Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Silvia Tenembaum, MD; Tanuja Chitnis, MD; Jayne Ness, MD, PhD; and Jin S. Hahn, MD;
for the International Pediatric MS Study Group*
Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) is an genesis, treatment, and outcomes, and includes a
immune-mediated inflammatory disorder of the proposed definition of this disorder.
CNS, which is commonly preceded by an infection,
and predominantly affects the white matter of the Epidemiology. ADEM can occur at any age, but it
brain and spinal cord.1-4 Several terms can be found is more common in pediatric patients than in adults.
in the literature to describe patients with ADEM, Rare cases in older adults have been reported,17 al-
reflecting the more prominent aspects of the disease: though careful exclusion of other diseases should be
applied in these cases. The diagnosis is often made
“Postinfectious or postvaccinial encephalomyelitis, in the setting of a defined viral illness or vaccination.
postinfectious multifocal encephalitis,” when the trig-
gering events were considered. Although there appears to be no gender predomi-
nance in ADEM,18,19 a male predominance has been
“Acute perivascular myelinoclasia, perivenous en- described in two pediatric cohorts, with reported fe-
cephalitis, disseminated vasculomyelinopathy,” when
male:male ratios of 0.620 and 0.8.21 as opposed to a
emphasizing the histopathologic features and distri-
bution of lesions. 2:1 female preponderance frequently described for
MS. The mean age at presentation in children
“Acute demyelinating encephalomyelitis, hyperergic ranges from 5 to 8 years.21-23
encephalomyelitis, postvaccinal perivenous encephali-
A seasonal distribution in the winter and spring
tis, postencephalitis demyelination,” relating to the
probable immunopathogenetic mechanism.5-16 months has been found in studies conducted in the
United States.19,20 A recent study conducted in San
Based on our current clinicopathologic under- Diego County, CA, estimated the mean incidence of
standing of the disease, ADEM is probably the most ADEM as 0.4/100,000/year among persons less than
appropriate nosologic designation, as the precipitat- 20 years of age living in that region.19 Five percent of
ing event may be absent and the pathogenesis of the these patients had received a vaccination within 1
disease is unclear. month prior to the ADEM event, and 93% reported
In the absence of specific biologic markers, the signs of infection in the preceding 21 days. There are
diagnosis of ADEM is based on the clinical and ra- no clear studies of worldwide distributions of ADEM.
diologic features. Although ADEM usually has a Some regional cases are linked to specific vaccines,
monophasic course, recurrent or multiphasic forms as in the case of the Semple rabies vaccine, smallpox
have been reported, raising diagnostic difficulties in vaccine, and older forms of the measles vaccine.
distinguishing these cases from multiple sclerosis
(MS). This article reviews what we currently know Clinical presentation. ADEM is classically de-
about ADEM, including diagnostic features, patho- scribed as a monophasic disorder which typically be-
*Members of the International Pediatric MS Study Group are listed in the Appendix.
From the Department of Pediatric Neurology (S.T.), National Pediatric Hospital, Dr. J.P. Garrahan, Buenos Aires, Argentina; Massachusetts General
Hospital for Children (T.C.), Brigham & Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston; Department of Pediatrics (J.N.), University of Alabama at
Birmingham and Children’s Hospital of Alabama; and Pediatric Neurology Division (J.H.), Stanford University Medical Center, CA.
Disclosure: The authors report no conflicts of interest.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Silvia Tenembaum, Pediatric Neurologist, Pediatric Multiple Sclerosis Clinic, Department of Neurology,
National Pediatric Hospital “Dr. J. P. Garrahan,” Buenos Aires, Argentina; e-mail: silviatenembaum@hotmail.com, solier@ciudad.com.ar
Murthy Dale Hynson Hung Tenembaum Gupte Mikaeloff Idrissova Leake Anlar
et al.,20 et al.,18 et al.,22 et al.,51 et al.,21 et al.,26 et al.,39 et al.,107 et al.,19 et al.,23
USA, England, Australia, Taiwan, Argentina, England, France, Russia, USA, Turkey,
2002, 2000, 2001, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2003, 2004, 2003,
n ⫽ 18 n ⫽ 35 n ⫽ 31 n ⫽ 52* n ⫽ 84 n ⫽ 18 n ⫽ 119† n ⫽ 90‡ n ⫽ 42§ n ⫽ 46
Mean age, y (range) 7.5 (2.5–22) 7.4 ⫾ 0.65 5.9 (2–16) 6.7 5.3⫾3.9 8.6 ⫾ 1.2 7.1 ⫾4.3¶ 9.8 ⫾ 0.5 6.5 (0.8–18) 8 (1–15)
(3–15) (0.7–16) (0.4–16) (2.5–16) (0.7–16) (2–16)
Male, % 61 54 42 56 64 61 56¶ 54 57 63
Mean follow-up, y (range) 1.8 (0.2–5) 5.8 ⫾ 0.8 1.5 ⬎1.5 6.6 (1–19) 1.2 ⫾ 0.2 2.9 ⫾3 Mean NR Mean NR Mean NR
(1–15) (0.25–4) (0.5–14.9) (1–5) (1–5) (1–12)
Ataxia/cerebellar, % NR 51 65 4 50 50 NR 52 50 28
Seizures, % 17 17 13 47 35 11 NR 34 19 10
* Hung et al. (2001) separated postinfectious encephalomyelitis (n ⫽ 38) from ADEM (n ⫽ 13) based on the number of MRI lesions, at least three for
ADEM. No difference in mental status, though 70% in both groups.
† Mikaeloff et al. (2004) initially gave the diagnosis of ADEM to 119 patients (out of 296 with demyelinating event) but reclassified all of them as MS if
any recurrence. As some patients may be considered multiphasic ADEM, we kept the original 119 in analysis. However, in table 1, “¶” provides data
from only the 85 monophasic cases.
‡ In the series of Idrissova et al., MRI was only performed in the 14 children with more severe clinical course. They reported full recovery only if no fa-
tigue was present. However, neurologic disability was identified by telephone contact.
§ Leake et al. (2004) reclassified as MS 7% of the relapsing forms of ADEM.
gins within 2 days to 4 weeks after an antigenic status, ataxia, motor deficits, and brainstem involve-
challenge. Approximately 70 to 77% of patients re- ment, other features appear to be age related.25
port a clinically evident antecedent infection or vac- Long-lasting fever22 and headaches19,21-23,26 occur
cination during the prior few weeks.21,22,24 The typical more frequently in children with ADEM, while sen-
symptoms and signs of ADEM include a rapid onset sory deficits predominate in adult patients.17 Sei-
encephalopathy associated with a combination of mul- zures are rarely observed in adult patients with
tifocal neurologic deficits. A prodromal phase with fe- ADEM,17 and are mainly seen in children younger
ver, malaise, headache, nausea, and vomiting may be than 5 years. One study has documented prolonged
observed shortly before the development of meningeal focal motor seizures in 70% of the younger patients,
signs and drowsiness. The clinical course is rapidly with 82% of these patients going on to status
progressive and usually develops over hours to maxi- epilepticus.21
mum deficits within days (mean, 4.5 days).21 Peripheral nervous system (PNS) syndromes such
The initial neurologic features are determined by as acute polyradiculoneuropathy24,27,28 may occur in
the location of the lesions within the CNS. Table 1 ADEM but are considered rare in childhood ADEM
summarizes the demographic distribution and pre- cases. The combination of PNS and CNS features
senting features in recently published case studies of may be more common in adults and was noted in
patients with ADEM. Frequent neurologic symptoms 43.6% of one cohort of adult patients.29
and signs described in various combinations include There is a wide variation in the severity of the
unilateral or bilateral pyramidal signs (60 to 95%), illness. Occasionally, ADEM can present as a subtle
acute hemiplegia (76%), ataxia (18 to 65%), cranial disease, with nonspecific irritability, headache, and
nerve palsies (22 to 45%), visual loss due to optic somnolence, or may show a rapid progression of
neuritis (7 to 23%), seizures (13 to 35%), spinal cord symptoms and signs to coma and decerebrate rigidi-
involvement (24%), impairment of speech (slow, ty.30 Respiratory failure secondary to brainstem in-
slurred, or aphasia) (5 to 21%), and hemiparesthesia volvement or severely impaired consciousness occurs
(2 to 3%), with invariable involvement of mental sta- in 11% to 16% of cases.21,30
tus, ranging from lethargy to coma.19-23 Although cer-
tain signs and symptoms may be observed in both MRI features. Neuroimaging is extremely impor-
pediatric and adult cases, such as changes in mental tant in establishing the diagnosis of ADEM. MRI
S24 NEUROLOGY 68(Suppl 2) April 17, 2007
Figure 1. Acute disseminated encepha-
lomyelitis with small lesions. (A) Axial
T2-weighted MRI showing bilateral,
poorly marginated hyperintense lesions
in central, periventricular, and juxta-
cortical white matter, (B) also involving
both thalami and internal capsules, in
a 17-month-old boy, 2 weeks after mea-
sles vaccination.
abnormalities are most frequently identified on T2- shaped (figure 5), nodular, gyral, or spotty patterns
weighted and fluid-attenuated inversion recovery have been described.36-38 Meningeal enhancement of
(FLAIR) sequences as patchy, poorly marginated ar- the brain or spinal cord is unusual.
eas of increased signal intensity. Lesions in ADEM Spinal cord involvement in ADEM has been de-
are typically large, multiple, and asymmetric. They scribed in 11 to 28%.18,21-23,39 The typical spinal cord
typically involve the subcortical and central white lesion is large and swollen, showing variable en-
matter and cortical gray-white junction of both cere- hancement, and predominantly affects the thoracic
bral hemispheres, cerebellum, brainstem, and spinal region.
cord.30 The gray matter of the thalami and basal Sequential MRI scanning during the follow-up pe-
ganglia are frequently involved, typically in a sym- riod plays an important role in establishing the diag-
metric pattern.21,31 The periventricular white matter nosis of ADEM. Monophasic ADEM is not associated
is also frequently involved, being described in 30 to with the development of new lesions. Complete
60% of cases.20,22,30 Lesions confined to the corpus resolution of MRI abnormalities after treatment
callosum are less common. However, large demyeli- has been described in 37 to 75% of patients with
nating lesions of the adjacent white matter may ex- ADEM, and partial resolution in 25 to 53% of
tend into the corpus callosum and cross into the
contralateral hemisphere.
Four patterns of cerebral involvement have been
proposed to describe the MRI findings in ADEM21: 1)
ADEM with small lesions (less than 5 mm; figure 1);
2) ADEM with large, confluent, or tumefactive le-
sions, with frequent extensive perilesional edema
and mass effect (figure 2); 3) ADEM with additional
symmetric bithalamic involvement (figure 3); and 4)
acute hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis (AHEM), when
some evidence of hemorrhage can be identified in the
large demyelinating lesions (figure 4). The MRI pat-
tern does not appear to correlate with any particular
outcome or disability, as observed in a large pediat-
ric cohort,21 since most lesions tend to resolve on
follow-up imaging studies.21,32 However, this classifi-
cation may be useful when considering the differen-
tial diagnosis of ADEM and may potentially help to
identify those children for whom the initial ADEM-
phenotype is really the first manifestation of MS.
The incidence of gadolinium enhancing lesions on
T1-weighted sequences is quite variable in ADEM
and may depend on the stage of inflammation.31,33,34 Figure 2. Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis with tu-
Gadolinium enhancing lesions have been described mefactive lesions. Axial T2-weighted image demonstrating
in 30 to 100% of patients.21,35,36 The pattern of en- extensive, tumefactive, and bihemispheric lesions with
hancement is variable; complete or incomplete ring- perilesional edema, in a 13-year-old boy.
April 17, 2007 NEUROLOGY 68(Suppl 2) S25
of MRI lesions, SPECT with acetazolamide detects
persistent cerebral circulatory impairment that may
contribute to the neurocognitive and language defi-
cits observed in some patients with ADEM.49,50
Measles
Live measles vaccine 1–2/million131 (compared to 20–30/million incidence of measles
virus–induced encephalitis)
Rabies
Neural vaccine (Semple) 1/300–1/7,000128
Duck embryo vaccine 1/25,0003
Non-neural human diploid cell ⬍1/75,000
Japanese B encephalitis
Inactivated mouse-brain derived JEV 1993–1999 0.2/100,000 (Japan)132; 0/813,000 (USA)132
Smallpox
135
New York City Board of Health strain of vaccinia 2002–2004 3/665,000 (reporting encephalitis or myelitis)
131
Diphtheria/pertussis/tetanus 0.9/100,000
133
Hepatitis B Eight cases of CNS inflammation within 10 weeks Four cases
of partial myelitis within 3 months134
some patients.118,119 Lesions largely involve the white pertussis, diphtheria, measles, mumps, rubella,
matter, but can also involve the cortex and deep gray pneumococcus, varicella, influenza, Japanese en-
matter structures. The CSF is characterized by ele- cephalitis, and polio.19,21,131-136 Vaccines produced in
vated protein and white blood cells. Oligoclonal CNS tissue including the Semple form of the rabies
bands are an acute manifestation in up to 30% of vaccine carry a higher risk of ADEM. It is important
patients with ADEM,18 and may be transient. Ele- to note that in general, vaccination forms with
vated CSF levels of the pro-inflammatory cytokines high rates of complications are no longer in use.
IL-6, IL-10, and TNF␣ have been described.120,121 Some reported incidences of encephalomyelitis asso-
Acute hemorrhagic and acute necrotizing hemor- ciated with various forms of vaccination are listed in
rhagic leukoencephalitis (AHEM, AHL, ANHLE) of table 2.
Weston Hurst shares some inflammatory histologic The pathogenesis of ADEM is unclear; however,
features with ADEM; however, demyelination is of- given its histologic features and typically monopha-
ten more widespread throughout the CNS and is as- sic course of disease, it has been likened to the
sociated with a pronounced neutrophilic infiltrate. animal model experimental autoimmune encephalo-
ANHLE is characterized by destruction of small myelitis (EAE). EAE is an autoimmune demyelinat-
blood vessels associated with acute hemorrhage and ing disease, which can be induced in a variety of
fibrin deposition.122 CSF analysis reflects the hemor- animal species by immunization with myelin pro-
rhagic nature of this disease with elevations in pro- teins or peptides. Moreover, the postvaccinial form of
tein, RBC, and WBC counts. ADEM associated with the Semple rabies vaccine,
ADEM may be classified as either postvaccinial or which contains rabies virus–infected neural tissue,
postinfectious; however, in many cases no clear ante- reinforces this analogy to EAE. Viral or bacterial
cedent history of either is present. Rare cases of epitopes resembling myelin antigens have the capac-
ADEM have been described following organ ity to activate myelin-reactive T cell clones through
transplantation.123-127 Postinfectious forms of ADEM molecular mimicry,137 and can thereby elicit a CNS-
typically begin within 2 to 21 days after an infectious specific autoimmune response. Thus, it has been sug-
event; however, longer intervals have also been de- gested that microbial infections preceding ADEM
scribed. Viral infections commonly associated with elicit a cross-reactive anti-myelin response through
ADEM include influenza virus, enterovirus, measles, molecular mimicry. Alternatively, ADEM may be
mumps, rubella, varicella zoster, Epstein Barr virus, caused by the activation of existing myelin-reactive
cytomegalovirus, herpes simplex virus, hepatitis A, T cell clones through a nonspecific inflammatory
and coxsackievirus. Bacterial triggers include Myco- process.
plasma pneumoniae, Borrelia burgdorferi, Lepto- Theiler murine encephalomyelitis virus–induced
spira, and beta-hemolytic Streptococcus. Acute demyelinating disease (TMEV-IDD) model is induced
hemorrhagic leukoencephalomyelitis (AHLE) typi- by direct CNS infection of the neurotropic TMEV
cally follows influenza or upper respiratory infection. picornavirus, initially resulting in an immune-
The only epidemiologically and pathologically proven mediated reaction primarily involving TMEV-specific
association of ADEM with vaccinations is with the CD4 and CD8 T cells.138,139 However, during the
Semple form of the rabies vaccine.3,128-130 Other vacci- chronic stages of disease, T cell reactivity to host
nations associated with ADEM include hepatitis B, myelin peptides has been observed, indicating
S32 NEUROLOGY 68(Suppl 2) April 17, 2007
epitope spreading has occurred secondary to T cell associated with the two diseases suggests differences
responses to myelin breakdown products, resulting in pathogenesis.
in an autoimmune response.140 Both microglia141 and
dendritic cells142 from the CNS of TMEV-infected Research/future directions. ADEM often poses
mice are able to present myelin peptides to naı̈ve T both a diagnostic and prognostic dilemma for clini-
cells, thereby facilitating epitope spreading to nonvi- cians. In the acute stage, there should be a low sus-
ral, host myelin antigens. The TMEV model high- picion of infection before initiation of corticosteroid
lights the phenomenon of epitope spreading or immunosuppressive therapy. Diagnostic tests that
secondary to a destructive CNS viral infection result- increase the rapidity of an accurate diagnosis are
ing in a secondary autoimmune response and chronic recommended. Over the long term, one of the most
inflammation. Although this model superficially pressing questions of a child presenting with ADEM,
bears some resemblance to ADEM, it is important to particularly recurrent or multiphasic forms of
note that overwhelming evidence has shown that ADEM, is the potential risk for conversion to MS.
ADEM is not due to direct viral infection of the CNS, Although ADEM and MS share many similar patho-
but is a secondary immune-mediated phenomenon. logic features, prognosis is drastically different.
Epitope spreading is likely to be an important phe- Therefore, identification of a biomarker that can pre-
nomenon in chronic inflammatory diseases such as dict the development of MS after an ADEM event is
MS, but involvement in ADEM is unknown. critical.
Sequences in myelin basic protein have been Additional studies are required to understand the
shown to resemble several viral sequences, and in worldwide epidemiology and distribution of ADEM.
some cases, cross-reactive T cell responses have been These studies may give insight into the pathogenesis
demonstrated. Examples of cross-reactive T cells of the disease and potential preventative measures.
with MBP antigens include HHV-6,143 coronavirus,144 Early identification of triggers for ADEM, such as
influenza virus hemagglutinin,145 and EBV.146 Prote- specific batches of vaccines, is facilitated by strin-
olipid protein (PLP) shares common sequences with gent monitoring mechanisms.
Haemophilus influenza.147 Semliki forest virus (SFV) Current treatments for ADEM generally lead to
peptides mimic myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein acceptable outcomes; however, further studies are
(MOG).148 Enhanced myelin basic protein (MBP)- required to investigate the use of additional agents,
reactive T cell responses have been demonstrated in particularly for refractory or multiphasic cases.
patients with postinfectious forms of ADEM.149,150 El- There is a paucity of literature on the use of chemo-
evated titers of anti-myelin antibodies in sera from therapeutic agents for ADEM, although anecdotal
patients with ADEM have recently been demon- use is prevalent. In addition, use of -interferons for
strated as compared to patients with MS or viral multiphasic forms of ADEM requires further
encephalitis.151 Previous studies have demonstrated investigation.
enhanced anti-MBP antibody titers in patients with The use of standardized definitions for ADEM and
postvaccinial ADEM following vaccination with the MS in children and adolescents will help to facilitate
Semple rabies vaccine.152,153 One of these studies future studies, regarding the prognosis, pathogene-
demonstrated elevated anti-MBP antibody titers in sis, and treatment of these two diseases.
ADEM samples compared with MS samples. Al-
though there is controversy surrounding the charac-
Appendix
terization of anti-myelin antibody responses in MS,
The International Pediatric MS Study Group: Lauren Krupp, MD (chair),
studies in ADEM have consistently shown detectable Brenda L. Banwell, MD, Anita Belman, MD, Dorothee Chabas, MD, PhD,
levels, suggesting differences in pathogenesis. Col- Tanuja Chitnis, MD, Peter Dunne, MD, Andrew Goodman, MD, Jin S.
Hahn, MD, Deborah P. Hertz, MPH, Nancy J. Holland, EdD, RN, MSCN,
lectively, these studies suggest that enhanced T and Douglas Jeffery, MD, PhD, William MacAllister, PhD, Raul Mandler, MD,
B cell myelin responses play a role in the pathogene- Maria Milazzo, RN, MS, CPNP, Jayne Ness, MD, PhD, Jorge Oksenberg,
sis of both postinfectious and postvaccinial ADEM; PhD, Trena L. Pelham, MD, Daniela Pohl, MD, PhD, Kottil Rammohan,
MD, Mary R. Rensel, MD, Christel Renoux, MD, Dessa Sadovnick, PhD,
however, further studies are required to determine Steven Robert Schwid, MD, Silvia Tenembaum, MD, Cristina Toporas,
causal relationship. Emmanuelle Waubant, MD, PhD, Bianca Weinstock-Guttman, MD.
ADEM was associated with the class II alleles
HLA-DRB1*01 and HLA-DRB*03 in a Russian References
study.107 A similar study from Korea showed an asso- 1. Rust RS. Multiple sclerosis, acute disseminated encephalomyelitis,
ciation of ADEM with HLA-DRB1*1501, as well as and related conditions. Semin Pediatr Neurol 2000;7:66–90.
2. Dale RC. Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis. Semin Pediatr Infect
HLA-DRB5*0101.154 The same Korean study showed Dis 2003;14:90–95.
an association of HLA-DRB3*0202 and HLA- 3. Garg RK. Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis. Postgrad Med J
DQB1*0502 with acute necrotizing forms of enceph- 2003;79:11–17.
4. Jones CT. Childhood autoimmune neurologic diseases of the central
alopathy. The gene mostly frequently linked with nervous system. Neurol Clin 2003;21:745–764.
MS is HLA DRB1,155 with DR215,156 being the most 5. Marsden JP, Hurst EW. Acute perivascular myelinoclasis (“acute dis-
seminated encephalomyelitis”) in smallpox. Brain 1932;55:181–193.
frequently involved allele. Similar associations have 6. Davison C, Brock S. Acute demyelinating encephalomyelitis following
been found in the pediatric MS population.157 Thus, respiratory disease. Bull Neurol Inst NY 1937;6:504–514.
7. Van Bogaert L. Post-infectious encephalomyelitis and multiple sclero-
class II alleles may play a role in MS as well as sis; the significance of perivenous encephalomyelitis. J Neuropathol
ADEM; however, the disparity between the alleles Exp Neurol 1950;9:219–249.