Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2002
De Vries LS, Liem KD, van Dijk K, Smit BJ, Sie L, Rademaker KJ, Gavilanes AWD; on behalf
of the Dutch Working Group of Neonatal Neurology. Early versus late treatment of posthaemor-
rhagic ventricular dilatation: results of a retrospective study from ve neonatal intensive care units
in The Netherlands. Acta Pædiatr 2002; 91: 212–217. Stockholm. ISSN 0803-5253
Posthaemorrhagic ventricular dilatation (PHVD) in very preterm infants carries a poor prognosis.
As earlier studies have failed to show a bene t of early intervention, it is recommended that
PHVD be rst treated when head circumference is rapidly increasing and/or when symptoms of
raised intracranial pressure develop. Infants with PHVD, admitted to 5 of the 10 Dutch neonatal
intensive care units were studied retrospectively, to investigate whether there was a difference in
the time of onset of treatment of PHVD and, if so, whether this was associated with a difference in
the requirement of a ventriculo-peritoneal (VP) shunt and/or neurodevelopmental outcome. The
surviving infants with a gestational age µ34 wk, born between 1992 and 1996, diagnosed as
having a grade III haemorrhage according to Papile on cranial ultrasound and who developed
PHVD were included in the study. PHVD was de ned as a ventricular index (VI) exceeding the
97th percentile according to Levene (1981), and severe PHVD as a VI crossing the p 97 ‡ 4 mm
line. Ninety- ve infants met the entry criteria. Intervention was not deemed necessary in 22
infants, because of lack of progression. In 31 infants lumbar punctures (LP) were done before the
p 97 ‡ 4 mm line was crossed (early intervention). In 20/31 infants, stabilization occurred. In 9 a
subcutaneous reservoir was placed, with subsequent stabilization in 6. In 5/31 infants a VP shunt
was eventually inserted. In 42 infants treatment was started once the p 97 ‡ 4 mm line was crossed
(late intervention). In 30 infants LPs were performed and in 17 of these a VP shunt was eventually
inserted. In 11 infants a subcutaneous reservoir was immediately inserted and in 8 of these infants
a VP shunt was needed. In one infant a VP shunt was immediately inserted, without any other
form of treatment. Infants with late intervention crossed the p 97 ‡ 4 mm earlier (p 0.03) and
needed a shunt (26/42; 62%) more often than those with early intervention (5/31; 16%). Early LP
was associated with a strongly reduced risk of VP-shunting (odds ratio = 0.22, 95% con dence
interval: 0.08–0.62). The number of infants who developed a moderate or severe handicap was
also higher (11/42; 26%) in the late intervention group, compared with those not requiring any
intervention (3/22; 14%) or treated early (5/31; 16%).
Conclusion: In this retrospective study, infants receiving late intervention required shunt insertion
signi cantly more often than those treated early. A randomized prospective intervention study,
comparing early and late drainage, is required to further assess the role of earlier intervention.
Key words: Hydrocephalus, intraventricular haemorrhage, posthaemorrhagic ventricular dilata-
tion; preterm infants
LS de Vries, KE 04 123.1, Department of Neonatology, Wilhelmina Children’s Hospital, PO Box
85090, NL-3508AB Utrecht, The Netherlands (Fax. ‡31 30 2505 320, e-mail. l.devries@wkz.a-
zu.nl)
The prevalence of periventricular haemorrhage-intra- oids and to overall improvement in neonatal intensive
ventricular haemorrhage (PVH-IVH) in very low birth- care (2). Until recently this decrease did not coincide
weight (VLBW) infants has decreased considerably with a decrease in the prevalence of infantile hydro-
during the past decade (1). This can be attributed cephalus. The latest study from Fernell and Hagberg
especially to the increased antenatal use of corticoster- (3), however, did show a decline in the prevalence of
infantile hydrocephalus from 17 to 14 infants per 1000 were studied. Only those preterm infants with a
born at less than 32 wk gestation. In the majority of gestational age of 34 wk or below who had a large
cases in this age group, infantile hydrocephalus could be IVH, lling the lateral ventricle by > 50% causing acute
attributed to posthaemorrhagic ventricular dilatation ventricular dilatation, without any evidence of paren-
(PHVD). chymal involvement (grade III, according to Papile et
In the absence of associated parenchymal injury, al. (13)) were eligible for this study. Infants with
PHVD is the most serious complication of an IVH and is evidence of a unilateral parenchymal haemorrhage or
known to occur in about 35% of the infants with an cystic periventricular leukomalacia (PVL), diagnosed
IVH; the larger the initial haemorrhage, the greater the using cranial ultrasound, were excluded.
risk of developing PHVD. Among those who develop Cranial ultrasound was performed by the paediatric
PHVD, about 35% require some form of intervention radiologist and/or the attending neonatologist . Exam-
and a further 15% of those receiving intervention go on inations were carried out regularly to diagnose the
to need insertion of a ventriculo-peritoneal (VP) shunt. maximum extent of the haemorrhage, to establish the
Early insertion of a VP shunt is not without complica- development of the PHVD and to follow the course of
tions, with infection and dysfunction being especially the PHVD and the effect of any intervention. The
common (4–6). The children usually remain shunt ventricular width was measured in the coronal view at
dependent and will require several shunt revisions the level of the foramen of Monro according to Levene
during early childhood. Neurodevelopmental outcome (12). This measurement was available in all centres and,
in infants with infantile hydrocephalus is reported as depending on the policy of the unit, was prospectively
being very poor, with about 75% of the children or retrospectively plotted in the graph. Special attention
developing cerebral palsy (CP) and 50% learning was paid to crossing the p 97 ‡ 4 mm line. This line
disabilities and a smaller percentage affected by represents ‡2SD above the p 97 for the ventricular
epilepsy and/or cerebral visual impairment (7, 8). width according to Levene (12). Furthermore, it was
Although the best way to prevent infantile hydro- recorded whether intervention was initiated before or
cephalus is prevention of PVH-IVH, optimal manage- after crossing the p 97 ‡ 4 mm line. It was also recorded
ment of PHVD is also important and this has been whether the p 97 ‡ 4 mm line was still crossed in
attempted many times over the years using different infants whose intervention was started before the p
methods of intervention. As the mechanism of PHVD is 97 ‡ 4 mm line had been exceeded.
related to blockage of cerebrospinal uid (CSF) The mode of intervention was recorded and varied
channels by small blood clots, early removal of bloody from lumbar punctures, ventricular taps (uncommon),
CSF by lumbar or even ventricular taps has been placement of a subcutaneous reservoir and insertion of a
performed in small studies and a large multicentre VP shunt. In most centres a volume of 10 ml/kg was
study, but without any bene cial effect (8–10). Intra- allowed to drain during a lumbar or ventricular tap, but
ventricular administration of brinolytic agents has also the volume aimed for was not always achieved. The
been used, but a recent review of 62 cases reported in need for a repeat LP was based on measurement of the
the literature was unable to show a positive effect, with VI and/or the shape of the ventricles. Owing to the
a need for shunt insertion varying from 11 to 100% (11). retrospective nature of the study, the exact amount of
In the majority of the studies mentioned above, the uid drained in each intervention, as well as the
infants were enrolled once the ventricular width pressure measured, was not always available.
measurement was more than 4 mm above the 97th
percentile for age (12). Outcome measures
The aim of the present retrospective multicentre
The primary endpoints included (i) shunt placement
study was to investigate whether there was a difference
before discharge home and before the corrected age of
in the timing and mode of treatment of PHVD in The
1 y and (ii) neurodevelopmental outcome at 2 y of age.
Netherlands and, if so, whether this was associated with
Owing to the limitations of a retrospective study, only
a difference in the percentage of children requiring
the presence or absence of a moderate disability
insertion of a VP shunt and whether this had an effect on
(including spastic diplegia, hemiplegia, moderate learn-
neurodevelopmental outcome.
ing disabilities (DQ 50–69)) or severe disability
(including quadriplegia, blindness, deafness, uncon-
trolled epilepsy, severe learning disability (DQ <50
Patients and methods and multiple disabilities) could be established.
The study, initiated by the Dutch Working Group of
Neonatal Neurology, included neonatologists and pae- Statistical analysis
diatric neurologists with a special interest in neonatal Statistical analysis was done using w2, Mann-Whitney
neurology and working in any of the 10 Dutch regional and Kruskal Wallis tests, using SPSS for Windows 7.5.
intensive care units. In 5 of the 10 units, the data of A p-value below 0.05 was considered signi cant.
infants born between January 1992 and December 1996 Logistic regression analysis was used to relate timing
214 LS de Vries et al. ACTA PÆDIATR 91 (2002)
Results
Ninety- ve infants with grade III IVH and a VI >p 97
were eligible for the study. Thirty- ve of the infants had
a gestational age (GA) of 27 wk or below and 60 a GA
of 28–34 wk.
Echolucencies in the brain parenchyma were not
detected by cranial ultrasonography in any of the Fig. 1. Flow chart for the 31 children who had “early intervention ”.
infants.
Table 1. Neurodevelopmenta l outcome at 24 mo of the 95 infants with posthaemorrhagi c ventricula r dilatation (PHVD).
trial for acetazolamide and furosemide, almost half of especially in those without apparent parenchymal injury
the infants had parenchymal lesions before trial entry, (22).
but no separate outcome data are given for the children Adverse effects of PHVD, without the symptoms
without parenchymal injury (15). mentioned above, have been shown using various
The best timing for intervention of PHVD is still a techniques in clinical studies. A delay in latency of
matter of debate (16). In the recent multicentre somatosensory and visual evoked potentials was ob-
randomized acetazolamide and furosemide trial (15), served during progressive PHVD and was found to
it was deemed advisable to delay the removal of CSF normalize following shunt insertion (23). A change in
until either head growth exceeded twice the normal rate the peak systolic velocity and even an absent or
for 2 weeks or the infant showed clinical symptoms or reversed diastolic velocity have been shown during
signs of raised intracranial pressure. The advice stems progressive PHVD (24) as was cerebral blood ow
from the lack of positive effect of early taps, as shown in measured using PET following a LP (25). An improve-
the ventriculomegaly trial (8). In both the ventriculo- ment in oxidation of cytochrome aa3 was shown using
megaly trial and the acetazolamide trial, the p near infrared spectroscopy (NIRS), re ecting improve-
97 ‡ 4 mm line has been taken as the point of entry ment in cellular oxygenation of brain tissue (26), and,
for the study. One cannot, however, exclude that nally, raised CSF hypoxanthine values have also been
intervention based on the value of the VI and started reported (27). In animal studies, a decrease in white
after the p 97 ‡ 4 mm has been crossed is too late, i.e. mater perfusion was especially noted in long-standing
that one has already reached the “point of no return”. hydrocephalus (28, 29). A recent study, using magnetic
Little data is available on earlier intervention, based resonance spectroscopy, showed progressive tissue
on the rate of progression of the ventricular width and injury in rats that were only treated at a late stage of
the change in shape of the lateral ventricle. The fact that their infantile hydrocephalus (30).
the change in shape, “the depth” of the lateral ventricle, In view of the data obtained in this retrospective
as measured in the midcoronal view, changes before the study, a prospective randomized multicentre study is
VI increases was already pointed out by Sauerbrei et al. presently being designed to compare early (<p
in 1981 (17). They identi ed a normal depth as 1–3 mm 97 ‡ 4 mm) and late (¶p 97 ‡ 4 mm) intervention of
and a depth ¶5mm as being increased. Recently, Davies PHVD. Once progression in ventricular size is noted,
et al. reported similar measurements (18). Even when only a few lumbar taps will be allowed in both groups,
treatment is started early, lumbar punctures are often before inserting a subcutaneous reservoir, to enable the
ineffective, as the amount of CSF that can be drained caretakers to drain the amount of CSF that was aimed
per tap does not often reach the desired 10 ml/kg. for. We hope that this study will resolve the issue of the
Ventricular taps are an alternative, but needle tracks do best time for intervention with the ultimate aim of
occur and can lead to porencephalic cysts when multiple reducing the number of shunts and the number of infants
tracks coalesce. Several recent publications have surviving with disabilities.
advocated the use of an external drainage system or a
subcutaneous access device (19–21). The external drain Acknowledgements.—We thank M. Jonkers and P. Rosias for their help in
has a poor reputation with regard to infection, but this is extracting the data from the notes and also the paediatric neurosurgeon s in
the ve centres for performing the surgical procedures . We also thank C.
no longer the case with careful tunnelling and im- Uiterwaal for advice regarding the statistics and R. Gooskens, F. van Bel
plementation under strict sterile conditions provided and J. S. H. Vles for their fruitful discussions.
that the system is changed every 2–3 wk (19).
Berger et al. (19) studied 37 infants, 11 of whom did
not require permanent shunts. Two infants developed
ventriculitis (5.4%). The mean duration of drainage was References
23 days. 1. Philip AGS, Allan WC, Tito AM, Wheeler LR. Intraventricula r
A subcutaneous reservoir was used in a number of haemorrhage in preterm infants: declining incidenc e in the
our infants, usually following the performance of 1980s. Pediatrics 1989; 84: 797–801
2. Shankaran S, Bauer CR, Bain R, Wright LL, Zachary J. Prenatal
several lumbar taps. The risk of infection was consider- and perinatal risk and protectiv e factors for neonatal intracrania l
able (24%), with coagulase-negative staphylococci haemorrhage . National Institute of Child Health and Human
being the organism in all but two cases. The risk of Development . Arch Paediatr Adolesc Med 1996; 150: 491–7
infection in our own unit (WKZ) has been reduced to 3. Fernell E, Hagberg G. Infantile hydrocephalus : declining
12%, including the years 1996–1999, and was 15% in prevalenc e in preterm infants. Acta Paediatr 1998; 87: 392–6
4. Dykes FD, Dunbar B, Lazarra A, Ahmann PA. Posthaemorrhagi c
one of the other participating units (6). The largest study hydrocephalu s in high risk infants: natural history, management
using subcutaneous reservoirs showed good results as and long term outcome. J Pediatr 1989; 114: 611–8
far as wound problems, blockage and infection were 5. Lin J-P, Goh W, Brown J, Steers AJ. Neurologica l outcome
concerned, but a high percentage of infants (88%) in following neonatal post-haemorrhagi c hydrocephalus : the effect
of maximum raised intracrania l pressure and ventriculoperito -
this study eventually required a shunt (21). Direct neal shunting. Child Nerv Syst 1992; 8: 190–7
placement of a reservoir without performing LPs was 6. Bruinsma N, Stobberingh EE, Herpers MJ, Vles JS, Weber BJ,
recently advocated to give more effective intervention, Gavilanes DA. Subcutaneous ventricula r catheter reservoir and
ACTA PÆDIATR 91 (2002) Late treatment of posthaemorrhagi c ventricula r dilatation 217
ventriculoperitonea l drain-relate d infection s in preterm infants 20. Gaskill SJ, Marlin AE, Rivera S. The subcutaneou s ventricula r
and young children. Clin Microbiol Infect 2000; 6: 202–6 reservoir : an effective treatment for posthaemorrhagi c hydro-
7. Fernell E, Hagberg G, Hagberg B. Infantile hydrocephalus : an cephalus. Child’s Nerv Syst 1988; 4: 291–5
indicator of enhance d survival. Arch Dis Child 1994; 70: F123–8 21. Hudgins RJ, Boydston WR, Gilreath CL. Treatment of post-
8. Ventriculomegal y Trial Group 1990. Randomised trial of early hemorrhagic hydrocephalu s in the preterm infant with a
tapping in neonatal posthaemorrhagi c ventricular dilatation. ventricula r access device. Pediatr Neurosurg 1998; 29: 309–13
Arch Dis Child 1990; 65: 3–10 22. Shankaran S, Baker JD, Becker C, Canady A, Delaney-Black V.
9. Anwar M, Kadam S, Hiatt IM, Hegyi T. Serial lumbar punctures Aggressive management of posthaemorrhagi c ventriculomegal y
in preventio n of posthaemorrhagi c hydrocephalu s in preterm may limit morbidity in VLBW infants with grade III ICH. Ped
infants. J Pediatr 1985; 107: 446–9 Res 2000; 47: 323A
10. Mantovani JF, Pasternak JF, Mathew OP, Allan WC, Mills MT, 23. de Vries LS, Pierrat V, Minami T, Smet M, Casaer P. The role of
Casper J, et al. Failure of daily lumbar puncture s to prevent somatosensor y evoked response s in infants with rapidly pro-
neonatal post haemorrhagi c hydrocephalus . Child Nerv Syst gressive ventricular dilatation . Neuropediatric s 1990; 21: 136–9
1997; 13: 73–6 24. Kempley ST, Gamsu HR. Changes in cerebral artery blood ow
11. Haines SJ, Lapointe M. Fibrinolytic agents in the management of velocity after intermitten t cerebrospina l uid drainage . Arch Dis
posthaemorrhagi c hydrocephalu s in preterm infants: the evi- Child 1993; 69: 74–6
dence. Childs Nerv Syst 1999; 15: 226–34 25. Perlman J, Herscovitc h P, Tarby T, Kreusser KL, Raichle ME,
12. Levene MI. Measurement of the growth of the lateral ventricle in Volpe JJ. The effect of lumbar puncture on regional cerebral
preterm infants with real-time ultrasound . Arch Dis Child 1981; blood ow as determined by positron emission tomography in
56: 905–10 neonatal posthemorrhagi c hydrocephalus . Ann Neurol 1985; 18:
13. Papile L, Burstein J, Burstein R, Kof er H. Incidenc e and 379–80
evaluatio n of subependyma l haemorrhage : a study of children 26. Du Plessis A, Miles K, Tsuji HN, Volpe JJ. Near infrared
with a birthweight less than 1500 g. J Pediatr 1978; 92: 529–34 spectroscop y (NIRS) shows pronounce d effects of CSF removal
14. Cooke RWI. Determinants of major handicap in post-haemor - on cerebral haemodynamic s in infantile hydrocephalus . Pediatr
rhagic hydrocephalus . Arch Dis Child 1987; 62: 504–17 Res 1995; 37: 377A
15. Internationa l PHVD drug trial group. Internationa l randomised 27. Bejar R, Saugstad OD, James H, Gluck L Increase d hypox-
controlle d trial of acetazolamid e and furosemide in posthaemor - anthine levels in cerebrospina l uid of infants with hydrocepha -
rhagic ventricular dilatation in infancy. Lancet 1998; 352: 433– lus. J Pediatr 1983; 103: 44–8
40 28. White RP, Kef er CW, Bada HS. Eicosanoid levels in CSF of
16. Du Plessis AJ. Posthemorrhagi c hydrocephalu s and brain injury premature infants with posthemorrhagi c hydrocephalus . Am J
in the preterm infant: dilemmas in diagnosi s and management. Med Sci 1990; 299: 230
Semin Pediatr Neurol 1998; 5: 161–79 29. Weller RO, Schulman K. Infantile hydrocephalus : clinical,
17. Sauerbrei EE, Digney M, Harrison PB, Cooperberg PL. Ultra- histologica l and ultrastructura l study of brain damage. J
sonic evaluatio n of neonatal intracrania l hemorrhag e and its Neurosurg 1972; 36: 255–65
complications . Radiology 1981; 139: 677–85 30. Jones HC, Harris NG, Rocca JR, Andersohn RW. Progressive
18. Davies MW, Swaminathan M, Chuang SL, Betheras FR. tissue injury in infantile hydrocephalu s and prevention /reversal
Reference ranges for the linear dimensions of the intracrania l with shunt treatment. Neurol Res 2000; 22: 89–96
ventricle s in preterm neonates. Arch Dis Child FetalNeonatal Ed
2000; 82: F218–23
19. Berger A, Weninger M, Reinprecht A, Haschke N, Kohlhauser C,
Pollak A. Long-term experience with subcutaneousl y tunneled
external ventricula r drainage in preterm infants. Child’s Nerv Received March 26, 2001; revision received Oct. 12, 2001; accepted
Syst 2000; 16: 103–9 Oct. 22, 2001