Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sagoff Can Environmentalists Be Liberals
Sagoff Can Environmentalists Be Liberals
01 2iqusuadsipur seme, 1 TEM Jo ueap uot ‘1]9pBUeT| snqumnjo) rodors {ooyag ME PIEAIEH ou ‘oBe Arnjuco © EY S10), ONAIOS ADITOA V SY AWOMHL TVOLLITOA nmanaid 03 paureoa0o axe s[es2qH [eorBojowwosp asoyn se ates om tom ase riqujod pow sisyemauuoraue syjo-2pem =i] ‘poo om yo womdaotio9 ® jiasit $i 11205 ‘poo amp yo suondzouoo sam, yey YH e "uae 013 s10N 38920101 Jo snIMOTED # UO Paseg Tous] JURA poof amp 30 oN -dlootoo 19se8 01 3 JoUTex “sozonur re Bumasse se Buy owes ay 10. st sny.“9pud puv ‘zazoesey> ‘4B0qo0pt jeuoueu jo stuIa4 UI 30 sonEg’suOds ‘ar [PION pur ‘onoqNsoe ‘Tesnyjn jo SHH) ur JONPIAE mo sui99U09 1 se rey OF ut “wAIGOIA sexo Senaqgu0D Jo woqgoud _ysiogio asurtfe jo popen 29 02 S671 weno sod 104 Soop YR 270 TEN (Beppe seca az sea axp Horus es) soynqeo apFNay amy Seoe}0es uD sSRI=ISE tm snowjuzaquoo se wefaord ears emt Jo wonTUyop ssansasqo Kueg weg Sy "used fn sosnyas yosaqi| PaH#ojowwoap am) SHO-spen ure99 swOTTE WEEE re stad 30} suosipuos aueumnt wo “Xjsodoud oxmnb sao9VS RUT gutsm sn op Saran ese ope pear eggs GS ssdpn eye soot oO, 962) (5 dang 2105, nox) fonouag fo onus snuoueng ‘sang Aono eA "HOD UoKEHE Ma) HOT URRY fo BY 24L 2IOENO ED ssoyasAqueseseu ox Soop “5-s6p uo “eed pon Triad song WEY ing ou tony a Bos ATE = ig pT, ET, pure ‘siajosqo at09aq woos plnom ‘uns aq o1 “HOS StH Jo suTEBIEG A301 -ramig "Se108 30 SumuV8seq Aq sastuosdai09 yno 30M sdnoss sazayut Bu apes amp putas Aeur 40} peorsas Sadosops pur somtoaoce pms 01 ssa4ne} eMssaE puE SeOYDs API BM 80> 34 xe] 2yeur 0} 20 uy Zpepeaty [ope] WH SH SI tr ogaioxs ue i OEE APE nelog[PSO|OTEODD {ower tu) ospiane ue woop (pn! 3h soe Soondde usresoqi wow se inp “eWy HoNSuE pe IE POR “fomoung sy Suez peat se ow 200 Semon sed “uorypes UERUES, sx at patootos Zaqdosongd © Ae agp Inq pMOH LSA 30 LEAST Smrowtaepany v 20 soos v uvaeuan © fen 21 308 S4SI00) Te “fod yo stonsonb zousue pu ou pious 38 reso (ered 30 soso sonst pe {eyy snus 2a anoo i O29 SE Spbop, isnut1stoo ¥ ae [BUORTANSUOD e004 BOK pe fet rmonnanseoo jo ate, 804 seo 21052) 2H S140 20H Supeodde sepootstpun aq sta, 198° rein sank $208 unyroeyprpEey *OLD AT Seon se yoy sont pu Sebo a pardws-aid A(Buiseassur sey [e2q MeN At 29UI8 YON 430 omgnd Jo sousyodun om Jo asewe a8 5 AE] oom (e8o] ULE ‘pateq 2g i800 ‘anisuaqoadiuo; ayy wai Jo} yunoa98 Aoyjatt0s ‘ognuang st 13 ‘Aoqod ongnd gary uo savour UONCT ‘or paredasd 2g ysnu 1 ssoxfoud jexour 2124 [pur snara fexow UNO som} aAey Lem OM ‘SoanenUasexdas sam Jo SuaZTIID MOTTE 10U axO}eIOm plnom KOU, “uonsonb [22a] 40 Aowod seInonsed Kae Ur paAjoxur saouvisuIOND ayy OF MOLA aaIsuouasdUTO op UT PeUTEIMOD ‘2auioe we Xepd prnous sumo om reNT 2A—H19q OsTe ST “aream feos SurzuurKe pue Suyeoqe ‘asosoxm SuDuHeG Jo yer AsUssooeT A yu om aonpap 02 sjeEyjo ongnd axmnbax pinom yoe> Koy, “sours juuodaa we aaeq PION ‘waqp ‘wst[es9qq JO StUI05 O%1 ‘Sa preon oped Sereaea Prrogs 10 sidaoue ssoxFuo> remy onze Kou weLENTN e “puod2g “sno 2m {hq yonns 29 321109 14S asttosdiwoo qwoIpyj9 axout e sseaK mo} B IOME 1 J0} LOUIS yp wpeam Jo MONEZuNXe ox 10 KoUDIOUa sOyEUI ‘DHL e'Paseq 2g Sew Sood jos WORN uO sASIA aaisuayaxduIOD ‘om soquasap ‘Suryeur-Aoyog oynuaias BuIssnON ur uELUIEXOY LONI ut {STVMAHIT 4 SUSTTVINSHNOMTANA NVO sa00VvS wav Burauamanenqoe ‘om seman uonsonb ayy sauAut IE “Pood oy: Jo uond2.u09 ueLTENIN e sidaooe wsresaqu [eaWFOqOIwOAP UGA a P99PU taTELD aqqeuondeoxeun ‘2n ‘Xem sty UE poysTorp st req2 01 vorsoddo ut Adios pauep o7e ‘aq wonsonb ovr syjeo “sandzv tapzes ‘Ajqesous 2u, gc YBfoaNO YSN” EE ‘uno si sourauzapum if 3nq “foes00urOp TAH WueystsuooMt kfuo you st! 'Aoqj0d 0s u; poo’ axp Jo ondsous ueUEANN e uo sisisut MISTEIOGN JT ‘oyu Cour sjenpistpur jenbo pue aaxy yore ut scone “ons aseq amp aqusep équo A “aquoseud tou Seu 1 suowa8paf wonrod aveum Boy saxeun req aonsal 3 Axdosoyryd rronyod »rareis aiexs0map wopour 20} 51804 241 aplaoad eo wodaDu09 Kons ou prtes pood au o amtew a amoqe peru fae puE swat aeatp WO TUE repoq aod ot ona shy aqeorongs anode Poe wspeiogt 30; vonepanoy sweudondde ae apmo%d you op “s0}I5 “hx por wey, qa paenosse aot) oso ‘snap eur ans4aq>xeN0> sone" poe arDo;Ne caja onan vlope 0 puoyaxoyoq ‘om youag 01 s2ps0 ut uN ozUUEEUE IHN sePGOd yokes eur 1: 40 “Sgqyn aqumpcemn vem seu0 Jo sm0Ke} UH Aiaies sneomop y “woddas Kaui somnod 2x1 dope prnoys K21208 fq suosear jesour 94i8 fe sdnox# suezni soqi0 Stew pur “suRLDIOA ‘ISIATOE 181 {STVMAGIT 4M SISITVINANNOMTANS NVO (ot ssonny Bun) "ou IaH IU Pa Zoaly St pal 8 thot wo tin prose 2 stopgap) amas fo AY nsf ry wou W SSID OFM at) mean soy Kuso on dom ang vrata nae 0) ees Eps stop onneppay psu 0 word ar ola yay og a ammyiom ‘sisqumay ‘seioape coved ‘sysyeruomuosUT ;,sIuoUNBTe Tes0u: uowiajdist pue pumssopun oy oes o1 USE yovowe axp Sey Aawez| onessowep ayp ‘suonsanb jeapsfod JO pazias st sseoord yeu se Xypees se suonsanb [exou jo pazias aq ssooaid aneowep oui vem sommbax, ‘sortum pang SapeyD ‘Aoeiowap jo ajdiouud eaneuoU penUass> aH, AQVYOOWAG GNV ADOTOINOAG “Tom se Kopssoutop quis ajqnedutoour 29 0} steadde yewwauuonAND que sjqnediwooar Aqureid sty wom—IOu wad ‘yorya—suondunsse esoui soyeu wstexoqy 3 “SHS ‘uy UMOD pre] BUD puE s2ydI9 saad ogruotos, 0} wzoyu09 suorsisop Aoqiod (je SuPyEUH Ob PUE AOL, 2aIs jod aaninansuoo om 109 ofp Jo ured eM 1 Ayuowine amp sino ss9] ou puv oxour ou xam Coup 3 se som ;peoadde prnom autn20p spunoa8 (Koua}9y}9 3'0) jeuonmnstoIqNS uo MalAar o1JaN0d ‘punyeyse@ay amp gt W949 ‘920 SEIU ‘ssoudxo Aes 1 30 “‘roa.z000r sf eMp 2u0 adope ew Armor, datsTaqazdtIO 2 adope or yoy dew amryjsiBor © req st we}goud ayy, “Aoxjod axjqnd jo ot, aaisuayoiduap @ uo SuOIs}oap soup 95@q s1zn09 aq aazy PMO OH asott 01 280d sounyeisiBay opeowsp AyMOUHP om S9AIOsqo 1s23qe/ED oping -somng fo a8y ay1 sof so] uounuoy ¥ “yo09 weHOduN UE Uy S4OOVS SAVE ostrem oummesBoxd su azuarsereyp 01 An EGS 1 ‘J2K@H0H “HUOHDOS HOM un uy tasrye199m Jo Az0aNp TeonITOR axTMIsG0O 242 01 WORRY S30 mst Jo aurures2oxd eonfod ain 2204 rep Aue uy 2q}289p 1000 | ai, parreo 9q prnows 2 Ayse puessiopon tes ax reg 08 Andosomtd sy 01 YBnowe asop> 29 prnoys oumuexFOxd -3G“wHPeuse MW) TR5E 8! CE-OB6T ado gz'¢ a R086 200 Any aes porn eo pied 24 J0 AGRE MRL "619201 WOREN 2m PEE ESHIBGFL, OE. -Koessourap pue mATEIWaCIUONTAKO ‘osoyorous ‘puE woREsBaye Jess “01 posoddo se ose nq "woss oussip se Aquo 100 11 0 uN éeans Kees 94 som ‘msrenptaur yo Puy Se LtTezoqq 0 AUN a4 3 "qaesedasu 30M “puios ou Jo 3894 atN JO TeMp qs 18939107 COuRLUOD sat Apuapy 01 wstqeu0}8a4 TeuoARU sit 62305 o1 KarunoD om Pati “SUID oo jeuonewsora iq feUORRE nf JOU asaM sonsst SONA LEHR partseyden> sno jo ssomnosor yeoishyd ama Jo diyspzbAa38 ro ‘YoNDNAISOP Jeo|oNE 10 twaath om, papn{gut af 16919007 oD Jo Poo8 uotHEUOD INO p9Ms29U09 qsow igdnoma 9q eqn sansst samp amp Jo a40ds wom Jue) Ioprse.A sues enpaspa ano pu 3270, ‘uouraroo mo si poo wowmoo ow ey: 13840} jou sna am pee amAHON TENTIAL qe ass om ssozrer ioe 10 aus 200 ye JO Las 2p SGBATE 10U Bf oP qouonee ot soneosg osodind sno woisp Ot saet 1 Sf (RRTOE MORSE wt Sorse mqunnp wa su, powoiod os sori syed Wo 20 PEW sof CODE She tuo 400 “aed 95 Isua}oue Te asso o} SuORTENEsO asses ead ‘pov scout onss afro} uaesp sqeuseanuy sue ax ‘stolgoud m0 Gm [3p ot anusonop oat fo nae a Jo egnop amu ona auoog ay dood ee SepO, -230] 0 poxiom wap youonta U7, ‘saA2sq0 199K ES se “ws 9X Jo souLD0p pure seOS SM uy “yy OWT poesBerU! wooq aaeq AyuNUT -mioo [euONED aT] Wo papnyaxe useq ped rem sdnowF yor UO sIseq_ reonyod pur ‘rouoo9‘eunyjo v apyaosd Kaun rem ur orzqetoNe, ose ‘axe Soi nq ‘Tenpraypuy ayy Jo aseyom om wo siseydaro me qa UOSTSUO swoddns yuaw.ojdave yy souraresBoxd mettepnaa ‘Bt Yao wl sS03H0xd pesudwos Aued onemomag am Jo sjeod au “sigs sores Jo ued E400VS UVHE oer