Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GROUP ASSIGNMENT
THE CASE OF FAIR TRADE ENTERPRISES IN
TURKEY, IRAN, VIETNAM AND NIGERIA
Group: C
Course name: Project Week #2
Course code: PW41_BL2n6_MBM_APL
Professor name: Dr. Natalia Leal
Word count: 4011
STATEMENT OF CONTRIBUTION FOR GROUP ASSIGNMENTS
This Statement of Contribution is for the group assignment which is part of the assessment
PW41_BL2n6_MBM_APL
In order to ensure the equal contribution hence a fair assessment on the group project, this
Statement of Contribution was confirmed by the group members who actively participated in
We hereby declare and confirm that the group report was conducted based on the equal
contribution of all above mentioned individuals. We acknowledge that each member will
receive the same assessment result awarded for the report and for any forthcoming issue we
1
Table of Contents
I. Introduction.......................................................................................................................3
1. In Turkey.........................................................................................................................3
2. In Iran..............................................................................................................................6
3. In Vietnam.......................................................................................................................8
4. In Nigeria......................................................................................................................11
III. Comparison..................................................................................................................14
References...............................................................................................................................17
2
I. Introduction
It is needless to say that there are still many big corporations around the cradle of humankind
which put much effort into increasing their power and domination over people for obtaining
more concessions and benefits and creating wealth for their investors. At the same time, this
phenomenon has risen inequality among the whole society (Sahan, 2019). In this
unfavourable, and to somehow harsh commercial environment, the Fair Trade aims to be
assistance for less powerful, and marginalised producers through establishing a new
relationship between consumers and them and introducing fairer methods for wealth
distribution (Zajaczkowski, 2018). According to international Fair Trade charter (2018, p.4),
seeking justice, equality, and sustainable development for human beings is the primary goal
of the Fair Trade movement, in which individuals and organisation cooperate to 'put people
and planet before financial profit'. Regarding the unique approach of the Fair Trade, which
were introduced in the charter, including creating conditions for its practice, defining
inclusive economic growth, providing decent jobs with equal wages and conditions,
promoting environmental issues, and influencing citizens and public policies, this paper
Vietnam, Nigeria, Iran, and Turkey considering their legal, economic and social frameworks.
3
II. Challenges and opportunities analysis of establishing a Fair Trade company
1. In Turkey
There are 13 certified Fair Trade companies in Turkey which most of them are cotton and
Turkey has several plans for sustainable development. However, Fair Trade organisations
sustainable development and Fair Trade have several common concepts. However, Fair Trade
does not have an official active agent in Turkey; the Turkish development policies provide
the right context for establishing a Fair Trade company. In Turkey, sustainable development
policies are incorporated within numerous laws, legislation, regulation, policy documents and
action plans in a variety of policy fields and sectors (Ministry of Development, 2016).
Turkey's National Development Plan as the highest-level national policy document defined
In the last few decades, the 10th development plan has been set out with harmonising the
indicates that there is a high consistency between the 10th Development Plan and the SDGs
(Ministry of Development, 2016). SDG indicators are integrated into the Official Statistics
The SDGs and Fair Trade's work have lots of similarities in goals and vision so that most of
SDGs targets are related to food and farming. Fair Trade has a "direct and indirect" impact on
SDGs, and 8 of 17 of goals are most closely linked to Fair Trade works (Fair Trade
International, 2020). So, from the perspective of legal frameworks, the highest-level national
4
policy document provides an opportunity for establishing a Fair Trade company and working
Agriculture sector, which plays an essential role in the Fair Trade market, consists of 6.43 per
cent of Turkey GDP in 2019 (Statista, 2020). Turkey is one of the most important producers
of agricultural products, including nuts, cotton, tea, and fruits. For example, cotton and
related products such as textile and apparel consist of one of the essential parts of exports in
Turkey. Despite a robust agricultural production industry in Turkey, many problems affecting
the production negatively are available (Çelimli, Adanacioğlu and Güler, 2017). Reducing the
problems that Turkish farmers and producers are struggling with, as well as achieving a fair
wage, can be two economic opportunities to brand products with Fair Trade
Turkey using the advantage of proximity to the European market, it can stand out from
competitors in quality and social compliance requirements in line with production. Social
compliance criteria should not be seen as an obstacle, but as an opportunity in the long term.
Turkish companies will be able to gain a competitive advantage if they move forward in this
regard.
In Turkey, Fair Trade is not a well-known concept yet, and only 35% of Turkish companies
are aware of the this concept (Çelimli, Adanacioğlu and Güler, 2017). The results of a study
show a tendency to increase more amount of Fair Trade products(Çelimli, Adanacioğlu and
Güler, 2017). According to this research, all managers of the textile companies surveyed
stated that they are continuing to produce certified Fair Trade products in the future.
However, the Fair Trade concept is not well-established in Turkish society that companies
5
generally acquire Fair Trade certification to get a better price for their products. (Çelimli,
In addition to companies, the Fair Trade label is not known to consumers. Therefore,
companies do not produce their products to adhere to the principles of Fair Trade; instead,
they make products with the Fair Trade label, which has more customers.
2. In Iran
The main strategic plan of the country has been a model of 'Five-Year Development Plan' for
some decades. After completion of five plans, obviously with some successes and defeats, the
6th one has become operational since 2017 (Leila, 2020). A report by UNESCO Tehran
Cluster Office in 2017 stated that the plan was formulated whilst considering Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs), after a proper two-way relationship had been established
between the government and the United Nations Development Assistance Framework
(UNDAF). The report also mentioned that a good assessment and evaluation mechanism was
defined for the process, so the progresses and possible setbacks would be measurable, and
traceable.
Due to the particular advisory and supervisory position of the framework, many principal
elements recommended by SDGs were taken into account in writing the mentioned plan (6th
(UNESCO Tehran Cluster Office, 2017). Giving some examples from 6th Development Plan
(2017) to substantiate the above statement, under article 27 the government has committed to
Reduce the time for answering inquiries and giving permission for establishing rural
businesses to less than fifteen days. Also, the government has to support rural cooperatives
6
Furthermore, another report from knowledge platform of SDGs (n.d.) explained that
enhancing the livelihoods of the farmers and rural settlers, development of complementary
activities, particularly small industries and modern services, and emphasis on the reformation
of the commodity pricing systems are the government's concerns for promotion of Fair Trade'
standards in Iran.
Apparently, the government's desire to employ the advantages of practicing Fair Trade which
have been reflected in the current legal framework of the country along with its close
With respect to Sustainable Development Goals and Fair Trade, the government and
UNESCO has made a coordinated effort to support Small and Medium-sized Enterprises
(SMEs), advocate for business incubators and business start-ups, formulate new policies on
Cluster Office, 2017), therefore the elements of Fair Trade are existed, at least theoretically,
However, taking this structure into careful consideration, these great goals are hard to reach
in the short run. Leila (2020, p.9) introduced some 'structural imbalances', including 'the
spread of major and minor corruption', 'imbalance of public budget structure', and more
country in various aspects. Practically, these obstacles are major challenges when an
7
Dadgar and Nazari (2018), demonstrated that Iran's economy has considerable dependence on
public sector, while the lack of good governance standards has resulted in kind of 'rentier
government' in which the country greatly depends on the oil sector. As a result, this
phenomenon has made the private sector weak and vulnerable. With respect to their findings,
we are able to conclude that the opportunity of establishing a sustainable Fair Trade business
is quite limited in the practice, because of two reasons. First, mounting lobby for obtaining
trade concessions are unlikely to achieve in this environment. Second, the economy structure
suffers the lack of interests of big corporations to include Fair Trade into the mainstream
economy, as an important reason for the dynamic development of Fair Trade (Zajaczkowski,
2018), due to their enormous power and domination over the market, and the shortage of
Clearly, the positive perception of people on Fair Trade is an important component for its
development in a society. Papa and Petrucciano (2019) stated in their research that caring
about issues such as fairness in contracts, balance between the counterparts, wellness of the
community, and so forth are rooted in the Iranian individuals' belief, because Ja'fari school, as
a doctrine of Islam which the most Iranians advocate it, considers ethics an immanent
In the other research, Bahaee et al. (2012) focused on undergraduate college students, as
representatives of the educated class in Iran, and found that they have positive attitudes
towards sustainable development and its elements, and they also have good knowledge about
Considering the mentioned findings, and regarding that ethical consumers play a vital role in
development of Fair Trade (Zajaczkowski, 2018), it is safe to say that the Iran's society is to
8
some extent ready to support Fair Trade, and it can be assumed as an opportunity for opening
a Fair Trade enterprise in Iran, however, it has not been officially tried so far, and various
3. In Vietnam
There are currently only five sectors that focus on Fair Trade registration: tea, coffee, cocoa,
spices, and handicrafts. In Vietnam, there are two companies certified Fair Trade for tea, 11
companies for coffee, and 5 companies for handicrafts; for cocoa and spices, no company has
Currently, the Vietnamese legal framework does not have specific regulations and laws for
Fair Trade companies or selling Fair Trade products. There are only regulations, laws, and
policies to support businesses in general and commercial activities for the agricultural sector
simplification of import and export licenses (Pham, B.D, 2013). Some laws regulate
investment activities. In parallel to the Investment Law, the Enterprise Law was enacted to
replace the 2005 Law, which specifies the kinds of businesses and the policies for
establishing private enterprises, organizations, and their activities (OECD,2015). The Law on
Tax Administration 2006 stipulates equality between economic entities and foreign and
domestic investors (Nguyen, 2012). In 2014, the Competition Law was enacted. Since 2008,
after Vietnam joined the WTO, the Cooperative and Fair Trade Club model in the agricultural
sector has flourished. There are two Fair Trade organisations in Vietnam: FLO focuses on
product certification, while WFTO focuses on organisations. Since craft products abound,
that's why FLO certifies primarily for agricultural products, while WFTO certifies for
handicraft companies.
9
Despite substantial improvement in upgrading the investment legal system, the process is not
fully completed. The legal system still carries aspects of a planned economic strategy (Tran
Cong Thang, 2014). Legal structures are designed to be excessively cumbersome and
complex. As regulations and laws evolve more complicatedly, they become incomprehensible
to those who have to govern as well as very sensitive and challenging to implement evenly
For more than 30 years of innovation, Vietnam's agriculture has always maintained an
average growth rate of about 3.5% per year, a high level in Asia in general and in Southeast
Asia in particular (OECD, 2015). Production structure is more efficient and associated with
market demand. Many high-tech and organic agricultural production models have been
deployed, bringing great value and a friendly environment. From the international level,
globalisation process with free trade agreements (FTAs). Therefore, although the rate of
return is not high, the investment is less risky. Moreover, Vietnam's processing rate is still
low; the average for these four industries is less than 10% (VIRI, 2015). In the future, this
rate will increase due to the policy of encouraging the government of Vietnam's processing
However, Vietnam's products such as tea, coffee, cocoa, and spices do not have a recognised
brand name in the world market due to the small production scale, low processing capacity,
lack of market development strategies and skills. The practice of Fair Trade in enterprises is
not sustainable when businesses no longer receive external funding and face competition in
the domestic market that is not really towards Fair Trade. The ability to supply raw materials
10
is only half of the processing capacity, leading to competition in buying ingredients, reducing
The government issues a crop development policy through planning and supporting the
transfer of scientific and technical advances to farmers. Promoting support for cocoa growers
is one of the important solutions proposed by industry experts to increase supply and stabilise
the market (Vo Van Phong, et al., 2011). This opens up a great opportunity for a Fair Trade
However, in Vietnam, this concept is still relatively new and not well recognised. Fair Trade
and domestic NGOs. Besides, the connection and consistency between manufacturers and
traders are inconsistent. While joining Fair Trade requires an amount of international
human resources in Vietnam. Businesses must carry out English procedures, which requires
enterprises to be knowledgeable about the international trade process and have to pay for
In Vietnam, applying Fair Trade is still difficult because consumers' psychology is to buy the
right products, but the price must be the cheapest. Meanwhile, businesses must commit and
create trust with consumers by ensuring quality, but the selling price is always appropriate for
the market. As a result, businesses have to accept to reduce interest to have the cheapest,
11
4. In Nigeria
corruption is in high marketing possibilities. (Jones and Bayley 2000). For instance, the well-
connected or networking business people tend to benefit from anti-competitive practices that
protect the country from other market sources. Thus, any firm willing to invest in the
individual should be aware of the corruption activities that happen in the market.
Another disturbing challenge is the crowding of products at the major ports of Nigeria.
Through the congestion of goods at the docks, it means that there is slow delivery of services,
which is not able to meet the market demands (Nigeria-Market Challenges 2019). Moreover,
Nigeria tends to experience this type of challenge because of poor management and national
policy that most of the developing nations face globally; hence, new investors find it difficult
to enter the market with such type of situation. Therefore, overcrowding of goods at the ports
affects the fair-trade approach in a negative notion where there is a high demand for products
in the market. Thus, through the adoption of Fair Trade, the producers can have access to the
global society where the business is conducted with limited interruptions from intermediaries
Despite the overwhelming challenges of Fair Trade in Nigeria, there is still a large gap in
market opportunities, such as the poor farmer's management. n (Borsky and Spata 2018).
Besides, through the acquisition of fair-trade policies, the investors can fill this gap and
prevent the economy from experiencing negative economic impacts associated with imports
and exports. Through Fair Trade, the producers can enjoy the fair share of their products that
comes along with the added advantage of premiums such as bonuses when the end price of
12
their commodities rises. global society where the business is conducted with limited
Lack of increase in knowledge exchange is another critical challenge that Fair Trade strives
to fill in the market environment of Nigeria. Most business individuals lack access to
knowledge, which makes the big frim continue driving smaller markets out of business by
using supply chain activities (Schenk 2019). For instance, Nigeria has a high degree of social
capital, but lack of proper access or connection to the international world makes the supply
chain process more complicated Despite the overwhelming challenges of Fair Trade in
Nigeria, there is still a large gap in market opportunities, such as the poor farmer's
management. Most of the producers in Nigeria tend to experience unfair wages during the
In the context of coffee trade farmers in Nigeria, the sector is not given any priority to
enhance their development through the interaction of coffee value stakeholders (Schenk
2019). Farmers have always pushed every member from consumers, agriculturalists, and the
government to promote the coffee industry but failed because no financial institution and
sponsors support the idea. Under normal circumstances in Nigeria, big institutions would
However, the farmers ever had to opt to depend on small and medium-sized enterprises to
make the event happen. Still, they are not reliable to facilitate the trade to reach international
consumers who are the main business target (Borsky and Spata 2018). Besides, the farmer's
credibility with the Nigerians is in a good situation because of their experience, which makes
13
In conclusion, Fair Trade is associated with both challenges and opportunities in any market
across the globe and not only in Nigeria. Moreover, the challenges are one of the main
reasons that many developing countries are adopting Fair Trade to eliminate the traditional
kind of business currently practiced. For instance, investors need to be aware of corruption
levels that the Nigerian market face and weigh various market options of Fair Trade, whether
it is worth risking. Therefore, through the above report, an individual can consider multiple
opportunities and challenges then decide whether to enter the Nigerian market or concentrate
III. Comparison
In general, the legal systems in the four countries mentioned above do not have different
regulations and laws for a Fair Trade company. The current law includes only the terms that
support and are related to the establishment of a trade company. Therefore, this is also a
challenge for establishing a Fair Trade enterprise when it is difficult to do right and enough
according to the government regulations in each country. It is also difficult for companies to
protect their products and companies when they get caught up in a legal issue that arises
productivity constraints is a huge obstacle to Fair Trade product sales. On the other hand, in
Iran and Nigeria, the government has a considerable dependence on oil. With the main export
products being oil and relying on oil, policies and technology will not be focused much on
handicraft and agricultural products. The specialisation and focus on oil will weaken their
positions in the world commodity market. Thereby, the trade of handicrafts and agricultural
products from these two countries will face difficulties when competing with other countries
with high specialisation in the same industry. Besides, the political situation also dominates
many business activities in Iran and Turkey. Especially in Iran, the influence of big
14
corporations will dominate business and fairness in trade. It directly impacts the operation
and production of Fair Trade products, which qualify for the Fair Trade label.
In terms of social framework, the concept of Fair Trade is still new in four countries.
Although the definition of Fair Trade is homogeneous around the world, in each nation, the
perception and application of Fair Trade differ depending on the countries' culture and
traditions. While in Turkey, Fair Trade gives producers a view of profit rather than fairness, it
is supported by the ethos of religion and belief in Iran, where it is believed that people
deserve to be treated fairly. Whereas, Fair Trade in Vietnam is widely known for its
promotion activities by the government and NGOs. On the other hand, in Nigeria and
Vietnam, Fair Trade is also a challenge for human resources education and foreign language
Although there are still many challenges, Vietnam is considered a suitable country to
establish a Fair Trade company comparing to Turkey, Iran, and Nigeria. Vietnam is not only
a country specialising in agricultural products but also famous for handicraft products. It will
help expand product lines but also create competition against products from other countries.
With investment and improvement in technology, farmers and artisans in Vietnam are
becoming more and more specialised. Besides, with the government's supportive policies and
NGOs' activities, the production and trading of Fair Trade products will be carried out more
smoothly. In addition, the successful signing of the EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement
(EVFTA) agreement between Vietnam and the EU has opened up great tariff reduction
15
On the corporate side, the company needs to improve production chain value actively. When
a company increases the value chain for its production process, it will reduce the cost of Fair
Trade price management, leading to increased cash and income benefits for producers. To
achieve this, the company needs to self-define the value-added segment and execute it. In
addition, strengthening links and information exchange among production units will help
share information so that organisations and individuals can access more details and better
Fair Trade practices by learning from each other. Information disclosure and transparency are
also one of the principles of Fair Trade. If the company performs this criterion well, they
comply with the Fair Trade principle and benefit from it. The company also needs to
continually improve to meet the criteria, proactively improve products, participate in capacity
building training, market promotion, and design improvement to complete Fair Trade criteria'
sustainable application.
However, there is no national system or network to link Fair Trade enterprises in Vietnam.
Therefore, it is necessary to set up a Fair Trade network in Vietnam to connect the companies
that have obtained the Fair Trade certification. This, on the one hand, helps Fair Trade
organisations to seek opportunities to expand the scope of Fair Trade operations, on the other
hand, to find new customers to join and increase sales to existing customers. In the case of
five industries in Vietnam, it is necessary to have a full market forecast to identify the future
Fair Trade market demand as a basis for decision-making and build business plans for Fair
Trade enterprises. The collection, synthesis, analysis, and prediction of the Fair Trade product
market should be under the management of the state management agency on trade promotion
16
References
1. 6th Development Plan, 2017. Full text of the law of the Sixth Five-Year Plan for
Economic, Social and Cultural Development of the Islamic Republic of Iran. [pdf]
2. Bahaee, M., Perez-Batres, L. A., Pisani, M. J., Miller, V. V., Sareemi, M., 2012.
https://fardapaper.ir/mohavaha/uploads/2018/02/Fardapaper-Sustainable-Development-
in-Iran-An-Exploratory-Study-of-University-Students-Attitudes-and-Knowledge-about-
3. Borsky, S. and Spata, M., 2018. The impact of Fair Trade on smallholders' capacity to
4. Çelimli, S., Adanacioğlu, H. and Güler, D. (2017). Tekstil firmalarının adil ticaret
Series – Edirne, p. 9
5. Dadgar, Y. and Nazari, R., 2018. Difficulties of public sector structure as main obstacle
7. FLOCERT (2020). Search for Fair Trade certified organisations using our customer
November 2020]
17
8. Gavin Fridell, 2014. Fair Trade slippages and Vietnam gaps: the ideological fantasies of
Fair Trade coffee, Third World Quarterly, Vol. 35, Issue 7, pp. 1179-1194
9. Gençer, O. and Özüdo, T, 2017. Türki̇ ye’de pamuk üreti̇ mi̇ ve sorunlari. [pdf] Available
November 2020]
10. Güzel, A., 2010. Yoksulluğun önlenmesinde “adil ticaret. Başka Bir Dünya Mümkün.
11. Jones, S. and Bayley, B., 2000. Fair Trade: Overview, Impact, Challenges: Study to
Inform DFID's Support to Fair Trade. Oxford Policy Management, www. opml. co. uk,
12. knowledge platform of SDGs, n.d. Sustainable development goals, knowledge platform,
13. Leila, S. H., 2020. The revival of the Iranian revolutionary economy: studying the
content/uploads/sites/2/2020/09/The-Revival-of-the-Iranian-Revolutionary-Economy-
14. Ministry of Development, 2016. Report on Turkey's Initial Steps towards the
https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/107102030%20Agenda
15. Nguyen, T.D.N., 2012, Investment in the private sector in Vietnam: Trends in agricultural
investment - The role of the state and private sector in Vietnam. [pdf] Available at:
18
www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/tci/pdf/CorporatePrivateSector/Vietnam_-
_Private_Sector_Investments_in_Agriculture__Final_Report.pdf [Accessed 10
November, 2020]
17. OECD, 2015. Vietnam Agricultural Policy 2015. OECD Food and Agriculture Report.
18. Papa, M., and Petrucciano, F., 2019. Development and perspectives of ethical finance in
November 2020]
19. Phạm, B.D, 2013. Considering the development of rural finance in Vietnam. Journal of
2020]
20. Sahan, E., 2019. The economy has been rigged. We can change that. [pdf] Available at:
https://www.wittenborg-online.com/pluginfile.php/220892/mod_folder/content/0/rigged-
economy-issue-18%20%28E%20Sahan%2C%202019%29.pdf?forcedownload=1
21. Schenk, P., 2019. A matter of principle: Comparing norm-based explanations for Fair
22. Statista, 2020. Turkey - share of economic sectors in gross domestic product 2009-2019.
19
23. Strateji Ve Bütçe Başkanliği, 2019. Sürdürülebilir Kalkinma Amaçlari Değerlendirme
http://www.surdurulebilirkalkinma.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Surdurulebilir-
Kalkinma-Amaclari-Degerlendirme-Raporu_13_12_2019-WEB.pdf [Accessed 4
November 2020]
24. The international Fair Trade charter, 2018. The international Fair Trade charter. [pdf]
a5cfded0ef09.filesusr.com/ugd/291e20_d0760267b37a41328b80e4df127f85cb.pdf
25. The international Fair Trade charter, 2018. The international Fair Trade charter. [pdf]
a5cfded0ef09.filesusr.com/ugd/291e20_d0760267b37a41328b80e4df127f85cb.pdf
26. Tran Cong Thang, 2014. Overview of Agricultural Policies in Vietnam. FFTC-AP, Food
and Fertilizer Technology for the Asian and Pacific Region. [pdf] Available at:
27. UNCTAD, 2008, Annual report 2018 - Consider investment policy of Vietnam. [pdf]
28. UNESCO Tehran Cluster Office, 2017. UNESCO country strategy for the Islamic
http://www.unesco.org/new/fileadmin/MULTIMEDIA/FIELD/Tehran/images/Iran.pdf
29. VIRI, 2015. Assessment Of The Potential Development Of Fair Trade In Vietnam Tea,
Coffee, Cocoa, Spice And Handicrafts. Fair Trade Promotion Project in Vietnam Report.
20
[pdf] Available at: http://Fair Trade.org.vn/wp-content/uploads/tai-lieu-dao-tao/Bao-cao-
30. Vo Van Phong at al., 2011. Promotion of Organic and Fair Trade Cocoa in Vietnam:
31. Zajaczkowski, M., 2018. Ethical aspects of the world trading system on the example of
http://yadda.icm.edu.pl/yadda/element/bwmeta1.element.ojs-doi-10_18778_1899-
32. Zajaczkowski, M., 2018. Ethical aspects of the world trading system on the example of
http://yadda.icm.edu.pl/yadda/element/bwmeta1.element.ojs-doi-10_18778_1899-
21