Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—This paper presents a novel small-size directional an- UWB antenna design has to be based on the main implementation
tenna design for ultrawide-band wireless body area networks/wire- requirements. As we will show later in this paper, this aspect is
less personal area networks applications. The design is based on a especially important in the UWB WBAN/WPAN applications.
typical slot antenna structure with an added reflector in order to
achieve directionality. The effects of different antenna parameters They require that antennas must have small form factor (esp.
and human body proximity on the radiation characteristics are an- in WBAN), good efficiency, easy integration with circuitry and
alyzed. Antenna measurements with an optic RF setup were per- good transient characteristics (short impulse response). There
formed in order to characterize the small-size antenna far field ra- are several UWB antenna designs available, which meet some
diation pattern. The different structural antenna parameters were of the imposed requirements [9]–[11]. Additional requirements
optimized via extensive numerical simulations. Results show that
for frequencies above 3.5 GHz, where the power front-to-back ratio exist for UWB WBAN antennas, since the proximity of the
of the directional antenna is greater than 10 dB, its impedance is human body can significantly modify their impedance bandwidth
nearly the same as in the free space. It is not the case neither for the and radiation characteristics, thus modifying also the transient
omnidirectional slot antenna nor the monopole antenna next to the characteristics of the antenna [13]. These main observations
body. Between 3 and 6 GHz performance of the novel directional have led us to the conclusion that for an efficient design the UWB
antenna, in terms of radiation efficiency and SAR values, is signif-
icantly improved compared to omnidirectional antenna designs. antennas used in WBAN/WPAN devices have to be designed
and tested in their normal operating scenarios. However, very
Index Terms—Body-worn antennas, human body, pulsed an-
tennas, specific absorption rate (SAR), ultrawide-band (UWB), few UWB antenna designs concerned with this issue were
wearable antennas, wireless communication. reported in open literature, both for WPAN [12] and WBAN
[13], [15] applications.
Most of the antenna designs presented so far for UWB
I. INTRODUCTION
WPAN/WBAN, present radiation patterns similar to the tradi-
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KLEMM et al.: NOVEL SMALL-SIZE DIRECTIONAL ANTENNA FOR UWB 3885
better than 10 dB across a wide frequency range (in far field). B. Source Pulse
By means of the full-wave electromagnetic (EM) numerical As a source pulse we have used the Gaussian modulated
FIT method (using commercial CST Microwave Studio), a pulse, which has the following form:
systematic parameter study of our new design was performed
to investigate the influence of the reflector and other antenna
parameters on transient characteristics of the new antenna. (1)
Further analysis incorporated the human body models in a
WBAN operating scenario. Moreover, a true characterization where defines center frequency of the pulse, (natural pulse
of UWB antenna is presented based on the antenna transfer width) defines its bandwidth. Based on the amplitude charac-
function. teristics of transfer functions of investigated antennas (see Sec-
The paper is organized as follows: In Section II, the param- tion V), we have chosen 5 GHz and 160 ps. It gives
eters used for UWB antenna characterization and source pulse the 10 dB pulse bandwidth from approximately 3 to 7 GHz.
are presented. In Section III we show the special cable-less
measurement set-up, suitable for electrically small antenna mea- C. Frequency Domain Transfer Functions
surements. This section also introduces human body models
used during numerical electromagnetic simulations. To provide During the design of the new antenna we have investigated
a reference for results obtained with the new antenna design a transmit (Tx) transfer function defined as [20]
commonly known/used example of small UWB antenna, the
disc monopole antenna is presented in Section IV. Section V
(2)
presents the design of an omnidirectional UWB slot antenna,
supported by a very small ground plane size, as well as the
design and characterization of a new directional UWB slot It relates the radiated electric field intensity and the
antenna. Spatial UWB characteristics (averaged transfer func- pulse from the generator driving the antenna. This definition
tions and pulse distortions) are analyzed in Section VI, for is very convenient for practical cases, because it also includes
two different directional antennas and omnidirectional antennas, the impedance match between the antenna and the pulse gener-
when operating in the free space. Finally, the influence of the ator. In this form is easily computable from the time-do-
human body on different designs (examining radiation effi- main electromagnetic solvers, applying Fourier transformation.
ciency, impedance and averaged transfer functions) is shown
in Section VII. D. Spatially Averaged Transfer Functions
We introduce a new parameter for UWB antenna characteri-
II. PARAMETERS USED FOR UWB ANTENNAS zation—the spatially averaged transfer function, expressed as
CHARACTERIZATION
A very wide operational bandwidth of UWB systems makes
the design and evaluation of antennas much more difficult. For (3)
the same reason traditional narrowband parameters character-
izing antenna, such as return loss, radiation pattern, polariza- where are the transfer functions in a given direction, nor-
tion are relatively less useful for UWB radio systems. There- malized to the maximum value within the frequency band .
fore UWB antennas should be evaluated by means of different and are propagation directions for the and coordinate,
parameters,such as the antenna transfer function (TF). Together respectively. The choice for the should be based on the spec-
with the waveform driving the antenna TF allows distortions in- trum of the antenna input pulse. is a very useful parameter
troduced by the UWB antenna to be calculated. In the following and can be calculated for different solid angles
sections we will base the antenna design and evaluation on the of the radiation sphere, or for the entire sphere, depending on
following parameters. the interest. Preferable directions of propagation with best per-
formance in terms of transient characteristics could be found
A. ‘Narrowband’ Parameters for a given antenna as well. Concept of parameter is sim-
ilar to the mean effective gain (MEG) [21] or mean effective
As it was mentioned, even if not directly useful, parame-
energy gain [22], however it deals with the frequency-depen-
ters known from the traditional (narrowband systems) antenna
dant transfer function (which is more appropriate to characterize
theory can be helpful. In our investigations we were looking at
UWB antennas).
the return loss parameter, as it is also the part in the antenna
transfer function. In further investigation the impedance band-
width is defined as 10 dB. We were also looking at E. Pulse Distortion Parameters
the radiation patterns on different frequencies, by which we can Based on the transfer functions we are able to calculate pulse
(only) roughly estimate the behavior of the transfer functions distortions introduced by an antenna. For UWB systems, the
in different propagation directions. The 3-D radiation patterns commonly used receivers are based on the pulse energy detec-
were used to calculate the antenna front-to-back (F2B) ratio, de- tion or correlation with the template waveform. Therefore we
fined as a ratio of total power radiated in the two half-spaces in will examine the pulse distortions by calculating fidelity factor
the far field. and time spread of radiated pulses (with respect to the antenna
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3886 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ANTENNAS AND PROPAGATION, VOL. 53, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2005
Fig. 1. Small-size antenna measurement setup using RF on fiber optic: (a) photo of the antenna measurement setup (antenna, optical receiver and fiber link) and
(b) block diagram of the RF on fiber optic setup.
input pulse). Fidelity between waveforms and is gen- significant impact on the antenna characteristics (radiation pat-
erally defined as tern, efficiency and input impedance). Therefore, it is important
to include the human body in the EM simulations. We have in-
(4) cluded two different models of the human body. The first one is
a three-tissue model, consisting of layers of skin (1-mm thick),
fat (3-mm thick) and a muscle tissue (40-mm thick), and the
The fidelity parameter , is the maximum of the cross-cor- second is a simple homogeneous model composed of muscle
relation function and compares only shapes of both waveforms, tissue (44-mm thick). Overall dimensions of these models are
not amplitudes. Time spread is a ratio between the lengths of the the same: 120 110 44 mm . The size of this truncated
99% energy window (E99) of the radiated pulse and the antenna body model was found by comparing the simulation results
input pulse (source pulse). It discloses how much the energy of in terms of antenna radiation characteristics when a larger (by
radiated pulse is spread compared to the input pulse. 50%) model was used. No significant differences were noticed.
The human tissues are dispersive and their electrical properties
III. MEASUREMENT AND SIMULATION SETUP are therefore changing over frequencies. The influence of these
A. Antenna Measurement Setup changes on the antenna characteristics was investigated by
an EM code which could include frequency dispersion and it
In traditional antenna measurements, the antenna is con- was found to have a minor influence (e.g., radiation efficiency
nected to the measurement equipment with a coaxial cable. This changes 5%), thus in all further investigations the electrical
set-up is perfectly suited for electrically large antennas, but not parameters of the tissues were assumed to be nondispersive and
for electrically small antennas, as the radiation characteristics the values as at the centre frequency (4.5 GHz) were used [25]:
are significantly influenced by the size of the ground plane skin- 38, 2.7 S/m ; fat- 5.1, 0.18 S/m ;
or any conductive cables acting as additional ground planes muscle- 50.8, 3 S/m .
[14], [15]. The influence of the connecting feed cables or any
other conductive cables connected to the device, which does
not belong to the final application, ought to be minimized if IV. REFERENCE ANTENNA DESIGN- UWB DISC MONOPOLE
not completely eliminated. In [14], [15] a practical set-up was Different kinds of monopole antennas are very often used in
proposed to achieve this, namely the use of an RF on fiber UWB applications and we have therefore included results for a
optic (FO) link (transmitter and receiver) instead of the usual UWB monopole antenna as reference. We designed the UWB
conductive cable feed connections. Fig. 1 shows the RF on fiber disc monopole, with the criteria of an impedance bandwidth
optic setup used in our antenna measurements. from 3 to 6 GHz 10 dB and with the size com-
The comparison between measured and simulated radiation parable to the of slot antenna. The antenna geometry is shown
patterns are presented in Fig. 2, for the two principal planes, at in Fig. 3(a). Its dimensions are: ground plane
3.5, 4.5, and 6 GHz. Good agreement is achieved, especially for 20 mm, disc diameter 16 mm. Gap between ground plane
the co-polarization component. In the final application the trans- and disc is 0.75 mm. Overall planar dimension of antenna is
mitter (pulse generator) will be integrated on the antenna, so we 36.75 20 mm. It was realized on a 0.5-mm thick FR4 sub-
expect the radiation characteristics very close to simulated of strate 4.4 and is fed from a 50 microstrip line.
the directional antenna (see Section VI), without any additional It is relatively easy to design a UWB monopole antenna when
cables or metallic elements. considering only the impedance bandwidth. But to achieve the
same radiation pattern bandwidth is difficult, due to the signif-
B. Human Body Models for Numerical Electromagnetic icant changes in the antenna pattern at higher frequencies [26].
Simulations Plots of the return loss and the function (in 0, 0
In the main applications (UWB WBAN) the antenna is direction) of the UWB disc monopole antenna are shown in
mounted on the human body. It is known that the body has a Fig. 3(b). As can be seen, the antenna is well matched in a much
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KLEMM et al.: NOVEL SMALL-SIZE DIRECTIONAL ANTENNA FOR UWB 3887
Fig. 2. Comparison of measured and simulated radiation patterns of directional slot antenna [see Fig. 1(a)]. (a) XZ plane 3.5 GHz, (b) XZ plane 4.5 GHz, (c)
XZ plane 6 GHz, (d) Y Z plane 3.5 GHz, and (e) Y Z plane 4.5 GHz, (f) Y Z plane 6 GHz.
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3888 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ANTENNAS AND PROPAGATION, VOL. 53, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2005
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KLEMM et al.: NOVEL SMALL-SIZE DIRECTIONAL ANTENNA FOR UWB 3889
j j j j
Fig. 5. (a) S for different S , (b) H (!; 0; 0; ) transfer function for different S (curve named “no refl.” corresponds to the slot antenna without reflector),
and (c) radiated waveforms from the directional antenna (as in Table I) and from the slot antenna.
Fig. 6. Radiation patterns of directional slot antenna for different S . (a) XZ plane 3.5 GHz, (b) XZ plane 4.5 GHz, (c) XZ plane 6 GHz, (d) Y Z plane 3.5
1
GHz, (e) Y Z plane 4.5 GHz, and (f) Y Z plane 6 GHz. Pattern of the omnidirectional slot antenna (S = ) included for comparison.
is compensated by a higher antenna gain. Varying does not B. Variation of the Reflector Width
have a large influence on the amplitude and the shape of .
Looking only at and characteristics, one could say The return loss and the of directional slot antenna,
that the new directional antenna has a 20–30% lower bandwidth when varying values of the reflector width ( 8, 12, 16
compared to the slot antenna. But the difference is not visible and 20 mm), were investigated. A decrease of impedance
when looking at the transient results, when using the source bandwidth, from 54% (3.7–6.4 GHz) for 8 mm, 47%
pulse described earlier in Section II-B. Fig. 5(c) presents ra- (4–6.5 GHz) for 16 mm, to only 20% (5.3–6.5 GHz)
diated waveforms by the omnidirectional slot antenna and the when 20 mm was observed. Thus, considering only
directional antenna with parameters as in Table I. We can see the impedance bandwidth, one would say that there is a sig-
that the radiated pulses have almost the same shapes, but the nificant difference when changing the reflector width. When
electric field intensity is higher for directional antenna. Further considering , however, we observed that its amplitude and
investigations of the transient characteristics of both antennas shape is almost the same for different values [similarly,
are presented in more details in Section VII. as shown in Fig. 5(b)]. Based on the results from the previous
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3890 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ANTENNAS AND PROPAGATION, VOL. 53, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2005
Fig. 7. (a) Return loss of the directional antenna for different ST values and (b) jH (!; 0; 0)j for different ST values.
E. Physical Operation of a Directional UWB Slot Antenna Fig. 9. Comparison of radiation mechanism at 4.5 GHz: (a) directional UWB
slot antenna and (b) omnidirectional UWB slot antenna. Presented cut taken
To further investigate the physical operation of the new di- along the Y axis, at the center of the slot.
rectional antenna, and the impact of the reflector on the antenna
impedance and radiation, we have examined the near-fields of unchanged. This significant change in the field distribution es-
the antenna. In Fig. 8, we present the electric field distribution pecially at low frequencies explains the serious change in the
in a slot, for the antenna without [Fig. 8(a)] and with the re- return loss (impedance) between 3 and 5 GHz [see Fig. 5(a)].
flector [Fig. 8(b)]. It can be seen that the reflector has a great Fig. 9 show the radiation of near-fields for the directional and
influence on the field distribution at lower frequencies (3.5 and omnidirectional slot antennas. Shown is the field (co-polar-
4.5 GHz). At 6 GHz however, the field distribution is almost ization) component at 4.5 GHz, at a cut taken along the axis, at
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KLEMM et al.: NOVEL SMALL-SIZE DIRECTIONAL ANTENNA FOR UWB 3891
E
Fig. 10. (a) Placement of the time-domain probes ( far-field component). Transfer functions recorded along XZ plane for: (b) the omnidirectional slot antenna,
and (c) the directional slot antenna with R = 16 mm.
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3892 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ANTENNAS AND PROPAGATION, VOL. 53, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2005
Fig. 12. Pulse distortion metrics for different antennas: (a) omnidirectional slot antenna, (b) directional slot antenna with R = 8 mm, (c) directional antenna
with R = 16 mm, and (d) monopole antenna (as the reference).
their characteristics look alike in this frequency range. It The omnidirectional slot antenna has a fidelity above 98% in
results from the fact that the gain of the directional antenna in- the plane. In the plane fidelity factors are above 95%
creases faster than for the omnidirectional slot antenna, thus its for angles of between 70 and 65 , for the rest of considered
half-power beam width also decreases faster (from 71 at 3.5 directions is lower, with a minimum of 84%. Very similar
GHz to 51 at 7 GHz, plane) than for the omnidirectional fidelity results are obtained for both directional slot antennas.
slot antenna (from 80 at 3.5 GHz to 67 at 7 GHz, plane). There is a slight difference for the plane, where 95
Therefore by choosing the 120 width of the solid angle for the is for angles within 65 50 . Monopole antenna has the
, its amplitude drops above 6 GHz. fidelity above 99% in the plane, but in the plane it is
much worse. 95 is only between 50 and 20 , and at
60 it reaches the minimum of 75%. Compared to all slot an-
B. Pulse Distortion Parameters tennas, we can also notice asymmetry in the plane, which
results from the changes of radiation pattern for different fre-
Based on the transfer functions we have calculated quencies. Considering pulse distortions based on time windows
parameters showing quantitative angular characteristics of with 99% of the pulse energy (E99), we can see that direc-
antennas for UWB systems: 1) 99% energy window (E99), rel- tional antennas introduce higher spatial variations of the E99
ative to the input pulse; 2) 99% energy window, relative to the time windows [Fig. 12(b) and (c)], compared to the slot an-
pulse radiated in the ( 0 , 0 ) direction; and 3) fidelity tenna [Fig. 12(a)] and also to the monopole antenna [Fig. 12(d)].
of radiated pulses (assuming the pulse radiated in ( 0 , Taking as the reference input antenna pulse (its E99 window is
0 ) direction as the reference waveform). It should be 0.392 ns), radiated pulses are 1.19–1.68 0.49 , 1.16–3.8
noted that all these parameters depend on the pulse driving the 2.64 , 1.28–2.44 1.16 , 1.13–1.83 0.7
antenna. Although these angular-dependent characteristics are times longer, for the slot antenna, directional slot antenna with
very important from the point of view of UWB system design, 8 mm, directional slot antenna with 16 mm and
they are very rarely presented in papers about antennas for monopole antenna, respectively. Angular spread of E99 win-
UWB systems. Results are presented in Fig. 18. Driving pulse dows is important if one is interested in applications where any
is the one presented in Section II-B. Results for the monopole relative position between Tx and Rx antennas is possible. An
antenna are presented for the reference. interesting point to notice that even if E99 windows are shorter
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KLEMM et al.: NOVEL SMALL-SIZE DIRECTIONAL ANTENNA FOR UWB 3893
TABLE II
RADIATION EFFICIENCY (RAD.EFF.) AND PEAK SAR VALUES FOR THE DIRECTIONAL SLOT ANTENNA. INPUT POWER P =1W
TABLE III
RADIATION EFFICIENCY AND PEAK SAR VALUES FOR THE OMNI-DIRECTIONAL SLOT ANTENNA. INPUT POWER P =1W
between 45 and 75 of the plane for the monopole than it was placed only 2 mm away from the body. The radiation effi-
directional slot 8 mm , its fidelity is lower at these di- ciency and SAR values are presented in Table II for directional
rections. For the system considerations that would mean one slot antennas and in Table III for the omnidirectional slot an-
would prefer a different antenna (directional slot or monopole), tenna. They show that:
depending on the type of receiver (e.g., energy detector or tem-
— Radiation efficiency of all antennas increases with fre-
plate-based).
quency. Only for the slot antenna in the position 2 mm
away from the body was a different behavior observed.
VII. COMPARISON OF ANTENNAS OPERATING CLOSE TO THE — Antenna performance in terms of the radiation effi-
HUMAN BODY ciency and SAR has improved for directional slot an-
tennas, compared to the omnidirectional slot antenna.
To show the effect of the human body on the antenna char- — Comparing only directional slot antennas, better per-
acteristics we have simulated the same antennas as used in formance (radiation efficiency and SAR) was obtained
Section VII with the addition of the truncated human body for the one with wider reflector (16 mm). Therefore,
models. For the different separations between the antenna and one would choose different values of for operation
the body we have examined: antenna radiation efficiency, peak in free space than close to the human body.
SAR values (10 g averaged), transmit transfer functions and — Comparing results obtained when using different body
input matching. models, higher (than 4–24%) radiation efficiencies
were calculated when homogeneous muscle-tissue
A. Radiation Efficiency and SAR body model was used. Again, different behavior for
The objective of these investigations was to show the differ- slot antenna 2 mm away from the body is observed.
As the electrical parameters of skin and muscle tissue
ence in the radiation efficiency and SAR values for different
antennas. The slot antenna has the omnidirectional pattern are very similar (conductivity plays a much bigger
(front-to-back ratio close to 0 dB) and the 10 dB impedance role than permittivity), the main difference between
bandwidth within 3–6 GHz. The first directional slot antenna these two models is an incorporation of the fat tissue.
Fat is a low water content tissue, thus its conductivity
(reflector width 8 mm) has 10 dB within
3.7–6.4 GHz and power front-to-back ratio of 7.1, 7.4 and 11.7 is lower than for skin and muscle.
dB at 3.5, 4.5, and 6 GHz, respectively. The second directional As an illustration to the results presented in Table II and III
slot antenna (reflector width 16 mm) has the 10 dB return we present the power absorbed in the skin layer (where the
loss bandwidth within 4–6.5 GHz and power front-to-back ratio maximum absorption occurs) of the three-layer human body
of 10.4, 10.8 and 15.4 dB at 3.5, 4.5, and 6 GHz, respectivel model. Fig. 13 shows results for the omnidirectional slot an-
y. For comparison we assume the same body-to-feed line dis- tenna, Fig. 14 for the directional slot antenna, normalized to
tance, 7 and 10 mm. For directional slot antennas it means that the same absolute value. It is visible that with the use of re-
the reflector is only 1 mm away from the body. Additional cal- flector, near-fields where scattered, resulting in the lower power
culations were made for the omnidirectional slot antenna, when deposited in the tissue.
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3894 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ANTENNAS AND PROPAGATION, VOL. 53, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2005
Fig. 13. Power absorbed in the skin layer of the three-layer human body model due to the omnidirectional slot antenna: (a) 3.5 GHz, (b) 4.5 GHz, and (c) 6 GHz.
Distance between the skin and the feed-lines is 7 mm.
Fig. 14. Power absorbed in the skin layer of the three-layer human body model due to the directional slot antenna: (a) 3.5 GHz, (b) 4.5 GHz, and (c) 6 GHz.
Distance between the skin and the feed-lines is 7 mm (1 mm between skin and reflector).
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KLEMM et al.: NOVEL SMALL-SIZE DIRECTIONAL ANTENNA FOR UWB 3895
H
Fig. 16. (a) Spatially averaged transmit transfer functions ( ) of body-mounted antennas: omnidirectional slot antenna and directional slot antennas with
R = 8 and 16 mm: (b) Difference inH between free-space and body-mounted operations. Distance between feed line of antennas and the body is 7 mm.
transfer function (propagation from the body) within the be an attractive alternative to the popular UWB monopole an-
3.4–8 GHz band is maximally 0.5 dB different from the one tennas, especially for WBAN/WPAN applications where direc-
in free-space. For the same frequency band, variations tional antenna could be of interest.
in the case of omnidirectional slot antenna are even up to 4 The advantage of using the proposed directional UWB an-
dB. Comparing only directional antennas, we can see again (as tenna is even more pronounced if we consider its operation
for the radiation efficiency and SAR), that the antenna with on the human body (UWB WBAN applications). Results show
16 mm performs slightly better, when one considers the that for frequencies above 3.5 GHz, where the power front-to-
difference in transient characteristics between the free back ratio of the directional antenna is greater than 10 dB, its
space and on the body operations. impedance bandwidth is nearly the same as in the free space. It is
not the case neither for the commonly used omnidirectional slot
antenna nor monopole antennas. Furthermore, between 3 and
VIII. CONCLUSION
6 GHz the performance of the novel directional slot antenna, in
A novel small-size directional UWB antenna for terms of radiation efficiency and SAR, is significantly improved
WPAN/WBAN applications has been proposed in this work. It compared to omnidirectional antenna designs. Results of spa-
utilizes the small reflecting/radiating patch element to achieve tially averaged transfer functions also prove better performance
a front-to-back ratio above 10 dB in a very large bandwidth of the directional slot antenna. They show that the difference of
from 3.5 to 7 GHz. Antenna measurements with an optic RF spatially averaged transfer functions between operation in the
setup were performed in order to characterize the small-size free space and when close to the body is much lower ( 0.5 dB
antenna far field radiation pattern. By means of numerical EM for , within 3.5–8 GHz) than for the omnidirectional slot
simulations, systematic parametric study was performed to antenna. These main observations lead to the conclusion that our
understand the influence of the reflecting element on transient new directional UWB antenna is indeed very suitable for UWB
characteristics of the new antenna. As will be the case in normal BAN applications, being a more efficient design with radiation
WPAN/WBAN operating scenarios, antenna performance was characteristics less influenced by proximity of the human body.
examined when in free space and close to the human body.
Two truncated body models were used, three-tissue model
(skin, fat and muscle tissues) and homogeneous muscle tissue REFERENCES
model. Performance of the novel directional UWB antenna [1] “European IST FP5 Project, Power Aware Communications for
was compared with the omnidirectional UWB slot antenna and Wireless OptiMised Personal Area Networks (PACWOMAN),”
with the UWB disc monopole antenna. As monopole antennas http://www.imec.be/pacwoman, Oct. 2003.
[2] “European IST FP6 Project MAGNET,” http://www.ist-magnet.org, Jan.
are very popular and commonly used in UWB systems, the 2004.
latter one serves as the reference design. [3] “Human ++ Project,” www.imec.be.
[4] T. Zasowski, F. Althaus, M. Staeger, A. Wittneben, and G. Troester,
In free space, spatial UWB characteristics of antennas have “UWB for noninvasive wireless body area networks: channel measure-
been obtained based on the transmit transfer functions, time ments and results,” presented at the IEEE Conf. Ultra Wideband Systems
windows with 99% energy and fidelity of radiated pulses. Re- and Technologies, UWBST, Reston, VA, Nov. 2003.
[5] Z. N. Chen, X. H. Wu, H. F. Li, N. Yang, and M. Y. W. Chia, “Consid-
sults show that the new directional antenna has slightly larger erations for source pulses and antennas in UWB radio systems,” IEEE
values of 99% energy windows of radiated pulses compared to Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 52, no. 7, pp. 1739–1748, Jul. 2004.
[6] X. H. Wu and Z. N. Chen, “Design and optimization of UWB antennas
the UWB disc monopole. However, when considering fidelity by a powerful CAD tool: PULSE KIT,” presented at the IEEE Antennas
of radiated pulses, the directional antenna performs better than and Propag. Society Symp., Jun. 20–25, 2004.
[7] J. S. McLean, H. Foltz, and R. Sutton, “The effect of frequency-depen-
the monopole, due to the more stable radiation pattern across dent radiation pattern on UWB antenna performance,” presented at the
the frequency band of interest. Therefore, our new design can Proc. IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society Symp., Jun. 20–25, 2004.
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3896 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ANTENNAS AND PROPAGATION, VOL. 53, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2005
[8] H. G. Schantz, “Dispersion and UWB antennas,” presented at the Proc. István Z. Kov́cs received the B.Sc. degree from
Joint Conf. Center For TeleInFrastruktur, Department of Communica- “Politehnica” Technical University of Timisoara,
tion Technology Int. Workshop Ultra Wideband Systems with Ultraw- Romania, in 1989, the M.Sc.E.E. degree from
ideband Systems and Technologies Conf., Kyoto, Japan, May 18–21, The Franco-Polish School of New Information
2004. and Communication Technologies/Ecole Nationale
[9] H. G. Schantz and L. Fullerton, “The diamond dipole: a Gaussian im- Supérieure des Télécommunications de Bretagne,
pulse antenna,” presented at the IEEE Antennas and Propagation Soc. Poland/France, in 1996, and the Ph.D.E.E. degree in
Symp., Jul. 8–13, 2001.
wireless communications from Aalborg University,
[10] M. Klemm and G. Troester, “Characterization of an aperture-stacked
patch antenna for ultra-wideband wearable radio systems,” in Proc. 15th Aalborg, Denmark, in 2002.
Int. Conf. Microwaves, Radar and Wireless Communications-MIKON, Currently, he is holding the position of Assistant
vol. 2, Warsaw, Poland, May 17–19, 2004, pp. 395–398. Research Professor with the Center For TeleInFras-
[11] D. H. Kwon and Y. Kim, “A small ceramic chip antenna for ultra-wide- truktur, Department of Communication Technology, Aalborg University, in the
band systems,” presented at the Int. Workshop on Ultra Wideband Antennas and Propagation Division. He is actively involved in the European
Systems Joint With Conf. Ultra Wideband Systems and Technologies, IST PACWOMAN and IST MAGNET projects and participated in several in-
Kyoto, Japan, May 18–21, 2004. dustrial projects with partners such as TeleDanmark, Motorola, IOSpan, and
[12] D. Manteuffel, J. Kunish, W. Simon, and M. Geissler, “Characteriza- ArrayComm. His research interests are in the field of radio channel propagation
tion of UWB antennas by their spatio-temporal transfer function based measurements and modeling, with major focus on short-range ultrawide-band
on FDTD simulations,” presented at the Proc. EUROEM Conf., Magde- radio channel and ultrawide-band antenna investigations.
burg, Germany, Jul. 12–16, 2004.
[13] M. Klemm and G. Troester, “Small patch antennas for ultra-wideband
wireless body area netwroks,” presented at the EUROEM 2004 Conf.,
Magdeburg, Germany, Jul. 12–16, 2004.
[14] W. A. T. Kotterman, G. F. Pedersen, K. Olesen, and P. Eggers,, “Cable-
less measurement setup for wireless handheld terminals,” in Proc. Symp.
Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications (PIMRC), vol. 1,
Oct. 2001, pp. B112–B116.
[15] Future Adaptive communication environment (FACE), internal research
project, Denmark: Center For PersonKommunikation Center for TeleIn-
Frastruktur, Aalborg Univ., Mar. 2004.
[16] X. Qing and Z. N. Chen, “Antipodal vivaldi antenna for UWB applica-
tions,” presented at the EUROEM 2004 Conf., Magdeburg, Germany,
Jul. 12–16, 2004. Gert F. Pedersen was born in 1965. He received the
[17] A. G. Yarovoy, “Antenna development for UWB impulse radio,” pre- B.Sc.E.E. degree from the College of Technology,
sented at the Eur. Microwave Week, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, Oct. Dublin, Ireland, and the M.Sc.E.E. degree from
2004. Aalborg University, Aalborg, Denmark, in 1993.
[18] W. S. T. Rowe and R. B. Waterhouse, “Reduction of backward radiation Since 1993 he was employed by Aalborg Uni-
for CPW fed aperture stacked patch antennas on small ground planes,” versity, Department of Communication Technology,
IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 51, no. 6, Jun. 2003. where he is currently working within the Center
[19] S. D. Targonski and D. M. Pozar, “Aperture-coupled microstrip an- For TeleInFrastruktur as an Associate Research
tennas using reflector elements for wireless communications,” in Proc. Professor heading an antenna group. His research
IEEE-APS Conf. Antennas and Propagation for Wireless Communica- has focused on radio communication for mobile
tions, Nov. 1998, pp. 163–166. terminal, including antennas, diversity systems,
[20] D. Lamensdorf and L. Susman, “Baseband-pulse-antenna techniques,” propagation and biological effects. He has also worked as a Consultant for
IEEE Antennas Propag. Mag., vol. 36, no. 1, Feb. 1994. developments of antennas for mobile terminals including the first internal
[21] “Analysis for mean effective gain of mobile antennas in land mobile
radio environments,” IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol., vol. 39, no. 2, May antenna for mobile phones in 1994 with very low SAR, first internal triple-band
1990. antenna in 1998 with low SAR and high efficiency, smallest internal dual-band
[22] J. McLean, H. D. Foltz, and R. Sutton, “Pattern descriptors for UWB antenna in 2000, and various antenna diversity systems rated as the most
antennas,” IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag., vol. 53, no. 1, pp. 553–559, efficient on the market. Recently, he has been involved in establishing a method
Jan. 2005. to measure the communication performance for mobile terminals that can
[23] S. D. Targonski, R. B. Waterhouse, and D. M. Pozar, “Design of be used as a basis for a 3G standard where measurements also including the
Wide-band aperture-stacked patch microstrip antennas,” IEEE Trans. antenna will be needed. Further, he is involved in mobile terminals for 3G
Antennas Propag., vol. 46, no. 9, Sep. 1998. including several antennas to enhance the data communication.
[24] X. Qing, M. Y. W. Chia, and X. Wu, “Wide-slot antenna for UWB appli-
cations,” in Proc. IEEE Antennas and Propagation Soc. Int. Symp., vol.
1, Jun. 22–27, 2003, pp. 834–837.
[25] C. Gabriel, “Compilation of the dielectric properties of body tissues
at RF and microwave frequencies,”, AL/OE-TR-1996-0037 Rep., Jun.
1996.
[26] T.-Y. Shih, C.-L. Li, and C.-S. Lai, “Design of an UWB fully planar
quasielliptic monopole antenna,” presented at the Proc. Int. Conf. Elec-
tromagnetic Applications and Compatibility (ICEMAC 2004), Taipei,
Taiwan, Oct. 14–16, 2004.
Authorized licensed use limited to: BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE. Downloaded on October 26,2020 at 08:50:46 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.