GRANGER, OP, VCR assisted block caving—a viable fue for Kimberley Mins. MASSMIV 92, Jbannesburg, SAIMM, 1992, pp 11-19,
VCR-assisted Block Caving—a Viable Future for Kimberley
Mines
Q.P. GRANGER
De Beers Consolidated Mines Ltd, Kimberley, South Africa
Kimberley Mines, which are owned by De Beers Consolidated Mines in association with Anglo
American Diamond Division, comprise 4 mines: De Beers, Dutoitspan, Bultfontein, and
Wesselton Mines.
‘The occurrence of a number of mud ‘pushes’ at De Beers Mine during 1986 to 1988 led to a
drastic reduction in production. To alleviate the problem, a combination of the vertical crater
retreat (VCR) and block-caving mining methods were introduced. This was the first use of VCR
mining in the diamond industry. This combined method, known as VCR-assisted block caving,
allowed the mine to continue operating until late 1990, The VCR test stope highlighted a number
of productivity and cost benefits that are enumerated in this paper.
‘The remaining three mines at Kimberley Mines have experienced the following major problems
in the past two years
+ the collapse of the sub-level cave at Bultfontein Mine
+ the flooding of Dutoitspan Mine
+ mud occurrences at Wesselton Mine associated with extremely poor ground conditions.
‘This has necessitated a major reconsideration of the mining strategy for these mines, resulting in
a change from sub-level caving to the VCR method. The implementation of a successful VCR
programme at Kimberley Mines will provide a viable and safe mining method for the futur.
Introduction
‘The discovery of diamonds at Kimberley in the middle of
the eighteenth century caught the world’s attention. Miners
and adventurers from all over the world joined the rush to
the banks of the Orange River. The primary source of
diamonds—the diamond pipes—were discovered only later.
Mining operations at Bultfontein Mine started in 1869,
followed by Dutoitspan Mine a year later and by De Beers
Mine and Kimberley Mine in 1871 and, finally, by
Wesselton Mine in 1891. These mines today comprise
Kimberley Mines, which are owned by De Beers
Consolidated Mines in association with Anglo American
Diamond Division. The mines have developed during their
hundred-year lives from a chaotic scramble to a
sophisticated underground mining operation utilizing
‘modern massive-mining methods.
De Beers Mine is the smallest of the four Kimberley
‘mines, and in 1989/90 produced about 1500 t per day. The
‘mine was started in May 1871 and operated as an opencast
mine until 1881, when underground work started in the
form of chambering. In 1908, the mine was closed because
of a depression in the diamond market, but was re-opened
in 1961. A block-caving method was developed and used
‘until 1979, when sub-level caving (SLC) was introduced,
‘The SLC mining method was used successfully until
1985, when mud problems in the workings seriously
affected production. During 1986, the mud problem
worsened and necessitated complete re-establishment of
production levels, with a resultant loss of drilled ore
‘The succession of country rock and the mining methods
used at De Beers are shown in Figure 1
An alternative mining method was required that would
provide a means of holding back the mud. In November
1986, vertical crater retreat (VCR) mining was considered,
and the go-ahead was given for a hybrid of this method and
block-cave stoping, known as VCR-assisted block-cave
mining.
‘This paper deals with the introduction of the VCR test
slope at De Beers Mine, the problems encountered, and the
results achieved. It also discusses the situation at the three
other Kimberley Mines and their changeover to VCR
stoping in the light of the lessons learnt at De Beers Mine
Sub-level Cave Mining
Sub-levels were installed at 15 m intervals and were
interconnected by ramps at 10 degrees to the horizontal,
Drill drives on cach sub-level were developed across the
orebody from the access tunnels located in the country
rock. These drives were 3,5 m wide and 3,5 m high, and
spaced at 10 m centres.
Blasting rings, consisting of 57 mm diameter holes
drilled in the shape of a fan, were located at right angles to
the drives. The rings had a burden of 1,6 m, and the holes
had a toe spacing of 2m,
A slot tunnel was cut on the furthest contact from the
access tunnel between the kimberlite and the country rack.
The fan rings were then blasted into the slot, with mining
retreating across the pipe. Loading and transporting of the
fragmented ore was undertaken by diesel and electric
Joad-haul-dump units to an ore-pass system.
De Beers Mine has a surface area of 28 ha, which acts as
f catchment for the rainfall and channels it into the open
‘mine. As mining has progressed deeper, the pipe has filledMAIN SHAFT
SUB LEVEL CAVE
ana Lem
500
VERTICAL
CRATER
RETREAT
Figure 1, Schematic section through De Beers Mine, illustrating the mining methods and the succession of country rock:
with approximately 400 m of remnant kimberlite and waste
rock from erosion of the sidewalls of the pit. Large pockets
‘of mud have formed in this overburden, and this mud has
found its way into the workings in the form of ‘mud
pushes’.
Prior to the mud problems encountered di
pushes had been experienced on several
1986, mud
'535 m level of the West SLC block. These were contained
by retreating the mining face rapidly, thus exposing fresh
dy ground from above. The upper levels of the SLC were
achieved, which, with hindsight, probably exacerbated the
problem,
‘The first hint of mud occurred on $60 m level towards the
end of 1985, when a push of very muddy water occurred.
At the end of 1985, difficulties were being experienced in
maintaining production from 575 m level since all the
Toading points had become very wet, reducing the available
tonnage for loading, owing to the imminent danger of a
‘mud push,
‘This situation continued for the first quarter of 1986, and
production targets were not met. During the remainder ofresources were concentrated on establishing new
production areas and re-establishing those affected by mud.
Strict loading limits were set in the affected areas, but there
were still signs of mud mixed with kimberlite, and many
fan holes were seen to be very wet
Even as late as August 1988, serious mud pushes were
being encountered. One particular mud push occurred on
{635 m level, flooding the access tunnel and blocking the
ramp to 650 m and 620 m levels.
The continuing occurrence of mud necessitated a change
in mining method for the following reasons.
+ The average tonnage produced had deteriorated from
10 per cent below target in the early part of 1986 to 40
per cent below target in the latter part of the year
(Figure 2),
+ It was impossible to handle the wet material through
the ground-handling system in that the mud caused the
passes to hang up, and the screens and chutes to
become blocked.
+ Loading of the mud was difficult since it was a
mixture of wet fine material and large boulders. The
ground had to be dumped into neighbouring
excavations to allow it to dry out before being tipped
into the orepass system,
+ Whenever a mud push occurred, the previously drilled
fan holes were lost, and the drilled ore reserves had to
be re-established.
+ Slot passes to provide a new free face were raised by
hand-held machines, and there was a danger that a
further mud push would entrap the machine crew.
+ The difficult mining method affected morale
negativel
VCR Mining at De Beers Mine
‘ly, 650 m level had been a sample level, consisting
of three tunnels driven across the orebody. It was from this,
level that the long down holes of 70 m were drilled. The
collection level for the broken ground was located on 720 m
level. Scraper drifts, 4,0 m wide and 3,5 m high, were
aessaues
BB 2 pecumnn ESD on are
Figure 2, Production at De Beers Mine
developed across the orebody and lined with 850 mm of,
cconcrete to withstand the pressure of the broken ground.
‘The blasted ground passed through cones into these scraper
drifts and then via a transfer gully into the two ore passes.
‘The VCR test stope is shown in Figures 3 and 4,
Large-diameter Long-hole Drilling
An Ingersoll Rand model CMM2 down-the-bole (DTH) rig
‘was used to drill 165 mm diameter holes from 650 m level
Figure 5). Split sings, ie. alternate hols offset, were used
to accommodate the concentration of drill holes in a ring.
‘The toe spacing of the drill holes was 4,3 m with a burden
of 5.0 m. A high degree of drilling accuracy was required
from the machine to keep the e-