You are on page 1of 16

Influence of the shape of intracellular

potentials on the morphology of single-fiber


extracellular potentials in human muscle
fibers

Javier Rodriguez-Falces, Javier Navallas,


Luis Gila, Armando Malanda & Nonna
Alexandrovna Dimitrova

Medical & Biological Engineering &


Computing

ISSN 0140-0118

Med Biol Eng Comput


DOI 10.1007/s11517-012-0879-7

1 23
Your article is protected by copyright and all
rights are held exclusively by International
Federation for Medical and Biological
Engineering. This e-offprint is for personal
use only and shall not be self-archived in
electronic repositories. If you wish to self-
archive your work, please use the accepted
author’s version for posting to your own
website or your institution’s repository. You
may further deposit the accepted author’s
version on a funder’s repository at a funder’s
request, provided it is not made publicly
available until 12 months after publication.

1 23
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput
DOI 10.1007/s11517-012-0879-7

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Influence of the shape of intracellular potentials


on the morphology of single-fiber extracellular
potentials in human muscle fibers
Javier Rodriguez-Falces • Javier Navallas •

Luis Gila • Armando Malanda •


Nonna Alexandrovna Dimitrova

Received: 18 December 2011 / Accepted: 24 February 2012


Ó International Federation for Medical and Biological Engineering 2012

Abstract Attention of the investigators is usually pointed Keywords Intracellular action potential  IAP spike
to the peak-to-peak characteristics of single-fiber action duration  SFAP third phase  SFAP morphology
potentials (SFAPs) that are mainly determined by the
depolarizing phase of the intracellular action potential
(IAP). However, the final portion of the SFAP has often 1 Introduction
specific shape that has to be related to peculiarities of the
repolarization phase of IAP and the duration of its spike. A Since the advent of single-fiber electromyography
novel piecewise SFAP model is proposed to achieve (SFEMG), a number of studies have analyzed the mor-
greater insight into the nature of declining portion of the phological aspects of experimental single muscle fiber
negative phase and of the third phase of SFAP. It was potentials (SFAPs) in human fibers [11, 12, 35, 36]. Greater
found that the SFAP third phase is essentially determined insight into the SFAP generation was obtained from theo-
by the specific profile of the transition of the IAP falling retical models that permits calculating the SFAP in terms of
phase toward the resting voltage, whereas the SFAP the volume conductor properties, position of the recording
declining negative phase is more dependent upon the width site with respect to the active fiber, and the intracellular
of the corresponding IAP spike. We tentatively suggest that action potential (IAP) [2, 4, 7, 17, 26, 29, 34]. The most
the duration of the spike of human IAPs should be over critical aspect of SFAP formulations is the IAP description
approximately 0.75 ms. chosen, since, at short fiber-to-electrode (radial) distances,
SFAP characteristics are essentially determined by the IAP
waveform and duration [6, 8, 11, 29, 34].
The accuracy of SFAP models is predominantly related to
their ability to generate potentials as similar as possible to
J. Rodriguez-Falces  J. Navallas  A. Malanda
Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Public experimental recordings. The majority of studies evaluate
University of Navarra, 31006 Pamplona, Spain the resemblance between measured and computed SFAPs by
analyzing only the features of the SFAP principally depen-
Present Address:
dent upon the IAP depolarization phase: peak values of the
J. Rodriguez-Falces (&)
Universidad Pública de Navarra D.I.E.E, Campus de Arrosadı́a first two phases, peak-to-peak duration, and peak-to-peak
s/n, 31006 Pamplona, Spain voltage [11, 14, 31, 37]. However, limited knowledge still
e-mail: javier.rodriguez@unavarra.es; exists about the SFAP characteristics more dependent upon
javier.rodriguez.falces@gmail.com
the IAP repolarization phase: namely, the time course of the
L. Gila declining negative phase of the SFAP and its third phase [11].
Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Virgen del Camino The reason for this is that the last portion of the SFAP has
Hospital, 31008 Pamplona, Spain longer duration and thus much lower frequency content than
the SFAP rising phase and therefore it is markedly more
N. A. Dimitrova
Institute of Biophysics and Biomedical Engineering, Bulgarian affected by slow components, such as potentials from the
Academy of Sciences, 1113 Sofia, Bulgaria cannula or from distant fibers, or by filter settings.

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

Inability to determine when (and to what extent) the As an example, computed SFAPs exhibit a well-defined
terminal portion of the SFAP is contaminated by nearby third phase, whereas SFAPs measured from humans appear
fibers or by technical factors [11] partially explains the either biphasic (Fig. 1a, b) [11] or present a rather small
relative uncertainty about the character of the repolariza- and prolonged third phase (Fig. 1c, d). Another remarkable
tion phase of the IAP in human muscle fibers. An imme- morphological feature that is frequently observed in human
diate consequence of this incertitude is that, in the last SFAPs is an abrupt change in the slope of the declining
decades, authors have used different descriptions for the negative phase (Fig. 1c, d). Such a feature, hereafter
IAP with large discrepancies in the duration of the spike. referred to as a slope-discontinuity point (S-D point), is not
The IAP spike duration can be estimated as the depolar- observed in the SFAPs simulated using Nandedkar and
ization–repolarization time (DRT) [32]. The well-known Stålberg’s model [26].
IAP analytical expression defined by Rosenfalck [34] had a Traditionally, authors have investigated how alterations
spike with a DRT of *1.0 ms (Fig. 3 of the cited paper). in the asymmetry and duration of the IAP are translated into
The IAP approximation used by Andreassen and Rosen- variations of the SFAP shape [11, 14, 31, 37]. However,
falck [4] was based on the in vitro human IAP recorded by when changing the characteristics of the IAP, the authors did
Ludin [23], which had a DRT of *0.75 ms. In an attempt not have independent control over its de- and repolarization
to accommodate the characteristics of simulated SFAPs to phases, which limits their capability to interpret correctly the
those of real recordings, Nandedkar and Stålberg [26] changes in the shape of the resulting SFAP. In the present
modified Rosenfalck’s IAP model by dividing the time paper, we have proposed an SFAP model that allows for
scale by two, and therefore obtaining an IAP with a DRT of independent calculation of the two hypothetical potentials
*0.50 ms. that would arise from de- and repolarization phases of the
Subsequent authors who used the Nandedkar and Stål- IAP. The ultimate objective of the present study is to use this
berg IAP’s description [10, 13, 25] did not perceive that piecewise SFAP description to investigate the effects of
certain morphological aspects of SFAPs simulated with this changes in the IAP falling phase (and IAP spike duration) on
particular IAP were not found in experimental potentials. the morphological characteristics of the last portion of the

Fig. 1 Superimposed 0.5


representations of four sets of 0.6 (a) (b)
consecutive SFAPs recorded
from the tibialis anterior muscle 0.4
using a single-fiber electrode.
0.2
Voltage (mV)

a, b Representative examples of
SFAPs with a biphasic shape.
0
c, d Representative examples of 0
SFAPs with an abrupt change in -0.2
the slope of the descending part
of the negative phase (i.e., the -0.4
slope-discontinuity point)
-0.6

-0.8 -0.5
0.5 1 1.5 2 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

1.5
(c) 0.8 (d)

1 0.6 S-D point


S-D point
Voltage (mV)

0.4
0.5
0.2

0
0

-0.5 -0.2

-0.4
0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
Time (ms) Time (ms)

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

SFAP and the way these characteristics change with the v  ðz0  vtÞ
fiber-to-electrode (radial) distance. IR(r; vtÞ ¼
½ðz0  vtÞ2 þ Kan  r 2 3=2
We hypothesize that the characteristics of the SFAP v  ðz0 þ vtÞ
third phase are directly related to the character of the þ ð2Þ
½ðz0 þ vtÞ2 þ Kan  r 2 3=2
transition of the IAP falling phase toward the resting
voltage. In addition, taking as a reference data from Parameters z0, Kan, v, and r were referred to as IR
experimental SFAPs, we raise the hypothesis that for an variables and by default their values were set to
S-D point to appear in the SFAP declining negative phase, z0 = 20 mm, Kan = 5 [4, 16, 34], v = 3.5 m/s [26, 27],
an IAP with sufficiently long spike duration is necessary. and r = 0.15 mm. A muscle fiber with a length of 90 mm
and a right semi-length of 40 mm were considered. The
time step (sampling interval) used in the simulations was
2 Methods 10 ls (100 kHz).

2.1 Dimitrov and Dimitrova SFAP convolutional 2.2 Description of three IAP models
model
Three different IAP models were used for the simulations, all
Simulations of SFAPs were performed using the model of them based on the IAP analytical expression proposed by
proposed by Dimitrov and Dimitrova (D–D) [7]. In this Dimitrov and Dimitrova [7]. These IAP descriptions were
model, the fiber is considered as a time-shift invariant convenient for our study, because they allowed the de- and
system, and SFAPs can be expressed as a convolution of repolarization phases to change independently. Moreover,
the input signal and impulse response (IR) of the corre- they permitted an independent control of different portions
sponding system: of the IAP falling phase, thereby enhancing the flexibility to
change the profile of this phase. The type-I IAP model had a
oIAPðtÞ
SFAP(tÞ ¼ Can   IR(tÞ ð1Þ time course divided into four portions: the rising phase, the
ot rapidly falling phase, the transition phase and the slowly
The coefficient of proportionality, Can, is defined in [7]. falling phase (i.e., the after-potential) (Fig. 2a). The char-
The input signal is the first temporal derivative of the IAP, acter of the rising (depolarization) phase is determined by
qIAP(t)/qt. The impulse response (2) comprised the three coefficients: A1, A2, and A3 (3):
anatomical [semi-lengths of the fiber (L1, L2 in mm)] and
IAPdep ðtÞ ¼ A1  tA2 t  eA3 t ; 0  t  Tdep ð3Þ
physiological [anisotropy ratio (Kan), propagation velocity
(v, in mm/ms)] properties of the fiber, as well as the The duration of the rising phase can be calculated as
detection conditions [radial distance (r, in mm), and Tdep = A2/A3. The point of steepest rise (d1) along this
longitudinal distance of the electrode relative to the phase occurs at Td1 , and is approximately Tdep/2 (Fig. 2a).
endplate (z0, in mm)]. Equation 2 is an approximation of The time course of the repolarization (falling) phase of
the IR for the finite-length fiber case. the IAP is determined by three equations and three

Type-I IAP Type-II IAP Type-III IAP


100 100 100
Rising (a) Rising (b) Rising (c)
Rapidly Rapidly Rapidly
80 falling 80 falling 80 falling
Voltage (mV)

60 60 60
d1 d2 d2 d2

40 Transition 40 40
After-potential
Transition
Transition
20 Vspl 20 20
Td1 Tdep Td2 Tspl
0 0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Time (ms) Time (ms) Time (ms)

Fig. 2 a Time course of the type-I IAP model divided into four divided intro three portions. The curvature of the transition phase of
portions. Tdep is the duration of the IAP rising phase. d1 and d2 are the the type-II IAP is smaller than that of the type-I IAP and the type-III
points of steepest rise and decay, respectively, along the IAP spike. IAP has the transition with the smallest curvature
b, c Time courses of the type-II and type-III IAP models, respectively,

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

parameters, namely Tspl, Vspl, and C1ap. The rapidly falling the after-potential, greater control of the transition of the
phase was approximated by a cubic spline function IAP falling phase toward a constant voltage value was
described in (4) obtained (see Fig. 2b, c). It should be mentioned that the
2  profile of type-I IAP approximated to that recorded by
t3 t
IAPFalling ðtÞ ¼ B1   ðTspl þ Tdep Þ  þ Tspl  Tdep  t Hanson [19] and Radicheva et al. [30], and the shape of
3 2
type-II IAP approached to that recorded by Wallinga et al.
Tdep  t  Td2 ð4Þ [39] or that simulated by Fortune and Lowery [15] on the
where basis of physiologic-realistic parameters. However, the
type-III IAP model exhibited a falling phase with a more
6  ð100  Tspl Þ gradual transition toward a constant voltage that was not
B1 ¼ ð5Þ
ðTspl  Tdep Þ3 found to correspond to any previously recorded IAP.
Tspl and Vspl are the coordinates of the spline function end
2.3 Definition of the duration of the IAP spike
on the time and potential axis, respectively (Fig. 2a). The
point of steepest decay (d2) of the falling phase occurs at
We defined the duration of the IAP spike or the depolar-
Td2 (Fig. 2), and can be calculated as
ization-to-repolarization time (DRT) as the time interval
ðTspl  Tdep Þ between the centers of mass of the positive (CM1) and
Td2 ¼ Tdep þ ð6Þ
2 negative (CM2) phases of the IAP first temporal derivative
The transition phase and after-potential phase were (Fig. 3b), as established in [32].
defined using differential equations as follows As shown in [32], because of the special architecture of
the D–D IAP, the point of steepest rise of the IAP depo-
dIAPTransition ðtÞ t  Td 2 larization phase (point d1, Fig. 3a) lies approximately at the
¼ 1  C1ap   IAPTransition ðtÞ
dt Tspl  Td2 center of mass of the positive phase of the IAP first
Td2  t  Tspl derivative. Similarly, the point of steepest decay of the IAP
ð7Þ repolarization phase (point d2, Fig. 3a) nearly coincides
with the center of mass of the negative phase of the IAP
dIAPAfter ðtÞ
¼ 0:9  IAPAfter ðtÞ Tspl  t  Tend ð8Þ first derivative. Thus, for the particular case of the D–D
dt
IAP, the DRT of the spike can be calculated approximately
where C1ap was a coefficient whose value was within the as Td2  Td1 . In addition, for the D–D IAP, points d1 and d2
range 0.001 and 0.5, depending on the IAP shape simulated. lie approximately at 50% of the IAP amplitude in the
The type-II and type-III IAP models were the same as depolarization and repolarization phases, respectively.
the type-I model but without the fourth phase. By removing From (6), it can be seen that Td2  Td1 nearly equals Tspl/2.

De-and repolarization phases Phases of the IAP first De-and repolarization components
of the IAP derivative of the SFAP
1
100 Depolarization Repolarization
phase
(a) 600
(b) 0.8 Depolarization SFAP (c)
phase EDep component
80 0.6
~ DRT 400
Voltage (mV)

Voltage (mV)

0.4
(mV / ms)

60 (0.5 ms)
CM1
d2 0.2
d1 DRT
200
40 0

20 0 -0.2

-0.4
CM2 Repolarization
0 ERep NPD
Td1 Tdep Td2 Tspl -200 -0.6 component
(0.5 ms)
-20 -0.8
0 0.5 1 0 0.5 1 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5
Time (ms) Time (ms) Time (ms)

Fig. 3 a Time course of type-I IAP model in which the de- and (DRT) is the time separation between the centers of mass of Edep
repolarization phases are represented using lines with open and closed (CM1) and ERep (CM2). c Depolarization and repolarization compo-
circles, respectively. The IAP has been truncated for the sake of nents of the SFAP that result from the convolution of Edep and ERep,
clarity. b Time course of the IAP first derivative, with two phases, respectively, and the system impulse response. The duration of the
Edep and ERep, corresponding to the de- and repolarization phases of negative phase (NPD) is also indicated (color figure online)
the IAP, respectively. The depolarization-to-repolarization time

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

2.4 Definition of the depolarization and repolarization A3 = 14. For the three IAP models, the values of coeffi-
components of the SFAP cient Tspl used to synthesize the IAPs with DRTs of 0.5,
0.75 and 1.0 ms were 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 ms, respectively. The
To get more insight into the SFAP generation, let us con- values of coefficient Vspl utilized to generate the same IAPs
sider the two hypothetical potentials that would result from were 25, 20, and 15, respectively. The coefficient C1ap was
the propagation of the de- and repolarization phases of the 0.01 for the type-I and type-II IAP, whereas it was 0.1 for
IAP, separately, along the fiber (Fig. 3a). These potentials type-III IAP. With the exception of radial distance, all other
were referred to as the de- and repolarization components impulse response variables (z0, Kan, and v) were fixed to their
of the SFAP (Fig. 3c). These components were obtained by default values. For the first two sets of simulations, de- and
splitting the time course of the IAP first derivative into the repolarization components of SFAP associated with the
two portions resulting from the de- and repolarization corresponding phases of IAPs were also calculated.
phases of the IAP [EDep and ERep shown in (9) and (10), The first group of simulations investigated the effect of a
respectively] and convolving each of these portions, sep- slowing of the IAP falling phase on the third phase of the
arately, with the system impulse response (2). resulting SFAP for two different radial distances. To do
 oIAPðtÞ this, for each IAP model, we generated three IAPs with
EDep ðtÞ ¼ ot 0  t  Tdep ð9Þ different DRT values (0.50, 0.75, and 1.0 ms) and obtained
0 Tdep \t  20 ms
 the corresponding SFAPs at r = 0.075 and 0.275 mm.
0 0  t  Tdep The second set of simulations studied the influence of
ERep ðtÞ ¼ oIAPðtÞ ð10Þ
ot Tdep \t  20 ms the IAP falling phase (and spike duration) on the declining
negative phase of the SFAP for three different radial dis-
In Fig. 3c, the SFAP components arising from the IAP tances. This was done by generating two type-I IAPs, one
de- and repolarization phases of Fig. 3a are represented short (DRT = 0.5 ms) and one long (DRT = 1.0 ms), and
using lines with red, open and blue, closed circles, calculating the corresponding SFAPs and de- and repolar-
respectively. Due to the linearity of the convolution ization components at r = 0.075, 0.175, and 0.275 mm.
operation, summing both components provided the final These set of simulations were not replicated for type-II and
SFAP, drawn with solid line in Fig. 3c. Note that, whereas -III IAPs
the SFAP has a triphasic shape, the de- and repolarization The third group of simulations analyzed how the vari-
components are biphasic. Note also that the first zero ation of the SFAP morphology with radial distance was
crossing of the SFAP approximately coincides with that of influenced by the spike duration of the IAP. To do this, for
the depolarization component, while the second zero each IAP model, we simulated three series of SFAPs, each
crossing of the SFAP is practically the same as that of of them with a different value of IAP DRT, namely 0.5,
the repolarization component, this being true only for short 0.75, and 1.0 ms. Each series comprised seven potentials
radial distances (less than *0.25 mm). Since the zero generated at different radial distances (r was increased
crossings of de- and repolarization components are from 0.10 to 0.28 in steps of 0.03 mm). We shall refer to
determined by the points of steepest rise and decay of the each of these series as r-varying SFAP series.
IAP time course, respectively, the duration of the negative
phase of the SFAP (NPD) approximately equals the DRT
of the corresponding IAP [32]. 3 Results

2.5 Simulation details 3.1 Effect of changes in the IAP falling phase
on the SFAP third phase for different
Three sets of simulations were carried out to analyze how radial distances
changes in the profile of the IAP falling phase (and in the
IAP spike duration) affected the morphological character- Irrespective of the radial distance and IAP typology,
istics of an SFAP and the way these characteristics varied broadening of the IAP spike (first column of Figs. 4, 5)
with radial distance. In all cases, variation of the IAP brought about similar changes in the corresponding SFAP
duration was achieved by changing the character of the repolarization component (blue curves in the second col-
falling phase: the rising phase was left unchanged. This umn of Figs. 4, 5), namely: (1) a reduction in amplitude,
simplified the study and resulted in no loss of generality, as (2) an increase in the overall duration, (3) a smoother
the Tdep measured in IAPs of normal muscle fibers was (slower) time course, and (4) a displacement of the zero
confined within the range 0.20–0.35 ms [23, 39]. The crossing to the right. The specific profile of the IAP
coefficient values used to synthesize the rising phase of the falling phase also influenced the characteristics of the
three IAP models were A1 = 25 9 107, A2 = 4.5, and repolarization component. An IAP with a falling phase

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

returning abruptly toward the resting potential level, as component. Characteristics of these components
the type-I IAPs of Fig. 4a, gave rise to a large and sharp depended on the distance from the fiber to the recording
repolarization component (blue lines in Fig. 4b). On the point.
contrary, an IAP with a falling phase decreasing more At very short radial distances (*0.075 mm), the depo-
gradually toward the resting value, as the type-III IAPs larization component (red curves in the second column of
shown in Fig. 4g, led to a smaller and more prolonged Fig. 4), with a sharp shape and a rapid return toward the
repolarization component. baseline, hardly overlapped with the positive phase of the
The third phase of the SFAP was the result of adding repolarization component (blue curves in the same graphs)
the declining negative phase of the depolarization and, consequently, its contribution to the SFAP third phase
component and the positive phase of the repolarization was practically zero. This means that, at such short radial

De-and repolarization components


Set of type-I IAPs with different DRT at r = 0.075 mm SFAPs at r = 0.075 mm
100
(a) 1.5 (b) 1.5
(c)
80 1
1
Voltage (mV)

0.5
0.5
60
0
0
40 -0.5 -0.5
-1 -1
20
-1.5 -1.5
0
0 1 2 3 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5

Set of type-II IAPs with different DRT


100
(d) 1.5 (e) 1.5
(f)
80 1
1
Voltage (mV)

· 0.5 0.5
60
0 0
40 -0.5 -0.5
-1 -1
20
-1.5 -1.5
0
0 1 2 3 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5

Set of type-III IAPs with different DRT


100
(g) 1.5 (h) 1.5 (i)
80 1
1
Voltage (mV)

· 0.5 0.5
60
0 0
40 -0.5 -0.5
-1 -1
20
-1.5 -1.5
0
0 1 2 3 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5
Time (ms) Time (ms) Time (ms)

Fig. 4 First row simulation of the effects of changes in the IAP spike distance of 0.075 mm. The IAP profiles utilized correspond to type-I
width (a) on the depolarization component (line with red, open IAP. Second and third rows the same as in the first row but using the
circles) and repolarization component (line with blue, closed circles) type-II and type-III IAPs, respectively. The IAP time courses in a, d,
of the SFAP (b), and on the third phase of the SFAP (c) at a radial and g have been truncated for the sake of clarity (color figure online)

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

De-and repolarization components SFAPs at r = 0.275 mm


Set of type-I IAPs with different DRT at r = 0.275 mm
100 0.4
(a) (b) (c)
0.2 0.3
80
Voltage (mV)

0.1 0.2
60
0.1
0
40 0
-0.1
-0.1
20
-0.2
-0.2
0
0 1 2 3 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5

Set of type-II IAPs with different DRT


100 0.4
(d) (e) (f)
0.2
0.3
80
Voltage (mV)

· 0.1 0.2
60
0.1
0
40 0
-0.1
-0.1
20
-0.2
-0.2
0
0 1 2 3 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5

Set of type-III IAPs with different DRT


100 0.4
(g) (h) (i)
0.2
0.3
80
Voltage (mV)

· 0.1 0.2
60
0.1
0
40 0
-0.1
-0.1
20
-0.2
-0.2
0
0 1 2 3 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5
Time (ms) Time (ms) Time (ms)

Fig. 5 The same as Fig. 4, but for a radial distance of 0.275 mm (color figure online)

distances, characteristics of the SFAP third phase (graphs considerably the formation of the SFAP third phase. At
of the third column of Fig. 4) were essentially determined such distances, the declining negative phase of the depo-
by positive phase of the repolarization component, i.e., by larization component overlapped with the positive phase of
the character of the last portion of the IAP falling phase. the repolarization component. Specifically, the narrower
Thus, with the IAP rising phase unchanged, the longer and the IAP spike, the shorter was the distance between these
more gradual the transition of the IAP falling phase toward components and, therefore, the higher the degree of over-
a resting potential level, the smaller and more prolonged is lapping (also cancelation) between them. This means that
the SFAP third phase. the positive phase of the repolarization component will be
At higher radial distances (*0.275 mm), the SFAP comparatively more affected by the negative phase of the
depolarization component (red curves in the second col- depolarization component for shorter-spike IAPs than for
umn of Fig. 5) became wider and with a more gradual wider ones. As a result, for each SFAP set, the differences
return toward the baseline and, therefore, it affected among the amplitudes of the third phases at 0.275 mm

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

(third column of Fig. 5) are much lower than at 0.075 mm the repolarization one for a short interval (between 3.3 and
(third column of Fig. 4). 3.7 ms in Fig. 6b). As a result of such an overlapping, a
well-defined discontinuity appeared in the slope of the
3.2 Effect of changes in the IAP falling phase declining negative phase of the SFAP (i.e., an S-D point).
on the SFAP declining negative phase For the wide IAP, increasing the radial distance to
for different radial distances 0.175 mm (Fig. 6c), left the amplitude and duration char-
acteristics of the repolarization component relatively
In the first row of Fig. 6, we show a type-I IAP with a DRT unchanged, whereas the depolarization one became sig-
of 1.0 ms (Fig. 6a) and the corresponding de- and repo- nificantly smaller (Fig. 6c), smoother (slower), and with a
larization components and SFAP simulated at radial dis- more gradual decline toward the baseline. Note the great
tances of 0.075 mm (Fig. 6b), 0.175 mm (Fig. 6c), and differences between the radial declines of these compo-
0.275 mm (Fig. 6d). In the second row of this figure, we nents shown in Fig. 7b. Now, the declining phase of the
show the same diagrams as in the first one but for a type-I depolarization component approximately equaled the
IAP with a DRT of 0.5 ms. repolarization component during the interval 3.4–3.6 ms
Let us focus first on the SFAP components arising from and, as a result, the S-D point became less pronounced. A
the wide IAP (DRT = 1.0 ms, Fig. 6a) at 0.075 mm further increase of r up to 0.275 mm (Fig. 6d) permitted
(Fig. 6b). The falling phase of this wide IAP was markedly the descending portion of the depolarization component to
longer than its rising phase (i.e., its spike is strongly be larger than the repolarization component for the entire
asymmetric) and, as a result, the repolarization component duration of the potential, giving rise to an SFAP without
(blue curves) had much lower amplitude, slower profile, S-D point.
and more prolonged time course than the depolarization The interactions between the SFAP components result-
component (red curves), these differences being more ing from the narrow IAP were strikingly different from
pronounced at short radial distances, as can be seen in those of the wide IAP. The short spike of this IAP was also
Fig. 6b. At these short distances, the long temporal sepa- rather symmetric, which means that its rising and falling
ration between these components (*1.0 ms), together with phases had commensurate durations. As a result, the dif-
the abrupt manner in which the depolarization component ferences in amplitude and duration between their corre-
approached the baseline, made this component smaller than sponding de- and repolarization components were not as

SFAP, de-and repolarization SFAP, de-and repolarization SFAP, de-and repolarization


IAPs with DRT = 1.0 ms components at r = 0.075 mm components at r = 0.175 mm components at r = 0.275 mm
0.6 0.3
100 (a) 1.5 (b) (c) (d)
1 0.4 0.2
Voltage (mV)

80
0.5 0.2 0.1
60
0 0 0
40 -0.5
-0.2 -0.1
20 -1
-0.4 -0.2
-1.5
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5

IAPs with DRT = 0.5 ms


2 0.8 0.4
100 (e) (f) 0.6
(g) (h)
0.3
Voltage (mV)

80 1 0.4 0.2
60 0.2 0.1
0
0 0
40
-0.2 -0.1
-1
20
-0.4 -0.2
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5
Time (ms) Time (ms) Time (ms) Time (ms)

Fig. 6 First row simulation of a type-I IAP with a DRT of 1.0 ms same as in the first row but for a type-I IAP with a DRT of 0.5 ms.
(a) and its corresponding depolarization component (line with red, The horizontal straight line shown in b and c indicates the interval
open circles), repolarization component (line with blue, closed during which the repolarization component is greater than or equal to
circles), and SFAP (black solid line) at radial distances of the depolarization one, giving rise to the slope-discontinuity point
0.075 mm (b), 0.175 mm (c), and 0.275 mm (d). Second row the (color figure online)

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

Fig. 7 IAPs (left column) and Radial decline of SFAP components


IAPs with DRT = 1.0 ms 8
radial declines of the peak-to-
peak amplitude (right column) 100 (a) (b)
of the depolarization (red, open
circles) and repolarization 6
80
(blue, closed circles)

Voltage (mV)
components within the range
0.03–0.3 mm for a long (first 60
4
row) and a short (second row)
type-I IAP (color figure online) 40
DRT = 1.0 ms
2
20

0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0 0.1 0.2 0.3

IAPs with DRT = 0.5 ms Radial decline of SFAP components


8
100 (c) (d)

80 6
Voltage (mV)

60
4

40

2
20
DRT = 0.5 ms
0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0 0.1 0.2 0.3
Time (ms) Radial distance (mm)

pronounced as in the case with the wide IAP. Additionally, practically identical for the SFAP components arising from
because of the proximity in time between the two SFAP the type-II and -III IAPs.
components (*0.5 ms), the second phase of the depolar-
ization potential overlapped to a large extent with the first 3.3 Effect of changes in the IAP falling phase
phase of the repolarization one (Fig. 6f). As a consequence, on the variation of the SFAP waveform
the transition between the second and third peaks of the with radial distance
resulting SFAP was rather smooth even at short radial
distances (black solid line in Fig. 6f). Figure 8 shows, for each type of IAP (Fig. 5, left column),
From Fig. 7, it can be readily seen that the radial three series of SFAPs simulated with three different values
declines of the depolarization and repolarization compo- of IAP DRT (0.5, 0.75, and 1.0 ms), each series consisting
nents are much more similar for the narrow than for the of seven potentials generated at varying radial distances.
wide IAP. Thus, for the narrow IAP, increasing radial SFAP series contained in the first column of Fig. 8 were
distance from 0.075 to 0.175 and 0.275 mm led to depo- simulated using IAPs with different shapes, but with the
larization and repolarization components more comparable same (narrow) spike width (DRT = 0.5 ms). As can be
in terms of amplitude and duration (compare Fig. 6f–h). In seen, within each of these SFAP series, changes in the
addition, for radial distances of 0.175 and 0.275 mm, the radial distance brought about commensurate changes in the
second phase of the depolarization potential broadly whole SFAP waveform. Irrespective of the IAP profile and
overlapped with the first phase of the repolarization one. radial distance, the descending portion of the negative
This explains why SFAPs simulated at these radial dis- phases of these SFAPs exhibited a roughly constant slope.
tances had a declining negative phase with a practically In addition, only the SFAP series simulated with the type-I
constant slope, i.e., without an S-D point (black solid lines and type-II IAP models (Fig. 8a, d) showed a well-defined
in Fig. 6g, h). third phase. In the three SFAP series simulated with IAPs
Since the first portion of the IAP falling phase (i.e., from of DRT = 0.75 ms (second column), increasing the radial
the IAP peak to dipole d2) was the same for the three IAP distance gave rise to marked reductions of the two first
models, it can be assumed that the above results would be peaks of the SFAP, while the decline in the SFAP third

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

SFAP series simulated with type-I IAPs of different DRTs


1.5 1.5 1.5
(a) (b) (c)
S-D point
1 1 less pronounced 1
S-D point
Voltage (mV)

0.5 0.5 0.5

0 0 0

-0.5 -0.5 -0.5

-1 DRT = 0.5 ms -1 DRT = 0.75 ms -1 DRT = 1.0 ms


5.5 6 6.5 7 5.5 6 6.5 7 5.5 6 6.5 7

SFAP series simulated with type-II IAPs of different DRTs


1.5 1.5 1.5
(d) (e) S-D point (f)
1 1
less pronounced 1
S-D point
Voltage (mV)

0.5 0.5 0.5

0 0 0

-0.5 -0.5 -0.5

-1 DRT = 0.5 ms -1 DRT = 0.75 ms -1 DRT = 1.0 ms


5.5 6 6.5 7 5.5 6 6.5 7 5.5 6 6.5 7

SFAP series simulated with type-III IAPs of different DRTs


1.5 1.5 1.5
(g) (h) S-D point (i)
less pronounced
1 1 1
S-D point
Voltage (mV)

0.5 0.5 0.5

0 0 0

-0.5 -0.5 -0.5

-1 DRT = 0.5 ms -1 DRT = 0.75 ms -1 DRT = 1.0 ms


5.5 6 6.5 7 5.5 6 6.5 7 5.5 6 6.5 7
Time (ms) Time (ms) Time (ms)

Fig. 8 First row simulation of sets of SFAPs using the type-I IAP 0.1 to 0.28 mm (see ‘‘Methods’’ for details). Second and third rows
with DRT values of 0.5 (a), 0.75 (b), and 1.0 ms (c). Each set the same as in the first row but using the type-II and type-III IAPs,
comprises seven SFAPs simulated at increasing radial distances from respectively

phase was comparatively less prominent. In these series, portions that were affected to different degrees by the same
SFAPs simulated at short radial distances exhibited a change in radial distance: the portion delimited between the
declining negative phase with visible changes in the slope. SFAP onset and the S-D point underwent pronounced
In the three SFAP series synthesized with wide changes in amplitude, whereas the terminal portion of the
(DRT = 1.0 ms) and strongly asymmetric IAPs (third SFAP (from the S-D point onwards) experienced much less
column), potentials detected at short distances displayed a change in amplitude. In addition, irrespective of the IAP
distinct S-D point in the descending portion of the negative typology and radial distance, the third phases of these
phase. In these series, the S-D point could be used as a SFAPs were of very small amplitude and had a markedly
reference to divide the SFAP time course into two different prolonged duration.

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

4 Discussion and, consequently, the SFAP third phase cannot be consid-


ered to depend only on the IAP falling phase.
As pointed out by Dumitru [11], some morphological The width of the IAP spike was also found to have a
aspects found in human SFAPs are not sufficiently well profound influence on the SFAP third phase. This finding,
accommodated by simulated potentials. Definite answers to however, can be misleading because, in the present study,
the discrepancies between measured and computed SFAPs broadening of the IAP spike was accompanied by a
are not straightforward, as the formation of an SFAP is the lengthening (and slowing) of its falling phase (the rising
result of intricate interactions between the potential fields phase remained unchanged). Thus, the fact that widening
produced by the de- and repolarization phases of its cor- of the IAP results in an SFAP with smaller and more
responding IAP, these interactions being strongly depen- prolonged third phase is not merely due to the longer time
dent upon the fiber-to-electrode distance [32, 33]. The separation between the SFAP de- and repolarization com-
model proposed in the present paper provides insight into ponents, but also, and especially, to the concomitant
these interactions by combining an IAP description that elongation of the IAP falling phase (and the more gradual
affords the possibility of making independent changes in its transition of this phase toward a constant voltage) follow-
de- and repolarization phases with an SFAP formulation ing the IAP widening (Fig. 4).
that allows computing separately the potentials arising Another important observation is that, when different
from these phases. types of IAPs were simulated to have narrow spikes (of
DRT = 0.5 ms), the third phases of the resulting SFAPs
4.1 Relationship between the IAP falling phase exhibit marked differences in amplitude and duration (first
and the SFAP third phase column of Fig. 8). However, when these same IAPs were
synthesized so as to generate broad spikes (of DRT =
According to Dumitru’s study [11], the initiation of the IAP 1.0 ms), the third phases of the corresponding SFAPs display
repolarization phase essentially generates the SFAP third much more similar characteristics: they were all decidedly
phase. Our results, however, indicate that characteristics of small and less pronounced (second and third columns of
the SFAP terminal portion are more coupled to the specific Fig. 8). The explanation for the above observation lies in the
profile (curvature) of the last part of the IAP falling phase fact that, when IAPs of different shapes are simulated with
(i.e., the transition phase) than to the outline of its first part the same DRT, the relative differences between their corre-
(i.e., the rapidly falling phase). This is clearly demonstrated sponding falling phases decrease as the DRT increases.
by the observation that an IAP with a transition with large The lack of an IAP model that affords introducing fine
curvature leads to an SFAP third phase with a much larger modifications along its time course has led some authors to
amplitude and shorter duration as compared to that unrealistic interpretations about the nature of the SFAP
resulting from an IAP with a transition of smaller curvature third phase. As an example, Dumitru’s group [11], in their
(compare IAPs and SFAPs of the first and third rows of search for the IAP specifications required to generate a
Fig. 4). Further support for this result has been provided by ‘‘biphasic’’ SFAP, came up with the conclusion that the
Rosenfalck [34] who used a collection of IAPs recorded duration of the IAP repolarization phase should be longer
from frogs and rats at different temperatures to calculate than *23 ms. Such a conclusion is probably due to the fact
SFAPs (Figs. 11 and 13 of the cited paper). In Rosenfalck’s that Dumitru’s group used the IAP description of Gootzen
work, one can clearly appreciate that the specific shape of et al. [17], which does not permit introducing fine and
the transition of the IAP falling phase toward the resting independent changes in the different portions of the IAP
voltage (at times the after-potential) is the characteristic falling phase. In fact, we have found that an IAP with a
that most significantly affects the SFAP third phase, though DRT value of only *1.0 ms (i.e., with a duration of the
the author did not comment on this result. A similar con- IAP falling phase of approximately 3.0 ms) is sufficient to
clusion can be obtained from subsequent simulation studies simulate SFAPs that can be considered as primarily
that calculate the SFAP in terms of the IAP [25, 28, 37]. biphasic (Fig. 4). Therefore, Dumitru’s group overesti-
Radial distance has been shown to influence the formation mated by a factor of 8 the duration of the IAP spike
of the SFAP third phase. Increasing the distance from the required to generate practically biphasic SFAPs.
electrode to the active fiber brings about stronger interactions
between the potential fields produced by the IAP de- and 4.2 Relationship between the IAP falling phase
repolarization phases [32, 33], i.e., a higher degree of over- and the SFAP declining negative phase
lapping between the SFAP de- and repolarization compo-
nents. Specifically, for radial distances greater than In their study of the SFAP morphology, Dumitru’s group
*0.275 mm (Fig. 5), the depolarization component affects directed special attention to the descending portion of the
noticeably the two phases of the repolarization component SFAP negative phase [11]. The authors claimed that the

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

majority of SFAPs, being essentially biphasic, had a steep and with a more gradual decline toward the baseline, and
declining negative phase with an approximately constant also they become more comparable in terms of amplitude
slope. However, they also reported the existence of some and duration. As a result, increasing the radial distance
SFAPs with a distinct shoulder-like feature (and therefore brings about an increase in the degree of overlapping
an S-D point) in the terminal negative phase. The appear- between the de- and repolarization components, leading to
ance of this shoulder could hardly be attributed to distant a gradual vanishing of possible discontinuities in the slope
signals overlapping with the near-field SFAPs, as these of the SFAP declining negative phase. According to our
SFAPs were recorded in the absence of cannula potential. simulations, for radial distances [0.15 mm, the S-D point
Other authors before Dumitru did not comment on such a should not be expected to appear clearly in the SFAP time
feature in the SFAP time course, although in their studies course.
one can easily find examples of recorded SFAPs with an
apparent S-D point (Fig. 23 of [12], Fig. 4.1 of [36], and 4.3 Relationship between the IAP falling phase
Figs. 4.10 and 5.25 of [18]). In addition, the SFAPs sim- and the variation of the SFAP waveform
ulated by Andreassen and Rosenfalck [4] taking as a ref- with radial distance
erence experimental human IAPs also displayed a visible
S-D point. Thus, the presence of the S-D point does not Expressing the SFAP as a function of its de- and repolar-
seem to be the result of low-frequency components from ization components also improves the understanding of
distant fibers or from artefacts. why (and how) the variation of the SFAP shape with radial
Our simulations have helped to elucidate the origin of distance depends on the characteristics of the IAP spike. In
the S-D point in the SFAP. It was found that when the three the r-varying SFAP series generated using symmetric
types of IAPs proposed in the paper were simulated to short-spike IAPs (first column of Fig. 8), the three phases
produce narrow spikes (of DRT = 0.5 ms), they all give of the SFAP undergo comparable amplitude variations.
rise to SFAPs with an approximately linear transition Two reasons are needed to account for such behavior. First,
between the second and third peaks (first column of Fig. 8). the de- and repolarization components arising from such
When these same three IAP descriptions were adjusted so IAPs have rather similar declines with radial distance.
as to synthesize wide spikes (of DRT = 1.0 ms), they all Second, these components, being of comparable magni-
result in SFAPs with a distinct S-D point in the descending tude, are separated by a short time interval which favors
portion of the negative phase (second and third columns of their overlapping, thereby reducing the cancelation
Fig. 8). Thus, it appears that the declining negative phase between their corresponding phases.
of the SFAP is more dependent on the width of the cor- On the contrary, in the r-varying SFAP series simulated
responding IAP spike than on the specific outline of the with strongly asymmetric long-spike IAPs, one can easily
IAP falling phase. appreciate that the first two peaks of the SFAP decline at a
The explanation for the above conclusion is as follows. much higher rate than the terminal phase (third column of
The character of the SFAP declining negative phase Fig. 8). The first reason for this behavior is that, for these
depends on the temporal summation, and more specifically IAPs, the depolarization component has a much more abrupt
on the degree of overlapping of the SFAP de- and repo- radial decline than the repolarization one because of their
larization components, which is determined by the tem- different length [9]. In addition, for the different declines to
poral separation between them. Then, IAPs with narrow become apparent, it is necessary that the depolarization and
spikes (DRT = 0.5 ms), irrespective of their shape, lead to repolarization components are separated by a long time
SFAP de- and repolarization components separated by a interval, something that occurs in IAPs with long spikes.
short time interval, which favors the highest overlapping
between them. As a result, the declining negative phase of 4.4 Applicability and limitations of the results
the corresponding SFAP has an approximately constant
slope. In the case of wide-spike IAPs (DRT = 1.0 ms), 4.4.1 Can the results of the present study be used to infer
however, the SFAP de- and repolarization components are characteristics of human IAPs?
separated by a long time interval which prevents a com-
plete overlapping between them. As a result of this ‘‘par- The findings of the present study suggest that the DRT of
tial’’ overlapping, the declining negative phase of the human IAPs cannot be as short as 0.5 ms. First, when using
resulting SFAP exhibits an apparent S-D point. the two physiologically realistic IAP models to synthesize
The S-D point in the SFAP time course vanishes pro- spike widths of *0.5 ms, the resulting SFAPs show a large
gressively with increasing radial distance. The reason for and well-defined third phase, a feature not commonly
this is that, at higher distances from the fiber, both the de- found in real SFAPs. Even for the type-III IAP model, with
and repolarization components of the SFAP become slower an overly gradual falling phase, the spikes with DRT of

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

*0.5 ms have been shown to result in SFAPs with a vis- correct and to validate the above inferences above the
ible third phase (Fig. 8g). Second, with a spike width of duration of human IAPs.
*0.5 ms, our three IAP descriptions can only generate Summarizing, we tentatively suggest that IAPs recorded
SFAPs whose declining negative phase approximates to a in humans should have a DRT longer than about 0.75 ms.
straight line (first column of Fig. 8). However, several lines The shape of the spike of these intracellular potentials
of evidence have demonstrated clear changes in the slope should be strongly asymmetric, provided that its rising
(including S-D points) of the declining negative phase of phase is about 0.3 ms.
human SFAP. Third, values of DRT within the range
0.43–0.66 ms have only been measured under in vitro
conditions in rat IAPs [1, 3, 19, 39], whose characteristics References
should not necessarily be identical to those of human IAPs.
Despite the above arguments, many authors [5, 14, 24], 1. Akaike N (1978) Resting and action potentials in white muscle of
following the modifications introduced in the IAP analyt- potassium deficient rats. Comp Biochem Physiol A Physiol
ical expression by Nandedkar and Stålberg [26], have 61:629–633
2. Albers BA, Put JH, Wallinga W, Wirtz P (1989) Quantitative
preferred to use IAP models with a DRT of approximately analysis of single muscle fiber action potentials recorded at
0.5 ms to simulate EMG signals. known distances. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol
The possibility that human IAPs have a DRT greater 73(3):245–253
than *0.75 ms appears to be more plausible. First, for the 3. Albuquerque EX, Thesleff S (1968) A comparative study of
membrane properties of innervated and chronically denervated
three IAP descriptions considered here, a spike DRT fast and slow skeletal muscles of the rat. Acta Physiol Scand
[0.75 ms has been shown to generate SFAPs with a 73:471–480
decidedly prolonged and small third phase which, under the 4. Andreassen S, Rosenfalck A (1981) Relationship of intracellular
typical conditions of noise and baseline drift of SFEMG and extracellular action potentials of skeletal muscle fibers. CRC
Crit Rev Bioeng 7:267–306
[36], would be easily lost in the baseline. Thus, the 5. Arabadzhiev T, Dimitrov GV, Chakarov V, Dimitrov A,
resulting SFAPs would appear as essentially biphasic, in Dimitrova NA (2008) Effects of changes in intracellular action
good accordance with the experimental data. Second, with potential on potentials recorded by single-fiber, macro, and belly-
an IAP DRT greater than *0.75 ms, the corresponding tendon electrodes. Muscle Nerve 37:700–712
6. Dimitrov GV, Dimitrova NA (1979) Influence of the afterpo-
SFAPs would show apparent S-D points in the declining tentials on the shape and magnitude of the extracellular potentials
negative phase, a characteristic recurrently observed in generated under activation of excitable fibres. Electromyogr Clin
human SFAPs. Third, the only data available on intracel- Neurophysiol 19:249–267
lular potentials recorded from human muscle fibers comes 7. Dimitrov GV, Dimitrova NA (1998) Precise and fast calculation
of the motor unit potentials detected by a point and rectangular
from the experiments performed by Ludin between 1969 plate electrode. Med Eng Phys 20:374–381
and 1973 [21–23] involving the in vitro measurement of 8. Dimitrova NA (1973) Influence of the length of the depolarized
IAPs from the human intercostal muscle. These IAPs had zone on the extracellular potential field of a single unmyelinated
DRT values of about 0.78 ms. nerve fiber. Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol 13:547–558
9. Dimitrova NA, Dimitrov GV (2006) Electromyography (EMG)
modeling. In: Metin A (ed) Wiley encyclopedia of biomedical
4.4.2 Limitations engineering. Wiley, Hoboken
10. Duchene J, Hogrel JH (2000) A model of EMG generation. IEEE
The above speculations about the spike duration of real Trans Biomed Eng 47:192–201
11. Dumitru D (1994) The biphasic morphology of voluntary and
IAPs are grounded on the hypothesis that the core-con- spontaneous SFAPs. Muscle Nerve 17:1301–1307
ductor model (on which our SFAP model is based) is valid 12. Ekstedt J (1964) Human single fibre action potentials. Acta
to accurately describe the generation of extracellular Physiol Scand 61(226):1–96
potentials. However, the core-conductor model is grounded 13. Farina D, Merletti R (2001) A novel approach for precise simu-
lation of the EMG signal detected by surface electrodes. IEEE
on two major simplifications: the excitation source is Trans Biomed Eng 48(6):637–646
assumed to be distributed along the axis of the fiber and the 14. Fleisher SM (1984) Comparative analysis of modelled extracel-
influence of the extracellular potential field on the IAP lular potentials. Med Biol Eng Comput 22:440–447
generation is neglected [20, 38]. Therefore, it is only by 15. Fortune E, Lowery MM (2011) Simulation of the interaction
between muscle fiber conduction velocity and instantaneous
assuming that these simplifications do not distort exces- firing rate. Ann Biomed Eng 39(1):96–109
sively the true relationship between the IAP and SFAP that 16. Griep PAM, Boon KL, Stegeman DF (1978) A study of the motor
the above hypothesis concerning the IAP spike width can unit action potential by means of computer simulation. Biol
be regarded as valid. Future studies involving simultaneous Cybern 30:221–230
17. Gootzen TH, Stegeman DF, Van Oosterom A (1991) Finite limb
recording, from the same fiber, of the IAP, transmembrane dimensions and finite muscle length in a model for the generation
current, and SFAP are needed to establish the extent to of electromyographic signals. Electroencephalogr Clin Neuro-
which the assumptions of the core-conductor model are physiol 81(2):152–162

123
Author's personal copy
Med Biol Eng Comput

18. Gydikov A (1991) Biophysics of the skeletal muscle extracellular (fatiguing) activity. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol
potentials. Bulg Acad Sci 132:60–100 55(5):545–552
19. Hanson J (1974) Effects of repetitive stimulation on membrane 31. Rodriguez-Falces J, Malanda-Trigueros A, Gila-Useros L,
potentials and twitch in human and rat intercostal muscle fibers. Rodriguez -Carreño I, Navallas-Irujo J (2006) Modelling fibril-
Acta Physiol Scand 92:238–248 lation potentials—a new analytical description for the muscle
20. Henriquez CS, Plonsey R (1988) The effect of the extracellular intracellular action potential. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng
potential on propagation in excitable tissue. Comments Theor 53:581–592
Biol 1:47–64 32. Rodrı́guez J, Malanda A, Gila L, Rodriguez I, Navallas J (2011)
21. Ludin HP (1969) Microelectrode study of normal human skeletal Estimating the duration of intracellular action potentials in
muscle. Eur Neurol 2(6):340–347 muscle fibres from single-fibre extracellular potentials. J Neuro-
22. Ludin HP (1970) Microelectrode study of dystrophic human sci Meth 197(221):230
skeletal muscle. Eur Neurol 3(2):116–121 33. Rodriguez J, Malanda A, Gila L, Rodriguez I, Navallas J (2011)
23. Ludin HP (1973) Action potentials of normal and dystrophic The peak-to-peak ratio of single-fibre potentials is little influ-
human muscle fibers. In: Desmedt JE (ed) New development in enced by changes in the electrode positions close to the muscle
electromyography and clinical neurophysiology. Karger, Basel, fibre. J Electromyogr Kinesiol 21:423–432
pp 400–406 34. Rosenfalck P (1969) Intra- and extracellular fields of active nerve
24. McGill KC, Lateva ZC (2001) A model of the muscle-fiber and muscle fibers. A physico-mathematical analysis of different
intracellular action potential waveform, including the slow models. Acta Physiol Scand 321:1–168
repolarization phase. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 48:1480–1483 35. Stålberg E (1966) Propagation velocity in human muscle fibers in
25. Miller-Larson A (1985) An analysis of extracellular single mus- situ. Acta Physiol Scand 287:1–112
cle fiber. Biol Cybern 51:271–284 36. Stålberg E, Trontelj J (1979) Single fiber electromyography.
26. Nandedkar S, Stålberg E (1983) Simulation of single muscle fiber Raven Press, Old Woking
action potentials. Med Biol Eng Comput 21:158–165 37. Trayanova NA, Dimitrov GV (1982) Extracellular potentials in
27. Nandedkar S, Sanders DB (1988) Simulation of concentric needle the proximity of the excitable fibers. Electromyogr Clin Neuro-
EMG motor unit action potentials. Muscle Nerve 11:151–159 physiol 22:291–301
28. Piotrkiewicz M, Miller-Larsson A (1987) A method of descrip- 38. Van Veen BK, Wolters H, Wallinga W (1993) The bioelectrical
tion of single muscle fiber activity. Biol Cybern 56:237–245 source in computing single muscle fiber action potentials. Bio-
29. Plonsey R (1974) The active fiber in a volume conductor. IEEE phys J 64:1492–1498
Trans Biomed Eng 21:371–381 39. Wallinga W, Gielen FLH, Wirtz P, de Jong P, Broenink J (1985)
30. Radicheva N, Gerilovsky L, Gydikov A (1986) Changes in The different intracellular action potentials of fast and slow
the muscle fiber extracellular action potentials in long-lasting muscle fibers. Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol 60:539–547

123

You might also like