793,134
Operating cash flow to sales ratio (times) 0.0918 0.0284 0.0169 0.0270 0.0291 0.0451
Market Capitalisation (Rm) 391,440,000 447,360,000 372,800,000 773,560,000 2,190,200,000 199,080,694
Price to earnings ratio (P/E) 8.4901 15.4262
Figure 9.3: Summary of V.S. Industry Berhad’s Financial Performance
Page | 8
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
To avoid paying too much for sellers, and to avoid overpaying for what
the business is worth, Koon would make sure that the Price-to-Earnings
ratio or forward Price-to-Earnings ratio of the stock did not exceed 10, and
did not exceed that of the industry average.
Price-to-Earnings ratio
= Share price / Earnings-per-share
= Rm 0.2150 / Rm 0.0236
= 9.13
Page | 9
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Figure 9.4 is the price chart of V.S. Industry from November 2013 to May 2016,
the period when Koon invested in the company. The green coloured line and red
coloured line are 50-day SMA and 200-day SMA, respectively. The Golden
Cross appeared in the chart on 2 December 2013 when the price was Rm
0.215/share, whereas the Death Cross appeared in the chart 5 April 2016 when
the price was Rm 0.975/share.
Figure 9.4: Price Chart of V.S. Industry from November 2013 to May 2016
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Prior to studying how Koon traded V.S. Industry, it is important to analyse the
support and resistance areas of the stock. Then we have to draw those obvious
and not-so-obvious support and resistance lines and to identify the price levels
that had been tested a few times. Those are the points where Koon would pay
attention to, and would make his buy and sell decisions. In addition, Koon
would also monitor the trade volume of the stock, and its trend. Figure 9.5 is the
price chart of V.S. Industry with its support and resistance lines drawn on the
chart.
Figure 9.5: Price Chart of V.S. Industry with Support and Resistance Lines from
November 2013 to May 2016
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 9.6 shows the major points where Koon would buy and sell V.S. Industry
shares. The points with strong support or weak resistance were probably his
Page | 10
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
buying points, whereas those points with weak support and strong resistance
after peaking were probably his selling points.
Figure 9.6: Price Chart of V.S. Industry and Good Trading Points from
November 2013 to May 2016
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Point A
The first point where Koon would start building his position in V.S. Industry
was Point A, where its short-term moving average (50-day SMA) crossed above
its long-term moving average (200-day SMA), on 2 December 2013. Even
though the fundamental analysis of V.S. Industry’s business showed that it was
safe to buy the stock, Koon would not go all-in at the beginning of his venture
in the investment. Instead of taking too much risk before his hypothesis was
proved right, as usual, he would probably dip his toe in V.S. Industry with just
20 ~ 30% of the money in his fund, around the price of Rm 0.215/share, when
the Golden Cross appeared. He would cut loss if the company reported two
consecutive quarters of reduced profits, or if downtrend started.
Point B
As can be seen from the chart, the share price of V.S. Industry had stopped
falling after the golden cross appeared. Point B was probably the time when
Koon would add more shares to his original position, with 20 ~ 30% of the
money in his fund, when the stock tested its bottom, around the price of Rm
0.220/share, and when its price broke above its previous high or resistance
(LN2), with higher volume (1.75 million shares) around Rm 0.235/share the
following month. In addition, the company just reported the second quarter of
increased profits (on a YOY basis).
Point C
After rising for a while, the stock came down to retest its short-term moving
average support (50-day SMA) at Point C, around Rm 0.225/share, with light
trading volume, on 5 February 2014. Short-term traders and weak holders who
had no intention to hold the stock for long term would be taken out of the stock
when the share price declined. Other than the emotions of market participants
turned negative, the profit growth prospect of the company had not changed.
That was a great bargain that Koon would not want to miss. He would add more
shares to his position, with another 5 ~ 10% of the money in his fund.
Page | 11
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Point D
The stock retested its short-term moving average support (50-day SMA) again
at Point D, around Rm 0.235/share, on 3 March 2014 with light trading volume
(0.41 million shares). In general, a low volume pullback toward a support area
near the bottom is actually a healthy correction, which signifies not many
people are willing to part with their shares, and that the uptrend is still intact.
That was another time when Koon would add more shares to his position, with
another 5 ~ 10% of the money in his fund, before the value of the stock was
discovered by the crowd.
Point E
The stock retested its short-term moving average support (50-day SMA) the
fourth time at Point E on 27 March 2014, but at a higher price, Rm 0.240/share.
It is noteworthy that the stock did not make a lower low even though it came
down to retest its support. That was an indication that the demand for the stock
was getting stronger and stronger. Again, that was the time when Koon would
add more shares to his position, with another 5 ~ 10% of the money in his fund,
as the share price continued to climb. Also, smart money would take advantage
of the elevated platform to build their positions in the stock.
Point F
The stock broke above its previous high (Rm 0.255/share) with high volume
(5.70 million shares) on 30 April 2014. Around that time, the stock reported the
third quarter of increased revenue and earnings. In addition, the management of
V.S. Industry mentioned in the quarterly report that the company had developed
a new key account, which was expected to contribute meaningfully to its top
and bottom lines. That was another point where Koon would to add more shares
to his position, with 5 ~ 10% of the money in his fund.
Point G
After moving sideways for six weeks, the stock retested its short-term moving
average support (50-day SMA) again on 13 June 2014. But its trading volume
had dropped significantly (46.25 thousand shares), as the number of people who
were willing to sell their shares at the level had also dropped a lot since many of
sellers had been taken out of the stock earlier. That was the point where Koon
would scoop up the fantastic bargains before they were gone. In investing, when
you discover a gem, you cannot get enough of it.
Point H
The stock broke above its resistance (LN4), around Rm 0.265/share on 8 July
2014. At the same time, its volume jumped to 9.99 million shares at the
breakout point (higher than the trade volume of the previous high), which
showed that the breakout was a valid one. That was the point where Koon
would add more shares to his winning position, as its resistance was weak,
supply was low and demand was high. In addition, the company just reported
the fourth quarter of increased earnings on a YOY basis. Further, the uptrend
was strong, as the stock continued to produce more higher highs and higher
lows.
Page | 12
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Point I
After consolidating for two weeks, the stock crossed above its resistance (LN5),
around Rm 0.300/share, and produced another higher high on 23 July 2014,
with high volume (17.80 million shares). That was another point where Koon
would add more shares to his winning position. By that time Koon probably had
used up all his original capital. But his accounts would not run out of money. In
fact, with margin finance, he would never short of fund to add more shares if the
share price continues to rise. As the share price of V.S. Industry went up, his
collateral value also went up in tandem. Therefore, Koon could borrow more
money from his brokers through margin finance to buy more shares as the price
continued to climb.
Point J
After rising for a while, the share price stopped moving upward. The stock
traded within a narrow price range, around Rm 0.350/share. It could also be due
to a shakeout to drive weak holders out. The stock moved sideways for a month,
from 14 August 2014 to 18 September 2014, and formed an elevated platform.
The stock broke above its resistance (LN6) on 19 September 2014 with high
volume (8.78 million shares). The elevated platform, and the breakout point
were the area where Koon would add more shares to his winning position using
borrowed money from his brokers. Additionally, the acquisition of shares by the
founding directors in open market, and share buybacks were also important
signs showing that it was safe to add more shares at the breakout point. Peter
Lynch once said, “insiders might sell their shares for any number of reasons, but
they buy them for only one: they think the price will rise.”
Point K
After the breakout, the original resistance (LN6) had now become a new support.
The stock continued to rise following the breakout, but was rejected at the level
of Rm 0.415/share. The stock then moved in a horizontal channel within a range,
bounded by support (Rm 0.350/share) and resistance (Rm 0.415/share) for three
months. On 15 December 2014, the stock broke below its support, but quickly
regained its strength three days later, on 18 December 2014. In hindsight, the
false breakout was actually a shakeout to eliminate weak hands. It is important
to note that even though the price broke below the support, the stock had not
shown any lower high and lower low, which indicated that the uptrend was still
intact, and the bulls were still in control. Also, the company just reported two
quarters of highest ever quarterly profits within that period of time. That was the
area where Koon would add more shares to his position using borrowed money
from his brokers.
Point L
Eventually the stock broke above its resistance (LN7) at Rm 0.415/share with
high volume on 7 January 2015, after moving in a horizontal channel for three
months, and tested its resistance for five times. Most of the weak holders and
short-term traders had been taken out of the stock at the breakout point. In
general, the more times price hits the key level, the more likely it is going to
break it. Again, the breakout point was the point where Koon would add more
shares to his position using borrowed money from his brokers.
Page | 13
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
Point M
Following the breakout, the stock shot up nearly 50% within three weeks
without experiencing any pullback. The movement was obviously too fast, and
the gradient was too steep, the stock was due for a correction. Koon always says
no stock can continue to go up and up for whatever reasons, and after some time
it will experience a pullback. A bearish engulfing candlestick was then appeared
in the chart on 29 January 2015. That was the point or area where Koon would
take some profit off the table to pare down his margin loan, and to reduce his
cost.
Point N
After a brief correction, the stock continued to climb again until profit-taking
began in March 2015. It then faced a strong resistance around Rm 0.700/share,
and experienced a consolidation for four months. The price movement of V.S.
Industry was bounded by its upper descending resistance (LN8) and lower
ascending support (LN1). Shares changed hands from weak holders to
newcomers, who had a tendency to hold the shares longer in their portfolios.
That was not an alarming sign. In fact, the process would increase the stability
of the stock. The volume dropped significantly when share price approached the
apex of the triangle. A breakout then occurred when the share price crossed
above the upper descending resistance with high volume on 19 June 2015,
which showed that the buying interest was high. That was the area where Koon
would add more shares to his position using margin loan.
Point O
After breaking above LN8, the share price continued to move up. It then
stopped at the level of Rm 0.750/share, and moved sideways for a while. The
stock broke above its resistance (LN9, around Rm 0.750/share) on 13 July 2015
with high volume (28.72 million shares), and continued its upward trend. One of
the reasons why the share price continued to rise was the company just reported
the eighth consecutive quarter of increased profit on a YOY basis, as the
company was still expanding at a very fast pace. That was the time when Koon
would add more shares to his position.
Point P
Following the breakout, the stock climbed rapidly. Within two weeks, the stock
rose more than 33% without experiencing any pullback. Again, the share price
went up too fast, too soon, and the gradient was too steep. A shooting star
candlestick then formed on 3 August 2015. That was the time when Koon
would sell some of his shares into strength, take some money off the table, so
that he could buy more shares during correction.
Point Q
After that the stock experienced a brief high-volume-pullback, and subsequently
it formed a double bottoms (BTM1 and BTM2) pattern. Its price crossed above
the neckline (LN10 at Rm 0.895/share) of the double bottoms on 1 September
2015. In general, a high-volume pullback indicates that the correction attracts a
lot of buyers, and is a form of divergence, which suggests that the market may
be reversing up soon. The double bottom pattern is a bullish reversal pattern.
Page | 14
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
That was the time when Koon would add more shares to his winning position
with the sales proceeds.
Point R
After rising for a month, the stock experienced another high-volume pullback
(but with relatively lower trading volume), and the second double bottoms
(BTM3 and BTM4) pattern was then formed. Its share price crossed above the
neckline (LN11 at Rm 1.17/share) of the double bottoms on 19 October 2015
with high volume (32.24 million shares). That was the area where Koon would
add more shares to his position with borrowed money.
Point S
Following the breakout, the original resistance line or neckline (LN11) had now
become a new support line. The stock attempted to climb after the breakout, but
on falling volume. It was then rejected at the level of Rm 1.300/share (LN12),
thus forming the first top. The stock then retraced and found a support near the
level of Rm 1.170/share (LN11), as late comers who missed the buying
opportunity during the breakout came in to buy at that level. That was also the
time when Koon would add some shares to his position, but at a relatively lower
volume. In general, rising price on decreasing volume is a form of bearish
divergence, which suggests that the uptrend is not sustainable.
Point T
The stock tried to climb again after testing its support (LN11). Even though it
managed to break above its resistance line (LN12) on 28 December 2015, it
quickly reversed, gapped down, and crossed below the line (LN12) after the
company issued bonus shares to shareholders, and had never broken through the
barrier again. It was clearly a false breakout, which signified that the price
might be changing its original direction, as smart money who just received the
bonus shares had started to cash in after the issuance of the bonus shares. That
was the period when Koon would start selling his shares.
Point U
The share price declined after the false breakout, which resulted in the
formation of double tops (TOP1 and TOP2) pattern. The breakout (of the
double-tops’ neckline or LN11) to the downside on 18 January 2016 was a
bearish sign that investors should not ignore. In addition, the price made a series
of lower highs and lower lows. That was the time when Koon would continue to
sell his shares as the stock declined further.
Point V
The stock continued to move downward, and crossed below its main trendline
(LN1) on 11 February 2016 with high volume. It then breached its long-term
moving average (200-day SMA) support the following day with higher volume.
It implied that smart investors had been selling shares aggressively to realise
their gains, whereas dumb money bought the shares from the smart money as
the stock became more affordable after the share split, and issuance of bonus
shares. That was another bearish sign that should not be ignored. That was also
the area where Koon would continue to sell his shares. Bear in mind that the
Page | 15
Case Study 1 - V.S. Industry Berhad
only way to turn paper gains into hard cash is by selling stocks near their peaks,
and if we do not act, someone else will.
Point W
After the share price crossed below its main trendline (LN1), the function of the
trendline was changed from providing support to exerting resistance. The stock
attempted to rally but was rejected when it touched the main trendline. A
shooting star candlestick was then formed on 23 February 2016. That was also a
bearish sign that should not be overlooked. If Koon still had any V.S. Industry
shares left unsold in his portfolio, he would take advantage of the sucker rally to
dispose his shares.
Point X
The price then retraced, and crossed below its long-term moving average (200-
day SMA) support again on 2 March 2016. That was another bearish sign that
any serious investors should not ignore. After the share price crossed below the
long-term moving average (200-day SMA) support, the line would become a
new resistance line.
Point Y
The stock attempted to rally again after the retracement, but was rejected when
it hit the long-term moving average (200-day SMA). That was another sign of
weakness, and it was the point where Koon would continue selling his shares if
he had not completely disposed all his shares earlier.
Point Z
V.S. Industry’s short-term moving average (50-day SMA) crossed below its
long-term moving average (200-day SMA) on 5 April 2016. The death cross
was the last bearish signal, and a loud warning alarm. On 28 March 2016, the
company also reported decreased profits, on a QOQ basis. Long-term investors
who had not sold their shares earlier should dispose their shares as soon as
possible.
Remark:
The above-mentioned points are just some of the points where Koon would buy
and sell the shares of V.S. Industry from 2014 to 2016. In fact, there are many
other points where Koon would buy and sell. Sometimes, if the volatility was
high or when the stock was overbought or oversold, he would trade around the
core position actively in order to reduce his cost, and to optimise his return.
Page | 16
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
Chapter 10:
Case Study 2 –
Supermax Corporation Berhad
Page | 1
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
Prior to investing in a stock, Koon would look at the business, and earnings
growth prospect of the company. In addition, he would also assess the
efficiency, and capability of its management, and the value of the stock
compared to its share price.
When Koon started investing the company in April 2009, the market
capitalisation of Supermax was only Rm 400 million. Today, as of May
2020, the market capitalisation of Supermax has crossed the mark of Rm
10 billion. In terms of capacity, it was also ranked No 2 in Malaysia in
2009, and could produce 14.5 million pieces of gloves per annum when
Koon started investing in the company.
• Profitability
First of all, Koon would make sure that the business made more
profits this year than last year, and could make more profits next
year than this year before placing his wager.
Page | 2
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
In order to determine the growth rate, we can use the linear equation
in the chart above to determine the adjusted net profit of Supermax
from 2005 to 2008.
It can be seen from Figure 10.1 that the Supermax did not suffer any
financial losses in 2008 in spite of the subprime mortgage crisis, and
the impairment charge. Moreover, it delivered 11.52% CAGR in net
profit during FY05-FY08.
Page | 3
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
Further, the net profit margin of Supermax was maintained at a satisfactory level,
around 10%, despite the increasing revenue. The number suggests that the
management was successful at controlling its cost.
Page | 4
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
• Solvency
Debt-to-EBITDA ratio
= Debt / EBITDA
= Rm 390,749,423 / Rm 101,119,000
= 3.86
Debt-to-Equity ratio
= Debt / Shareholders’ Equity
= Rm 390,749,423 / Rm 416,380,000
= 0.94
• Liquidity
Also, we must not forget to assess the company’s ability to pay its
short-term obligations. It can be done by determining the current
ratio and quick ratio of the stock.
Page | 5
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
Current ratio
= Current assets / Current liabilities
= Rm 407,312,394 / Rm 347,382,835
= 1.17
Quick ratio
= (Current assets – Inventories) / Current liabilities
= (Rm 407,312,394 – Rm 135,507,463) / Rm 347,382,835
= 0.78
The current ratio and quick ratio of Supermax in 2008 were 1.17 and
0.78, respectively. In comparison, the figures were somewhat lower
than those of the industry average, 1.33 and 0.86, respectively, and
were the lowest ones in the past five years. One of the reasons why
the figures were so low is that the company borrowed a lot of money
to facilitate its expansion plan. Nevertheless, the company still
managed to maintain its current ratio above 1.00, which showed that
the company was able to meet their short-term obligations, and had
the necessary financial resources to maintain its solvency.
• Activity Ratio
Page | 6
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
highest one in the last five years. This implies that the company was
working hard to utilise its assets to generate higher revenue.
In addition, its inventory turnover ratio, 5.99, was lower than that of
the industry average, 6.89. Given the increasing demand of gloves
amid the widespread of H1N1 virus, it was sensible that the
management built higher inventory in 2008 so that they could
deliver goods to clients once they received their orders, and to
prevent shortage of gloves.
• Cash Flow
To ensure that the company is not running out of cash, we must also
analyse the free cash flow and operating cash flow to sales ratio of
the firm.
Its operating cash flow to sales ratio, 0.07, was close to that of the
industry average, 0.07. This indicates that the management was as
good as their competitors in turning sales into cash in their day-to-
day operation.
Page | 7
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
Industry
Description 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Average (in 2008)
Revenue (Rm) 284,688,000 400,324,000 574,260,000 811,824,000 803,633,000 563,642,076
Earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and
44,522,000 61,113,000 93,730,000 101,119,000 205,670,000 75,992,563
amortisation, EBITDA (Rm)
Net profit (Rm) 36,273,000 39,749,000 55,946,000 46,997,000 126,585,000 42,461,192
Adjusted earnings per share (Rm) 0.0267 0.0292 0.0411 0.0346 0.0931 0.0305
Net profit margin (%) 12.74% 9.93% 9.74% 5.79% 15.75% 7.53%
Equity (Rm) 204,522,000 239,904,000 383,789,000 416,380,000 558,835,000 279,166,032
Return on equity (%) 17.74% 16.57% 14.58% 11.29% 22.65% 15.21%
Debt (Rm) 179,570,848 196,899,547 345,936,125 390,749,423 289,607,227 159,118,718
Debt-to-EBITDA ratio (times) 4.0333 3.2219 3.6908 3.8643 1.4081 2.0939
Debt-to-equity ratio (times) 0.8780 0.8207 0.9014 0.9384 0.5182 0.5700
Current ratio (times) 1.9308 1.7969 1.3883 1.1725 1.7838 1.3340
Quick ratio (times) 1.6835 1.4557 0.9715 0.7824 1.2400 0.8594
Total assets (Rm) 473,013,618 521,974,073 868,528,734 946,726,801 945,249,232 533,278,407
Total asset turnover ratio (times) 0.6019 0.7669 0.6612 0.8575 0.8502 1.0569
Inventory turnover ratio (times) 10.6439 9.5052 5.3992 5.9910 6.9160 6.8860
Receivables turnover ratio (times) 8.2766 7.3179 5.9035 6.5103 10.1515 6.0180
Free cash flow (Rm) -20,661,938 9,974,470 39,958,453 14,541,183 208,421,277 -5,679,413
Operating cash flow to sales ratio (times) -0.0050 0.0781 0.1287 0.0654 0.2810 0.0725
Price to earnings ratio (P/E) 8.6814 14.9010
Figure 10.5: Summary of Supermax Corporation Berhad’s Financial Performance
Page | 8
Case Study 2 - Supermax Corporation Berhad
To avoid paying too much for sellers and avoid overpaying for what the
business is worth, Koon would make sure that the Price-to-Earnings ratio
or forward Price-to-Earnings ratio of the stock were lower than 10, and
lower than that of the industry average.
Price-to-Earnings ratio
= Share price / Earnings-per-share
= Rm 0.300 / Rm 0.035
= 8.57
Page | 9
Case Study 1
Figure 10.6 is the price chart of Supermax from April 2009 to November 2010,
the period of time when Koon invested in Supermax. The green coloured line
and red coloured line are 50-day SMA and 200-day SMA, respectively. Golden
Cross appeared in the chart on 7 May 2009 when the price was Rm 0.30/share,
whereas Death Cross appeared in the chart 15 Oct 2010 when the price was Rm
1.10/share.
Figure 10.6: Price Chart of Supermax from April 2009 to November 2010
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 10.7: Price Chart of Supermax with Support and Resistance Lines from
April 2009 to November 2010
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Figure 10.8 shows the major points where Koon would buy and sell Supermax
shares during the outbreak of H1N1 Swine Flu after noticing that Malaysian
Airport Authorities installed temperature testing equipment to check the
temperature of arrival passengers, and after seeing the removal of the
Page | 10
Case Study 1
temperature detection equipment from the airport when the situation was under
control.
Figure 10.8: Price Chart of Supermax and Good Trading Points from April 2009
to November 2010
Source: TradingView (www.tradingview.com)
Point A
The share price of Supermax climbed for a couple of months after the global
stock market bottomed out in March 2009. The stock then traded within a
narrow price range and formed a strong platform between May 2009 and July
2009. The elevated platform was the best area where smart money took
advantage of to build their positions in the stock. The first point where Koon
would start building his position in Supermax was Point A, where its short-term
moving average (50-day SMA) crossed above its long-term moving average
(200-day SMA), around early May 2009. It was also the time when he saw the
temperature detection equipment installed at airport and train stations. Note that
even though the fundamental analysis of Supermax’s business showed that it
was safe to buy the stock, Koon would not go all-in at the beginning of his
venture in the investment. Instead of taking too much risk before his hypothesis
was proved right, he would buy the stock with just a fraction of his fund. For
example, he would probably dip his toe in Supermax with just 30 ~ 40% of the
money in his fund, around the level of Rm 0.300/share, when the Golden Cross
appeared. He would cut loss if the company reported two consecutive quarters
of reduced profits, or if downtrend started.
Point B
The stock then climbed for a couple of days, and fell again to test its support, as
some doubtful traders sold it when it approached the resistance (LN3). It could
also be due to a shakeout within the narrow price range to drive weak holders
out. As can be seen from the chart, the share price of Supermax did not produce
a lower low after the golden cross appeared, as other smart money had also
started to discover the value, and future earnings of Supermax’s business. Point
B was probably the time when Koon would add more shares to his original
position, with 5 ~ 10% of the money in his fund, when the price retested its
support (LN2) around Rm 0.300/share the following week. The reason of
adding shares progressively in this manner is to avoid losing too much money in
the stock at the beginning of his venture.
Page | 11
Case Study 1
Point C
The stock moved in the narrow trading range for a couple of weeks. It retested
its support (LN2) at Point C, with light trading volume, on 28 May 2009. That
was another time when Koon would add more shares to his position, with
another 5 ~ 10% of the money in his fund, as the stock did not make a lower
low. It can also be seen from the chart that its trading volume was getting lighter
and lighter (about 2 million shares per day) as the stock tested its support,
around Rm 0.300/share. It signified that those doubtful traders and impatient
sellers who intended to get out of the stock had become fewer and fewer. Hence,
it was very safe to buy the stock during that period of time before it broke above
its resistance (LN3).
Point D
The stock broke out of its resistance (LN3) on 8 July 2009 with high volume
(21.09 million shares, which was higher than that of the previous high). The
break out signified that those weak sellers who wanted to sell their shares near
the resistance (LN3), around Rm 0.340/share, had all been taken out of the stock
by eager buyers. In addition, the buying pressure was higher than the selling
pressure. That was the time that Koon would add more shares to his winning
position, with about 5% ~ 10% of the money in his fund. Latecomers or
indecisive investors who were interested in the stock but did not buy before the
breakout occurred would miss the opportunity to buy the stock at cheap prices.
Point E
The share price of Supermax continued to move up after the breakout, as sellers
became fewer and fewer, and some major investors’ aggressive buying pushed
the price up. Subsequently, the stock hit its next resistance (LN4) around Rm
0.500/share. The stock traded in a range-bound market (descending channel) for
a week, and then broke out again on 7 August 2009 with high volume (58.88
million shares). The trade volume at breakout point was also higher than that of
the previous high, which signifies that the breakout was a valid breakout.
Therefore, the breakout was the area where Koon would add more shares to his
winning position, with 20% ~ 30% of the money in his fund, as sellers were
getting less and less, buying interest was high, and the company had just
released the second quarter of increased earnings.
Point F
After the breakout, the original resistance line (LN4) turned into a new support
line, as investors who missed the opportunity to buy at the breakout point would
join others to buy when its price approached the price region. The share price of
Supermax rose quickly after the breakout. Profit-taking then began after the
stock went up about 25% to Rm 0.625/share. Shakeout could also be happening
at the same time. The stock came down to test its support (LN4) on 1 September
2009 with low trading volume. The low volume pullback toward support area
was actually a healthy correction and the long-term uptrend remained intact.
That was another point where Koon would add more shares to his winning
position, with 5 ~ 10% of the money in his fund, before the value of the stock
was realised.
Page | 12
Case Study 1
Point G
Supermax retested its support (LN4) on 2 Oct 2009. At that point, the stock was
not only supported by the descending support (LN4), it was also supported by
the short-term moving average (50-day SMA). Technicians or traders who
waited at the side line patiently would come in to buy the stock at that point in
time, thus preventing the share price of Supermax from declining further. In
addition, the number of people who were willing to part with their shares at the
level had dropped significantly, as many of these weak longs had already been
taken out of the stock earlier. That was the point where Koon would scoop up
the fantastic bargains before the supply dried up.
Point H
After a period of consolidation, the stock broke above its descending resistance
(LN5) or falling wedge on 5 Oct 2009, around Rm 0.500/share. At the same
time, its volume picked up at the breakout point. That was the area where Koon
would add more shares to his winning position. By that time Koon probably had
used up all his original capital. But his accounts would not be running out of
money. In fact, with margin finance, he would never short of fund (to buy more
shares) if the share price continues to rise. As the share price of Supermax went
up, his collateral value also went up in tandem. Therefore, Koon could borrow
more money from his brokers through margin finance to buy more Supermax
shares as the price continued to climb. Note that even though his original fund
had run dry, Koon would not settle down for just a small gain. If he believed
that the stock still had plenty of room to grow, he would stick to his guns, and
borrow money from banks to buy more shares, despite the disagreement of his
friends.
Point I
The stock continued to rise, crossed above Rm 0.600/share (LN6), and produced
another higher high on 13 October 2009, with high volume (44.03 million
shares). That was another area where Koon would add more shares to his
winning position, using margin loan, as the resistance of the stock was very low
at that level. Note that as the share price climbed, the trade volume also
increased in tandem. This signified that the price rise had attracted a lot more
market participants to the stock.
Point J
The stock continued its upward move, and attracted more and more traders into
the game. A bearish engulfing candlestick then appeared on the chart of
Supermax on 23 October 2009, as S&P500 index futures fell more than 1% after
US market hours. At that point in time, the price of Supermax had gone up too
fast, and its gradient was too steep. It was due for a correction. Koon always
says no stock can continue to go up higher and higher for whatever reasons.
That was the point where Koon would take some money off the table, so that he
could reduce his margin loan, realise some of his gains, and buy more shares
during pullback.
Point K
Supermax’s share price then moved in a narrow descending channel (bullish
flag) from 23 October 2009 to 9 November 2009. The pullback on falling
Page | 13
Case Study 1
volume was not only a good time for the stock to take a breather, it was also an
opportunity to drive weak holders out. Subsequently it crossed above the
resistance or upper descending line (LN7) on 10 November 2009. The lower
section of the consolidation zone, and the breakout point were the area where
Koon would add more shares to his winning portfolio, as the price had fallen
15%, but the demand for gloves was still expected to increase since the H1N1
Swine Flu epidemic had not shown any sign of improvement. Around that
period in time, the company also indicated that the gains from the sale of
treasury shares at higher prices, and the extraordinary profits from higher
demand of gloves would be distributed to shareholders as special dividend.
Point L
An ascending triangle subsequently formed, as its share price failed to move
higher after hitting the resistance level (LN8), but each pullback within the
triangle reversed at a higher low. Note that the trade volume was getting lighter
and lighter before the breakout occurred. It was an indication showing that weak
holders or sellers had become less and less as the consolidation continued. After
trading the range bound for eight weeks, the stock broke above its resistance
(LN8) on 17 December 2009 with high trading volume. Additionally, it showed
that the buying pressure was higher than the selling pressure. That was the
period in time that Koon would add more share to his position using borrowed
money from his brokers.
Point M
After the breakout, the old resistance became a new support. The stock came
down to test the new support (LN8) after the breakout, and moved sideways,
bounded by LN9 (resistance) and LN8 (support), for a week, which led to the
formation of a small box pattern. Impatient speculators, doubtful traders, and
other weak holders, who had no intention to invest for long-term, and had no
confidence in the company, were taken out of the stock slowly within that week.
After a week of sideways drift, the resistance dropped significantly. The stock
then crossed above the resistance (LN9) of the box on 28 Dec 2009. The
sideways market, and the breakout point were another area where Koon would
add more shares to his winning position.
Point N
After breaking through the line of least resistance, Supermax’s share price
moved up very fast, as many of the weak holders had been taken out of the
stock earlier. It shot up nearly 50% within two weeks without experiencing any
corrections. The movement was obviously too fast, the gradient was too steep,
and the stock was due for another correction. Koon always says no stock can
continue to go up and up for whatever reason, and after some time it will
experience a pullback. A shooting star then appeared on the chart on 14 January
2010. That is an indicator showing that whilst the crowd still pushed the share
price up, smart money had started to take some profits off the table. That was
also the point where Koon would sell some of his shares into strength, in order
to pare down his margin loan, to realise some of his gains, and to bring down
his cost. To Koon, profit is not a dirty word if earned ethically. If he did not take
it, someone else would.
Page | 14
Case Study 1
Point O
Subsequently the stock experienced a correction, as profit-taking began after the
stock rose 50% within two weeks. At the same time, short-term traders,
gamblers, or weak holders were also forced to either take a small profit or cut
loss when the share price dropped. The stock came down to test its support (50-
day SMA) on 9 February 2010. Traders who missed the chances to buy earlier
would take advantage of the opportunity to build their positions at that level.
That was also the point where Koon would use the sales proceeds to buy more
shares at a lower price (around Rm 0.95/share). The reason of buying at that
point was that many of the weak holders had already been taken out of the stock,
and newcomers had a tendency to hold the shares longer in their portfolios,
which would increase the stability of the stock. In addition, the demand for
medical gloves was still high. Therefore, the company would continue to
produce increasing profits, which was one of the key factors that could drive
interest of market participants in the stock higher.
Point P
The stock broke above its descending resistance (LN10) with high volume on 17
Feb 2010. It is noteworthy that trade volume before the breakout was very light,
which signified that most if not all weak holders and sellers who intended to sell
near the level had already been taken out of the stock. That was another area
where Koon would continue to buy with borrowed money from his stock
brokers.
Point Q
The stock continued its upward trend following the breakout until profit-taking
began on 4 March 2010. It then experienced a mild correction for two weeks,
from 5 March 2010 to 22 March 2010. The next breakout occurred on 23 March
2010 when Supermax crossed above its previous high or resistance (LN11) with
high volume. Again, that would be the point where Koon would add more
shares to his winning position.
Point R
The stock experienced a consolidation following the breakout at Point Q, and
led to the formation of a descending triangle. Its share price broke out upward
(crossed above the descending resistance or LN12) on 9 June 2010. The
breakout was a signal of the continuation of the original bullish trend. At the
same time, it crossed above the 50-day SMA. That was another point that Koon
would add more shares to his position.
Point S
After rising for a week, its share price stopped rising again. It then went through
a period of consolidation, for about two weeks. During the consolidation, its
share price made a series of higher lows, thus forming a rising support (LN13),
and several equal highs, thus forming a flat resistance line (LN14). Breakout of
the ascending triangle occurred on 12 July 2010, but with a relatively low
volume. That was the point where Koon would buy, but with just a very little
amount of money. The reason is that the breakout with low volume and the rally
on contracting volume, were a bearish sign, which indicated that people
interested in the stock had decreased.
Page | 15
Case Study 1
Point T
After peaking around Rm 1.620/share, the share price of Supermax began to
decline on 20 July 2010, and crossed below its main trendline (LN1) on 12
August 2010. That was a warning sign indicating that the uptrend has ended.
Also, the temperature testing equipment used at the airport had been removed at
that point in time. It implied that the situation was under control, and the
demand for medical gloves would begin to fall. That was the time when Koon
would start disposing his shares, as the demand for medical gloves would
decrease, and the earnings of Supermax would decline.
Point U
The price crossed below its prior low (Rm 1.400/share) or support (LN15) on 18
August 2010. The series of lower highs and lower lows were a sign showing
that the downtrend was confirmed. As can be seen on the chart, there were more
bearish candlesticks than bullish candlesticks in that area, and the bullish
candlesticks were short, which indicated that the buying pressure was low,
selling pressure was higher than buying pressure, and most of the buyers were
dumb money. In addition, the price decline was on increasing volume, which
was also a bearish signal. That was the point where Koon would dispose his
shares aggressively.
Point V
The price crossed below its prior low (Rm 1.250/share) or support (LN16) on 3
September 2010. It signified that the support was weak, and the selling pressure
was strong. That was another good selling opportunity for investors who wanted
to get out of their positions.
Point W
Supermax crossed below its 200-day SMA (Rm 1.220/share) on 7 September
2010. It was also a bearish sign, as the long-term support (or long-term moving
average) had been breached. That was another selling opportunity for investors
who had not sold their shares earlier. By that time, Koon had completely sold all
his Supermax shares. After several weeks of decline, the writing was on the wall
for all investors, and there was no reason to not getting out, as most smart
money had disposed their shares.
Point X
The long-term moving average support (200-day SMA) then became a new
resistance for the stock after the breakdown. The stock attempted to bounce
back but failed to crossed above the 200-day SMA. Sellers would dispose their
shares aggressively when price approached the line. Apparently, the selling
pressure was too strong. The price then resumed its downward move on 14
September 2010.
Point Y
The stock continued its downward move and its price crossed below the prior
low (Rm 1.140/share) or support (LN17) on 17 September 2010. The support
was a weak one, as there were not many peaks and troughs on the left-hand side
of the chart. The breakdown of LN17 was another selling opportunity for
Page | 16
Case Study 1
investors who wanted to get out of their positions, and to turn their paper gains
into cold cash.
Point Z
After hitting the trough with high volume on 30 September 2010, the stock
attempted to bounce back. At that level, the stock was oversold, and its price
had gone down too fast. At the same time, dumb money who missed the chance
to buy previously would join the crowd to buy shares aggressively at the level.
After rising for two weeks, Supermax’s short-term moving average (50-day
SMA) crossed below its long-term moving average (200-day SMA) on 15
October 2010. The death cross was the last bearish signal that investors should
not ignore. Investors who had not sold their shares earlier should take advantage
of on the dead cat bounce to sell their share at a higher price before the stock
falling further.
Remark:
The above-mentioned points are just some of the major points where Koon
would buy and sell his Supermax shares during the outbreak of H1N1 Swine Flu
in 2009. In fact, there were many other points where Koon would buy and sell
within the two years, in order to reduce his cost, and to optimise his return.
Sometimes, if the volatility was high, or when the stock was overbought or
oversold, he would get in and out, several times a day, to make some small
quick profits.
Page | 17
Further Reading
Further Reading
Books:
Page | 2
Further Reading
Page | 3
Further Reading
59. The Essays of Warren Buffett: Lessons for Corporate America. By: Warren E.
Buffett and Lawrence A. Cunningham
60. The Four Pillars of Investing: Lessons for Building a Winning Portfolio. By:
William J. Bernstein
61. The Great Minds of Investing: William Green, Michael O'Brien, and Hendrik
Leber
62. The Guru Investor: How to Beat the Market Using History's Best Investment
Strategies. By: John P. Reese and Jack M. Forehand
63. The Intelligent Investor: The Definitive Book on Value Investing. By: Benjamin
Graham.
64. The Intelligent Investor's Mind: The Psychology and Philosophy of Smart
Investing. By: Eldon Frost
65. The Interpretation of Financial Statements. By: Benjamin Graham.
66. The Little Book of Behavioral Investing: How not to be Your Own Worst
Enemy. By: James Montier
67. The Little Book of Common Sense Investing: The Only Way to Guarantee Your
Fair Share of Stock Market Returns. By: John C. Bogle
68. The Little Book of Trading: Trend Following Strategy for Big Winnings. By:
Michael W. Covel
69. The Little Book of Valuation: How to Value a Company, Pick a Stock and
Profit. By: Aswath Damodaran
70. The Little Book of Value Investing. By: Christopher H. Browne
71. The Market Gurus: Stock Investing Strategies You Can Use from Wall Street's
Best. By: John P. Reese and Todd Glassman
72. The Most Important Thing: Uncommon Sense for the Thoughtful Investor. By:
Howard Marks
73. The New Market Wizards: Conversations with America's Top Traders. By: Jack
D. Schwager
74. The New Sell and Sell Short: How to Take Profits, Cut Losses and Benefit from
Price Declines. By: Alexander Elder
75. The Only Investment Guide You'll Ever Need. By: Andrew Tobias
76. The Outsiders: Eight Unconventional CEOs and Their Radically Rational
Blueprint for Success. By: William Thorndike
77. The Psychology of Investing. By: John R. Nofsinger
78. The Swing Trader’s Bible: Strategies to Profit from Market Volatility. By:
Matthew McCall & Mark Whistler
79. The Tao of Charlie Munger: A Compilation of Quotes from Berkshire
Hathaway’s Vice Chairman on Life, Business and the Pursuit of Wealth. By:
David Clark
80. The Treasury of Wall Street Wisdom. By: Harry D. Schultz & Samson Coslow
81. The Value Investors: Lessons from the World’s Top Fund Managers. By:
Ronald W. Chan
82. The Warren Buffett Portfolio: Mastering the Power of the Focus Investment
Strategy. By: Robert G. Hagstrom
83. The Warren Buffett Way. By: Robert G. Hagstrom
84. Thinking, Fast and Slow. By: Daniel Kahneman
85. Trade Like A Stock Market Wizard: How to Achieve Superperformance in
Stocks in Any Market. By: Mark Minervini
86. Trade Like an O'Neil Disciple: How We Made 18,000% in the Stock Market.
By: Gil Morales and Chris Kacher
Page | 4
Further Reading
87. Trader Vic--Methods of a Wall Street Master. By: Victor Sperandeo, T. Sullivan
Brown
88. Trend Trading for a Living: Learn the Skills and Gain the Confidence to Trade
for a Living. By: Thomas K. Carr
89. Valuation: Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies. By: McKinsey &
Company
90. Value Investing: How to Become a Disciplined Investor. By: Glen Arnold
91. Value Investing Made Easy: Benjamin Graham's Classic Investment Strategy
Explained for Everyone. By: Janet Lowe
92. Value Investing: From Graham to Buffett and Beyond. By: Bruce C. N.
Greenwald, Judd Kahn, Paul D. Sonkin, and Michael van Biema
93. Value Investing: Tools and Techniques for Intelligent Investment. By: James
Montier
94. Visual Guide to Chart Patterns. By: Thomas N. Bulkowski
95. Way of the Turtle: The Secret Methods that Turned Ordinary People into
Legendary Traders. By: Curtis M. Faith
96. What Works on Wall Street, Fourth Edition: The Classic Guide to the Best-
Performing Investment Strategies of All Time. By: James O’Shaughnessy
97. Why Moats Matter: The Morningstar Approach to Stock Investing. By: Heather
Brilliant & Elizabeth Collins
98. Winning on Wall Street. By: Martin Zweig
99. Winning the Loser’s Game: Timeless Strategies for Successful Investing. By:
Charles D. Ellis
100. You Can Be a Stock Market Genius: Uncover the Secret Hiding Places of Stock
Market Profits. By: Joel Greenblatt
Page | 5
Further Reading
Website:
1. https://klse.i3investor.com/index.jsp
2. https://seekingalpha.com/
3. https://www.gurufocus.com/
4. https://www.investopedia.com/
5. https://www.koonyewyin.com/
6. https://www.valuewalk.com/
7. https://www.zerohedge.com/
Page | 6