Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Virus Detectives Keep Pandemic in Check: No Easy Choices Facing County
Virus Detectives Keep Pandemic in Check: No Easy Choices Facing County
z
WINNER OF THE 2018 PULITZER PRIZE
No easy
choices
facing
county
STAY-HOME ORDER »
Limits on activity set
to be loosened, extended
By JULIE JOHNSON
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT
Public health workers dig deep to track down possible COVID-19 cases and real estate
restrictions / B1
transactions to ■ Local builders
resume. reexamine future
By MARTIN ESPINOZA But the ma- during economic
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT jority of re- uncertainty / E1
A
strictions will
team of Sonoma County public remain in place. The directive to
health nurses wear face masks, face stay home, apart from essential
shields, blue gowns, gloves and shoe business or errands, and to wear
covers, waiting for a caravan of cars, SUVs masks in public settings will be
and pickups to start driving into a narrow extended to continue preventing
downtown Santa Rosa parking lot. the coronavirus from spreading
One afternoon last week, the people widely within the community,
who arrived in the vehicles, often families Mase said.
and couples, appeared a little bewildered. She did not say how long these
Many, however, are thankful to get a break orders must stay in place but
from home quarantine, eager to speak to noted the state directive is in-
someone in person, someone who under- definite and the county aims to
stands what they’re enduring. align local rules with those set
This is not just any Monday through by California public health offi-
Friday drive-thru county testing site to cials and Gov. Gavin Newsom.
detect the new coronavirus. The people “We’re under an executive or-
in these vehicles are unique. They are der from our governor,” Mase
our friends, neighbors and co-workers, said. “Regardless of what hap-
but there’s a great probability they have pens, the governor needs to be
COVID-19 because of their close contacts the one to lift shelter-in-place.”
with others infected. Public health officials Local leaders have been
say identifying, testing and monitoring urging Mase to ease restric-
Sonoma County Public Health nurses Katy Jenkins, from left, Maggie Wideau, Sylvia Brown and tions where she can. Fielding a
TURN TO DETECTIVES » PAGE A13 Jacob Soled work Wednesday to swab a carload of Sonoma County residents in Santa Rosa.
TURN TO ORDERS » PAGE A2
residents
Regina Rolland was going the extra
mile.
Actually, by driving a shipment of
s’mores bars, chocolate-dipped Oreos
1 in every 10 workers in and sea salt caramels 35 miles from her
Kenwood store to a customer in Vallejo,
Sonoma County filed for she was going 15 miles beyond her usual
unemployment last month delivery area.
Extraordinary times call for extraor-
By ETHAN VARIAN dinary measures. When you’ve had to
THE PRESS DEMOCRAT switch your business overnight from
KENT PORTER / THE PRESS DEMOCRAT 99% walk-in customers to 100% online
Michael Hunter saw the layoffs com- Michael Hunter was laid from his job as a winery cook at Ram’s Gate Winery. Hunter found orders, when you’re fighting for your
ing. So a few weeks before the winery ways to cut back by ending streaming services and being mindful of spending. livelihood, you’re willing to drive out of
cook and the rest of the hourly staff at your way.
Ram’s Gate Winery in Sonoma were let tified the things he could live without, “I remind myself not to buy anything “Traffic wasn’t bad at all,” said
go last month, he took a close look at his including his Amazon Prime and Netflix extravagant when I go shopping,” he Rolland, the relentlessly optimistic
budget. DVD subscriptions, which he canceled af- said. “And I don’t drive anywhere unless owner of Wine Truffle Boutique choc-
Hunter found he spends about $1,000 ter getting laid off. absolutely necessary, to save on gas.” olate and gelato bar, inside VJB Vine-
— close to half his monthly income — on Facing the possibility of months with- As Sonoma County residents grapple yard and Cellars. “I cruised down and
fixed expenses including rent, auto in- out work, he’s drastically cut back his
surance and car payments. He also iden- spending. TURN TO FINANCIAL » PAGE A15 TURN TO INNOVATE » PAGE A14
Advice T5 Community B8 LeBaron T1 Obituaries B4 PRIORITIES DURING PANDEMIC: Democrats SANTA ROSA ©2020
Business E1 Crossword T5 Lotto A2 State news A7 shift focus to confront President Trump over High 79, Low 48 The Press
Democrat
Classified C5 Forum B9 Nevius C1 Sonoma Life D1 his handling of the coronavirus. / B1 THE WEATHER, C6
A2 THE PRESS DEMOCRAT • SUNDAY, APRIL 26, 2020
ORDERS “Ultimately it is on her shoulders. If there’s didn’t account for how dras-
tically California’s stay-
home directives would limit
CONTINUED FROM A1 a decision to be made, it will be made by her.” the spread of COVID-19,
Mase said. These models ar-
––– barrage of concerns DAVID RABBITT, Sonoma County supervisor, on Dr. Sundari Mase considering changing stay-at-home orders en’t designed to inform the
from residents, some coun- public about what might oc-
ty supervisors want Mase again, and the county any county public health But the financial toll vaccine, it’s going to be cur, but rather are intended
to allow some people to should prioritize financial rule, meaning local juris- has been swift and brutal months and months — we to provide the county and
return to their jobs and recovery over recreation in dictions can add restric- in California, where more need to know how to sur- hospitals with some data to
businesses to resume op- risk-benefit analyses. tions but cannot loosen than a half-million resi- vive,” Rabbitt said. prepare for worst-case sce-
erations in order to lessen “I’d err on the side of giv- them compared to the dents filed unemployment The decisions are out of narios.
some of the financial hard- ing people the opportunity state’s order. claims just last week, more their hands at a time when “When they’re ready to
ship falling on thousands. to earn a paycheck before While the county is ex- than any other state. All public health officers hold give us very accurate mod-
Sonoma County Super- getting the opportunity to pected to allow access to told, 1 in 6 Californians ultimate authority, pow- els, I want them,” Mase
visor David Rabbitt said get fresh air in a park, and local parks, it cannot open have lost jobs, according to ers that allow them to take said. “I don’t want them
he believes local business- that’s not saying that parks up Trione-Annadel, Arm- state figures. drastic measures such as before that because it’s
es are highly motivated to aren’t important,” Rabbitt strong Redwoods, Jack County supervisors are seizing property. hard to make sense of data
institute new protective said. London or the Sonoma hearing complaints from That dynamic causes that’s not fully analyzed
physical distancing mea- California’s sweeping Coast among the 11 state all corners of the commu- some tension but ulti- and vetted.”
sures in order to operate isolation order supersedes parks closed to the public. nity, including local resi- mately provides “checks While Mase is expect-
Sonoma County’s public dents concerned about los- and balances” on the com- ed to relax some elements
health order puts great- ing their jobs to business peting interests of public of her stay-home order
We are in this er limits than the state on
some business sectors,
owners questioning why
they cannot safely operate
health concerns and finan-
cial stability, Rabbit said.
in the coming days, she is
nowhere close to lifting it
together, and together such as only allowing con-
struction for affordable
while others can.
Some restrictions have
“Ultimately it is on her
shoulders. If there’s a de-
entirely.
The county, and the state,
we can get through housing projects or wild-
fire rebuilds. But Mase
been difficult to defend.
“I’ve struggled to explain
cision to be made, it will
be made by her,” Rabbitt
must have the ability to im-
plement a series of public
anything! said that most businesses
are closed due to the gov-
why it’s OK for someone to
work on a multimillion-
said of Mase. “And it’s not
always the decision the
health measures aimed at
slowing the spread of the
ernor’s order “so there’s dollar expansion that’s a board would like to hear.” virus and swiftly address-
nothing we can do for over (fire) rebuild while some- As of Saturday evening, ing outbreaks before life in
Don!t
95% of business facilities.” one working on a granny 218 people in Sonoma California can resume any
Newsom announced the unit is not allowed to go County had tested positive degree of normalcy.
first iteration of the state’s forward,” Sonoma County for COVID-19, about 4% of Newsom’s “six indica-
stay-home rule on March Supervisor Lynda Hopkins the 5,287 people tested for tors” include widespread
Forget!
19, one day after Sonoma said. “We need all kinds of the disease since the first testing, programs to mon-
County’s first public health housing.” case was detected March 2, itor and track COVID-19
stay-home order went into Other North Coast coun- according to local data. cases, protect high-risk
effect and three days after ties with lower numbers of and vulnerable residents
six Bay Area counties be- people testing positive for Unanswered questions from infection, expand
came the first to shut down COVID-19 have begun re- Mase said that pub- hospital capacity, develop
public life. laxing their rules. lic health investigations therapeutics, implement
Wash your hands frequently. ly
The directive has sharp-
limited commerce,
Lake, Napa and Mendoci-
no counties all have eased
into recent increases in
the numbers, including a
physical distancing mea-
sures at schools, restau-
Maintain social distancing. closed schools and isolated limits on some aspects of 22-person jump Thursday, rants and other businesses
millions from friends and recreation, such as golfing, showed little evidence the — measures that will take
Avoid touching your face. family. hiking and jogging. Con- virus is circulating widely months to implement.
Epidemiologists have struction and pet groomers in the community. Instead, The state and counties
If you have a fever, cough or credited these measures can resume in Lake County. people had contracted the must also have plans in
difficulty breathing, seek for dramatically decreas-
ing the spread of the novel
Drive-in religious services
can take place in Mendoci-
disease from contact with
those already known to be
place to restore restric-
tions if cases surge.
medical care early. coronavirus in California no County. infectious. Mase has said she has lit-
and so far preventing the Hopkins and Rabbitt Two central questions tle leeway to relax restric-
Stay informed. type of devastating surge both mentioned mobile pet remain unanswered: When tions on business opera-
that has overwhelmed hos- grooming and flower deliv- will the pandemic peak in tions further but intends
Support Groups postponed until further notice. pitals in places like New ery services as examples Sonoma County? And how to do so where she can and
York City. of the kinds of businesses bad will it be? where she can be sure busi-
that require little interac- The county expects to nesses can operate safely.
California and the virus tion between people and receive soon new results When asked if she felt
Since the first cases shouldn’t be hampered from computer modeling pressure from business or
were detected in February, from operating. that attempt to answer political interests, Mase
1,562 Californians have Rabbitt pointed out that those questions. shrugged off the notion.
Engaged senior living for individuals died from complications flower delivery supports A previous model done for “We’re looking at it in a
with memory loss since 1997 of COVID-19, the disease farmers, florists and driv- Sonoma County by Imperi- very evidence-based way,”
caused by the novel coro- ers and said he wants the al College London predicted Mase said.
Family Owned and Operated
navirus, including two county to focus on allow- a surge of infections would
www.primrosealz.com Sonoma County residents. ing people to support them- hit the county between You can reach Staff Writer
More than 5,100 people selves during a time of in- May 29 and June 2, sending Julie Johnson at 707-521-
Residential License # 496803764 • Day Club License # 496803761 tense uncertainty.
have died from the respi- about 1,500 people to hos- 5220 or julie.johnson@
ratory disease in New York “If we’re going to be in pitals at its peak. However, pressdemocrat.com. On
City alone. this mode until there’s a that model, among others, Twitter @jjpressdem.
707-509-8267
hard we’re going to have the disease control team, pandemic.”
to work to keep that down while three public health As epidemiologists,
by contacting more people nurses were brought in to Gardner and Mercado
and more people and do active case identification summarize the case data,
more people, and it can by going out in the field count the number of
be exhausting,” Ballard among vulnerable groups contacts for each case, look www.goodhearing.com/covid-19
said. of people to find cases of at worksites and addresses
During a wildfire, COVID-19. The team also and social networks to try