You are on page 1of 108

De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute i

SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

COMPARATIVE STUDY ON THE DEPRESSION LEVELS BETWEEN


JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL AND SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
TEACHERS IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS OF THE
CITY OF DASMARIÑAS, CAVITE

A Capstone Project
Presented to
The Faculty of the Special Health Sciences Senior High School
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute
City of Dasmariñas, Cavite

In Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements in


Inquiries, Investigation, and Immersion

BIANCA EMMANUELLE DANA R. BARZAGA


JERSEY MARIELL E. CO
JERICHO DANIEL D. IGDANES
ANFERNIE S. LORILLA
CAITLIN JOY A. SANCHEZ
ALYANNA KIARA S. SARINAS

July 2019
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute ii
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

RESEARCH OUTPUT OPEN ACCESS PERMISSION

We, Bianca Emmanuelle Dana R. Barzaga, Jersey Mariell E. Co, Jericho Daniel D.
Igdanes, Anfernie S. Lorilla, Caitlin Joy A. Sanchez, And Alyanna Kiara S. Sarinas,
authors of the research output Comparative Study on the Depression Levels between
Junior High School and Senior High School Teachers in the Public Schools of the City
Of Dasmariñas, Cavite, submitted to De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute –
Special Health Sciences Senior High School in partial fulfillment of the year level 12th Grade,
do hereby grant DLSMHSI the right to reproduce, publish, and distribute copies of the said
research output in whatever form deemed appropriate by DLSMHSI subject to applicable
laws, institutional policies, and contracts. Specifically, the following rights are granted to
DLSMHSI:

1. To upload a copy of this research output and be made accessible online through the
institutional repository or database,
2. To publish a copy of this research in the Compendium of Research Abstracts or
similar publications, whether print or online,
3. To provide open access to the research output provided that the author/s is/are
properly acknowledged and the work is cited.

RESEARCH OUTPUT ACCESS AUTHORIZATION


FOR POTENTIALLY PATENTABLE WORK

Permission is given for the following people to have access to this research ouput:
Available to the general public (YES or NO)
Available only after consultation with author/thesis adviser/Dean or Director (YES or NO)
Available only to those bound by confidentiality agreement (YES or NO)

BIANCA EMMANUELLE DANA R. BARZAGA ANFERNIE S. LORILLA

JERSEY MARIELL E. CO CAITLIN JOY A. SANCHEZ

JERICHO DANIEL D. IGDANES ALYANNA KIARA S. SARINAS


Student Authors

JOSE ISAAK M. CALAMLAM, LPT, MA


Research Adviser

VIVIAN B. RAMIREZ, MSc


Director, SHSSHS
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute iii
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

ABSTRACT

Through the years, very few studies have been made on depression-
causing factors among public school teachers despite the increase in work-related
depression in the teaching profession. The objective of the present study was to
determine the differences between the levels of depression among Junior High
School and Senior High School Teachers in Public Schools in Dasmariñas City,
Cavite. This study investigated the relationship between the professional and
personal concerns on the mental health of a public school teacher. The research
was carried out in 3 public high schools in Dasmariñas City, Cavite, with a
sample consisting of 108 teachers by using a data questionnaire model of a
Correlational Quantitative Study with elements of a Comparative Qualitative
Study. Analysis and statistical testing rendered the result that there was no
significant difference between the depression levels of both groups. Generally
speaking, both are most susceptible to a moderate degree of depression, as a result
of exposure to personal and professional stressors.

Key Terms: stressors, public high schools, mental health, PHQ-9


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute iv
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

RESEARCH APPROVAL SHEET

This is to certify that this Research titled COMPARATIVE STUDY ON THE


DEPRESSION LEVELS BETWEEN JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL AND SENIOR
HIGH SCHOOL TEACHERS IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS OF THE CITY OF
DASMARIÑAS, CAVITE prepared and submitted by BIANCA EMMANUELLE
DANA R. BARZAGA, JERSEY MARIELL E. CO, JERICHO DANIEL D.
IGDANES, ANFERNIE S. LORILLA, CAITLIN JOY A. SANCHEZ, and
ALYANNA KIARA S. SARINAS in partial fulfillment of the requirements in Inquiries,
Investigation, and Immersion (I3) was successfully defended by the researchers and
approved by the Research Review Panel (RRP) on ____________________.

JOSE ISAAK M. CALAMLAM, LPT, MA SHAIYNE C. DEQUE, LPT


Research Adviser Chair, RRP

MARK LAWRENCE F. FABREGAS, LPT LENARD CHARLES C. MONSADA, MD


Member, RRP Member, RRP

The Special Health Sciences Senior High School Department (SHSSHS)


endorses acceptance of this Research as partial fulfillment of the requirements in
Inquiries, Investigation, and Immersion (I3).

JOSE ISAAK M. CALAMLAM, LPT, MA VIVIAN B. RAMIREZ, MSc


Academic Chair, SHSSHS Director, SHSSHS
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute v
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This research would not have happened without the support of the De La

Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute. We thank our professors from the

Special Health Sciences Senior High School, particularly our subject instructor,

Mr. Jose Isaak Calamlam. Their input and support significantly supported the

research, and their insights on the topic further fueled our desire to work in the

field of the health sciences.

We thank Mr. Lord Joseas Conwi for providing us a Psychometrician’s

point of view. His comments greatly improved and refocused the trajectory of this

study. Also, we would like to show our gratitude to Ms. Maria Ligaya Lopez, Ms.

Mia Maica Mangoba, Mr. Jose Royce Aledia, and Ms. Edeline Quial for sharing

their expertise with us during the early stages of instrument construction.

We are also immensely grateful to Ms. Imee Serrano for being a

consultant during the statistical analysis stage. Her in-depth discussions of the

treatments required in the study also provided us a refresher of the foundations to

statistics and probability. We are also thankful to Ms. Charina Shane Co, who was

instrumental in removing and revising grammatical errors in this paper.

Any oversights are our own and should not tarnish the reputations of these

esteemed persons. The participation of the respondents of the study is highly

valued, as well as the approval of their respective school principals.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute vi
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Certainly, we would also like to thank our friends and family members

who remained supportive all throughout the duration of the study.

Lastly, we would like to acknowledge the Filipino teachers. They are truly

valuable assets to this nation and they are undeniably the foundation of our

workforce.

To God be the glory.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute vii
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Title Page i

Research Output Open Access Permission ii

Abstract iii

Approval Sheet iv

Acknowledgments v

Table of Contents vii

List of Tables x

List of Figures xii

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION

Background of the Study 1

Conceptual Framework 3

Statement of the Problem 4

Hypotheses 4

Scope and Limitations 5

Significance of the Study 6

Definition of Terms 7

CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW

Mental Health 11

Stress 12

Depression 13

Depression vs. Sadness 15


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute viii
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Severity of Depression 16

Gender and Age Range-Specific Depression 17

Work-Related Stress 18

Teachers and Stressful Workload 20

Cases of Depression and Suicide among Teachers 21

Erik Erikson’s Stages of Psychosocial Development 22

Theory of Anomie 24

Psychiatric Hegemony 25

Bell Curve of Abnormal Psychology 26

CHAPTER 3 METHODOLOGY

Research Design 28

Population and Sampling 28

Respondents of the Study 28

Research Instrument 29

Validity and Reliability of Instruments 30

Ethical Considerations 31

Data Gathering Procedure 31

Analysis of Data 32

CHAPTER 4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Demographic Profile of the Respondents 33

Item Analysis of Personal and Professional Concerns 37

Depression Level Based on Mental Health Assessment 54


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute ix
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Comparison between Depression Levels of the Departments 56

CHAPTER 5 SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION, AND

RECOMMENDATIONS

Summary of Findings 57

Conclusion 58

Recommendations 60

Cited References 62

Appendices

A. Informed Consent Form 72

B. Research Instrument 74

C. Site Map 78

D. Letter for School Principal 79

E. Photo Documentation 81

F. Validation of Research Instrument 82

G. Certification from the Psychometrician 87

H. Certification from the Statistician 88

I. Certification from the Editor 89

Curriculum Vitae 90
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute x
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1. Age Range of Respondents 33

Table 2. Sex of Respondents 34

Table 3. Civil Status of the Respondents 35

Table 4. Teaching Load of the Respondents 36

Table 5.1 Responses from JHS Participants 37


(Communication with Family and Friends)

Table 5.2 Responses from SHS Participants 37


(Communication with Family and Friends)

Table 6.1 Responses from JHS Participants 39


(Misunderstandings with Family Members)

Table 6.2 Responses from SHS Participants 39


(Misunderstandings with Family Members)

Table 7.1 Responses of JHS Participants 40


(Misunderstandings with Friends and Significant Others)

Table 7.2 Responses of SHS Participants 41


(Misunderstandings with Friends and Significant Others)

Table 8.1 Responses of JHS Participants 42


(Problems Relating to Finances)

Table 8.2 Responses of SHS Participants 42


(Problems Relating to Finances)

Table 9.1 Responses of JHS Participants 44


(Entertainment Habits)

Table 9.2 Responses of SHS Participants 44


(Entertainment Habits)

Table 10.1 Responses of JHS Participants 46


(Deadlines and Time Allocation)
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute xi
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Table 10.2 Responses of SHS Participants 46


(Deadlines and Time Allocation)

Table 11.1 Responses of JHS Participants 48


(Exertion of Effort)

Table 11.2 Responses of SHS Participants 48


(Exertion of Effort)

Table 12.1 Responses of JHS Participants 49


(Working Atmosphere)

Table 12.2 Responses of SHS Participants 50


(Working Atmosphere)

Table 13.1 Responses of JHS Participants 51


(Relationship with Supervisors)

Table 13.2 Responses of SHS Participants 51


(Relationship with Supervisors)

Table 14.1 Responses of JHS Participants 53


(Relationship with Co-workers)

Table 14.2 Responses of SHS Participants 53


(Relationship with Co-workers)

Table 15.1 Frequency Distribution of Level of 55


Depression of Junior High School Teachers

Table 15.2 Frequency Distribution of Level of 55


Depression of Senior High School Teachers
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute xii
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1. Conceptual Framework 3

Figure 2. Age Range of Respondents 33

Figure 3. Sex of Respondents 34

Figure 4. Civil Status of Respondents 35

Figure 5. Teaching Load of Respondents 36

Figure 6.1 Responses to Question No. 1 (JHS) 38

Figure 6.2 Responses to Question No. 1 (SHS) 38

Figure 7.1 Responses to Question No. 2 (JHS) 39

Figure 7.2 Responses to Question No. 2 (SHS) 39

Figure 8.1 Responses to Question No. 3 (JHS) 41

Figure 8.2 Responses to Question No. 3 (SHS) 41

Figure 9.1 Responses to Question No. 4 (JHS) 43

Figure 9.2 Responses to Question No. 4 (SHS) 43

Figure 10.1 Responses to Question No. 5 (JHS) 45

Figure 10.2 Responses to Question No. 5 (SHS) 45

Figure 11.1 Responses to Question No. 6 (JHS) 47

Figure 11.2 Responses to Question No. 6 (SHS) 47

Figure 12.1 Responses to Question No. 7 (JHS) 48

Figure 12.2 Responses to Question No. 7 (SHS) 48

Figure 13.1 Responses to Question No. 8 (JHS) 50

Figure 13.2 Responses to Question No. 8 (SHS) 50


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute xiii
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Figure 14.1 Responses to Question No. 9 (JHS) 52

Figure 14.2 Responses to Question No. 9 (SHS) 52

Figure 15.1 Responses to Question No. 10 (JHS) 53

Figure 15.2 Responses to Question No. 10 (SHS) 53

Figure 16. Map of Dasmariñas City, Cavite 78

Figure 17. Photo during the Data Gathering 81


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 1
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

CHAPTER 1

INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background of the Study

The increase in cases of depression among public school teachers

increased the intent of the researchers to investigate the phenomena. The study of

depression has become an important aspect of the society for it is a major health

problem (Cujipers, et al., 2011). Depression is a mental disorder wherein it

negatively affects the way a person thinks, acts, and feels. It makes one lose

interest in things that are enjoyed before, unable to find the will to function and

live every day. This disorder can lead not only to emotional problems but to

physical problems as well that some of the worst cases lead to self-harm or

suicide.

Due to personal and professional concerns, an increasing number of

teachers have been experiencing mental health problems (Gorsy, Panwar, &

Kumar, 2015). The journal, Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epistemology,

published a report showing that the education industry falls in the mid-level of

those who suffer from depression (Wulsin, Alterman, Bushnell, Li, & Shen, 2014,

p. 1805). It has a depression rate of about 10 percent while the average rate across

all industries is 10.45 percent (DiMauro, 2016). Teachers who have depression

are having a hard time resisting themselves not to break down in front of the class.

Insomnia and feelings of dread are additional symptoms. Their depression leads to
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 2
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

being too physically and mentally drained that they do not have the energy to do

their jobs anymore. They would procrastinate their work which would make them

feel stressed.

It is commonly suggested that the key to overcome depression is to seek

help and prioritize one's mental health. Dilekmen (2013) found out that teachers

in Turkey experience some psychological problems that affect their students

negatively. Some teachers reported several symptoms of depression, such as

feelings of shame, dread, and insomnia (Finley, 2018). In addition, up to 93

percent of elementary school teachers have reported feeling high levels of stress

(Terada, 2018).

Although a numbers of research papers have been published on the topic

of mental health, only a limited number has focused solely on teachers for

responses. Hence, additional studies investigating the mental health of teachers

are needed to further increase awareness and research efforts. The study will be

obtaining responses by the means of administering examinations gauging the

workload and personal symptoms of the respondent.

This study aims to determine and compare the difference of the levels of

depression among junior high school and senior high school teachers. In addition

to that, this research aims to identify if there’s a relationship between being a

teacher assigned in a particular department and being depressed.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 3
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

1.2 Conceptual Framework

The diagram below shows the research paradigm of the proposed study:

Junior High School Senior High School


Public Teachers in Public Teachers in
Dasmariñas, Cavite Dasmariñas, Cavite

Personal and Professional


Concerns
Personal – family, friends, habits,
relationships, finances

Professional – relationship with co-


workers, academic workload, schedule,
work ethic

Depression Levels
Mental Health

Figure 1. Conceptual Framework

This study is anchored on a conceptual framework composed of two

groups of factors leading towards depression. The first of these is personal

concerns, which involves the respondent’s family, friends, habits, relationships,

and finances. On the other hand, professional concerns are concerned with

relationships with co-workers, academic workload, schedule, and work ethic

make up the second group. This framework is influenced by concepts employed

in a study by Kinser and Lyon (2014). The aforementioned study focused on

stress vulnerability, depression, and health outcomes among women and

complementary therapies for depression.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 4
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

1.3 Statement of the Problem

This study aims to determine if there are any differences between the

levels of depression among Junior High School and Senior High School Teachers

in Public Schools in Dasmariñas City, Cavite. The study also seeks to answer the

following questions:

1. What is the depression level of the respondents in terms of:

a. Personal Concerns

b. Professional Concerns?

2. What is the depression level of the respondents as categorized as:

a. Mild

b. Moderate

c. Severe

d. Profound?

1.4 Hypotheses

The following hypotheses are to be tested to accept or reject the proposed

study on the Comparative Study on the Depression Levels between Junior High

School and Senior High School Teachers in the Public Schools of the City of

Dasmariñas, Cavite:

1) Null Hypothesis (H0) – There is no statistical difference between the

average level of depression among JHS teachers to the average level of

depression among SHS teachers.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 5
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

2) Alternative Hypothesis (H1) – There is a statistical difference between the

average level of depression among JHS teachers to the average level of

depression among SHS teachers.

1.5 Scope and Limitations

This correlational study deals with determining the difference between the

depression levels among Junior High School and Senior High School Teachers in

Public Schools in Dasmariñas City, Cavite. The study was conducted in three (3)

public schools in Dasmariñas City, Cavite. These schools have both Junior High

School and Senior High School Departments. A questionnaire inquiring about the

personal concerns, professional concerns, and mental health of the respondents is

administered.

Demographics such as age, sex, civil status, teaching load, socioeconomic

status, and wage earnings were not taken into account. These factors were not

concerned with the problems this research sought to address. Furthermore, the

data gathering stage occurred within one month. This time frame was influenced

by extraneous factors such as availability and academic constraints. It is not based

on any related literature and is not historical in nature.

The questionnaire specifies a two-week period in some items. This is

consistent with the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, which

characterizes major depressive disorder by episodes of at least two (2) weeks

duration.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 6
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

1.6 Significance of the Study

Teachers. This refers to professionals tasked with helping people acquire

knowledge, competences, values, and ethics. This research aims to help raise

teachers’ awareness on issues concerning their mental health.

Students. This refers to people studying at schools, colleges, or

universities. This research aims to inform students and school officials about the

experiences of teachers with depression.

Mental Health Practitioners. This refers to professionals who diagnose,

and treat mental illnesses and behavioral disorders. Psychologists,

psychometricians, and guidance counselors fall within this umbrella classification.

This study aims to provide mental health practitioners additional knowledge and

possible interventions regarding teachers who are also vulnerable to depression.

Academic Institutions. This refers to schools, colleges, universities,

review centers, and workplaces. The study will be of help to academic institutions

in creating appropriate workplace environments for their teachers and employees.

Government. This refers to a group of individuals tasked with making

decisions for a department, region, or country. The study will be of help to the

government, particularly agencies concerned with education, in the adjustment of

curricula, policies, and educational system that may be contributing to the

depression levels of teachers.

Society. This is defined as a large group of individuals sharing a common

interaction, territory, occupation, religion, or culture. This study aims to raise


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 7
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

awareness on the phenomena of depression among teachers. The study will not

only contribute to their awareness of the topic, but also their understanding of the

concept of depression in the workplace.

Researchers and Research Community. This refers to individuals

interested in conducting research or investigative studies about teachers and

depression in the Philippines. This study will further help and contribute to future

studies, potentially serving as a reference for further research involving the topic

at hand. The results and findings of the study will contribute to further research

developments in the field of education, psychology, psychiatry, medicine, and

humanities, especially within the Philippine setting.

1.7 Definition of Terms

The following terms are defined for conceptual and technical purposes.

Anxiety. Refers to a feeling of apprehension and fear characterized by

physical symptoms such as palpitations, sweating, and feelings of stress.

Curriculum. Defined as the syllabus and totality of the application of an

educational system in a particular level of education.

Depression. Defined as a serious medical illness and mood disorder that

causes a persistent feeling of sadness and loss of interest. Several classifications

of depression are recognized. In this paper, depression is limitedly defined to

major depressive disorder (MDD).


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 8
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Depression Levels. Defined as the degree of melancholic mood and loss

of interest in hobbies, work, and other activities. Categorized as mild, moderate,

severe, or profound.

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition

(DSM-5). The most recent and available version of the taxonomic and diagnostic

tool published by the American Psychiatric Association (APA) as of this writing.

It is used by health care providers for treatment recommendations. DSM-5 is

frequently cited in this paper.

Educational System. The educational system is a working body designed

to be the backbone of an academic institution. Composed of teachers,

administrative officials, students and stakeholders. The system is heavily

influenced by the curricula being mandated by government agencies such as the

Department of Education and Commission on Higher Education.

Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAM-D). A 23-item questionnaire

used to determine indications of depression, and provide suggestions to evaluate

recovery. It should be administered by a psychologist or specialist who has

experience working with psychiatric patients.

Insomnia. Refers to a sleep disorder that is characterized by difficulty

falling and/or staying asleep. It can be caused by psychiatric and medical

conditions, unhealthy sleep habits, and stress.

International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health

Problems, 10th revision (ICD-10). Refers to the 10th revision of a medical


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 9
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

classification list by the World Health Organization. ICD-10 contains codes and

classifications of psychiatric diseases, and is also frequently cited in this paper.

Junior High School (JHS). In the K-12 curriculum, defined as grade

levels 7 to 10 in secondary education.

K to 12 Program. It covers Kindergarten and 12 years of basic education

(6 years of primary education, 4 years of Junior High School, and 2 years of

Senior High School). It is to provide sufficient time for mastery of concepts and

skills, develop lifelong learners, and prepare students for tertiary education,

average skills developments, employment, and entrepreneurship.

Major Depressive Disorder (MDD). Also known as clinical depression,

or simply depression. It is a mental disorder benchmarked by at least two weeks

of symptoms affecting the feelings, thoughts, and activities of an individual. In

this paper, depression pertains to MDD.

Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9). An instrument available

within the public domain that is used to measure the severity of depression in

adults. It may be used and reproduced by researchers and specialists.

Personal Concerns. Features of personality that describe personal

adaptations to developmental tasks. Personal concerns cover the big 3 motives

(need for achievement, power, and intimacy/affection), attachment styles, and

status of psychosocial stage resolution.

Professional Concerns. Matters pertaining to a person's work,

particularly jobs that require special training or educational attainment.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 10
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Public School. An academic institution subsidized by the government.

Senior High School (SHS). Defined as the 11th and 12th grades in

secondary education.

Stress. A concept that forces usually situational or environmental

impinging on the individual. It can lead to a host of physical and psychological

issues and, left untreated, develop into full-scale depression.

Teacher. A person involved in facilitating, teaching, creating lesson plans,

and reporting and/or submitting relevant information within the academic

institution. Also referred to as professors or instructors, these individuals are

found in schools, colleges, universities, and review centers.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 11
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

CHAPTER 2

LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 Conceptual Literature

Mental Health

Mental health includes the emotional, psychological, and social aspects of

a person. It affects how an individual thinks, feels, and acts. It also aids in

determining how people handle stress, interact with others, and make important

decisions. Mental health is essential in all stages of life, from childhood and

adolescence to adulthood (U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, 2017).

A mental illness is a disorder that disrupts an individual’s method of

thinking or feeling (National Alliance on Mental Illness, 2018). These

circumstances may affect a person’s ability to relate to others, as well as their

quality of work and output. Varying experiences will manifest in each patient,

even in people with identical diagnosis. Mental illnesses are not the outcome of a

single event. Studies imply that there are many overlapping causes: genetics,

environment, and lifestyle affect the development of a mental health disorder. A

stressful professional or personal life increases susceptibility in a number of

individuals, as well as distressing life events. Biochemical mechanisms and basic

brain structure are also important factors.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 12
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Stress

The word “stress” was devised by Hans Selye in 1936 (American Institute

of Stress, 2018). It is defined as the non-specific response of the body to any

demand for change” is the most generic. Stress persists as a negative feeling

rather than a positive feeling. Instances of positive stress include manifestations

while under pressure, which motivates an individual to finish a task. A working

explanation for stress that is appropriate for multiple scenarios is that it is a

condition wherein an individual is triggered and made anxious by an

uncontrollable stimulus. This leads to fear and anxiety. The scale of the stress and

its physiological effects like anxiety or post-traumatic stress disorder are affected

by the individual’s discernment of their capability to handle the stressor (Fink,

2016).

According to the U.S. National Library of Medicine, stress is a sensation

manifesting in emotional or physical strain. It may result from any event or

thought that makes an individual feel frustrated, angry, or nervous. There are two

primary subdivisions of stress: Acute Stress, which is short-range stress that

resolves quickly, and it aids an individual manage a dangerous situation. It also

occurs when doing a task that is new or exciting. Conversely, Chronic Stress

persists for an extended period of time. It could last for even weeks or months and

if it’s not managed, it may lead to health problems (U.S. National Library of

Medicine, 2018).
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 13
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Examples of short-term effects of stress include headaches, shallow

breathing, difficulty in sleeping, anxiety, and an upset stomach. Long-term

constant stress can amplify the risk for heart disease, back pain, depression,

persistent muscle aches and pains, and an impaired immune system (Blaivas &

Nelson, 2018). Stress is also related to reducing concentration and imagination.

Depression

Defined as a state of apathy and repulsion to activity, depression may have

a deliberate impact on a person’s thoughts, feelings, behavior, and sense of well-

being. Major Depressive Disorder (or Clinical Depression) is a critical and

restricting psychiatric condition and occasionally leads to suicide or premature

death (Qahtani, 2017).

Symptoms must be present for at least two weeks before one can be

diagnosed with depression (National Institute of Mental Health, 2018). The yearly

prevalence rate of Major Depressive Disorder is 6.6 %, while the lifetime

prevalence rate of depression is 16.2%. The prevalence of depression and increase

in suicide risk is a growing public health concern (Miller & Chung, 2009).

Anxiety and depression are also common among persons belonging to the

working population. Depression is also associated with functional disability and

work impairment (Andrea, Bültmann, van Amelsvoort, & Kant, 2009). Despite its

prevalence in employees, little is known about the incidence rate and possible risk

factors for developing depression in the working population.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 14
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Worldwide, there is an estimated 676 million (one in ten) people

experiencing depression. Furthermore, 804,000 people committed suicide in 2012.

This makes depression one of the top causes of death in young adults (ages 15-

29), second only to road traffic accidents. Individuals experiencing major

depression have a 40% higher chance of premature death than people who do not

experience it. The link between depression and higher chance of death and

morbidity is a clear sign of the danger the disorder poses, particularly when the

WHO data on life expectancy and the causes of death is considered.

A considerable dimension of depression encompasses the psychosocial

difficulties (PSDs) that people experience. PSDs make up the deficiency on

psychological and social daily behaviors of individuals, in connection to their

health concerns. The broad range of PSDs does not only include the personal, but

also the economic and social bearings of depression (Kamenov et al., 2014).

Depression is also characterized by the imbalance of neurotransmitters in the

brain, and is the leading cause of suicide (Schimelpfening, 2018).

Lerner, Adler, and Reed (2010) found out that the incidence of depression

and its symptoms severely affect the capacity to work. Based on their study,

depressed workers had four times the amount of work limitation than health

controls. Presenteeism and absenteeism were also higher with at least two to three

times for the workers with depression symptoms. Investigations on the

relationship between work related circumstances and depression showed an

increase in cases of depression in work situations that possessed high


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 15
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

psychological demands. These include low reward, low social support, low

decision latitude, stressful experiences, and mismatched tasks (de Vries, Koeter,

Nabitz, Hees, & Schene, 2012).

Depressive symptoms also have “an adverse effect on immediate recall of

new information and the amount (not rate) of acquisition, but not on retrieval or

retention (long delay free recall and recognition hits, respectively)”. Moreover,

when compounded with anxiety, depression has also an adverse effect on the

retrieval of newly learned information (Kizilbash, Vanderploeg, & Curtiss, 2002).

Depression vs. Sadness

Considering the fact that sadness is one of the primary symptoms of

depression, the discrepancy between the two psychological states may be difficult

to recognize. Sadness is defined as an emotional state that everyone will

experience throughout a lifetime, and is brought about by a trigger. A trigger may

be a situation, person, or event. In the case of depression, a specific cause may not

be present. Sadness also does not cause lack of enthusiasm for hobbies and other

activities. A depressed individual will no longer find enjoyment in activities that

he or she once found pleasurable (Shelton, 2019).

Depression also causes disruptions in eating and sleeping patterns, as well

as persistent feelings of worthlessness and guilt. These symptoms are not present

in mere sadness. However, it is possible for major depressive disorder to occur in

tandem to sadness. This may occur due to significant loss, such as mourning,
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 16
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

bankruptcy, or a fatal sickness. The verdict as to whether a diagnosis of

depression should be declared will hinge on the physician’s discretion.

Severity of Depression

The fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental

Disorders (DSM-5) uses number of symptoms, degree of distress affected by

intensity of symptoms, and damage to social and occupational functioning as

markings to define severity. Four severity levels of intellectual disorder are the

most extensively outlines (mild, moderate, severe, profound). Although research

outcomes have not been completely stable, intensity of depression has been linked

to health-related living conditions, functional damage, suicidality, longitudinal

course, and numerous biological variables (Zimmerman, Morgan, & Stanton,

2018).

The 10th version of the International Statistical Classification of Diseases

and Related Health Problems identifies three levels of severity for depression—

mild, moderate, and severe. Mild depression denotes the occurrence of two or

three symptoms that are troubling the patient, but does not affect daily activity.

Moderate depression involves four or more symptoms and greatly affects the

patient’s lifestyle. Severe depression is benchmarked by the appearance of several

symptoms that are difficult and distressing, and involve self-esteem loss, feelings

of worthlessness, and guilt. Harmful and even suicidal thoughts and actions are

prevalent, and somatic symptoms may be present.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 17
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Despite these distinctions, the ICD-10 designations may be accurate due to

a lack of symmetry in the given descriptions. Due to this, ICD-10 may be

imprecise and is not recommended for use in diagnosis (Zimmerman, Morgan, &

Stanton, 2018). Clusters of DSM-5 symptoms, with the aid of the Hamilton

Depression Rating Scale (HAM-D), may help clinical practitioners accurately

infer depression severity (Tolentino & Schmidt, 2018). The HAM-D form lists

twenty-one (21) items, although scoring is based on the first seventeen (17). The

HAM-D has an 86.4% sensitivity rate and a 92.2% specificity rate.

A scoring of 0-7 on the HAM-D would indicate the absence of depression,

while 8-13 shows mild depression and 14-18 suggests moderate depression. A

score within the values of 19-22 signposts severe depression and 23 specifies very

severe or profound depression. Patient Health Questionnaire–9 (PHQ-9), a

measure of depression severity in adults, has an interpretation table with similar

signposts and values as the HAM-D. PHQ-9 is in the public domain and is widely

available to researchers.

Gender and Age Range-Specific Depression

Although the belief that depression is a “women’s disease” relating to

factors such as hormones and premenstrual syndrome has been debunked, studies

have shown that men are less prone to depression than women (National Institute

of Mental Health, 2017). Over the course of a lifetime, women are twice as likely

as men to develop symptoms of depression (Kuehner, 2016). Subtypes of


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 18
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

depression that are associated with gender have been proposed to exist, from

which the developmental subtype has the highest possible chance to impact the

gender gap. In 2010, the global annual prevalence rate of depression in women

was 5.5% and 3.2% for men. This demonstrates a 1.7-fold greater frequency rate

in women (Albert, 2015).

According to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services

Administration, data from 2008 to 2010 indicates that 8.4% of full-time college

students aged 18 to 22 and 8.2% of other young adults underwent a major

depressive episode within the past year. From the projected 9.3 million adults in

the United States who described having suicidal ideations in the past year,

college-aged or young adults (ages 18 to 25) had the leading percentage of grave

thoughts about suicide at 7.4% (Levine, 2017).

Work-Related Stress

Depression is a primary cause of psychiatric indisposition and may be

hastened by psychosocial factors in the workplace. In a study conducted by Jens

Peter Bonde (2008), adversarial psychosocial factors in the workplace are linked

to a higher predisposition to depressive symptoms or major depressive episodes.

Depression was most consistently associated with job strain.

Work-related stress refers to the response people have demonstrated after

experiencing work demands and pressures that are inappropriate to their

knowledge and abilities (World Health Organization, 2018). These manifestations


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 19
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

challenge the employees’ ability to cope with everyday tasks and responsibilities.

This type of stress occurs in a broad scope of situations in the workplace, but is

often hastened when there is a lack of support from co-workers and superiors.

There is often confusion between pressure and challenge, leading to bad

management practices. Thus, this places a burden onto the workers.

Stigma is a major problem in the workplace, leading to situations where

employees are afraid to voice out their concerns. Their reluctance to seek support

or report their condition stems from the fear of losing their job. Thus, mental

health problems often go undiagnosed and untreated (Schoeman, 2018). The

demands in a fast-paced work environment may be a source of stress for

employees (Doyle, 2018). The work pattern and work environment of an

employee tend to incorporate stressors such as unrealistic deadlines,

unmanageable workload, under recruitment and long work hours. A lack of

influence over aspects of their job has also been cited as a cause for stress and

burnout.

Stress also increases the risk of error in tasks due to a lack of

concentration. Constant stress can affect one’s emotions and behavior by

rendering a person impatient and less enthusiastic (Blaivas & Nelson, 2018).

Furthermore, the societal expenses of work stress are excessive. Based on a recent

report from the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (2014), it was

projected that the annual economic liability of work stress totals to an estimated

EUR 617 billion in Europe and EUR 219 billion in the United States.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 20
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Male managers served as the respondents in a study investigating work-

related stress. For the first two years of the study, all respondents were subjected

to an 18-hour psychotherapeutic SMI intervention which was adapted from the

Effort-Reward Imbalance (ERI) model: stressor on mismatch between effort and

reward and encouraging recovery on overcommitment. Work stress was exhibited

as the main outcome, and the secondary outcome was symptoms of depression

(Li, et al., 2017).

Teachers and Stressful Workload

Teachers have referred to their working routines as toxic (Tapper, 2018).

Support and self-affirmation can help people in a high-demand job such as

teaching adapts to stress easier. This construct is defined as “decision latitude”.

Decision latitude is critical in professions wherein high job demands are part of

the routine, such as in teaching and education. Extra workload is given to

teachers, such as observations, marking, and substitutions. These additional tasks

contribute to the physical and mental stress that teacher’s experience. When put

together, these tasks add about seven hours to the average time a teacher works in

a day.

Teachers have reported experiencing numerous symptoms of depression,

including shame, confusion and weakness (Finley, Teaching with Depression,

2018). Educators have also experienced difficulty in continuing their work while

experiencing these symptoms. Teachers have felt that there is no time to deal with
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 21
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

these symptoms, and are forced to dismiss their mental health concerns in favor of

continuing their responsibilities as educators (Keating, 2017).

A study was conducted among Italian-state schoolteachers employing the

Karasek Job Content Questionnaire, the Self-Rating Anxiety Scale (SAS) and the

Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) (2014). The results

showed that about half of the respondents scored more than the threshold for

depression and ~1 in 10 for anxiety and depression on self-rating questionnaires.

Factors such as high job demand and low social support was then concluded to be

linked to inadequate mental health.

A separate study focusing on Behavioral Dysphonia and depression in

elementary teachers was conducted in 2014. Among all respondents, the

pervasiveness of dysphonia was 33.9%. 55% conveyed that they went on leave

due to problems relating to stress. These affected voice and overall performance

(da Rocha, Behlau, & de Mattos Souza, 2014).

Cases of Depression and Suicide among Teachers

Underdiagnosis of clinical depression in teachers is a cause of concern

(Soria-Saucedo, Lopez-Ridaura, Lajous, & Wirtz, 2018). The unhealthy behavior

and toxic environment prevalent in the teaching workplace is associated with

severe depression and may result in self-harm and suicide. In the study by Soria-

Saucedo et al., a number of 7, 026 teachers met the severe depression category

(16%).
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 22
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

There have been cases of suicide among teachers in the Philippines during

the past year (De La Cruz & Mocon-Ciriaco, 2018). This has become a cause of

alarm in the country, and the Teachers Dignity Coalition (TDC) and Camarines

Sur Rep. Luis Raymund F. Villafuerte have called on the government to act on the

spate of suicide involving teachers and children. TDC National Chairman

Benjamin Basas claims that the DepEd’s usage of a new performance rating

system known as the “Learner Information System,” or LIS, has added pressure to

teachers and educators. On the contrary, the Department of Education has claimed

that the LIS helps teachers save time spent on the system and allows them to put

their attention towards teaching. Despite this, the TDC continues to attest that the

system would lead to heavy workloads.

As a result, the Department of Education has been urged to lessen teaching

workloads (Esguerra, 2018). The TDC group also demands for a comprehensive

health care program for teachers as indicated by the Magna Carta for Teachers,

which was ratified in 1966. This health program should compensate for mental

wellness as well.

Erik Erikson’s Stages of Psychosocial Development

Erikson's Stages of Psychosocial Development is a wide-ranging

psychoanalytic theory that recognizes a succession of eight stages that a

developing person undergoes from infancy to late adulthood. This theory is often
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 23
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

deemed similar to Freud’s Psychosexual Stage, but Erikson’s focus on a person’s

ego throughout their lifespan makes it distinct from the former (Cherry, 2014).

According to the theory, psychosocial challenges or turning points would

occur at each stage which individuals are especially vulnerable, but also have

great potential for development. Once a person resolves a psychosocial challenge

or crisis consisting of opposing psychological and sociocultural needs, a healthy

personality and basic virtues will be acquired, which the ego can subsequently use

to resolve other crises that may follow. On the other hand, failure to resolve a

crisis and complete a stage might result in a more unhealthy personality and lower

state of well-being (Bornstein, 2018).

Ego identity, ego strength, and conflict are the three essential components

of this theory.

Stage Age Virtue

Trust versus Mistrust 0–2 Hope

Autonomy versus Shame and Doubt 2–4 Will

Initiative versus Guilt 4–5 Purpose

Industry versus Inferiority 5 – 12 Competence

Identity versus Role Confusion 13 – 19 Fidelity

Intimacy versus Isolation 20 – 39 Love

Generativity versus Stagnation 40 – 59 Care

Integrity versus Despair 60+ Wisdom


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 24
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

A 2016 study published in the International Journal of Behavioral

Development focusing on adult crisis used a sample of British adults in early life

(20–39 years), midlife (40–59 years) and later-life (60+) (Robinson, Demetre, &

Litman, 2016). The same ranges were used in this study’s instrument as they are

representative of the teaching population in the Philippines.

Theory of Anomie

All nations create normal behavior patterns and belief systems as their

residents evolve. Anomie is referred to as a person’s self-reported loneliness or

powerlessness. Moreover, it is a state of mind that portrays one’s despair,

frustration, confusion, and isolation. As the educational system changes and

technological advancement makes itself prominent, teachers experience variance

in their anomie (Abrutyn, 2019).

A theoretical construct on anomie was presented that defines it as a

psychosocial phenomenon utilizing at unit-level of social reality that are effects of

chronic or acute disturbances that produce present or unrealistic pressures.

Furthermore, the disruptions of anomie are not only expected by imagined or real

isolation from society (Zhao & Cao, 2010). Comprehensible social disconnection

and physical dislocation from others are at play. Anomie shows factors of pain of

losing important social relationships that are possible which pushes one to do self-

harm, become anti-social or pro-social in order to run away from this kind of pain.

It is also an effect of the rapid social changes happening all over the world and the
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 25
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

coping strategies of an individual for these changes (Teymoori, Jetten, & Wohl,

2016).

Psychiatric Hegemony

Psychiatry, during its beginnings, was developed with an aim to cast

society’s ills as mental health problems of an individual. A number of books have

sought to discuss psychiatry’s crimes against humanity; nevertheless, only some

analyze psychiatry in tandem with capitalism. In Marxist philosophy, Hegemony

is the process by which the views and interests reflected by the ruling class come

to be accepted as an absolute truth by the oppressed despite being directly

affected by those in power.

Cohen (2016) stresses how psychiatry serves the capitalist system through

a Marxist analysis. According to him, psychiatry supports capitalism by taking

social problems and diagnosing these as cognitive or biological disorders, which

in turn fuels how the capitalist class avoid responsibility for these problems. This

phenomenon incites dismissing disorders as natural occurrences. As such, the

growing epidemic of mental illnesses only further frames social issues as medical

in causation.

In Psychiatric Hegemony: A Marxist Theory of Mental Illness, Cohen

rebukes the claim that the prime factors of the increase in mental illnesses are

solely loss of social support and inequality. He further explains that Psychiatric

Hegemony is manifested when the medicalization of social problems and


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 26
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

suffering in society results to people self-diagnosing themselves and others. If

Psychiatric Hegemony is adapted, society is thought to be associated with risks of

mental illness and should periodically self-evaluate for possible symptoms of

disorder (p.90).

Abnormal Psychology

Evaluating when a patient case is a psychiatric diagnosis is a tough duty.

The “Four D’s” consisting of Deviance, Dysfunction, Distress, and Danger is a

valuable tool when weighing described traits, symptoms, or conditions in order to

clarify the crux where these factors might signify a psychological disorder, such

as depression.

Image credit: Psychology for Beginners


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 27
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

The normal bell curve or normal distribution is a statistical outlook of

normality that represents a bell-shaped curve. It illustrates the ABC’s of

frequency: Amount of time, Behavior, and the Curve. Frequency is the amount of

time that behavior persists. The duration of these thoughts, feelings or behaviour

is also focused on. It also involves the amount of time that the behavior is

experienced (Curtis & Kelley, 2017).

Next is the frequency of the behavior as an indicator of abnormality. A

high frequency or low frequency of behavior is deemed abnormal or disordered. It

is that many actions are normally distributed in terms of frequency. Lastly, the

curve deals with how many people struggle with this issue.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 28
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

CHAPTER 3

METHODOLOGY

3.1 Research Design

This research employs a correlational research design in order to critically

compare the depression levels between Junior and Senior High School Public

Teachers in Dasmariñas City, Cavite. It makes use of both quantitative and

qualitative data because it is a quantitative correlational study fused with elements

of qualitative comparative study.

3.2 Population and Sampling

The study incorporates stratified random sampling. This type of sampling

divides the population into subgroups called Strata. Separate random samples

from each stratum were obtained. The sample of the study is one hundred eight

(108) teachers handling either Junior or Senior High School from three (3) Public

Schools located in Dasmariñas City, Cavite.

3.3 Respondents of the Study

There are five (5) Public Schools in Dasmariñas City, Cavite that have

Junior High School and Senior High School departments. The respondents of the

study are fifty-seven (57) junior high school teachers and fifty-one (51) senior
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 29
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

high school teachers working in three (3) of these schools. Overall, there are one

hundred eight (108) respondents.

3.4 Research Instrument

The questionnaire developed by the researchers incorporates a few

concepts from a health and well-being assessment program, WorkSafe™. The

program was created by the local government of Tasmania, Australia. Items from

the Swedish Demand Control Support Questionnaire (SDCSQ) were also adapted.

However, majority of the questions in the final instrument were retooled to be in

line with the factors illustrated in the conceptual framework of this paper. Several

questions were also added to render more streamlined results.

The instrument is composed of two parts that utilize four-point Likert

Scale (by agreement and frequency). The first part consists of questions pertaining

to personal and professional concerns, which are both essential in this study’s

conceptual framework. These aspects were gauged because inadequate mental

health in teachers is reportedly linked to poor support systems and job-related

problems (Borrelli et al., 2014).

The second portion of the questionnaire adapted elements from the Patient

Health Questionnaire–9 which focused on questions pertaining to the mental

health of teachers. These are queries that expand emphasis on the mental and

emotional well-being of the teachers. All questionnaires contained a control

number in order to track the location or school where it was used. These numbers
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 30
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

also allowed the data to be easily double-checked once recorded in a spreadsheet.

Questions were encoded in both English and Filipino for the respondents’

convenience.

3.5 Validity and Reliability of Instruments

Before administering the questionnaires, the instrument was subjected to a

validity test. This was first done by a group of guidance counselors. These

consultants checked the appropriateness of the questions and ensured that none

were triggering of any depressive episodes.

Grammar in both English and Filipino was checked by licensed professors

from De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute and St. Edward

Integrated School.

This was further crystallized upon consultation with a psychometrician.

This resulted in an updated version of the instrument which allowed the study to

be more direct and operative.

As a follow-up, a pilot test was conducted in two schools — Dasmariñas

West National High School and De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences

Institute. Fifteen (15) participants from each school answered the test. Cronbach’s

alpha, a psychometric test, was used to compare the expected correlation of the

two parts of the questionnaire.

Upon completion of the pilot testing and further discussion with research

consultants, the instruments were deemed ready for distribution.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 31
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

3.6 Ethical Considerations

Ethical considerations that were taken into account include the possibility

of questions being too invasive and triggering. Any questions that met these

criteria were modified or omitted altogether. Consultants (guidance counselors,

psychometrician) were instrumental to this process. Furthermore, private

demographic information that was unnecessary to the results was marked as

“optional”.

Other considerations revolved around the privacy of the participants of the

study. Any personal data collected were only used for academic and research

purposes, and were managed with strict confidentiality. A letter of consent was

signed by the respondents in order to verify that the researchers were given full

permission to collect the data. This informed consent form was attached to the

instrument upon instrument distribution.

3.7 Data Gathering Procedure

The researchers administered the instrument to Junior High School and

Senior High School Teachers from three (3) Public Schools located in Dasmariñas

City, Cavite. This was done over the course of April to May 2019. Before

proceeding, letters of correspondence were addressed to the principals and

department heads of each school.

To give ample amount of time for the respondents to accomplish

instrument, the researchers collected the materials upon being notified by the
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 32
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

department secretaries. This also allowed the respondents to take the test at their

most convenient time.

3.8 Analysis of Data

Analysis of the data was accomplished with the validation of a statistician.

Item analysis was done for each group of items. T-test of independent mean was

later used to compare the depression levels of the Junior High School and Senior

High School teachers. Frequency distribution tables were created for each

department, taking into account the mean, standard deviation, and the sample of

the population. Lastly, interpretation and conclusion for the result of t were made.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 33
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

CHAPTER 4

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

The researchers have collected all the data and used the necessary tools

needed to come up with the results. This chapter elaborates more on the findings

gathered on this study. It presents all the data accumulated from the research

instrument which contains questions about personal concerns, professional

concerns, and mental health of Junior High School and Senior High School

Teachers.

4.1 Demographic Profile of the Respondents

4.1.1 Age Range of Respondents

Table 1. Age Range of Respondents

Age Range Tally Percentage


20 – 39 79 73.15%
40 – 59 27 25.23%
60 and above 2 1.90%

AGE RANGE OF
RESPONDENTS
20 - 39 40 - 59 60 and above
2%

25%
73%

Figure 2. Age Range of Respondents


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 34
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

For the ages of the respondents, the students referred to Erik Erikson’s

stages of psychosocial development. Erikson’s concept is highly suitable for this

particular demographic concern as the teaching profession requires the application

of physical and mental skills acquired throughout one’s lifespan. The ages are

classified into three: 20 – 39 (early adulthood), 40 – 59 (middle adulthood), and

60 above (late adulthood).

73.15% of the respondents (77 out of 108) belong to the 20 – 39 range.

25.23% (27 out of 108) fall under 40 – 59, with only 2% (2 out of 108) part of the

60 above category.

4.1.2 Sex of Respondents

Table 2. Sex of Respondents

Sex Tally Percentage


Male 31 28.70%
Female 77 71.30%

SEX OF RESPONDENTS
Male Female

29%
71%

Figure 3. Sex of Respondents


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 35
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

For the sex, most of the respondents were mostly female. Women made up

71.30% of the respondents, with 77 out of 108 respondents. Males accounted for

28.70% (31 out of 108).

4.1.3 Civil Status of the Respondents

Table 3. Civil Status of Respondents

Civil Status Tally Percentage


Single 39 36.11%
Married 66 61.11%
Divorced/Annulled 0 0%
Separated 1 0.93%
Widowed 2 1.85%

CIVIL STATUS OF
RESPONDENTS
Single Married
Divorced / Annulled Separated
Widowed
2%
0% 1%
36%

61%
Figure 4. Civil Status of Respondents

61.11% (66 out of 108) of the respondents are married, while 36.11% (39

out of 108) are single. 1.85% accounted for those widowed (2 out of 108), while

less than 1% were separated from their partners (1 out of 108, 0.93%). None of

the respondents were divorced or annulled.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 36
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

4.1.4 Teaching Load of the Respondents

Table 4. Teaching Load of Respondents (per week)

Teaching Load (per week) Tally Percentage


Less than 30 hours 56 51.85%
More than 30 hours 52 48.15%

TEACHING LOAD OF
RESPONDENTS
(PER WEEK)
Less than 30 Hours More than 30 Hours

48%
52%

Figure 5. Teaching Load of Respondents

The teaching load of the respondents was included in their demographic

profiles as the Cavite chapter of the Department of Education implemented a

standard of 30 hours weekly teaching load for all public school teachers

(Department of Education - Region IV-A, 2018). Since the teaching load is

standardized at thirty (30) hours, data obtained from this field is purely nominal.

51.85% (56 out of 108) of the respondents are teachers who have a load of less

than 30 hours per week. The remaining 52 respondents (48.15%) had more than

30 hours per week.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 37
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

4.2 Item Analysis of Personal and Professional Concerns

4.2.1 Personal Concerns

The first section of the instrument talks about personal and professional

factors that may contribute to the mental well-being of an individual. The first

five (5) questions encompass the “big 3 motives” (need for achievement, power,

and intimacy/affection), attachment styles and status of psychosocial stage

resolution.

A 4-point Likert scale was used (although the inclusion of 0 makes the

system function similarly to a 5-point scale). The legend is as follows:

4 – Always 3 – Often 2 – Sometimes 1 – Seldom 0 – Never

4.2.1.1 Communication with Family Members and Friends

Table 5.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 1
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
communicate with
44 12 0 1 0
family members or
friends?
Percentage 77.19% 21.05% 0% 1.75% 0%

Table 5.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 1
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
communicate with
34 14 2 1 0
family members or
friends?
Percentage 66.67% 27.45% 3.92% 1.96% 0%
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 38
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 1 (JHS) NO. 1 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)
2% 0%
0% 2% 0% 4%

21%
27%

77% 67%

Figure 6.1 Responses to Question No. 1 (JHS) Figure 6.2 Responses to Question No. 1 (SHS)

For this question, majority (77.19%, 44 out of 57) of the Junior High

School-teaching respondents stated that they always communicate with their

family members and friends. This sentiment is echoed with those respondents

belonging to the Senior High School department (66.67%, 33 out of 51). Based on

this data, both sets of respondents frequently talk to their family and friends.

Second to “always” for the Junior High School group is “often” at 21.05%

(12 out of 57), and then “seldom” (1.75%, 1 out of 57). No respondents answered

“sometimes” or “never”.

As for the Senior High School teachers, trailing “always” is “often”

(27.45%, 14 out of 51), then “sometimes” (3.92%, 2 out of 51), and “seldom”

(1.96%, 1). No respondents answered “never”.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 39
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

4.2.1.2 Misunderstandings with Family Members

Table 6.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 2
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
have
misunderstandings 0 5 23 27 2
between family
members?
Percentage 0% 8.77% 40.35% 47.37% 3.51%

Table 6.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 2
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
have
misunderstandings 1 8 21 20 1
between family
members?
Percentage 1.96% 15.69% 41.18% 39.22% 1.96%

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 2 (JHS) NO. 2 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)
4% 0% 2% 2%

9%
16%

39%
47% 40%
41%

Figure 7.1 Responses to Question No. 2 (JHS) Figure 7.2 Responses to Question No. 2 (SHS)
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 40
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

This question inquires on the frequency of misunderstandings with family

members. Majority of the Junior High School teachers seldom experience

misunderstandings with their family members, with 47.37% (27 out of 57). On the

other hand, the leading response for Senior High School teachers was

“sometimes”, with 41.18% (21 out of 51).

For the Junior High School teachers, the second leading response was

“sometimes” at 40.35% (23 out of 57), followed by “often” (8.77%, 5 out of 57),

and then “never” (3.51%, 2 out of 57). No respondents answered “always”.

Behind “sometimes” for the Senior High School group is “seldom” at

39.22% (20 out of 51). Next is “often” at 15.69%, with 8 out of 51 responses.

Lastly, both “always” and “never” have 1.96% (1 out of 51 responses).

These results imply that the misunderstandings of the Junior High and

Senior High Public School Teachers with their families do not fall under

extremes. These experiences usually range from sometimes-seldom in terms of

frequency.

4.2.1.3 Misunderstandings with Friends and Significant Others

Table 7.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 3
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
have problems
related to
1 7 12 32 5
relationships
(platonic or
romantic)?
Percentage 1.75% 12.28% 21.05% 56.14% 8.77%
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 41
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Table 7.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 3
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
have problems
related to
0 9 18 21 3
relationships
(platonic or
romantic)?
Percentage 0% 17.65% 35.29% 41.18% 5.88%

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 3 (JHS) NO. 3 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)
9% 2% 12% 6% 0%

18%

21% 41%
56% 35%

Figure 8.1 Responses to Question No. 3 (JHS) Figure 8.2 Responses to Question No. 3 (SHS)

The third question probes on the frequency of problems relating to friends

and significant others (spouses, boyfriends, girlfriends). Majority of the Junior

High School teachers seldom experience problems with their platonic and

romantic partners, with 56.14 % (32 out of 57). Similarly, the same case was

made for Senior High School teachers. The leading answer was “seldom”, with

41.18% (21 out of 51).


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 42
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

21.05% (12 out of 57) of the Junior High School-teaching respondents

“sometimes” have problems with their friends and significant others. 12.28% (7

out of 57) experience these “often”, 8.77% (5 out of 57) “never” experience these

and 1.75% (1 out of 57) answered “always”.

Similarly, the second leading response for Senior High School teachers

was “sometimes” at 35.29% (18 out of 51), followed by “often” (17.65%, 9 out of

51), then “never” (5.88%, 3 out of 51). No respondents answered “always”.

Parallel to that of number 2, these results imply that the problems of the

Junior High and Senior High public school teachers with their families do not fall

under extremes. The frequency of these occurrences can generally be

characterized as “sometimes”.

4.2.1.4 Problems Relating to Finances

Table 8.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 4
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
have problems 11 7 33 5 1
regarding finances?
Percentage 19.30% 12.28% 57.89% 8.77% 1.75%

Table 8.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 4
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
have problems 6 13 18 14 0
regarding finances?
Percentage 11.76% 25.49% 35.29% 27.45% 0
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 43
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 4 (JHS) NO. 4 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)

9% 2% 0%
12%

19%
27%
12% 26%
58%
35%

Figure 9.1 Responses to Question No. 4 (JHS) Figure 9.2 Responses to Question No. 4 (SHS)
This question places emphasis on problems relating to finances. For both

sets of respondents, the leading answer was “sometimes”. This accounts for

57.89% (33 out of 57) of the Junior High School teachers and 35.29% (18 out of

51) of the Senior High School teachers.

57.89% (33 out of 57) of the Junior High School-teaching respondents

“sometimes” experience financial problems. 19.30% (11 out of 57) experience

these “always”, and 12.28% (7 out of 57) “often” experience these. In addition,

8.77% (5 out of 57) answered “seldom” while 1.75% (1 out of 57) answered

“always”.

Similarly, the second leading response for Senior High School teachers

was “seldom” (27.45%, 14 out of 51), followed by “often” at 25.49% (13 out of

51), then “always” (11.76%, 6 out of 51). No respondents answered “never”.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 44
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

These results implicate that most Junior High and Senior High teachers

sometimes experience financial problems. Disparities in finances and salary have

been cited to be one of the reasons for teachers’ dissatisfaction (Kolbe & Strunk,

2012).

4.2.1.5 Entertainment Habits

Table 9.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 5
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
pursue means of
entertainment
(reading a book, 28 16 10 3 0
watching television,
going to the movies,
listening to music)?
Percentage 49.12% 28.07% 17.54% 5.26% 0%

Table 9.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 5
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
How often do you
pursue means of
entertainment
(reading a book, 28 17 6 0 0
watching television,
going to the movies,
listening to music)?
Percentage 54.9% 33.33% 11.76% 0% 0%
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 45
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 5 (JHS) NO. 5 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)
5% 0% 0% 0%

12%
18%
49%
33% 55%
28%

Figure 10.1 Responses to Question No. 5 (JHS) Figure 10.2 Responses to Question No. 5 (SHS)

The top response for both sets of respondents was “always”. 49.12% (28

out of 57) and 54.9% (28 out of 51) of Junior High School-teaching and Senior

High School-teaching respondents identified with this answer, respectively.

Tailing “always” is “often” (28.07% for Junior High Teachers, 33.33% for

Senior High Teachers), then “sometimes” (17.54% for Junior High School,

11.76% for Senior High School) and “seldom” (5.26% for Junior High Teachers,

0% for Senior High Teachers). None of the respondents answered “never”.

These responses indicate that entertainment is an essential part of a public

school teacher’s daily routine and leisure time. Studies show that leisure time

enhances a teacher’s passion for work and teaching (Caudroit, Boiché, Stephan,

Le Scanff, & Trouilloud, 2011).


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 46
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

4.2.2 Professional Concerns

Questions 6-10 of part 1 of the instrument focus on factors relating to the

workplace and job of the teachers (relationships with colleagues, effort, deadlines,

and supervisors). These are factors that may directly influence the stress that a

teacher experiences, contributing to the hastening of depression.

The same 4-point Likert scale was used (although the inclusion of 0 makes

the system function similarly to a 5-point scale). The legend is as follows:

4 – Always 3 – Often 2 – Sometimes 1 – Seldom 0 – Never

4.2.2.1 Deadlines and Time Allocation

Table 10.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 6
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
You have sufficient
time to work on 30 18 7 2 0
tasks.
Percentage 52.63% 31.58% 12.28% 3.51% 0%

Table 10.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 6
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
You have sufficient
time to work on 23 24 4 0 0
tasks.
Percentage 45.10% 47.06% 7.84% 0% 0%
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 47
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 6 (JHS) NO. 6 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)
3% 0% 8% 0% 0%
12%

45%
32% 53% 47%

Figure 11.1 Responses to Question No. 6 (JHS) Figure 11.2 Responses to Question No. 6 (SHS)

As for this question, 52.63% (30 out of 57) of the Junior High School-

teaching respondents agreed to “always” having sufficient time to work on tasks.

In contrast, majority (47.06%, 24 out of 51) of the participants belonging to the

Senior High School department stated to only “often” having sufficient time to

work on tasks.

The second leading response for the Junior High School group is “often”

at 31.58% (18 out of 57); followed by “sometimes” at 12.28% (7 out of 57); and

then “seldom” (3.51%, 2out of 57). None of the respondents answered “never”.

As for the Senior High School group, succeeding “often” is “always”

(45.10%, 23 out of 51), followed by “sometimes” at (7.84%, 4 out of 51). None of

the respondents answered with “seldom” or “never”.

This category revolves around time management which has been linked to

job stress (Zafarullah, & Pertti, 2017). In their study, the researchers explained
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 48
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

how teachers may increase job satisfaction and motivation through improving

their time management skills.

4.2.2.2 Exertion of Effort

Table 11.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 7
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
Your job requires
29 16 8 4 0
too much effort.
Percentage 50.88% 28.07% 14.04% 7.02% 0%

Table 11.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 7
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
Your job requires
28 12 10 0 1
too much effort.
Percentage 54.90% 23.53% 19.61% 0% 1.96%

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 7 (JHS) NO. 7 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)
7% 0% 0% 2%

14% 20%

51% 55%
28% 23%

Figure 12.1 Responses to Question No. 7 (JHS) Figure 12.2 Responses to Question No. 7 (SHS)
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 49
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Question 7 is primarily concerned with inquiring about how much energy

and effort the respondents expend in correlation with their workload. The leading

response for both sets of respondents is “always”, which garnered 50.88% (29 out

of 57) and 54.9% (28 out of 51) of the answers from the Junior High School

teachers and Senior High School teachers respectively.

Second to “always” is “often” (28.07% for Junior High teachers, 23.53%

for Senior High teachers), followed by “sometimes” (14.04% for Junior High

School, 19.61% for Senior High School). 7.02% (4 out of 57) of the Junior High

teachers responded with “seldom” which 0% of the Senior High teachers

answered with. None of the Junior High teachers answered “never” which

contrasts how only 1.96% (1 out of 51) of the Senior High teachers did.

Studies suggest that if a balance in the levels of effort exists in the work

environment, less burnout syndrome disorders and depression will be found

(Inocente, 2005). These responses indicate the importance of establishing a

balance in the efforts exerted by the respondents to enhance their passion for work

and avoid symptoms leading to burnout and depression.

4.2.2.3 Working Atmosphere

Table 12.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 8
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
There is a pleasant
atmosphere at your 23 24 7 3 0
place of work.
Percentage 40.35% 42.11% 12.28% 5.26% 0%
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 50
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Table 12.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 8
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
There is a pleasant
atmosphere at your 21 21 7 2 0
place of work.
Percentage 41.18% 41.18% 13.73% 3.92% 0%

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 8 (JHS) NO. 8 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)
5% 0% 4% 0%
12%
14%
41% 41%

42% 41%

Figure 13.1 Responses to Question No. 8 (JHS) Figure 13.2 Responses to Question No. 8 (SHS)

This question is concerned with the teachers’ perception and experience of

the atmosphere at their workplace. Majority of the Junior High School teachers

answered “often”, with 42.11% (24 out of 57). On the other hand, the leading

answers for the Senior High School teachers were both “always” and “often”,

with 41.18% (21 out of 51) equally.

40.35% (23 out of 57) of the Junior High School-teaching respondents

“always” experience a pleasant atmosphere in their workplace. 12.28% (7 out of


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 51
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

57) experience these “always”, and 5.26% (3 out of 57) “often” experience these.

None of the respondents in this group answered “never”.

The second leading response for Senior High School teachers was

“sometimes” (13.73%, 7 out of 51), followed by “seldom” at 3.92% (2 out of 51).

Similar to the Junior High School-teaching group, none of the respondents from

this set answered with “never”.

4.2.2.4 Relationship with Supervisors

Table 13.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 9
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
You get along well
with your 36 18 1 1 1
supervisors.
Percentage 63.16% 31.58% 1.75% 1.75% 1.75%

Table 13.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 9
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
You get along well
with your 32 15 4 0 0
supervisors.
Percentage 62.75% 29.41% 7.84% 0% 0%
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 52
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 9 (JHS) NO. 9 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)

2% 2% 2% 8% 0% 0%

31% 29%
63% 63%

Figure 14.1 Responses to Question No. 9 (JHS) Figure 14.2 Responses to Question No. 9 (SHS)

For both sets of respondents, the leading answer was “always”. This

response garnered 63.16% (36 out of 57) of the answers from the Junior High

School teachers and 62.75% (32 out of 51) from that of the Senior High School

teachers.

For this question, 31.58% (18 out of 57) of the Junior High School-

teaching respondents stated that they often get along with their supervisors. This

set of respondents also answered with “sometimes”, “seldom”, and “never” of

equal distribution, with 1.75% (1 out of 57 each).

Second to “always” for Senior High School-teaching group is “often” at

29.41% (15 out of 57), and then “sometimes” (7.84%, 4 out of 57). None of the

respondents from this group answered “seldom” or “never”.

Based on this data, it can be inferred that both sets of respondents

frequently get along with their supervisors. As for the Senior High School
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 53
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

teachers, trailing “always” is “often” (27.45%, 14 out of 51), then “sometimes”

(3.92%, 2 out of 51), and “seldom” (1.96%, 1). No respondents answered “never”.

4.2.2.4 Relationship with Co-workers

Table 14.1 Responses from JHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 10
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
You get along well
with your co- 37 18 2 0 0
workers.
Percentage 64.91% 31.58% 3.51% 0% 0%

Table 14.2 Responses from SHS Participants

4 3 2 1 0
Question No. 10
(Always) (Often) (Sometimes) (Seldom) (Never)
You get along well
with your co- 31 17 3 0 0
workers.
Percentage 60.78% 33.33% 5.88% 0% 0%

RESPONSES RESPONSES
TO QUESTION TO QUESTION
NO. 10 (JHS) NO. 10 (SHS)
4 (Always) 3 (Often) 4 (Always) 3 (Often)
2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom) 2 (Sometimes) 1 (Seldom)
0 (Never) 0 (Never)
3% 0% 0% 6% 0%0%

32% 33%
65% 61%

Figure 15.1 Responses to Question No. 10 (JHS) Figure 15.2 Responses to Question No. 10 (SHS)
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 54
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

For this question, majority (64.91%, 37 out of 57) of the Junior High

School teachers answered “always”. This is mirrored by the data gathered from

the Senior High School-teaching group whose response was also “always”

(60.78%, 31 out of 51).

Second to “always” for both the Junior High School and Senior High

School group is “often” (31.58% for Junior High teachers, 33.33% for Senior

High teachers), and then “sometimes” (3.51% for Junior High Teachers, 5.88%

for Senior High teachers). None of the respondents from both sets answered with

“seldom” or “never”.

4.3 Depression Level Based on Mental Health Assessment

The second section of the instrument focuses on determining the

depression level of the participants: mild, moderate severe, profound. It is based

on the number, type, and severity of symptoms present. Frequency distribution

tables were used to further analyze the data. Furthermore, to determine the mean

and standard deviation of each level, this will be utilized in verifying the

hypothesis.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 55
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Table 15.1 Frequency Distribution of Level of Depression of Junior High School Teachers

f x cf x-µ (x-µ)2 f (x-µ)2 f(x)


Mild 1-10 28 5.5 28 -7.19 51.70 1447.6 154
Moderate 11-20 19 15.5 47 2.81 7.90 150.1 294.5
Severe 21-30 8 25.5 55 12.81 164.10 1312.8 204
Profound 31-40 2 35.5 57 22.81 520.30 1040.6 71
Total 3951.1 723.5

Based from the frequency distribution table, Junior High School teachers

are mostly “mild” in terms of depression level with 28 in total. Following it would

be moderate level with 19 in total, then severe level with 8 in total. Lastly, with 2

in total is profound level.

The leading result above implies that exposure to personal stressors such

as relationships and finances puts Junior High School teachers at risk for “mild”

depression. Workplace factors (supervisors, co-workers, effort) also contribute to

the susceptibility of the teachers to this level of depression.

Table 15.2 Frequency Distribution of Level of Depression of Senior High School Teachers

f x cf x-µ (x-µ)2 f (x-µ)2 f(x)


Mild 1-10 17 5.5 17 -7.72 59.60 1013.2 93.5
Moderate 11-20 22 15.5 39 2.28 5.20 114.4 341
Severe 21-30 8 25.5 47 12.28 150.80 1206.4 204
Profound 31-40 1 35.5 48 22.28 496.40 496.4 35.5
Total 2830.4 674

However, Senior High School teachers are mostly “moderate” in terms of

depression level with 22 in total based from the frequency distribution table.

Behind it is “mild” level with 17 in total, then severe level with 8 in total. Lastly,

with 1 in total is “profound” level.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 56
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

The leading result above implies that the exposure to personal stressors

such as relationships and finances put Senior High School teachers at risk for

“moderate” depression. Workplace factors (supervisors, co-workers, effort) also

contribute to the susceptibility of the teachers to this level of depression.

4.4 Comparison between Depression Levels of the Departments

The students finally identified that there is no difference between the

levels of depression among Junior High School and Senior High School Teachers

in Public Schools of Dasmariñas City, Cavite. This has been provided with

statistical evidence using hypothesis testing done through T-testing of the

independent means. The depression levels of the two departments, which are the

study’s test variables, got mean values that are under the moderate level. Those

rates were then substituted to the formula for Independent Samples. The test

statistic t result of -0.35 was subjected to a decision rule. As a result, the null

hypothesis was accepted.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 57
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

CHAPTER 5

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This chapter contains the summary of findings, conclusion, and

recommendations of the study that the researchers have conducted.

5.1 Summary of Findings

Based from the data that was gathered, the researchers came up with the

findings that there was no difference between the average level of depression

among Junior High School teachers to the average level of depression among

Senior High School teachers. Upon getting the mean of Junior High School

teachers and Senior High School teachers, both fell on the “moderate” level.

The Null Hypothesis of the study which states that there is no difference

between the average level of depression of Junior High School teachers and

Senior High School teachers was accepted. Both departments got a mean value

indicating that majority of the respondents are susceptible to depression level of

moderate degree.

The level of significance for two-tailed test was taken as well as the

degree of freedom. The decision rule states of the study states that if the value is

more than or equal to 1.980, the Null Hypothesis is to be rejected and if it is less

than or equal to 1.980, the null hypothesis is to be accepted. The values were then

substituted to a formula and resulted with -0.35 which makes the Null Hypothesis

accepted.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 58
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

5.2 Conclusion

The following conclusions can be drawn from the results of the study:

1) For the item analysis pertaining to personal and professional concerns:

a. For the Personal Concerns:

i. In terms of communication with family members and

friends, majority of the respondents from both departments

stated that they always communicate with their family

members and friends.

ii. In terms of misunderstandings with family members, most

of the Junior High School teachers seldom experience it,

while the Senior High School teachers sometimes do.

iii. In terms of misunderstandings with friends and significant

others, majority of the respondents from both departments

seldom experience it.

iv. In terms of problems relating to finances, both sets of

respondents’ leading answer was “sometimes”.

v. In terms of entertainment habits, most responses for both

sets of respondents were “always”, which means

respondents always pursue different means of

entertainment.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 59
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

b. For the Professional Concerns:

i. In terms of deadlines and time allocation, Junior High

School-teaching respondents responded that they always

have sufficient time to work on tasks, while in contrast,

majority of the participants belonging to the Senior High

School department said they only often having sufficient

time to work on tasks.

ii. In terms of exertion of effort, the leading response for both

sets of respondents is “always” which means that their job

always requires too much effort.

iii. In terms of working atmosphere, majority of the Junior

High School teachers answered there is often a pleasant

atmosphere at their place of work, while the leading

answers for the Senior High School teachers were both

“always” and “often”.

iv. In terms of relationship with supervisors, most of the

respondents from both departments stated that they always

get along well with their supervisors.

v. In terms of relationship with co-workers, majority of the

respondents from both departments answered that they

always get along well with their co-workers.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 60
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

2) By getting the mean of Junior High School teachers and Senior High School

teachers, both fell on the “moderate” level. This implicates that Public

School Teachers in the City of Dasmariñas, Cavite are susceptible to

depression of moderate degree.

3) Null hypothesis was accepted at -0.35. This states that there is no significant

statistical difference between the average level of depression among Junior

High School teachers and the average level of depression among Senior

High School teachers.

5.3 Recommendations

In line with the results and findings of this research, the following are

recommended in order to give the mental health of Philippine Schools (public

school) Teachers further importance:

• Depression screenings that include adequate systems in place to

ensure accurate diagnosis, effective treatment, and appropriate follow-

up consultations.

• Mental health talks and conferences aiming to spread awareness on

mental health, depression, and workplace stress.

• Re-evaluation of workplace systems in academic institutions, in order

to assess and address its detriments to the mental health of teachers.

This may include removal of workplace factors that make public

school teachers susceptible to depression, such as overexertion.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 61
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

• A follow-up study concerning coping strategies for public school

teachers in order to focus on formulating programs and interventions.

o Partnerships with outside research entities may also aid

in research papers with this specific endeavor.

• A similar study with a larger sample size, in order to identify other

possible factors that make teachers susceptible to depression and other

mental health disorders.

o Factors that were not taken into account in this research

(demographics) may also be explored in order to

investigate their relationship to the teachers’ depression

levels.

• All in all, further studies concerning the topic would raise awareness

on mental health in a Philippine context. In the wider context of

research, these efforts will serve as supporting literature for more

investigations on the matter.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 62
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

CITED REFERENCES

Abrutyn, S. (2019). Toward a General Theory of Anomie The Social Psychology

of Disintegration. European Journals of Sociology, 109-136.

Albert, P. (2015). Why is Depression More Prevalent in Women? Journal of

Psychiatry and Neuroscience, 219-221.

American Institute of Stress. (2018). What is stress? Retrieved from The

American Institute of Stress: https://www.stress.org/what-is-stress/

Andrea, H., Bültmann, U., van Amelsvoort, L. G., & Kant, Y. (2009). The

Incidence Of Anxiety And Depression Among. Depression and Anxiety,

1040-1048.

Blaivas, A. J., & Nelson, G. A. (2018). Managing Work-Related Stress. Retrieved

from University of Rochester Medical Center:

https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/encyclopedia/content.aspx?contenttypeid

=1&contentid=2882

Bonde, J. (2008). Psychosocial Factors at Work and Risk of Depression: a

Systematic Review of the Epidemiological Evidence. Occupational and

Environmental Medicine, 438-445.

Bornstein, M. (2018). The SAGE Encyclopedia of Lifespan Human Development.

Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, Inc.

Borrelli, I., Benevene, P., Fiorilli, C., D'Amelio, F., & Pozzi, G. (2014). Working

Conditions and Mental Health in Teachers:. Occupational Medicine, 530-

532.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 63
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Caudroit, J., Boiché, J., Stephan, Y., Le Scanff, C., & Trouilloud, D. (2011).

Predictors of Work/Family Interference and Leisure-time Physical Sctivity

Among Teachers: The Role of Passion Towards Work. European Journal

of Work and Organizational Psychology , 326-344 .

Cherry, K. (2014, June 19). Erikson’s Eight Stages of Psychosocial Development.

Retrieved from Explore Psychology:

https://www.explorepsychology.com/psychosocial-development/

Cohen, B. M. (2016). Psychiatric Hegemony: A Marxist Theory of Mental Illness.

Springer.

Cujipers, P., Clignet, F., van Meijel, B., van Straten, A., Li, J., & Andersson, G.

(2011). Psychological Treatment of Depression in Inpatients: A

Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Clinical Psychological Review.

Curtis, D., & Kelley, L. (2017). Understanding Abnormality: “A Look at Crazy”.

Kendall Hunt Publishing.

da Rocha, L. M., Behlau, M., & de Mattos Souza, L. D. (2014). Behavioral

Dysphonia and Depression in Elementary. Journal of Voice.

De La Cruz, J. N., & Mocon-Ciriaco, C. (2018, August 26). Suicide of teachers,

Children Prompts Call for Govt Action. Retrieved from BusinessMirror:

https://businessmirror.com.ph/suicide-of-teachers-children-prompts-call-

for-govt-action/
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 64
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

de Vries, G., Koeter, M., Nabitz, U., Hees, H., & Schene, A. (2012). Return To

Work After Sick Leave Due to Depression; A Conceptual Analysis.

Journal of Affective Disorders, 1017-1026.

Department of Education - Region IV-A. (2018, September 20). DepEd Cavite.

Retrieved from https://depedcavite.com.ph/wp-

content/uploads/2018/09/RM-550-2018_.pdf

Dilekmen, M., & Erdem, B. (2013). Depression levels of the elementary school

teachers. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 793-806.

DiMauro, S. (2016). Study Finds Education Industry Has Average rate of

teachers with Depression. Retrieved from Education World:

educationworld.com/a_news/study-finds-education-industtry-has-average-

rate-of-teachers-with-depression-2074928826#

Doyle, G. C. (2018, December 12). Work Related Stress – 6 Common Causes.

Retrieved from EazySAFE: https://eazysafe.com/blog/stress-

management/work-related-stress-common-causes/

Esguerra, D. J. (2018, August 27). DepEd urged to lighten teacher workloads

following suicide reports. Retrieved from Inquirer News:

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1025288/deped-urged-to-lighten-teacher-

workloads-following-suicide-reports

European Agency for Safety and Health at Work. (2014). Calculating the Cost of

Work-Related Stress and Psychosocial Risks. Bilbao, Spain: European

Agency for Safety and Health at Work.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 65
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Fink, G. (2016). Stress: Concepts, Cognition, Emotion, and Behavior: Handbook

of Stress Series - Google Books. Academic Press.

Finley, T. (2018, August 17). Teaching with Depression. Retrieved from

Edutopia: https://www.edutopia.org/article/teaching-depression

Finley, T. (2018, August 17). Teaching With Depression | Edutopia. Retrieved

October 13, 2018, from https://www.edutopia.org/article/teaching-

depression

Gorsy, C., Panwar, N., & Kumar, S. (2015). Mental Health among Government

School Teachers. The International Journal of Indian Psychology.

Kamenov, K., Mellor-Marsá, B., Leal, I., Ayoso-Mateos, J., & Cabello, M.

(2014). Analysing Psychosocial Difficulties in Depression: A Content

Comparison between Systematic Literature Review and Patient

Perspective. BioMed Research International.

Keating, D. (2017, September 16). What It Really Means to Be a Teacher With

Depression | The Mighty. Retrieved from The Mighty:

https://themighty.com/2017/09/what-it-really-means-to-be-a-teacher-with-

depression/

Kinser, P. A., & Lyon, D. E. (2014). A conceptual framework of stress

vulnerability, depression, and health outcomes in women: potential uses in

research on complementary therapies for depression. Brain and Behavior,

665-674.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 66
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Kizilbash, A. H., Vanderploeg, R. D., & Curtiss, G. (2002). The effects of

depression and anxiety on memory performance. Archives of Clinical

Neurpsychology, 57-67.

Kolbe, T., & Strunk, K. O. (2012). Economic Incentives as a Strategy for

Responding to Teacher Staffing Problems: A Typology of Policies and

Practices. Education Administration Quarterly, 779-813.

Kuehner, C. (2016). Why is depression more common among women than among

men? The Lancet, 146-158.

Leedy, P. D., & Ormrod, J. E. (2013). Practical Research: Planning and Design,

10th Edition. Pearson.

Lerner, D., Adler, D. A., Rogers, W. H., Chang, H., Lapitsky, L., McLaughlin, T.,

& Reed, J. (2010). Work Performance of Employees With Depression:

The Impact of Work Stressors. American Journal of Health Promotion,

205-213.

Levine, D. (2017, May 2). Are Some Age Groups More Prone to Depression Than

Others? Retrieved from Patient Advice | US News:

https://health.usnews.com/health-care/patient-advice/articles/2017-05-

02/are-some-age-groups-more-prone-to-depression-than-others

Li, J., Riedel, N., Barrech, A., Herr, R., Aust, B., Mörtl, K., . . . Angerer, P.

(2017). Long-Term Effectiveness of a Stress Management Intervention at

Work: A 9-Year Follow-Up Study Based on a Randomized Wait-List

Controlled Trial in Male Managers. BioMed Research International.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 67
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Miller, E. J., & Chung, H. (2009). A Literature Review of Studies of Depression

and Treatment Outcomes Among U.S. College Students Since 1990.

Psychiatric Services, 1257-1260.

Mondal, P. (n.d.). Educational System: The Meaning, Aspects and Social

Functions of Education. Retrieved from Your Article Library:

http://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/education/educational-system-the-

meaning-aspects-and-social-functions-of-education/8582

National Alliance on Mental Illness. (2018). Mental Health Conditions. Retrieved

from NAMI: National Alliance on Mental Illness:

https://www.nami.org/Learn-More/Mental-Health-Conditions

National Institute of Mental Health. (2017, January). Men and Depression.

Retrieved from NIMH:

https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/men-and-

depression/index.shtml

National Institute of Mental Health. (2018, February). NIMH » Depression.

Retrieved from NIMH:

https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/topics/depression/index.shtml

Qahtani, A. A., & Qahtani, A. N. (2017). Prevention of Depression: A Review of

Literature. Journal of Depression and Anxiety.

Robinson, O. C., Demetre, J. D., & Litman, J. A. (2016). Adult life stage and

crisis as predictors of curiosity and authenticity: Testing inferences from


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 68
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Erikson’s lifespan theory. International Journal of Behavioral

Development, 426-431.

Schimelpfening, N. (2018, May 11). 7 Facts You Should Know About Depression.

Retrieved from Very Well Mind:

https://www.verywellmind.com/depression-facts-you-should-know-

1067617

Schoeman, R. (2018, April 25). 1 in 4 SA workers suffers from depression.

Retrieved from Health24:

https://www.health24.com/Medical/Depression/About-depression/1-in-4-

sa-workers-suffers-from-depression-20180425

Shelton, J. (2019, March 18). Depression Definition and DSM-5 Diagnostic

Criteria. Retrieved from IVAN GOLDBERG's PSYCOM.NET - Mental

Health Treatment Resource Since 1986:

https://www.psycom.net/depression-definition-dsm-5-diagnostic-criteria/

Simon, M., & White, J. (2016, February 4). Survey / Interview Validation Rubric

for an Expert Panel. Retrieved from Dissertation Recipes:

dissertationrecipes.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/Expert-Validation-

v3.pdf

Soria-Saucedo, R., Lopez-Ridaura, R., Lajous, M., & Wirtz, V. J. (2018). The

prevalence and correlates of severe depression in a cohort of Mexican.

Journal of Affective Disorders, 109-116.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 69
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Tapper, J. (2018, May 13). Burned out: Why are so many teachers quitting or off

sick with stress? Retrieved from The Guardian:

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2018/may/13/teacher-burnout-

shortages-recruitment-problems-budget-cuts

Terada, Y. (2018, July 13). Burnout Isn't Inevitable | Edutopia. Retrieved October

13, 2018, from https://www.edutopia.org/article/burnout-isnt-inevitable

Teymoori, A., Jetten, J., & Wohl, M. (2016). Revisiting the measurement of

Anomie. Public Library of Science.

Tolentino, J. C., & Schmidt, S. L. (2018). DSM-5 Criteria and Depression

Severity: Implications for Clinical Practice. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 450.

U.S. Department of Health & Human Services. (2017, August 29). What Is

Mental Health? Retrieved from MentalHealth.Gov:

https://www.mentalhealth.gov/basics/what-is-mental-health

U.S. National Library of Medicine. (2018). Stress and your health: MedlinePlus

Medical Encyclopedia. Retrieved from MedlinePlus Medical

Encyclopedia: https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/003211.htm

Vogt, W., Vogt, E. R., Gardner, D. C., & Haeffele, L. M. (2014). Selecting the

Right Analyses for Your Data: Quantitative, Qualitative, and Mixed

Methods. Guilford Publications.

World Health Organization. (2018). Stress at the workplace. Retrieved from

World Health Organization:

https://www.who.int/occupational_health/topics/stressatwp/en/
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 70
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Wulsin, L., Alterman, T., Bushnell, P. T., Li, J., & Shen, R. (2014). Prevalence

rates for depression by industry: a claims database analysis. Social

psychiatry and psychiatric epidemiology, 49 (11), 1805-1821.

Zhao, R., & Cao, L. (2010). Social Change and Anomie: A Cross-National Study.

The University of North Carolina Press.

Zimmerman, M., Morgan, T. A., & Stanton, K. (2018). The severity of psychiatric

disorders. World Psychiatry, 258-275.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 71
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDICES
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 72
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX A

INFORMED CONSENT FORM

INFORMED CONSENT FORM

I, ________________________________________, agree to participate


in the study entitled, COMPARATIVE STUDY ON THE DEPRESSION LEVELS
BETWEEN JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL AND SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
TEACHERS IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS OF THE CITY OF DASMARIÑAS,
CAVITE in regards to informing of my mental health and depression level. This
research is being conducted by students from Grade 12 -11 (Scubilion) from the
Special Health Sciences Senior High School of the De La Salle Medical and
Health Sciences Institute, under the supervision of Mr. Jose Isaak M. Calamlam.

The aim of this study is to identify the Difference between the Depression
Levels of Junior High School and Senior High School Teachers in Public Schools
of the City of Dasmariñas, Cavite. While participating in this study, I will answer
the instrument containing questions regarding the said topic. Also, I have the
right to withdraw or resign for doing so. The researchers are given permission
and are granted access to the personal information I have provided. This is also
an opportunity to raise my awareness on mental health issues within the
academic community.

In addition to fulfilling academic requirements, this study also allows the


researchers to further immerse themselves in the field of investigation. In turn,
they will protect the confidentiality of my information, contact details and identity.
Moreover, the data gathered will be utilized for the Second Semester of AY 2018-
2019 and for Inquiries, Investigation and Immersion (I3) subject purposes only.

I understand that my participation is voluntary, and I am not forced to


contribute to this study. I also acknowledge the right to withdraw my participation
in this study without given any reason. I am also aware that my answers in the
questionnaire will not be made public, and I confirm that I have fully understood
the concept of this study. I have also been given the chance to ask questions
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 73
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

regarding the purpose of this research. Another copy of this signed informed
consent has also been given to me.

Finally, should there be a need to contact the researchers, I can easily


reach them through their mobile numbers and email addresses stated below:

MOBILE EMAIL ADDRESS


NAME
NUMBER

Barzaga, Bianca Emmanuelle Dana R. 09959633000 barzagabianca@gmail.com

Co, Jersey Mariell E. 09055635402 akojerseyy@gmail.com

Igdanes, Jericho Daniel D. 09064473502 jerichodigd@gmail.com

Lorilla, Anfernie S 09263964235 anfernie.sabillo.lorilla@gmail.com

Sanchez, Caitlin A. 09988597909 caitlinsanchez01@gmail.com

Sarinas, Alyanna Kiara S. 09663287793 yannah.sarinas@gmail.com

__________________________________ __________________
Signature over Printed Name Date
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 74
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX B

RESEARCH INSTRUMENT

Greetings in Saint La Salle!

Thank you for agreeing to participate in the research entitled Comparative Study
on the Depression Levels between Junior High School and Senior High
School Teachers in the Public Schools of the City of Dasmariñas, Cavite.
This research is being conducted by students of Grade 12 – 11 (Scubilion) of the
Special Health Sciences Senior High School in De La Salle Medical and Health
Sciences Institute under the supervision of Mr. Jose Isaak Calamlam.

The survey does not request for your name, email address, or postal address. All
information collected will be treated as private and confidential and will be used for
academic purposes only.

Please answer the following questions honestly and completely.

This questionnaire incorporates concepts from The WorkSafe Health and Well-
being Assessment, The Swedish Demand Control Support Questionnaire, and
The Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ)-9.

Name (optional): ________________________________________________


Age: _________
Sex: ○ Male ○ Female
Civil Status: ○ Single ○ Married ○ Divorced/Annulled ○ Separated ○ Widowed
Department: ○ Junior High School ○ Senior High School
Teaching Load (no. of hours per week): ○ Less Than 30 Hours ○ More Than 30 Hours

Please indicate your response by checking the box corresponding to the


number.

4 – Always 3 – Often 2 – Sometimes 1 – Seldom 0 – Never


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 75
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

PART 1

4 3 2 1 0

How often do you communicate with family members


or friends?
1
Gaano ka kadalas nakikipag-usap sa iyong mga
kapamilya o kaibigan?

How often do you have misunderstandings between


family members?
2
Gaano ka kadalas nagkakaroon ng mga hindi
pagkaka-unawaan sa iyong mga kapamilya?

How often do you have problems related to


relationships (platonic or romantic)?
3
Gaano ka kadalas nagkakaroon ng mga problemang
may kaugnayan sa iyong mga relasyon sa ibang tao?

How often do you have problems regarding finances?


4 Gaano ka kadalas nagkakaroon ng mga problemang
tungkol sa pera?

How often do you pursue means of entertainment


(reading a book, watching television, going to the
movies, listening to music)?
5
Gaano ka kadalas naglilibang (pagbabasa ng libro,
panonood sa telebisyon, panonood sa sinehan,
pakikinig sa musika)?

You have sufficient time to work on tasks.


6 Ikaw ay mayroong sapat na oras sa mga gawain sa
trabaho.

Your job requires too much effort.


7 Ang iyong trabaho ay nangangailangan ng sobra-
sobrang pagsisikap.

There is a pleasant atmosphere at your place of work.


8
Mayroong kaaya-ayang kapaligiran sa iyong trabaho.

You get along well with your supervisors.


9 Mayroong pagkakasundo sa iyo at iyong mga
superbisor.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 76
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

You get along well with your co-workers.


10 Mayroong pagkakasundo sa iyo at iyong mga
katrabaho.

PART 2

4 3 2 1 0

In the past two weeks, you have little or decreased


interest or pleasure in doing things.
1
Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, nababawasan ang
iyong gana sa mga gawain.

In the past two weeks, you are feeling down, depressed,


or hopeless lately.
2
Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay nakararanas ng
lungkot o kawalan ng pag-asa.

In the past two weeks, you experience having trouble


falling or staying asleep, or sleep too much.
3
Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay nakararanas ng
hirap sa pagtulog.

In the past two weeks, you feel tired or have little energy
lately.
4
Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay nakararanas ng
pagod o kawalan ng gana.

In the past two weeks, you have a poor appetite or


overeat.
5
Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay nagkakaroon
ng kaunting gana sa pagkain o laging kumakain.

In the past two weeks, you have a low self-esteem or


you think that you are a failure or have let yourself or
the people around you down.
6
Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay nagkakaroon
ng mababang tingin sa sarili at pakiramdam mo na ikaw
ay isang kabiguan.

In the past two weeks, you are experiencing trouble


concentrating on things.
7 Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay nakararanas ng
problema sa pagkakakaroon ng konsentrasyon sa
bagay-bagay.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 77
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

In the past two weeks, you are moving or speaking in a


slow manner that other people are starting to notice.
8 Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay nagsasalita sa
mabagal na paraan na nagsisimulang mapansin ng mga
tao sa iyong paligid.

In the past two weeks, you feel restless that you have
been moving a lot more than usual.
9
Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay mas madalas
na hindi mapakali.

In the past two weeks, you are having thoughts of


hurting yourself or thoughts that you would be better off
dead.
10
Sa nakaraang dalawang linggo, ikaw ay naka-iisip na
saktan ang iyong sarili o na mas mabuti nang ikaw ay
mamatay.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 78
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX C

SITE MAP

Figure 16. Map of Dasmariñas City, Cavite


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 79
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX D

LETTER FOR SCHOOL PRINCIPAL

(Date)

(NAME OF SCHOOL PRINCIPAL)


Principal
(Name of School)

Dear Mr./Ms. (Surname of School Principal):

Greetings!

The following students, Bianca Emanuelle Dana R. Barzaga, Jersey


Mariell E. Co, Jericho Daniel D. Igdanes, Anfernie S. Lorilla, Caitlin Joy A.
Sanchez, and Alyanna Kiara S. Sarinas, of the Special Health Sciences Senior
High School of De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute are conducting a
study entitled COMPARATIVE STUDY ON THE DEPRESSION LEVELS
BETWEEN JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL AND SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL TEACHERS
IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS OF THE CITY OF DASMARIÑAS, CAVITE.
In light of this, we are asking permission to conduct data gathering in your
institution, for the faculty members of the Junior High School and Senior High
School departments. The aim of this study is to identify the difference between the
depression levels of junior high school and senior high school teachers in public
schools of the City of Dasmariñas, Cavite. All personal information will be kept
private. Any results will only be used for the subject requirements in Inquiries,
Investigations, and Immersion (I3).
We are hoping to conduct the testing during the week of April 1-5, 2019.
Attached here is a copy of the questionnaire.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 80
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Should there be any concerns or questions, here are the contact details of
the members:
NAME MOBILE NUMBER EMAIL ADDRESS

Barzaga, Bianca Emmanuelle Dana R. 09959633000 barzagabianca@gmail.com

Co, Jersey Mariell E. 09055635402 akojerseyy@gmail.com

Igdanes, Jericho Daniel D. 09064473502 jerichodigd@gmail.com

Lorilla, Anfernie S 09263964235 anfernie.sabillo.lorilla@gmail.com

Sanchez, Caitlin A. 09988597909 caitlinsanchez01@gmail.com

Sarinas, Alyanna Kiara S. 09663287793 yannah.sarinas@gmail.com

We are hoping for your favorable response regarding this matter.

Sincerely,

BIANCA EMMANUELLE DANA R. BARZAGA ANFERNIE S. LORILLA

JERSEY MARIELL E. CO CAITLIN JOY A. SANCHEZ

JERICHO DANIEL D. IGDANES ALYANNA KIARA S. SARINAS

The Researchers

Endorsed by:

JOSE ISAAK CALAMLAM, LPT, MA


Research Adviser

VIVIAN B. RAMIREZ, MSc


Director, Special Health Sciences Senior High School
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 81
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX E

PHOTO DOCUMENTATION

Figure 17. Photo during the Data Gathering


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 82
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX F

VALIDATION OF RESEARCH INSTRUMENT

(Date)

Greetings in Saint La Salle!

We are researchers from 12 – 11 Scubilion conducting a study entitled “Comparative


Study on The Depression Levels Between Junior High School and Senior High
School Teachers in The Public Schools of the City of Dasmariñas, Cavite”. In light of
this, we are asking for assistance in measuring the face validity, construct validity, and
content validity of our research instrument, which incorporates concepts from the
WorkSafe assessment program of Tasmania, Australia, and the Swedish Demand Control
Support Questionnaire (DCSQ).
For the validation checklist, the Validation Rubric for Expert Panel (VREP), formulated by
Marilyn K. Simon, Ph.D with input from Jacquelyn White, is a tool designed to measure the
face validity, construct validity, and content validity of an instrument. We are hoping that
this tool will help you assess our questionnaire.
A copy of the research instrument is attached to this validation checklist / rubric.

Respectfully yours,

Bianca Emmanuelle Dana R. Barzaga


Jersey Mariell E. Co
Jericho Daniel D. Igdanes
Anfernie S. Lorilla
Caitlin Joy A. Sanchez
Alyanna Kiara S. Sarinas
The Researchers

Permission to use this rubric was granted by the author, Marilyn K. Simon, Ph.D and
Jacquelyn White. All rights are reserved by the authors. Any other use or reproduction of
this material is prohibited.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 83
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Rubric obtained from https://www.dissertationrecipes.com/surveyinterview-validation-


rubric-for-an-expert-panel/. Items regarding the measure of construct were modified to fit
this particular study.

Survey/Interview Validation Rubric for Expert Panel - VREP©


Criteria Operational Definitions Score Questions NOT
meeting
1 = Not standard
Acceptable (major
modifications (List page and
needed) question
number) and
2 = Below need to be
Expectations revised.
(some
modifications Please use the
needed) comments and
suggestions
3 = Meets section to
Expectations (no recommend
modifications revisions.
needed but could
be improved with
minor changes)

4 = Exceeds
Expectations (no
modifications
needed)
1 2 3 4
Clarity • The questions are direct and
specific.
• Only one question is asked
at a time.
• The participants can
understand what is being
asked.
• There are no double-barreled
questions (two questions in
one).
Wordiness • Questions are concise.
• There are no unnecessary
words
Negative Wording • Questions are asked using
the affirmative (e.g., Instead
of asking, “Which methods
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 84
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

are not used?”, the


researcher asks, “Which
methods are used?”)
Overlapping • No response covers more
Responses than one choice.
• All possibilities are
considered.
• There are no ambiguous
questions.
Balance • The questions are unbiased
and do not lead the
participants to a response.
The questions are asked
using a neutral tone.
Use of Jargon • The terms used are
understandable by the target
population.
• There are no clichés or
hyperbole in the wording of
the questions.
Appropriateness • The choices listed allow
of Responses participants to respond
Listed appropriately.
• The responses apply to all
situations or offer a way for
those to respond with unique
situations.
Use of Technical • The use of technical
Language language is minimal and
appropriate.
• All acronyms are defined.
Application to • The questions asked relate
Praxis to the daily practices or
expertise of the potential
participants.
Relationship to • The questions are sufficient
Problem to resolve the problem in the
study
• The questions are sufficient
to answer the research
questions.
• The questions are sufficient
to obtain the purpose of the
study.
Measure of • The survey adequately
Construct: measures the construct
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 85
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

A: (Personal “personal concerns”.


Concerns) Personal concerns are the
features of personality that
describe the big 3 motives
(need for achievement, need
for control, need for
intimacy/affection).
Measure of • The survey adequately
Construct: measures the construct
B: (Professional “professional concerns”.
Concerns) Professional concerns are
matters pertaining to a
person's work, particularly
jobs that require special
training or educational
attainment.
Measure of • The survey adequately
Construct: measures the construct
C: (Depression “depression levels”.
Levels) Depression level is defined
as the degree of melancholic
mood and loss of interest in
hobbies, work, and other
activities.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 86
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

(Date)

Greetings in Saint La Salle!

We are researchers from 12 – 11 Scubilion conducting a study entitled “Comparative


Study on The Depression Levels Between Junior High School and Senior High
School Teachers in The Public Schools of the City of Dasmariñas, Cavite”. In light of
this, we are asking for assistance in checking the language, spelling, punctuation, and
grammar of our research instrument, which incorporates concepts from the WorkSafe
assessment program of Tasmania, Australia, and the Swedish Demand Control Support
Questionnaire (DCSQ).

A copy of the research instrument is attached.

Respectfully yours,

Bianca Emmanuelle Dana R. Barzaga


Jersey Mariell E. Co
Jericho Daniel D. Igdanes
Anfernie S. Lorilla
Caitlin Joy A. Sanchez
Alyanna Kiara S. Sarinas
The Researchers
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 87
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX G

CERTIFICATION FROM THE PSYCHOMETRICIAN


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 88
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX H

CERTIFICATION FROM THE STATISTICIAN


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 89
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

APPENDIX I

CERTIFICATION FROM THE EDITOR


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 90
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

CURRICULUM VITAE

Bianca Emmanuelle Dana R. Barzaga is an alumna at De La Salle

Medical and Health Sciences Institute – Special Health Sciences Senior High

School. In Junior High School, she and her former research team conducted a

study about the English Vocabulary Fluency of Grade 7 students while in

Practical Research I, she and her former group conducted a study regarding the

Stress Levels and Factors of the Staff in De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences

Institute.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 91
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Jersey Mariell E. Co is an alumna at Special Health Sciences Senior

High School of De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute. In Junior High

School, she and her former research team conducted a study about the Impact of

Authoritative Parenting on the Self-Esteem of a Grade 10 Students while in

Practical Research I, she and her former group conducted a research about the

Psychological Effects of Skin Care Products among the Female Students of

Senior High School in De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 92
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Jericho Daniel D. Igdanes is an alumnus at the Special Health Sciences

Senior High School of the De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute. For

Practical Research I, he and his former group mates conducted a study on the

Emotional Well-Being of Persons with Disabilities (PWDs). The respondents for

their study consisted of PWDs residing in the greater Molino area of the city of

Bacoor in Cavite.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 93
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Anfernie S. Lorilla is an alumna at De La Salle Medical and Health

Sciences Institute under the program Special Health Sciences Senior High School.

In Junior High School, she and her former research team conducted a study about

the Effects of Extra Curricular Activities in Academic Performances of the

Students while in Practical Research I, she and her former group conducted a

study regarding the Manifestations of Social Anxiety Disorder among Senior

High School Students of De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute.


De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 94
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Caitlin Joy A. Sanchez is an alumna at the De La Salle Medical and

Health Sciences Institute – Special Health Sciences Senior High School. She has

participated in divisional science fairs under the Applied Science Research

Category along with her group mates over the course of her time in Junior High

School. As for Practical Research I, she and her former research team conducted a

study on The Effects of Oophorectomy on the Health-Related Quality of Life of

Post-Operative Patients.
De La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute 95
SPECIAL HEALTH SCIENCES SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

Alyanna Kiara S. Sarinas is an alumna at De La Salle Medical and

Health Sciences Institute – Special Health Sciences Senior High School. She and

her groupmates during Junior High School conducted a Science Investigatory

Project about Honey Water as an Alternative Way of Preventing Enzymatic

Browning. For Practical Research I, she and her research group administered a

study about the Physiological Impacts of Diabetes among Teenagers.

You might also like