Tranore Does axial force alec the shear force diagram? - Quora Search for questions, people, and topics Does axial force affect the shear force diagram? ‘Ad by Quon fo Business A great advertising solution to get high quality customers. Promote your business on Quora i's where people look for reliable information about your industry. Stat now at quora.com 2 Answers & ‘Alan Wang, structural engineer turned sotware developer Poses May 7, 2014 Upwey lesa Cabs, License Sct gist Autor has 72 ‘The short answer is: No, While the moment and shear diagrams are intricately connected (the moment diagram isthe Integral of the shear diagram), In ‘general, the axial force diagram has no effect on them, ‘The long answer is:It depends on the situation, What you have to realize is that ‘we divide a force into “axial and "shear" components based on its orientation to the cross section of whatever structural thing is carrying it. By definition, axial forces are perpendicular to the cross section and shear forces are parallel tothe cross section, However, the force itself couldn’ careless about al that, it just to get to a support through any path available to it, For example let's say ‘you wanted to support a vertical, downward force. Ifyou support that vertical, downward force on a Vertical column siting directly under it, then that column sees the force as “axial. instead, you support the same downward force on a horizontal beam, then that beam will see the force as “shear: Now imagine the following situation, Let's say you have a structure with one column, and one beam attached to the middle of it, The colurmn is supported at e beam is attached on it's let side to the column, and has & support on Its right side, Itkind of fooks lke a sideways T: the bottom. 7 Now imagine that you have 30lbs of force being applied downwards atthe top of. ‘the column, BUT for whatever reason, the column support can only hold a ‘maximum of 20Ibs. How do we support the remaining 10lbs? The answer is that the beam is going to have to take it, So now we have the beam carrying 10lbs, of vertical force. Since the beam is horizontal, this means that a downward force ‘would be parallel to the beams cross section; the beam takes this 10lbs as shear. What started out as axal force inthe column, Is now carried as shear force in the beam, If you were to draw the axial diagram for the above example, you would see 30Ibs of compression on the upper half ofthe column, 20Ibs of compression on. Sill have 8 question? Ask your ov! What is your question? ask [Renew Guecton] | Sign a Related Questone Wat the coneapt behind moment and shear forces? How do you draw an ail fore diagram? ‘Wat sx frco? What aro ts functons? How can | daw a shear force dagraa? Wat ar steps to convert a shea force dlagram Inthe shear ore agra, the shear force often takes a vt jump fram posite fo negative and veevera, What athe slgnvicanca of ‘Whats ser fores? Wy isthe shear force is zoo in maxim ‘Whats weal load? Wats shear force dagram? + Ask New Question tps hw. quora,com/Does- axial frce-affecthe-shearforce-diagram 48Tranore Ifyou were to draw the shear diagram, you would see 0 shear in the column, and. 10lbs, ofshear in the beam. Promeid by MobloAton ‘Make your app visible today. Increase rankings, drive up conversion and get moze downloads. Deal ending soon, last 24 hours, Sign up st mabeactonco Related Questions More Arena low Whats the concept behind moment and shear forces? How do you draw an axial force diagram? ‘hati axial force? What ere ts functions? How can | draw a shear force dlagram? What are steps to convert a shear force diagram into load dlagram? + Ask Now Question Jinal Dosh, structural Engineer and Founder ef Structural Mads Pros Mar 31,2014 Autor has 617 answers ard 2m ansner views Force diagram is the analysis diagram so in case of analysis you just deal with force direction and resolve the vectors. Shear force is induced in the structure because of the lateral loading while axial force because ofa load applied parallel tothe longitudinal axis, So when we calculate the forces and plot the diagrams ‘we will se that the shear force diagram is not affected by the axial force diagram. ‘But what is affected isthe shear stress across the cross section, as well as shear strength ofthe member. When you put compressive loads on member, the shear stress will increase wail it will decrease in case of tension. Related Questions Inthe shear force dlagram, the shear force often takes a vertical jump fom postive to nagative and viceversa, Whats the significance of Whats shoar force? why isthe shear force i zero in maximum moment? Whats axial nad? ‘hati shear force dlagram? Does any one know the best website to draw the shea fores and bending moment diagram online for oe? ‘Whats an axial force? ‘Whats the diference between the shear force diagram andthe bending moment dlagram? ‘what the vss of shear force alagram? Sill have 9 question? Ask your oun! Whatis your question? ask hitps hw. quora,com/Does-axialforce-afectse-shear-force-dagram oes axial force affect the shear force diagram? -Quora Related Questone Wat the coneapt behind moment and shear forces? How do you draw an ail fore diagram? ‘Wat sx frco? What aro ts functons? How can | daw a shear force dagraa? Wat ar steps to convert a shear force dlagram Inthe shear ore agra, the shear force often takes a vt jump fram posite fo negative and veevera, What athe slgnvicanca of ‘Whats ser fores? Wy isthe shear force is zoo in maxim ‘Whats weal load? Wats shear force dagram? + Ask New Question 28242018 Does axial force affect he shear force diagram? - Quora ‘What's a shear force? How many types of mechanical forces are there? ‘Whats a shear force and bending moment diagram in mecharical engin ing? “The lacing of compression members should be designate relet haw much transverse shear of axial force inthe member? + Ask Now Question Sillhave 9 question? Ask your oun! What is your question? hitps Aww. quora,com/Does-axialforce-afectse-shearforce-diagram ask Related Questons Wat the coneapt behind moment and shear forces? How do you draw an ail fore diagram? ‘Wat sx frco? What aro ts functons? How can | daw a shear force dagraa? Wat are steps to convert a shea force dlagram Inthe shear ore agra, the shear force often takes a vt jump fram posite fo negative and veevera, What athe slgnvicanca of ‘Whats ser fores? Wy isthe hear force is zoo in maxim ‘Whats weal load? Wats shear force dagram? + Ask New Question 38