Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Telephone: +44 (0)191 334 1961 Fax: +44 (0)191 334 1962 E-mail: ibru@durham.ac.uk Website: www.dur.ac.uk/ibru
Boundary & Territory Briefings
2 0 °W
internationally acknowledged expert in the
25°
Dronning Ma
u
W
d L
Falkland Islands / a nd
T
Islas Malvinas A
°E
B
45
field. 53
°W
60°
A
SOUTH Weddel
A
N
A
Sea
Au
TC
AMERICA
str
alia
74 °W
Australian
80 °W
n A n t a r c t i c Te r
Price of Briefings 90°W South Pole
Ant
rit
tic
or
lai
y
C
me
ir
cl
d
e
Se
Ross
PDF Copy £175** £25 Sea
ct
13
6°
o
E
r
14
2°
Ne
E
°W
w Zealand
Fr
150
Ro
an
ss D
Au stra tic T
ependency
ce
°E
A
An
u rc
Ad
st lian err
ta
él
ra
£499
ie
South Pacific
lia
La
Ocean
nd
ito
ry
Ceuta and the Spanish Sovereign Territorial Proposals for the Settlement
Territories: Spanish and Moroccan of War in Bosnia-Hercegovina
Claims Vol.1 No.3
Vol.1 No.2 Mladen Klemenc̆ ić
Gerry O’ Reilly Written over the course of the first two years of the war
Both Morocco and Spain claim sovereignty over the in Bosnia-Hercegovina, this briefing represents a unique
five territories of Ceuta, Melilla, Penon de Vélez de record of the various proposals for the partition of the
la Gomera, Penon de Alhucémas and the Chafarinas country put forward between the spring of 1991 and
Islands in North Africa. The most important of these May 1994. Drawing on local sources which were largely
is Ceuta which is located at the eastern entrance to the overlooked by Western media, Mladen Klemenc̆ i ć paints
Strait of Gibraltar. Spain claims these territories on a vivid picture of the disintegration of the ‘land of hidden
largely historical grounds: right of conquest, terra nullis hatred’ and the political machinations which undermined
principles and longevity of occupation. Spain stresses every attempt to resolve the conflict. The research is
that the majority of residents there are Spanish and wish drawn from the territorial claims and proposals of the
to remain under Spanish rule. It also argues that military Bosnian communities (made first to one another and
bases in the territories are important for Spanish national later to international mediators) and the proposals
security. Morocco argues that United Nations principles of assembled by international organisations in search of
decolonization should be applied, that Spanish occupation a solution to the ‘Bosnian knot’. This briefing explores
obstructs the economic and political independence of the the justifications for those territorial claims and positions
kingdom, and that the Spanish bases threaten Moroccan taken by the international community. The study is a
national security. Morocco also stresses that Spanish systematic analysis of the territorial dimensions of the
arguments for the recovery of the British Crown Colony struggle, within the greater chaos of events in Bosnia
of Gibraltar substantiate Morocco’s claim. Both countries during this critical period.
attempt to justify their claims in terms of the UN principle
of the territorial integrity of the state. This dispute has
on occasion reached boiling point, such as the face-off
between Moroccan and Spanish forces in July 2002 over
the islet of Perejil near Ceuta.
S PA I N N
Gibraltar (GB)
36°00'
Ceuta / Sebta
0 km 50
Mediterranean Sea
Islas
Melilla Chafarinas
The Boundary Between Ecuador and Cross-Border Crime in the Former Soviet
Peru Union
Vol.1 No.4 Vol.1 No.5
Ronald Bruce St John Mark Galeotti
Ronald Bruce St John first visited Ecuador and Peru in “For you [Westerners], borders represent barriers and
1968 and has been a regular commentator on Andean termini, for us they represent opportunities.” (Chechen
affairs since then, publishing more than 100 books and gangster, 1993)
articles. His timely and authoritative briefing traces the
From the assassination of a respected Russian television
historical roots of the boundary dispute between Ecuador
presenter to Moscow’s guerilla war in Chechnya, there
and Peru, analyses the legal cases of the two sides, and
have been numerous warnings indicating the extent to
discusses the various attempts that have been made to
which crime has exploded in all the post-Soviet states.
resolve the conflict from the Spanish arbitration of 1887
This is not only a problem of domestic politics, it has
to the present day.
direct implications for the rest of the world:
Note: Much of the material in this briefing has been
• for business executives looking towards investment
incorporated into the updated study in Boundary &
and operation within Eurasia;
Territory Briefing Vol. 3 No.1.
• for insurance firms being called upon to make risk
Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-12-8, 1994, 24pp assessments in the region;
• for financial institutions facing illegal money
laundering operations;
• for security analysts considering the potential
dangers posed by the new gangs, and their trade in
guns, narcotics and even nuclear materials;
• for every Westerner faced with the implications of
criminal penetration, from the eastwards flow of
stolen cars to the impact of cheaper eastern drugs on
the streets.
K A Z A K H S TA N
U Z B E K I S TA N Chu
Valley
Traffic North K Y R G Y S TA N
into Russia
Fergana N
● Tashkent Valley
Traffic North
into Russia
Cross - border
activity into
TA J I K I S TA N Xinjiang
Drugs,
Guns
Drugs INDIA
A F G H A N I S TA N Drugs
0 kilometres 300 PA K I S TA N
Herat Kabul
● ●
The Bolivia-Chile-Peru Dispute in the wide range of interrelated territorial, economic, and
political issues which defied energetic, creative attempts
Atacama Desert at settlement. Over time the controversy reached beyond
Vol.1 No.6 the original three protagonists to repeatedly involve other
regional powers, including the governments of Argentina,
Ronald Bruce St John Brazil, and the United States.
The Atacama Desert, situated on the central-west This briefing provides a detailed overview of the
coast of South America, is one of the more remote and Atacama Desert question, tracing the development of the
inhospitable areas in the world. In spite of its location this dispute from the early nineteenth century through to the
arid, sparsely inhabited region occupies a unique place in present day. Territorial changes and proposals are clearly
the contemporary pantheon of outstanding boundary and illustrated in a series of specially-drawn maps, and Dr St
territorial disputes. In a continent awash with territorial John’s commentary highlights the key events and actors
controversy the dispute in the Atacama Desert stands in this long and seemingly intractable dispute.
apart as one of the most involved and intractable. The
dispute reflects the conflicting geopolitical ambitions Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-14-4, 1994, 32pp
of Bolivia, Chile and Peru. It began before two of the
disputants won their independence from Spain, and it is
still active today, although the salient issues have changed
considerably over the last century.
Tiquina
Strait
16°
Copacabana
PERU
Desaguardero
a
am
S
BOLIVIA
Sama Grande Tacara
18° Tacna
Arica auc
L
A a
Vitor
Camarones
Ravine
B C
20°
Inquique
CHILE
Lo
a
22° Tocopilla
Calama
Cobija
San Pedro
Mejillones de Atacama
Calama
Antofagasta Final boundary Peru /
A Chile 1929
24° (1868)
Confirmed Chillean
B boundary after War
of Pacific 1883
Paposo C Final boundary 1904
Taltal 0 kilometres 200
o
d
26°S
72°W 70°
Sala 68°
Boundaries in Flux: The ‘Green Line’ The Evolution of the Egypt - Israel
Boundary Between Israel and the West Boundary: from Colonial Foundations to
Bank - Past, Present and Future Peaceful Borders
Vol.1 No.7 Vol.1 No.8
David Newman Nurit Kliot
Until 1967, the boundary between Israel and the West
The formation of the present Egyptian-Israeli border
Bank was known as the ‘Green Line’. This line, delimited
has taken place over a period of almost 80 years during
in the armistice agreement of 1949, was formally
which four wars have been fought between Israel and
removed in 1967 following the Israeli occupation of the
Egypt themselves, as well as two world wars involving
West Bank. However, it has continued to function as an
the colonial powers which formerly ruled Egypt and
important boundary between Israel and the Occupied
Israel/Palestine. The final border line thus reflects three
Territories, albeit with different, and constantly changing,
major factors:
formal and functional definitions.
• The colonial struggle which took place between
This briefing examines the history and present
Great Britain and the Ottoman Empire, with the
characteristics of the ‘Green Line’. It shows how
participation of such bystanders as Russia, Germany,
the ‘Green Line’ has been preserved as an important
France and Austria.
administrative and perceptual boundary since 1967. It
also examines, and proposes, scenarios in which the • The wars between Egypt and Israel, the most
‘Green Line’ (or a modified Green Line) will return to important being the 1948-9 war (the Israeli War of
become the eventual political boundary separating Israel Independence).
from a Palestinian state under a final peace agreement
between the two parties. • The Peace Treaty which was signed between Israel
and Egypt in 1979 and which provided the final
a Location of the water aquifier 0 km 20
b Location of Israeli settlements 0 km 20 formal recognition of the border line as a mutually
N N
Samaria
nea
Jordan
nea
Jordan
Trans-Samaria Route
ra
ra
e r
Jordan
e r
Valley
dit
River
River
JORDAN
Me
JORDAN
West Bank
Me
Gus Etzion
in the period 1949 to 1982 and the ‘cold peace’ which
developed along the boundary thereafter. In addition,
Dead Dead
Sea Southern Sea
Hebron Hills
Critical regions
Aquifer boundary
Water divide
Major concentrations of a special section is devoted to the Taba dispute and its
settlement.
in proximity Israeli settlements
to the ‘Green Line’ Direction of flow
c Region of Israeli 0 km 20
d Cross-boundary areas of 0 km 20
redemarcation Palestinian settlement
N Israeli Arab populations
Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-17-9, 1995, 21pp
Jordan
N
e a n
Israeli Arabs
Jordan
River
in the Triangle
a n
an
Region
r r
ne
t e
ra
d i
e r
River
JORDAN
JORDAN
t
M e
di
Jerusalem Jerusalem
The Riau Islands and Economic This briefing provides a detailed analysis of the Riau
Islands project and its consequences. It begins by
Cooperation in the Singapore - discussing the context for Indonesian-Singaporean
Indonesian Border Zone cooperation in the area and outlines the development
Vol.2 No.3 strategy being followed. It then examines the flagship
projects and their impact on the Riau islands. Finally, it
Karen Peachey, Martin Perry and Carl considers the influence of the project on the Indonesia-
Grundy-Warr Malaysia-Singapore Growth Triangle and the region in
general.
In the early 1990s, Indonesia’s Riau islands to the south of
Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-27-6, 1997, 59pp
Singapore experienced an investment boom. Singaporean
investment in infrastructure and management combined
with low operating costs in Indonesia produced dramatic
growth. Between 1988 and 1993, Batam, the closes Riau
island to Singapore, experienced population growth
of over 50%, an eight-fold increase in the value of its
exports and a fifteen-fold increase in annual private
investment. Similar rates of growth have also taken place
on the neighbouring islands of Bintan and Karimun.
How to Prove Title to Territory: a Brief, War or Peace on the Line of Control?: the
Practical Introduction to the Law and India - Pakistan Dispute over Kashmir
Evidence Turns Fifty
Vol.2 No.4 Vol.2 No.5
John McHugo Robert G Wirsing
This monograph is developed from a lecture given by The Kashmir dispute between Pakistan and India passed
John McHugo of Trowers and Hamlins at the IBRU the fiftieth anniversary of its formal origins in mid-
workshop on negotiating international boundaries in August 1997. It is one of the world’s longest-running
December 1997. Its purpose is to show readers how to boundary conflicts, with a record of interstate violence
assess the strength of a claim to a territory and how to which continues to justify maintenance of the United
prove it before an international tribunal (or in mediation Nations’ second oldest peacekeeping mission. Efforts by
or negotiations). It is based on eleven years’ experience the international community to mediate the dispute stretch
by the author assembling and collating evidence, writing back nearly the entire fifty years, and the two feuding
objective assesments of the strength of territorial claims, governments of India and Pakistan have themselves for
and preparing pleadings to substantiate them. the same length of time repeatedly attempted to sort out
their differences through bilateral talks. The dispute’s
The author sets out the basic rules for acquiring and
intractability, in the face of all these efforts, warrants it
maintaining title to territory in international law, giving
being clubbed amongst the world’s ‘conflicts unending’
concrete examples of how the conduct states has affected
the strength of their claims. He then turns his attention to
the evidence which can prove a claim, including the use
and value of archival material, maps and expert evidence.
Before concluding, he takes the reader through two of the
leading cases concerning title to territory this century, and
examines which arguments by the parties convinced the
Tribunal. This well thought out and clearly written paper
is designed in particular for diplomats and others who
have not previously acquired an in-depth background in
this area, but wish to develop quickly a grasp of how to
prove title to territory. It concentrates on the practical, and
explains concepts and technical terms in approachable
language, avoiding complicated jargon.
Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-29-2, 1998, 23pp
Lill
Indochina with the Treaty of Saigon in 1862 and
e B
Mandø
æ lt
Union in 1893. Where the former rulers of Cambodia, Rømø
ZO NE 1
I I
I I I I I
I I I I I
I I I
I I
N I I I I
I
Kiel
I
Ei
I
der I
I
I
l
na
I
Ri
I
ver
a
I
l C
I
I
I
I
ie
I
I
I
I
I I I I
K
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
HOL S TE IN
I
I
I
I
I
Dannewerk
I I
G E R M A N Y
I
I
1864 boundary
1920 boundary
Jutland Territories of the Kingdom 0 km 20
F
Louangphrabang ●
G Ceded to France, 23rd March 1907 dispute between Ecuador and Peru, sometimes referred
D E Retroceded to Thailand, 23rd March 1907
to as the Zarumilla-Marañón dispute, was one of the
n a
Nam N
A N
last unresolved issues dating from this period. After
complicating and disrupting inter-American relations
Ma e
E
Ban Chai Buri ● 0 kilometres 150
the dispute was finally settled with the signing of the
package of accords known as the Brasilia Agreements in
● Dan Sai
THAILAND Mukdahan ●
October 1998.
Khemmarat ●
● Nakhon Ratchasima ● Champasac (Bassac) 1 Zarumilla Zone 1942 Rio Protocol line
o
Battambang ● River Guepi Riv
Tonle Sap 6 Mouth of the Yaupi Zone Quito er Ca
q ueta
● Kampong Thom
Chantaburi ● 7 Bellavista Zone
● Kratie
Ri
ve
D E C U A D O R r P
utum
Trat ● Riv ay
er
Con
onaco
o
Ko Chang
C
River
FRENCH ay
Koh Kut River R i v er River Curar Y
Phnom Penh ● INDOCHINA Co
Pin
as
na
mbo toyac
un
Ri
Gulf 2°
u
7
i
er
v
Bo Rive
of bo r
ap
N
na
Saigon ● Guayaquil o
Thailand
za
5
Ri
ver
Ri
S
ve
Ti
6 re A
r
N
Riv
Co
ora
Y
rr
er Pastaz
A en
Zarumilla M
Ri
te
Ri
rZ
s
ver Santiago
Tumbes Iquitos
ve
1 e
Riv
River Ce
r M
4°
relevant case law, is to describe how these concepts
a
ango
ver Puy
Ri
o ro n a
g ar i t z a
nep
2
er
a
3 r Mar
ve
Ri
C h i n ch
Riv ipe
hi
C r
e
River
y
ca
U
River
r
v
e
6°S Jaén Ri
nc Moyobamba
a
abamba
0 kilometres 200
Boundaries, Borders and Peace War and Peace on the Danube: The
- Building in Southern Africa: the Evolution of the Croatia - Serbia
Spatial Implications of the ‘African Boundary
Renaissance’ Vol.3 No.3
Vol.3 No.2 Clive Schofield and Mladen Klemenc̆ i ć
Richard A Griggs The Croatia-Serbia border was the scene of some of the
Border and boundary problems have enormous most intense fighting that accompanied the disintegration
implications for peace-building and demilitarisation in of communist Yugoslavia in 1991. This Briefing offers
the Southern African Development Community (SADC). a historical overview of the evolution of the Croatia
On one hand, secessionist movements, conflicting state - Serbia boundary, detailing events in Eastern Slavonia
claims to territory, ethnic claims to state powers and between 1991 and 2001. The authors examine the success
territories, and the illegal movement of people and goods of UN efforts to defuse ethnic and nationalist tensions,
bring instability and conflict to the region. On the other and bring about dispute resolution through the peaceful
hand, the spatial plans associated with the concept of an reintegration of Eastern Slavonia into Croatia. Events
African Renaissance propose opportunities for building in the region in the aftermath of the UN’s withdrawal
stability, peace and prosperity through regionalisation, are also studied to identify remaining points of dispute,
cooperative management of resources and transport explore the prospects for the region and analyze whether
corridors that link Southern African economies. and how new borderland regional identities are being
forged in Eastern Slavonia. In addition, the authors
UGANDA TRANS AFRICA RAIL LINK outline the prospects for the emergence of a borderlands
identity in the region.
BENGUELA DEVELOPMENT Links the narrow guage railroads
CORRIDOR KENYA
north of Zambia with the wider
Links mining areas of Zaire guages to the south through
and Zambia to the DEMOCRATIC RWANDA
Nairobi a transhipment facility at
Angolan port of Lobito. REPUBLIC OF Kidatu, Tanzania.
THE CONGO
(formerly ZAIRE)
BURUNDI
Kikoma TANZANIA
This creates a Trans Africa
railway to stimulate North-South
trade through lower transport costs.
Including detailed maps and colour images, this briefing
Luanda
Dar es Salaam
TAZARA CORRIDOR
is essential for understanding the historical and political
Lobito
Benguela
Lumbumbashi
Kidatu
Links Tanzania and significant
areas of Zambia into the
aspects of the Croatia-Serbia boundary specifically, as
well as the variety of complications associated with a
MALAWI Benguela Development
Huambo
corridor
ANGOLA ZAMBIA MOZAMBIQUE
LUMBOMBO SPATIAL ˘
Knezevo Draz̆
Draz SERBIA
Gajić
Gajic Batina
DEVELOPMENT INITIATIVE
Links Durban and Maputo ( Vo j v o d i n a )
in a spatial development H U N G A R Y Branjina
initiative focussed on tourism Popovac Podolje
and agriculture. Zmajevac
TRANS-KALAHARI CORRIDOR ˘ ´
Secerana Branjin Vrh Kotlina
Ri
Pe
er
with those on the Atlantic to become ˘
Sumarina Beli Manastir
a major transport artery tied into Kamenac
Da
both the Maputo Corridor and Torjanci B. Petrovo ˘
Knezevi
Selo Karanac
Petlovac
nube
.. N. Bezdan
Novo Nevensinje ˘ Mede
Majiske
Development corridor . N. Bolman
.. Bolman Kozarac
Rail links
Jagodnjak Tikves˘
Grabovac Manor House
Graphics: J. McDowell ˘´
Belisce ˘
Ceminac
˘
Novi Ceminac
Tikves̆
Tikves
Valpovo Ugljes̆
Ugljes Lug
v e Bilje ˘
Kopacevo
r SE R B IA
D
Positioning and mapping techniques have advanced International boundary Dutch territory ceded to Portugal
(delimited by the 1904 Dutch - Portuguese (Article I of the 1904 convention)
convention and the 1914 award of the
Disputed territory allocated to Portugal
O’Kusi Tahakay
(Pante Macassar) Lakmaras
C
Pulu Batek D Maucatar
EAST
T I M OR
A
( O e c u s s i) B Tamiru
Ailala Suai
South West
Maucatar
▲ I N D O N E S I A
Bidjael T I M O R S E A
Sunan
0 kilometres 20
Noimutu
124°E 125°
Sea
of IS
E
Okhotsk R IL
KU R U S S I A N F E D E R AT I O N
Etorofu
Ta r t a r y
Sea Kunashiri
of in 1945, administered by Russia, Sakhalin D
S
N
Japan claimed by Japan Matsuwa To
A
lf of
L
Shasukota
I S
Shikotan Matsuwa To
Gu
Hokkaido
L
N O R T H R
I Rashuwa To
U
JA PA N Habomai
Kaiba To
K Shimoshiru To
Islands PA C I F I C Uruppu To
Rebun
Shima
O C E A N C H I N A Etorofu Shima
O Shima
Hachijo Shima
PHILIPPINES
0 kilometres 600
IA
SS
RU
Hokkaido
CHINA
Sea of Japan
Sagoda-shima
Seoul ● Ullung-do
Honshu
SOUTH Oki-Shoto JAPAN
Yellow KOREA ● Tokyo
Sea
Tsushima
Cheju-do
Shikoku
Kyushu P A C I F I C
East China
Sea O C E A N
S TAT E A
B A
S TAT E B
Acts of Piracy in the Malacca and Some Problems Relating to the Definition
Singapore Straits of ‘Insular Formations’ in International
Vol.1 No.4 Law: Islands and Low-tide Elevations
Robert Beckman, Carl Grundy-Warr and Vol.1 No.5
Vivian Forbes Clive Symmons
No less than 69 per cent of worldwide piracy attacks in Of the many possible sources of disagreement between
1992 occurred in south-east Asian waters. This briefing states over issues of maritime sovereignty and jurisdiction,
examines the issue of piracy in the busy waters of the the treatment of insular formations (i.e. islands, low-tide
Straits of Malacca and Singapore, and the jurisdictional elevations, islets, rocks, reefs, cays, etc) is probably the
rights of a coastal state with regard to piracy. The most complex and problematic. In some instances, the
changing historical nature of piracy in these straights is way an insular formation is defined can affect jurisdiction
examined, but the main focus of the study is on recent over literally thousands of square miles of ocean space.
efforts by the littoral states of Singapore, Malaysia and
This briefing sets out to highlight the key issues in the
Indonesia, as well as various other international bodies
definition of insular formations. Written by one of the
and shipping companies, to combat piracy in the region.
world’s leading legal experts in this area, the briefing
The authors argue that the current cooperative measures covers issues such as: the regimes attached to insular
by the littoral states seem to be having the desired effect formations in international law; insular sub-categories;
of reducing incidents of piracy attacks in the straits. the effect of government or estoppel on insular status;
Suggestions are also offered on how international and analysis of the ‘above-tide requirement’ in international
transboundary cooperation may be enhanced in future law; the optimal tidal choices for insular definition; and
should the current measures prove insufficient. the importance of locational permanence of an island.
Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-09-8, 1994 37pp Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-10-1, 1995 32pp
Maritime Briefings
reefs that uncover at low water and shoals that reach Barents Sea Severnaya
Zemlya
Novosibirskiye
● Pevek Bering
These descriptions have been based on the best available Zemlya ● Chokurdakh
●
Murmansk
Kara Sea ● Nizhneyansk
● Yamburg
The second part reviews the history of charting the 0 kilometres 1500
Nares Bk Reed
Bank Templer Bk
addition, this briefing takes a look at Soviet and Russian
Amy Douglas
Flat I Bk
Nanahan I
Sandy Sh
Seahorse or Routh Bk
jurisdiction policies towards the Arctic region.
Jackson Atoll Weed Brown Bk
Commodore
RI
8° Rf = Reef
Bk = Bank
Sh = Shoal
6°N
BO RNE O
116° 118°
Mir
na
Mischief Reef - the 44th outpost to be taken by one of
Novigrad
the claimants.
C R O AT I A
Istria
A D R I A T I C
S E A
Maritime Boundaries in the Baltic Sea : The Falkland Islands and their Adjacent
Past, Present and Future Maritime Area
Vol.2 No.2 Vol.2 No.3
Erik Franckx Patrick Armstrong and Vivian Forbes
This briefing documents the origins of the sovereignty
IA
dispute over these remote islands in the South Atlantic,
SS
Norwegian
RU
and traces its development over 200 years up through
Sea
0 nm 200
Hiiumaa I.
(Estonia)
Gotska ESTONIA 9
Sandön 1
(Sweden)
ARGENTINA
Saaremaa I.
Læsø (Denmark) (Estonia) RU SSIA
Gotland I.
Anholt (Denmark) (Sweden) 3 2 FICMZ
29
K
LATV IA 4
AR
(Sweden) EEZ
t
Bornholm
50°
19
(Denmark) Utklippan I.
DE
86
Kaliningrad
55°N Christiansø I. Falkland Islands
(RUSSIA)
(Denmark)
International maritime boundary
Greifswalder Oie OUTER
(Germany) Tripoint still to be delimited
1 12 ZONE
GE RM ANY POLAND Settled tripoints 26 Dec 1990
SPECIAL 11
10
AREA
10°E 15° 20° 25° 30° 9 8
27 Sep 1995
2 3
processes at work in the region between 1945 and the early 65° 60° 55°W
part of the 1990s when dramatic world events led to the
8
Island Disputes and the Law of the Sea: Basic Legal Issues of Joint Development
An Examination of Sovereignty and of Offshore Oil and Gas in Relation to
Delimitation Disputes Maritime Boundary Delimitation
Vol.2 No.4 Vol.2 No.5
Robert W Smith and Bradford L Thomas Masahiro Miyoshi
The use, or non-use, of islands in establishing national Maritime boundary negotiations between coastal states
jurisdiction over ocean space has been somewhat have become increasingly complicated, especially
inconsistent and troublesome on a global scale for many when hydrocarbon resources are present. This briefing
years. While on the one hand, islands are to be treated in show how joint development arrangements around the
the same manner as any mainland territory, the extent of world have been reached in connection with efforts
this ‘equal’ treatment is often disputed. Consideration of towards maritime boundary delimitation. It begins with
islands in the law of the sea is often influenced by their a brief history of joint development before dealing with
size, location, political status, and the nature of the island the following key issues: the basic concept of joint
itself. development; eight precedents of joint development in
the absence of boundaries and six precedents as part
Agreed maritime boundaries
IRAN Greater Tunb
● Bandar-e Abbas of boundary delimitation; a theoretical review of the
Lesser Tunb
Tunb as Sughra /
Tunb al Kubra /
Jazireh-ye Tonb-e Bozorg
Qeshm o rm
uz precedents, discussing the presence or absence of joint
of H
boundaries, definition of joint development, powers of
Jazireh-ye Tonb-e Kuchek
IR a it
QA AN S tr
TA
law of the sea, highlighting the major disputes involving Isla de San Andres
C A R I B B E A N S E A
Albuquerque Cay
SE
AW B e a u f o r t S e a
zones. In turn, the accurate definition of these lines and
AR
D
BOUN
D
A Reindeer Cross Island
features is dependent upon the tidal datum adopted in a
R
particular area.
72° Island
Re
Y
t
ur
Beechey Midway
n
Is
Point lan Islands
ds
Stump McC
Island Dinkum lur Vertical clearance - ID Tidal Gauge - IT Tidal Levels & Charted Data
Ste e
fan
sso
Sands Is
la
n S Narwhal
ou Island
nd
nd
IH 20
s
Prudhoe
Bay Charted elevation
HAT
MHWS HW datum (or MSL) Charted vertical clearance Charted HW
Spring range of tide (coast) line
MHWN
71°N if Dinkum Sands is an island
Neap range of tide
if Dinkum Sands is not an island Fo gg
y Is la
nd Ba y MSL
Land survey datum
Sea surface at any time
MLWN
Observed depth
MLWS Height of tide
A central notion in the case was whether there is such
(sounding) Drying height
Charted LW (drying) line
CD (usually LAT on
a phenomenon in international law as a ‘seasonal’ or BA charts)
Charted depth
‘occasional’ island. Although this was not international
litigation, it did directly involve international legal Planes of reference are not exactly as shown for all charts.
nm
0
Lan Yu 20
islands. The final section explores the possibility that Oluan Pi
Bashi Channel
circumstances might persuade one or both countries Pratas
Amianan I
North I
Ibayat
to argue that the line of equidistance would create an 20˚
Reef
20˚
C. Bojeador
Notable disputes which are considered include the
Treaty Limits
Canada-USA disagreements in the Dixon Entrance and
e
ta n c
Lincoln I C.
Bolinao
f qu
Bombay
Li n e o e
Reef
PHI L IP PIN ES
Scarborough
Reef
● Ketchikan Cabra I
Pri nce of Wal es I s l a n d
55°N
nd
Forrester
Island
Cape
Chacon
disputes (including disputes over rocks and islands)
‘A’
Canadian Claim
‘B’ throughout the region and their subsequent effects
on future boundary delimitation. Comprehensively-
Nunez
Cape
Rocks
Muzon
806 n.m. 2
Dundas
Island researched, this briefing gives a clear impression of how
Leamouth
at
St
d m
e s
the undelimited boundaries in this large and influential
Bank
Un
ite lai
C region might look in years to come.
D i x o n E n t r a n c e
Langara
Island Quee Stephen
Note: See also Maritime Briefing Vol.2 No.8 for
information concerning undelimited maritime boundaries
n C
ha rlot Island
te I
slands
of the Pacific Ocean excluding the Asian Rim.
Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-43-8, 2001, 68pp
H e c a t e
54°
Graham Island S t r a i t
SAUDI
AR AB IA
imit
imit
CZ L
waters (Part V)
STATE A EEZ
(Part V)
Ex
)
74
clu
State A Continental
siv
(A
Ec
om
on
ry
ic
Zo da
ne un
n
Bo
gi
Lim e
it (A STATE B EEZ
ntal Mar
High Seas im
rt. 5 rit
(Part VII) 7) Ma (Part V)
The Area
ne
implementing n
Co
agreement) Low Tide Elevation
(Art. 13)
Internal Waters
(Art. 8)
coral reefs and tourist attractions. Transit disputes dating Not to Scale
such as what does and does not constitute an island? The VIETNAM Tai Shan Tao CHINA
Vinh Thruc Nam
9
space is discussed. Finally, the study explores the avenues Dao Bach Long vi
oun
dar
y
10
p o r Area provided by
the technical expert in maritime boundary negotiations. 14 Re
Dao Bach Long vi
Sen-Chien Jiao
F1
HG 11
ui ito
di ria
16°N
L KJ I
st
12
an l d
M Channel
t L isp
112°E
Islands
in ute
0 kilometres 100
e:
(UK)
18°N
Hon Son Cha
108°E Ban Dao So’n Tra 110°E 112°E
Ushant
. Island
U .K E
C
AN
FR
48°N
N
F R A N C E The briefing is divided into two main sections. The first
of these traces the importance of the border disputes
between the two states and the way in which they were
10°W 8° 6° 4° 2°
Comprehensive in scope and clearly depicted, these two managed in the 1975-1991 period. The second, more
briefings take the mystey out of the technical details substantive, section is devoted to the developments
involved in maritime boundary delimitation. relating to the border disputes following the full
normalisation of bilateral relations in November 1991
Note: See also Maritime Briefing Vol.3 No.3 for to the end of 2000. The concluding section provides a
additional information on technical issues relating to critical analysis of the efforts of the two countries to
maritime boundary delimitation. manage their territorial disputes with a view of explaining
Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-47-0, 2002 68pp the progress achieved and tensions endured during the
1990s. It also encompasses a discussion relating to the
prospects for the future.
Paperback, ISBN 1-897643-48-9, 2002 80pp
Maritime Briefings
experts, soldiers and journalists. The bulletin * A charge for postage and packing will be
added to all printed publication orders.
also offered reviews of significant conferences,
** Volumes 1-6 are not available in PDF
seminars and exhibitions, and provided a forum format
Listed by region and theme: The Great Lakes Conflict and Spatial
Designs for Peace: A Neorealist Analysis
AFRICA 1997; Vol. 4 No. 4
Somaliland: Passing the Statehood Test? Richard Griggs
2000; Vol. 8 No. 3 The Boundaries of Afrikaner Self-
Peggy Hoyle determination
Caprivi Strip: World Court Awards Islands (995; Vol. 3 No. 2
to Botswana Richard Griggs
2000; Vol. 8 No. 2 Boundaries and War in Africa in 1995
Alan Perry 1995; Vol. 3 No. 1
Facts on the Ground: War and Peace in the Richard Griggs
Horn of Africa, May-June 2000 The Boundaries of a New South Africa
2000; Vol. 8 No. 2 1995; Vol. 2 No. 4
Justin Pearce Richard Griggs
Breaking Down the Barricades Rwanda in Crisis: Why are we Surprised?
1999; Vol. 7 No. 3 1994; Vol. 2 No. 3
John Warburton-Lee A B Featherstone
Bad Times in Badme: Bitter War Continues A Note on the International Court of Justice
Along the Eritrea-Ethiopia Border Ruling on the Chad - Libya Dispute
1999; Vol. 7 No. 1 1994; Vol. 2 No. 1
Margaret Fielding Gerald Blake
Gulf of Guinea Boundary Disputes The Bondage of Boundaries
1999; Vol. 7 No. 1 1994; Vol. 2 No. 1
Daniel J Dzurek Ali A Mazrui
The Return of the Old Guard: Boundary and
Security Implications of the Congo War AMERICAS
1998; Vol. 6 No. 3
Richard Griggs The World’s Longest Defended Border: A
Return to the Days of Militarisation
The Eritrea - Ethiopia Border Conflict 2002; Vol. 9 No. 4
1998; Vol. 6 No. 2 David Bercuson
Jean-Louis Peninou
Navassa: Legal Nightmare in a Biological
Creating Geographies of Peace: Provinces, Heaven?
Referenda and Spatial Decision-making in 2001; Vol. 9 No. 3
South Africa Fabio Spadi
1998; Vol. 5 No. 4
Richard Griggs The Work and Value of International
Boundary Commissions: The Canadian /
American Experience
The Boundaries of an African Renaissance
2001; Vol. 9 No. 3
1997; Vol. 5 No. 2
Michael O’ Sullivan
Richard Griggs
The Guyana - Suriname Maritime Boundary
Dispute and its Regional Context
2001; Vol. 9 No. 2
Peggy A Hoyle
Boundary & Security Bulletins
The Maritime Boundary Dispute Between Conflict in the Cordillera del Cóndor: The
Honduras and Nicaragua in the Caribbean Ecuador - Peru Dispute
Sea 1996; Vol. 4 No. 1
2001; Vol. 9 No. 2 Ronald Bruce St John
Martin Pratt
Territorial Implications of Quebec’s
The US - Mexico International Boundary Referendum
and Water Commission in the Sustainable 1996; Vol. 3 No. 4
Development Era Stephen P Mumme & Pamela Duncan
2001; Vol. 9 No. 2
Stephen P Mumme Fishing Beyond the Limit: the Canada -
European Union Dispute
Discovering Rocks Off Labrador: A Photo 1995; Vol. 3 No. 1
Essay Douglas Day
2000; Vol. 8 No. 2
David H Gray Transboundary Dimensions of Petroleum
Development in Ecuador and Peru
Chile, Peru and the Treaty of 1929: The 1995; Vol. 3 No. 1
Final Settlement Edward Korzetz
2000; Vol. 8 No. 1
Ronald Bruce St John Falkland Islands Hydrocarbon Exploration
1995; Vol. 2 No. 4
US - Mexico Borderlands Studies at the Patrick Armstrong
Millennium
2000; Vol. 7 No. 4 Canada Asserts Jurisdiction over High Seas
Stephen P Mumme Fisheries
1994; Vol. 2 No. 2
The International Peace Garden: A Case William V Dunlap
Study in Locational Harmony
1999; Vol. 7 No. 3 Falklands Oil
Stanley D Brunn & Douglas C Munski 1994; Vol. 2 No. 2
Patrick Armstrong
Ecuador - Peru Endgame
1999; Vol. 6 No. 4 Stalemate in the Atacama
Ronald Bruce St John 1994; Vol. 2 No. 1
Ronald Bruce St John
Canada’s Unresolved Maritime Boundaries
1997; Vol. 5 No. 4 The Hardening of the United States
David H Gray - Mexican Borderlands: Causes and
Consequences
Doughnut Holes in the Gulf of Mexico 1994; Vol. 1 No. 4
1997; Vol. 5 No. 3 Edward J Williams & Irasema Coronado
David Applegate
The Gulf of Fonseca and St Pierre and
After NAFTA: Trade Integration and the Miquelon Cases
Border Three Years On 1993; Vol. 1 No. 1
1997; Vol. 5 No. 2 Keith Highet
Stephen P Mumme & Donna Lybecker
The Laguna del Desierto Case Between
Ecuador and Peru Discuss Border Impasses Argentina and Chile
1997; Vol. 5 No. 2 1993; Vol. 1 No. 1
Bradford L Thomas Marcelo G Kohen
Boundary & Security Bulletins
The Maritime Limits of the Falkland Islands The Moscow Declaration, the Year 2000 and
1993; Vol. 1 No. 1 Russo - Japanese Deadlock over the ‘Four
Patrick Armstrong & Vivian L Forbes Islands’ Dispute
1999; Vol. 6 No. 4
ASIA - PACIFIC Yakov Zinberg
The Association of South-East Asian Cross-border Crime and the Grey Area
Nations and the Management of Territorial Phenomena in southeast Asia
Disputes 1998; Vol. 6 No. 3
2002; Vol. 9 No. 4 Peter Chalk
Ramses Amer Between Deterrence and Cooperation: East
What Vietnam Could Gain from Redrawing Asian Security after the ‘Cold War’
its Baselines 1998; Vol. 6 No. 2
2002; Vol. 9 No. 4 Liselotee Odgaard
Johan Henrik Nossum Russia’s Far East - Russian or Eastern?
Disorder in Megawati’s ‘New’ Indonesia 1998; Vol. 6 No. 1
2001; Vol. 9 No. 3 Mark Galeotti
Lesley McCulloch The Uncertainties of Middleton and
Geopolitics of Drugs and Cross-Border Elizabeth Reefs
Relations: Burma - Thailand 1998; Vol. 6 No. 1
2001; Vol. 9 No. 1 Victor Prescott
Carl Grundy-Warr & Elaine Wong The Australia - Indonesia Maritime
Land Boundaries of Indochina Boundary Delimitation Treaty
2001; Vol. 9 No. 1 1998; Vol. 5 No. 4
Ronald Bruce St John Vivian L Forbes
The China - Vietnam Border Delimitation The Kurile Islands Dispute: Towards Dual
Treaty of 30 December 1999 Sovereignty
2000; Vol. 8 No. 1 1998; Vol. 5 No. 4
Nguyen Hong Thao Yakov Zinberg
The Question of East Timor’s Maritime The Tumen River Area Development
Boundaries Programme
2000; Vol. 7 No. 4 1998; Vol. 5 No. 4
Victor Prescott Richard Pomfret
Joint Development in the Gulf of Thailand Sanctuary Under a Plastic Sheet: The
1999; Vol. 7 No. 3 Unresolved Problem of Rohingya Refugees
Nguyen Hong Thao 1997; Vol. 5 No. 3
Carl Grundy-Warr & Elaine Wong
Scarborough Reef: A New Flashpoint in
Sino-Philippine Relations? Vietnam’s First Maritime Boundary
1999; Vol. 7 No. 2 Agreement
Zou Keyuan 1997; Vol. 5 No. 3
Nguyen Hong Thao
Boundary & Security Bulletins
Border Conflicts Between Cambodia and China Occupies Mischief Reef in Latest
Vietnam Spratly Gambit
1997; Vol. 5 No. 2 1995; Vol. 3 No. 1
Ramses Amer Daniel J Dzurek
Ethnic, Religious and Political Conflict Recent Developments on the Thai - Burma
on China’s Northwestern Borders: The Border
Background to the Violence in Xinjiang 1995; Vol. 3 No. 1
1997; Vol. 5 No. 1 Bertil Lintner
Michael Dillon
Cross-Border Wildlife Trade in Ratanakiri
Japan’s Ratification of UN Law of the Sea Province, Cambodia
Convention and its New Legislation on the 1994; Vol. 2 No. 3
Law of the Sea Marcus J Phipps
1997; Vol. 4 No. 4
Yutaka Kawasaki-Urabe & Vivian L Forbes Khmer Rouge Territoriality in Pre- and Post-
Election Cambodia
Straddling Stocks in the Barents Sea 1994; Vol. 2 No. 3
Loophole Carl Grundy-Warr
1997; Vol. 4 No.
William V Dunlap The Halockani Incident and the Redefinition
of a Boundary Issue Between Burma and
The Vladivstok Curve: Subnational Thailand
Intervention into Russo - Chinese Border 1994; Vol. 2 No. 3
Agreements Ananda Rajah
1996; Vol. 4 No. 3
Yakov Zinberg A Pollock-Fishing Agreement for the Central
Bering Sea
Partitioned States, Divided Resources: 1994; Vol. 2 No. 2
North / South Korea and Cases for William V Dunlap
Comparison
1996; Vol. 4 No. 2 An Arms Race in the South China Sea?
Peter Hocknell 1994; Vol. 2 No. 2
Clive Schofield
The People’s Republic of China Straight
Baseline Claim Managing Boundaries in the South China
1996; Vol. 4 No. 2 Sea
Daniel J Dzurek 1994; Vol. 2 No. 2
Greg Englefield
The Sino - Russian Boundary Settlement
1996; Vol. 4 No. 2 Emerging Asian Growth Circles: An
Eric Hyer Example in Between South-east Asia and
China
Cross-Border Migrations, Trafficking 1994; Vol. 2 No. 1
and the Sex Industry: Thailand and its Lim Joo-Jock
Neighbours
1996; Vol. 4 No. 1 Preah Vihear and the Cambodia - Thailand
Carl Grundy-Warr, Rita King & Gary Risser Borderland
1994; Vol. 1 No. 4
Indonesia’s Maritime Claims and Ronald Bruce St John
Outstanding Delimitation Problems
1996; Vol. 3 No. 4
Victor Prescott
Boundary & Security Bulletins
The Boundaries, Internal Order and Boundaries and the Internet: A Surfer’s
Identities of Bosnia and Herzegovina Guide
2001; Vol. 8 No. 4 1999; Vol. 7 No. 2
Mladen Klemenc̆ ić Martin Pratt
Brave New Borderless State: Illegal The Impact of the Greek Military
Immigration and the External Borders of the Surveillance Zone: On the Greek Side
EU of the Side of the Bulgarian - Greek
2000; Vol. 8 No. 3 Borderlands
Shelagh Furness 1999; Vol. 7 No. 2
Lois Labrianidis
Football Across the Ethnic Divide
2000; Vol. 8 No. 3 Gibraltar: Sovereignty Dispute and
Mladen Klemenc̆ ić Territorial Waters
1999; Vol. 7 No. 1
Borderlands: An Unlikely Tourist Gerry O’ Reilly
Destination
2000; Vol. 8 No. 1 Kosovo: What Solutions for Albanians in
Dallen J Timothy the “Cradle of the Serbian People”?
1999; Vol. 6 No. 4
International Boundaries: The Next Mladen Klemenc̆ i ć
Generation
2000; Vol. 7 No. 4 The Objectives of Land Boundary
William V Dunlap Management
1998; Vol. 6 No. 3
Into the Millennium: The Study of Gerald Blake
International Boundaries in an Era of Global
and Technological Change Dayton in the Balance: The Continuing
2000; Vol. 7 No. 4 Dispute over Brcko
David Newman 1998; Vol. 6 No. 1
Mladen Klemenc̆ i ć & Clive Schofield
The Border Agreement Between Croatia and
Bosnia-Herzegovina: The First But Not the Ireland and the Rockall Dispute
Last 1998; Vol. 6 No. 1
2000; Vol. 7 No. 4 Clive Symmons
Mladen Klemenc̆ ić
Problems, Progress and Prospects in a
What Makes Some Boundary Disputes Post-Soviet Borderland: The Republic of
Important? Moldova
2000; Vol. 7 No. 4 1997; Vol. 5 No. 1
Daniel J Dzurek Trevor Waters
Permeating the Irish Border: Practical The Chameleon Territory of South
North-South Cooperation Under the Belfast Schleswig (Slesvig): Fluctuations in the
Agreement Perceptions of National Identity
1999; Vol. 7 No.3 1997; Vol. 5 No. 1
Austen Morgan Norman Berdichevsky
Boundary & Security Bulletins
Kaliningrad: NATO and EU Enlargement The Role of the United Nations in the
Issues Focus New Attention on Russia’s Balkans
Border with Central Europe 1995; Vol. 3 No. 2
1996; Vol. 4 No. 3 Yasushi Akashi
Lyndelle D Fairlie
United Nations Peacekeeping
Mostar: Make or Break for the Federation? 1995; Vol. 3 No. 1
1996; Vol. 4 No. 2 Colin Warbrick
Mladen Klemenc̆ ić & Clive Schofield
Croatia and Slovenia: The ‘Four Hamlets’
Philatelic Propaganda: Stamps in Territorial Case
Disputes 1995; Vol. 2 No. 4
1996; Vol. 4 No. 2 Mladen Klemenc̆ i ć & Clive Schofield
Todd Pierce
Northern Ireland - A Time of Hope
The Imia / Kardak Rocks Dispute in the 1995; Vol. 2 No. 4
Aegean Sea Dick Spring
1996; Vol. 4 No. 1
Martin Pratt & Clive Schofield Operating in Bosnia
1994; Vol. 2 No. 3
The Question of NATO Expansion Alastair Duncan
1996; Vol. 4 No. 1
Roland Dannreuther The Criminal Implications of the ‘Soft
Borders’ of the Former Soviet Union
Some Lessons from the 1924-25 Irish 1994; Vol. 2 No. 3
Boundary Commission Mark Galeotti
1996; Vol. 3 No. 4
Gerald Blake Effects of the Economic and Political
Changes in Eastern Europe for the
The Geography and Geopolitics of Europe’s Hungarian - Austrian Border Region -
Fourth World Results of a Research Project
1996; Vol. 3 No. 4 1994; Vol. 2 No. 1
Richard Griggs & Peter Hocknell Wolfgang Aschauer
Fourth World Faultlines and the Remaking Northwest Bohemia: A Central European
of ‘International’ Boundaries Border region in Transition
1995; Vol. 3 No. 3 1994; Vol. 2 No. 1
Richard Griggs & Peter Hocknell Hans-Joachim Burkner
Summer Storms Over the Balkans Relations Across the Boundaries Between
1995; Vol. 3 No. 3 the Old and the New Lander in Germany
Mladen Klemenc̆ ić & Clive Schofield after Reunification: Which Side Makes More
Profit?
An UNhappy Birthday in the Former 1994; Vol. 2 No. 1
Yugoslavia: A Croatian Border War Wilfried Heller
1995; Vol. 3 No. 2
Mladen Klemenc̆ ić & Clive Schofield The Crimea: Russia’s Ukrainian Peninsula
1994; Vol. 1 No. 4
The Cossacks: A Cross-Border Mark Galeotti
Complication to Post-Soviet Eurasia
1995; Vol. 3 No. 2 The Maastricht Treaty
Mark Galeotti 1994; Vol. 1 No. 4
Jacques Delors
Boundary & Security Bulletins
Israel and Jordan: Bridges over the Cooperative Preparations for Determining
Borderlands the Outer Limit of the Juridicial Continental
1995; Vol. 2 No. 4 Shelf in the Arctic Ocean
John Roberts 2001; Vol. 9 No. 1
Ron Macnab, Paul Neto & Rob van de Poll
Territorial Disputes of the Middle East
Peace Process The Exploitation of Antarctica’s Natural
1994; Vol. 2 No. 3 Resources and the Evolution of the
David Newman Antarctic Treaty System: An Overview
1995; Vol. 3 No. 3
The Iraq - Kuwait Boundary Dispute: Tom Cioppa
Historical Background and the UN
Decisions of 1992 and 1993 A Natural Reserve, Devoted to Peace and
1994; Vol. 2 No. 3 Science: Antarctica Today
Harry Brown 1993; Vol. 1 No. 1
Peter J Beck
Civil War in Yemen
1994; Vol. 2 No. 2
John Roberts
Boundary & Security Bulletins
Editors: Gerald Blake, Martin Pratt, Clive As international political and economic relations
Schofield and Janet Allison Brown have become increasingly complex, so have
the pressures on international boundaries and
This collection of papers by leading experts the borderlands which surround them. Although
explores the relationship between boundaries there are still many examples of ‘traditional’
and energy on land and at sea. Global boundary problems associated with disputes
overviews are combined with detailed case between states concerning control over territory
studies to produce a comprehensive survey of and maritime space, the papers in this volume
the key issues confronting governments and demonstrate the vulnerability of borderlands to
the energy industry in this increasingly complex other forces, most notably illegal immigration
area. Contributors also discuss a range of ideas and cross-border crime. This book aims to
for overcoming boundary-related problems investigate the causes and implications of
which are hindering the development of energy borderland stress. The papers in this volume
resources in various parts of the world. The represent the proceedings of the fifth IBRU
papers in this volume represent the proceedings international conference in 1998.
of the fourth IBRU conference in July 1996.
International Boundaries Study Series
Published by Kluwer Law International, 2000 edge on which hangs suspended the modern
ISBN: 90-411-9790-7, 446pp issues of war and peace, of life and death
(http://www.kluwerlaw.com) to nations”) the book contains a fascinating
selection of papers written by colleagues and
BOUNDARIES OF COOPERATION: former students reflecting the main thematic
CYPRUS, DE FACTO PARTITION AND THE and regional interests of Professor Gerald Blake
DELIMITATION OF TRANSBOUNDARY during his long and distinguished career as a
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT political geographer and boundary scholar.