7

Nominal Material Properties

Span = 78 in fc' 4000 psi
Top bars 2#4 fy 60 ksi
Bot Bars 4#8
Eff depth 15 in
Stirrups None Use ACI values including f factor
ACI 318 Nominal Predictions ACI 318 using actual properties Test Results Test/ACI Nom Test/ACI Actual Failure
Year fc' fy Mn fMn Vn fVn Mn fMn Vn fVn Pmax Mmax Vmax Moment Shear Moment Shear Mode
(psi) (ksi) (K-ft) (K-ft) (kips) (kips) (K-ft) (K-ft) (kips) (kips) (kips) (k-ft) (kips)
2006 4742 73
2008 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 118 191.75 59 1.2419 4.1469 1.0402 3.8079 shear
2010 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 115 186.875 57.5 1.2103 4.0415 1.0138 3.7111 shear
2011 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 68 110.5 34 0.7157 2.3897 0.5994 2.1944 shear
2012 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 99 160.875 49.5 1.0419 3.4792 0.8727 3.1948 shear
2013 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 78 126.75 39 0.8209 2.7412 0.6876 2.5171 shear
2014 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 56 91 28 0.5894 1.9680 0.4937 1.8072 shear
2015 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 91 147.875 45.5 0.9577 3.1980 0.8022 2.9366 shear
2016 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 78 126.75 39 0.8209 2.7412 0.6876 2.5171 shear
2017 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 70 113.75 35 0.7367 2.4600 0.6171 2.2589 shear
2018 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 92 149.5 46 0.9683 3.2332 0.8110 2.9689 shear
2019 4742 73 193 154.4 18.97 14.23 233.34 184.34 20.66 15.49 58 94.25 29 0.6104 2.0383 0.5113 1.8717 shear
Mean 83.90909 136.3523 41.95455 0.8831 2.9488 0.7397 2.7078
SD 21.06872 34.23667 10.53436 0.22174 0.740422 0.185727 0.6799
Beam 8
Year Specimen Test/fVn (kips) Test/fVn actual fVnMEAN Vn STD
2008 4.1469 3.8079 2.8290 0.6585641002
2010 4.0415 3.7111 fVn actualMEANfVn actual STD
2011 2.3897 2.1944 2.7078 0.67989968
2012 3.4792 3.1948
2013 2.7412 2.5171
2014 1.9680 1.8072
2015 3.1980 2.9366
2016 2.7412 2.5171
2017 2.4600 2.2589
2018 3.2332 2.9689
2019 2.0383 1.8717

0.45274463007 0.3396181384 -3.780057478 ???

-3.608279983 ACI 318 18.97 ACI 318 14.23 deviation
Nominal value Design Value exceed
0 0

Vn Normal Distribution
0 5.9592E-05
0.25 0.0002832117
0.5 0.0011653323 0.7
0.75 0.0041514865
1 0.0128047994 0.6
1.25 0.034194576
1.5 0.0790600274 0.5
1.75 0.1582603025
2 0.2742851629
normal distribution

0.4
2.25 0.4115740009
2.5 0.5346983483 0.3
2.75 0.6014299421
3 0.5857017769 0.2
3.25 0.4938366644
3.5 0.3605001191 0.1
3.75 0.2278467234
0
0 25 .5 75 1 25 .5
0 . 0 0. 1. 1 1
 normal
0.2

0.1

4 0.1246796159 0
4.25 0.0590695166 0 25 .5 75 1 25 .5
0 . 0 0. 1. 1 1
4.5 0.0242296238
4.75 0.0086048879
5 0.0026458125
5.25 0.0007043495
5.5 0.0001623426

0.7

actual Vn Normal Distribution 0.6

0 0.0002110
0.25 0.0008528 0.5
0.5 0.0030113

Normal Distribution
0.75 0.0092884 0.4
1 0.0250275
1.25 0.0589079 0.3
1.5 0.1211190
1.75 0.2175367 0.2
2 0.3412984
2.25 0.4677539 0.1
2.5 0.5599925
2.75 0.5856370 0
3 0.5350031 0 25 .5 75 1 25 .5
0. 0 0 . 1. 1 1 .
3.25 0.4269389
3.5 0.2976162
3.75 0.1812296
4 0.0964013
4.25 0.0447939
4.5 0.0181818
4.75 0.0064467
5 0.0019967
5.25 0.0005402
 Test Vn
59 Mean STD
57.5 41.95454545 10.53435937
34
49.5 Norm. Distribution
39 10 0.0003804221
28 15 0.0014342379
45.5 20 0.0043165671
39 25 0.0103709299
35 30 0.0198910992
46 35 0.0304552211
29 40 0.0372243068
45 0.0363206298
50 0.0282905904
55 0.0175910815
60 0.0087318237
65 0.0034600252
70 0.0010944992
75 0.0002763844
80 5.571518E-05

0.04

0.035

0.03

0.7 Norm. Distribution 0.025

0.6 0.02

0.015
0.5

0.01
normal distribution

0.4
0.005
0.3
Column D 0
0.2 10 15 20

0.1

0
0 25 .5 75 1 25 .5 75 2 25 .5 75 3 25 .5 75 4 25 .5 75 5 25 .5
0 . 0 0. 1. 1 1 . 2 . 2 2. 3. 3 3 . 4. 4 4. 5. 5

fVn (kip)
 Column D

normal 0.2

0.1

0
0 25 .5 75 1 25 .5 75 2 25 .5 75 3 25 .5 75 4 25 .5 75 5 25 .5
0 . 0 0. 1. 1 1 . 2 . 2 2. 3. 3 3 . 4. 4 4. 5. 5

fVn (kip)

0.7

0.6

0.5
Normal Distribution

0.4

0.3
Column D
0.2

0.1

0
0 25 .5 75 1 25 .5 75 2 25 .5 75 3 25 .5 75 4 25 .5 75 5 25
0. 0 0 . 1. 1 1 . 2. 2 2. 3. 3 3. 4. 4 4. 5.

Test/fVn
m. Distribution
nominal -2.181864568 1.50%
design -2.631820739 0.40%

0.04

0.035

0.03
Norm. Distribution

0.025

0.02
Column L
0.015

0.01

0.005

0
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80
Shear (kips)
Beam 8
Nominal Material Properties
Span = 78 in fc' 4000 psi
Top bars 2#4 fy 60 ksi
Bot Bars 4#8
Eff depth 15 in
Stirrups None
ACI 318 Nominal Predictions
Year fc' fy As Mn fMn Vn fVn
(psi) (ksi) (K-ft) (K-ft) (kips) (kips)
2006 4742 73
2008 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2010 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2011 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2012 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2013 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2014 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2015 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2016 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2017 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2018 4742 73 3.56 14.23
2019 4742 73 3.56 14.23

B1=0.7758 As 3.16 As' 0.4

Year fc' (psi) fy (ksi) As (in^2) c (in) Es' fs' Cs' (kip) Cc (kip) T (kip)
4742 73 3.16 6.8 0.001676 48.61765 17.83478 212.6372 230.68
 Use ACI values including f factor
ACI 318 using actual properties Test Results Test/ACI Nom Test/ACI Actual
Mn fMn Vn fVn Pmax Mmax Vmax Moment Shear Moment
(K-ft) (K-ft) (kips) (kips) (kips) (k-ft) (kips)

118
115
68
99
78
56
91
78
70
92
58
Mean
SD

T=Cc+Cs c/d phi Mn phiMn

230.47 0.453333 0.73 48136.72 35139.81

0.453333
including f factor
Test/ACI Actual Failure
Shear Mode

3.75