Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—E-Service in Bangladesh has become a catalytic calls or fax transmission is basically termed as the VAS.
agent for empowering additional effective government services. Conventionally, mobile telecommunication promoted two most
This article investigates issue covering clues on IT policy about popular VAS services like, Short Messaging Services (SMS),
the implementation of marketable commercial services as mobile and Multimedia Messaging Services (MMS). The VAS
e-services under the boundary expansion issue of large emerged as voice call-related services such as call waiting, call
organization like Mobile Network Operator. In Bangladesh, forwarding, multiparty conferencing and voice mail. A policy
Specialized services are provided by different vendors, where the debate can play effective role as Mobile Network Operators
service quality is always differed, because there is no integration (MNOs) have started practicing on providing specialized e-
of such collaboration. Operators can play a vital role by enabling
services under the category of VAS. Due to their technical
the service through Value Added Service (VAS). Users and
providers can find solutions that can help to increase penetration
nature of service, MNO can perform the convergence and
of this untouched sector. In this article, we organize some issues, control issues of enabling specialized service or such services
provisioning approximately resilient guideline to the operators, with considerable policy debate [4].
so that operators cannot play monopoly and ensure a healthy Broadly, Apps based data services of mobile operators
competition. It concentrate on the effects of within and between
through 3G and LTE enhanced technology services could be
standards race and competition between operators on
performance developing and adopting new VAS services like e-
also defined as advance platform of future Telecom VAS [5].
health, as swelling of penetration of mobile services. Our Surrounded by numerous aspects, the convergence of voice
empirical exploration provides an indication of introduction of oriented telecommunication network as to data network,
specialized VAS service over Mobile Network, so users of the increasing penetration of smartphones and super speed mobile
core services will be migrated to new data services. Finally, the wireless connectivity technology like 3G or LTE are
control of the service level agreement of e-services with fair proposing the opportunity of delivering functionally
practice of competition among operators to positively change the specialized services such as health, education and media over
curve of specialized service penetration is investigated. the telecommunication network. There is an emerging practice
of prefixing 'e' to these services, such as e-heath, e-newspaper
or e-education, when they are carried over electronic network.
Keywords—Value Added Service (VAS), E-service, Mobile
When these services are delivered over mobile network,
Network Operator (MNO), and Policy.
instead of e as prefix m is added to these services as m-VAS,
is also common [5] [6] [7] [8].
I. INTRODUCTION
Conventionally, the roll out implementation and migration
The Telecom Industry of Bangladesh has demonstrated the of the specialized VAS service in the mobile network operators
development in the mobile service penetration of the users that can be divided into some decision issues. In this regards,
has already surpassed all anticipation with 134.64 million of practice of the fair competition and the control of the regulation
subscriber as of May, 2016 contrasted with 116.23 million of the specialized service providers, an authority can dig some
subscriber in May 2014. There are six licensed private cellular- policy issues [9] [10]. Movement of the market leader on this
phone network operators in the telecommunication industry of business segment can change the market behavior which
Bangladesh [1]. These operators were established in reflects the producer and consumer surplus from these
association with overseas telecom companies [2], except the specialized services. If the other operators are not feeling the
state-owned TeleTalk. The mobile phone operators provide the market proposition of specialized service than the monopoly or
service on major part of the total telephone traffic in negative impact change the nature of the business arena.
countryside and remote parts of Bangladesh as well as Moreover, specialized service provider will be pushed in some
commercial users in large cities because of the availability of condition that their experienced will be sold in lower price that
land-based networks in the country is very limited [3]. reflect negative consumer behavior [6]. Impact on the
competition of the service prices and the control over the fair
Value Added Service (VAS) has an evolving definition in
polices of the specialized services provider with enhanced
the telecommunication industry. The services which add value
issues of service migration will raise the policy issues. Hence,
to the standard or core telecom-services offering like voice
value added services through the mobile network operators. specialized service providers to offer better products at less
For example, mobile phone and ICT facilities have also made cost to more customers, over the telecom network [6] [4] [7]
medical care possible at doorstep through fast communication [17]. From the fundamental theoretical point of view, unless
and over the phone support in primary treatment. A study and until there is significant opportunity to benefit from
shows that, telecommunication itself has helped consumer economies of scale and scope, and innovation, network
money during taking doctors’ appointments and seeking operators should not be allowed to enter the service segment of
service availability. It can be stated without any doubt that the value chain. The entry of mobile network operators
mobile phone alone improved the availability of health care (MNOs) in the functionally specialized service delivery market
service at a great extent in rural areas. Villagers are now well opens the door of enabling MNOs to apply multi-dimensional
tactics such as vertical foreclosure, cross subsidy and predatory
aware of availing a better and cost effective service for them.
pricing to weaken competition [4].
Seeking a good doctor or getting primary treatment without a
visit to a healthcare facility has become a regular scenario in
B. Who will Impose Policy and Control Functional
those areas [22]. A portion of them is very familiar with the
Specialized e-services by MNO?
fast cash service like “bKash”, “rocket” and “mobile money”
by some of the mobile operators [22] [23]. The next issue is all about the service control and
assurance of the specific market economy. Enabling MNO in
the classified functional e-services under VAS technology can
need some expertise of in-house development but it also need
III. ISSUES ON E-SERVICE CONVERGENCE TO VAS to focus on the controlling the aspects and the progress of the
market which change the customer satisfaction behavior. So,
A. Allow Mobile Operators to Provide e-services as VAS? the base of the second issue is who should formulate guideline
Offering quality technology services at an affordable price and regulate the delivery of the functionally specialized e-
in a non-discriminatory manner is the basic purpose of issuing services, to be delivered over the telecom network?
license to telecom operators. Mobile Network Operators The telecommunication sector of Bangladesh was
(MNO) are entitled with specific roles of technology unlocked to competition with the 1998 National
integrators, telecommunication and specific platform based Telecommunication Policy and 2001 Telecommunication
customer services providers. In course of time, they have also Acts. The market is controlled by the an self-governing
delegated technology integrator's role to global system organization, the Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory
integrators. All operators giving some common services to the Commission (BTRC) that was founded in 2002 and is in
users like caller tune, IVR portal , Job Portal , Daily News charge for licensing operators, ensuring compliances with
Portal, Ringtone Alert , Miss call alert, Sports service, Quiz license terms and conditions, supervising radio spectrum ,
contest, Different religion specific services and data services observing quality of telecom services, and setting
through some other agent. Specific service holders are not interconnection disputes and approving tariffs [12] [13] .
creating buzz in the mobile market economy in that level. So Without getting into the debate, it could be easily said that
the fair competition is mostly absent where service provider BTRC is most capable organization to handle VAS [26].
and market leader playing the monopoly.
Here, Fig. 02 expresses the activity flow of the e-services
With the growth of mobile technology, data service and which started from the specialized e-service provider, the
smart phone usage, as opportunity is evolving to offer diverse control aspects will be set by the management or the authority
services over such technology network - should we allow who will control and ensure the policy parameters. Finally the
mobile operators to be providers of such services? In regard of convergence of the e-services from the functional services of
this question, first need to check the status of the MNO’s VAS on the telecom industry comes into discussion. Hence,
strategy of development in specialized services. In recent time, specialized service provider uses different channel to distinct
MNOs have neither technology development capability, nor their service policy and optimize the core competence. Due to
track record of delivering specialized services like media, convergence of dissimilar service delivery channels, there
health or any social services [24]. The question appears to appears to be some degree of lack of clarity about the
have confusing merit to deserve discussion of engaging definition of these e-service products along with the role of
operators in delivering specialized services. To draw a regulatory authority [13]. Notwithstanding of delivery
parallel, should we entertain discussion whether the channel, regulation of delivery of specialized e-services
department of health and medicine should be allowed to be should not be guided by concerned regulatory bodies and
hospital service provider? [13] [25]. policy-making institutions, such as ministries of health,
Over decades, the whole nation has invested time, finance, or education [5] [4] [8].
experience, money and loyalty to develop each major service
segment such as financial, media, entertainment, education,
health, and insurance by functionally specialized service
providers, instead of asking MNOs to enter these industries.
The discussion always ends with the confusion, as such role of
MNOs will rather strongly facilitate competition among
policies. It does not sound rational to follow others without significant advantage from democratization of wireless
analyzing their policy decisions within their context to network and smartphone [30] [32].
understand how far they are prudent as well as adaptable
within the local context. Many Asian countries suffered from F. Summary of Advantages and Disadvantages of E-services
financial meltdown, except Bangladesh. Was it desirable for offered by MNOs and Other Specialized Entities?
Bangladesh to suffer from similar meltdown by following Here, the issues could be finalized by a wrap up with the
policy decision of other nations? [2] [16] competitive merits and demerits of the specific e-services
As boundary expansion can lead to failure to realize new roles enabled by the Mobile Network Operators and other private
in evolving industry, failure to improve organization agility entities which have already penetrated in this service segment.
could be a concern. Besides expansion issue can face big The Table. 01 in following showing the difference in a
trouble due to the lack of data integrity to drive growth, the nutshell.
inability to extract the value creation from the inorganic growth
and the failure to adopt new routes of innovation. Applying Advantages Disadvantages
regulation to standardize the behavior of MNOs and other
providers to have fair competitive environment, which is Economy scale of market can Low quality of service can
creating the concern of proper business vertical expansion. It give the operators confidence create service dissatisfaction
has been found that the policy of segmenting the value chain on finding target customers. and increase migration.
and limiting the entry of operators in appropriate segments MNOs can perceive benefits Playing fast and forward rule
minimizing the interest of applying counter competitive of e-services customization as can create monopoly on the
practices such as vertical foreclosure, cross subsidy and they are already in operation. customer service market.
predatory pricing works far better than regulating and
penalizing. [18] [32] [33]. MNOs enables homogenous Specialized service provider
e-service, so customer will get couldn’t able to create
the chance to taste alternatives alternatives in low cost, so
E. How VAS Gain Surplus when MNO on Steering Instead if switching cost is low. Lock-in behavior activated.
Specialized Operators? Merits will be nurtured when It might not be possible to
Economic value of the process improvement of the value specialized service provider create zero economic profit
addition through functional e-services refers to the surplus and consumer will glance the where market leader is
theory of the consumer and the producer. Bangladesh has a values of economic surplus. already far forward than other
large number of specialized operators in every major service operators.
segment, what is the merit of allowing only a handful of
Convergence of e-services to MNO will activate in-house
MNOs, which have no specialized capability, while raising
mobile VAS, telecom policy development of services for
concern over weakening competition? Now the question of
regulation could ensure the more profits, that adversely
new revenue source and survivability of the MNOs come into
benefits to the private entities. impacted the private entities.
discussion. Although the success of policy and regulation in
governing the telecom sector depends on many factors, one of Table. 01: Summary of service advantages and disadvantages
the important success factors is to create possibilities of
profitable competition of multiple operators. IV. CONCLUSION
Viewing the latest example in telecom, the pending merger of There could be many other issues which need to be
AirTel and Robi, weak financial health of Teletalk and debated to derive insights to feed into policy discussion to
Citycell, and long loss-making track record of Banglalink; the address the disconnection between policy decisions and
vital question of the success of market-led reform of the interpretation of evidences within sound theoretical
telecom industry of Bangladesh [34] surfaces- Grameenphone,
framework. Instead of keeping room for the MNOs to become
made more profit in each year than the amount shareholders
invested (paid up capital) to build the company. The market specialized services providers in the name of VAS, the smarter
leader is reporting very high profitability like more than BDT policy option will be to encourage them to develop as
12 net earnings (or profit) for each share of BDT 10. Such dependable fair technology service providers and intensify
profitability disparity does not appear to be a good health competition among the already existing service providers to
indicator of the state of competition of the sector [35]. deliver essential services like health, education and financial
services over telecom network and smartphones. By using the
Policy makers and regulators have reasons to look into the scope of facility to convergence the technology and adopting
matter. Instead of looking into the core underlying issues of the service they also meet the demand of the customer service
governing market led reform of the telecom industry, the under appropriate controlling authority of the regularity body.
argument of taking policy decision of opening the entry of
MNOs in functionally specialized services, runs the risk of
aggravating the competition scenario, with the likelihood of
spreading the counter competitive forces among other major
service segments of the society-which are poised to take