On the Currency of Egalitarian Justice, and Other Essays in Political Philosophy G. A. COHEN Edited by Michael Otsukaeck that ihr aaron a smal re oxy foe th own esl {else han wb they'd eo shel ow Se BUPA [poate hel ‘trace improved annular systems 2 house he stb, {inlaw Bat bower they Spe tho ae ing then ose {So ae pinay inthe freee? andr pote of common Inet a copnt at oe psp eee chapter Eleven HOW TO DO POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY 1, Front ee nu tho Bove been yng d pilose for mace hao ers dein dc coc er ifthe ah, owe hat thee en eying at they ert ow tod logy. ar ‘itoush Pe ese how sod pho nob eve é mht {Enttand tor ssl wonld gies ood il gre rl you how tet iitl to el gou tot rod inthe tare The mascara lnaton of at fac the at har bey te poopy ‘Sper howto do posh thr ripe sxpla 9o. dy tom pesca bedone "Theol way rota rapes hit ty unger wc el ater omni thal Slanton a esis fac the ac awe dot ech yout 2 ‘iptonpsy sats who ae eared howto rund {elandengelisee we now ate that we ow sly race pe ‘oacome ltr four srap or ewe hk ou shoal ‘cr obably cee ome thn each nan. 2. bahowever ala ny et nen sie ozone iy hon how {ocd psp no prea de Aer even the peli ‘hay abou Ka wd pileyy tare vant some out laa peony parece Sy Se pee of ait th yu ald yo Be ea po {isle Mou har ou thn you're eiving when ou pee St emer To be mor oct when yon pee 50 sue Ino {Pe tro bes era youl wlrer yu tn So ‘em gic apie someting you apps hle el on oy ‘Spars yous awe positon if you See ono nea, wee You {Hi the sagt pws Your our yt, eon oi aa thotol ours you ave ov enep tha yt by ‘try ot lopprtog poston tha sas He the dite eee Eocene pe! Ao, ob dear about ow dee ou ha {be epumenen queion healt a gunn en aris oc Th pepe tat Cae wr sealed is ee tan ee ear Sereda lnbeneel Re soe nateDome Toamney yo oppo, whee fate es oon, a mare change apa aia Aad analogue belek ‘hanieratan sain our opm foot Your os poston may fi oer et portion of yours or deciles See lee ‘Eivcen ce coluoorin gun 1) So wee now gots oud ela ln pes ofrgemen ih perp, o for hn er lai thn fp panes eco adn cenit de 4. Now ht nd ty be cas aou ich ox one or tne note eae Utd i later, ten 908 how ht you wee ‘eg cay shou snc mnt a a you cul yy ta a na cae tnd you waned ole ny aac, you might toot bec oc eof lang tv ton be Sse ‘ersafingthn cir conor coin of anting woe hop Prcnophy navy tras ob a ca er Rrdtobe cee abut whe Toe rgd yout cle abu tat Spec war outed ay wha ewe fn conden ‘Sirona to youts Sons oe nove ea cosarstonbemes torte tenon convey wht Knotng te Co MR TOS tro wisa cum thong dt eae worth eng ‘Sc comsdeston forward only tease nny provoke ecaon ‘Sort os seaar ae of be pened sake of be car ‘ine vo mh Coxlen hour mati lle One ld ape {etinan bot ove hold oc soi pone aight fora oe SS Earle utes 5. Another sip When yout doing phibsophy, do’ be aso som dint or siplemnde for ntl hat sted tye sounds $ouso abuomly mistaken thor ou cone te you mast be mai ‘Seong ire morn ere nan 1 they ae he echer Some oe mow scent ppb ‘enna ve iene bate es tater Of pring ou a herr aoe meen ay ee, Th sen whi seated peoesicacs con make huge makes, uae i sn 1 2 choi Tigttne fer mobeuler cou of omc ne, of coun + fae hay cheat woul ee me 6 Lee nowt poi ilonphy adn parca sam SifeiRea panopiy wach 8 a0 sea howe pipe eat ‘pelea sate sb phd wre Herc ny Bp a whe {eee pce awe soon doin pla pon, and we ‘cst pon entre ate esque tht we oul eSfoe nae suo sueos te egy cone with oe ‘SOS Sen ty advanced patnrn rane pocsones cha Tear rnd who Te wen hte Thee ree ques ple Cai pose State afer ho h afe o isagued Shep aol oe ae htc fae a Seguin ou opine The hc dae ution ae {Fivcectancey tr bul he are dts an a Wich soca ‘ha aoe gh iy con ot SECS ston waheashcbee Oeste stn ‘Teer oe thy for read ar awesome a oem ete se fey ee Thy ake raed fr amp KePaiseonenaie ote normative sas ofthe sare tars HS (22 ei sme pawn coms cram he tee uations i, action (hs ater mine ona gaston un Pease MO ‘Seng hr tou o some should Go nhs SOTUF kee en aod hr weaker ta fr ea “ucneton tcc guns) ana he ey compte SESehral moe hse shold, Converter p= ob STE ese lyon nt tery concep of ies does or br tinal jos to bese by hese Queso (0 05 ‘ikoves the ume geaton wn gsion fl eco gus i cs eurston and quam Gs) xe at on ageey wher ‘Sweet vo too te bug stow Ard ily gi TED dete sme gua quo i sce usa at he hip rensonnhy misc cheesey boats eae SLTEaR tet oe il ses of aac ave, at ck, ies ‘She ana ae nae Siete gn a trl a mo SEE cise tramConv, fo exe, ce view sociated ecily wih Hatey esa, brats eps wh Jomph a. wich tha ea fea ne dea that aly ames tat ererone shold TEE Such Aco tthe em many hte ne be ed ‘Syeda ebm oy cosine he abe dere uy witht eters of sec. The safc ve ‘purus sly and syst wt mars noe thet poole Be Eu bur tease be enw Eu fr wate here's ‘Shc obscanty erecta ry pet purposes Never tnd ore he nn enough supposed egy My peset ‘plas rot abou sapere ut aow he 20 oe we ke ‘Eel cn) hse steve uct (eres ‘Snypeae wosome ese compete veroce ses Sear posy gaze fg mom, ort ase o question [iskekay ett teponsiy ofthe ce se coomejste {Eni nen sveyoe tn eu oe es igh dere Sewer qn i one ch ayy dilerenydhahe esuosbny Tikes ede thn ae uence ce lc myo ay rte Fanta ppl oa ae 0 ‘rn which wha hacen tue of as ne nem. ‘rel rele ota ove am ser wc Beat ria Irewt tarcowscscar equi anos eve uate prefab “Chace wha he ae od ol ow sox ses a numa as any an quo sad contort wa he ‘Slumasips-anng hr newex qt te Sone oad ‘haribesurerle bane jee dbs ah sy tha ae Doone sear shy nde 0 be ie enc arta ‘Leandso on Pere posed chou hee dation dan ane telnade when ty ceurepoe owe ppt stash how sec Fring ih of te the cose ar ave dating eye {hone compra feonen competi pen Ge races of ices ang tom tbe cen of ik geet sre telly posem al oak ede dscns pene pos “Tilman samp te sled ling en sbjectan ea tani The eeldown obeton sy tha iia make oot ‘uy becuse favo eae conse you evig dow mes ‘Reatane egy ss Paco epee negate “Shean scree seed a at, wth sts Geno ol nhs yore oo a7 es ame wa be in {fen “Egg Mae" Th yf a ao Sat ope esse SSE en Oe Fig. 2 Te Leap Dow bon Bate mesa dieence wither ne angio (ei or ‘Seston utero ore quest tet fete, or while mash TGF totem fo te newman 9 eclng down ea ‘Sonesta te equi tures th wees baton iene Donia he obey heen tar mah beget Force saretn male eerpbdy moe doesnt tha re ‘nace inthe Snead uty forthe eso, doe no ‘ow tn oe soud el ogee Sod our 2a uy s ue sone Slr of aur to the Jaymes taps petal sore see of atte th no sn whch tau rn sven rod sac guy Renae he see ‘Bh tar he eg ny code wh mao ror beens Now up ove sins seni if iremovshie sod unedirbtable but o ‘rae aces fas on Jae plates ke do wa hi ‘hs mena got cormale ap bone wih to which youre eed Nene no ae el scl fr eto have mre han ouzays da you thnk se beg mer fly, be ou mh {rim that dhe lneting dow objecion apis to oly asi ‘Reppert sve sol free uy bas pis te {idea ee for gus: Rar for one wuld no tink fac gli no cess spl ema Fesons sll i. we salted Hr Begg nea eae {Goal bes wit teeta anes, Oren te shuld nt peasy "Shand her wth tesa mane ance tt mah ona te very trian of eay pon ni be ce we mig nevertbele e etic he mr and pacar teste een (hsm ne sho Conk deren ue foe wi areal oo (Sone ferent sites ster she ecormened tht ete 500 ne oesing cai, ne ns oy eel rags at a tea enpnte sd toby may tik wold Be oi fe 0 ‘Regattas mo hee roach Reamvon can, Not fac tha fs dos how aay.ts wl io Suchet tayiody cs expe “cose nom eso xaplein which ets manna land on equ hn, bt 10 noo an aol on re lt of ech ‘Sheryl And spp Srey aoa Jane aa do eying th ‘pe to whee te mana ys nob ha ae dso et ‘Sethe crerbad ee mann gf Tein ae Seample Ton’ hag sheep oct again 2 20- tedptengen, burt she ome ese ht lb a the expense (hace ow dy wo ny hat nee oibalesanple whee she (ovr tne Soe Jane fas th ib throw hes args ‘Rg snd fon tha beds ioe aya exemple en he ‘ows adm devon to pnce. Br one ay question whether Sheath igh shrew espa ne econ sera, on he [Pow ho ase mol thc a ores of otha they ‘Not andy een Pay fo ea ese, mod x that nldecrshoe reste ti sd example he she shows aaron ‘Mintel bor fn devon oie (Oe erage etn ‘Shoes se prepare ote owe meee {ole ho lmancl aan seis pe otc thers of ‘ie tot eople he dn ope thimeay utah aa ‘iin both aes ary vn sees opment ae ny wewesue conse wey pent a he eond ad ony Pec poing baton ni Fierce, hmong be raze ht Rona Dwr Lin es fr opposing ean ef wl eth ie ek cock teil venus pele he we mum aeere am enone qa yee ry ced po lr eyo (eur ha emp the net of ands pp people ah then ‘Show tues gen’ Beth bj fo egaiy of well, ‘oneed no ra ply tase ofthe concent fi ‘Shue hatch sappse thar ei onditon of rae eat Should tesa be pene though reson state le of ‘eoltion ee in hr argument, eat of goston 6) with ‘seen Tri pete commend et, beeing Spl hate tat ete tras nsednen! for stings oon ta nv oe {rosa po made more fee aan bom pe than Shr belo Desk rece ebcrcs phrase And tha ished ‘nt fecean deere of pail ated ow 48 mand oe a ow 1090 Pou MaLosree Po toy an eer of pric tha ae vere when pres ‘icc mee 9 Saw afin Pets reat pee or tht Atoms nay bte=* The challenge sha he eeing dons becson sens ao eu tat eget paper mane tht [ope canes ene pole sod erm body gis Yet ‘he euatnn cacy the wou oe do, bene atl [SS asset main ore ory io tty beer thaci ssc sme of ale lost bce nln na etore sn fie hen sore ave ore “Se oagh no ewes aor che mone, The ecg dow Statin st hey inate for soo wo enya a wo heheerone bin! inary yb an one sn neh sme, Di ovals can see Some who woal e Jon or eying he ou wed er mt fol Sepak ree ou ea ‘inc ulate shower htm be kip that tos ‘thon al ind wv mn oe nay Beer re other Coenteleplockingoutthe ees edie woke me “Thethetl Isso that hae aes bore, ene hat see sd yw je ad wha prea ht eres ‘take cwoty-one maw roced aire Tbr, and hey Tne become tomy compat. me sow hve «Csiarony mati ‘afb cls ic fan shcr ig ese why role alk pose xr sna npc ponphy. en people area pat one ee eco ey dan rele tat eye speaking ihn een elo hemaese ‘i before wold be iat be lee abou a consiertion stato bee be aon competing ripe ne you te 350 Ita lech nese [aout sien cr sour what he ‘Se ibe doo shoe whc wl ete pcre) esa fort [re you be cin to ich cette cl Your Cobuton pare fossa combo to be wore a ‘Donte eee nasa ae Seo ene ol te cer ae Scebcierro mereemetr mee ee ee ad rama Sinctegtht atta ag Se rye ee a ky econ Vandel rn Pt)2 curren eves inthe cous of bis egy we math by publi wok thar ae ‘oat binteve. TInt mr here ae highly ied pisoeher of whom Ladi \Wigznsta ne pects aoe wh ended tama peat {est tn own dept yore at tare ee the pee ‘Sesdewnln ay nea) rw eo import #0 andectnd the put of neher sein of si plow by cnr with phys pethgs, ery {Een ie becrae so by propel poses ae pees ely ‘ect hey ante he rua of eater of ral ppd pone heen An the sicaae sot of test an pose Shine ae dered eh paral rt rh el of apparent incmnet propo smog whch we mus chon where he ‘Seats one cote om ‘penn pheno, mene ac ofthe pts on be oppo ses of gran oon ha Hose the ter ae woe ‘hei nem evn wrong Ard sch ef parsean, ec ee beaten eave fee oer pena ew were bey ony then Fn hve een report iby ay dey elem eon ar acoale of thomsen wesc ato Le ne inte ‘he goon ofthe fiom ofthe will (i) fer besa coe (2) Allsucbclpoesseoealy ena (3) fo on bebo socal pail, then we ae otal of (tHe ae. Ber ayone who does motexpeece he eon alt eath spoons no sted pony ‘Same one ini ee fos oe svi psi anahie ‘Egy nin fawopey Bling ls Bed we my cane ‘stb nd ti th ceria singel ace’ In ali deep pop robles tee are competing aparere ciate that waza wren he we de {he wl somtomenscy ye seme sins tae pats conte: ‘les cominon sme as deep inept ssh so ‘date: My cu some seampes eon yt ty bik Fremont Inve roiene of owe, 2 opened tof ee ‘ens Tsr wih ad wiih pet example mh Ee ale made rece ow Too FouEAL MaLOsONY a The eon dow abiecionoparianom {1} Euan ees vel doa, her vel mos 2} Nobody bene on eng down er mae pene om ‘lato berween ur ng i 0 ee (3) Somuing as bene oon inno) po 18) Eyal 8 lean oe way good “Tein jets ("and do. Sameer eal, Thomas Che ‘iano andlngmar Penn (oy hee ta pope nde rain ofthe nau ofthe ct tanya ling dom eve hae Joke roo 2) a eer ty eae espe “inl pod” which “depen on he lan be en ne person's postion and hr pg" Many mc ya ‘amy the Betta any pe he eng dow Btn gt (The sae shal ese ht pope have oo ee. = (2) The satestoal be eae ould ot nar cneeaion ‘eter of» ay that smelter the (9) Avtmwhchlemural contenu at role re Many anigeicionis liberals calles (1) Socal pero. change 2 hom cou io favor apy tart esol et ‘ee era Taner eres htenge (ha he tet ply dor ake pepe ives bee ‘The ufiiency cntovery (Gl Noon wo reno ight complain abot esas, {2} Amongatwho ave sno sot may have mae han es (3 tse have me then ahr for no Gal st tn ns ston hve sgt compan, enka Rope Crp ad Ra ee) Cn et 22" he ck earn concer Gc an some have move than ok hong mo fat or ‘hie of eh tose ma hove re tire wi ave. cae raha aaeum Rem iy tee nie int 8 aC SE ad cosine ih) ‘a Testo ogo a wn eg sgae Curren inv (2) Th geen of ils fae od ew (2) The pletion 2 the prin formals n (2) would leads mor epee sey laabeth Andon jc 1" Cae jc 2)” Paha Riba Ari ot (ha he me of conpnon oh et hav (eee ppt ocheck hat our (i fae he ses bes (2 Jie cone! wit he ste tht shape peopl’ Hes 1) nd chor, aap, exes hae Fel’ es oben Lise Murphy jc Raw inte eee che ta ay ate, oer a a Andrew Wiis ree 2 Sot ‘Mh (2 te wens tick ve.” Aree ola ol suri people Hee az teeelared inconsistent ply, whch concen being be sea 1 a hing ange tour day, you bv fo save ve if ‘Besaiice you herby aks pty be (2) Ener (0) pesneeaker vo mea ieee 07 (whether Frm ged tip someone dpe ty apy Bly sot ontscaparywconmmice wha, (2) The are ons of dying sans You coud. (@) Youbave ato good te (5) Arie nppens, you tre aot mide ke Mother Teen ae fou thereore cont bare goodie you sayy Allg se. 1 We se noe moray ding (2) Leting people mel laguriag (31 Meeps people eet Rca pr ay emote’ nd Was aca ey nd al now 1090 Fou maLosonte as 1H) Lik ght lp he sain re san Lda 12} yonvely isk you ssh rode meting tat you deo da, Shen ou el ply bow that. (5) Tn fl (gal ly abot ot ping be arg ‘oor tena