Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5000079
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Purpose. To evaluate ocular surface changes in long-term silicone hydrogel contact lens wearers.
Methods. Thirty patients were included in this study. Twenty patients (40 eyes) using contact lenses
constituted group 1 and 10 (20 eyes) volunteers constituted group 2. The duration of average contact
lens usage was 7.74±3.3 years. Ocular surface was evaluated by surface staining, tear film break-
up time (TBUT), Schirmer I test, and conjunctival impression cytology with color-coded mapping
technique and by the Ocular Surface Disease Index (OSDI).
Results. The mean break-up time was lower and staining scores were higher in group 1 (p<0.001)
but Schirmer values were not significantly different from group 2 (p>0.05). The mean OSDI score was
34.59±11.93 to 19.28±6.7 in group 1 and 2. Increased metaplastic predominant changes of grade II
and III were observed in the interpalpebral and perilimbal areas in group 1. Significant correlations
were observed in TBUT, cornea staining, and grade II to grade III metaplasia ratios between duration
of the lens usage and contact lens wear time in a day.
Conclusions. Silicone hydrogel lenses produce significant changes on tear film and impression cytology
of the ocular surface in long-term use.
Key Words. Contact lens side effects, Dry eye, Impression cytology, Ocular surface, Ocular Surface
Disease Index
Accepted: October 17, 2011
examine conjunctival epithelium. In 1977, Egbert et al (5) Tear quality was measured with TBUT, tear production
documented the usage of cellulose acetate filters to detect was measured with Schirmer I test (without using topical
goblet cell density in patients with dry eye syndrome. anesthesia), and ocular surface was evaluated by corneal
Nelson et al devised a 3-stage classification based on and interpalpebral conjunctival staining and by conjunctival
nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio of conjunctival epithelium and impression cytology.
goblet cell density (6). Corneal fluorescein staining was examined with cobalt
Squamous metaplasia in conjunctival epithelium, decrease blue illumination and graded using the Oxford Scheme
in goblet cells due to tear film instability and increased 6-point scale (from 0 to 5). After instilling Lissamine green,
irritation (3), and abnormal chromatin in nuclei are reported interpalpebral conjunctival staining of temporal and nasal
in contact lens wearers. Previous studies on impression conjunctivas were graded with the Oxford Scheme (13).
cytology (7-10) generally used a single or average grade for Impression cytology was performed in superior-temporal
one specimen over a limited area of conjunctiva. Using a and inferior-nasal quadrants with the 11-mm diameter
single average grade for one specimen and attributing this semicircular (forming a large perilimbal ring) cellulose
grading over a large area may obscure very valuable data acetate filter papers with 0.025 µm pore size (Millipore
(11). Color-coded mapping technique in impression cytology GSWPO 4300). This system was preferred to obtain
is a method aimed to demonstrate metaplastic changes in samples from a large area (Fig. 1).
a wide area of conjunctival epithelium. During this mapping Cytologic changes were evaluated under light microscopy
technique, different stages of metaplastic changes are according to Nelson’s grading system with the color-coded
marked with different colors on a millimetric scale paper mapping technique (12). The grades of impression cytology
and then, the distribution degree and percentage of ocular per square millimeter under light microscope were marked
surface metaplasia are determined (12). on the millimetric scale paper. A different color was used
The aim of the study was to evaluate tear functions and for each grade. The percentage of distribution of grades
ocular surface changes by using impression cytology with was calculated and a color map was prepared for each
color-coded mapping technique and contact lens–related specimen (Fig. 2).
dry eye symptoms in long-term soft silicone hydrogel Dry eye symptoms were scored by a questionnaire (OSDI,
contact lens wearers. Allergan Inc, Irvine, CA), which measures range and
severity of symptoms and impact of symptoms on patient’s
performance of daily functions. Twelve items of the OSDI
METHODS questionnaire were graded on scale from none (= 0) to all (=
4) of the time. Total OSDI score was calculated according
Thirty patients (60 eyes) were enrolled in the study. Forty to a formula (14). Thus a score on a scale of 0 to 100 was
eyes of 20 patients using contact lenses constituted group obtained with higher scores representing a greater disability.
1 and 20 eyes of 10 volunteers who did not wear contact Descriptive statistics were used to summarize all variables.
lenses in the past and during the study constituted group Mann-Whitney U, Kruskal-Wallis, and Pearson tests were
2 (the control group). Patients in group 1 were all using used for statistical analysis.
silicone hydrogel contact lenses with low water content
(Lotrafilcon A [24%], Focus Night & Day, or Senofilcon A
[38%], Acuvue OAsys). RESULTS
Patients with any previous ophthalmic surgery, ocular
trauma, long-term use of topical medication, or systemic The mean age of the patients was 28.77±4.29 years in
diseases were excluded. Informed consent was obtained group 1 and 29.2±2.86 years in group 2; female:male ratio
from all the patients following all the guidelines for was 11:9 in group 1 and 6:4 in group 2 (p>0.05). The mean
experimental investigation in human subjects required by duration of average contact lens usage was 7.74±3.30
the Institutional Review Board. years (range 3 to 12). All the patients in group 1 were using
During slit-lamp biomicroscopy, the presence of blepharitis, new generation silicone hydrogel contact lenses on a daily
meibomitis, or any abnormality in cornea, conjunctiva, and wear modality. The mean lens diopter was –2.79±2.35 D
lid were recorded. (range –2.0 to –6.50).
Fig. 3 - Impression cytology result of a patient in group 1 (contact Fig. 4 - Impression cytology result of a patient in group 2 (control
lens wearers) with color-coded mapping technique. The perilimbal group) with color-coded mapping technique. Isolated areas of grade
area shows predominantly grade II. I to grade II metaplasias were observed in the inferior-nasal areas.
TABLE I - THE MEAN VALUES FOR THE TBUT AND SCHIRMER I AND OSDI SCORES ACCORDING TO THE GROUPS
OSDI = Ocular Surface Disease Index; TBUT = tear film break-up time.
a
p<0.05.
b
p<0.001.
TABLE II - SQUAMOUS METAPLASIA GRADE RATIOS IN THE SUPERIOR-TEMPORAL AND INFERIOR-NASAL QUADRANTS
ACCORDING TO THE GROUPS
Superior-temporal
Grade 0 9.67 34.30 0.0572
Grade I 44.03 20.30 0.0019a
Grade II 35.40 0.40 0.0000b
Grade III 2.92 0.00 0.0195a
Inferior-temporal
Grade 0 6.78 33.19 0.0468a
Grade I 39.47 17.06 0.0016a
Grade II 49.21 4.75 0.0000b
Grade III 3.44 0.00 0.0195a
a
p<0.05.
b
p<0.001.
of contact lens use was also correlated with TBUT, cornea day or duration of the contact lens use (p>0.05, Pearson).
staining, and grade II metaplasia ratio in the superior- Eight patients were using lotrafilcon A (24%), Focus Night
temporal quadrant and grade III metaplasia in the inferior- & Day, and 12 patients were using senofilcon A (38%),
nasal quadrants (p<0.05, Pearson). No correlation was Acuvue OAsys lenses. There was no statistically significant
observed between OSDI and contact lens wear time in a difference between lens brands when compared (p>0.05).
DISCUSSION report dry eye (18). It has also been shown that there is
no correlation between dehydration, movement, diameter,
The report of the National Eye Institute/Industry Workshop and dryness symptoms between different water content
on clinical trials in dry eyes proposed a classification hydrogel lenses (24). Instead of dehydration of the lenses,
scheme that stratifies patients with dry eye from those with it is proposed that the polar headgroups associated with
decreased aqueous tear production by the lacrimal glands the tear film lipid molecules are attracted to lenses of
to those with increased evaporative loss (15). Contact lenses higher water content, leaving their nonpolar tails extended
were listed as a subcategory of evaporative dry eye in the away from the lens surface, leading to evaporation and/
overall dry eye schema. Approximately 50% of contact lens or dewetting (2). New lens materials—silicone hydrogels
wearers report experience of dry eye symptoms at least with their low water content, high oxygen transmissibility,
occasionally. It is also shown that contact lens wearers are and unique biocompatibility—may have some advantages
12 times more likely than clinical emmetropes and 5 times on this aspect. Our patients were using low water content
more likely than spectacle wearers to report dry eye (16). non-ionic lenses with 24%-38% water content.
Although Farris (17) discussed 20 years ago that contact The highest correlation coefficient found with tolerance
lenses might be the cause of dry eye, the etiology was to contact lens wear in the literature is TBUT, which is a
poorly understood. Possible mechanisms of contact lens– measure of tear film stability and symptom scoring tests.
related dry eye include increased evaporation of the tear Researchers have found a significant difference of TBUT
film, inflammation, increased osmolality, dewetting related and basal Schirmer values between control group and
to the lack of biocompatibility of the lens surface, or any contact lens wearers. The TBUT and basal Schirmer values
combination of these mechanisms (18). are reported to decrease directly according to the duration
Contact lenses all affect the tear film by increasing the of lens wear (25-27). The mechanism that affects the tear
evaporation rate, and decreasing tear thinning time, and film is unclear but microtrauma and subclinical inflammation
the effect of a silicone hydrogel material on the tear film is in the conjunctiva and conjunctival glands may contribute
similar to that of all other lens types (19). The precorneal (26). In our study, TBUT was shorter in the contact lens
tear film is divided into 2 layers when a contact lens is wearing group (group 1) than the control group (group 2),
applied: the pre-lens tear film (PLTF) and the postlens compatible with other studies, but we did not observe
tear film (PoLTF). The PLTF is thought to be associated a significant difference for basal Schirmer test results
more with wearing comfort and clinical performance; the between control group and contact lens wearers.
PoLTF, with lens fit and movement (20). Thinner PoLTF Impression cytology has been used to study ocular
are associated with lower tear exchange and may allow surface and conjunctival epithelial changes including
tear film debris and metabolic by-products to accumulate contact lens related. Cytologic alterations are observed
between the lens and the cornea, causing lens binding within 3 to 6 months for the contact lens wearers and it
and threatening corneal integrity (21). Evaporative effects is increased significantly with the duration of contact lens
will differ, and while low water content lenses may prevent wear (8, 9, 28).
evaporation from the PoLTF, it is not clear that evaporation Direct chronic mechanical irritation and metabolic
from the PLTF will be similarly affected. The main structural inflammation induced by contact lenses contribute to the
alteration to the tear film when lenses are applied is that development of certain cytologic changes in the ocular
which occurs to the superficial lipid layer. The lens sits surface such as squamous metaplasia and goblet cell
within the aqueous layer, not only disturbing the regularity loss leading to symptoms (8, 24). Research on cytologic
of the ocular surface, but also leaving a very thin layer for changes induced by contact lenses usually focused on the
the lipid layer to form on. Consequently, the PLTF is much superior bulbar conjunctiva (8, 28, 29).
thinner than a normal precorneal tear film and there will be According to the chronic mechanical irritation theory, the
only a thin lipid layer on top of hydrogel lenses (22, 23). most mechanical effect is exposed in the limbus between
While higher water content materials are related to dry eye the 12 o’clock and 6 o’clock positions (9). Knop and Brewitt
status (2), contact lens dehydration was not shown to be observed cytologic changes and snake-like chromatin
related to dry eye in lens wearers. Patients wearing low appearance mostly in the 12 o’clock position in 13 out of
water content lenses that maintained their hydration do not 14 patients through conjunctiva impression cytology and
fewer amounts in the 6 o’clock position and rarely in the and accurate assessment of the range and severity of
nasal and limbal conjunctiva in a group of asymptomatic dry eye symptoms, as well as impact of symptoms on
soft contact lens wearers (10). patient’s performance of daily functions, which may be
Silicone hydrogel lenses are reported to transmit oxygen considered important for a contact lens wearer. The dry
that is closely matching to the oxygen available to an eye not eye questionnaire administered by Begley et al (32) showed
wearing contact lenses (30). Therefore hypoxic response that the symptoms of ocular dryness and discomfort are
in the conjunctiva is not expected with silicone hydrogel relatively common among contact lens wearers and that
lenses. In our study soft silicone hydrogel contact lens they worsen toward the end of the day. The contact lens
wearers showed severe metaplasia which was increasing dry eye questionnaire’s short form developed by Nichols et
predominantly in the interpalpebral and perilimbal areas. al (33) has been shown to be moderately reliable in contact
Mechanical effect of the silicone hydrogel lenses around lens wearers. In our study, OSDI scores were significantly
the limbus and increased evaporation in the interpalpebral higher in the contact lens wearers and they were correlated
area, which has an important role in contact lens–related with TBUT and impression cytology results.
dry eye, may be responsible for the cytologic changes that Soft contact lens wearers who were symptomatic
were observed. are reported to have a significant increase in both
The effect of hydrogel contact lenses on ocular surface biomicroscopic and cytologic grades but no correlation was
with color-coded mapping technique was evaluated in a found between duration of lens use and biomicroscopic or
previous study (12). Higher degrees of metaplastic changes cytologic grades in a study (34). In our study, we found
were observed around the limbus and in the lower quadrants correlation between duration of contact lens use and
with a sharp demarcation line separating them from the TBUT, cornea staining, and grade II metaplasia ratio in the
other grades. In this previous study, crescent-shaped filter superior-temporal quadrant and grade III metaplasia in
papers were put in a vertical manner in the temporal and the inferior-nasal quadrants (p<0.05). We also found that
nasal quadrants. Differently in this study, filter papers were correlation between contact lens wear time in a day with
cut in a semicircular shape not to leave any unexamined TBUT, cornea staining, and grade II to grade III metaplasia
area and placed in the superior-temporal and inferior-nasal ratios in superior-temporal and inferior-nasal quadrants
quadrants to help the manipulation. In this study, increased was even more evident (p<0.001).
metaplastic changes, predominantly grade II and isolated In conclusion, silicone hydrogel lenses, despite their high
areas of grade III, were observed in the interpalpebral and oxygen permeability and low water content, produce
perilimbal areas with a sharp demarcation line with the significant changes on tear film and impression cytology
areas under the lid during the mapping of the cytologic on long-term use.
changes in the contact lens wearers in both quadrants,
while in the control group only isolated areas of grade I The authors report no proprietary interest or financial support.