Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The pursuit of youth and beauty has Extrinsic factors are preventable envi- dures such as light chemical peels and
become a hallmark of the baby-boomer ronmental influences leading to prema- microdermabrasion. Category II patients
generation, which has now advanced to ture aging of the skin, including ultravio- are in their thirties, with early to moderate
midlife and beyond. The distinct increase let (UV) exposure, smoking, chemicals, signs of photoaging and characterized by
in an older population due to newer med- and gravity. UV exposure is the primary wrinkles in motion. Category III patients
ical and technological advancements and environmental factor, preferentially affect- have moderate to advanced photoaging
career development has brought a larger ing those with a lighter skin color. The with static wrinkles requiring more signif-
healthy population interested in cosmetic mechanism includes the production of icant ablative resurfacing techniques. Cat-
procedures. This mid-age population has UV-inducing oxygenated fine radiants egory IV patients are the oldest, with more
remained active in the workforce and now that have been shown to invite a cascade of severe photoaging changes and wrinkles
demands "no downtime" procedures for molecular events leading to the produc-
skin rejuvenation that will maintain their tion of collagen-degrading enzymes. This
appearance for work and pleasure. This creates the characteristic features of pho- Table 69-1 Glogau's Classification of
Photoaging
has encouraged the development of new toaging, including rough texture, atrophy,
lasers, new fillers, botulinum toxin, cos- fine and coarse wrinkles, and sallow and Group I: Mild (typically age 28-35 years)
moceuticals, and many other innovations leathery appearance with dyschromia.' A. Little wrinkling or scarring
that have reduced the downtime and In the evaluation of the patient with B. No keratoses
increased the safety of our cosmetic facial photoaging, equal emphasis must be C. Requires little or no makeup
rejuvenation procedures. Anyone interest- placed on prevention as well as treatment. Group II: Moderate (age 35-50 years)
ed in providing facial cosmetic procedures Agents available range from cosmoceutical A. Early wrinkling; mild scarring
and surgery needs to become familiar with topical agents to filling agents that include B. Sallow color with early actinic
all the procedures now available. resurfacing devices such as chemical peels, keratoses
Aging of the skin is the combined result C. Little makeup
ablative resurfacing lasers, and dermabra-
of both intrinsic factors and extrinsic exter- sion. An initial consultation is performed Group III: Advanced (age 50-65 years)
nal influences from the environment. to determine which of these tools is best A. Persistent wrinkling or moderate
Intrinsic aging is the roles that genetics plays acne scarring
for the patient based on severity and diver-
B. Discoloration with telangiectasias
in relation to chronologic age. These include sity of the condition.
and actinic keratoses
alteration of skeletal mass and proportion, Methods to evaluate photoaging
G. Wears makeup always
atrophy and redistribution of subcutaneous include the Glogau classification of wrin-
Group IV; Severe (age 60-75 years)
fat, increased laxity of underlying fascia and kles. It classifies patients into one of four
A. Wrinkling: photoaging, gravitafional,
musculature, and skin changes character- groups based on degree of severity (Table
and dynamic
ized by thinning and atrophy. Most intrinsic 69-1). Category I patients are young, with B. Actinic keratoses with or without
factors cannot be prevented, but rejuvena- "no wrinkles" and minimal photoaging skin cancer or severe acne scars
tive changes can be made with cosmoceuti- and are best managed with cosmoceutical G. Wears makeup with poor coverage
cal agents and resurfacing procedures. agents and superficial resurfacing proce-
1420 Part 9: Facial Esthetic Surgery
significant enough to justiiy deep resurfac- index (Table 69-3). This system categorizes Table 69-2 Classification of Ablative
ing and other surgical techniques.^ the visual changes in photoaging skin and Skin Resurfacing Methods'^
Ablative resurfacing injures the skin in quantitates the amount to guide the physi-
Superficial: VeryLight^
a controlled fashion to a specific depth, cian with appropriate therapy. The system
encouraging the growth of new and combines age-related textural and lesional Low-potency formulations ot glycoHc
improved skin. These methods include changes into a numeric system that will acid or other alpha-hydroxy acid
chemical peeling, dermabrasion, and laser predict how aggressive a physician should 10-20% TCA (weight-to-volume
resurfacing. Skin resurfacing techniques be in using superficial, medium-depth, and formulation)
are divided into superficial, medium deep resurfacing procedures.^ Jessner's solution (see Table 69-3)
Tretinoin
depth, and deep, relating to the level of
Medical Care of Salicylic acid
injury (Figure 69-1). The deeper proce-
Photoaging Skin Microdermabrasion
dures are restricted to the face since other
body areas do not have the healing capaci- The basis of all rejuvenative therapy Superficial: Light^
ty to rejuvenate new skin after such an involves using sunscreen protection and
injury. Care must also be taken with the cosmoceutical preparations that will help 70% glycolic acid
neck, which may scar with medium-depth reverse photoaging changes. These prod- [essner's solution
or deep injury.^ 25-30% TCA
ucts include sunscreens, retinoids, hydroxy
Solid CO: slush
Table 69-2 presents a useful classifica- acids, antioxidants, and bleaching agents
Microdermabrasion
tion system for categorizing skin resurfac- as needed.
ing methods. It is based on the objective Ultraviolet damage is caused by both Medium-Depth
data collected by Stegman, who correlated UVB (290 to 320 nm) and UVA (320 to
strengths of trichloroacetic acid (TCA) by 400 nm). Both the burning rays of UVB 88% phenol
and the more deeply penetrant UVA cause 3 5 ^ 0 % TCA
biopsy of depth of tissue destruction and
Iessner's-35% TCA
then new collagen rejuvenation.•* Thus problems of photocarcinogenesis and
70% glycolic acid-35% TCA
superficial, medium depth, and deep resur- photoaging of the dermis. Most sun-
Solid CO2-35% TCA
facing correlates modalities of peeling, der- screens provide adequate protection
Conservative manual dermasanding
mabrasion, and laser to common denomi- against the burning effects of UVB but ErbiumiYAG laser resurfacing
nators; namely, inflammation and injury.'* deliver only partial protection against Conservative CO^ laser resurfacing
A useful method of assessing skin- UVA. Sunscreens are divided into chemi-
related photoaging is the Monheit-Fulton cal and physical blockers. The chemical Deep
Table 69-3 . Monheit-Fulton Index of Photoagiiig bSn -PI screens include oxybenzene, para-
1 aminobenzoic acid, and octyl methoxycin-
Texture Changes Points Score
namate. The physical blockers nowadays
Wrinkles—dynamic 1 2 3 4 are transparent micronized formulations
(% of potential lines) < 25% < 50% < 75% < 100% of titanium dioxide and afford more com-
Wrinkles—photoaging 1 2 3 4 plete UVA and UVB protection.*
(% of potential lines) <25% < 50% < 75% < 100% Topical retinoids have a direct effect on
Cross-hatched lines—fine lines 1 2 3 4 epidermal cell proliferation and dermal
(% of potential lines) < 10% <20% < 40% < 60% collagen growth. Tbey have demonstrated
significant effects on photoaging skin
Sallow color and dyschromia 1 2 3 4
including dyschromias, epidermal
Dull Yellow Brown Black
growths, and fine wrinkle lines. The Feder-
Leathery appearance 1 2 3 4 al Drug Administration has approved topi-
Crinkly (thin and parchment) 1 2 3 4 cal retinoids for the treatment of aging and
Pebbly (deep vi'hitish nodules) 2 4 6 8
photodamaged skin in the form of
(% of face) <25% < 50% < 75% < 100% tretinoin cream (0.05% or 0.02%) and
most recently tazarotene cream 0.1%. Use
Pore no. and size 2 4 6 8
of a retinoid with a sunscreen is basic in
< 25% < 50% < 75% < 100%
skin care for photoaging skin problems. It
Lesions Points Score is also used prior to resurfacing procedures
lYeckies—mottled skin I 2 3 4
to enhance the epidermal and dermal
(no. present) < 10 <25 <50 <100 regenerative effect after resurfacing injury.^
Lentigenes (dark/irregular) 2 4
Hydroxy acids have become a part of
6 8
and SKs (size) < 5 mm < 10 mm < 15 mm < 20 mm
skin care programs for their effect on thin-
ning the stratum corneum and decreasing
Telangiectasias—erythema 1 2 3 4
epidermal cell cohesion. This has a regen-
flush (no. present) <5 < 10 < 15 > 15
erative effect on epidermal cell kinetics,
Actinic keratoses and 2 4 6 8 giving the skin texture a plumper rejuve-
seborrheic keratoses <5 < 10 < 15 > 15 native appearance. There is little definitive
(no. present)
evidence that topical alpba-hydroxy acids
Skin cancers (no. present— 2 4 6 8 have an effect on dermal collagen per se.^
now or by history) ica 2ca 3ca >4ca Topical antioxidants have shown an
Senile comedones 1 2 3 4 effect in retarding the reactive oxygen
(in cheekbone area) <5 < 10 <20 >20 species created by ultraviolet damage. Vit-
amin C (ascorbic acid) has been shown to
Total Score
be a potent scavenger of free oxygen radi-
als. Topical products have shown activity
Corresponding Rejuvenation Program in the experimental mode but clinical effi-
Score Needs cacy as of yet is anecdotal. Vitamin E is a
lipid-soluble antioxidant that has become
1-6 Skin-care program with tretinoin, glycoiic acid peels
popular in topical form, but little true
7-11 Same plus lessner's peel; pigmented lesion laser and/or vascular laser
12-16 Same plus medium peel—Jessner's-TCA peel; skin fillers and/or
objective data are present to document its
botulinum toxin effect on photoaging sldn.*^
17 or more Above plus laser resurfacing
Chemical Peeling
Chemical peeling remains one of the most
popular choices for both patient and physi-
Staff Signature Date Patien Signature Date cian. In comparison to some of the newer
options available, chemical peels have a
1422 Part 9: Facial Esthetic Surgery
long-standing safety and efficacy record, are unique advantages. These products are
performed with ease, are low in cost, and often expensive and have not been
have a relatively quick recovery time. Vari- unequivocally shown to be safer or more
ous acidic and basic compounds are used to effective than tbe conventional solutions.
produce a controUed skin injury and are Tbe following sections will therefore
classified as superficial, medium-depth, and focus on the specific chemical agents that
deep peeling agents according to their level are actively responsible for producing the
of penetration, destruction, and inflamma- various patterns of injury.
tion (see Table 69-2). In general superficial
peels cause epidermal injury and occa- Superficial Chemical Peeling
sionally extend into the papillary dermis, Superficial chemical peels are indicated
medium-depth peels cause injury through in the management of acne and its
the papillary dermis to the upper reticular postinflammatory erythema, mild pho- FIGURE 69-2 A, Irregular surface. B, Clean regu-
dermis, and deep peels cause injury to the toaging (Glogau I and II), epidermal lar surface. \
midreticular dermis.'* growths such as lentigines and keratoses,
Prior to tbe application of peeling as well as melasma and other pigmentary Alpha-hydroxy acid (AHA) peeling
solutions the surgeon must vigorously dyschromias. Multiple peels on a repeat- agents have been used widely in skin reju-
cleanse the skin surface to remove resid- ed basis are usually necessary to obtain venation programs since the early 1990s.
ual oils, debris, and excess stratum optimal results. The firequency of peels The depth of injury is determined by the
corneum. The face is initially scrubbed and degree of exposure to the peeling specific AHA used, its pH, the concentra-
with 4" X 4" gauze pads containing 0.25% agent may be increased gradually as nec- tion of free acid, the volume applied to the
Irgasan (Septisol solution; Calgon Vestal essary. Results are enhanced by medical skin, and the duration of contact or time
Laboratories, St. Louis, MO, USA), tben or cosmoceutical therapy." All superfi- that the agent is left on tbe skin before neu-
rinsed with water and dried. Because of cial chemical peels share the advantages tralization.^ In low concentrations (20 to
the defatting and degreasing properties of only mild stinging and burning during 30%), AHAs have been shown to decrease
of acetone, gauze pads moistened in an application as well as minimal time the cohesion of corneocytes at the junction
acetone preparation are then used to needed for recovery. They are a part of of the stratum corneum and the stratum
cleanse the skin even fixrther. The impor- office-based procedures.'^ granulosum, whereas higher concentra-
tance of cleansing in the peeling proce- Superficial chemical peels are divided tions (up to 70%) are associated with com-
dure cannot be overemphasized. A thor- into two varieties; very light and light (see plete epidermolysis. Weekly or biweekly
ough and evenly distributed cleansing Table 69-2). With very light peels the injury applications of -^0 to 70% unbuffered gly-
and degreasing of tbe face assures uni- is usually limited to the stratum corneum colic acid witb cotton swabs, a sable brush,
form penetration of the peeling solution and only creates exfoHation, but tbe injury or 2" X 2" gauze pads have been used most
and leads to an even result without skip may extend into the stratum granulosum. often for acne, mild photoaging, and
areas {Figure 69-2).'° The agents used for these peels include low melasma.** The time of apphcation is criti-
The effect of a chemical peel is depen- potency formulations of glycoHc acid, 10 to cal for glycolic acid, as it must be rinsed off
dent upon the agent used, its concentra- 20% TCA, Jessner's solution (Table 69-4), with water or neutralized with 5% sodium
tion, and the techniques employed before tretinoin, and salicylic acid. Light peels bicarbonate after 2 to 4 minutes.
and during its application. Each wound- injure tbe entire epidermis down to the Application of 10 to 20% TCA with
ing agent used in peels has unique chemi- basal layer, stimulating the regeneration of either a saturated 2" x 2" gauze pad or
cal properties and causes a specific pattern a fresh new epithelium. Agents used for
of injury to the skin.^ It is important for light peels include 70% glycolic acid, 25 to Table 69-4 Jessner's Solution (Combes'
the physician using these solutions to be 35% TCA, [essner's solution, and solid car- Formula) ,"'
familiar with their cutaneous effects and bon dioxide (CO2) slush.^-^ During the
Resordnol, 14 g
proper methods of application to ensure apphcation of superficial peeling agents,
Salicylic acid, 14 g
correct depth of injury. The marketplace there may be mild stinging followed by a
85% lactic acid, 14 g
has been fiooded with numerous propri- level I fi-osting, defined as the appearance 95% ethanol (q.s.a.d.), 100 mL
etary formulations of these peeling of erythema and streaky whitening on the
q.s.a.d. - quanlum satis ad ("up to SLiffiticnt quanlity").
agents, with each product claiming surface (Figure 69-3).
Skin Rejuvenation Procedures 1423
FIGURE 69-6 Postinfiammatory hyperpigmentation unresponsive to topical agents (hydroquinone Anatomic areas of the face are peeled
and tretinoin} and superficial chemical peeling. Full response to medium-depth chemical peel and with TCA sequentially from the forehead
topical agents. A, Preoperative. B, Six weeks postoperative. to temple to cheeks and finally to the lips
1426 Part 9: Facial Esthetic Surgery
FIGURE 69-7 Medium-depth chemical peel for treatment of diffuse actinic keratoses and photoaging. The }essner's-35% TCA peel was used as a single treatment,
with healing in 8 days. A, Preoperative. B, Frosting after trichloroacetic acid. C, One month postoperative.
and eyelids. Careful feathering of tbe solu- because they may pull the solution into the takes longer to frost than phenol prepara-
tion into the hairline and around the rim eye by capillary action. tions but a shorter period of time than the
of the jaw and brow conceals the demarca- The white frost fTom the TCA applica- superficial peeling agents. The desired end
tion line between peeled and nonpeeled tion appears on the treated area within point in medium-depth peeling is level II to
skin. Areas of wrinkled skin are stretched 30 seconds to 2 minutes (see Figure 69-5C). level III frosting (Table 69-6). Level II
taut with the help of an assistant to allow This response is representative of keratoco- frosting is defined as a white-coated frost-
even application of the solution into the agulation and indicates that the TCA's ing with a background of erythema (see
folds and troughs. This technique is par- physiologic reaction is complete. TCA Figure 69-3B).
ticularly helpful on the skin of the upper
and lower lips. For perioral rhytids, TCA is
applied with the wood portion of a cot-
ton-tipped applicator and extended onto
the vermilion border (see Figure 69-9D).
Eyelid skin must be treated delicately
and carefiilly to avoid overapplication and
to prevent exposure of the eyes to TCA
solution.-^ The patient should be posi-
tioned with the head elevated at 30 degrees,
and excess peel solution on the cotton tip
A
should be squeezed out so that the applica-
tor is semidry. With tbe eyes closed a single FrGURE 69-8 Combination procedure
applicator is rolled gently from the perior- using perioral-periorbital carbon dioxide
laser resurfacing with Jessner's-35%
bital skin onto the upper eyelid skin with- TCA peel over the remaining face. The
out going beyond the moveable lid. Anoth- peel will blend color and texture of the
er semidry applicator is then rolled onto laser-treated areas. A, Preoperative: the
eyelids and lips need deeper resurfacing
the lower eyelid skin within 2 to 3 mm of than cheeks, which require only medium-
the lid margin while the patient is looking depth injury. B, Four days postoperative:
superiorly. Excess peel solution should note the difference in rate of healing
between laser- and peel-treated areas. C,
never be left on the lids because it can roll One year postoperative.
into the eyes, and tears should be immedi-
ately dried with a cotton-tipped applicator
Skin Rejuvenation Procedures 1427
FIGURE 69-9 Technical aspects of the Jessner's-35% trichloroacetic acid (TCA) peel.
A, Appearance of level I frosting after application of Jessner's solution; erythema with
blotchy frosting. B, TCA (35%) applied after Jessner's solution dries with an even applica-
tion using cotton-tipped applicators, one to four. A level III or white enamel frosting is
obtained. C, Eyelids are treated with one cotton-tipped applicator moistened with 35%
TCA. A dry applicator is used to absorb tears during eyelid peeling. D, Lip rhytids are
peeled with saturated cotton-tipped applicators. The wooden shaft is used to rub peel solu-
tion further into the Up rhytids.
Level III frosting, which is associated should apply more solution only to the ing to improve their greater degree of skin
with penetration to tbe reticular dermis, is underfrosted areas. damage. As discussed with medium-depth
a solid white enamel frosting with no Although there is an immediate burn- peels, deep chemical peeling leads to pro-
background of erythema (see Figure 69- ing sensation as the peel solution is duction of new collagen and ground sub-
5C). A deeper level III frosting sbould be applied, the discomfort begins to subside stance, down to a level in proportion with
restricted only to areas of thick skin and as frosting occurs and resolves fully by the the depth of the peel. The peeling agent of
heavy actinic damage. Most medium- time of discharge. This peel can be per- choice is the Baker-Gordon phenol peel.
depth chemical peels achieve a level II formed with light sedation such as The Baker-Gordon peel uses phenol in
frosting, and this is especially important a formulation that permits deep penetra-
Diazepam 10 mg orally
over the eyelids and areas of sensitive skin. tion into the dermis, deeper than full-
Meperidine 50 mg intramuscularly
Areas with a greater tendency to form strength phenol.^-^ The Baker-Gordon for-
Hydroxyzine 25 mg intramuscularly
scars, such as the zygomatic arch, the bony mula consists of Septisol solution, croton
prominences of the jawline, and chin, After the skin is cooled with saline the oil, and tap water added to a solution of
should receive no greater than level II patient will remain comfortable through- phenol, reducing its concentration to
frosting. out tbe postoperative period. Cool saline 50% or 55% (Table 69-7). The mixture of
Before re-treating an area with inade- compresses offer symptomatic relief at the
quate frosting, the surgeon sbould wait at conclusion of the peel. Unlike the com-
Table 69-6 Grades of Frosting with
least 3 to 4 minutes after the application of presses in glycolic acid peels, the saline fol- Trichloroacetic Acid Peels
TCA to ensure that frosting has reached its lowing a TCA peel simply provides relief
peak. Each cosmetic unit is then assessed, Grade Visual Finding
and does not "neutralize" the acid.
and areas of incomplete or uneven frosting I Erythema with streaky frosting
are carefully re-treated with a thin applica- Deep Chemical Peeling II White frosting with visible
tion of TCA. Additional applications of Patients with more extreme pbotoaging erythema
TCA increase the depth of penetration as skin may require deep chemical peeling, III White enamel frosting, no
well as tbe risk of complications, so one motorized dermabrasion, or laser resurfac- erythema
1428 Part 9: Facial Esthetic Surgery
treatment of each cosmetic area, allowing Mechanical Resurfacing Ideal candidates for microdermabrasion
60 to 90 minutes for the entire procedure. Procedures typically are young patients who desire
Cotton-tipped applicators are used with a limited facial rejuvenation without
During the pastfivedecades, dermabrasion
similar technique as discussed with the "downtime" and thus must have realistic
using a rotating abrasive surface attached
medium-depth Jessner's-35% TCA peel, expectations of the limited anticipated
to a power-driven hand engine has been
though less solution is used because frost- results. Patients often report that their skin
considered a premier skin resurfacing pro-
ing occurs very rapidly {Figure 69-12). has a smoother texture and that cosmetics
Occlusion of the peel can be accomplished cedure for facial scars. It has generally been
are easier to apply and blend in with their
with strips of waterproof zinc oxide tape regarded as a deep resurfacing modality
skin more easily (Figure 69-13). Although
{eg, 0.5 inch Curity tape) to each cosmetic based on its depth of injury and its pro-
the role of microdermabrasion in facial
unit just after the phenol is applied. Care is longed healing time. The original descrip- rejuvenation has grown dramatically since
exercised to extend the peel shghtly tions of modern dermabrasion involved these units were developed, the scientific
beyond the mandibular rim to conceal the the use of a wire brush, which remains in data to justify their use has been lacking.
demarcation between treated and untreat- use today.^^'^'^ In 1957 the diamond fi-aise
ed skin. The last esthetic unit, the perior- was introduced and became the preferred Manual Dermasanding
bital skin, is treated cautiously and conser- instrument for dermabrasion by some sur-
Manual dermasanding involves abrading
vatively to avoid overpenetration which geons because it is less aggressive and more the skin by hand using silicon carbide
can lead to ectropion or scarring. It is forgiving than the wire brush.^' Recently sandpaper or wallscreen commercially
important to remember that diluting a there has been a resurgence of interest in available at any hardware store. Its classifi-
phenol compound with water may manual dermasanding which allows for cation as a wounding agent is entirely
increase its penetration, so mineral oil more deliberate and controlled skin plan- dependent on the type of paper used, the
rather than water should be used to fiush ing and microdermabrasion.^^'^^ force applied by the surgeon, and the
the eyes if contact occurs. duration of contact with the skin.
Microdermabrasion
Application of the peeling agent cre- Although it can be used to produce a
ates an immediate burning sensation, Microdermabrasion is considered superfi- wound as deep as with wire brush der-
which lasts for 15 to 20 seconds, subsides cial because it removes the stratum mabrasion or several passes with a pulsed
for 20 minutes, and then returns for the corneum and outer epidermis. Its classifi- CO2 laser, manual dermasanding is proba-
next 6 to 8 hours. Ice packs may be applied cation as light or very light in comparison bly most commonly used as a medium-
as necessary for patient comfort. Narcotics to the other superficial resurfacing proce- depth or "minimally deep" resurfacing
are usually prescribed on discharge for dures depends on the techniques and modality {Table 69-8).
adequate pain control. Systemic steroids aggressiveness of the operator. The micro- Manual dermasanding is most often
are also administered by some surgeons to dermabrasion unit's handpiece is a closed used for resurfacing localized regions to
lessen the inflammatory response. For system, which propels aluminum oxide minimize the appearance of a scar or to
untaped peels, petrolatum is applied and a crystals at the skin at high speeds and
biosynthetic dressing can be used for the simultaneously removes them with suc-
first 24 hours. tion. These units were developed commer-
cially in the mid-1990s and are currently
in widespread use in both physicians'
offices and nonmedical esthetic spas.
Microdermabrasion may be indicated for
acneiform conditions, pigmentary
dyschromias, and as a "lunchtime" proce-
dure for facial rejuvenation in all skin
types.'^^'^'^ Both the patient and physician
must understand that the degree of objec-
tive improvement with microdermabra-
sion may be limited. This is a repetitive
FIGURE 69-12 Rapid frosting from small procedure performed every 2 weeks along FIGURE 69-13 Microdermabrasion: aluminum
amounts of Baker-Gordon phenol solution oxide crystals are propelled at high speeds within
applied with cotton-tipped applicators.
with appropriate cosmoceutical agents.
a closed system and removed with suction.
1430 Part 9: Facial Esthetic Surgery
Table 69-8 Advantages of Manual Dermasanding over Motorized Dermabrasion Motorized Dermabrasion
Greater control over depth of injury, particularly on the lips and orbital rims Some of the units most commonly used
Blending of abraded areas into adjacent unabraded areas accomplished more easily and with today are the Bell hand engine (Bell Inter-
better results national, Burlingame, CA), the AEV-12
Lower cost and greater simplicity of instrumentation and set-up hand engine (Ellis International, Madi-
No risk of aerosolizing infectious particles son, NI), and the Osada surgical hand-
Possibly lower incidence of postinflammatory piece (Osada, Inc., Los Angeles, CA). A
topical refrigerant spray (Frigiderm,
Frigiderm Corp., Costa Mesa, CA) is used
blend or enhance the effects of a medium- experience suggests that dermasanding after to produce anesthesia and to harden the
depth chemical peel or a combination pro- a Jessners-35% TCA peel may yield impres- skin as it is abraded. The spray immobi-
cedure.^'^ It can be used following CO2 sive postoperative results that approach lizes the topographic features so that
laser resurfacing to feather the transition those seen with either motorized dermabra- there is no distortion by the pressure of
into hair-bearing areas that are inaccessi- sion or CO2 laser resurfacing in patients the abrasive instrument.
ble to the laser. Manual dermasanding of with photoaging skin. (Figure 69-15). This
the eyebrows and hairline and gentle abra- combination is particularly helpful in The two abrasive instruments most
sion of the upper neck at the inferior patients who may not tolerate the greater often employed with these units are the
aspect of the laser-irradiated zone are all degree of sedation often necessary with wire brush and the diamond fraise. The
effective at minimizing lines of demarca- CO2 laser resurfacing. wire brush has numerous small-caliber
tion between treated and untreated skin stainless steel wires that project circumfer-
The necessary materials for manual
(Figure 69-14). It can also be useful imme- entially from the curved side of a cylindri-
dermasanding include sihcon carbide
diately after laser resurfacing for stubborn cal hub. A diamond fraise consists of a
sandpaper or wallscreen. Both may be
rhytids, particularly in the perioral region. stainless steel cylinder to which industrial-
purchased in a variety of grades: fine grade
Manual dermasanding can improve the out- grade diamonds are bonded to create the
(no. 400), medium grade (nos. 220-320),
come by producing a slightly greater depth abrasive surface. As compared with wire
and coarse grade (no. 180). The sandpaper
of injury in a controlled fashion where fur- brush instruments, diamond fraises are
is easy to use because of its flexibility and
ther thermal injury would be risky. It will manufactured with a greater variety in
is easily cut into smaller pieces, which can
also remove adherent necrotic debris and shape, width of abrasive surface, wheel
be steam autoclaved. A 1.5" x 3" piece of
thermal damage, thus speeding up the heal- diameter, and coarseness of grit. The wire
sterilized sandpaper is wrapped around
ing process. Similarly a medium-depth brush is more aggressive and cuts more
either the barrel of a 3 mL syringe or a
chemical peel can be immediately fol- quickly and more deeply into the skin with
rolled-up 2" x 2" gauze pad and moistened
lowed by manual dermasanding on the each stroke, thereby posing a greater risk
with saline or a soap-free cleanser for
more troublesome areas to enhance the of injury and requiring more skill to oper-
lubrication. A 1% solution of lidocaine
results and also along the borders of the ate. Although the diamond fraise is gener-
with epinephrine may be used instead if
peeled skin to blend the effects. Our clinical ally safer and more forgiving, it may not
additional anesthesia is necessary. Both
yield the degree of improvement possible
back-and-forth and circular motions are
with the wire brush, especially for more
used to gradually abrade the skin layer-by-
stubborn conditions such as deep acne
layer until the hills and valleys are softened
scarring (Figure 69-16).
or adjacent areas are blended to the
desired degree. Coarse grades may be used Because dermabrasion with either
initially for "debulking," followed by finer instrument is highly technique-dependent
grades later in the procedure. The fine and its learning curve is steep, there may
grade is used to blend delicate areas of be considerable variability in the clinical
skin, such as around the eyelids. At the results obtained by different operators.
completion of the procedure the dark- It is very important for beginning
colored silicon carbide particles remaining dermabraders to attain thorough hands-
on the skin surface should be rinsed off on instruction from an experienced oper-
FIGURE 69-14 Manual dermasanding using
320-grit silicone carbide sandpaper to blend carbon because there is a theoretical risk of their ator in order to be adequately trained.
dioxide laser resurfacing into the eyebrow area. becoming implanted. The proper techniques for motorized
Skin Rejuvenation Procedures 1431
FIGURE 69-15 Medium-depth chemical peel with manual dermasanding for photoaging skin. A, Prcopcralivc: moderate photoaging offace with more advanced
perioral rhagades. B, }essner's-35% trichloroacetic acid peel applied over face including the perioral area. C, Manual dermasanding to the perioral skin to bloody
points. D, One-month postoperative photograph revealing improvement in all areas.
dermabrasion have also been the subject The use of CO2 lasers has revolution- laser resurfacing. This gives an added ben-
of comprehensive reviews in the litera- ized resurfacing techniques for pbotoaging efit to wrinkle treatment that is not found
ture.^^"^^ Careful evaluation of the depth skin. Because of the varying properties of with either dermabrasion or chemical peel-
of injury throughout the procedure is crit- lasers, the physician must be thoroughly ing. This is especially true with perioral
ical to ensure sufficient depth for optimal familiar with the physics, technology, and and periorbital wrinkled skin.
results without penetrating beyond the operating geometry of the laser. Whether CO2 laser resurfacing requires anes-
desired level and risking scarring. Because or not the laser is pulsed, continuous, or thesia: either general operative anesthesia
of the potential for aerosolization of infec- computer scanned impacts the physiologic or tumescent local anesthesia for the entire
tious particles during dermabrasion, response. The level of destruction is differ- face. Laser safety precautions are needed to
appropriate precautions are mandatory to ent for each laser; thus, tbe physician prevent laser fire or laser injury to the
protect the operating room staff. should be familiar with the laser of choice. employees, the unprotected skin, the teeth,
Moderate to severe acne scarring is the For reliable vaporization of skin layers, a or even the endotracheal tube for general
most notable indication for dermabrasion, pulsed laser witb a computer-generated anesthesia. These must be protected with
as laser resurfacing has yielded variable scanner (CPG) makes the procedure safer. appropriate laser-resistant materials: eye
results and chemical peeling is generally Each pass destroys 75 to 100 fim of tissue shields, teeth guards, and appropriate
disappointing (Table 69-9). Dermabrasion with a zone of thermal damage below. laser-resistant endotracheal tube wrap-
selectively planes off the "hilltops" that Thus, two to three passes with an ultra- ping. Using the CPG the operator must
surround the atrophic "valleys," whereas pulse CO2 laser is maximal for rejuvenation remember that the pulse overlap for a cho-
chemical peeling and lasers produce an of photodamaged skin—a deep resurfacing sen pattern size and shape is set so that
injury of equivalent depth in both areas technique. The zone of thermal damage each pattern is made to touch yet not over-
(Figure 69-17). causes collagen shrinkage or contraction, lap. The density is an important parameter
which is a unique characteristic for CO2 in determining laser beam intensity. One
Table 69-9 Conditions for Which Motorized Dermabrasion May Be the Preferred
Resurfacing Modality
Acne scarring
Surgical or traumatic scars
Benign neoplastic processes (multiple trichoepitheliomas, syringomas, adenoma scbaceum)
Malignant and premalignant neoplastic processes (skin cancer treatment and prevention in
basal cell nevus syndrome and xeroderma pigmentosum as well as management of exten-
sive carcinoma in situ)
Extensive epidermal lesions such as epidermal nevi
FIGURE 69-16 Mechanical dermabrasion is Decorative or traumatic tattoos unresponsive to the pigmented lesion lasers
performed with a diamond fraise over rigid skin Rhinophyma
cooled with a topical refrigerant spray.
1432 Part 9: Eacial Esthetic Surgery
6. Lowe, NJ. Textbook of facial rejuvenation. Lon- medium depth chemical peeling. J Derma- 28. Beeson WH. The importance of cardiac moni-
don: Martin Danitz; 2002. p. 3-11. tol Surg Oncol 1989;15:953-63. toring in superficial and deep chemical peel-
7. Kligman, AM. Topical retinoic acid (tretinoin) 19. Coleman WP, Futrell JM. The glycolic acid ing. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 1987; 13:949-50.
for photoaging: conceptions and misper- trichloroacetic acid peel. J Dermatol Surg 29. Burks JW. Abrasive removal of scars. South
ceptions. Cuds 1996:57:142-4, Oncol i994;20:76-80. Med I 1955;48:452-9.
8. Moy LS, Murad H, Moy RL. Glycoiic acid 20. Witheiler DD, Lawrence N, Cox SE, et al. Long- 30. Kurtin A. Corrective surgical planing of the
peels for the treatment of wrinkles and term efficacy and safety of Jessner's solution skin. Arch Dermatol Syphil l953;68:389-97.
photoaging. I Dermato! Surg Oncol 1993; and 35% trichloroacetic acid vs 5% fluo- 31. Alt TH. Facial dermabrasion: advantages of the
19:243-6. rouracil in the treatment of widespread diamond fraise technique. ] Dermatol Surg
9. Draelos, ZD. Topical agents used in association facial actinic keraloses. Dermatol Surg Oncol 1987;13:618-24.
with cosmetic surgery. Semin Cutan Med 1997;23:191-6. 32. Harris DR, Noodieman FR. Combining manu-
Surg 1999; 18(2):l!2-8. 2L Monheit GD. The Jessnerls-TCA peel. Facial al dermasanding with low strength
10. Monheit GD. Skin preparation: an essential Plast Surg Clin North Am 1994;2;21-7. trichloroacetic acid to improve actinically
step before chemical peeling or laser resur- 22. Morrow DM. Chemical peeling of eyelids and injured skin. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 1994;
facing. Cosmet Dermatol 1996;9(9):13-4. periorbital area. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 20:436-42.
11. Rubin M. Manual of chemical peels. Philadel- 1992;18:102-10. 33. Chiarello SE. Tumescent demiasanding with
phia (PA): Lippincott; 1995. p. 50-67. 23. Baker, TS, Gordon HL. Chemical face peeling. cryospraying. A new wrinkle on the treat-
12. Clark CP. Office-based skin care and superficial In: Surgical rejuvenation of the face. St. ment of rhytids. Dermatol Surg 1996;
peels: the scientific rationale. Piast Reconstr Louis (MO): C.V. Mosby; 1986. p. 230-2. 22:601-10.
Surg 1999; 104:854-64; discussion 65-6. 24. Hetter GP. An examination of the phenol-croton 34. Bernard RW. Beran SI, Rusin L. Microder-
13. Brody HJ. Chemical peeling. St. Louis (MO): mabrasion in clinical practice. Clin Plast
oil peel: Part 1. Dissecting the formula. Plast
Mosby; 1992. p. 59-^0. Surg2000;27:571-7.
Reconstr Surg 2000;105:227-39; discussion
14. Monheit GD. The Jessner's + TCA peel: a 35. Warmuth IP, Echt A. Scarborough DA, Bisaccia
49-51.
medium depth chemical peel. J Dermatol E. Microdermabrasion: a new rejuvenation
25. Hetter GP. An examination of the phenol-croton
treatment option. Cosmet Dermatol
Surg Oncol 1989;15:945-30. oil peel: part IV. Face pee! results with differ-
]999;12:7-10.
15. Kligman D, Kligman AM. Salicylic acid peels ent concentrations of phenol and croton oil.
36. Zisser M, Kaplan B, Moy RL. Surgical pearl:
for the treatment of photoaging. Dermatol Plast Reconstr Surg 2000;105:1061-83; dis-
manual dermabrasion. J Am Acad Derma-
Surg 1998;24:325~8. cussion 84-7.
tol l995;33;105-6.
16. Monheit, GD. Chemical peeling for pigmen- 26. Alt T. Occluded Baker/Gordon chemical peel. 37. Yarborough |M. Dermabrasion by wire brush.
tary dyschromias. Cosmet Dermatol Review and update. J Dermatol Surg Oncol I Dermatol Surg Oncol I987;13:610-5.
1995;8(5):10-5. 1989; 15:980-93. 38. Alt TH. Technical aids for derniabrasion. J
17. Brody H|, Hailey CW. Medium-depth chemical 27. McCollough EG, Langsdon PR. Chemical peel- Dermatol Surg Oncol 1987;13:638^8.
peeling of the skin: a variation of superficial ing with phenol. In: Roenigk H, Roenigk R, 39. Yarborough IM. Coleman WP, Lawrence N.
chemosurgery. J Dermatol Surg Oncol editors. Dermatologic surgery: principles Wire brush dermabrasion. Jn: Coleman
1986;12:1268-75. and practice. New York (NY): Marcel WP, Lawrence N, editors. Skin resurfacing.
18. Brody HJ. Variations and comparisons in Dekker; 1989. p. 997-1016. Baltimore (MD): Williams & Wilkins; 1998.