Professional Documents
Culture Documents
chapter 1
Marty’s search for summer employment led
him to a Boys and Girls Club in northern Virginia
and to Connie, the director of the center. He had
a good summer working at the club.
A little less than a year later, it was time for
him to complete his internship. We shouldn’t be
surprised that he chose to do his internship at the
Boys and Girls Club: he had positioned himself
to do his internship there. For him, it was as if
he was sitting next to that very special person in
high school. He liked the job. He knew something
about the organization, its mission, and the clientele
it served. He had a realistic idea of what
the work entailed. He knew the director, and she
knew him. Since he had already worked there,
she knew his capabilities and work performance.
Stated another way, she wasn’t taking much of a
chance with Marty. From her perspective, he was
a known commodity. Marty consulted about the
potential internship with his faculty supervisor,
who affirmed that the Boys and Girls Club would
be a logical choice for his internship.
Marty’s experience is anecdotal, but variations
of his experience are played out daily within the
workplace. And similar scenarios are described
in the job search literature. Several sources
suggest that between 50 and 80 percent of job
vacancies in the U.S. are filled before the position
is advertised outside of the organization
(Ganske, 2005; Kopiske, 2003; O’Donnell, 2004).
Kopiske noted that “it’s estimated that between
70 and 80 percent of all the jobs that get filled
Career Development in Recreation, P 2 Parks, and Tourism are by people who first heard about the
position
A Tale of Two Models
Chapters 1 through 12 of this book include a section called A Tale of Two Models. This section compares
the traditional and positioning job search models. Juxtaposing the two models helps explain
the positioning model and when you should use each of the models.
In the traditional job search model, the organization identifies a position that it needs, or one that
is unfilled and needs to be filled. Next, it advertises the position in newspapers, in trade journals, on
the Internet, and through other standard media. You see the advertisement for the position and, along
with many others, apply for the position. You send the firm your cover letter, resume, references, and
anything else required. Those in charge of hiring for the firm sort through the applications and invite
you for an interview. Finally, if you are the last person standing, the firm offers you the position.
In contrast to the traditional model is the positioning model. This model begins with your deciding
on your career goal or at least where you want to work. Next, you identify positions in organizations
that will potentially advance your career goal. You then research the organizations in terms of their
viability in advancing your career, asking yourself several basic questions: Is this an organization
where I would like to work? Will this organization advance my career? If I take a position with this
organization,
how quickly will it advance my career? The next step is to identify and approach a person
in the organization and explore ways you can become involved. Depending on the situation, your
involvement could be volunteer, part-time, or even full-time employment. Finally, your involvement
with the organization leads to full-time employment or to a promotion depending on whether you
were previously employed full- or part-time. Often, a new position appears, and you are the only
one interviewed. Or, if the position is opened up to the public, it is merely a formality to satisfy the
human resources department because the managers have already decided to hire you. As noted, the
positioning model is most likely the norm regarding how most people obtain their next job.
In some cases, the two models work in concert with each other. Although the organization may
need to use the traditional model to officially search for the candidate, the positioning model may
have already been working to select the candidate who will eventually be chosen. For example, the
candidate may already be working at the agency, and the formal search process is merely a formality
that must be completed to satisfy human resources. Or, the organization is in the process of a traditional
job search, and one of the applicants is someone who worked there previously or someone
who is known through their professional contacts. These candidates have enhanced the likelihood
of being selected because they have positioned themselves.
Most people are familiar with the traditional job search model. Most career advice books are written
from the perspective of this model. Although the positioning model is theoretically new, most
people have already used aspects of it throughout their lives without realizing it. And, because a
significant number of positions are awarded to people within the organization, it is the new paradigm
that represents the norm in the job search process.
The positioning model is the primary model delineated in the job search process described in
this book. The process requires that you proactively seek the position you want. You decide where
and for whom you want to be employed. You case the joint to make sure it is the place for you. By
working there, you place yourself in close proximity to the position that will advance you and your
career. Or, by developing the skill set necessary for the position that you seek, you are able to build
a bridge to the new position.