Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dermatologi Vulva Geriatri
Dermatologi Vulva Geriatri
https://doi.org/10.1007/s13670-020-00332-8
INVITED COMMENTARY
Abstract
Purpose of Review The purpose of this review is to provide the diagnosis and management of inflammatory vulvar dermatoses in
the geriatric population. The increasing geriatric population in the USA necessitates informing a broad base of healthcare
providers on this topic.
Recent Findings In the elderly, there are increasing case reports of contact dermatitis due to sanitary napkins, incontinence pads,
and over the counter medications. Superimposed vulvovaginal candidiasis and lichen simplex chronicus can occur simultaneous-
ly with the primary vulvar disease. The limited research specific to geriatric populations confirms the current state of vulvar
dermatosis underdiagnosis.
Summary In order to close the gaps in diagnosis and treatment of vulvar dermatoses, providers should carefully review the
patient’s medical history and complete a physical examination of the genitoanal area for asymptomatic and symptomatic elderly
women. Prompt, consistent treatment can vastly improve the patient’s quality of life and is critical to preventing the advancement
of lesions to squamous cell carcinoma in conditions that incur this increased risk such as lichen sclerosus and lichen planus.
Keywords Geriatric . Vulvar dermatoses . Contact dermatitis . Lichen planus . Lichen sclerosus . Vulvovaginal candidiasis
decreasing the risk of squamous cell carcinoma in lichen changes [9]. Treatment with estrogen therapy should be con-
sclerosus and lichen planus. sidered in postmenopausal women with genitoanal skin dis-
ease as GSM often co-exists with the inflammatory vulvar
diseases discussed herein. Without treatment of GSM, the
patient may still experience bothersome symptoms that are
Vulvar Anatomy
falsely attributed to ineffective treatment of the dermatologic
condition. Not all vulvar conditions can be attributed to attri-
The vulva is the external layer of the female genitalia [6]. The
tion and diagnosis requires a thorough clinical exam, pertinent
border of the vulva extends anteriorly from the mons pubis to
history gathering, and further diagnostic tests including saline
the posterior commissure or fourchette posteriorly [6]. The
microscopy of vaginal secretions to evaluate the maturity of
lateral borders are from the genitocrural folds to the hymenal
the vaginal epithelium.
ring medially [6]. The vulva comprises major structures in-
cluding the clitoral hood, clitoris, outer labia, inner labia, and
vestibule (introitus) [6]. Hart’s line is an anatomic marker that
separates the medial aspect of the labia minora and the mucous Lichen Planus
membranes of the vestibule [6]. Figure 1 details the normal
external female genitalia. Normal variations of the vulva in- Lichen planus is a chronic inflammatory condition of undeter-
clude differences in size, shape, pigmentation, and symmetry. mined etiology that can affect the skin, oral mucosa, and
These changes are dependent on age, hormonal status, and anogenital area [10, 11, 12•, 13, 14]. Approximately 1% of
ethnicity. Special consideration should be given when exam- the population has oral lichen planus and 10 to 51% of women
ining patients with darker complexion as it may disguise ery- who are diagnosed with oral lichen planus may also present
thema commonly seen in inflammatory skin conditions [7]. with vulvovaginal disease [11, 13, 15]. The wide range in
From childhood to adulthood, the normal vulvar changes incidence may be due to differences in provider awareness
expected during pubertal development include fat deposition of this skin disease. The average age of onset is within the
of the mons pubis and labia majora, prominence of the clitoris, 4th and 5th decades of life [16].
thickening of the epithelium, and pubertal hair growth. Lichen planus can have more than one subtype present with
Reversal of these features can be observed during the meno- the most common being classic cutaneous lichen planus, hy-
pausal period. The decrease in estrogen leads to vaginal atro- pertrophic, and erosive [16]. The most common subtype in
phy, graying of pubic hairs, and decrease in vaginal secretions anogenital lichen planus is the erosive subtype. Erosive lichen
[8]. Genitourinary syndrome of menopause (GSM) consists of planus presents as erythema and erosions that can extend into
a constellation of symptoms secondary to postmenopausal the vagina and perianal regions [10, 13]. The classic purple
changes from low estrogen levels [9]. This condition is prev- papules of lichen planus are seen on the hair-bearing portion
alent in 40–54% of postmenopausal women [9]. Treatment for of the vulva in only 3–5% of vulvovaginal lichen planus cases
GSM is estrogen therapy and can restore the vaginal epitheli- [10, 17–19]. Up to two-thirds of patients with erosive lichen
um and secretions reducing symptoms related to sexual dis- planus can have oral involvement; therefore, clinical diagnosis
comfort, urological complications, and external genital can be facilitated by examining the oral mucosa for lichen
Allergic Contact Dermatitis allergens or irritant [25]. The most common allergens impli-
cated in allergic contact dermatitis of the vulva are listed in
The vulva is particularly prone to allergic contact dermatitis Table 1.
(ACD) due the nature of the location. Barrier dysfunction The most common allergens are associated with medica-
allows exposures to potential allergens. Additionally, many tions, fragrances, and preservatives [25]. Convenient access
women are embarrassed to seek medical help and thus per- and self-treatment with over the counter medications increase
form self-treatments with over the counter or at home reme- exposure to products associated as an allergen including ben-
dies. Allergic contact dermatitis is a delayed hypersensitivity zocaine, corticosteroids, and antibiotics [7, 25]. Vagisil and
reaction. On the first contact, the sensitization occurs, and on sometimes antihemorrhoidal creams contain benzocaine [7].
subsequent contacts, the hypersensitivity reaction takes place. Among patients diagnosed with anogenital ACD, 12.5% of
While the exact incidence is unknown, several studies have patients had reactions to benzocaine [25]. Benzocaine also
shown a high rate of allergic contact dermatitis in patient with cross-reacts with specific dyes or sulfa drugs [7]. Verifying
dermatitis of the vulva. A review of patients presenting with the patient’s history for allergies to hair dyes or sulfa can
vulvar symptoms at the Mayo Clinic showed that of 90 pa- support clinical suspicion for ACD to benzocaine [7, 25].
tients, 39% experienced positive patch tests which were Corticosteroids are another class of topical medications that
deemed relevant [24]. The Oxford vulva clinic in the UK is a potential anogenital allergen [25]. The sensitization rate
found 43% of patients with vulvar dermatitis had positive ranges from 1.1 to 3.3% and develops over time due to long-
patch test results for allergens [25]. In older patients, greater term use for treatment of other genital conditions [25]. If treat-
than the age of 70, this prevalence of positive patch testing ment with corticosteroids worsens the condition, ACD due to
increases to 62% compared to 32% in patients younger than steroid use may be considered [25].
the age of 70 [25]. Disruptions in barrier function due to in- In elderly patients, use of absorbent disposable underwear
creased urinary incontinence and decreased estrogen in post- for incontinence and wipes are two major sources of ACD.
menopausal women reduces the protection from potential Fragrance Mix I and Balsam of Peru are two fragrances that
Corticosteroids
Antibiotics Neomycin, bacitracin, clindamycin
Antifungals Terconazole
Vehicle components Propylene glycol, lanolin
Fragrance Cosmetics Fragrance I/II, Balsam of Peru, cinnamic alcohol, tolu balsam, hydroxyisohexyl
Perfumes/sprays 3-cyclohexane carboxaldehyde, hydroxycitronellal, eugenol
Toilet paper
Wipes
Shave cream
Sanitary pads/incontinence pads
Lubricants
Preservatives Cosmetics Methylisothiazolinone, methylchloroisothiazolinone, formaldehyde,
Lotions/creams quaternium-15, DMDM hydantoin, thimerosal, benzalkonium chloride, methyl
Soaps/shampoos dibromo glutaronitrile, benzoic acid, butylhydroyanisole, parabens, bronopol,
ethylenediamine, chlorocresol
Wipes
Sanitary pads/incontinence pads
Medications
Adhesives/resin Sanitary pads/incontinence pads Acrylates, colophony
Rubber Condoms Tetramethylthiuram disulfide, mercaptobenzothiazole, diphenylguanidine, thiuram
accelerators Catheters mix, latex
Pessaries
Textiles Undergarments and clothing Disperse blue, disperse orange 3, paraphenylenediamine, PABA
Spices and Personal care products, food products with hand Primin, peppermint oil, nutmeg, coriander, curry powder, onion powder,
herbs to genital contact or excretion in feces chamomile, arnica, propolis, jojoba oil, jasmine
Curr Geri Rep
can be found in incontinence pads and are responsible for in incontinent women due to increased skin moisture resulting
genital ACD in up to 20% of patients [25]. Dryness of the in increased penetration of irritants into the skin [34, 36].
vaginal area may lead to increased frequency of wipes for Other threshold lowering factors include friction and obesity
comfort as compared to toilet paper. Increasing case reports [34].
of allergic contact dermatitis to wipes or moist toilet paper are External factors for irritant contact dermatitis include over
published in the literature. Within a 6-month period, one in- the counter products ranging from cosmetics to medications.
stitution found 4 adult patients with allergic contact dermatitis Common vulvar irritants include skin care products, personal
caused by methylchloroisothialzolione/methylisothialozlione cleanliness products, and deodorants [34]. Excessive washing
(MCI/MI) [33]. All four cases reported seeing numerous pro- practices by patients to reduce odor and infection fall under
viders and misdiagnosis including psoriasis and pityriasis the category of physical vulvar irritants and is worsened with
rubra pilaris prior to seeing a dermatologist who recommend- use of caustic chemicals such as bleach or alcohol [27].
ed patch testing [33]. This theme is challenging for patients Common vulvar irritants are listed in Table 2.
and can lead to a decrease in quality of life as treatments fail to In particular for the older population, possible irritants in-
improve their persistent symptoms. clude incontinence pads or briefs, feminine wipes, and topical
Patients with ACD often present with a chief complaint of medications [36]. Incontinence-associated dermatitis (IAD)
pruritus [7]. The exam may demonstrate erythema, edema, was found in 5.7% of older individuals in long-term care fa-
vesicles, or bullae with weeping in the acute and subacute cilities [38]. The risk of IAD increases with immobility and
stages. These lesions are present in the vulva and can extend the use of absorptive products saturated with urine or fecal
into the perianal area [33]. Over time, they can develop into matter [38]. Urine disrupts the vulvar skin barrier by increas-
scaling plaques with erythema, hyperpigmentation, and ing moisture and acts as an irritant [35]. Sanitary napkins can
lichenification as seen in cases of more chronic ACD [7, also cause ICD through a different mechanism. A prior case
25]. The first step to diagnosis includes a discussion of the series describes 28 women who experienced ICD due to re-
patient and their partner’s personal product use. To increase peated episodes of vulvar itching and burning after use of
the sensitivity of patch testing results, selection of patch- Always sanitary napkins [39]. The condition was resolved
testing options should be guided by the discussed history. after discontinuation and switching to another brand of sani-
Products to specifically inquire about include cosmetics, over tary napkins [39]. In a subset of the women, there was recur-
the counter products, prescribed medications, foreign prod- rence of ICD after resuming use of Always sanitary napkins
ucts, spices, alternative medicine preparations, sanitary/ [39]. A potential cause for this irritation or chafing is the Dry
incontinence pads, hygiene wipes, cleansers, lubricants, and Weave plastic that is a component of the “wings” portion of
undergarment materials [25]. Treatment requires avoidance of sanitary napkin preferred by the women [39].
suspected allergens and those confirmed through patch test- Patients with ICD may present with a chief complaint of
ing. Prior to patch testing results, discontinuation of any elec- pain in addition to itching and burning [18, 19]. In acute ICD,
tive topical products and conversion to products with less dye the examination demonstrates vesicles, erosions, and edema
and free of fragrance should be recommended. Patch testing [18, 19]. In chronic ICD, the examination shows a different
can also inform which topical treatments are appropriate for appearance with deeper red tones of erythema, absence of
treatment of ACD [25]. vesicles, and increased lichenification [18, 19]. Similar to
ACD, treatment requires discontinuation of suspected inciting
products or habits [34]. Patient should be counseled regarding
Irritant Contact Dermatitis cleansing practices with hands and water only in the area no
more than twice daily [34]. The vulvar area should not be in
Of all cases of contact dermatitis, the majority is due to irritant contact with soap, cleanser, or detergent [34]. For relief of
contact dermatitis (ICD). Although ICD is a common disease, symptoms, patients are recommended a Sitz bath for approx-
the exact incidence of vulvar involvement in the geriatric pop- imately 5–10 min twice daily [34]. For barrier protection, a
ulation is unknown [34]. Similar to allergic contact dermatitis, moisturizing emollient such as plain white petrolatum should
barrier dysfunction is a mechanism that allows the vulva to be be applied [34, 38]. An appropriate strength corticosteroid
more prone to irritants leading to acute or chronic ICD [35]. corresponding to severity of the vulvar eruption should be
Unlike allergic contact dermatitis, ICD results from direct cy- applied twice daily until resolved [34].
totoxic damage without prior sensitization [34]. Acute ICD is Other considerations in diagnosing contact dermatitis in-
caused by exposure to a strong irritant through avenues such clude performing a skin biopsy, patch testing, and consider-
as contamination of skin and clothes or direct application [35]. ation of other superimposed skin conditions [31, 34]. Skin
Chronic exposure to irritants occurs more frequently and biopsies can confirm the presence of contact dermatitis, but
symptoms tend to develop after skin damage has exceeded further investigation into the patient’s history and examination
an individualized threshold [35]. This threshold is lowered are required to differentiate between ACD or ICD [34].
Curr Geri Rep
Table 2 Common Vulvar Irritants [27–30, 32, 34, 35, 37] 41]. In patients with recurrent vulvar dermatitis, attention to
Topical vehicle Propylene glycol timing may be helpful in determining an allergen or irritant
preparations Hexylene glycol [39].
Lanolin
Ethanol/Alcohol based creams and gels
Physical Overcleaning
Vulvovaginal Candidiasis
Sanitary/incontinence pads
Vulvovaginal candidiasis (VVC) or vaginal yeast infection is
Clothing
a common problem, but its prevalence in postmenopausal
Sponges
women is approximately 5 to 6% with decreasing odds of
Towels
detection with each increasing year of age [42]. Candidal
Hairdryer
growth is not favored in postmenopausal women due to the
Prolonged sexual intercourse
vaginal environment with pH level greater than 5.0 and low
Endogenous Urine
glycogen concentrations from decreased hormonal circulation
Feces
[42]. Patients may be at increased risk for candida vulvovag-
Perspiration
initis if they are receiving estrogen hormone replacement ther-
Vaginal secretions
apy, antibiotics, or steroids [42]. Other conditions that results
Obesity ➔ increased skin moisture and
in increased risk include immunosuppression and diabetes
friction
[42]. Patients may present with symptoms of itching, burning,
Saliva (frequent oro-genital contact)
and vaginal discharge [42]. These symptoms overlap with a
Semen
wide array of vulvovaginal inflammatory conditions; there-
Personal care products Wipes
fore, key physical exam findings or KOH microscopy results
Bubble baths/soap/shower gels/cleansers
are important in distinguishing the diagnosis. The exam may
Powders
demonstrate bright erythematous patches, thin plaques, or fis-
Douches
sures with satellite papules [18, 19]. Pustules or collarettes of
Deodorants
scale from dissolved pustules can also be present [18, 19].
Sprays/perfumes
VVC is the number one cause of fissures on the interlabial
Depilatories
creases of the vulva [18, 19]. For KOH microscopy, the pres-
Lotions/creams
ence of pseudohyphae and yeast buds confirms the diagnosis
Caustic irritants Bleach
of VVC [18, 19]. This test sensitivity is approximately 40%
Lye
and may require further testing with a fungal culture if there is
Isopropyl alcohol clinical suspicion for VVC in spite of a negative KOH micros-
Topical medications Tea tree oil copy result [18, 19]. Treatment of choice is an azole antifungal
5-Fluorouracil cream or a one-time dose of fluconazole 150 mg for an un-
Imiquimod complicated infection with Candida albicans [18, 19].
Phenol
Podophyllin
Trichloroacetic acid Lichen Simplex Chronicus
Sexual support Lubricants
Condoms with lubricant or spermicide Lichen simplex chronicus (LSC) is a condition defined as the
chronic scratching and rubbing of the skin [2]. LSC can be
primary with no identified cause or secondary to underlying
Biopsy is crucial when there is a concern for malignancy and inflammatory vulvovaginal diseases described in this article
the biopsy should be taken from an active lesion [3]. A neg- [2]. Heightened sensation of itch is a result of increased stim-
ative patch test may guide diagnosis towards ICD over ACD, ulation from scratching or rubbing behavior that leads to the
but patch testing of the upper limb or back may not be repre- prominent “itch-scratch cycle” in LSC [2]. Affected individ-
sentative of the vulvar skin reaction towards an allergen [40]. uals tend to struggle with controlling their scratching behavior
ACD should be considered in recurrent vulvar dermatitis even during the night time [43]. Common triggers for itching in-
in the case of a negative patch test. Candidal vulvovaginitis clude heat, sweating, rubbing of thighs, and mental stress [43].
and lichen simplex chronicus are both conditions that can be This may be due to factors such as tight-fitting clothing, use of
superimposed or occur simultaneously with contact dermati- over the counter medications, use of incontinence or sanitary
tis. Lesions may resolve with antifungal creams or corticoste- pads, or obesity [2]. Psychological factors have been de-
roids in parallel to discontinuation of allergens or irritants [39, scribed in literature as a risk factor for developing LSC. One
Curr Geri Rep
study found individuals with anxiety had a 41-fold greater risk Patients can present on opposite ends of the spectrum,
of developing LSC compared with individuals in the cohort from no symptoms to extreme pruritus with pain and
matched for age, sex, and index date of anxiety [44]. The labia burning [18, 19, 53]. Physical exam may demonstrate
majora is the most commonly affected location. The exam well-demarcated plaques which may lack characteristic
demonstrates lichenified, erythematous, or hyperpigmented thick scale in the intertriginous areas due to occlusive
plaques [2, 43]. In chronic LSC, the involved skin can cause nature of the site [18, 19, 31]. Clinical suspicion of gen-
hyperpigmentation or hypopigmentation [2, 43]. LSC is a di- ital psoriasis can be further evaluated with inspection of
agnosis that requires physical examination and potentially bi- the nails for onycholysis or pitting [18, 19]. Characteristic
opsy to rule out other conditions that may be instigating the psoriatic plaques can also be demonstrated in other areas
pruritic sensation [2]. of the body [18, 19]. Topical therapy with corticosteroids,
calcineurin inhibitors, and/or calcipotriene is the first-line
therapy for mild to moderate psoriasis in elderly patients
Autoimmune Blistering Disorders [18, 19, 54]. Advancement of treatment with combina-
tions of phototherapy or immunomodulators requires con-
Autoimmune blistering disorders are differentiated based on sideration for the balance of side effects with therapy
specific targets of autoantibodies in the skin and mucosa. The benefits [54••].
most common subsets that affect middle-aged or elderly indi-
viduals in order of incidence include bullous pemphigoid,
mucous membrane pemphigoid (cicatricial pemphigoid), and
pemphigus vulgaris [45]. Patients typically present with pru- Conclusion
ritus and tense bullae with bullous pemphigoid. With pemphi-
gus vulgaris, flaccid bullae and painful erosions of the skin Vulvar inflammatory dermatoses continue to be
and oral mucosa are seen. One study reviewed clinical data underreported, misdiagnosed, and undertreated in the elderly
from 1988 to June 2005 in a tertiary dermatology referral population. Key themes for provider improvement include
center and identified 34 patients with genital involvement of careful review of the patient’s medical history and physical
pemphigus vulgaris [46]. Physical examination that shows examination of the genitoanal area for asymptomatic and
erosions of the genital mucosa should prompt further inspec- symptomatic elderly women. Overlapping symptoms of pru-
tion of the oral mucosa for lesions since this is a prominent site ritus or pain and disease processes including genitourinary
for involvement [17–19]. The presence of lesions in the syndrome of menopause, vulvovaginal candidiasis, or lichen
vulvovaginal area alone without oral mucosal involvement is simplex chronicus can often complicate the diagnosis of the
rare [47]. Diagnosis can be confirmed with a biopsy for H&E primary vulvar dermatosis. Vulvar dermatoses which cannot
stain and direct immunofluorescence as well as serum for be controlled require altering the treatment plan to the next
indirect immunofluorescence to identify target location of tier for the condition or reinvestigating potential causes.
the antibodies [47]. First-line treatment of pemphigus vulgaris Prompt, consistent treatment can vastly improve the patient’s
is systemic corticosteroids and rituximab [48, 49]. Oral corti- quality of life and is critical to minimizing the risk of devel-
costeroids in combination with immunosuppressive drugs oping squamous cell carcinoma in conditions predisposed to
such as methotrexate, azathioprine, mycophenolate mofetil, this risk such as lichen sclerosus and lichen planus. When
dapsone, or cyclophosphamide are also possible treatment treatment requires advancing to systemic immunosuppres-
regimens [50]. sive therapy or oral corticosteroids, there should be a discus-
sion regarding risk versus benefits of treatment with patients
due to the increased vulnerability of geriatric patients to side
Psoriasis effects. Further research should be aimed at developing tools
for communicating with patients regarding this topic, identi-
Psoriasis is a chronic inflammatory condition that affects fying modifiable risk factors, and determining optimal
2 to 3.2% of adults in the USA [51, 52]. The estimated therapy.
prevalence of genital involvement in patients with psori-
asis ranges from 29 to 46% [53]. Genital psoriasis is more Compliance with Ethical Standards
common than realized previously since there is a lack of
examination of the genital area for chronic psoriatic pa- Conflict of Interest The authors declare that there is no conflict of
interest.
tients, which accounts for the variable range of prevalence
[53]. This condition may have a negative effect on quality
Human and Animal Rights and Informed Consent This article does not
of life or sexual health by interfering with patients’ activ- contain any studies with human or animal subjects performed by any of
ities of daily living, social life, and self-esteem [52, 53]. the authors.
Curr Geri Rep
45. Bertram F, Bröcker E-B, Zillikens D, Schmidt E. Prospective anal- 50. Schmidt E, Zillikens D. The diagnosis and treatment of autoim-
ysis of the incidence of autoimmune bullous disorders in Lower mune blistering skin diseases. Dtsch Arztebl Int. 2011;108:399–
Franconia, Germany. J Dtsch Dermatol Ges. 2009;7:434–40. 405 I.
46. Malik M, Ahmed AR. Involvement of the female genital tract in 51. Rachakonda TD, Schupp CW, Armstrong AW. Psoriasis preva-
pemphigus vulgaris. Obstet Gynecol. 2005;106:1005–12. lence among adults in the United States. J Am Acad Dermatol.
47. Davis SA, Davis LS. Pemphigus vulgaris presenting as chronic 2014;70:512–6.
vulvovaginal erosions: the importance of autoantibody testing: a 52. Weigle N, Mcbane R. Psoriasis. Am Fam Physician. 2013 May
case report. J Reprod Med. 2016;61:589–91. 1;87(9):626–633. https://www.aafp.org/afp/2013/0501/
48. Murrell DF, Peña S, Joly P, Marinovic B, Hashimoto T, Diaz LA, afp20130501p626.pdf
et al. Diagnosis and management of pemphigus: recommendations 53. Meeuwis KAP, Potts Bleakman A, van de Kerkhof PCM, Dutronc
of an international panel of experts. J. Am. Acad. Dermatol. Y, Henneges C, Kornberg LJ, et al. Prevalence of genital psoriasis
2020;82:575–585.e1. in patients with psoriasis. J Dermatolog Treat. 2018;29:754–60.
49. Joly P, Maho-Vaillant M, Prost-Squarcioni C, Hebert V, Houivet E, 54.•• Kamel JG,Yamauchi PS.Managing mild-to-moderate psoriasis in
Calbo S, et al. First-line rituximab combined with short-term pred- elderly patients: Role of topical treatments. Drugs Aging.
nisone versus prednisone alone for the treatment of pemphigus 2007;34:583–8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40266-017-0480-8
(Ritux 3): a prospective, multicentre, parallel-group, open-label
randomised trial. Lancet. 2017;389:2031–40. Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdic-
tional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.