Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Claas T. Buschmann
Michael Tsokos
Frequent and rare complications
of resuscitation attempts
Received: 8 January 2008 Abstract Introduction: Resuscita- injuries are lesions of pleura, peri-
Accepted: 7 August 2008 tion attempts require invasive cardium, myocardium and other
Published online: 20 September 2008 iatrogenic manipulations on the internal organs as well as vessels,
Ó Springer-Verlag 2008 patient. On the one hand, these mea- intubation-related damages of neural
sures are essential for survival, but on and cartilaginous structures in the
the other hand can damage the patient larynx and perforations of abdominal
and thus contain a significant viola- organs such as liver, stomach and
tion risk of both medical and forensic spleen. Conclusion: We differenti-
relevance for the patient and the ate between frequent and rare
physician. We differentiate between complications. The risk of iatrogenic
frequent and rare resuscitation-related CPR-related trauma is even present
injuries. Factors of influence are with adequate execution of CPR
duration and intensity of the resusci- measures and should not question the
tation attempts, sex and age of the employment of proven medical
C. T. Buschmann ()) M. Tsokos patient as well as an anticoagulant techniques.
University Medical Centre Charité, medication. Materials and methods:
University of Berlin, Institute of Legal Review of current literature and Keywords Resuscitation-related
Medicine and Forensic Sciences, Turmstr. report on autopsy cases from our injuries Frequencies Medical
21, Building L, 10559 Berlin, Germany relevance Forensic relevance
e-mail: claas.buschmann@charite.de institute (approximately 1,000 autop-
Tel.: ?49-30-901728147 sies per year). Results: Frequent
Fax: ?49-30-901728154 findings are lesions of tracheal struc-
URL: http://remed.charite.de/ tures and bony chest fractures. Rare
successful resuscitation [1] without forensic relevance. myocardium, pericardium, pleura, diaphragm or pneumo-
Bony chest injuries can be connected with further and/or hematothoraces, success of resuscitation measures
superficial skin lesions caused by external CPR in the is affected negatively [32]. Bode and Joachim [4] describe
sternal area. Dermabrasiones are very often found after cases of aortic ruptures from CPR, particularly located in
resuscitation measures and are usually without forensic the Pars descendens, and give the incidence of 1%.
relevance, but may hint to underlying bone lesions of the According to literature findings, these complications are
chest wall. We observed sternal dermabrasio combined rare and arise more frequently if external CPR is per-
with solid iatrogenic serial rib fractures as well as sternal formed with active compression–decompression devices
fractures in the case of a fatal aortic dissection with like the Cardio PumpÒ [26]. Aspiration of stomach con-
following pericardial tamponade; with pericardial tam- tents may be evoked if external CPR is performed with
ponade, the rescue team was unable to generate sufficient substantial energy expenditure [17].
blood circulation. Thus, external CPR was performed
with increased energy expenditure, which caused, apart
from skin lesions, pronounced bony chest injuries. Abdomen
Chest
produced in this vessel and ambient air may be sucked Table 1 Resuscitation-related injuries, percentage of occurrence
into the venous system of the head. Also, pulmonary with reference to the literature
barotrauma caused by intubation and artificial respiration
Injury pattern Percentage of Reference
may provoke cerebral air embolism [31, 39]. occurrence no.
The successful execution of CPR requires the Table 2 Possible post-resuscitation injury complications
knowledge of topographic and anatomical conditions, the
applied techniques and their specific risks. Thus, among Injury Pattern Possible post-resuscitation
injury complications
emergency medical professionals the question is raised
whether the avoidance of serial rib fractures is to be (Temporary) skin erythema None
settled higher than the acceptance of a smaller mechan- Defibrillation Rhabdomyolysis
ical effect on the heart by performing CPR with smaller Rib-/sternal fractures Hemato- and pneumothorax,
traumatic lesions of heart, lungs
energy expenditure. and upper belly organs
The guidelines to CPR of the European Resuscitation Tracheal lesions Pneumomediastinum, hypoxemia
Council of 2005 recommend a compression depth of 4– Retropharyngeal bleedings Vena cava superior syndrome
5 cm with a compression frequency of 100/min to ensure Liver and spleen injuries, Hemorrhagic shock, exsanguination
aortic ruptures
an effective arterial blood flow. Moreover, the value of a Stomach lesions Pneumoperitoneum
sufficient thorax compression is emphasized in relation to Air embolism Apoplectic insult
breath donation, since 80% of cardiopulmonary arrests
are based cardiacally and arterial oxygen content is still
sufficiently high in the first minutes after cardiopulmo- consequences for the physician after obviously wrong
nary arrest [11]. This can be interpreted in such a manner treatment of the patient, for example false intubations of the
that—in particular with a rigid thorax—a sufficient effect trachea, are conceivable, of course. However, it is negligent
of CPR is only enabled if rib or sternal fractures are taken to miss necessary CPR measures to prevent oneself from
in purchase. Altogether, complication rates are lower and prosecution. Forensic relevance also exists in omitting CPR
outcome is higher if CPR measures are executed attempts without safe death signs being present. From the
according to guidelines. This mainly applies if thorax medicolegal point of view, complications and accidental
compression—even in the first minutes after cardiac iatrogenic injuries will never be completely avoidable but
arrest—is not interrupted [36, 38]. their possibility has to be taken into consideration
We remark that rib and sternal fractures often occur throughout further medical treatment. Beside physicians,
after successful CPR (Lederer and colleagues [18] give a medical assistance personnel such as nurses and paramed-
frequency of 94.7%), but rarely affect the patient’s out- ics are concerned. For forensic pathologists, forensic
come after resuscitation negatively. On the other hand, relevance lies in the secure, autopsy-confirmed differenti-
sternal or rib fractures can cause pneumo- and/or hemat- ation between CPR-related and other injury causes.
othoraces and/or lung injuries, so that secondarily
respiration disturbances in the post-resuscitation phase
may occur frequently, containing the long-term risk of Consequences for hospitals and practice
lethal complications such as the ‘‘Adult Respiratory Dis-
tress Syndrome’’ (ARDS) [4]. Thus, iatrogenically induced Resuscitation-related injuries cannot be avoided and will
traumata are not only of high significance pre-clinically appear inevitably with increasing duration of resuscitation
while performing CPR, but also injuries can become evi- attempts, particularly if some factors are added; factors of
dent in the hospital after successful stabilization, e.g., influence are duration and intensity of the resuscitation
splenic two-stage bleeding or covered organ perforations. measures, sex and age of the patient as well as an anti-
It is more important to further consider the means and coagulant medication. Furthermore, these injuries are
circumstances and to seize measures which on the one often not conspicuous immediately, but manifest them-
hand minimize the risk of immediate complications and selves rather by missing success of CPR measures. Thus, a
on the other hand save the patient from damage in the diagnostic consideration of the physicians must be to look
further process. The placement of a gastric tube may be for iatrogenic injuries if the condition of a patient under
performed, e.g., for pressure relief and aspiration pro- CPR cannot be stabilized and no causes are recognizable
phylaxis; an iatrogenically induced complication can be which let the success of CPR measures appear improbable
the aspiration of stomach contents [17] or gastric rupture (e.g., traumatic genesis with hemorrhagic shock after blunt
after artificial respiration with high pressure ratios, usu- trauma [5]) and/or these factors can be treated causally.
ally located in the small curvature [4, 27].
even present with adequate execution of CPR measures to avoid these traumas if possible and to be able to dis-
and should not question the employment of proven tinguish them from injuries of other origin.
medical techniques.
Forensic scientists as well as clinical practitioners Acknowledgments This work was supported by the State Institute
should know about the relevance and frequency of the of Legal and Social Medicine, Berlin/Germany (Director: Prof. M.
Tsokos, MD).
occurrence of iatrogenically induced resuscitation injuries
References
1. Alconero Camarero AR, Casaus Pérez 12. Klintschar M, Darok M, Radner H 22. Minor RL Jr, Chandran PK, Williams
M, Gutiérrez Caloca N (2006) Incidents (1998) Massive injury to the heart after CL (1990) Rhabdomyolysis and
of cutaneous alteration secondary to attempted active compression– myoglobinuric renal failure following
external electrical cardioversion. decompression cardiopulmonary cardioversion and CPR for acute MI.
Enferm Intensiva 17:163–172 resuscitation. Int J Legal Med 111:93– Chest 97:485–486
2. Bauer H, Welsch K (1976) Punktions- 96 23. Noffsinger AE, Blisard KS, Balko MG
Techniken in der Notfallmedizin. 13. Kurkciyan I, Meron G, Sterz F, Müllner (1991) Cardiac laceration and
Münchener Medizinische M, Tobler K, Domanovits H, Schreiber pericardial tamponade due to
Wochenschrift 118:567–572 W, Bankl HC, Laggner AN (2003) cardiopulmonary resuscitation after
3. Betz P, Liebhardt E (1994) Rib Major bleeding complications after myocardial infarction. J Forensic Sci
fractures in children—resuscitation or cardiopulmonary resuscitation: impact 36:1760–1764
child abuse? Int J Legal Med 106:215– of thrombolytic treatment. J Int Med 24. Odom A, Christ E, Kerr N, Byrd K,
218 253:128–135 Cochran J, Barr F, Bugnitz M, Ring JC,
4. Bode G, Joachim H (1987) Zur 14. Krause S, Donen N (1984) Gastric Storgion S, Walling R, Stidham G,
Differentialdiagnose von Unfall- und rupture during cardiopulmonary Quasney MW (1997) Prevalence of
Reanimationstraumen. Z Rechtsmed resuscitation. Can Anaesth Soc J retinal hemorrhages in pediatric patients
98:19–32 31:319–322 after in-hospital cardiopulmonary
5. Darok M (2004) Injuries resulting from 15. Krischer JP, Fine EG, Davis JH, Nagel resuscitation: a prospective study.
resuscitation procedures. In: Tsokos M EL (1987) Complications of cardiac Pediatrics. doi:10.1542/peds.99.6.e3
(ed) Forensic pathology reviews Vol 1. resuscitation. Chest 92:287–291 25. Price EA, Rush LR, Perper JA, Bell MD
Humana Press Inc, Totowa NJ, pp 293– 16. Larsen R (2002) Kardiopulmonale (2000) Cardiopulmonary resuscitation-
303 Reanimation. In: Larsen R (ed) related injuries and homicidal blunt
6. Eldor J, Ofek B, Abramowitz HB Anästhesie, 8th edn. Urban and Fischer abdominal trauma in children. Am J
(1990) Perforation of oesophagus by Publishing House, München Jena, pp Forensic Med Pathol 21:307–310
tracheal tube during resuscitation. 851–900 26. Rabl W, Baubin M, Haid C, Pfeiffer KP
Anaesthesia 45:70–71 17. Lawes EG, Baskett PJ (1987) R, Scheithauer R (1997) Review of
7. Hartoko TJ, Demey HE, Rogers PE, Pulmonary aspiration during active compression–decompression
Decoster HL, Nagler JM, Bossaert LL unsuccessful cardiopulmonary cardiopulmonary resuscitation (ACD-
(1991) Pneumoperitoneum—a rare resuscitation. Intensive Care Med CPR). Analysis of iatrogenic
complication of cardiopulmonary 13:379–382 complications and their biomechanical
resuscitation. Acta Anaesth Scand 18. Lederer W, Mair D, Rabl W, Baubin M explanation. Forensic Sci Int 89:175–
35:235–237 (2004) Frequency of rib and sternum 183
8. Hashimoto Y, Moriya F, Furumiya J fractures associated with out-of-hospital 27. Reichardt JA, Casey GD, Krywko D
(2007) Forensic aspects of cardiopulmonary resuscitation is (2008) Gastric rupture from
complications resulting from underestimated by conventional chest cardiopulmonary resuscitation or
cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Leg X-ray. Resuscitation 60:157–162 seizure activity? a case report. J Emerg
Med 9:94–99 19. Maxeiner H (1988) Med. doi:
9. Hoke RS, Chamberlain D (2004) Weichteilverletzungen am Kehlkopf bei 10.1016/j.jemermed.2007.10.041
Skeletal chest injuries secondary to notfallmäßiger Intubation. Anästh 28. Ryan MP, Young SJ, Wells DL (2003)
cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Intensivmed 29:42–49 Do resuscitation attempts in children
Resuscitation 63:327–338 20. Meron G, Kurkciyan I, Sterz F, Susani who die, cause injury? Emerg Med J
10. Jaeger K, Ruschulte H, Osthaus A, M, Domanovits H, Tobler K, 20:10–12
Scheinichen S, Heine J (2000) Tracheal Bohdjalian A, Laggner AN (2007) 29. Saternus KS, Fuchs V (1982)
injury as a sequence of multiple Cardiopulmonary resuscitation- Verletzungen der A. carotis communis
attempts of endotracheal intubation in associated major liver injury. durch Reanimationsmaßnahmen. Z
the course of a preclinical Resuscitation. doi: Rechtsmed 88:305–311
cardiopulmonary resuscitation. 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2007.05.023 30. Schvadron E, Moses Y, Weissberg D
Resuscitation 43:147–150 21. Mills SA, Paulson D, Scott SM, Sethi G (1996) Gastric rupture complicating
11. Kardiopulmonale Reanimation— (1983) Tension pneumoperitoneum and inadvertent intubation of the esophagus.
Aktuelle Leitlinien des European gastric rupture following Can J Surg 39:487–489
Resuscitation Council (2006) Notfall- cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Ann 31. Shulman D, Beilin B, Olshwang D
und Rettungsmedizin 9:4–170 Emerg Med 12:94–95 (1987) Pulmonary barotrauma during
cardiopulmonary resuscitation.
Resuscitation 15:201–207
404
32. Sokolove PE, Willis-Shore J, Panacek 35. Umach P, Unterdorfer H (1980) 38. Wik L, Kramer-Johansen J, Myklebust
EA (2002) Exsanguination due to right Organverletzungen durch H, Sørebø H, Svensson L, Fellows B,
ventricular rupture during closed-chest Reanimationsmaßnahmen. Beiträge zur Steen PA (2005) Quality of
cardiopulmonary resuscitation. J Emerg Gerichtlichen Medizin 38:29–32 cardiopulmonary resuscitation during
Med 23:161–164 36. Valenzuela TD, Kern KB, Clark LL, out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. JAMA
33. Sperry K (1990) Anterior thoracic wall Berg RA, Berg MD, Berg DD, Hilwig 293:299–304
trauma in elderly homicide victims. The RW, Otto CW, Newburn D, Ewy GA 39. Yamaki T, Ando S, Ohta K, Kubota T,
‘‘CPR’’ defense. Am J Forensic Med (2005) Interruptions of chest Kawasaki K, Hirama M (1989) CT
Pathol 11:50–55 compressions during emergency demonstration of massive cerebral air
34. Strear CM, Jarnagin WR, Schecter W, medical systems resuscitation. embolism from pulmonary barotraumas
Mackersie RC, Hickey MS (1998) Circulation 112:1259–1265 due to cardiopulmonary resuscitation.
Gastric rupture and tension 37. van der Voort DJ, Geusens PP, Dinant J Comput Assist Tomogr 13:313–315
pneumoperitoneum complicating GJ (2001) Risk factors for osteoporosis 40. Ziegenfuss MD, Mullany DV (2004)
cardiopulmonary resuscitation: case related to their outcome: fractures. Traumatic liver injury complicating
report. J Trauma 44:930–932 Osteoporos Int 12:630–638 cardio-pulmonary resuscitation. The
value of a major intensive care facility:
a report of two cases. Crit Care Resusc
2:102–104