You are on page 1of 6

CERVICAL FACET JOINT SEPTIC ARTHRITIS: A CASE REPORT

James M. Stecher, MD; Georges Y. El-Khoury, MD, Patrick W. Hitchon, MD

Abstract abscess formation, spinal cord/nerve root impingement


Facet joint septic arthritis is a rare but severe and sepsis. Two retrospective reviews of case reports in
infection with the possibility of significant morbid- the literature found that septic arthritis of the facet joint
ity resulting from local or systemic spread of the causes 4-20% of pyogenic spinal infections, the average
infection. Pain is the most common complaint on patient age is 55-59 and the overwhelming majority, 86-
presentation followed by fever, then neurologic 97%, occur in the lumbar spine.1,2 While most cases are
impairment. While the lumbar spine is involved thought to occur via hematogenous spread, there are a
in the vast majority of cases presented in the number of case reports in the literature where septic
literature, the case presented here occurred in arthritis of the facet joint resulted from iatrogenic causes
the cer vical spine. The patient presented with a including corticosteroid injection3-7 and epidural catheter-
three week histor y of neck and left shoulder pain ization.8,9 These infections can also occur secondary to
and was diagnosed by MRI when his pain did not spread from adjacent infections such as spondylodiscitis,
respond to analgesics and muscle relaxants. The epidural or paraspinal abscess, psoas muscle abscess
only predisposing factor was a histor y of diabetes or other intraabdominal infections. MRI has become
mellitus and the infection most likely resulted from the imaging modality of choice for diagnosis and de-
hematogenous spread. MRI is highly sensitive in termining extent of the infection. Timely and accurate
diagnosing septic arthritis and it is the preferred diagnosis of septic arthritis of the facet joint followed
modality for demonstrating the extent of infection by definitive therapy of this entity requires a multidis-
and secondar y complications including epidural ciplinary approach. Most cases are treated with up to 6
and paraspinal abscesses as seen in this case. weeks of parenteral antibiotics, percutaneous drainage
Without familiarity with this entity’s predisposing or open debridement depending on clinical symptoms
factors, clinical symptoms and appropriate lab/ and severity. While most patients typically experience
imaging work up, many patients experience a some delay in diagnosis, the majority of patients fully
delay in diagnosis. Treatment involves long term recover or experience mild residual pain/neurologic
parenteral antibiotics or percutaneous drainage. sequela following appropriate therapy.1
Surgical debridement is reserved for cases with se-
vere neurologic impairment. The incidence of facet Case presentation
joint septic arthritis is increasing likely related to The patient is a 57 year old male with a past medical
patient factors (increasing number of patients >50 history significant for type 2 diabetes mellitus who pre-
yo, immunosuppressed patients, etc), advancement sented to an outside hospital with a three week history
in imaging technology, availability of MRI, and of left shoulder and neck pain after a trial of analgesics
heightened awareness of this rare infection which and muscle relaxants did not improve his symptoms. The
is the aim of this case presentation. patient was afebrile with no focal neurological deficits on
physical exam. He had a normal white blood cell count
Introduction with elevated Erythrocyte Sedimentation Rate (ESR) of
Septic arthritis of the facet joint is a rare clinical entity 91 (normal 0-15 MM/HR) and C-reactive protein (CRP)
with a similar clinical presentation to spondylodiscitis. of 3.2 (normal <0.5 Mg/Dl). Cervical spine MRI revealed
Septic arthritis most commonly affects the larger periph- left C5-C6 facet joint septic arthritis with extension of the
eral joints and rarely the facet joint, however many of infection into the paraspinal musculature, prevertebral
the same principles apply regarding predisposing factors, soft tissues and epidural space with abscess formation
clinical presentation, lab/imaging work up and treatment and spinal canal narrowing. (Figure 1, Figure 2, and
modalities. Without appropriate diagnosis and treatment, Figure 3).
infection can spread to adjacent structures resulting in The patient was then transferred to the University of
Iowa for further care. He was started on IV Vancomycin
and Ceftriaxone. Cultures from a CT guided aspiration
Department of Radiology, University of Iowa (Figure 4) revealed Staphylococcus aureus as the caus-
Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, University of Iowa ative agent. As the patient had no neurolgic deficits,

182    The Iowa Orthopaedic Journal


Cervical Facet Joint Septic Arthritis: A Case Report

A
B
Figures 1A, B. Contiguous axial T2 weighted MR images at C5-6. There is high T2 signal in the left facet joint space with adjacent bony destruc-
tion. Both images show fluid collections in the paraspinous tissues consistent with abscess (white arrows). Figure 1A shows direct extension
of the infection into the epidural space (arrowhead) with abscess formation.

Figure
2A

Figure
2C

Figure
2B

Figures 2A-C. Two contiguous axial (A and B) and a coronal (C) T1 weighted fat saturation post gadolinium images. Figure 2A shows bony
destruction at the left C5-C6 facet joint with extension into both the epidural space and bilateral paraspinal soft tissues. Figure 2B shows
paraspinal abscess formation (white arrow) and enhancement extending anteriorly into the prevertebral soft tissues. Figure 2C shows direct
extension of the paraspinal abscess from the level of the left C5-C6 facet (black arrow).

Volume 30    183


J. M. Stecher, G. Y. El-Khoury, P. W. Hitchon

A B
Figures 3A, B. Sagittal T2 weighted images in the midline and left of midline. Figure 3A shows the epidural abscess (white arrow) with pos-
terior mass effect on the cer vical spinal cord at C5-C6. Figure 3B demonstrates the paraspinal abscess and adjacent high T2 signal in the
musculature consistent with inflammation.

Figure 4. Axial CT scan in bone windows at the time of CT-guided


aspiration shows sclerosis, erosions and facet joint space widening
at the left C5-C6 facet joint (white arrow).

184    The Iowa Orthopaedic Journal


Cervical Facet Joint Septic Arthritis: A Case Report

negative blood cultures and no signs of sepsis, he was discussed above. Further evaluation includes lab work up
placed on IV Vancomycin for 6 weeks followed by two (white blood cell count, ESR, CRP, and blood cultures)
weeks of oral Linezolid by the Infectious Disease ser- followed by appropriate imaging studies.
vice. The patient remained afebrile, his pain subsided Plain radiographs are not sensitive in diagnosing early
and the ESR and CRP returned to normal within a few disease as radiographic findings may not be evident
weeks. Six week follow up MRI showed resolution of for weeks to months following onset of symptoms.1,14-18
the abscesses and decreased soft tissue enhancement. However there are a few reports where facet joint space
There was no evidence of infection on the six month widening suggesting joint pathology was noted at 4 and
follow up study as well. 21 days after onset of symptoms.14,15 Radionuclide studies
including Technitium-99m MDP bone scan, Gallium-67,
Discussion and In-111 labeled white blood cell scans have shown
Septic arthritis is most commonly secondary to a very high sensitivity for this entity as early as one week
bacterial infection with less common, more indolent after onset of symptoms.2 Tc-99m MDP bone scan can
infections resulting from fungal or mycobacterial causes. be helpful for assessing osteoblastic activity or bony
Predisposing factors include elderly patients, diabetes remodeling secondary to infection. However, the low
mellitus, immunosuppressed patients, rheumatoid ar- specificity of this test limits its utility in diagnosing septic
thritis, skin infection, IV drug abuse, and previous joint arthritis. Ga-67 and more recently In-111 are being used
manipulation including joint prosthesis, recent joint sur- to evaluate for infection/inflammation with very high
gery and intra-articular corticosteroid injections.10 Septic sensitivity, more specificity than Tc-99m bone scans and
arthritis is caused by hematogenous spread (where the improved spatial resolution with the implementation of
presenting sign can be bacterial endocarditis), direct SPECT and co-registered SPECT-CT images.
inoculation of the joint from corticosteroid injection, sur- Non-contrast CT is able to show joint space widening,
gery or trauma, or from spread of adjacent infection into pre-existing joint disease, bony erosions and either a fluid
the joint space. One retrospective review of 191 cases of collection or soft tissue air that could suggest abscess
septic arthritis found that 72% of cases were thought to formation. CT is also very helpful for establishing the
arise from hematogenous spread.11 The majority of cases diagnosis via obtaining synovial fluid for isolation of the
in adults is caused by Staphylococcus aureus and occur organism and for drainage of the affected joint. MRI
in the larger peripheral joints including knees, wrists, is the imaging modality of choice for diagnosing facet
shoulders, elbows, ankles and hips. Smaller joints are joint septic arthritis due to its high sensitivity, specificity
rarely affected including the sternoclavicular joint, sac- and soft tissue contrast.15-17,19,20 MRI is also essential for
roiliac joint, pubic symphysis and the spinal facet joint. therapeutic planning.
One or more predisposing factors was seen in 38-58% Soft tissue gadolinium enhancement may be seen
of patients diagnosed with facet joint septic arthritis with on MRI within 2 days from the onset of symptoms.17
the most common being concomitant infection and im- Reportedly 81% of cases show epidural and/or paraspi-
munosuppression (most notably diabetes mellitus, liver nal extension of the infection,1 and MRI is superior at
disease, transplant patients, long-term corticosteroid use demonstrating extension into the epidural or disc spaces,
and malignancy).1,2 Another predisposing factor is under- paraspinal soft tissues, vertebra and abscess formation.
lying joint disease which is reportedly found in almost Many case reports of facet joint septic arthritis are as-
50% of cases of septic arthritis.12 Related to underlying sociated with epidural or paraspinal abscesses.1,2,5-8,15,19-23
facet disease, there was a retrospective study where It may be difficult to distinguish on imaging whether
209 consecutive lumbar spine MRIs were reviewed re- the infection started in the facet joint or if the infection
gardless of patient history or clinical indication which spread to the facet joint. Some authors have postulated
revealed that 41% of patients were found to have facet that the incidence of this infection may be underesti-
synovitis based on signal abnormality within the joint mated if the infection decompresses into the surrounding
capsule and peri-articular region.13 paraspinal tissues or epidural space prior to diagnosis.17
A high index of suspicion is needed to prevent a delay Facet joint septic arthritis should be considered when
in diagnosis and therapy. Mean time from symptom onset a patient presents with back pain, fever and elevated
to diagnosis has been reported to be 36-43 days with a inflammatory markers (ESR and CRP), however the
large range from 2 days to 6 months.1,14 This delay in presentation and at risk populations are nearly identical
diagnosis can result in increased patient morbidity and to that of spondylodiscitis. Over 90% of patients present
highlights the need for consideration of this disease in with pain, roughly 75% present with fever and about 33-
the differential diagnosis of patients presenting with 50% present with neurologic symptoms. Facet joint septic
neck/back pain, fever and with any of the risk factors arthritis may be suspected in patients with unilateral

Volume 30    185


J. M. Stecher, G. Y. El-Khoury, P. W. Hitchon

symptoms or when there is a more rapid symptom pro- References


gression (4 weeks) compared to the typical presentation 1. Nar váez J, Nolla JM, Nar váez JA, Martinez-
of the more common spondylodiscitis (2-3 months).2 Carnicero L, De Lama E, Gómez-Vaquero C,
Other differential diagnosis considerations include Murillo O, Valverde J, Ariza J. Spontaneous pyo-
non-pyogenic infection such as Tuberculosis, degenera- genic facet joint infection. Semin Arthritis Rheum.
tive or inflammatory arthritis and malignancy. Lytic or 2006 Apr;35(5):272-83.
destructive lesions involving the posterior elements are 2. Muffoletto AJ, Ketonen LM, Mader JT, et al.
most often neoplastic in etiology. One retrospective study Hematogenous pyogenic facet joint infection. Spine
using CT to determine infection vs. tumor in the spine 2001 ; 26 :1570-1576.
noted that severe neurological impairment was more 3. Weingarten TN, Hooten WM, Huntoon MA.
common with spinal infection (39%) than tumor (14%).24 Septic facet joint arthritis after a corticosteroid facet
Complications of septic arthritis of the spinal facet injection. Pain Med. 2006 Jan-Feb;7(1):52-6.
joint include chronic pain, joint/bony destruction, 4. Orpen NM, Birch NC. Delayed presentation of
pyomyositis, abscess (epidural, psoas muscle and septic arthritis of a lumbar facet joint after diagnos-
paraspinal), neurologic sequelae, spondylodiscitis, en- tic facet joint injection. J Spinal Disord Tech. 2003
docarditis, meningitis, septic emboli and rarely death. Jun;16(3):285-7.
In one review of 42 patients excluding cases involving 5. Cook NJ,  Hanrahan  P, Song S.  Paraspinal ab-
pediatric patients, IV drug users and prior surgical in- scess following facet joint injection.   Clin Rheuma-
strumentation/surgery, the most severe complications tol  1999; 18:52-53.
were paraplegia in one patient and death during surgery 6. Magee M, Kannangara S, Dennien B. Paraspinal
in another patient.1 The majority of patients in the case abscess complicating facet joint injection.  Clin Nucl
reports recovered fully or had minimal residual pain Med  2000; 25:71-77.
following treatment. 7. Alcock E, Regaard A, Browne J. Facet joint injec-
Patients are typically treated with long-term (at least 6 tion: a rare form of epidural abscess formation. Pain
weeks) parenteral antibiotics followed by oral antibiotics 2003; 103:209-210.
or a combination of percutaneous drainage and long- 8. Okano K, Kondo H, Tsuchiya R, et al. Spinal
term antibiotics. Open arthrotomy and surgical drain- epidural abscess associated with epidural catheteriza-
age/debridement is typically reserved for the patient tion: report of a case and a review of the literature.
with infection refractory to antibiotic trial or with acute Jpn J Clin Oncol 1999;29:49–52.
neurological compromise. MRI is less helpful in assess- 9. Arun R, Al-Nammari SS, Mehdian SM. Multilevel
ing for treatment response as soft tissue enhancement vertebral osteomyelitis and facet joint infection follow-
can persist following clearance of infection. Treatment ing epidural catheterisation. Acta Orthop Belg. 2007
response can be assessed using the patient’s subjective Oct;73(5):665-9.
improvement in symptoms and improvement in inflam- 10. Margaretten, ME, Kohlwes, J, Moore, D, Bent,
matory serum markers. S. Does this adult patient have septic arthritis?. JAMA
In conclusion, septic arthritis of the facet joint is an 2007; 297:1478.
uncommon infection that requires a high clinical sus- 11. Morgan, DS, Fisher, D, Marianos, A, Currie
picion for accurate and timely diagnosis. This infection BJ. An 18 year clinical review of septic arthritis from
shares many features with septic arthritis in the more tropical Australia. Epidemiol Infect 1996; 117:423.
commonly affected large peripheral joints as well as with 12. Kaandorp, CJE, Kriknen, P, Moens, HJB, et
spondylodiscitis. The incidence of this entity is increas- al. The outcome of bacterial arthritis. A prospective
ing and MRI will continue to play an important role community-based study. Arthritis Rheum 1997; 40:
in diagnosis and surgical planning. Lastly, while most 884.
patients recover with little or no neurologic sequlae, 13. Czervionke LF, Fenton DS. Fat-saturated MR imag-
prompt diagnosis and definitive therapy are essential for ing in the detection of inflammatory facet arthropathy
decreasing patient morbidity and mortality. (facet synovitis) in the lumbar spine. Pain Med. 2008
May-Jun;9(4):400-6.
14. Michel-Batôt C, Dintinger H, et al. A particular
form of septic arthritis: septic arthritis of facet joint.
Joint Bone Spine. 2008 Jan;75(1):78-83. Epub 2007
Aug 29.

186    The Iowa Orthopaedic Journal


Cervical Facet Joint Septic Arthritis: A Case Report

15. Doita M, Nishida K, Miyamoto H, et al. Septic 20. Ahl T, Hedstrom M, von Heijne A, et al. Acute
arthritis of bilateral lumbar facet joints : report of a spinal epidural abscess without concurrent spondy-
case with MRI findings in the early stage. Spine 2003 lodiscitis: successful closed treatment in 10 cases.
; 28 : 198-202. Acta Orthop Scand 1999;70:199–202.
16. Pilleul F, Garcia J. Septic arthritis of the spine facet 21. Ogura T, Mikami Y, Hase H, et al. Septic arthritis
joint: early positive diagnosis on MRI. Review of two of a lumbar facet joint associated with epidural and
cases. Joint Bone Spine 2000 ; 67 : 234-237. paraspinal abscess. Orthopedics. 2005;28:173–175.
17. Fujiwara A, Tamai K, Yamato M, et al. Septic 22. Hickey NA, White PG. Septic arthritis of a lumbar
arthritis of a lumbar facet joint: report of a case with facet joint causing multiple abscesses. Clin Radiol.
early MRI findings. J Spinal Disord 1998;11:452–3. 2000;55:481–483.
18. Ergan M, Macro M, Benhamou CL, et al. Septic 23. Heenan SD, Brton J. Septic arthritis in a lumbar
arthritis of lumbar facet joints: a review of six cases. facet joint: a rare cause of an epidural abscess. Neu-
Rev Rhum Engl Ed 1997;64:386–95. roradiology 1995;37:462–4.
19. Glaser JA, El-Khour y GY. Unknown case. Diag- 24. Van Lom KJ, Kellerhouse LE, et al. Infection
nosis: facet joint septic arthritis T12-L1 on the left versus tumor of the spine: Criteria for distinction with
with extension of the infection into the spinal canal CT. Radiology 1988 March; 166:851-855.
producing a large epidural abscess. Spine (Phila Pa
1976). 2001 Apr 15;26(8):991-3.

Volume 30    187

You might also like