Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—This study investigated the success factors of integrated financial management information system in selected local government
districts of Kanungu and Rukungiri using by adapting employed the information systems success model of Delone and Mclean (2003) and the
CRUT model of Kappos and Rivard (2008) and employing descriptive comparative design. Data was collected from 86 sample size in a total
population of 110 using Interviews, observation and questionnaire method. findings revealed that information quality, organisational,
technology and user factors were rated very high in Rukungiri and Kanungu with average mean above 3.3; while system and service quality
were rated high in both districts of Rukungiri and Kanungu with average mean above 2.8. The study recommended improved IS training and
capacity building and encourage IS users in quality participation.
34
http://ijses.com/
All rights reserved
International Journal of Scientific Engineering and Science
Volume 2, Issue 7, pp. 34-40, 2018. ISSN (Online): 2456-7361
reliability, user participation, and training (CRUT) to ensure critical assessment has been conducted on local governments
information systems success. to ascertain the success factors of IFMIS, this study can help
Kappos and Rivard noticed that organizations become find out success factors that can be used to implement IFMIS
heavily involved in IS adoption, management is more likely to and improve general performance of local governments and
pay attention to factors that would enable them to properly service delivery. The main purpose of the study was to assess
maintain the quality of the IS. Considering the societal success factors of the integrated financial management
framework in which IS initiatives are established, Kappos and information system towards improving performance of local
Rivard (2008) declared that the perspectives IS researchers governments.
have about systems do not capture the relationship between IFMIS is an information system that tracks financial events
culture and the method of manufacturing IS. To properly and summarizes financial information. It supports adequate
adopt the right IS to accomplish organizational goals, management reporting, policy decisions, priority
management should consider utilizing systems that can be responsibilities and the preparation of auditable financial
controlled and maintained. statements. In its basic form, an IFMS is little more than an
Other IS researchers have addressed the centrality of accounting system configured to operate according to the
reliability in IS success, how IS can be manufactured clearly needs and specifications of the environment in which it is
for control and harmonization of organizational operations, the installed and IFMIS design must carefully meet the functional
importance of user participation in IS development and the needs and requirements of agencies, including the accounting
benefits of training employees on IS maintenance (Spears & and financial management tasks. In some cases, programmes
Barki, 2010). must create interfaces with existing IT systems (Semakula and
However, some scholars claimed that the Delone and Muwanga, 2012).
Mclean model is incomplete and suggested that more
dimensions should be included in the model the other models A well-Integrated Financial Management Information
be proposed. (Seddon, 2014). Therefore, researcher went System will support government wide as well as agency level
ahead and proposed a new model that integrates Delone and policy decisions. It will also integrate budget and budget
Mclean model and CRUT that can be used to make IFMIS execution data, allowing greater financial control and reducing
implementation succeed in local governments of Kanungu and opportunities for discretion in the use of public funds. This
Rukungiri system will provide information for budget planning, analysis
According to local government scorecard conducted by and government wide reporting. It also facilitate preparation of
Advocates For Development And Environment (ACODE) in financial statements and provide a complete audit trail in order
conjunction with Mending Broken Hearts Uganda (MBHU) in to facilitate audits (Research Journal of Finance and
2016, IFMIS has not only helped Rukingiri and Kanungu Accounting, 2014).
local Government to gain effective control over its finances,
1.1 IFMIS Success Factors
but also enhance transparency and accountability, reducing
political discretion and act as a deterrent to corruption and This study was guided by the information systems success
fraud. However, improvement of these local governments in model adapted from DeLone and McLean (2003) and The
their performance regarding service delivery is uncertain. The CRUT model) of Kappos and Rivard (2008).These outlined
system has occasions of delayed budget planning and the success factors as follows:
execution by providing untimely and in accurate data for System quality
budget management and decision-making. Some users adhere According Delone and Mclean (2003), the overall quality
to common standards, rules and procedures, with the view to of a system is also one of the most common dimensions along
reducing risks of mismanagement of public resources in the which information systems are evaluated. System quality
district but some activities still remain un accomplished yet indirectly impacts the extent to which the system is able to
their budget allocations are returned to the coffers of ministry deliver benefits by means of mediational relationships through
of finance at the end of a given financial years. There have the usage intentions and user satisfaction constructs. These
been several studies on the implementation of IFMIS in come in form of reliability, responsiveness, assurance, and
Uganda especially on the ministry of finance in general but no empathy to measure service quality.
35
http://ijses.com/
All rights reserved
International Journal of Scientific Engineering and Science
Volume 2, Issue 7, pp. 34-40, 2018. ISSN (Online): 2456-7361
Information quality the system is able to store, deliver, or produce, and is one of
According to dimensions of information systems model, the commonest dimensions along which information systems
Information quality refers to the quality of the information that are evaluated.
36
http://ijses.com/
All rights reserved
International Journal of Scientific Engineering and Science
Volume 2, Issue 7, pp. 34-40, 2018. ISSN (Online): 2456-7361
decision-makers choose the most adaptable and appropriate failure and deficient functionality. Studies conducted in
IFMIS tools for their environments. various countries such as Tanzania, Ghana, Uganda, Malawi
The sheer size and complexity of an Integrated Financial and Rwanda indicated that there are a number of challenges
Management Information System (IFMIS) poses significant that may influence the successful implementation of an IFMIS
challenges and a number of risks to the implementation but technological factors out ride the rest (Diamond
process that go far beyond the mere technological risk of &Khemani, 2006; Rodin-Brown, 2008).
Organization Factors done through various channels such as the media, workshops,
Implementing any system in the organization brings about seminars or conferences.
changes in processes, roles policies and functions. With these The objectives for a project provide the overall guidance
changes come resistance from some of those affected. for the upfront planning that translates into the future vision
Hendricks (2012) asserts that resistance to change may come for the organization, and the steps needed to accomplish the IT
from various stakeholders in the organization such as system implementation. This should also result in specified
individuals with vested interests who benefited from previous measures of success that can be used to evaluate the outcome
methods, civil servants who see it as a threat to their jobs and of the system implementation. The requirements provide the
people who resist change for the fear of the unknown. Change checklist as to what needs to be accomplished and what needs
management is therefore the process of creating, maintaining to be embodied in the software itself, and the implementation
and systematically evaluating changes that occur in the plan provides the actual steps to be performed. The project
organization (Barcan, 2010). This can be done through clear team and project manager should then be evaluated against
communication, education, training and other methods that these outcomes (Grabski& Leech, 2007).
emphasize on the need and benefits of the change. This can be
User Factors 1998). Somers and Nelson (2001) found that many
Kalbasi (2007) found that it is critical to build a cross- organizations use consultants to facilitate the implementation
functional team. A team with a mix of consultants and internal process and that these consultants generally have experience
staff should be created to enable internal staff to develop in specific industries with comprehensive knowledge about
technical skills for design and implementation. Grabski and certain modules.
Leech (2007) found that an organization, however, cannot Grabski and Leech (2007) found that a lack of project team
completely rely on consultants to implement an IT system, as expertise is often associated with software development risk.
consultants have limited specific knowledge of the In a survey by Nah (2003), it was found that having competent
organization‟s detailed operations. Thus, a close working members in the project team is the most important success
relationship between consultants and the organization‟s factor for IT system implementations. Both business and
project team could lead to a valuable skill transfer (Bowen technical knowledge are essential for IS success (Bingi et al.
37
http://ijses.com/
All rights reserved
International Journal of Scientific Engineering and Science
Volume 2, Issue 7, pp. 34-40, 2018. ISSN (Online): 2456-7361
1999; Sumner 1999). Grabski and Leech (2007) identified that attention should be paid to the composition of the project team
knowledge; skills, abilities, and experience in both technical which should contain both business and well trained technical
and business aspects are all critical factors in determining a team members.
project‟s success or failure. Doom et al. (2009) noted that
1.2 Proposed Model and Rukungiri context like technological factors, organization
Delone and Mclean (2003) and Kappos and Rivard (2008) factors and user factors, these factors together with
explained information quality, system quality, service quality performance dimensions of local government performance
as the major constructs that determines success of information discussed in the later in this study informed the new model
systems. They neglected other key success factors in Kanungu adopted by the researcher.
38
http://ijses.com/
All rights reserved
International Journal of Scientific Engineering and Science
Volume 2, Issue 7, pp. 34-40, 2018. ISSN (Online): 2456-7361
39
http://ijses.com/
All rights reserved
International Journal of Scientific Engineering and Science
Volume 2, Issue 7, pp. 34-40, 2018. ISSN (Online): 2456-7361
Available: http://www.iconnect- [14] Information Systems Maintenance: The Application of Total Quality
online.org/base/ic_show_news?sc=118&id=2363 [20.04. 2004]. Management Construct, IrikefeUrhuogo, Argosy University, Valerie
[8] R. Heeks, 2003a-last update, Building E-governance for Development: Vann University of Phoenix, Harish C. Chandan Argosy University
A framework for national and donor action [Homepage of Institute for [15] Journal of Business Studies Quarterly 2012
development policy and management], [Online]. Available: [16] H. Jun and W. R. King, “The role of user participation in information
http://idpm.man.ac.uk/publications/wp/igov/igov_wp12.pdf [18.02. systems development: Implications from a meta-analysis,” Journal of
2004]. Management Information Systems, vol. 25, issue 1, 2008.
[9] R. Heeks, 2003b-last update, Causes of E-Government Success and [17] A. Kappos and S. Rivard, “A three-perspective model of culture,
Failure [Homepage of IDPM, University of Manchester], [Online]. information systems, and their development and use,” MIS Quarterly,
Available: http://www.e-devexchange.org/eGov/causefactor.htm [24.08. vol. 32, issue 3, pp. 601-634, 2008.
2004]. [18] L. Semakula and R. Muwanga, Uganda: implementing an Integrated
[10] R. Heeks, 2002. Information Systems and Developing countries: Failure, Financial Management System and the automation of the budget process
success, and local improvisations. (Country Learning Notes). ODI, Budget Strengthening Initiative, 2012.
http://www.fes.uwaterloo.ca/crs/plan674d/isysanddcountries.pdf edn. [19] J. L. Spears and H. Barki, “User participation in information systems
Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis. Heeks, R. and Davies, A., 2000. security risk management,” MIS Quarterly, Vol. 34 No. 3, pp. 503-522,
Different Approaches to Information Age Reform. In: R. HEEKS, ed, 2010.
Reinventing [20] Uganda Development Partners, Joint Assistance Strategy for the
[11] GOK (2011). Integrated Financial Management Information System Republic of Uganda. Kampala, 2005.
(IFMIS) IFMIS Re-Engineering, From Modular, to Full Cycle End–To- [21] USAID (2003), Integrated Strategic Plan for USAID‟s Program in
End Processes, Strategic Plan 2011-2013. Uganda 2003-2007. Washington DC
[12] IFMIS Strategic Plan review paper of, 2011-2013
[13] IFMIS Strategic Plan review paper of, 2011-2013
40
http://ijses.com/
All rights reserved