Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Shaini2008 PDF
Shaini2008 PDF
SUMMARY Three-hundred and seventy-two porcelain using the Kaplan-Meier method. Results showed
laminate veneers were fitted to defective and higher rates of failure and problem development in
discoloured teeth in 102 patients. Ninety per cent of veneers fitted over existing restorations and in those
the restorations were fitted to unprepared teeth. fitted by inexperienced operators. A considerable
Restorations were reviewed up to 78 months after number of veneers suffered minor problems that
cementation. Survival probabilities were calculated were successfully repaired.
© 1997 Blackwell Sd
554 F.J. SHAINI etal.
Table 1. Number and (%) of failure and problem development Table 2. Probability of survival (PS) of porcelain laminate veneers
seen in porcelain laminate veneers fitted to prepared and
unprepared teeth
PS (%) 9 5 % Cf PS (%) 9 5 % CI
(month) (A) (A) (B) (B)
PLV fitted Failure Repairable problem
12 88 84-92 85 81-89
No. No. (%) No. (%)
24 76 70-82 71 64-77
36 68 61-76 61 53-70
Tooth prep. 51 37-2 4 7-8
48 62 52-71 51 39-62
No tooth prep. 321 32-1 31 97
60 58 47-69 40 26-54
72 48 36-61 26 10^2
78 47 34-61 25 5-45
the use of PLVs started in late 1984. The aim of this
study was to evaluate the clinical performance of the PLV PS, prohahility of survival: Cl. confidence interval; A, the PS
restorations fitted in BDH over a period of 78 months. without failure; B. the PS without developing any problem.
100
Fig. L Survival probabilities ot porcelain laminate veneers. A. witbout tailtire, B, witbout developing any problem.
Table 3. Distribution of tbe fitted, failed restorations and restorations presenting with a repairable problem according to the age and
sex of tbe patients
14-24 160 69 56 15 19 0
25-34 35 10 11 3 1 1
35-44 21 7 3 3 2 1
45-54 21 0 7 0 2 0
55-64 19 19 8 12 5 1
>64 8 3 3 1 3 0
Total 264 108 88 34 32 3
Any necessary adjustments or additional finishing and the aesthetic quality of tbe restoration. Restorations
polishing were performed as required. classified as failures were those that presented with
problems that were not liable to repair and required
Criteria for clinical evaluation remaking or changing to an alternative treatment. This
group included fractured restorations and debonded
The veneers were reviewed and evaluated by one of restorations tbat were either fractured and had to be
tbe staff members at variable intervals, either during replaced, or intact, which were re-cemented. It also
routine recall visits or wben presenting with a problem. included discoloured restorations and restorations not
At each review tbe restorations were classified acceptable to the patient due to their appearance or bulk.
either as: All tbe restorations tbat were remade due to failure
1. Clinically satisfactory. during tbe study were treated as new ones. All tbe
2. Presenting with a repairable problem. restorations presenting with a repairable problem were
3. Failed: repaired and remained in the study, and all the sound
a) Fractured restoration(s). debonded restorations were re-cemented and were
b) Debonded restoration(s). followed up as a separate group.
c) Other.
Tbe restorations that were classified as clinically
Survival analysis
satisfactory were the ones that were physically intact
and aesthetically acceptable with no adverse gingival In this study the survival time was defined as the
reaction. Repairable problems were mostly in tbe form period of time starting from the successful fitting of the
of chipping or minor fracture and tbese were repaired restoration and ending wben the restoration presented
by smoothing and polishing of the chipped edge or by witb an irreparable problem.
restoring witb composite resin without major effect on Tiie Kaplan-Meier 'product limit' estimation method
Table 4. Porcelain laminaie veneers fitted by students and staff 24 year age group. As expeaed, most of the PLVs were
members, number and (%) of failed restorations, and restorations fitted on maxillary anterior teeth (87-4%) and only
presenting with a repairable problem
relatively few on mandibular anterior (8-6%), maxillary
posterior (3-5%) and deciduous teeth (0-5%) (Table 5).
PLV fitted Failti Repairable problem The PLV restorations were considered mainly to mask
No. (%) No. (%) tooth discolourations and to cover existing restorations.
53-7% were fitted to mask existing tooth discolouration,
Si[udenis 235 91 38-7 26 I M
a high proportion of which was due to tetracycline
Silafl 1 37 31 22-6 9 6.6
staining especially in young individuals. PLV restorations
were infrequently used for a number of otber
was utilized for the calculation of the survival applications including closure of inter-proximal spaces,
probabilities in this study (Table 2). This non-parametric median diastemas and as a method of re-contouring
statistical technique takes account of censored malformed teeth such as the case of peg-shaped lateral
observations resulting from incomplete lollow-up incisors. The number of PLVs used for closure of spaces
(Bulman & Osborn, 1989). between teeth was surprisingly low (4 PLV) and formed
The analysis of survival probability was performed only about 1% of the total number. The original
over a period of 78 months after which it was decided condition of the restored teeth that indicated the use
to stop because the number of restorations remaining of PLVs are detailed in (Table 6).
in the study dropped to 42; namely 11'3% of the The original condition of 85'5% of the teeth restored
original number. The decision to stop at this level was with PLV was identified before veneering. In 14'5% of
made to avoid any possible inaccuracy in the prediction the restorations it was not possible to identify the tooth
of survival probabilities due to the small number condition prior to veneering (reason of veneering) as
remaining. After 78 months 208 restorations (55-9%) the records did not contain the relevant data.
were classified as censored and the remaining 122 The incidence of failure and the incidence of
(32-8%) presented with irreparable problems. Survival occurrence of any sort of problem including failure
curves were produced to estimate the probability of were analysed according to the sex and age of the
survival without failure and the probability of survival patients at the time of cementation, the location of the
without developing any problems (Fig. 1). restoration in the oral cavity, the tooth condition before
treatment and the operator's clinical experience. Chi-
squared tests were used to detect any significant
Results
diflerences in the incidence of failure and problem
During the period covered by the investigation, 383 occurrence among the various groups (Table 7).
PLVs were constructed of which 372 were fitted. Eleven
PLVs fractured during try-in; these restorations were
Discussion
not included in the statistical analysis because it was
decided to consider the successful cementation of each when the technique of porcelain veneering was first
restoration as the starting point (titne 0) of the survival introduced in the Birmingham Dental Hospital in 1984
analysis. PLVs were fitted for 104 patients. 70 female it was still in the experimental stage. Therefore, it was
(67-3%) and 34 male (32-7%), with an average number considered preferable not to undertake any sort of tooth
of 3-6 PLVs per patient, range 1-12. The numbers of preparation to maintain the conservative quality and
PLVs fitted for the different age groups for both sexes ihe reversible nature of the procedure. It is believed
are detailed in (Table 3). The mean age at the time of that this lack of tooth preparation might be one of the
cementation was 34 4 years for female patients and major factors contributing to the high failure rates
29-6 years for male patients with a range of 14-71 years noticed in this study. Stress concentration is less intense
{for both sexes). Two hundred and thirty-five (63-2%) within the restoration fitted to prepared teeth (Highton,
of the PLVs were fitted by students and 137 (36 8%) Caputo & Matyas, 1987). Tooth preparation creates
by staff members (Table 4). some space for the composite resin cement to mask the
The greatest percentage of the PLVs incorporated in underlying discolouration and it facilitates the
this study (61-6%) were fitted to individuals in the 14- positioning of the restoration during cementation
Table 5. Distribution of the number and (%) of fitted porcelain laminate veneers and those presenting with irreparable and repairable
problems according to the tooth position
Table 6. The distribution of the fitted, faiied and porcelain laminate veneers presenting with repairable problem (number and %)
according to the tooth condition before veneering
1. Discolouration
a. Tetracycline (Te) 119 320 29 24-4
b. Non vital (Nv) 47 12'6
12'6 20 42-5
42-5 5 10-6
c. Non specific (Ns) 34 9 1
9-1 8 23-5
23'5 4 11-8
2. Hypoplasia (Hy) 47 12-6
12 6 9 19-1
19-i 7 14-9
3. To cover existing restorations (Er). 56 1 51
151 30 53-6
53-6 6 10-7
4. Tootb wear (We) , 11 1
1 3 - 300 2 18-2
18-2 1 9-1
5. Spacing 4 II 2 50
6. Others 54 14 5 22 41-5
(GiJmour & Stone, 1993). It was reported that surface not only provides the necessary retention needed to
preparation increases the bond strength of composite keep the restoration in its place, it also allows the
resin lo the enamel by removing the aprismatic and restoration to function as an integral part of the tooth
hyper-mineralized enamel layers which can be resistant structure. This intimate contact allows better stress
to acid etching (Schneider, Messer & Douglass, 1981). distribution and prevents local overloading of the
Most of the clinical studies published on PLV brittle material. Any factor that influences this bond
restorations involved some form of tooth preparation is likely to be a risk factor that might affect the long
(Calamia, 1989; Jordan, Suzuki 6-Senda, 1989, Rucker term or even the short term performance of the
e/fl/., 1990; Karlsson^ffl/., 1992; Dunned Millar, 1993; restoration. This was clearly demonstrated by the
Nordbo etai, 1994). Some researchers did not find any increased incidence of failure of PLV restorations that
significant difference in the clinical performance of had been cemented to teeth with reduced enamel
different veneer preparation designs (Karlsson et al.. bonding area due to the presence of other restorations
1992; Dunne & Millar, 1993). compared with PLVs cemented to sound continuous
The acid etch technique is considered to be the enamel surfaces. The same effect is expected if the
basis for successful bonding of resin to enamel. It can restoration is bonded to an exposed dentine surface
be said also that bonding of porcelain to tooth enamel because of the inferior bond quality of the cementing
through the composite resin cement is the key for resin to the pre-existing restorations and dentine
successful veneering. Bonding of porcelain to enamel compared lo enamel (Dunne & Millar, 3 993).
Problem developir
*A11 restorations fitted to mandibular leeth were ( sidered as one group, and all restoration fitted to maxillary premolars and molars
were considered as one group.
Staiistical analysis showed a higher incidence t>f rather than the actual age of the patient. However, the
failure in PLVs fitted lo discoloured non-vital teeth quality of bond between the cementing resin and the
(Table 7). This finding might be related to the significant highly mineralized enamel in older individuals, the
decrease in the amount of supporting tooth structure possibility of higher stress concentration in the anterior
as a consequence of extensive loss of this structure teeth as a result of posterior tooth loss and occlusal
subsequent to endoduiitic treatment. It is believed that wear are also points to be considered.
the possible loss of enamel bonding surface area as a The significantly higher incidence of failure and
result of the presence of heavy restorations usually problem development in PLVs fitted by students
encountered in endodontically treated teeth might be
compared to the ones fitted by staff members emphasizes
a major faaor contributing to ihe increase in the rate
the sensitivity of the technique and the importance of
of problem development and failure.
the clinical experience of the operator in both improving
The higher incidence of failure in the restorations
the clinical pertormance and the survival probability of
fitted to central incisors compared to lateral incisors and
these restorations. Presumably, this might be considered
canines is difficult to explain. This difference might be
due to the faa that a large number of restored central as one of the main factors contributing to the higher
incisors belong to the high risk group, i.e. non-vital failure rate of PLVs found in this work. Dunne & Millar
(NV) teeth and teeth with existing restorations (ER) (1993) reported similar differences in the incidence of
(71 out of 181). It is possible that the surface tooth problem development and failures between experienced
condition is the cause of the difference rather than the and inexperienced operators.
actual tooth position. The lack of significant difference between PLVs fitted
It has been shown that the restorations fitted to older to prepared and unprepared teeth is not considered to
individuals experienced a higher incidence of failure and be strong evidence against tooth preparation due to the
problem occurrence compared to younger individuals. tact that the number of prepared teeth included in
Approximately half of the restored teeth in older this study is very small compared to the number of
individuals (22 out of 49) were actually from the high unprepared teeth and due to the fact that the type of
risk group, which may have influenced the rate of failure tooth preparation performed was not consistent with
S> 1997 Blackwell Science Ltd, Journal of Oral RehabiUtation 24; 553-559
CLINICAL P E R F O R M A N C E OF P O R C E L A I N LAMINATE VENEERS 559
the currently recommended preparation designs (Hui CALAMIA. J R . (1989) Clinical evaluation of etched porcelain
elai, 1991). veneers. American Journal of Dentistry. 2, 9,
COYNE, B . M . C . A . & WILSON, N . H . P . (1994) A clinical evaluation of
A laboratory-based study has been nndertaken to
ihe marginal adaptaton of porcelain laminate veneers. European
compare tbe shear bond strength of resin-based Journal of Prosihodontics and Restorative Dentistry, 3. 87.
composite with both grit-blasted and HF add-etched DUNNE, S.M. 6- MILLAR, B J. (1993) A longitudinal study of the
porcelain using bonding materials and technique similar clinical performance of porcelain veneers. British Dental Journal.
to those employed in the clinical study. The results 175, 317.
showed no statistically significant differences in the FAUNCE, F,R. & FAUNCE, A.R. (1975) The use of laminate veneers
bond strength according to the porcelain surface for restoration of fractured discoloured teeth. Tixas Dental
preparation (Shaini, 1995). Journal, 9 8 , 6.
GiLMOUR, A.S.M.& STONE, D C . (1993) Porcelain laminate veneers:
a clinical success. Dental Update. 20, 167.
Conclusions HiGHTON, R., CAPUTO, A . A . & MATYAS, J . (1987) A photoelastic
study of stresses on porcelain laminate preparations. Journal of
1. The survival probability of PLVs in this study is
Prosthetic Dentistry, 58. 157,
low in comparison to a similar study where tooth HORN, HR. (1983) Porcelain laminate veneers bonded to etched
preparation was undertaken. enamel. Dental Clinics of North America, 27, 671.
2. A significantly higher failure rate and problem HUI, K . K . K . , WILLIAMS, B., DAV[S, E . H . & HOLT, R . D . (1991) A
development is seen with inexperienced operators comparative assessment of the strengths of porcelain veneers
(students compared to staff members). for incisor teeth dependent on their design characteristics. British
3. An increase in failure rate and problem development Dental Journal, 171, 51.
JORDAN, R.E., SUZUKI, M . fr SENDA, A, (1989) Four year recall
has been shown when PLV restorations are fitted
evaluation of labial porcelain veneer restorations. Journal of
over existing restorations. Detttal Research. 68, 249 /Abstract No. 544).
4. The high incidence of porcelain fractures suggests KARLSSON, S,, LANDAHL, I,, STEGERSJO, G, &• MSLLEDING, P. (1992) A
that porcelain is the weakest link in this system. clinical evaluation of ceramic laminate veneers. The International
5. A considerable number of PLV problems may be Journal of Prosthodontics, 5,447.
resolved by repair, a procedure that will significantly LIU, F-R., ESENBERG, B P. & LEfNFEi.DER, K.F. (J993) Evaluating CAD-
prolong the service life of these restorations. CAM generated ceramic veneers. Journal of American Dental
Association, 124, 59.
6. Proper case selection is a key factor in the success of
NoRDBO, H,, RYGH-THORESEN, N , & HENAUG, T. (1994) Clinical
PLV restorations.
performance of porcelain laminate veneers without incisal
PLV restoration can be considered as one alternative overlapping: 3-year results. Journal of Dentistry, 22, 342.
when dealing with aesthetic treatment of anterior teeth. PLANT, C G . & THOMAS, G , D . (1987) Porcelain facings: a simple
Full understanding of the limitations and potential clinical and laboratory method. British Dental Journal, 163, 231.
drawbacks of this technique must always be kept REID. J.S., KINANE, D F. & ADONOGIANAKI, E. (1991) Gingival health
in mind and explained to the patient prior to the associated with porcelain veneers on maxillary incisors.
start of the treatment. The sensitivity of the technique International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry, 1, 137.
RucKER, L.M., RjcHTtR, W., MACENTEE, M . & RICHARDSON, A, (1990)
demands meticuJous attention to the detail before,
Porcelain and resin veneers clinically evaluated: 2-year results.
during and after treatment. Patient co-operation and
Journal of American Dental Association. 121, 594.
understanding of the importance of home care are SCHNEIDER, P.M-, MESSER, L.B. & DOUGLAS, W , H , (1981) The effea
essential for optimum results. of ename! surface reduction in vitro on the bonding of composite
resin to permanent human enamel. Journal of Dental Research,
Acknowledgments 60, 895.
SHAINI, F J . (1995) Clinical performance of porcelain laminate
The authors would like to thank Mr G Thomas and veneers and the factors affecting Composite/Porcelain bonding.
the Dental Records Department in Birmingham Dental M.Sc. thesis. University of Birmingham,
Hospital for their assistance. StMONSEN, R.J. & CALAMIA, J R . (1983) Tensile bond strength of
etched porcelain. Journal of Dental Research. 7, 297 (Abstract
BULMAN. J.S. & OsBORN. J.E (1989) Statistics in Dentistry, pp. 9 1 - Correspondence: Dr F.J. Shaini, The School of Dentistry, St. Chad's,
99. British Dental Association, London. Queensway, Birmingham B4 6NN, D,K.