Professional Documents
Culture Documents
METROPOLITAN AREA
Abstract. The distribution of 41 trace and 11 major elements in 4000 samples of topsoils
(0–20 cm) from the Berlin Megacity is interpreted. The detailed comparative analysis of the element
distributions and the results of factor analysis showed that the distributions of the elements Al, K,
Na, Rb, Zr, Nb and Ti are mainly natural origin, i.e. related to the composition of the parent material.
Industrial and commercial areas often display considerably elevated values for Mo, Ni, As, Ag, Cr,
Sb, Fe, Mn, Mg, P, TOC and especially Pb, Hg and electrical conductivity relative to the geogenic
background of the area surrounding Berlin. Industrial areas tend to be characterised by contamination
of the subsoil with Cu, Cd, Zn, Hg, Pb and Sn. In the area around Berlin, extensive, strong anamalies
of Cd, Zn, Pb, Cu and Hg occur near iron and steel industries and construction materials industries,
as well as in the vicinity of sewage farms.
1. Introduction
A third of the population of Germany lives in cities with greater than 100,000
people. Anthropogenic activities are the determining ecological factor in cities and
industrial regions. In the early stages of industrialisation and urbanisation, land
was used to obtain raw materials, for building houses, businesses and factories, as
well as for waste disposal. The need to have local services led to a high density of
building with few open areas, which in turn led to an increase in traffic density.
Besides the rehabilitation of polluted areas, the ‘Research for the Environment’
programme of the German federal government makes the development of a sci-
entific basis for the recognition and evaluation of polluted areas a priority project.
Metropolitan regions and industrial areas have a more complex and much higher
production of hazardous substances, reaching back to the beginning of the indus-
trial revolution in the last century. Before the introduction of filter systems, sources
of hazardous substances included coal- and oil-fired power plants, gasworks, me-
tallurgical, chemical and electronic plants, motor vehicles and landfills.
The soils in residential areas and industrial centres show a strong anthropo-
genic impact. Owing to the considerable compaction, the functions of the soils in
metropolitan areas are greatly reduced. Soils in these areas serve primarily as a
foundation for buildings and other construction.
In all of these key issues that are likely to have special environmental and socio-
economic impacts, geochemistry is a powerful tool for detecting and monitoring
economic and environmental systems and their development. Looking at the rel-
evance to the cities, human activities have the most deleterious influence on the
urban environment, for example, groundwater pollution, surface water pollution,
contaminated land and urban waste disposal.
Berlin is the first European megacity to be covered in its entirety (1993–1996)
by a geochemical survey of the topsoil, including large, more or less rural areas.
This extensive urban study is unique in Germany, although similar studies have
been undertaken in London (Thornton, 1991; Kelly et al., 1995), Warsaw (Lis,
1992), Minsk (Lukashev, 1994), Hong Kong (Li xiang-Dong, 1997), New Orleans
(Mielke, 1994; Viverette et al., 1996; Mielke et al., 1997; Mielke and Reagan,
1998), Vilnius, Šiauliai, Panevežys (Kadūnas, Budavičius, Gregorauskiene et al.,
1999) and Tallinn (Birke, Bityukova and Grunsky, 1998).
Our studies have been aimed at obtaining a differentiated picture of the complex
geochemistry of soils in urban areas with respect to their natural composition and
the secondary or anthropogenic contamination. The geochemical studies also aim
at developing a set of regulations and standards for documenting contamination
on a regional scale, as well as to combat hazards caused by contamination. These
investigations in Berlin can provide a basis upon which to draw up general reg-
ulations for nature conservation and soil protection, conducting an environmental
impact assessment, and estimating contamination of soils.
About 4000 soil samples (depth 0–0.2 m) were taken in suburban areas with little
or no contamination as well as industrial areas in and around Berlin. The < 2-mm
fraction was analysed for 11 major elements (Si, Al, Fe, Mg, Ca, Na, K, P, S, Ctot,
TOC) and 41 trace elements (Ag, As, B, Ba, Be, Bi, Br, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Cu,
F, Ga, Ge, Hg, I, In, La, Mn, Mo, Nb, Ni, Pb, Rb, Sb, Se, Sn, Sr, Ta, Te, Th, Ti,
Tl, U, V, W, Y, Zn, Zr). TOC, pH and electrical conductivity were also determined
(Table I). Major and trace elements were analysed using energy-dispersive X-ray
fluorescence spectroscopy with polarised X-rays (EDXRF; Heckel et al., 1991),
atomic absorption spectrophotometry (AAS), and inductively coupled plasma-
atomic emission spectrometry (ICP-AES). All soil samples were dried at 25 ◦ C,
disaggregated and sieved. Organic pollutants, such as hydrocarbons, aromatics, and
volatile halogenated compounds were also analysed in topsoils from the central
part of Berlin and from locations currently or formerly occupied by chemical in-
dustries. Polychlorinated dibenzodioxins and dibenzofurans (PCDD/PCDF) were
analysed only in topsoils from central part of Berlin.
URBAN GEOCHEMISTRY OF BERLIN 235
TABLE I
Analytical methods and detection limits of elements
On the basis of our geochemical survey of Berlin soils, it was possible to de-
termine the natural geochemical backgrounds of elements (Table III, IV) and the
anthropogenic load. The inner city and surrounding area of Berlin show enriched
concentrations, sometimes considerably, of Cd, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mo, Ni, Pb, Sn, Sr and
Zn with respect to the regional geochemical background (Figure 1). These studies
confirm the results of Brose and Brühl (1993) on the most abundant near-surface
sediments of West Berlin.
Element distributions are shown on coloured contour maps. A set of regularly
spaced data was obtained from the irregularly spaced sites using a geostatistical
gridding method (Kriging). The maps also indicate where the soil pH exceeds the
value at which the respective metal becomes soluble. The maps were drawn using
the Gauss-Krueger projection.
These maps are useful for locating anthropogenic geochemical halos, assess-
ing environmental conditions, and making well-based ecological decisions. The
mercury distribution in topsoils in urban Berlin is shown in Figure 2.
Certain types of industries are typically associated with mercury contamination
(> 0.35 mg Hg kg−1 soil). These include the metal-working industry, non-ferrous
smelters, sewage farms, the chemical industry, including manufacturers of paint,
and other coatings, chlorine, asphalt, photochemicals, and electrical components,
as well as the wood-processing industry. Anomalous concentrations of mercury
(Figure 2) also occur in association with landfills and areas where building rubble
has been dumped.
URBAN GEOCHEMISTRY OF BERLIN 237
TABLE II
Scheme for a geochemical survey in an urban environment
238 MANFRED BIRKE AND UWE RAUCH
Figure 1. Ratios of mean concentration to regional background concentration of the Berlin environs
for selected elements determined for different types of land use.
TABLE IV
Regional geochemical background values for the major elements in soils of Berlin and
environs (in g kg−1 )
Parameter Entire area Areas Woodlands Agricultural Low-density High-density Allotment Sewage Industrial
within around areas residential residential areas farm areas
city limits Berlin areas areas areas
(N = 2182) (N = 1564) (N = 614) (N = 388) (N = 826) (N = 476) (N = 102) (N = 64) (N = 459)
As Median 3,9 2,9 2,8 2,9 3,4 4,3 3,7 2,9 4,1
Arithmetic 5,1 3,4 3,2 3,1 4,0 4,9 4,9 3,2 6,8
Parameter Entire area Areas Woodlands Agricultural Low-density High-density Allotment Sewage Industrial
within around areas residential residential areas farm areas
city limits Berlin areas areas areas
(N = 2182) (N = 1564) (N = 614) (N = 388) (N = 826) (N = 476) (N = 102) (N = 64) (N = 459)
Hg Median 0,19 0,05 0,04 0,06 0,10 0,34 0,17 0,70 0,21
241
242
TABLE VI
Parameter values for topsoils in several European cities (in mg kg−1 )
Warsaw (Lis, 1992) Berlin (Birke & Rauch, 1994) Tallinn (Birke, Bitykova & Grunsky, 1998) Hamburg (Lux, 1993)
Para- N = 1713 (0 – 20 cm) N = 3746 (0 – 20 cm) N = 531 (0 – 20 cm) N = 1475 (0 – 5 cm)
As 5,0 2,0 2830 4,4 2,4 126 6,0 2,0 136 23,0 27,0 918
B – – – 17,6 13,0 1800 – – – – – –
Cd < 0.30 < 0.30 19,1 0,65 0,08 131 – – – 1,2 0,90 27,8
Co 1,9 1,0 10,0 1,9 4,0 192 2,2 <1 18,0 – – –
Cr – – – 28,7 12,2 1840 26,9 17,0 475 52,0 27,0 492
Cu 10,0 6,0 560 53,1 6,0 12300 25,9 11,0 604 81,0 103,0 3688
Hg 0,13 0,1 10,8 0,29 0,04 71,2 0,24 0,04 10,0 0,60 0,30 19,1
Ni 5,0 4,0 31,0 8,1 2,7 769 4,4 4,0 205 31,0 19,0 182
Pb 20,0 13,0 401 85,8 21,7 4710 45,5 17,0 468 168 118 3074
Sn – – – 7,6 1,6 498 3,3 2,0 71,0 – – –
Zn 54,0 34,0 1432 166 19,3 25210 115 18,0 1463 381 361 11850
pH 5,9 6,1 7,8 6,6 4,2 9,1 7,1 7,5 8,5 – – –
URBAN GEOCHEMISTRY OF BERLIN 243
TABLE VII
Approximate metal accumulation in the Berlin topsoils (in t)
soil, however, but wind up in the sewage plants and consequently in the sewage
sludge or in the fields irrigated with the water from the sewage plants. When sewage
sludge is used for soil amelioration, for example, in parks, the hazardous substances
return to the city. Dioxins and furans are the only organic parameters that have been
measured in the soils throughout the central part of Berlin.
The average PCDD/F content increases with the intensity of anthropogenic
land use. Investigations in different urban and suburban areas show an increase
of PCDD/F in soil from wooded and agricultural areas to residential and industrial
areas.
To clarify the sources of PCDD/F contamination, the congener composition of
the samples and the sum of the PCDD/F and toxic-equivalent (TE) concentrations
are compared with the patterns of PCDD/F congeners that are typical of known
sources. This is followed by a cluster analysis. Another method for distinguishing
between the main causes of an element distribution is to include the PCDD/F values
in a factor analysis.
The city center (Figure 3) is characterized by a geochemical background of
0.98 ng ITE kg−1 (2.19 ng TE kg−1 as defined by the Federal Health Office 1984).
In industrial districts of Berlin, the geochemical background is about three times
higher than it is in the inner city. The maximum toxicity equivalents (Figure 3,
4) were determined in the Thälmann Park residential area (33.1 ng ITE kg−1 ) and
the former border area (28.5 ng ITE kg−1 ). They stem from sewage sludge (used as
URBAN GEOCHEMISTRY OF BERLIN 245
Figure 3. Distribution of PCDD and PCDF concentrations in topsoils in the inner city of Berlin (in
ng ITE kg−1 .
fertiliser). The main sources of PCDD/F input were found to be fly ash (from waste
incineration plants, district heating plants). Mobility of PCDD/F is extremly low in
the soil water phase due to their low solubility and strong sorption in the organic
soil fraction.
For the last hundred years or more, toxic substances have been used in in-
dustrial processes by various companies within the urban area of Schöneweide,
Berlin. Industrial emission of these substances has led to a variable but locally
high accumulation of toxic materials in the soil of the area.
The distribution patterns of certain element associations in urban Berlin and
its surroundings were determined by principal component analysis and cluster-
Q analysis. They allow regional and local migration of the various elements in
industrial emissions to be studied in the exogenic geochemical field, as well as the
recognition of natural and anthropogenic element associations.
The methods of multivariate statistics permit the geochemical characterisation
of the geogenic and anthropogenic factors and their effect on the individual samples.
The complex linear correlations between the parameters measured in the topsoils
of the study area were determined by factor analysis. The factor values determined
by varimax rotation factor analysis are a measure of the influence of a factor on
an individual sample and can be plotted on maps. Factor analysis explained 90.2%
246 MANFRED BIRKE AND UWE RAUCH
The various geochemical studies in metropolitan regions can provide general con-
clusions for nature conservation and soil protection, for environmental impact state-
ments, and estimates of pollution. Only by considering the situation of the entire
region with the multitude of superimposed influences from various sources can
methods be derived for estimating the hazards of the complex mixture of sub-
stances and to determine the sensitivity of landscapes to land uses. The geochem-
ical characterisation of vertical migration of substances and determination of the
element bonding in areas with different degrees of contamination, together with
a geochemical inventory, provides a scientific database for the evaluation of soils
for different land uses. Reliable evaluations are possible only on the basis of a
sufficiently large, uniformly determined data base. Since soils are naturally very
heterogeneous and contamination can have many causes, it is important to develop
strategies for investigating and evaluating soil contamination.
The resulting geochemistry database can be integrated into any of several in-
formation systems and thus forms a basis for further interdisciplinary evaluations
(e.g., for emissions covering several countries, planning regional strategies for the
environment, for geomedicine, agriculture, forestry, water management, regional
planning, ecology research).
For the first time, a comprehensive geochemical data base is available for the
urban Berlin environment that permits differentiation between the natural geo-
chemical background and local anthropogenic contamination.
Multivariate statistical methods allow long-range and local migration of pollut-
ants to be traced and natural and anthropogenic element associations to be distin-
guished.
The regional or local geochemical situation in an urban area can be described
only by comparison with the non-industrial surroundings.
The studies have shown that heavy-metal concentrations in the topsoil vary con-
siderably in an urban environment. These concentrations primarily reflect land use
and the type and volume of industrial production in the areas under consideration.
A geochemical survey of the urban environment also provides a reliable data
base for setting concentration limits for urban and other soils.
248 MANFRED BIRKE AND UWE RAUCH
References
Birke, M., Bityukova, L. and Grunsky, E.: 1998, Urban Geochemistry of Tallinn, Estonia, Final
Report, NATO (EVIR. CRG. 960910), 67 pp., Brussels.
Birke, M and Rauch, U.: 1994, Geochemical investigations in the urban areas of Berlin, Mineral
Magazine 58A, 95–96, London (Mineralogical Society).
Birke, M. and Rauch, U.: 1997, Geochemical investigations in the Berlin metropolitan area, Z. Angew.
Geol. 43(1), 58–65, Hannover.
Bityukova, L., Scholger, R. and Birke, M.: 1999, Magnetic Susceptibility as Indicator of Envir-
onmental Pollution of Soils in Tallinn – Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, vol. 24, Elsevier
Science Pergamon Press.
Brose, F. and Brühl, H.V.: 1993, Untersuchungen zur geogenen und anthropogenen Grundlast
umweltrelevanter Schadstoffe in oberflächennahen Lockergesteinen und Grundwässern im west-
lichen Stadtgebiet von Berlin, Z. dt. Geol. Ges. 144, 279–294, Hannover.
Earickson, R.J. and Billick, J.H.: 1988, The areal associated of urban air pollutants and residential
characteristics: Louisvill and Detroit, Applied Geogr. 8, 5–23.
Heckel, J., Brumme, M., Weinert, A. and Irmer, K.: 1991, Multielement trace analysis of rocks and
soils by EDXRF using polarized radiation. X-ray Spectrometry, 20, 287–292, Chichester, Sussex,
Wiley.
Kadunas, V., Budavicius, R. and Gregorauskiené, V. et al.: 1999, Geochemical Altas of Lithuania,
Geological Survey of Lithuania, Geological Institute, Vilnius, 162pp.
Kelly, J., Thornton, J. and Simpson, P.R.: 1995, Urban Geochemistry: A Study of the Influence
of Anthropogenic Activity on the Heavy Metal Content of Soils in Traditionally Industrial
and Nonindustrial Areas of Britain, Applied Geochemistry, Oxford, New York, Seoul, Tokyo,
Pergamon (in press).
Lis, J.: 1992, Geochemical Atlas of Warsaw and Environs 1:100 000, Paustwowy, Geological
Institute, Warsaw, 33p.
Li, Xiang-Dong, Poon, Chi-Sum, Chan, R. et al.: 1997, Concentration and Chemical Partitioning of
Heavy Metals in Road Dusts and Urban Soils in Hong Kong, 4th International Symposium on
Environmental Geochemistry, Open File Report 97-496, Vail, pp. 54.
Lukashev, V.K.: 1994, Soil and Plants Geochemical Monitoring in Urban Environments, Abstracts
of the 3rd International Symposium on Environmental Geochemistry, Krakow, pp. 245.
Lux, W.: 1993, Long-Term Heavy Metal and As Pollution of Soils, Hamburg, Germany. Applied
Geochemistry, Suppl. 2: 135–143; Oxford, New York, Seoul, Tokyo, Pergamon Press.
Mielke, H.W.: 1997, Urbane Geochemie: Prozesse, Muster und Auswirkungen auf die menschliche
Gesundheit, in: Matschullat, J., Tobschall, H.J. and Voigt, H.-J. (eds) Geochemie und Umwelt:
Relevante Prozesse in Atmo-, Pedo- und Hydrosphäre, Berlin, Springer-Verlag, 169–179.
Mielke, H.W.: 1994, Lead in New Orleans soils: new images of an urban environment, Environmental
Geochemistry and Health London 16, 123–128.
Mielke, H.W., Dugas, D., Mielke, P.W. et al.: 1977, Associations between soil lead and childhood
blood lead in urban New Orleans and rural Lafourch Parish of Louisiana, Environmental Health
Perspetives 105(9), 950–954.
Mielke, H.W., Reagan, P.L.: 1988, Soil as an impact pathway of human lead exposure, Environmental
Health Perspectives 106(1), 217–229.
Reimann, C.L., De Caritat, P.: 1998, Chemical elements in the environment, Factsheet for the
Geochemist and environmental scientist, Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 397 pp.
Thornton, J.: 1991, Metal contamination of soils in urban areas, in: Bullock P and Gregory P.J. (eds)
Soils in the Urban Environment, Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publ, pp. 47–55.
Viverette, L., Mielke, H.W., Brisco, M. et al.: 1996, Environmental health in minority and other
underserved populations: benign methods for identifying lead hazards at day care centres of New
Orleans, Environmental Geochemistry and Health, London 18, 41–45.